Bright
orange
and
noisy
...
easily
describes
a
bajaj
.
These
traditional
transportation
vehicles
became
popular
in
India
where
they
were
developed
with
Vespa
and
later
imported
to
and
built
in
Indonesia
.
Similar
vehicles
are
known
as
rickshaw
in
Africa
,
Tuk
-
Tuk
in
Thailand
and
MotoTaxi
in
Peru
.
With
an
estimated
20
,
000
bajaj
in
Jakarta
,
it
is
evident
they
are
very
popular
here
too
!
Bajaj
seat
two
passengers
comfortably
and
up
to
five
passengers
-
depending
on
the
size
of
the
passenger
of
course
.
Their
areas
of
operation
are
limited
to
one
mayoralty
in
the
city
.
On
the
side
of
the
driver
'
s
doors
you
'
ll
see
a
big
circle
in
which
the
area
is
designated
...
Jakarta
Barat
,
Jakarta
Pusat
,
etc
.
,
with
a
different
color
for
each
mayoralty
.
The
drivers
are
not
allowed
to
go
out
of
their
area
and
aren
'
t
allowed
onto
many
main
roads
,
so
routes
may
be
a
bit
circuitous
.
Fare
determination
is
by
bargaining
.
It
'
s
always
best
to
ask
an
Indonesian
what
they
would
pay
for
a
trip
to
a
particular
destination
from
your
point
of
departure
,
and
then
bargain
and
pay
accordingly
.
A
ride
in
a
bajaj
is
hot
,
utilizing
AC
alam
-
or
nature
'
s
air
conditioning
.
The
ride
will
also
be
noisy
,
smelly
(
car
and
bus
fumes
)
,
bumpy
,
harrowing
,
and
a
grand
adventure
.
My
favorite
maneuver
is
when
the
bajaj
driver
decides
to
flip
a
u
-
turn
in
the
middle
of
the
road
.
There
is
some
protection
from
the
rain
,
unless
it
'
s
blowing
hard
.
You
'
d
think
you
'
d
have
to
be
careful
about
robbery
since
the
vehicle
is
so
open
-
but
it
'
s
not
as
common
as
robberies
in
buses
.
Having
said
all
that
...
bajaj
are
extremely
convenient
in
many
areas
of
Jakarta
for
a
short
drive
.
In
April
2001
the
government
announced
that
they
are
going
to
replace
bajaj
with
kancil
,
a
new
4
-
wheel
transportation
.
It
will
be
interesting
to
see
if
they
are
any
improvement
!
Becak
Becak
were
banned
within
the
Jakarta
city
limits
in
1994
due
to
their
propensity
to
cause
traffic
jams
.
Former
President
Soeharto
(
and
others
)
also
wanted
to
eradicate
becak
from
the
city
streets
because
they
felt
the
work
to
be
degrading
to
the
drivers
.
Becak
are
widely
missed
by
people
who
live
in
housing
complexes
off
the
main
roads
and
small
roads
which
are
not
serviced
by
bus
routes
-
as
their
sheer
numbers
in
the
city
prior
to
the
crackdown
attests
to
how
widely
they
were
used
.
It
used
to
be
a
common
site
in
Jakarta
to
see
becak
drivers
taking
children
to
school
each
morning
,
and
women
home
from
the
pasar
(
traditional
market
)
.
However
,
you
can
still
find
a
few
becak
drivers
ignoring
the
ban
in
certain
locations
within
the
city
limits
-
like
behind
the
luxurious
Plaza
Indonesia
.
Outside
city
limits
becak
are
still
found
at
the
junctions
of
main
roads
and
smaller
country
lanes
that
don
'
t
have
smaller
bus
routes
.
Models
of
becak
are
different
in
each
city
they
are
found
in
across
Indonesia
.
Becak
fit
two
passengers
comfortably
and
possibly
even
more
,
depending
on
the
size
of
the
passenger
.
There
is
some
protection
from
the
sun
...
and
a
plastic
sheet
that
comes
down
over
the
front
helps
protect
passengers
during
rainstorms
.
Bargain
before
you
get
in
...
!
And
don
'
t
expect
the
driver
to
have
change
for
large
bills
.
Bemo
Another
noisy
little
neighborhood
vehicle
is
the
bemo
,
which
is
used
for
local
transportation
in
limited
areas
in
Jakarta
.
Originally
brought
to
Indonesia
by
the
Japanese
government
as
part
of
a
disaster
relief
package
in
1962
,
the
vehicles
were
never
manufactured
in
Indonesia
in
as
great
a
number
as
bajaj
or
becak
.
Bemo
are
found
in
and
near
Benhil
,
Tanjung
Priok
,
Kramat
Jati
and
other
areas
outside
Jakarta
.
Bis
There
are
a
large
number
bus
(
bis
)
companies
servicing
routes
in
Jakarta
.
Many
of
the
larger
buses
seat
25
-
40
people
(
depending
on
type
of
bus
)
.
The
buses
have
set
prices
(
which
should
be
posted
on
the
bus
)
.
Bus
companies
include
the
government
-
owned
PPD
and
Damri
,
which
provides
service
to
the
airport
.
Private
companies
include
Metro
Mini
.
Some
buses
are
air
conditioned
like
Mayasari
and
Patas
AC
;
they
are
more
expensive
.
Other
bus
lines
are
run
by
cooperatives
like
Kopaja
and
Kopami
.
All
buses
have
set
routes
and
set
fares
,
but
not
set
schedules
.
Students
in
uniform
pay
a
lower
rate
of
Rp
300
-
no
matter
the
distance
.
If
you
'
re
not
sure
of
the
fare
,
ask
other
passengers
what
it
is
.
Pay
the
“
conductor
”
,
who
is
usually
hanging
out
the
back
door
.
He
won
'
t
have
change
for
big
bills
.
Buses
are
the
most
common
transport
of
the
masses
.
As
we
near
the
fourth
year
of
the
monetary
crisis
,
they
are
almost
universally
in
bad
condition
.
There
are
less
buses
on
the
road
as
the
price
of
spare
parts
has
caused
companies
to
vandalize
other
buses
in
their
fleet
and
up
to
half
of
many
of
the
fleets
may
not
be
roadworthy
.
Bus
passengers
are
often
the
target
for
robberies
,
street
singers
,
and
beggars
-
both
on
the
buses
and
in
the
major
bus
terminals
.
Many
bus
drivers
are
notoriously
dangerous
as
they
race
against
each
other
to
try
and
pick
up
passengers
before
the
other
buses
plying
the
same
route
.
Metro
Mini
has
the
worst
reputation
for
poor
drivers
.
Buses
do
not
necessarily
stop
at
bus
stops
...
they
stop
wherever
they
can
pick
up
a
passenger
be
it
in
the
middle
of
the
road
or
on
a
busy
intersection
.
Buses
do
not
necessarily
come
to
a
complete
stop
for
passengers
to
get
off
and
on
.
So
be
careful
as
to
which
foot
you
step
off
the
bus
with
!
The
beginning
and
end
points
of
each
bus
route
are
found
on
the
front
and
back
of
each
bus
,
along
with
a
route
number
.
If
you
don
'
t
know
which
bus
to
take
,
just
ask
the
people
at
the
bus
stop
and
they
'
ll
tell
you
(
helps
if
you
speak
Indonesian
,
of
course
)
.
Inter
-
city
buses
to
other
cities
in
Java
and
Sumatra
(
bis
antar
kota
)
can
be
found
at
the
biggest
bus
stations
-
Pulau
Gadung
,
Kampung
Rambutan
,
Lebak
Bulus
,
Blok
M
,
and
Kota
.
Delman
Perhaps
the
only
truly
traditional
transportation
left
in
Jakarta
,
delman
(
horse
-
drawn
carriages
)
are
getting
harder
to
spot
in
Jakarta
nowadays
.
They
are
most
commonly
used
to
transport
goods
from
major
markets
.
Delman
can
often
be
found
around
Pasar
Palmerah
,
Kemanggisan
,
Cipulir
,
around
big
pasar
run
by
PD
Pasar
Jaya
(
the
city
market
authority
)
.
On
Sundays
you
can
rent
a
delman
in
the
roads
surrounding
Monas
(
the
national
monument
)
.
The
locals
usually
pile
in
the
kids
and
have
the
delman
driver
take
them
for
a
fun
ride
around
the
Monas
park
.
Delman
are
often
rented
by
a
Betawi
family
to
transport
kids
around
the
neighborhood
to
celebrate
a
sunatan
ceremony
(
circumcision
)
.
When
rented
for
parties
such
as
this
,
the
delman
are
often
decorated
with
traditional
Betawi
ornamentation
which
lends
a
very
festive
air
.
Delman
have
been
used
by
the
expatriate
community
in
Permata
Hijau
for
years
to
carry
their
kids
around
the
housing
complex
to
the
participating
homes
for
trick
-
or
-
treat
fun
.
They
provide
great
fun
for
a
expat
child
'
s
birthday
party
as
well
.
Bargain
ahead
of
time
to
settle
on
a
price
as
the
price
varies
depending
on
the
distance
.
Delman
pictured
above
is
from
Cibadak
,
near
Sukabumi
.
Kereta
Api
A
commuter
train
(
kereta
api
)
runs
several
times
daily
from
Bogor
to
Jakarta
.
These
trains
are
quite
simply
furnished
and
often
quite
dirty
.
Scores
of
passengers
brave
the
dangers
and
seat
themselves
atop
the
trains
to
avoid
paying
the
fares
.
Trains
to
other
major
cities
on
Java
leave
Jakarta
from
train
stations
at
Gambir
,
Tanah
Abang
and
Senin
.
Different
classes
of
service
are
available
,
with
the
first
class
or
executive
class
being
quite
comfortable
.
Some
trains
are
bookable
in
advance
.
Trains
are
a
good
transportation
option
for
inter
-
city
travel
on
a
budget
.
Information
on
train
schedules
can
be
found
on
the
National
Railways
web
site
.
Mikrolet
/
Angkot
Mikrolet
and
angkot
(
these
vehicles
go
by
other
names
as
well
)
are
smaller
vans
/
mini
-
buses
that
serve
set
routes
on
smaller
main
roads
.
They
seat
9
-
12
people
,
depending
on
the
type
.
Fares
run
from
Rp
500
to
1
,
200
,
depending
on
the
distance
.
Students
pay
Rp
300
if
in
uniform
-
for
any
distance
.
The
beginning
and
end
points
of
the
routes
are
visible
on
the
front
and
back
of
each
bus
,
along
with
a
route
number
.
For
example
,
Tanah
Abang
-
Meruya
M11
.
Ojek
Ojek
“
motorcycle
taxis
”
began
appearing
in
Jakarta
after
becak
were
banned
in
1994
.
Ojek
service
began
as
a
people
'
s
initiative
to
provide
a
transportation
options
for
people
who
used
to
use
becak
from
main
roads
into
housing
complexes
.
There
is
no
government
licensing
for
or
control
over
ojek
.
By
law
all
motorcycle
passengers
should
wear
helmets
,
so
ojek
drivers
should
have
a
spare
for
you
to
wear
.
Ojek
tend
to
congregate
at
t
-
junctions
on
main
roads
and
near
smaller
roads
that
are
not
serviced
by
bus
routes
.
Ladies
have
a
careful
balancing
act
if
wearing
a
dress
and
must
sit
sidewise
on
the
back
of
the
vehicle
.
Bargain
before
you
get
on
-
ask
a
local
what
the
price
should
be
first
.
Ojek
Sepeda
Rarely
seen
in
areas
of
Jakarta
outside
Kota
and
Tanjung
Priok
in
North
Jakarta
.
Ojek
Sepeda
“
bicycle
taxis
”
operate
much
like
ojek
,
except
for
shorter
distances
.
Taksi
Please
read
our
separate
article
on
Taking
Taxis
in
Indonesia
.
River
Taxi
Back
in
time
,
long
before
taxis
,
bajaj
and
becak
...
Jakarta
'
s
residents
traveled
the
many
canals
and
rivers
and
canals
in
a
variety
of
boats
.
Today
there
are
still
places
in
Jakarta
where
you
can
find
perahu
penyeberangan
(
boats
used
to
cross
)
.
These
boatmen
take
people
across
a
river
often
from
a
major
road
to
the
kampung
on
the
other
side
/
so
that
they
don
'
t
have
to
travel
way
out
of
their
way
.
Panoramic
photographs
for
this
Traditional
Transportation
article
are
the
work
of
Martin
Bennett
of
Gambar
Panjang
...
we
appreciate
his
generous
and
unique
contribution
to
the
site
.
[
Practical
Information
]
[
Expat
Forum
]
[
Site
Map
]
[
Search
]
[
Home
Page
]
Tell
a
friend
about
the
Living
in
Indonesia
web
site
Copyright
©
1997
-
2006
,
Expat
Web
Site
Association
.
Jakarta
,
Indonesia
http
:
//
www
.
expat
.
or
.
id
All
rights
reserved
.
The
information
on
Living
in
Indonesia
,
A
Site
for
Expatriates
may
not
be
retransmitted
or
reproduced
in
any
form
without
permission
.
This
information
has
been
compiled
from
sources
which
we
,
the
Expat
Web
Site
Association
and
volunteers
related
to
this
site
,
believe
to
be
reliable
.
While
reasonable
care
has
been
taken
to
ensure
that
the
facts
are
accurate
and
up
-
to
-
date
,
opinions
and
commentary
are
fair
and
reasonable
,
we
accept
no
responsibility
for
them
.
The
information
contained
does
not
make
any
recommendation
upon
which
you
can
rely
without
further
personal
consideration
and
is
not
an
offer
or
a
solicitation
to
buy
any
products
or
services
from
us
.
Opinions
and
statements
constitute
the
judgment
of
the
contributors
to
this
web
site
at
the
time
the
information
was
written
and
may
change
without
notice
.
After
20
hours
of
traveling
,
you
find
yourself
in
a
twin
-
cam
doing
200
kph
diagonally
across
the
toll
road
.
Your
knuckles
are
white
and
you
are
sweating
.
You
timidly
ask
the
driver
to
slow
down
-
a
mistake
,
as
he
looks
at
you
instead
of
the
road
,
smiles
broadly
and
says
,
"
Yes
!
"
-
the
only
English
word
he
knows
.
He
doesn
'
t
slow
down
.
You
wish
you
hadn
'
t
worn
that
vest
.
In
the
city
,
you
spend
20
minutes
in
the
car
without
moving
while
old
men
overtake
you
pushing
carts
.
You
wonder
if
all
the
blue
/
grey
stuff
in
the
air
is
normal
,
and
resolve
never
to
eat
in
one
of
the
millions
of
roadside
food
stalls
for
fear
of
your
life
.
At
least
the
hotel
is
a
bit
like
home
.
They
even
have
fish
'
n
chips
on
the
menu
.
Beer
costs
a
fortune
.
You
have
your
first
meeting
with
your
Indonesian
business
contacts
scheduled
at
10
:
00
a
.
m
.
Arriving
on
time
,
you
are
about
to
leave
30
minutes
later
to
find
the
CORRECT
venue
when
everyone
else
shows
up
.
Your
secretary
keeps
laughing
heartily
at
the
Indonesian
comments
,
which
is
unsettling
.
Unfortunately
,
it
is
Friday
,
and
everyone
disappears
again
at
11
:
30
a
.
m
.
to
go
and
pray
.
They
never
come
back
.
All
the
Indonesian
girls
in
the
hotel
bar
seem
very
friendly
.
They
all
speak
English
,
and
are
intrigued
to
learn
about
your
home
and
family
.
Then
the
barmaid
who
took
pity
on
you
on
your
first
day
whispers
you
the
girl
'
s
price
lists
.
You
are
aware
you
stick
out
like
a
sore
thumb
,
as
even
the
westerners
call
you
'
bule
'
-
you
guess
that
must
mean
'
newcomer
'
.
More
time
in
the
traffic
going
nowhere
,
until
suddenly
an
unseen
light
goes
green
and
you
suffer
minor
whiplash
from
the
acceleration
.
Motorbikes
with
whole
families
aboard
come
at
you
on
the
wrong
side
of
the
road
.
You
wonder
where
you
can
buy
a
copy
of
the
local
Highway
Code
(
It
probably
consists
of
7
words
:
"
If
you
get
there
first
,
it
'
s
yours
"
)
.
You
give
up
drinking
tea
and
coffee
,
because
no
matter
what
gestures
you
make
you
can
'
t
stop
them
putting
4
tablespoons
of
sugar
in
it
.
You
also
give
up
smoking
,
because
Silk
Cut
Ultra
-
Low
doesn
'
t
seem
to
be
very
widely
available
.
The
driver
hasn
'
t
showed
up
,
so
you
get
a
taxi
.
Despite
having
worked
all
day
,
the
taxi
driver
only
has
Rp
500
in
his
pocket
,
so
you
have
to
pay
Rp
50
,
000
for
a
Rp
5
,
730
journey
.
Later
you
wonder
if
the
driver
was
telling
the
truth
.
You
are
enjoying
some
Indonesian
home
hospitality
when
a
2
-
inch
long
brown
thing
runs
over
your
foot
.
No
one
flinches
except
you
,
and
as
you
re
-
enter
the
earth
'
s
atmosphere
you
realize
it
wasn
'
t
a
mouse
,
but
a
cockroach
.
For
the
third
time
that
day
you
look
away
awkwardly
from
the
beggar
,
pretending
not
to
notice
.
You
wonder
how
the
hell
you
'
ll
stand
it
here
for
the
rest
of
the
week
.
Part
2
:
The
Twenty
-
first
Week
Your
driver
,
Pak
Yanto
collects
you
from
your
apartment
at
6
:
00
a
.
m
.
During
the
drive
to
the
office
you
alternately
read
the
paper
,
sleep
and
exchange
jokes
in
Indonesian
with
Pak
Yanto
.
You
get
to
the
office
with
no
recollection
of
the
journey
whatever
.
At
11
:
10
a
.
m
.
you
decide
it
must
be
lunch
time
.
You
are
by
now
well
used
to
"
rubber
time
"
-
the
concept
that
watches
are
useless
,
as
it
is
whatever
time
you
want
it
to
be
.
You
go
to
a
little
restaurant
with
your
colleagues
and
eat
"
ayam
rica
-
rica
"
with
extra
sambal
.
That
makes
you
sleepy
,
so
you
postpone
a
couple
of
meetings
until
next
week
.
Back
home
,
the
maid
greets
you
with
genuine
enthusiasm
and
runs
your
bath
and
lays
out
your
evening
clothes
.
She
doesn
'
t
speak
English
,
but
you
understand
the
intricacies
of
her
analysis
of
today
'
s
price
increases
at
the
market
and
the
scandal
surrounding
the
fact
that
the
maid
next
door
was
seen
smoking
in
the
street
,
as
she
chatters
happily
away
to
you
.
You
stop
off
at
one
of
the
millions
of
roadside
food
stalls
with
your
beautiful
Indonesian
girlfriend
and
enjoy
a
huge
bowl
of
s
oto
kambing
that
tastes
like
heaven
,
and
decide
on
the
spot
that
you
'
ll
marry
the
girl
.
The
thought
of
eating
fish
'
n
chips
now
seems
about
as
appealing
as
eating
your
own
fingernails
.
No
one
seems
to
notice
you
'
re
the
only
westerner
in
the
place
-
perhaps
you
'
re
starting
to
look
Indonesian
?
You
go
to
the
beach
with
your
newly
appointed
fiancee
at
the
weekend
and
eat
fresh
barbecued
lobster
in
the
sunset
.
Pak
Yanto
joins
you
to
drink
coffee
(
tidak
pakai
gula
!
)
,
and
smoke
Sampoerna
underneath
the
sign
you
vaguely
noticed
that
says
"
Dilarang
merokok
"
.
You
are
not
alone
.
Your
driver
is
at
the
workshop
with
the
car
so
you
get
a
taxi
.
Unfortunately
the
taxi
driver
has
no
change
and
you
only
have
a
Rp
50
,
000
note
for
a
Rp
5
,
730
journey
.
You
exclaim
"
cuek
aje
!
"
and
leap
out
of
the
car
to
get
the
exact
money
,
but
the
taxi
driver
suddenly
remembers
a
sack
of
cash
he
'
d
accidentally
overlooked
in
his
back
pocket
.
Pak
Yanto
is
looking
pleased
with
himself
.
He
explains
that
as
you
spend
so
much
time
at
the
nightclub
of
the
best
hotel
in
town
,
they
now
let
him
park
out
front
with
the
limos
instead
of
in
the
underground
car
park
.
You
wonder
if
you
might
be
overdoing
things
a
bit
.
You
wonder
if
any
city
in
the
world
is
as
beautiful
as
some
parts
of
Jakarta
at
night
.
Despite
having
driven
this
way
hundreds
of
times
before
,
you
never
get
bored
with
the
lights
.
It
was
driving
down
here
with
the
music
loud
and
a
car
full
of
Indonesian
friends
,
excited
at
the
prospect
of
a
good
night
out
,
that
you
decided
this
was
the
place
you
wanted
to
be
for
a
long
,
long
time
.
You
are
enjoying
some
Indonesian
home
hospitality
with
your
fiancee
'
s
family
and
her
sister
'
s
newly
arrived
westerner
friend
,
when
a
2
-
inch
long
brown
thing
runs
over
his
foot
.
As
he
picks
himself
out
of
the
ceiling
,
you
realize
how
far
you
'
ve
come
in
the
last
few
months
.
For
the
third
time
that
day
,
you
help
make
a
poor
person
happier
,
and
ponder
the
best
ways
of
helping
others
on
a
broader
scale
.
And
you
wonder
how
the
hell
you
'
d
stand
it
if
you
ever
went
home
.
Semi
autobiographical
!
(
Pak
Yanto
is
a
pseudonym
!
)
Dave
Cook
Mini
Glossary
:
Ayam
rica
-
rica
Chicken
dish
Bule
Derogatory
slang
word
for
foreigners
,
literally
means
albino
Cuek
aje
"
No
Problem
"
,
"
I
don
'
t
care
"
Dilarang
merokok
Smoking
forbidden
Sambal
Spicy
hot
chili
paste
,
an
essential
condiment
to
Indonesian
food
Soto
kambing
Goat
soup
Tidak
pakai
gula
Don
'
t
add
sugar
[
Practical
Information
]
[
Expat
Forum
]
[
Site
Map
]
[
Search
]
[
Home
Page
]
[
Contact
]
Tell
a
friend
about
the
Living
in
Indonesia
web
site
Copyright
©
1997
-
2006
,
Expat
Web
Site
Association
.
Jakarta
,
Indonesia
http
:
//
www
.
expat
.
or
.
id
All
rights
reserved
.
The
information
on
Living
in
Indonesia
,
A
Site
for
Expatriates
may
not
be
retransmitted
or
reproduced
in
any
form
without
permission
.
This
information
has
been
compiled
from
sources
which
we
,
the
Expat
Web
Site
Association
and
volunteers
related
to
this
site
,
believe
to
be
reliable
.
While
reasonable
care
has
been
taken
to
ensure
that
the
facts
are
accurate
and
up
-
to
-
date
,
opinions
and
commentary
are
fair
and
reasonable
,
we
accept
no
responsibility
for
them
.
The
information
contained
does
not
make
any
recommendation
upon
which
you
can
rely
without
further
personal
consideration
and
is
not
an
offer
or
a
solicitation
to
buy
any
products
or
services
from
us
.
Opinions
and
statements
constitute
the
judgment
of
the
contributors
to
this
web
site
at
the
time
the
information
was
written
and
may
change
without
notice
.
Jogjakarta
is
truly
a
unique
city
.
Ruled
by
a
king
(
sultan
)
whose
lineage
can
be
traced
to
centuries
,
this
city
offers
plenty
cultural
and
historical
heritage
.
Here
you
can
eat
lesehan
style
without
chairs
.
The
rather
sweet
cuisine
of
Jogjakarta
might
surprise
you
first
,
but
many
people
have
been
longing
for
good
Javanese
food
after
trying
it
once
,
so
you
might
have
the
same
experience
.
This
city
offers
many
luscious
delicacies
.
From
bakpia
cookies
,
wingko
babat
,
to
enting
-
enting
kacang
,
visitors
will
be
delighted
to
find
there
are
so
many
delicious
choices
here
in
this
town
.
Getting
There
To
make
it
easier
,
and
shorter
,
you
can
take
a
plane
from
major
cities
such
as
Jakarta
or
Bali
.
From
Jakarta
and
Bandung
you
can
also
go
to
Jogjakarta
by
train
and
the
journey
will
take
approx
.
8
-
12
hours
,
though
.
Some
travel
agents
or
rental
cars
also
offer
trips
to
Yogya
from
big
cities
with
a
reasonable
fee
.
The
journey
will
take
longer
than
12
hours
from
Jakarta
or
Bandung
.
Where
to
Stay
Packed
with
local
and
international
tourists
,
Yogya
is
ready
with
its
innumerable
inns
and
hotels
.
Choose
the
place
to
stay
according
to
your
budget
and
your
liking
.
Moving
Around
Jogjakarta
is
a
small
city
.
To
illustrate
this
,
for
some
Jogjakartans
,
2
kilometers
is
considered
very
far
.
In
the
city
,
you
can
give
your
legs
some
exercise
,
ride
andong
/
delman
(
cart
carried
by
a
/
two
horse
/
s
)
,
use
the
bus
and
public
transportation
,
ride
a
taxi
,
or
,
try
how
it
feels
like
to
ride
becak
/
pedicab
.
If
you
want
to
visit
interesting
sites
within
the
city
,
it
is
best
to
move
around
on
foot
.
If
,
however
,
you
want
to
marvel
at
the
grandiose
of
Borobudur
Temple
,
for
instance
,
it
is
best
if
you
rent
a
car
.
Dining
Guide
Gudeg
is
one
of
Jogjakarta
'
s
specialties
.
This
dish
is
made
of
young
jackfruit
with
traditional
herbs
,
sometimes
with
eggs
and
chicken
.
Cow
'
s
inner
skin
,
cooked
until
tender
,
usually
accompanies
gudeg
with
steamed
rice
.
Most
traditional
restaurants
in
Jogjakarta
sell
this
specialty
.
Don
'
t
let
the
sweet
taste
of
gudeg
fool
you
,
however
,
the
chili
sauce
of
Javanese
food
can
be
really
,
really
spicy
because
it
is
made
mainly
from
cabe
rawit
the
spiciest
chili
in
Indonesia
.
Restaurants
worth
visiting
in
Jogjakarta
:
DJOGJA
KAFE
Jalan
Kyai
Mojo
57
GADJAH
WONG
Jalan
Gejayan
79D
OMAH
DHUWUR
Jalan
Mondorakan
252
,
Kota
Gede
MBOK
BEREK
RESTAURANT
Jalan
Kaliurang
Km
16
Pakem
MORO
SENENG
RESTAURANT
Jalan
Solo
55
AYAM
GORENG
SUHARTI
RESTAURANT
Jalan
Laksda
Adisucipto
208
Souvenir
Tips
Jogjakarta
is
synonymous
with
arts
and
crafts
.
There
are
plenty
to
choose
from
:
from
batik
clothings
,
silverwares
and
silver
jewelries
,
potteries
,
to
wayang
figurines
made
of
cow
'
s
hide
or
wood
.
You
can
also
bring
along
boxes
of
the
famous
bakpia
for
your
family
and
close
friends
.
Bakpia
doesn
'
t
last
long
,
though
,
so
please
ask
the
salespeople
for
expiration
date
.
Other
Things
to
See
or
Do
Take
a
walk
on
Malioboro
street
,
it
'
s
packed
with
people
selling
interesting
souvenirs
,
with
stores
offering
more
exclusive
products
.
Bering
Harjo
market
on
Malioboro
street
offers
cheaper
products
.
Don
'
t
forget
to
use
your
bargaining
skill
!
Visit
Kota
Gede
,
the
center
of
silverwares
and
silver
jewelries
.
You
can
even
see
silversmith
at
work
here
.
The
items
sold
here
are
usually
more
pricey
because
they
'
re
more
exclusive
.
For
regular
yet
still
beautiful
silver
jewelries
,
visit
Malioboro
instead
.
Visit
Kasongan
if
you
'
re
into
potteries
.
Explore
the
city
from
Kraton
(
Palace
)
to
Taman
Sari
,
where
old
kings
and
their
families
spent
their
happy
days
,
swimming
and
enjoying
themselves
.
Take
a
trip
to
Borobudur
and
Loro
Jonggrang
(
Prambanan
)
Temples
.
Travel
Tips
Because
there
are
so
many
things
to
see
,
if
you
don
'
t
have
much
time
,
it
is
best
if
you
go
to
a
travel
agency
.
It
will
save
you
time
.
On
traditional
markets
and
Malioboro
,
most
of
the
items
sold
there
are
bargainable
.
When
in
doubt
,
ask
if
the
wares
are
bargainable
or
not
.
Bargain
at
least
half
the
price
the
seller
offers
first
.
If
you
'
re
not
certain
,
take
a
look
around
and
ask
for
the
similar
item
'
s
prices
,
for
comparison
.
If
you
have
a
travel
guide
from
a
travel
agency
,
ask
her
/
him
to
bargain
things
for
you
.
The
same
goes
if
you
'
re
lucky
enough
to
have
locals
as
your
friends
or
relatives
.
Never
hire
an
unlicensed
travel
guide
.
Bring
lightweight
clothings
,
also
hats
and
shades
,
if
necessary
.
Jogjakarta
can
be
quite
hot
.
If
you
'
re
being
offered
things
that
do
not
interest
you
,
be
firm
and
say
no
.
Government
may
raise
production
revenue
share
for
gas
contractors
Leony
Aurora
and
Wahyudi
Soeriaatmadja
/
Bloomberg
-
2006
-
08
-
29
11
:
07
:
43
Jakarta
,
August
29
,
2006
(
Bloomberg
)
-
Indonesia
may
raise
the
share
of
gas
production
revenue
for
contractors
willing
to
sell
the
fuel
to
the
domestic
market
as
demand
rises
.
The
government
is
considering
increasing
the
30
percent
share
of
gas
revenue
that
Premier
Oil
Plc
,
a
UK
based
-
oil
company
that
operates
the
West
Natuna
Block
A
concession
,
to
as
much
as
49
percent
to
persuade
the
explorer
to
sell
the
gas
to
Batam
instead
of
Singapore
,
Energy
Minister
Purnomo
Yusgiantoro
said
in
Jakarta
Monday
.
"
We
are
willing
to
get
as
low
as
51
percent
"
of
the
revenue
,
Purnomo
said
.
The
government
is
calculating
a
suitable
for
contractors
that
allows
them
to
sell
the
gas
at
US
$
3
.
50
per
million
British
thermal
unit
,
the
highest
price
that
power
generated
from
the
fuel
remains
competitive
,
he
said
.
The
government
is
promoting
the
use
of
natural
gas
and
coal
to
cut
the
country
'
s
dependence
on
oil
after
crude
prices
tripled
since
2002
.
Producers
that
can
sell
the
gas
abroad
have
been
reluctant
to
deliver
the
fuel
to
the
domestic
market
,
where
prices
can
be
less
than
half
of
that
for
exported
gas
.
"
The
government
should
let
go
of
some
of
its
revenue
to
gain
from
intangible
benefits
,
such
as
jobs
and
economic
growth
"
from
the
gas
agreements
,
Purnomo
told
reporters
Sunday
.
"
In
principal
,
we
don
'
t
want
producers
nor
consumers
to
lose
.
"
Prices
of
gas
channeled
outside
the
country
through
pipes
or
exported
as
liquefied
natural
gas
are
about
$
8
per
million
a
British
thermal
unit
,
Purnomo
said
.
Premier
has
discovered
new
gas
fields
in
Block
A
with
reserves
amounting
to
500
billion
cubic
feet
,
Kardaya
Warnika
,
chairman
of
the
state
oil
and
gas
regulator
BPMigas
said
Sunday
.
The
company
should
be
able
to
channel
120
million
standard
cubic
feet
a
day
to
Batam
for
20
years
,
Warnika
said
.
Premier
has
channeled
gas
from
its
Anoa
and
Kakap
fields
in
West
Natuna
through
a
400
-
kilometer
underwater
pipeline
to
Singapore
since
2001
.
The
company
is
in
negotiations
for
further
gas
sales
to
the
city
-
state
,
Premier
said
on
its
Web
site
.
Batam
is
an
Indonesian
island
located
about
24
kilometers
south
of
Singapore
.
The
government
has
earmarked
'
the
island
as
a
special
econom
¬
ic
zone
with
simplified
tax
system
and
labor
conditions
.
The
government
in
June
last
year
previously
raised
the
share
of
ConocoPhillips
and
its
partner
at
the
time
,
Exxon
-
Mobil
Corp
.
,
in
Block
A
exploration
area
near
Aceh
to
48
percent
from
40
percent
.
Houston
-
based
ConocoPhillips
,
the
operator
of
the
area
,
hasn
'
t
developed
the
field
so
far
because
it
said
the
high
carbon
dioxide
content
makes
gas
production
unprofitable
.
NRM
Headline
News
is
a
free
,
weekly
e
-
mail
news
service
in
English
,
covering
the
issues
of
natural
resources
governance
and
policy
in
Indonesia
.
Headline
News
contains
selected
news
items
from
the
Indonesian
press
,
information
about
upcoming
events
and
employment
opportunities
,
and
regular
updates
on
the
activities
of
the
Natural
Resources
Management
(
NRM
)
Program
.
Funding
is
provided
by
the
United
States
Agency
for
International
Development
(
USAID
)
.
T
he
NRM
Headline
News
is
available
in
plain
text
or
HTML
formats
.
Contributions
from
readers
are
always
welcome
.
Please
e
-
mail
us
at
headline
@
nrm
.
or
.
id
Story
No
.
1
:
Bunaken
Village
Receives
Seacology
Grant
for
Community
Dock
Construction
The
Seacology
Foundation
awarded
a
$
20
,
000
grant
to
Bunaken
Village
in
recognition
of
the
cooperation
and
foresight
of
the
villagers
in
formulating
a
zonation
system
.....
more
Story
No
.
2
:
Workshop
on
Developing
of
PLH
Concept
,
Balikpapan
Notes
from
workshop
focused
on
developing
concepts
for
environment
education
for
the
City
of
Balikpapan
.....
more
Story
No
.
3
:
CRMP
(
Proyek
Pesisir
)
Monthly
Report
for
June
2002
Implementation
Progress
Update
.....
more
Story
No
.
4
:
Certification
:
Plain
and
Simple
Provides
up
-
to
-
date
facts
,
figures
,
and
analysis
on
the
different
certification
schemes
,
the
relations
between
them
,
and
the
impact
they
are
having
in
the
tropics
.....
more
Story
No
.
5
:
Officials
Ignore
Warnings
on
Real
Environmental
Threats
Planners
,
environmentalists
and
other
experts
often
link
the
problem
of
flooding
to
the
lack
of
green
areas
in
the
city
as
violations
of
the
principles
of
environmentally
friendly
development
continue
.....
more
Story
No
.
6
:
Tarsiers
Threatened
with
Extinction
The
tarsier
population
has
dropped
because
its
habitat
has
been
damaged
by
logging
and
land
clearing
.....
more
Story
No
.
7
:
Environment
Minister
Slams
Law
Enforcers
Environment
Minister
Nabiel
Makarim
says
deforestation
remains
rampant
because
law
enforcers
are
corrupt
and
incompetent
.....
more
Story
No
.
8
:
RI
Proposes
3
National
Parks
to
Become
World
Heritage
Sites
"
The
three
are
the
national
parks
of
Kerinci
Seblat
and
Bukit
Barisan
Selatan
(
in
Sumatra
)
and
Gunung
Leuser
(
in
Aceh
)
,
"
Widodo
S
Ramono
,
director
of
the
National
Park
and
Natural
Resources
Conservation
(
KSDA
)
told
ANTARA
and
Bisnis
Indonesia
.....
more
Story
No
.
9
:
Definition
of
'
Degraded
'
,
'
Sustainable
'
Forest
Needed
Business
will
be
judged
in
part
by
the
level
of
transparency
provided
,
and
clear
,
unambiguous
definitions
of
that
being
talked
about
.....
more
Story
No
.
10
:
Government
Pay
no
Serious
Heed
to
Environmental
Issues
"
The
gloomy
picture
on
the
enforcement
of
environmental
laws
in
Indonesia
is
merely
a
proof
of
this
government
'
s
weak
commitment
to
imposing
the
principles
of
Good
Sustainable
Development
Governance
,
"
ICEL
executive
director
Wiwiek
Awiati
said
on
Friday
.....
more
Story
No
.
11
:
NRM
Noon
Seminar
.....
more
Story
No
.
12
:
Director
,
CIDA
PSU
,
Jakarta
CIDA
is
currently
seeking
a
qualified
candidate
to
fill
the
position
of
Director
for
the
PSU
.....
more
Story
No
.
13
:
Vacancies
at
CIFOR
CIFOR
,
in
cooperation
with
the
Forestry
Research
and
Development
Agency
(
FORDA
)
,
Ministry
of
Forestry
Indonesia
,
are
looking
for
scientists
to
coordinate
research
activities
in
the
Bulungan
Research
Forest
,
East
Kalimantan
,
Indonesia
.
The
positions
are
fixed
term
and
will
be
funded
through
a
recently
approved
project
supported
through
the
International
Tropical
Timber
Organization
(
ITTO
)
.....
more
Story
No
.
1
:
Bunaken
Village
Receives
Seacology
Grant
for
Community
Dock
Construction
Sunday
is
typically
a
very
stressful
day
in
the
life
of
the
corals
that
fringe
the
reef
in
front
of
Bunaken
Village
.
As
the
tide
falls
and
the
corals
and
seagrass
are
exposed
to
the
punishing
heat
of
the
day
,
they
experience
an
added
insult
:
boats
carrying
hundreds
of
churchgoers
,
fisherfolk
and
beach
tourists
are
forced
to
drop
anchor
at
the
reef
edge
and
trample
the
reefs
on
their
way
in
to
the
village
.
The
experience
is
seldom
pleasant
for
the
humans
involved
either
;
scorpionfish
punctures
and
coral
cuts
are
a
common
outcome
of
these
beach
treks
.
Fortunately
,
relief
is
in
sight
for
both
the
marine
plants
and
animals
of
Bunaken
and
the
people
who
depend
on
them
.
The
Seacology
Foundation
(
www
.
seacology
.
org
)
,
an
organization
which
focuses
on
preserving
the
environments
and
cultures
of
islands
throughout
the
world
,
has
awarded
a
$
20
,
000
grant
to
Bunaken
Village
for
the
construction
of
a
community
landing
dock
.
The
grant
is
made
in
recognition
of
the
cooperation
and
foresight
of
the
villagers
in
formulating
a
zonation
system
for
their
island
that
includes
a
number
of
“
no
-
take
”
zones
(
totaling
approximately
30
%
of
the
island
’
s
reef
area
)
where
fishing
is
absolutely
prohibited
.
These
strict
marine
reserve
areas
on
Bunaken
Island
have
now
been
closed
to
fishing
for
almost
two
years
,
and
many
villagers
and
divers
claim
to
see
a
noticeable
difference
in
the
number
of
larger
fish
(
including
sharks
,
grouper
and
Napoleon
wrasse
)
present
.
Seacology
’
s
one
prerequisite
for
releasing
the
funds
for
the
dock
is
for
Bunaken
village
to
“
upgrade
”
the
zonation
system
’
s
legal
basis
to
that
of
village
law
(
the
zones
are
currently
part
of
an
MOU
between
the
village
and
the
Bunaken
National
Park
office
)
.
The
villager
’
s
are
eagerly
wrapping
up
the
legal
procedures
necessary
to
ratify
this
law
,
and
hope
to
start
construction
on
the
dock
by
September
.
Duane
Silverstein
,
the
Executive
Director
of
Seacology
,
praised
the
Bunaken
villagers
for
their
strong
commitment
to
conservation
of
their
marine
resources
:
"
Seacology
is
pleased
to
recognize
the
foresight
and
sacrifice
of
Bunaken
village
in
establishing
marine
reserves
to
protect
their
coral
reefs
and
sea
grass
for
generations
to
come
.
In
exchange
for
this
sacrifice
Seacology
is
pleased
to
provide
funding
for
a
much
needed
community
landing
dock
.
"
It
seems
likely
that
Bunaken
’
s
reefs
are
pleased
as
well
!
Mark
V
.
Erdmann
Marine
Protected
Areas
Advisor
NRM
/
EPIQ
SULUT
erdmann
@
nrm
.
or
.
id
Top
Story
No
.
2
:
Workshop
on
Developing
of
PLH
Concept
,
Balikpapan
NRM
-
EPIQ
,
Proyek
Pesisir
,
and
Yayasan
Bina
Manusia
dan
Lingkungan
(
YBML
)
,
in
cooperation
with
the
National
Education
Office
(
Dinas
Pendidikan
Nasional
-
Diknas
)
of
Balikpapan
,
conducted
a
three
days
workshop
focused
on
developing
concepts
for
environment
education
for
the
City
of
Balikpapan
.
The
workshop
was
conducted
from
May
3
-
5
,
2002
,
in
Hotel
Benakutai
.
The
objective
of
workshop
was
to
develop
a
basic
concept
and
framework
for
environmental
education
(
or
PLH
-
Pendidikan
Lingkungan
Hidup
)
for
students
in
Balikpapan
specially
tailored
for
the
potential
and
characteristics
of
the
region
.
The
workshop
marks
the
beginning
of
joint
work
between
the
three
organizations
to
develop
guidance
for
developing
the
Balikpapan
City
’
s
educational
curriculum
,
including
the
means
for
delivery
and
supporting
infrastructures
.
Participants
at
the
workshop
including
the
government
agencies
,
academicians
,
international
organizations
(
NRM
,
Proyek
Pesisir
,
Tropenbos
)
,
NGOs
(
YBML
,
Yayasan
BIKAL
)
,
private
sectors
(
Unocal
,
TotalFinalElf
E
&
P
Indonesie
)
,
and
the
general
public
representatives
.
On
the
first
day
,
papers
were
prepared
and
presented
by
teachers
,
university
representatives
(
University
of
Mulawarman
-
UNMUL
)
,
government
’
s
personnel
(
Bapedalda
Balikpapan
)
,
and
a
private
sector
(
Unocal
)
.
On
the
second
day
,
all
the
participants
took
a
field
study
to
learn
the
linked
issues
that
must
be
included
in
any
week
planned
environmental
education
program
.
Participants
were
divided
into
three
groups
(
green
,
brown
,
and
blue
)
.
The
Green
Group
observed
all
issues
related
to
mangrove
forest
and
other
forestry
activities
including
Sungai
Wain
Protected
Forest
area
.
The
Brown
Group
observed
all
issues
related
to
the
environmental
pollution
and
reclamation
.
The
Blue
Group
observed
all
issues
(
industry
,
human
settlement
,
fishpond
/
tambak
)
found
in
the
coastal
and
bay
.
These
issues
illustrated
the
need
for
well
-
designed
integrated
management
of
upstream
as
well
as
downstream
activities
and
include
areas
from
the
city
to
the
coastal
and
marine
zones
.
On
the
third
day
,
the
participants
conducted
presentation
and
discussion
,
came
up
with
the
issues
highlighted
during
the
field
study
and
generated
recommendations
on
how
to
address
these
in
the
Balikpapan
environmental
education
program
.
The
workshop
recommendations
for
developing
the
PLH
concept
include
:
Joint
development
of
the
overall
concept
,
framework
,
curriculum
,
and
modules
with
a
variety
of
stakeholders
;
PLH
training
for
PLH
facilitators
and
school
teachers
to
ensure
capacity
for
delivery
;
Preparation
of
location
as
a
real
place
to
study
the
environmental
condition
Preliminary
testing
of
PLH
modules
and
materials
in
several
schools
;
Monitor
,
evaluate
,
and
revise
the
concept
,
materials
and
modules
after
the
testing
;
Use
local
content
reflecting
Balikpapan
special
characteristics
.
With
support
from
USAID
’
s
Proyek
Pesisir
and
NRM
/
EPIQ
programs
,
plans
are
now
being
made
to
proceed
with
development
of
the
modules
.
As
currently
conceived
,
there
will
be
three
main
modules
each
dealing
with
a
different
area
of
environmental
education
.
These
include
terrestrial
issues
,
marine
and
coastal
issues
and
urban
or
city
issues
.
NRM
-
EPIQ
has
taken
the
lead
in
securing
additional
outside
funding
for
the
program
.
During
the
month
of
June
,
all
organizations
,
represented
through
a
special
team
(
Tim
Kecil
)
will
initiate
work
on
developing
a
more
detailed
concept
for
the
modules
.
The
effort
is
supported
by
a
decree
from
Balikpapan
Mayor
,
Imdad
Hamid
,
that
Balikpapan
will
develop
and
include
environmental
education
as
a
key
part
of
its
school
curriculum
.
This
decision
by
Mayor
Imdad
Hamid
signifies
his
commitment
to
environmental
issues
and
establishes
him
as
a
leader
in
Indonesia
for
environmental
education
.
For
more
information
,
please
contact
:
Elisabeth
Wetik
/
Ramon
Proyek
Pesisir
,
Balikpapan
,
East
Kalimantan
Phone
:
(
62
-
542
)
731
016
pesisir
@
indosat
.
net
.
id
or
Satria
Iman
Pribadi
Outreach
&
Education
Specialist
NRM
/
EPIQ
Kalimantan
Timur
satriai
@
samarinda
.
org
Top
Story
No
.
3
:
CRMP
(
Proyek
Pesisir
)
Monthly
Report
for
June
2002
A
.
Regional
Programs
I
.
North
Sulawesi
The
Kabupaten
Minahasa
Community
-
Based
Coastal
Management
Perda
(
Peraturan
Daerah
-
Local
Regulation
)
was
signed
into
law
on
June
26
,
2002
.
This
is
an
incredible
milestone
for
Proyek
Pesisir
and
the
Minahasa
Kabupaten
Government
,
and
puts
into
place
one
more
piece
of
the
bridge
to
achieving
stronger
decentralized
coastal
management
in
Indonesia
.
The
Perda
identifies
the
Kabupaten
Office
of
Fisheries
and
Marine
Affairs
(
Dinas
Perikanan
dan
Kelautan
)
as
the
lead
agency
for
integrated
coastal
management
and
established
a
stakeholder
advisory
body
.
This
Perda
stands
as
both
a
symbol
of
what
can
be
done
under
decentralization
and
a
model
for
other
kabupatens
to
follow
.
This
is
a
major
accomplishment
for
institutionalizing
the
work
that
Proyek
Pesisir
has
been
undertaking
over
the
past
five
years
and
represents
a
major
break
through
for
local
governments
.
The
Perda
will
be
distributed
widely
as
a
reference
for
other
kabupatens
and
provinces
.
It
will
also
be
translated
into
English
as
it
is
a
model
that
is
useful
not
only
in
Indonesia
,
but
for
other
governments
around
the
world
that
are
developing
"
nested
"
community
-
based
ICM
programs
within
a
larger
governance
context
.
The
development
of
a
similar
Perda
for
the
Province
of
North
Sulawesi
has
also
started
through
Proyek
Pesisir
’
s
contract
with
Sam
Ratulangi
University
(
UNSRAT
)
School
of
Law
to
lead
the
process
.
Working
through
UNSRAT
builds
more
ownership
and
transparency
in
the
Province
,
and
increases
the
capability
of
UNSRAT
School
of
Law
.
Proyek
Pesisir
’
s
contract
with
UNSRAT
further
broadens
the
circle
of
Proyek
Pesisir
partners
that
already
includes
many
academics
,
non
-
governmental
organizations
and
government
agencies
.
Starting
last
year
,
Proyek
Pesisir
began
expanding
(
Scaling
-
Up
)
its
direct
engagement
of
villages
in
community
-
based
ICM
in
Kecamatan
Likupang
.
The
scaling
-
up
process
is
proceeding
at
a
rapid
pace
.
In
Kecamatan
Likupang
,
Proyek
Pesisir
is
assisting
local
partners
in
22
villages
to
build
upon
the
experiences
in
the
Proyek
Pesisir
anchor
sites
of
Blongko
,
Bentenen
,
Tumbak
and
Talise
(
See
Issue
12
of
NRM
Headlines
News
,
June
27
,
2002
for
other
news
on
cross
-
visits
to
Proyek
Pesisir
Anchor
Sites
from
Riau
)
.
Training
is
ongoing
in
the
villages
through
community
organizers
who
volunteered
from
each
village
.
Eight
different
training
modules
have
been
developed
,
four
that
are
required
for
program
participation
and
four
that
are
optional
at
village
request
.
Dinas
Perikanan
dan
Kelautan
is
heavily
involved
in
the
implementation
and
oversight
of
the
Likupang
scaling
-
up
program
.
A
number
of
key
activities
have
already
been
identified
as
options
for
implementation
in
these
villages
,
including
:
marine
sanctuaries
,
mangrove
sanctuaries
,
and
village
ordinances
(
Perdes
)
.
With
the
passage
of
the
Minahasa
Perda
it
is
expected
that
there
would
be
significant
local
government
budget
allocated
next
year
for
further
scaling
-
up
of
Proyek
Pesisir
’
s
best
practices
across
Kabupaten
Minahasa
.
The
Minahasa
Stakeholder
Monitoring
Program
is
moving
along
.
Local
stakeholders
and
Proyek
Pesisir
staff
have
worked
collaboratively
to
create
a
voluntary
stakeholder
monitoring
program
that
includes
villages
,
universities
,
government
,
and
the
private
sector
in
gathering
data
on
changes
in
coastal
and
near
-
shore
marine
resources
.
This
information
will
be
provided
to
the
government
and
UNSRAT
,
both
of
which
have
agreed
to
maintain
the
resulting
data
sets
over
time
so
that
the
province
will
eventually
have
a
time
series
for
data
points
that
are
important
to
coastal
resources
users
.
In
addition
to
data
being
available
for
other
uses
,
a
main
desired
outcome
of
the
program
is
involving
local
stakeholders
in
a
process
that
demonstrates
changes
in
the
status
of
coastal
resources
over
time
,
especially
in
relation
to
certain
types
of
natural
events
and
human
activities
.
The
anchor
-
site
graduation
program
for
the
villages
of
Blongko
,
Talise
,
and
Bentenan
/
Tumbak
has
been
fully
developed
using
a
village
self
-
assessment
program
that
leads
villagers
to
recognize
their
achievements
and
how
much
they
know
about
their
CB
-
CRM
process
and
the
results
.
The
three
anchor
sites
are
expected
to
graduate
by
the
end
of
this
calendar
year
.
II
.
East
Kalimantan
The
development
of
the
Balikpapan
Bay
Management
Plan
(
BBMP
)
is
in
the
final
stages
of
review
.
Dr
.
Dietriech
Bengen
of
the
Center
for
Coastal
and
Marine
Resources
Studies
(
CCMRS
)
of
Bogor
Agricultural
Institute
(
IPB
)
has
just
completed
a
technical
review
of
the
BBMP
and
final
edits
are
underway
.
The
BBMP
was
distributed
to
local
stakeholders
in
several
previous
versions
and
a
workshop
was
conducted
with
local
stakeholders
to
compile
all
the
comments
.
There
will
be
additional
involvement
of
stakeholders
and
socializing
with
key
counterparts
as
the
process
moves
along
.
The
BBMP
is
one
of
the
only
coastal
management
plans
in
Indonesia
that
integrates
coastal
management
within
four
governmental
administrative
authorities
-
City
of
Balikpapan
,
Kabupatens
Pasir
and
Penajam
,
and
the
Province
of
East
Kalimantan
.
Two
early
action
programs
have
been
initiated
with
local
government
counterparts
to
examine
the
management
processes
related
to
mangrove
management
,
sedimentation
,
and
erosion
.
These
early
actions
illustrate
the
purpose
of
the
BBMP
as
a
tool
that
focuses
on
institutional
change
by
establishing
new
management
mechanisms
,
rather
than
conducting
more
mini
-
field
demonstration
projects
that
ultimately
have
limited
effect
.
The
Friends
of
Balikpapan
Bay
(
Sahabat
Teluk
Balikpapan
-
STB
)
received
its
official
legal
authorization
in
March
2002
.
In
May
,
Proyek
Pesisir
contracted
a
new
Executive
Director
who
is
currently
preparing
a
business
plan
for
the
new
NGO
created
with
USAID
assistance
.
The
STB
will
be
the
first
NGO
in
East
Kalimantan
focused
exclusively
on
coastal
and
marine
management
issues
.
The
business
plan
is
due
in
July
and
will
include
plans
for
soliciting
funds
from
the
private
sector
,
government
and
donors
to
achieve
sustainability
.
Proyek
Pesisir
is
cooperating
with
NRM
/
EPIQ
,
the
Balikpapan
Office
of
Education
(
Dinas
Pendidikan
)
to
create
a
new
environmental
curriculum
for
schools
in
Balikpapan
.
Led
by
NRM
/
EPIQ
and
Dinas
Pendidikan
,
Proyek
Pesisir
is
providing
limited
support
for
coastal
and
marine
sector
issues
.
Last
year
,
the
Walikota
signed
a
decree
requiring
environmental
education
be
included
in
Balikpapan
’
s
school
curriculum
.
With
outside
funding
secured
through
NRM
/
EPIQ
,
there
will
be
three
environmental
education
modules
created
-
urban
,
terrestrial
and
coastal
/
marine
.
In
May
a
workshop
was
held
to
discuss
this
effort
that
included
government
,
universities
,
private
sector
and
NGOs
.
In
June
,
the
Special
Team
(
Tim
Kecil
)
created
at
this
workshop
has
been
working
to
clarify
the
concept
for
these
modules
.
III
.
Lampung
,
South
Sumatra
The
Proyek
Pesisir
Lampung
program
beginning
its
phase
-
out
program
and
it
is
expected
that
all
activities
will
be
completed
there
by
December
2002
.
Lampung
has
been
one
of
the
most
successful
programs
of
Proyek
Pesisir
,
producing
its
Provincial
Coastal
Resources
Atlas
and
Coastal
Strategic
Plan
(
Renstra
)
that
have
resulted
in
significant
allocation
of
funding
for
coastal
resources
management
in
the
province
.
Evaluation
and
monitoring
of
the
implementation
of
the
Renstra
have
led
to
updating
of
the
Atlas
and
reprinting
in
response
to
many
continuing
requests
for
copies
.
The
new
Lampung
Coastal
Atlas
is
now
available
on
request
through
Proyek
Pesisir
or
the
Center
for
Coastal
and
Marine
Resources
Studies
(
PKSPL
)
at
IBP
.
One
of
Proyek
Pesisir
’
s
lead
activities
in
Lampung
was
assisting
villagers
on
Pulau
Sebesi
,
a
small
island
off
the
coast
of
Lampung
,
to
inventory
their
coastal
resources
and
identify
opportunities
for
community
-
based
coastal
management
.
Last
month
the
villagers
established
their
first
Marine
Sanctuary
at
an
event
attended
by
many
local
officials
.
Proyek
Pesisir
will
continue
to
support
the
villagers
in
further
defining
coastal
management
options
on
Pulau
Sebesi
.
Pematang
Pasir
has
completed
it
’
s
village
management
plan
for
best
practice
shrimp
farming
and
is
now
moving
toward
close
out
of
Proyek
Pesisir
assistance
.
Other
activities
:
A
mini
-
scaling
-
up
program
is
planned
using
the
modules
created
in
the
North
Sulawesi
scaling
up
program
.
This
will
be
started
later
this
year
.
Monitoring
of
the
implementation
of
the
Coastal
Strategic
Plan
(
Renstra
)
also
will
continue
later
this
year
.
B
.
National
Coastal
Management
Law
Initiative
(
RUU
PWP
)
A
series
of
discussions
among
members
of
the
multi
-
stakeholder
RUU
Special
Team
(
Tim
Kecil
)
on
the
drafting
of
the
national
coastal
management
law
took
place
during
the
month
and
resulted
in
a
much
cleaner
draft
of
the
law
and
its
public
consultation
strategy
.
A
series
of
inter
-
departmental
and
regional
public
consultations
are
planned
for
July
,
August
,
and
September
with
the
hope
that
by
the
end
of
October
there
will
be
a
final
draft
ready
for
submission
to
the
DPR
.
The
RUU
PWP
is
the
first
law
of
its
kind
in
Indonesia
relying
as
much
on
provisions
for
voluntary
compliance
and
participation
as
legal
requirements
.
The
most
recent
version
of
the
law
is
available
on
line
at
“
www
.
dkp
.
go
.
id
”
.
Proyek
Pesisir
was
part
of
a
multi
-
stakeholder
and
multi
-
organizational
effort
to
initiate
an
review
of
the
Indonesia
National
Marine
Protected
Area
Strategy
.
The
effort
included
such
organizations
as
the
Ministry
of
Marine
Affairs
and
Fisheries
,
Ministry
of
Forestry
,
Worldwide
Fund
for
Nature
,
The
Nature
Conservancy
,
World
Commission
on
Protected
Areas
,
NRM
/
EPIQ
and
others
.
Efforts
will
be
taken
to
support
this
over
the
coming
months
by
working
closely
with
the
Ministry
of
Forestry
and
Ministry
of
Marine
Affairs
and
Fisheries
.
Proyek
Pesisir
began
support
for
a
collaborative
initiative
to
develop
a
coastal
resource
atlas
for
the
Bintuni
Bay
in
Papua
.
Meetings
were
held
with
the
Papua
delegation
at
the
Indonesia
National
Coastal
Management
Conference
(
KONAS
)
in
May
and
additional
meetings
were
held
in
Jakarta
in
June
.
As
a
result
of
these
meetings
,
local
government
and
universities
in
Papua
have
already
begun
to
set
up
teams
to
support
the
Bintuni
Atlas
initiative
.
In
July
,
Maurice
Knight
,
Chief
of
Party
for
Proyek
Pesisir
,
will
travel
to
Papua
to
meet
with
local
stakeholders
to
further
define
the
program
,
identify
partners
and
finalize
arrangements
for
a
kickoff
workshop
in
August
.
Through
this
workshop
,
stakeholders
will
work
collaboratively
to
identify
appropriate
roles
for
local
government
,
universities
and
non
-
governmental
organizations
at
the
local
and
provincial
levels
.
The
special
arrangements
under
Papua
Special
Autonomy
will
require
effective
engagement
across
all
levels
of
government
including
a
significant
role
for
universities
and
NGOs
.
IPB
’
s
Center
for
Coastal
and
Marine
Resources
Studies
(
CCMRS
)
is
leading
training
for
members
of
the
Indonesian
Coastal
Universities
Network
(
INCUNE
)
in
outreach
and
extension
for
community
supported
coastal
management
and
development
.
A
schedule
of
events
is
being
developed
by
IPB
.
CCRMS
also
will
assist
DKP
and
Proyek
Pesisir
in
undertaking
regional
consultations
for
the
draft
national
coastal
management
law
in
a
number
of
provinces
.
USAID
Indonesia
Coastal
Resources
Management
Project
(
CRMP
)
Ratu
Plaza
-
Fl
18
Jl
.
Jend
.
Sudirman
Kav
9
Jakarta
10270
Indonesia
Ph
:
(
6221
)
720
9596
Fax
:
(
6221
)
720
7844
crmp
@
cbn
.
net
.
id
Top
Story
No
.
4
:
Certification
:
Plain
and
Simple
For
one
-
stop
shopping
to
find
out
the
latest
on
forest
certification
,
"
Forest
Certification
:
Pending
Challenges
for
Tropical
Timber
"
by
Richard
Eba
'
a
Atyi
and
Markku
Simula
is
as
good
as
it
gets
.
This
new
paper
produced
for
the
International
Tropical
Timber
Organization
provides
up
-
to
-
date
facts
,
figures
,
and
analysis
on
the
different
certification
schemes
,
the
relations
between
them
,
and
the
impact
they
are
having
in
the
tropics
.
By
reading
it
,
I
learned
that
:
In
January
2002
,
the
world
had
109
million
hectares
of
certified
forests
.
That
was
twice
what
it
had
in
2001
and
almost
four
times
as
much
as
in
1999
.
Some
2
.
8
%
of
the
world
'
s
forests
are
certified
.
North
America
has
8
.
7
%
of
its
forest
certified
and
Europe
has
5
.
7
%
certified
.
The
other
regions
have
only
about
0
.
5
%
of
their
forest
certified
.
Only
8
%
of
all
certified
forests
are
in
Asia
,
Africa
,
and
Latin
America
.
The
Pan
-
European
Forest
Certification
(
PEFC
)
scheme
and
the
Forest
Stewardship
Council
(
FSC
)
are
the
two
main
international
certification
schemes
.
PEFC
only
covers
Europe
.
FSC
,
the
Malaysian
national
certification
scheme
,
and
Kerhout
are
the
main
certification
schemes
operating
in
the
tropics
.
Only
86
certificates
for
forest
holdings
larger
than
50
,
000
hectares
each
account
for
more
than
90
%
of
the
FSC
certified
area
.
FSC
has
only
certified
284
forest
holdings
smaller
than
50
,
000
hectares
.
As
of
1999
,
FSC
had
only
certified
29
communal
or
community
forests
.
In
contrast
,
PEFC
and
the
American
Tree
Farm
System
scheme
(
ATFS
)
were
specifically
designed
for
smaller
holdings
and
most
of
their
certificates
have
gone
to
smaller
holdings
.
Three
certification
companies
-
SGS
,
Rainforest
Alliance
/
Smartwood
,
and
SCS
-
have
certified
88
%
of
the
forest
area
certified
under
the
FSC
.
The
United
Kingdom
,
Denmark
,
the
Netherlands
,
Belgium
,
Austria
and
several
states
in
the
United
States
now
have
"
green
procurement
policies
"
,
which
increasingly
favor
certified
products
.
The
forests
certified
in
the
tropics
tend
to
be
those
that
were
already
relatively
well
managed
.
Nonetheless
,
certification
seems
to
have
encouraged
better
forest
management
planning
,
establishment
of
permanent
sample
plots
,
the
use
of
reduced
impact
logging
,
more
set
-
asides
for
conservation
,
and
better
documentation
of
forest
practices
.
These
facts
alone
do
not
do
justice
to
Eba
'
a
Atyi
and
Simula
'
s
great
analysis
.
I
only
hope
they
catch
your
attention
enough
to
order
and
read
the
entire
paper
.
To
request
free
electronic
copies
of
Eba
'
a
Atyi
and
Sumula
'
s
paper
or
to
send
comments
or
queries
to
the
authors
you
can
write
Markku
Simula
at
:
MARKKU
.
SIMULA
@
INDUFOR
.
FI
David
Kaimowitz
d
.
kaimowitz
@
cgiar
.
org
Top
Story
No
.
5
:
Officials
Ignore
Warnings
on
Real
Environmental
Threats
Source
:
Jakarta
Post
,
July
08
,
2002
By
Bambang
Nurbianto
Jakarta
The
city
administration
have
turned
a
deaf
ear
to
the
warnings
of
experts
that
future
floods
could
be
worse
if
they
fail
to
maintain
or
even
expand
the
number
of
green
areas
in
the
city
.
"
It
is
typical
of
the
city
officials
that
they
always
try
to
pursue
short
-
term
benefits
as
much
as
possible
without
considering
the
long
-
term
problems
that
result
,
"
said
Ahmad
"
Puput
'
Safrudin
of
the
Jakarta
branch
of
the
Indonesian
Forum
for
the
Environment
(
Walhi
)
.
Puput
was
commenting
on
the
planned
development
of
a
new
business
center
in
a
40
-
square
-
meter
area
of
Senayan
that
comes
under
the
control
of
the
Senayan
sports
complex
authority
in
Central
Jakarta
,
and
which
was
originally
zoned
as
a
public
,
green
area
.
There
have
been
a
number
of
controversial
projects
constructed
in
the
Senayan
area
,
including
the
Mulia
Hotel
,
Plaza
Senayan
and
Taman
Ria
Senayan
.
Governor
Sutiyoso
has
agreed
to
reconstruct
the
fire
-
razed
flea
market
in
Taman
Puring
in
South
Jakarta
,
whose
location
according
to
the
2010
city
master
plan
is
supposed
to
be
a
green
area
.
He
also
approved
the
construction
of
a
controversial
sports
mall
in
Kelapa
Gading
,
East
Jakarta
,
that
was
originally
zoned
for
social
and
public
facilities
.
Chairman
of
the
Jakarta
chapter
of
the
Indonesian
Association
of
Planners
(
IAP
)
Abdul
Alim
Salam
said
the
city
would
eventually
pay
an
expensive
price
for
the
administration
'
s
lack
of
commitment
to
the
environment
.
If
the
development
of
a
business
centers
in
Senayan
continued
,
it
would
cause
environmental
problems
.
But
more
problems
would
arise
if
the
city
needed
more
land
for
sports
facilities
in
the
future
,
he
said
.
Puput
said
the
administration
should
expand
the
green
areas
in
the
city
from
the
present
nine
percent
to
about
14
percent
of
the
total
area
of
Jakarta
as
mandated
by
the
city
master
plan
up
to
2010
.
"
How
can
the
city
administration
increase
the
number
of
green
areas
if
it
continues
to
violate
the
land
use
policies
set
out
in
the
city
master
plan
,
"
said
Puput
,
adding
that
the
ideal
extent
of
green
areas
should
be
30
percent
of
the
total
area
of
the
city
.
Wicaksono
Sarosa
,
an
executive
director
of
the
Urban
and
Regional
Development
Institute
(
URDI
)
,
said
that
worse
flooding
would
not
be
the
only
consequence
of
the
dwindling
green
spaces
.
The
city
would
become
hotter
due
to
the
loss
of
green
spaces
and
because
more
people
would
buy
air
conditioners
.
"
So
,
those
who
suffer
most
will
be
the
people
who
are
not
able
to
afford
air
conditioners
,
"
said
Wicaksono
.
[
Courtesy
of
the
Indonesian
Nature
Conservation
List
]
Top
Story
No
.
6
:
Tarsiers
Threatened
with
Extinction
Source
:
Jakarta
Post
,
July
09
,
2002
By
Badri
Jawara
Palu
Belonging
to
the
family
of
small
primates
,
a
tarsier
has
a
body
that
measures
about
20
centimeters
in
length
and
resembles
a
rat
or
a
squirrel
.
Its
tail
is
longer
than
its
body
,
and
its
head
is
slightly
round
.
The
tarsier
has
eyes
that
are
round
and
sharp
,
with
large
irises
like
those
of
an
owl
.
A
female
tarsier
is
pregnant
for
6
months
before
giving
birth
.
Then
,
like
a
baby
monkey
,
a
baby
tarsier
is
breast
-
fed
by
the
mother
.
An
arboreal
animal
,
it
jumps
from
one
tree
to
another
like
a
squirrel
,
using
its
feet
,
which
resemble
those
of
a
rabbit
.
A
tarsier
lives
on
lizards
,
grasshoppers
,
worms
,
crickets
,
flies
,
mosquitoes
and
other
insects
.
Like
an
owl
,
it
is
a
nocturnal
animal
:
sleeping
during
the
day
and
looking
for
its
food
at
night
.
Tarsiers
,
which
are
among
the
world
'
s
smallest
primates
,
are
a
protected
species
.
The
total
tarsier
population
in
Sulawesi
has
never
been
calculated
.
But
the
animal
is
much
easier
to
spot
in
Central
Sulawesi
than
the
region
'
s
other
rare
and
unique
animals
,
like
deer
-
hogs
and
anoa
(
dwarf
buffaloes
)
.
"
A
census
has
yet
to
be
conducted
on
tarsiers
and
other
animals
endemic
to
this
province
.
One
of
the
reasons
is
a
lack
of
both
funds
and
the
necessary
equipment
,
"
M
.
Z
.
Hudiyono
,
the
head
of
Central
Sulawesi
'
s
natural
resources
conservation
center
,
said
.
Despite
its
status
as
a
protected
species
,
tarsiers
enjoy
less
attention
and
care
than
other
rare
species
in
Central
Sulawesi
,
like
deer
-
hogs
and
anoa
.
Physically
,
tarsiers
are
not
attractive
enough
to
be
in
demand
as
pets
,
so
they
are
generally
safe
from
hunters
.
Compared
with
other
animals
,
there
has
been
little
research
about
tarsiers
.
In
Indonesia
,
a
study
of
this
animal
was
not
conducted
until
1994
,
when
the
Center
for
Primate
Studies
at
the
Agricultural
Institute
of
Bogor
and
the
Indonesian
Safari
Park
in
Cisarua
teamed
up
to
do
some
research
on
tarsiers
.
This
1994
study
recommended
the
captive
breeding
of
tarsiers
because
their
habitat
had
been
damaged
by
logging
.
Unfortunately
,
it
was
found
that
tarsiers
born
in
captivity
grew
very
slowly
.
There
is
no
definite
data
about
the
size
of
the
entire
tarsier
population
in
the
world
.
Perhaps
,
the
number
is
larger
than
current
estimates
.
The
results
of
a
number
of
studies
on
the
animal
shows
that
there
are
three
species
of
tarsiers
:
Tarsius
bancanus
in
Sumatra
and
Kalimantan
,
Tarsius
spectrum
in
Sulawesi
,
particularly
in
the
Lore
Lindu
National
Park
,
and
Tarsius
syrichta
,
which
is
found
only
in
the
Philippines
.
These
species
are
also
divided
into
a
number
of
sub
-
species
.
The
largest
number
of
sub
-
species
--
44
--
is
found
in
Sulawesi
,
particularly
in
Central
Sulawesi
,
said
Hudiyono
.
Many
years
ago
,
he
said
,
tarsiers
could
still
be
found
in
Java
,
particularly
in
West
Java
.
Today
,
however
,
there
are
no
longer
tarsier
sightings
in
Java
,
and
it
is
thought
the
animal
has
disappeared
for
good
from
the
island
.
And
unless
logging
is
controlled
,
tarsiers
will
some
day
just
be
animals
from
the
past
.
Luckily
,
in
Sulawesi
,
tarsiers
are
still
enjoying
their
freedom
in
the
thick
forests
.
But
even
here
,
if
forest
clearing
is
allowed
to
continue
unabated
,
the
tarsier
population
will
continue
to
fall
.
Sulawesi
can
today
still
boast
of
its
diversified
rare
flora
and
fauna
.
Deer
-
hogs
and
anoas
are
good
examples
,
as
they
can
be
found
nowhere
else
in
the
world
.
Tarsiers
are
not
highly
sought
after
as
pets
,
nor
do
farmers
view
them
as
crop
-
destroying
pests
.
This
rare
animal
attracts
the
scientists
,
though
.
Hudiyono
said
the
Lore
Lindu
National
Park
was
the
area
with
the
largest
number
of
tarsiers
.
In
Sumatra
and
Kalimantan
,
there
are
some
tarsiers
,
but
their
numbers
are
not
as
high
as
in
Sulawesi
.
Research
conducted
by
R
.
P
.
Agus
Lelana
,
a
veterinary
surgeon
at
the
Center
for
Primates
Studies
,
concluded
that
tarsiers
were
primates
in
a
transition
from
simple
primates
to
a
more
advanced
species
.
The
tarsier
begins
to
mate
at
the
age
of
six
.
The
question
is
whether
this
small
primate
will
eventually
become
extinct
.
Of
course
,
the
answer
lies
in
our
wisdom
in
conserving
our
forests
.
As
long
as
there
are
forests
,
the
tarsier
will
survive
.
But
once
the
forests
are
gone
,
this
animal
will
have
lost
its
natural
habitat
and
will
have
become
extinct
.
Today
,
the
Central
Sulawesi
'
s
Center
for
Natural
Resources
Conservation
and
the
Lore
Lindu
National
Park
are
developing
a
new
system
to
maintain
the
region
'
s
rare
and
endemic
flora
and
fauna
.
The
head
of
the
Lore
Lindu
National
Park
,
Banjar
Yulianto
Laban
,
called
this
new
system
a
policy
of
"
eco
-
populism
"
.
He
said
that
under
this
system
,
the
involvement
of
local
people
in
environmental
conservation
was
a
must
.
"
Eco
-
populism
is
the
opposite
'
eco
-
fascism
'
,
the
removal
of
indigenous
people
from
the
conservation
concept
,
"
he
said
.
[
Courtesy
of
the
Indonesian
Nature
Conservation
List
]
Top
Story
No
.
7
:
Environment
Minister
Slams
Law
Enforcers
Source
:
LaksamanaNet
,
July
10
,
2002
Environment
Minister
Nabiel
Makarim
says
deforestation
remains
rampant
because
law
enforcers
are
corrupt
and
incompetent
.
Speaking
Tuesday
(
9
/
7
/
02
)
in
Riau
province
at
the
opening
of
seminar
on
efforts
to
prosecute
people
responsible
for
forest
fires
,
the
minister
said
law
enforcers
are
completely
ignorant
of
legislation
that
was
designed
to
protect
the
environment
.
"
When
I
watched
footage
of
a
court
trial
of
a
forest
fire
case
in
Riau
,
it
was
apparent
that
law
enforcers
have
no
knowledge
of
the
environment
,
"
he
was
quoted
as
saying
by
state
news
agency
Antara
.
He
said
the
judge
presiding
over
the
trial
had
"
bargained
"
with
an
expert
witness
on
the
number
of
trees
that
were
burned
by
the
fire
.
Some
officials
regard
enforcement
of
the
environment
law
as
a
hindrance
to
the
flow
of
investment
and
local
revenues
,
he
added
.
Makarim
said
his
ministry
has
been
making
every
possible
effort
to
conserve
the
environment
by
cooperating
with
law
enforcement
agencies
,
such
as
the
National
Police
,
Attorney
General
'
s
Office
,
and
Justice
and
Human
Rights
Ministry
.
He
said
the
ministry
is
preparing
various
plans
of
action
to
improve
conservation
,
such
as
the
provision
of
environmental
awareness
training
courses
for
police
,
state
prosecutors
and
civilian
investigators
.
The
ministry
has
also
proposed
the
creation
of
an
Environment
Court
to
deal
with
relevant
violations
of
the
law
.
Under
the
plan
,
the
Environment
Ministry
will
join
forces
with
the
Supreme
Court
and
Justice
and
Human
Rights
Ministry
to
recruit
12
prosecutors
and
12
judges
who
will
be
assigned
to
different
parts
of
the
country
to
deal
with
environmental
cases
.
Almost
every
year
Indonesia
and
neighboring
countries
suffer
serious
pollution
caused
by
illegal
forest
fires
in
Sumatra
and
Kalimantan
.
Although
many
of
the
fires
have
been
blamed
on
plantation
owners
seeking
to
clear
land
,
none
of
the
perpetrators
have
ended
up
in
jail
.
Environmentalists
warn
that
at
the
present
level
of
deforestation
,
Indonesia
'
s
lowland
jungles
will
be
destroyed
within
5
to
15
years
.
[
Courtesy
of
the
Indonesian
Nature
Conservation
List
]
Top
Story
No
.
8
:
RI
Proposes
3
National
Parks
to
Become
World
Heritage
Sites
Source
:
Antara
,
July
18
,
2002
Denpasar
The
Indonesian
government
has
proposed
to
the
United
Nations
that
three
of
its
national
parks
be
named
world
heritage
,
an
official
of
the
Forestry
Ministry
said
on
Thursday
.
"
The
three
are
the
national
parks
of
Kerinci
Seblat
and
Bukit
Barisan
Selatan
(
in
Sumatra
)
and
Gunung
Leuser
(
in
Aceh
)
,
"
Widodo
S
Ramono
,
director
of
the
National
Park
and
Natural
Resources
Conservation
(
KSDA
)
told
ANTARA
and
Bisnis
Indonesia
here
.
Indonesia
`
s
Ujung
Kulon
National
Park
in
Banten
province
,
Komodo
National
Park
in
East
Nusa
Tenggara
province
,
and
Lorentz
National
Park
in
Papua
province
have
been
named
world
heritage
.
[
Courtesy
of
the
Indonesian
Nature
Conservation
List
]
Top
Story
No
.
9
:
Definition
of
'
Degraded
'
,
'
Sustainable
'
Forest
Needed
Source
:
Jakarta
Post
,
July
20
,
2002
By
Jim
Jarvie
,
Ecologist
Jakarta
The
Secretary
General
of
the
Indonesian
Pulp
and
Paper
Association
recently
had
a
letter
published
in
The
Jakarta
Post
(
July
11
)
attempting
to
correct
a
previous
article
on
the
Indonesian
logging
ban
.
It
used
two
terms
,
"
sustainable
forest
"
and
"
degraded
forest
"
,
which
badly
need
clarification
.
Their
definitions
have
serious
ramifications
for
management
of
remaining
forests
in
Sumatra
and
their
continued
exploitation
by
the
pulp
and
paper
industry
.
On
the
short
term
they
affect
how
mill
production
targets
are
set
and
how
the
natural
resource
assets
exploited
are
valued
in
the
mess
of
billions
of
dollars
in
corporate
debt
among
companies
like
APP
and
APRIL
and
their
creditors
.
In
the
mid
to
long
term
they
affect
the
chances
of
Sumatran
forests
surviving
against
a
backdrop
of
expected
extinction
by
2005
in
the
lowlands
if
destruction
remains
unchecked
.
The
pulp
and
paper
industry
in
Indonesia
frequently
talks
about
its
"
sustainable
forest
"
estates
.
This
definition
refers
to
plantations
or
in
other
words
,
tree
farms
.
Whereas
a
natural
forest
in
Sumatra
can
contain
more
than
450
tree
species
a
hectare
,
and
thousands
more
of
herbs
,
animals
,
insects
and
more
,
pulp
tree
farms
are
intensively
planted
with
less
than
five
species
,
most
often
from
Acacia
or
Eucalyptus
.
What
is
more
,
these
species
are
not
native
to
Sumatra
or
its
ecoregion
,
despite
claims
by
some
in
the
industry
that
some
plantation
species
should
be
seen
as
native
because
they
are
found
in
dry
areas
of
Eastern
Indonesia
.
The
truth
of
the
matter
is
that
the
political
boundary
of
Indonesia
has
little
to
do
with
biological
reality
.
A
natural
forest
is
a
complex
ecosystem
that
has
evolved
over
millennia
.
Communities
in
and
around
these
forests
have
co
-
evolved
in
past
centuries
,
benefiting
directly
from
forest
products
providing
food
and
shelter
,
and
indirectly
from
provision
of
water
and
retention
of
soils
.
In
contrast
,
plantations
are
man
-
made
and
new
,
almost
sterile
environments
supporting
little
wildlife
and
providing
few
services
.
From
a
biodiversity
prospective
,
they
are
virtual
deserts
.
From
community
perspectives
,
where
plantations
do
work
they
can
be
poor
substitutes
for
the
benefits
of
natural
forest
.
Economically
their
pay
off
is
poor
when
compared
to
other
tree
crops
,
including
oil
palm
.
When
plantations
do
not
work
properly
the
impacts
are
bared
land
,
polluted
water
,
fires
and
haze
.
These
effects
are
happening
now
and
affect
not
just
communities
,
but
also
those
at
a
distance
including
in
other
countries
.
So
,
the
term
"
sustainable
forest
"
should
not
be
applied
to
pulp
and
paper
plantations
.
Call
them
plantations
or
farms
.
In
the
Sumatran
context
they
have
nothing
to
do
with
the
diminishing
lush
forests
facing
extinction
in
the
lowlands
.
This
leads
to
the
second
term
,
"
degraded
forest
"
.
Some
in
the
pulp
and
paper
industry
would
have
the
public
believe
degraded
forest
is
cleared
and
planted
with
tree
farms
to
the
benefit
of
all
.
But
what
is
a
degraded
forest
?
A
certified
,
sustainably
managed
production
forest
is
a
natural
forest
that
under
current
management
conditions
will
survive
in
perpetuity
.
It
is
used
to
extract
timber
,
equitably
distribute
benefits
and
not
disturb
natural
processes
unduly
.
So
,
a
logged
area
need
not
be
seen
as
degraded
.
Much
forest
in
Indonesia
has
been
badly
logged
,
yet
numerous
studies
indicate
that
if
left
alone
much
can
recover
.
These
forests
are
,
or
were
,
degraded
,
yet
are
in
the
process
of
returning
to
their
natural
state
.
Yet
more
forest
has
been
affected
by
humankind
to
a
lesser
extent
.
All
such
forests
are
not
pristine
,
yet
whereas
might
be
interpreted
as
degraded
to
some
extent
,
they
are
certainly
not
without
hope
.
It
is
these
sorts
of
forests
that
are
classified
as
degraded
by
elements
of
the
pulp
and
paper
industry
and
being
cleared
right
now
for
their
fiber
,
and
exported
to
domestic
and
international
markets
.
Perfectly
good
natural
forest
is
being
cleared
in
the
name
of
removing
"
degraded
forest
"
,
which
is
in
turn
being
planted
by
sterile
tree
farms
called
"
sustainable
forest
"
.
There
is
no
rationale
for
clearing
these
sorts
of
forests
;
they
are
close
,
or
can
return
to
,
their
original
state
.
Given
how
little
forest
remains
in
Sumatra
given
its
former
glory
,
there
is
no
justifiable
reason
to
clear
it
.
To
do
so
may
even
be
illegal
;
the
government
of
Indonesia
has
committed
to
the
Consultative
Group
on
Indonesia
not
to
clear
natural
forest
.
This
said
,
an
effective
and
ethical
pulp
and
paper
industry
can
and
should
contribute
to
Indonesia
'
s
economy
and
recovery
.
Any
satellite
image
,
flight
or
drive
through
Sumatra
shows
huge
amounts
of
barren
scrubland
that
could
be
converted
to
fiber
bearing
tree
farms
that
would
have
economic
benefit
and
reduce
risks
of
fire
and
other
environmental
catastrophe
.
What
is
needed
is
the
political
will
to
drop
current
capacity
in
the
pulp
and
paper
industry
to
levels
that
can
be
supplied
by
fiber
from
current
tree
farms
,
truly
degraded
forest
and
scrub
that
has
no
hope
of
recovery
.
The
definitions
for
"
degraded
"
here
need
transparent
and
public
discussion
.
Those
running
the
industry
,
their
business
and
finance
partners
must
take
full
responsibility
for
the
lands
they
manage
and
the
damage
they
cause
.
Ethical
business
will
be
rewarded
with
happy
buyers
,
poor
business
with
more
frequent
and
damaging
boycotts
.
[
Courtesy
of
the
Indonesian
Nature
Conservation
List
]
Top
Story
No
.
10
:
Govt
Pay
no
Serious
Heed
to
Environmental
Issues
Source
:
Jakarta
Post
,
July
20
,
2002
By
Tertiani
ZB
Simanjuntak
Jakarta
Megawati
Soekarnoputri
'
s
administration
had
the
worst
record
of
every
previous
administration
in
this
country
with
regard
to
environmental
concerns
,
a
non
-
governmental
organization
said
.
The
Indonesian
Center
for
Environmental
Law
(
ICEL
)
said
the
enforcement
of
environmental
laws
had
worsened
in
comparison
with
previous
administrations
.
"
The
gloomy
picture
on
the
enforcement
of
environmental
laws
in
Indonesia
is
merely
a
proof
of
this
government
'
s
weak
commitment
to
imposing
the
principles
of
Good
Sustainable
Development
Governance
,
"
ICEL
executive
director
Wiwiek
Awiati
said
on
Friday
.
During
a
celebration
of
ICEL
'
s
9th
anniversary
,
which
falls
on
July
19
,
its
researchers
revealed
that
the
absence
of
a
pro
-
environment
policy
had
allowed
alleged
perpetrators
to
walk
free
and
had
stepped
up
repressive
measures
against
anyone
who
struggles
on
behalf
of
the
environment
.
The
government
'
s
lack
of
attention
to
environmental
issues
has
seemingly
emboldened
law
enforcers
to
block
public
demands
for
legal
proceedings
against
those
who
contravene
existing
environmental
laws
.
This
,
has
led
to
recent
clashes
and
protests
in
many
provinces
where
villagers
feel
they
are
being
repressed
while
their
traditional
lands
continue
to
be
destroyed
.
ICEL
deputy
Indro
Sugiarto
said
that
the
prolonged
economic
crisis
had
been
the
main
excuse
for
the
government
to
overlook
environmental
issues
and
,
instead
,
to
stick
to
its
(
short
-
term
)
economic
growth
paradigm
which
welcomed
investors
but
encouraged
uncontrolled
exploitation
of
natural
resources
.
He
cited
an
example
such
as
the
suggestion
from
Coordinating
Minister
for
the
Economy
Dorodjatun
Kuntjoro
-
Jakti
to
allow
protected
forests
to
be
exploited
for
mining
,
as
well
as
the
policy
on
permits
for
genetically
modified
seeds
or
products
to
enter
the
country
,
which
neglected
international
principles
of
prudence
.
This
apparent
neglect
seems
to
contradict
some
ministers
'
official
words
at
the
recently
concluded
4th
Preparatory
Committee
Meeting
on
Sustainable
Development
,
which
was
hosted
by
Indonesia
.
Commenting
on
the
proposal
of
State
Minister
for
Environment
Nabiel
Makarim
on
the
establishment
of
a
"
Formula
12
"
special
team
comprised
of
judges
and
prosecutors
to
handle
environmental
cases
,
Indro
stressed
that
the
issue
was
much
more
complex
than
simply
assembling
a
few
environmentally
conscious
judges
and
prosecutors
.
ICEL
co
-
founder
Mas
Achmad
Santosa
,
who
is
now
its
senior
researcher
,
suggested
several
solutions
to
encourage
legal
enforcement
,
including
to
develop
a
"
one
-
stop
enforcement
system
"
where
the
selected
civilian
investigators
,
police
and
prosecutors
were
put
under
Nabiel
'
s
office
and
the
ministry
'
s
regional
offices
.
"
The
government
should
also
'
green
'
the
bench
by
appointing
qualified
judges
or
letting
non
-
career
judges
handle
environmental
cases
.
Another
alternative
would
be
to
establish
a
special
environmental
court
,
"
he
said
.
In
the
short
-
term
,
Santosa
urged
the
government
to
cooperate
with
the
National
Ombudsman
Commission
to
investigate
bribery
allegations
in
the
courts
,
especially
in
environmental
cases
with
dubious
outcomes
.
[
Courtesy
of
the
Indonesian
Nature
Conservation
List
]
Top
Story
No
.
11
:
NRM
Noon
Seminar
Dear
all
,
We
are
pleased
to
announce
that
we
will
have
another
noon
seminar
on
Thursday
,
July
25
,
2002
,
at
NRM
office
,
Jl
.
Jend
.
Sudirman
9
,
Jakarta
.
Dr
.
Togu
Manurung
of
IPB
and
FWI
will
present
preliminary
results
of
a
study
of
Indonesia
'
s
log
export
ban
from
1985
-
1997
.
This
is
a
timely
and
relevant
updating
of
Dr
.
Togu
'
s
PhD
research
,
which
was
commissioned
by
the
World
Bank
after
Indonesia
re
-
imposed
the
ban
(
for
different
reasons
)
last
October
.
The
final
report
will
be
presented
at
a
workshop
for
Ministry
of
Forestry
,
Industry
Associations
,
NGOs
,
Donors
,
Academicians
,
and
other
GOI
representatives
,
possibly
during
the
third
week
of
August
.
Highlight
of
his
study
can
be
found
below
this
e
-
mail
As
usual
,
the
event
is
informal
and
participants
are
welcome
to
bring
their
own
lunch
and
eat
during
the
presentation
.
Hope
to
see
you
all
there
.
Submitted
by
:
Timothy
H
.
Brown
Natural
Resources
Economics
Policy
Advisor
NRM
/
EPIQ
Program
Jakarta
brownth
@
nrm
.
or
.
id
Top
Story
No
.
12
:
New
Position
-
Director
,
CIDA
PSU
,
Jakarta
The
Canadian
International
Development
Agency
(
CIDA
)
is
the
international
development
co
-
operation
arm
of
the
Government
of
Canada
.
Canada
has
been
an
active
partner
in
Indonesia
’
s
development
since
1954
and
Indonesia
has
been
one
of
Canada
’
s
largest
development
co
-
operation
partners
since
the
1970s
.
CIDA
is
based
in
the
Development
Section
of
the
Canadian
Embassy
in
Jakarta
.
CIDA
is
provided
with
logistical
,
administrative
and
analytical
support
by
a
Program
Support
Unit
(
PSU
)
which
is
located
within
the
same
building
as
the
Embassy
.
Details
on
the
position
and
minimum
requirements
follow
:
PSU
Director
As
the
PSU
is
going
through
a
significant
transformation
in
terms
of
its
size
,
legal
structure
,
financial
and
information
management
systems
and
overall
function
,
CIDA
is
looking
for
an
enthusiastic
,
self
-
motivated
individual
with
a
solid
management
background
to
guide
the
PSU
through
this
transition
process
.
The
PSU
will
shortly
have
nine
personnel
in
the
office
,
five
in
administrative
services
and
four
providing
sector
specific
technical
support
.
This
staff
complieent
may
be
supplemented
by
additional
part
time
technical
specialists
over
the
next
year
.
Main
responsibilities
:
ensure
that
the
PSU
is
meeting
the
needs
and
expectations
of
the
Development
Section
design
and
implement
a
transition
process
for
the
PSU
provide
quality
control
of
the
outputs
of
the
various
consultants
within
the
PSU
provide
support
to
CIDA
-
funded
projects
in
Indonesia
on
an
as
-
required
basis
Education
/
Experience
:
A
S2
degree
with
a
minimum
of
3
years
of
management
experience
.
Candidates
with
an
S1
degree
and
at
least
5
years
of
management
experience
will
be
considered
Fluency
in
written
and
spoken
English
Significant
experience
managing
an
office
of
at
least
10
persons
Strong
inter
-
personal
skills
Proven
capability
to
build
and
work
within
a
team
Experience
working
on
international
development
projects
or
programs
Experience
reviewing
,
analysing
and
commenting
on
reports
drafted
in
English
Willingness
to
travel
to
some
regions
in
Indonesia
and
to
East
Timor
Sensitivity
to
gender
issues
Experience
in
computer
word
processing
and
email
Experience
in
developing
networks
with
key
local
professionals
CIDA
is
an
equal
opportunities
employer
.
Applications
are
welcomed
from
all
parts
of
the
community
and
women
in
particular
are
encouraged
to
apply
.
Selection
is
based
on
merit
but
preference
will
be
given
to
qualified
Indonesian
and
Canadian
candidates
.
Only
short
-
listed
candidates
will
be
contacted
for
an
interview
.
The
selection
process
will
consist
of
a
comparison
of
CVs
and
a
personal
interview
which
will
take
place
in
August
.
A
written
test
might
be
administered
.
The
contract
will
be
for
a
eighteen
month
period
and
the
fee
scale
will
be
determined
by
a
market
survey
and
will
be
adjusted
based
on
the
qualifications
and
experience
of
the
successful
candidate
.
If
you
are
interested
in
this
opportunity
,
please
submit
an
application
letter
and
CV
of
no
more
than
3
pages
by
02
August
2002
,
to
:
The
Embassy
of
Canada
Development
Section
World
Trade
Center
,
6th
.
Floor
Jl
.
Jend
.
Sudirman
Kav
.
29
-
31
Jakarta
12920
If
you
have
recently
applied
for
another
position
in
the
Canadian
Embassy
or
in
the
CIDA
PSU
,
and
wish
to
be
considered
for
this
new
position
of
Director
PSU
,
you
must
apply
again
.
If
you
have
any
questions
please
contact
Ms
Felicia
Effendi
at
the
CIDA
PSU
in
Jakarta
:
felicia
@
psujkrta
.
or
.
id
Top
Story
No
.
13
:
Vacancies
at
CIFOR
1
.
Project
Co
-
ordinator
(
National
position
)
Location
:
Bulungan
Research
Forest
(
BRF
)
,
East
Kalimantan
,
Indonesia
.
Extensive
travel
between
BRF
and
CIFOR
HQ
is
required
Period
:
Three
years
,
beginning
as
soon
as
possible
Responsibilities
In
overall
charge
of
the
Bulungan
Research
Forest
activities
and
will
co
-
ordinate
the
inputs
from
ITTO
,
Ministry
of
Forestry
,
INHUTANI
II
,
Universities
,
and
NGOs
,
the
Forest
Research
Development
Agency
(
FORDA
)
and
CIFOR
.
Supervise
the
reduced
impact
logging
program
for
the
Bulungan
Research
Forest
.
This
will
involve
working
closely
with
INHUTANI
field
operation
staff
and
scientists
from
the
partner
organisations
in
developing
a
detailed
research
and
management
program
for
the
forest
site
.
He
or
she
will
be
responsible
for
the
day
-
to
-
day
management
and
integration
of
research
and
operational
activities
.
Co
-
ordinate
the
baseline
surveys
,
particularly
of
forest
resources
and
biodiversity
in
the
Bulungan
Research
Forest
.
This
will
include
mobilisation
,
supervision
and
co
-
ordination
of
all
the
technical
experts
working
on
this
aspect
of
the
project
.
Co
-
ordinate
and
participate
in
Steering
Committee
Meetings
and
present
budget
and
other
Project
information
.
Organise
annual
workshops
to
bring
together
technical
people
involved
with
the
project
together
with
senior
staff
of
ITTO
,
FORDA
,
CIFOR
and
the
Ministry
of
Forestry
.
These
workshops
will
also
have
a
training
function
for
younger
scientists
and
operational
managers
.
Manage
the
funds
applied
to
the
project
and
for
the
preparation
of
technical
and
operational
reports
to
all
the
participating
agencies
.
This
will
include
writing
technical
reports
synthesising
the
progress
on
,
and
results
of
the
,
research
program
.
Inform
ITTO
members
of
progress
and
results
of
the
project
through
participation
in
technical
workshops
organised
by
ITTO
.
Requirements
Have
at
least
a
MSc
.
Degree
(
Ph
.
D
.
preferred
)
and
have
a
solid
background
in
forest
ecology
,
forest
management
,
silviculture
or
land
use
planning
with
at
least
10
years
experience
in
forest
-
related
research
.
Proven
expertise
in
research
management
.
Experienced
with
multi
-
disciplinary
and
multi
-
cultural
research
team
.
Commitment
to
work
with
various
partners
and
students
to
build
research
capacity
.
Have
excellent
interpersonal
and
communication
skills
.
Commitment
to
fieldwork
.
Have
excellent
spoken
and
written
English
and
Bahasa
Indonesia
.
2
.
Forest
/
Field
Manager
(
National
position
)
Report
to
:
Project
Co
-
ordinator
Location
:
Bulungan
Research
Forest
(
BRF
)
,
East
Kalimantan
,
Indonesia
.
Period
:
Two
years
,
beginning
as
soon
as
possible
Responsibilities
:
Assist
team
of
researchers
with
the
training
and
supervision
of
field
crews
,
collection
of
field
data
and
their
analysis
,
and
preparation
of
scientific
and
donor
reports
related
to
sustainable
forest
management
efforts
in
the
hill
-
dipterocarp
forests
in
East
Kalimantan
.
Specifically
,
the
successful
candidate
will
:
Assist
in
the
supervision
and
coordination
of
field
research
related
to
the
impact
of
logging
techniques
on
forest
composition
and
structure
(
establish
permanent
sample
plots
and
transects
,
assess
environmental
impacts
associated
with
logging
and
the
response
of
plant
and
animal
communities
,
etc
.
)
.
Assist
research
related
to
the
impact
of
logging
on
the
availability
and
use
of
non
-
timber
forest
products
by
local
peoples
.
Supervise
reduced
impact
logging
practices
and
sustainable
forest
management
according
to
guidelines
produced
by
CIFOR
and
other
research
collaborators
.
Participate
and
facilitate
the
organization
of
technical
training
for
field
staff
.
Establish
a
database
framework
for
the
project
,
including
remote
sensing
and
other
spatially
referenced
information
.
Facilitate
the
field
management
of
the
research
and
the
development
of
management
and
land
use
plans
under
the
direct
supervision
of
the
Project
Coordinator
.
Requirements
Have
a
MSc
.
Degree
with
training
and
experience
(
preferred
)
in
the
following
areas
:
silviculture
,
timber
harvesting
,
forest
ecology
,
wildlife
ecology
,
integrated
land
use
planning
,
inventory
techniques
,
and
statistics
.
Proven
managerial
skills
,
including
report
preparation
,
project
accounting
and
management
,
and
training
of
personnel
,
are
required
.
Have
excellent
interpersonal
and
communication
skills
.
Experienced
with
multi
-
disciplinary
and
multi
-
cultural
research
team
.
Commitment
to
fieldwork
.
Have
excellent
spoken
and
written
English
and
Bahasa
Indonesia
.
Computer
literacy
is
required
and
a
familiarity
with
the
software
packages
used
at
CIFOR
is
an
advantage
.
Application
Process
Applications
for
each
position
will
be
accepted
until
August
16
,
2002
.
Interviews
will
be
held
in
Bogor
,
Indonesia
.
All
correspondence
will
be
held
in
confidence
.
A
letter
of
interest
and
a
curriculum
vita
including
publication
record
should
be
sent
to
:
Human
Resources
Manager
,
CIFOR
P
.
O
.
Box
6596
JKPWB
Jakarta
10065
,
Indonesia
Fax
:
+
62
251
628
626
cifor
-
hr
@
cgiar
.
org
(
Please
indicate
the
position
in
the
subject
line
)
CIFOR
is
an
equal
opportunity
employer
and
believes
that
a
diversity
of
staff
contributes
to
excellence
The
above
announcement
is
posted
on
CIFOR
web
site
at
http
:
//
www
.
cifor
.
cgiar
.
org
Top
The
views
expressed
by
the
authors
and
organizations
contributing
to
this
electronic
newsletter
do
not
necessarily
reflect
the
views
of
the
NRM
Program
,
its
partner
organizations
,
USAID
,
or
its
government
of
Indonesia
sponsors
.
The
purpose
of
the
NRM
Headline
News
is
to
provide
a
forum
for
a
wide
diversity
of
opinion
and
information
on
NRM
Program
activities
,
selected
upcoming
events
and
news
.
The
NRM
Program
is
a
collaborative
program
between
the
governments
of
Indonesia
and
the
United
States
of
America
.
The
six
partners
implementing
the
NRM
Program
include
:
the
Environmental
Policy
and
Institutional
Strengthening
Indefinite
Quantity
Contract
(
EPIQ
)
,
the
Yayasan
KEMALA
,
the
Coastal
Resources
Management
Program
(
CRMP
-
Proyek
Pesisir
)
,
Conservation
International
,
The
Nature
Conservancy
and
the
World
Wide
Fund
for
Nature
-
Indonesia
.
From
:
sunweb
@
cbn
.
net
.
id
(
sunweb
)
Subject
:
Collections
of
Lawyer
Jokes
A
Collection
of
Lawyer
Jokes
1
.
An
engineer
,
a
physicist
,
and
a
lawyer
were
being
interviewed
for
a
position
as
chief
executive
officer
of
a
large
corporation
.
The
engineer
was
interviewed
first
,
and
was
asked
a
long
list
of
questions
,
ending
with
"
How
much
is
two
plus
two
?
"
The
engineer
excused
himself
,
and
made
a
series
of
measurements
and
calculations
before
returning
to
the
board
room
and
announcing
,
"
Four
.
"
The
physicist
was
next
interviewed
,
and
was
asked
the
same
questions
.
Before
answering
the
last
question
,
he
excused
himself
,
made
for
the
library
,
and
did
a
great
deal
of
research
.
After
a
consultation
with
the
United
States
Bureau
of
Standards
and
many
calculations
,
he
also
announced
"
Four
.
"
The
lawyer
was
interviewed
last
,
and
was
asked
the
same
questions
.
At
the
end
of
his
interview
,
before
answering
the
last
question
,
he
drew
all
the
shades
in
the
room
,
looked
outside
the
door
to
see
if
anyone
was
there
,
checked
the
telephone
for
listening
devices
,
and
asked
"
How
much
do
you
want
it
to
be
?
"
2
.
Following
a
distinguished
legal
career
,
a
man
arrived
at
the
Gates
of
Heaven
,
accompanied
by
the
Pope
,
who
had
the
misfortune
to
expire
on
the
same
day
.
The
Pope
was
greeted
first
by
St
.
Peter
,
who
escorted
him
to
his
quarters
.
The
room
was
somewhat
shabby
and
small
,
similar
to
that
found
in
a
low
grade
Motel
6
type
establishment
.
The
lawyer
was
then
taken
to
his
room
,
which
was
a
palatial
suite
including
a
private
swimming
pool
,
a
garden
,
and
a
terrace
overlooking
the
Gates
.
The
attorney
was
somewhat
taken
aback
,
and
told
St
.
Peter
,
"
I
'
m
really
quite
surprised
at
these
rooms
,
seeing
as
how
the
Pope
was
given
such
small
accommodations
.
"
St
.
Peter
replied
,
"
We
have
over
a
hundred
Popes
here
,
and
we
'
re
really
very
bored
with
them
.
We
'
ve
never
had
a
lawyer
.
"
3
.
Question
:
Do
you
know
how
to
save
five
drowning
lawyers
?
Answer
:
No
.
Reply
:
Good
!
4
.
Why
don
'
t
snakes
bite
attorneys
?
Professional
courtesy
.
5
.
How
can
you
tell
that
an
attorney
is
about
to
lie
?
His
lips
begin
to
move
.
6
.
How
can
you
tell
the
difference
between
an
attorney
lying
dead
in
the
road
and
a
coyote
lying
dead
in
the
road
?
With
the
coyote
,
you
usually
see
skid
marks
.
7
.
How
many
lawyers
does
it
take
to
screw
in
a
light
bulb
?
How
many
can
you
afford
?
8
.
An
attorney
passed
on
and
found
himself
in
heaven
,
but
not
at
all
happy
with
his
accommodations
.
He
complained
to
St
.
Peter
,
who
told
him
that
his
only
recourse
was
to
appeal
his
assignment
.
The
attorney
immediately
advised
that
he
intended
to
appeal
,
but
was
then
told
that
he
would
be
waiting
at
least
three
years
before
his
appeal
could
be
heard
.
The
attorney
protested
that
a
three
year
wait
was
unconscionable
,
but
his
words
fell
on
deaf
ears
.
The
lawyer
was
then
approached
by
the
devil
,
who
told
him
that
he
would
be
able
to
arrange
an
appeal
to
be
heard
in
a
few
days
,
if
the
attorney
was
willing
to
change
venue
to
Hell
.
When
the
attorney
asked
why
appeals
could
be
heard
so
much
sooner
in
Hell
,
he
was
told
,
"
We
have
all
of
the
judges
.
"
9
.
As
Mr
.
Smith
was
on
his
death
bed
,
he
attempted
to
formulate
a
plan
that
would
allow
him
to
take
at
least
some
of
his
considerable
wealth
with
him
.
He
called
for
the
three
men
he
trusted
most
his
lawyer
,
his
doctor
,
and
his
clergyman
.
He
told
them
,
"
I
'
m
going
to
give
you
each
$
30
,
000
in
cash
before
I
die
.
At
my
funeral
,
I
want
you
to
place
the
money
in
my
coffin
so
that
I
can
try
to
take
it
with
me
.
"
All
three
agreed
to
do
this
and
were
given
the
money
.
At
the
funeral
,
each
approached
the
coffin
in
turn
and
placed
an
envelope
inside
.
While
riding
in
the
limousine
to
the
cemetery
,
the
clergyman
said
"
I
have
to
confess
something
to
you
fellows
.
Brother
Smith
was
a
good
churchman
all
his
life
,
and
I
know
he
would
have
wanted
me
to
do
this
.
The
church
needed
a
new
baptistery
very
badly
,
and
I
took
$
10
,
000
of
the
money
he
gave
me
and
bought
one
.
I
only
put
$
20
,
000
in
the
coffin
.
"
The
physician
then
said
,
"
Well
,
since
we
'
re
confiding
in
one
another
,
I
might
as
well
tell
you
that
I
didn
'
t
put
the
full
$
30
,
000
in
the
coffin
either
.
Smith
had
a
disease
that
could
have
been
diagnosed
sooner
if
I
had
this
very
new
machine
,
but
the
machine
cost
$
20
,
000
and
I
couldn
'
t
afford
it
then
.
I
used
$
20
,
000
of
the
money
to
buy
the
machine
so
that
I
might
be
able
to
save
another
patient
.
I
know
that
Smith
would
have
wanted
me
to
do
that
.
"
The
lawyer
then
said
,
"
I
'
m
ashamed
of
both
of
you
.
When
I
put
my
envelope
into
that
coffin
,
it
held
my
personal
check
for
the
full
$
30
,
000
.
"
10
.
The
National
Institutes
of
Health
have
announced
that
they
will
no
longer
be
using
rats
for
medical
experimentation
.
In
their
place
,
they
will
use
attorneys
.
They
have
given
three
reasons
for
this
decision
:
1
.
There
are
now
more
attorneys
than
there
are
rats
.
2
.
The
medical
researchers
don
'
t
become
as
emotionally
attached
to
the
attorneys
as
they
did
to
the
rats
.
3
.
No
matter
how
hard
you
try
,
there
are
some
things
that
rats
won
'
t
do
.
11
.
A
man
woke
up
in
a
hospital
bed
and
called
for
his
doctor
.
He
asked
"
Give
it
to
me
straight
.
How
long
have
I
got
?
"
The
physician
replied
that
he
doubted
that
his
patient
would
survive
the
night
.
The
man
then
said
"
Call
for
my
lawyer
.
"
When
the
lawyer
arrived
,
the
man
asked
for
his
physician
to
stand
on
one
side
of
the
bed
,
while
the
lawyer
stood
on
the
other
.
The
man
then
laid
back
and
closed
his
eyes
.
When
he
remained
silent
for
several
minutes
,
the
physician
asked
what
he
had
in
mind
.
The
man
replied
"
Jesus
died
with
a
thief
on
either
side
,
and
I
thought
I
'
d
check
out
the
same
way
.
"
12
.
What
do
you
get
if
you
send
the
Godfather
to
law
school
?
An
offer
you
can
'
t
understand
.
13
.
A
doctor
,
an
architect
,
and
an
attorney
were
dining
at
the
country
club
one
day
,
and
the
conversation
turned
to
the
subject
of
their
respective
dogs
,
which
were
apparently
quite
extraordinary
.
A
wager
was
placed
on
who
had
the
most
intelligent
dog
.
The
physician
offered
to
show
his
dog
first
,
and
called
to
the
parking
lot
,
"
Hippocrates
,
come
!
"
Hippocrates
ran
in
,
and
was
told
by
the
doctor
to
do
his
stuff
.
Hippocrates
ran
to
the
golf
course
and
dug
for
a
while
,
producing
a
number
of
bones
.
He
dragged
the
bones
into
the
country
club
,
and
assembled
them
into
a
complete
,
fully
articulated
human
skeleton
.
The
physician
patted
Hippocrates
on
the
head
,
and
gave
him
a
cookie
for
his
efforts
.
The
architect
was
only
marginally
impressed
,
and
called
for
his
dog
,
"
Sliderule
,
come
!
"
Sliderule
ran
in
,
and
was
told
to
do
his
stuff
.
The
dog
immediately
chewed
the
skeleton
to
rubble
,
but
reassembled
the
fragments
into
a
scale
model
of
the
Taj
Mahal
.
The
architect
patted
his
dog
and
gave
him
a
cookie
.
The
attorney
watched
the
other
two
dogs
,
and
called
"
Bullshit
,
come
!
"
Bullshit
entered
and
was
told
to
do
his
stuff
.
Bullshit
immediately
sodomized
the
other
two
dogs
,
stole
their
cookies
,
auctioned
the
Taj
Mahal
replica
to
the
other
club
members
for
his
fee
,
and
went
outside
to
play
golf
.
14
.
Good
News
:
A
busload
of
lawyers
ran
off
a
cliff
.
The
bus
was
destroyed
and
there
were
no
survivors
.
Bad
News
:
There
were
three
empty
seats
.
15
.
What
do
you
have
when
you
bury
six
lawyers
up
to
their
necks
in
sand
?
Not
enough
sand
.
16
.
What
'
s
black
and
brown
and
looks
good
on
a
lawyer
?
A
doberman
pinscher
.
17
.
When
a
person
assists
a
criminal
in
breaking
the
law
before
the
criminal
gets
arrested
,
we
call
him
an
accomplice
.
When
a
person
assists
a
criminal
in
breaking
the
law
after
the
criminal
gets
arrested
,
we
call
him
a
defense
lawyer
.
18
.
A
prominent
young
attorney
was
on
his
way
to
court
to
begin
arguments
on
a
complex
lawsuit
when
he
suddenly
found
himself
at
the
Gates
of
Heaven
.
St
.
Peter
started
to
escort
him
inside
,
when
he
began
to
protest
that
his
untimely
death
had
to
be
some
sort
of
mistake
.
"
I
'
m
much
too
young
to
die
!
I
'
m
only
35
!
"
St
.
Peter
agreed
that
35
did
seem
to
be
a
bit
young
to
be
entering
the
pearly
gates
,
and
agreed
to
check
on
his
case
.
When
St
.
Peter
returned
,
he
told
the
attorney
,
"
I
'
m
afraid
that
the
mistake
must
be
yours
,
my
son
.
We
verified
your
age
on
the
basis
of
the
number
of
hours
you
'
ve
billed
to
your
clients
,
and
you
'
re
at
least
108
.
"
19
.
A
snake
and
a
rabbit
were
racing
along
a
pair
of
intersecting
forest
pathways
one
day
,
when
they
collided
at
the
point
where
the
pathways
meet
.
They
immediately
began
to
argue
with
one
another
as
to
who
was
at
fault
for
the
mishap
.
When
the
snake
remarked
that
he
had
been
blind
since
birth
,
and
thus
should
be
given
additional
leeway
,
the
rabbit
said
that
he
,
too
,
had
been
blind
since
birth
.
The
two
animals
then
forgot
about
the
collision
and
began
commiserating
concerning
the
problems
of
being
blind
.
The
snake
said
that
his
greatest
regret
was
the
loss
of
his
identity
.
He
had
never
been
able
to
see
his
reflection
in
water
,
and
for
that
reason
did
not
know
exactly
what
he
looked
like
,
or
even
what
he
was
.
The
rabbit
declared
that
he
had
the
same
problem
.
Seeing
a
way
that
they
could
help
each
other
,
the
rabbit
proposed
that
one
feel
the
other
from
head
to
toe
,
and
then
try
to
describe
what
the
other
animal
was
.
The
snake
agreed
,
and
started
by
winding
himself
around
the
rabbit
.
After
a
few
moments
,
he
announced
,
"
You
'
ve
got
very
soft
,
fuzzy
fur
,
long
ears
,
big
rear
feet
,
and
a
little
fuzzy
ball
for
a
tail
.
I
think
that
you
must
be
a
bunny
rabbit
!
"
The
rabbit
was
much
relieved
to
find
his
identity
,
and
proceeded
to
return
the
favor
to
the
snake
.
After
feeling
about
the
snake
'
s
body
for
a
few
minutes
,
he
asserted
,
"
Well
,
you
'
re
scaly
,
you
'
re
slimy
,
you
'
ve
got
beady
little
eyes
,
you
squirm
and
slither
all
the
time
,
and
you
'
ve
got
a
forked
tongue
.
I
think
you
'
re
a
lawyer
!
"
20
.
A
man
walked
into
a
curio
shop
and
began
to
browse
.
He
was
attracted
to
a
brass
rat
on
a
shelf
behind
the
counter
.
He
asked
the
shopkeeper
for
a
price
,
and
was
told
to
make
an
offer
.
Presently
they
agreed
on
a
price
,
and
the
brass
rat
changed
hands
.
The
shopkeeper
warned
the
customer
as
he
took
the
money
,
"
This
sale
is
final
.
If
you
leave
the
shop
with
the
brass
rat
,
I
won
'
t
take
it
back
under
any
circumstances
.
"
The
customer
agreed
and
left
with
the
rat
.
As
he
walked
home
,
he
noticed
that
a
live
rat
came
scurrying
out
of
an
alley
and
began
to
follow
him
.
Soon
there
were
more
,
all
following
him
and
milling
bout
his
feet
.
The
man
began
to
run
,
but
the
rats
kept
up
,
and
more
joined
the
procession
.
After
a
few
minutes
,
thousands
of
rats
were
chasing
after
the
man
.
The
man
ran
frantically
for
the
river
,
and
threw
the
brass
rat
into
the
water
.
The
live
rats
followed
the
brass
rat
,
and
soon
all
had
drowned
.
The
man
returned
to
the
curio
shop
,
and
on
seeing
him
enter
,
the
shopkeeper
shouted
,
"
I
told
you
,
the
sale
was
final
!
You
cannot
return
the
brass
rat
!
"
The
customer
replied
,
"
That
'
s
no
problem
.
I
just
wondered
if
you
had
a
brass
lawyer
in
stock
.
"
21
.
A
police
chief
,
a
fire
chief
,
and
a
city
manager
were
traveling
together
by
car
to
a
municipal
management
conference
in
a
distant
city
.
Their
car
broke
down
in
a
rural
area
,
and
they
were
forced
to
seek
shelter
for
the
night
at
a
nearby
farmhouse
.
The
farmer
welcomed
them
in
,
but
cautioned
them
that
there
were
only
two
spare
beds
,
and
that
one
of
them
would
have
to
sleep
in
the
barn
with
the
farm
animals
.
After
a
short
conference
,
the
police
chief
agreed
to
take
the
barn
.
Shortly
after
retiring
,
a
knock
was
heard
on
the
door
of
the
farmhouse
.
The
party
inside
answered
to
find
the
police
chief
standing
there
,
complaining
that
he
could
not
sleep
.
There
were
pigs
in
the
barn
,
he
said
,
and
he
was
reminded
of
the
days
when
everyone
called
him
a
pig
.
The
fire
chief
then
volunteered
to
exchange
with
the
police
chief
.
A
short
time
later
,
another
knock
was
heard
at
the
door
.
The
fire
chief
complained
that
the
cows
in
the
barn
reminded
him
of
Mrs
.
O
'
Leary
'
s
cow
that
started
the
Chicago
fire
,
and
that
every
time
he
started
to
go
to
sleep
,
he
started
to
have
a
fireman
'
s
worst
nightmare
,
that
of
burning
to
death
.
The
city
attorney
,
in
desperation
for
sleep
,
then
agreed
to
sleep
in
the
barn
.
This
seemed
like
a
good
idea
until
a
few
minutes
later
,
when
another
knock
was
heard
at
the
door
.
When
the
occupants
answered
the
door
,
there
stood
the
very
indignant
cows
and
pigs
.
22
.
A
mother
and
son
were
walking
through
a
cemetery
,
and
passed
by
a
headstone
inscribed
"
Here
lies
a
good
lawyer
and
an
honest
man
.
"
The
little
boy
read
the
headstone
,
looked
up
at
his
mother
,
and
asked
"
Mommy
,
why
did
they
bury
two
men
there
?
"
23
.
An
attorney
was
sitting
in
his
office
late
one
night
,
when
Satan
appeared
before
him
.
The
Devil
told
the
lawyer
,
"
I
have
a
proposition
for
you
.
You
can
win
every
case
you
try
,
for
the
rest
of
your
life
.
Your
clients
will
adore
you
,
your
colleagues
will
stand
in
awe
of
you
,
and
you
will
make
embarrassing
sums
of
money
.
All
I
want
in
exchange
is
your
soul
,
your
wife
'
s
soul
,
your
children
'
s
souls
,
the
souls
of
your
parents
,
grandparents
,
and
parents
in
law
,
and
the
souls
of
all
your
friends
and
law
partners
.
"
The
lawyer
thought
about
this
for
a
moment
,
then
asked
,
"
So
,
what
'
s
the
catch
?
"
For
many
newcomers
to
Jakarta
,
the
thought
of
hiring
household
staff
seems
quite
foreign
-
a
luxury
reserved
for
the
fortunate
few
.
In
Jakarta
,
however
,
having
household
staff
is
a
part
of
everyday
life
for
Indonesians
and
foreigners
alike
.
Your
staff
will
not
only
be
an
enormous
help
to
you
around
your
home
,
but
will
also
serve
as
your
first
window
into
Indonesian
culture
,
a
sort
of
liaison
between
two
worlds
.
At
the
same
time
,
you
will
be
providing
much
needed
jobs
and
financial
support
to
your
staff
.
The
first
thing
to
consider
when
hiring
staff
would
be
your
own
personal
household
needs
.
Do
you
have
a
large
house
?
A
small
apartment
?
Do
you
have
children
?
A
large
garden
or
pool
?
Listed
below
are
the
different
types
of
domestic
helpers
,
or
pembantu
,
who
will
be
available
for
hire
:
Cook
Maid
Houseboy
Babysitter
Laundress
Gardener
Driver
Guard
Juru
masak
or
koki
Pembantu
wanita
Pembantu
laki
Pengasuh
anak
Tukang
cuci
Tukang
kebon
Sopir
or
supir
Penjaga
or
jaga
For
a
single
person
or
a
couple
in
a
small
apartment
a
part
-
time
live
-
out
maid
,
plus
a
driver
,
will
probably
be
adequate
,
but
for
a
family
in
a
large
house
with
a
garden
a
team
of
4
to
5
people
is
recommended
to
keep
the
household
running
smoothly
.
The
division
of
duties
is
very
flexible
and
some
of
the
jobs
mentioned
above
can
be
combined
,
such
as
maid
/
laundress
or
houseboy
/
gardener
.
In
order
to
maintain
harmonious
relationships
amongst
the
staff
it
can
be
a
good
idea
to
choose
people
from
the
same
ethnic
group
,
or
to
allow
the
most
senior
staff
member
,
usually
the
cook
,
to
give
recommendations
or
advice
on
selecting
the
others
.
When
you
have
decided
on
what
sort
of
helpers
you
need
,
the
next
question
is
where
to
find
them
.
In
Jakarta
there
are
various
ways
to
locate
and
set
up
interviews
with
potential
staff
for
your
home
.
Perhaps
the
very
best
way
is
through
word
-
of
-
mouth
from
friends
and
colleagues
as
you
will
have
personal
references
to
go
by
.
Another
excellent
source
is
community
bulletin
boards
,
where
expatriates
who
are
leaving
the
country
often
post
notices
in
order
to
place
their
staff
.
Often
you
will
have
the
chance
to
speak
with
the
former
employer
.
These
bulletin
boards
are
found
in
many
supermarkets
,
clubs
and
organizations
frequented
by
the
expatriate
community
.
However
,
to
ensure
authenticity
of
information
,
it
is
recommended
to
choose
staff
from
boards
that
are
not
accessible
to
the
general
public
and
are
located
inside
the
buildings
of
the
clubs
and
organizations
.
If
you
need
additional
assistance
,
the
Jakarta
International
Community
Center
holds
a
servants
'
registry
two
mornings
a
week
staffed
by
volunteers
who
will
help
expatriates
to
interview
prospective
staff
members
if
necessary
.
Another
way
to
source
staff
is
from
other
helpers
'
friends
and
family
.
It
is
possible
that
someone
who
is
working
for
a
friend
may
know
of
someone
who
is
looking
for
work
.
Indonesians
normally
would
not
recommend
just
anyone
,
as
it
is
seen
as
a
loss
of
face
if
that
person
does
not
work
out
.
What
to
ask
when
interviewing
a
potential
servant
will
depend
a
great
deal
on
your
own
household
needs
and
the
duties
involved
,
but
perhaps
the
most
important
thing
to
go
by
is
your
own
instinct
or
personal
feelings
about
the
person
you
are
interviewing
.
Remember
that
this
person
will
play
a
large
role
in
your
personal
life
in
Jakarta
,
and
will
be
spending
a
lot
of
time
with
both
you
and
your
family
.
Don
'
t
hire
anyone
that
you
do
not
feel
comfortable
with
or
trusting
of
no
matter
how
glowing
his
or
her
references
might
be
.
A
person
'
s
nature
is
often
more
important
than
his
or
her
skill
when
you
will
be
living
in
the
same
household
.
With
luck
,
you
may
find
someone
with
whom
you
and
your
family
will
establish
a
long
and
warm
relationship
for
years
to
come
.
Listed
below
are
a
few
recommended
questions
you
may
wish
to
ask
when
interviewing
:
Identification
and
Personal
Details
.
Find
out
as
much
as
possible
about
family
,
children
,
what
village
they
are
from
,
how
long
they
have
been
in
Jakarta
,
etc
.
Ask
to
see
their
original
KTP
(
identity
card
)
and
driver
'
s
license
and
should
you
decide
to
employ
them
always
make
a
copy
of
your
employee
'
s
KTP
,
or
identity
card
,
on
the
first
day
of
employment
and
keep
this
in
a
secure
place
.
Experience
.
Usually
,
you
will
be
handed
a
few
letters
of
reference
to
read
,
written
by
former
employers
.
If
possible
contact
the
referee
to
ensure
that
they
are
authentic
.
These
will
normally
give
a
description
of
the
length
of
employment
,
the
duties
that
were
performed
,
any
particular
skills
,
as
well
as
personal
attributes
.
Sometimes
these
will
be
glowing
,
other
times
more
to
the
point
.
Ask
questions
that
outline
experience
specifically
;
for
example
,
if
you
are
interviewing
a
cook
who
tells
you
that
he
or
she
is
familiar
with
preparing
Western
food
,
ask
him
or
her
to
explain
some
examples
of
the
kinds
of
dishes
prepared
.
This
will
give
you
a
better
idea
of
his
or
her
ability
.
Ability
to
Read
.
This
may
or
may
not
be
of
great
importance
to
you
,
depending
on
the
position
.
In
the
case
of
a
cook
,
the
ability
to
read
a
recipe
or
a
shopping
list
would
be
important
.
The
ability
to
read
would
also
be
crucial
for
a
babysitter
or
nanny
,
particularly
if
an
emergency
should
occur
.
Living
Arrangements
.
Find
out
if
he
or
she
is
looking
for
a
live
-
in
position
and
would
be
occupying
a
room
in
the
household
quarters
,
or
living
outside
the
home
and
commuting
.
This
may
have
an
effect
on
the
hours
worked
,
and
on
flexibility
with
regard
to
hours
worked
,
so
discuss
this
carefully
.
Expectations
.
Identify
and
explain
in
detail
the
duties
and
responsibilities
of
the
position
.
Ground
Rules
.
Explain
again
,
in
detail
,
what
their
normal
hours
would
be
,
whether
or
not
you
would
need
some
flexibility
with
these
hours
,
whether
or
not
visitors
would
be
allowed
,
phone
usage
,
etc
.
,
and
make
sure
that
this
is
mutually
acceptable
.
Most
staff
employees
expect
one
day
off
a
week
and
work
12
-
hour
days
,
which
of
course
includes
a
lunch
hour
(
s
)
and
periodic
breaks
for
prayers
or
rest
.
Children
.
If
you
are
interviewing
a
babysitter
or
nanny
for
your
child
,
clearly
outline
your
expectations
,
rules
and
philosophy
concerning
the
care
of
your
children
.
If
you
are
simply
hiring
someone
to
work
in
the
household
,
find
out
how
they
feel
about
working
in
a
house
full
of
kids
(
most
Indonesians
adore
children
and
truly
love
having
them
around
)
.
Ask
the
potential
employee
if
they
have
children
themselves
,
how
old
they
are
,
and
if
they
would
be
living
in
or
visiting
your
home
(
you
must
decide
ahead
of
time
if
this
is
acceptable
to
you
and
if
you
have
enough
room
)
.
Pets
.
If
you
own
a
dog
it
is
of
great
importance
that
you
mention
this
at
the
time
of
the
interview
.
Many
Indonesians
,
being
Muslims
,
do
not
wish
to
care
for
or
even
live
in
the
same
environment
as
a
dog
.
This
is
rarely
a
problem
with
household
help
who
have
worked
for
expatriates
before
,
and
you
will
certainly
be
able
to
find
someone
who
doesn
'
t
mind
dogs
.
Indonesians
,
for
the
most
part
,
feel
comfortable
with
many
other
types
of
pets
,
particularly
cats
and
birds
,
but
you
should
ask
to
be
sure
.
More
information
on
this
in
the
Pets
article
.
Salary
.
Identify
what
the
starting
salary
would
be
,
and
determine
if
this
is
acceptable
.
It
is
also
important
at
this
time
to
discuss
when
and
if
you
would
give
future
raises
and
what
they
would
be
based
on
,
holiday
bonuses
,
and
any
other
extras
that
you
may
want
to
include
at
this
time
.
The
following
chart
gives
a
rough
idea
of
the
average
salaries
paid
by
expatriates
for
servants
in
Indonesia
.
This
reflects
the
average
only
,
as
a
salary
would
vary
depending
upon
the
servant
'
s
individual
skills
,
language
abilities
,
years
of
service
,
and
your
own
personal
standards
.
Normally
,
a
servant
will
receive
a
raise
periodically
and
consequently
,
over
time
,
his
or
her
salary
would
be
quite
high
in
comparison
with
the
average
salary
.
This
provides
incentive
and
reward
for
service
.
The
following
Average
Salary
Chart
does
not
reflect
Koll
'
s
recommendations
;
it
is
based
on
our
survey
results
.
While
there
are
no
formal
regulations
governing
the
salaries
of
household
staff
,
it
is
worth
remembering
that
the
official
minimum
wage
for
a
laborer
in
Jakarta
if
for
people
who
are
not
living
in
with
an
employer
.
Staff
Salary
Guidelines
Average
Salaries
for
Household
Staff
November
2006
Source
:
Koll
Relocations
General
Rp
700
,
000
to
Rp
1
,
300
,
000
+
optional
food
allowance
Cook
Rp
800
,
000
to
Rp
1
,
500
,
000
+
optional
food
allowance
Houseboy
Rp
600
,
000
to
Rp
1
,
300
,
000
+
optional
food
allowance
Jaga
/
Guard
Rp
600
,
000
to
Rp
1
,
300
,
000
+
optional
food
allowance
Food
Allowance
.
Some
employers
provide
a
food
allowance
,
or
will
provide
basic
food
items
such
as
rice
,
sugar
,
tea
,
coffee
and
oil
.
However
,
many
choose
to
simply
work
this
into
the
salary
,
so
that
the
staff
is
responsible
for
their
own
food
purchases
.
This
method
seems
to
work
with
fewer
headaches
and
misunderstandings
.
Vacation
.
Employees
are
entitled
to
a
paid
vacation
period
each
year
.
This
vacation
usually
falls
over
the
Lebaran
holiday
period
(
see
below
)
.
The
timing
and
scheduling
of
this
and
any
other
vacation
period
that
you
choose
to
offer
also
depends
upon
your
own
personal
schedule
and
needs
,
so
this
should
be
discussed
and
mutually
agreed
upon
as
well
.
This
is
especially
important
if
Lebaran
is
just
a
few
months
away
,
even
though
they
haven
'
t
been
working
for
you
for
a
year
,
they
will
still
expect
to
take
vacation
over
the
holidays
.
Severance
Pay
.
It
is
standard
practice
to
provide
the
equivalent
of
one
month
'
s
salary
for
each
full
year
of
service
to
an
employee
when
you
leave
the
country
and
no
longer
require
his
or
her
services
,
or
in
the
event
of
termination
.
Probation
Period
.
If
you
choose
to
do
so
,
let
the
potential
employee
know
that
he
or
she
would
initially
work
for
a
trial
period
of
time
,
normally
two
to
three
months
,
after
which
both
parties
may
decide
if
the
arrangement
is
working
out
.
Starting
Date
.
If
all
goes
well
,
everyone
should
agree
upon
the
starting
date
.
Some
additional
information
and
common
practices
regarding
staff
include
the
following
:
Lebaran
Bonus
.
Lebaran
is
the
celebration
at
the
end
of
the
holy
month
of
Ramadhan
for
those
of
the
Moslem
faith
.
This
is
a
very
special
time
for
Indonesians
where
it
is
the
custom
to
give
gifts
of
money
and
clothing
.
Although
it
is
called
a
"
bonus
"
it
is
not
only
customary
but
,
by
law
,
all
employees
are
entitled
by
law
to
receive
the
equivalent
of
a
full
month
'
s
salary
as
a
yearly
bonus
at
this
time
.
Many
domestic
helpers
choose
this
time
to
return
to
their
villages
to
celebrate
the
holiday
with
family
.
The
bonus
is
very
important
,
as
most
Indonesians
do
not
manage
a
savings
account
and
use
the
"
bonus
"
to
cover
holiday
shopping
and
tickets
home
.
In
the
case
of
employing
a
Christian
servant
,
you
would
compensate
for
the
Christmas
holidays
in
the
same
manner
.
Uniforms
.
It
is
standard
practice
to
provide
either
a
uniform
or
a
work
clothing
allowance
for
employees
,
with
perhaps
the
exception
of
night
guards
.
Overtime
.
If
an
employee
works
past
normal
hours
,
for
example
during
a
dinner
party
,
paying
overtime
wages
would
be
customary
.
This
is
also
true
for
the
Indonesian
official
public
holidays
.
If
a
servant
chooses
to
work
during
a
public
holiday
,
he
or
she
should
be
compensated
for
this
.
Medical
Care
.
Most
Indonesians
do
not
have
health
insurance
and
very
few
have
enough
money
in
their
savings
account
to
cover
their
medical
and
hospital
bills
.
It
is
common
practice
for
the
employer
to
cover
medical
and
hospital
bills
in
the
event
that
a
domestic
helper
should
become
sick
,
and
while
most
employers
reimburse
all
medical
expenses
it
is
advisable
to
set
an
annual
limit
in
advance
.
Should
your
helper
exceed
his
or
her
limit
you
can
decide
at
your
own
discretion
if
you
wish
to
cover
the
excess
.
The
equivalent
of
1
-
2
months
salary
is
the
usual
amount
agreed
upon
as
a
yearly
medical
reimbursement
limit
.
Should
your
employee
have
family
or
dependents
,
you
should
let
him
or
her
know
whether
or
not
you
are
prepared
to
cover
family
members
'
medical
costs
.
Pre
-
employment
health
checks
.
Many
expatriates
arrange
for
a
pre
-
employment
medical
exam
at
their
own
expense
.
It
is
recommended
that
any
staff
handling
food
or
working
with
young
children
be
tested
for
hepatitis
,
tuberculosis
and
typhoid
before
beginning
employment
.
For
drivers
in
particular
include
a
test
of
eyesight
.
The
health
check
should
be
carried
out
by
a
reputable
medical
clinic
that
gives
the
results
of
the
tests
direct
to
you
,
not
to
the
potential
employee
.
Keeping
Records
.
It
is
very
important
to
keep
track
of
salary
and
bonus
payments
,
medical
payments
,
loans
,
or
any
other
type
of
financial
transaction
between
employer
and
employee
.
Put
everything
in
writing
in
a
record
book
,
and
make
sure
that
each
time
a
transaction
occurs
,
your
employee
counts
his
or
her
money
,
understands
everything
,
and
then
signs
the
book
next
to
each
individual
transaction
.
You
may
also
want
to
keep
any
medical
receipts
,
and
a
copy
of
your
employee
'
s
KTP
,
or
identity
card
,
in
this
book
.
This
book
should
then
be
kept
in
a
safe
place
.
Security
Concerns
.
It
is
advisable
to
keep
anything
of
value
,
such
as
jewelry
,
cash
,
passports
,
etc
.
,
locked
up
in
a
secure
place
at
all
times
.
You
may
decide
to
purchase
a
small
safe
to
keep
in
your
closet
for
extra
peace
of
mind
.
Remember
that
no
matter
how
fond
you
are
of
your
domestic
helpers
,
and
no
matter
how
honest
they
are
,
leaving
valuables
accessible
only
serves
as
a
great
temptation
and
may
invite
trouble
.
Courses
and
Skills
.
Special
courses
are
available
at
the
Jakarta
International
Community
Center
and
International
SOS
that
are
designed
to
improve
various
skills
required
by
household
staff
.
These
include
courses
such
as
English
,
cooking
,
food
handler
'
s
skills
,
swimming
pool
care
,
first
aid
and
CPR
,
child
minder
'
s
first
aid
,
and
household
cleaning
.
After
the
course
,
each
student
receives
a
certificate
of
participation
which
is
beneficial
in
future
job
searches
.
Leaving
the
Country
.
Most
employers
provide
their
household
staff
with
letters
of
recommendation
and
help
with
job
placement
before
departure
from
Indonesia
.
This
is
in
addition
to
the
severance
pay
as
described
above
.
If
you
decide
to
terminate
an
employee
,
it
is
recommended
not
to
give
notice
beforehand
for
security
reasons
.
It
is
best
to
simply
terminate
the
employee
in
a
very
calm
manner
,
and
ask
that
he
or
she
prepare
to
depart
the
premises
immediately
.
Once
again
,
for
security
reasons
,
you
should
supervise
this
preparation
in
the
company
of
another
person
.
Avoid
accusations
,
emotions
and
angry
words
.
If
your
employee
has
worked
for
one
year
or
more
,
he
or
she
should
be
provided
with
severance
pay
equal
to
one
month
'
s
salary
per
year
of
service
even
if
they
are
being
terminated
.
This
should
be
stipulated
in
your
initial
agreement
.
Make
sure
that
he
or
she
signs
a
statement
in
your
record
book
affirming
receipt
of
this
payment
.
If
your
servant
is
resigning
,
you
are
not
responsible
for
severance
pay
.
However
,
you
should
still
supervise
the
departure
.
If
you
have
several
members
of
staff
it
is
up
to
you
to
decide
whether
you
prefer
to
have
them
take
their
days
off
on
different
days
,
or
whether
you
would
like
them
all
to
take
the
same
day
off
so
that
you
can
have
a
"
staff
-
free
"
day
.
It
certainly
takes
some
adjustment
in
getting
used
to
having
staff
around
your
house
,
but
most
expatriates
will
find
that
the
benefits
far
outweigh
the
drawbacks
.
For
more
information
on
Household
Staff
,
read
AWA
'
s
Introducing
Indonesia
,
A
Guide
to
Expatriate
Living
and
Privacy
Issues
in
Indonesia
and
how
they
affect
expatriates
.
Our
thanks
to
Koll
Residential
for
their
generous
contribution
of
this
article
!
[
Practical
Information
]
[
Expat
Forum
]
[
Site
Map
]
[
Search
]
[
Home
Page
]
[
Contact
]
Tell
your
friends
about
the
Living
in
Indonesia
web
site
Copyright
©
1997
-
2006
,
Expat
Web
Site
Association
Jakarta
,
Indonesia
http
:
//
www
.
expat
.
or
.
id
All
rights
reserved
.
The
information
on
Living
in
Indonesia
,
A
Site
for
Expatriates
may
not
be
retransmitted
or
reproduced
in
any
form
without
permission
.
This
information
has
been
compiled
from
sources
which
we
,
the
Expat
Web
Site
Association
and
volunteers
related
to
this
site
,
believe
to
be
reliable
.
While
reasonable
care
has
been
taken
to
ensure
that
the
facts
are
accurate
and
up
-
to
-
date
,
opinions
and
commentary
are
fair
and
reasonable
,
we
accept
no
responsibility
for
them
.
The
information
contained
does
not
make
any
recommendation
upon
which
you
can
rely
without
further
personal
consideration
and
is
not
an
offer
or
a
solicitation
to
buy
any
products
or
services
from
us
.
Opinions
and
statements
constitute
the
judgment
of
the
contributors
to
this
web
site
at
the
time
the
information
was
written
and
may
change
without
notice
.
Expatriate
community
organizations
in
Malang
Rainbow
Preschool
,
contact
:
Ibu
Atiek
,
Jalan
Soka
3
,
phone
491126
(
since
6
months
not
open
,
due
to
lack
of
small
children
in
expat
community
)
Wesley
International
School
,
Jalan
Simpang
Kwoka
1
,
contact
:
Jeff
Seely
,
phone
586410
,
Email
:
wesley
@
wesleyinterschool
.
org
Hash
House
Harriers
(
hiking
/
running
)
,
contact
:
Pak
Poedji
,
UD
.
Mandarin
,
(
Computer
shop
)
,
Jalan
Jagung
Suprapto
7
,
phone
325888
,
361996
German
-
English
Library
,
contact
:
Hidayati
Phillips
,
Jalan
Puncak
Tidar
,
Blok
VE
2
,
No
.
1A
,
phone
563002
English
Language
Christian
Worship
Service
:
Sunday
afternoon
from
4pm
.
OMS
,
Lembah
Dieng
,
phone
580753
,
bible
study
,
singing
,
fellowship
,
Sunday
School
is
available
for
children
during
the
message
Medical
Information
and
Housing
,
contact
:
Bonita
Hendra
,
Jalan
Esberg
1
,
phone
561605
,
0816551047
,
Email
:
hendrath
@
indo
.
net
.
id
Bahasa
Indonesia
language
study
,
contact
:
KPN
,
Jalan
Lokon
3
,
phone
565523
,
Email
:
navi
@
malang
.
wasantara
.
net
.
id
or
Bhinneka
Language
School
,
Jalan
Terusan
Bondowoso
6
,
phone
580296
Recreation
Opportunities
There
are
very
good
recreation
opportunities
in
the
Malang
area
.
Many
big
hotels
provide
a
fitness
club
with
gymnasium
,
pool
,
sauna
,
spa
,
massage
,
tennis
courts
,
basket
ball
court
,
some
have
a
beach
volley
ball
field
.
There
are
also
fitness
clubs
outside
these
hotels
which
are
cheaper
,
but
not
of
the
same
quality
,
also
facilities
/
opportunities
to
play
tennis
,
squash
or
badminton
.
Golf
courses
are
situated
between
Malang
and
Surabaya
along
the
main
road
,
the
nearest
is
a
one
hour
drive
from
Malang
.
For
the
ladies
there
are
aerobic
clubs
,
where
they
can
attend
courses
in
the
early
morning
hours
,
when
the
husband
is
at
work
and
the
children
are
in
school
or
in
the
evening
.
We
have
8
Hash
House
Harrier
groups
in
Malang
,
so
that
you
can
choose
the
most
convenient
time
during
the
week
or
on
weekends
for
you
.
This
is
a
worldwide
organization
for
people
who
would
like
to
go
hiking
or
running
with
a
group
.
You
can
have
some
soft
drinks
,
beer
or
water
and
often
also
food
after
the
run
.
Malang
has
several
movie
theaters
with
the
choice
of
3
or
4
films
(
Dieng
Plaza
is
the
most
comfortable
)
,
some
hotels
show
videos
on
a
big
screen
(
Klub
Bunga
)
.
The
beaches
are
2
3
hours
drive
to
the
south
coast
(
Sedangbiru
,
Balekambang
,
Ngliyep
)
.
Unfortunately
there
is
only
basic
accommodation
available
,
if
any
at
all
and
you
cannot
find
a
nice
restaurant
either
.
So
you
better
prepare
for
a
picnic
on
the
beach
.
Swimming
can
be
dangerous
at
the
south
coast
,
better
be
careful
and
ask
the
locals
for
a
safe
place
to
swim
.
Visit
the
nearby
town
of
Tretes
.
Traditional
Cultural
Performances
Taman
Rekreasi
Senaputra
,
Jalan
Brawijaya
,
shows
every
Sunday
morning
at
10
.
00
o
clock
traditional
dances
from
East
Java
during
the
dry
season
.
Every
last
Wednesday
of
the
month
there
is
a
Wayang
at
22
.
00
h
.
In
Pandaan
there
is
an
open
-
air
theater
,
where
you
can
watch
dance
performances
from
the
Ramayana
or
Mahabarata
epics
on
weekends
.
In
Tumpang
is
the
art
center
"
Pandepokan
Seni
Mangun
Dharma
"
,
which
was
established
1989
to
promote
the
research
,
study
and
performances
of
East
Javanese
arts
.
They
offer
classes
for
dance
,
Gamelan
,
batik
,
wood
carving
,
Shadow
puppetry
and
stage
performances
on
mask
dance
drama
,
Shadow
puppetry
(
Wayang
Kulit
,
regularly
on
Monday
night
,
Kliwon
,
according
to
the
Javanese
Calendar
,
every
5
weeks
)
,
horse
trance
dancing
(
Kuda
Kepang
)
,
Ludruk
theater
,
remo
and
uyon
-
uyon
.
To
obtain
information
about
the
art
center
,
please
contact
:
Karen
&
Soleh
Adi
Pramono
,
phone
787
-
907
.
These
performances
are
of
excellent
quality
.
The
dancers
are
trained
from
childhood
on
and
they
perform
on
many
occasions
in
their
villages
.
East
Javanese
Dances
are
very
expressive
and
dynamic
and
it
s
really
an
adventure
to
see
them
.
Difficulties
with
utilities
Electricity
,
water
,
telephone
and
Internet
service
providers
are
available
in
Malang
.
Getting
connected
to
the
Internet
is
pretty
slow
and
on
peak
hours
nearly
impossible
.
Internet
providers
in
Malang
are
:
Indo
.
net
,
Wasantara
.
net
,
Global
.
net
,
Meganet
,
and
Telkom
.
net
.
Other
the
other
supply
-
utilities
work
quite
normally
.
It
is
better
to
use
a
Stavol
stabilizer
to
regulate
electricity
flow
for
major
appliances
and
electronic
equipment
as
electricity
can
be
unstable
and
blackouts
are
normal
in
some
areas
.
Shopping
For
everyday
use
,
you
can
get
nearly
everything
you
need
in
Malang
.
Fruits
,
vegetables
and
spices
you
can
buy
here
at
the
market
in
good
quality
and
very
cheap
,
comparable
to
western
countries
.
Products
which
are
hard
to
get
or
not
in
the
quality
we
would
like
are
:
cheese
,
soft
cheese
,
yogurt
,
sour
cream
,
meat
for
steaks
that
is
tender
,
other
kinds
of
meat
like
beef
or
chicken
(
sometimes
you
can
buy
lamb
)
,
dark
or
rye
-
bread
,
western
style
cakes
,
books
and
newspapers
in
English
or
other
foreign
languages
,
quality
toys
for
children
,
wine
,
champagne
,
deodorant
and
tampons
,
among
others
.
Clothing
is
not
a
problem
in
Malang
.
If
your
size
is
not
available
in
the
stores
,
you
can
get
it
tailor
-
made
in
good
quality
.
Sometimes
it
is
even
enough
to
bring
a
clipping
from
a
magazine
with
your
favorite
design
.
Swimsuits
and
shoes
for
ladies
in
bigger
sizes
can
be
a
problem
,
however
,
"
Toko
Modern
"
can
make
shoes
for
you
,
but
they
are
not
cheap
.
There
have
been
some
improvements
in
recent
years
.
A
new
Supermarket
(
Tops
)
on
Jalan
Kawi
,
a
big
Gramedia
(
books
,
newspapers
,
stationary
,
sports
,
music
)
opposite
of
Hero
,
a
Holland
Bakery
in
Jalan
Wilis
opened
.
Many
Factory
Outlets
for
clothing
have
sprung
up
like
mushrooms
all
over
the
town
.
Especially
small
shops
are
changing
frequently
.
Even
in
big
supermarkets
the
produce
and
brands
are
constantly
changing
.
If
something
is
not
available
in
Malang
,
sometimes
it
can
be
found
in
Surabaya
,
which
is
only
2
hours
drive
by
car
.
Many
working
people
must
also
go
to
Jakarta
or
Singapore
for
business
reasons
.
These
trips
are
always
a
good
opportunity
to
stock
up
on
missing
necessities
(
time
permitted
)
.
The
Gajayana
train
goes
directly
from
Jakarta
-
Gambir
to
Malang
.
We
have
also
collected
some
useful
addresses
where
we
can
order
food
(
meat
from
a
German
butcher
in
Bali
or
bread
from
a
German
lady
in
Jakarta
)
.
What
"
Expat
Life
"
is
like
Most
of
the
community
activities
are
organized
by
the
Expats
or
Indonesians
themselves
,
there
is
not
much
"
night
life
"
in
Malang
.
There
are
some
nice
hotels
where
you
can
go
to
for
dinner
:
the
famous
Tugu
Hotel
or
the
Graha
Cakra
Hotel
(
former
RRI
radio
station
)
,
Regent
s
Hotel
or
Kartika
Graha
in
the
center
of
Malang
.
Also
to
mention
the
Toko
Oen
Cafe
which
is
better
to
visit
at
daytime
,
because
the
lighting
is
not
very
pleasant
in
the
evening
,
some
neon
bulbs
hanging
from
the
ceiling
.
Gardena
Vegetarian
Cafe
,
Cafe
Und
s
at
Jalan
Besar
Ijen
or
Chahayaningrat
,
a
typical
Javanese
restaurant
where
you
can
sit
in
a
nice
atmosphere
and
also
watch
some
traditional
performances
on
weekends
.
The
food
is
mainly
Indonesian
or
Chinese
.
When
they
offer
western
dishes
,
don
t
expect
the
same
style
as
in
your
home
country
,
or
you
will
be
disappointed
.
There
is
a
Japanese
restaurant
at
the
Kartika
Graha
Hotel
on
the
top
of
the
building
with
a
view
over
Malang
and
good
food
too
,
don
t
be
put
off
,
if
you
are
the
only
guest
,
it
can
happen
!
There
are
some
good
Chinese
restaurants
in
town
,
"
KDS
"
is
famous
among
Chinese
and
Expats
alike
.
On
weekends
you
can
go
golfing
,
hiking
in
Malang
s
mountain
ranges
or
visit
one
of
the
Agrowisata
Hotels
in
Batu
which
has
long
been
a
recreation
site
for
Indonesian
people
.
Make
a
day
-
or
weekend
trip
to
the
beaches
at
the
south
or
north
coast
,
which
may
be
crowded
with
local
people
on
Sundays
.
Visit
the
Island
of
Madura
,
the
Bromo
Bertiri
National
Park
,
the
Baluran
National
Park
,
one
of
the
many
waterfalls
,
or
go
up
to
the
tea
plantations
near
Singosari
and
Lawang
.
The
landscape
in
East
Java
offers
many
possibilities
for
a
short
trip
.
Here
are
also
many
culturally
interesting
places
that
could
be
visited
,
like
ancient
Hindu
temples
.
You
could
also
go
to
some
of
the
villages
,
places
of
Indonesian
home
industry
,
where
they
produce
leather
ware
,
stone
reliefs
and
statues
or
bronze
statues
,
or
"
antik
"
furniture
,
just
to
have
a
look
,
how
it
is
produced
and
also
to
buy
something
.
Then
there
are
the
many
wedding
invitations
,
Javanese
ceremonies
,
Wayang
-
Kulit
or
dance
performances
that
you
can
attend
.
Life
can
be
filled
with
all
these
community
activities
,
as
soon
as
you
get
in
contact
with
the
Indonesian
people
,
who
will
invite
you
to
all
their
festivities
if
you
are
a
newcomer
.
Expat
life
in
Malang
is
much
more
integrated
in
the
community
life
of
the
Indonesian
people
than
it
is
in
Jakarta
.
Housing
Most
expats
live
in
a
large
house
with
garden
(
some
have
their
own
pool
)
at
reasonable
prices
.
There
are
plenty
of
houses
you
can
choose
from
.
You
can
also
decide
,
if
you
prefer
to
live
directly
in
the
city
of
Malang
or
up
in
the
mountains
in
Batu
,
or
somewhere
in
the
new
building
areas
,
called
Perumahan
,
around
Malang
.
Malang
is
a
fast
developing
city
and
it
is
unbelievable
how
many
houses
have
been
built
during
the
last
5
10
year
period
.
It
did
not
stop
in
the
economic
crisis
,
krismon
.
As
many
expats
left
in
recent
years
,
it
is
a
paradise
for
everyone
,
who
is
looking
for
a
house
in
Malang
and
around
.
The
quality
is
not
comparable
to
our
western
standards
,
however
,
most
expats
have
better
housing
conditions
than
in
their
home
country
,
one
of
the
reasons
,
why
they
would
like
to
stay
here
.
If
you
are
looking
for
a
house
in
Malang
,
contact
Bonita
Hendra
,
Jalan
Esberg
1
,
phone
561605
,
Email
:
hendrath
@
indo
.
net
.
id
Dining
-
foreign
cuisine
or
fast
food
restaurants
Mc
Donalds
,
Kentucky
Fried
Chicken
,
Wendy
s
,
Dunkin
Donuts
,
Pizza
Hut
.
Café
Bunga
Bali
is
a
nice
Restaurant
in
Balinese
style
with
a
little
court
inside
.
They
serve
good
steaks
and
their
special
is
Swiss
Roesti
.
On
weekends
they
have
live
music
and
Balinese
dancers
.
Another
restaurant
in
Balinese
style
was
opened
in
a
renovated
Dutch
villa
of
colonial
time
,
PADI
,
Resto
-
Galeri
,
on
Jalan
Pahlawan
Trip
19
,
where
they
also
serve
western
food
.
Japanese
and
Chinese
restaurants
The
big
hotels
offer
foreign
cuisine
,
but
the
food
is
not
the
same
as
in
Europe
,
USA
or
Australia
.
You
can
order
foreign
food
,
for
example
Blackforest
Cake
from
an
Indonesian
lady
who
was
trained
by
Swiss
expats
,
also
Apple
Cake
,
Pizza
and
other
western
dishes
.
Approximate
size
of
Expat
population
In
2005
one
mailing
list
had100
names
=
families
+
couples
+
single
persons
.
44
%
on
the
list
are
western
expats
,
30
%
are
Asian
expats
,
20
%
are
mixed
families
(
western
Indonesian
)
and
6
%
are
Indonesian
institutions
or
persons
with
special
connections
to
the
expat
community
.
The
list
is
not
complete
,
some
people
do
not
want
to
be
mentioned
on
the
list
or
live
already
here
for
many
years
and
are
fully
integrated
into
the
Indonesian
society
.
Access
to
good
medical
care
Some
Indonesian
doctors
were
trained
abroad
and
can
speak
German
,
Dutch
,
English
or
another
language
.
For
less
serious
cases
,
medical
care
is
sufficient
.
For
medical
checkups
,
most
expats
use
their
home
leave
to
do
it
in
their
home
country
.
Some
go
to
Surabaya
,
Jakarta
or
Singapore
.
Malang
has
some
good
Chinese
doctors
who
can
cure
many
illnesses
with
acupuncture
and
herbs
and
also
good
laboratories
if
you
need
to
test
for
malaria
or
other
tropical
deceases
.
Learning
the
Language
In
Malang
,
it
is
essential
that
you
can
speak
some
Bahasa
Indonesia
,
because
not
many
people
can
speak
English
or
other
foreign
languages
.
However
,
some
older
Indonesians
can
speak
Dutch
and
fewer
still
can
understand
a
bit
of
German
.
It
is
recommended
to
start
learning
Bahasa
Indonesia
as
soon
as
you
arrive
in
Malang
.
There
are
several
good
language
schools
in
Malang
:
BHINNEKA
,
Jalan
Terusan
Bondowoso
6
,
phone
580
-
296
,
or
KPN
language
school
,
Jalan
Lokon
3
,
phone
563
-
264
,
contact
Roger
and
Wanaka
Clibborn
,
Jalan
Simpang
Dieng
I
,
No
.
6
,
phone
565
-
523
,
Email
:
navi
@
malang
.
wasantara
.
net
.
id
Primary
employers
of
Expats
There
are
some
large
cigarette
factories
like
Philip
Morris
,
Bentoel
and
Rothman
s
,
chemical
industry
like
Beiersdorf
,
Schering
,
Schulmann
Plastics
,
also
Nestle
in
Pasuruan
for
milk
products
,
paperfactories
,
agrobusiness
,
some
expats
work
at
the
universities
,
the
Wesley
International
School
or
at
the
VEDC
Malang
which
is
a
training
institute
for
technical
teachers
of
STM
Schools
and
in
recent
years
also
for
local
industry
.
Malang
has
many
missionaries
from
different
Christian
organizations
,
who
work
as
teachers
or
do
social
work
and
support
Indonesian
Christian
organizations
.
There
is
a
Swiss
project
for
small
and
medium
scale
industry
,
called
SMEP
,
an
Austrian
project
for
water
treatment
facilities
,
some
people
work
in
the
Agrobusiness
,
which
is
a
substantial
factor
in
the
Malang
area
.
Our
thanks
to
Brigitte
Klaws
for
her
efforts
to
compile
and
periodically
update
the
information
above
and
willingness
to
answer
other
questions
of
intending
expat
residents
of
Malang
.
[
Practical
Information
]
[
Expat
Forum
]
[
Site
Map
]
[
Search
]
[
Home
Page
]
[
Contact
]
Tell
a
friend
about
the
Living
in
Indonesia
web
site
Copyright
©
1997
-
2006
,
Expat
Web
Site
Association
.
Jakarta
,
Indonesia
http
:
//
www
.
expat
.
or
.
id
All
rights
reserved
.
The
information
on
Living
in
Indonesia
,
A
Site
for
Expatriates
may
not
be
retransmitted
or
reproduced
in
any
form
without
permission
.
This
information
has
been
compiled
from
sources
which
we
,
the
Expat
Web
Site
Association
and
volunteers
related
to
this
site
,
believe
to
be
reliable
.
While
reasonable
care
has
been
taken
to
ensure
that
the
facts
are
accurate
and
up
-
to
-
date
,
opinions
and
commentary
are
fair
and
reasonable
,
we
accept
no
responsibility
for
them
.
The
information
contained
does
not
make
any
recommendation
upon
which
you
can
rely
without
further
personal
consideration
and
is
not
an
offer
or
a
solicitation
to
buy
any
products
or
services
from
us
.
Opinions
and
statements
constitute
the
judgment
of
the
contributors
to
this
web
site
at
the
time
the
information
was
written
and
may
change
without
notice
.
Local
students
doing
insect
research
at
the
Leuser
Ecosystem
The
Research
,
Monitoring
,
and
Information
Division
of
the
Leuser
Management
Unit
has
managerial
responsibility
through
governmental
decrees
for
research
activities
within
the
Leuser
Ecosystem
.
It
actively
supports
the
participation
of
Indonesian
researchers
and
students
for
both
pure
and
applied
research
of
relevance
to
the
conservation
of
the
L
.
E
.
In
particular
,
support
is
given
to
those
from
the
state
universities
in
North
Sumatra
and
Aceh
.
Four
research
stations
are
run
within
the
Leuser
Ecosystem
:
Ketambe
(
lowland
forest
,
focused
on
habituated
groups
of
orang
-
utan
and
Thomas
Leaf
monkeys
)
,
Soraya
(
lowland
forest
protected
within
a
logging
concession
,
focusing
on
biodiversity
monitoring
and
educational
and
awareness
activities
)
,
Suaq
(
lowland
peat
swamp
forest
,
focusing
on
studies
on
habituated
orang
-
utans
)
,
and
Bengkung
(
a
new
site
based
in
a
closed
transmigration
site
in
the
middle
of
lowland
rain
forest
,
which
may
become
the
focus
for
large
-
mammal
studies
)
.
Two
monitoring
posts
have
also
been
established
to
date
,
considerably
extending
the
potential
for
survey
work
within
the
vast
and
diverse
Leuser
Ecosystem
.
Lymnonectes
blythii
in
the
Leuser
Ecosystem
The
completion
of
floral
and
faunal
inventories
is
an
important
priority
for
biological
research
,
as
is
the
ecological
study
of
individual
species
.
Of
particular
importance
are
studies
on
the
IUCN
SSG
animals
found
within
the
Leuser
Ecosystem
,
such
as
the
white
-
winged
duck
,
and
the
Sumatran
serow
,
the
Sumatran
tiger
,
and
the
rhinoceros
.
Click
Here
for
Table
of
Research
Priorities
on
endangered
animal
species
Applied
research
topics
such
as
the
effect
of
logging
,
erosion
problems
,
wildlife
management
,
and
land
use
patterns
outside
the
Ecosystem
,
are
key
issues
to
be
addressed
in
the
formulation
of
management
strategies
.
In
addition
,
the
surrounding
programme
area
offers
many
opportunities
for
sociological
and
economic
research
.
Of
particular
interest
to
the
LMU
is
the
influence
of
adat
(
tradition
)
on
the
adjacent
communities
and
community
resource
management
systems
.
Ecotourism
development
is
part
of
the
LMU
s
mandate
but
there
are
no
longer
any
active
orang
-
utan
rehabilitation
centres
in
the
Leuser
Ecosystem
;
the
Bohorok
centre
has
become
a
tourist
-
oriented
orangutan
viewing
area
only
.
Research
into
all
these
factors
is
actively
encouraged
through
national
and
international
networks
.
Access
to
stations
and
posts
from
Medan
:
Soraya
:
6
-
hour
tarmac
road
journey
followed
by
1
.
5
-
hour
river
journey
Ketambe
:
6
-
hour
tarmac
road
journey
followed
by
a
short
river
crossing
Bengkung
*
:
6
-
hour
tarmac
road
journey
followed
by
2
-
hour
river
journey
then
1
hour
by
motorbike
or
8
-
hour
tarmac
and
dirt
road
journey
.
Suaq
Balimbing
*
:
10
-
hour
tarmac
and
dirt
road
journey
followed
by
narrow
river
crossing
and
short
forest
walk
.
Gunung
Air
:
6
-
hour
tarmac
road
journey
followed
by
2
-
hour
river
journey
,
and
a
half
-
hour
walk
.
Agusan
:
7
-
hour
tarmac
road
journey
followed
by
1
-
hour
walk
.
*
Note
:
Suaq
Balimbing
and
Bengkung
Research
Stations
have
been
closed
temporarily
for
all
research
activities
.
Traditional
canoe
is
used
to
cross
the
Alas
river
to
Ketambe
Research
Station
LMU
Field
Offices
FIELD
OFFICE
ADDRESS
CONTACT
DETAILS
LMU
Langsa
Jl
.
Lilawangsa
No
.
12
,
Langsa
,
Aceh
Timur
Tel
.
/
Fax
:
0641
-
21487
LMU
Kutacane
Jl
.
Raja
Bintang
Kutacane
,
Aceh
Tenggara
Tel
.
0629
-
21009
Fax
:
0629
-
21491
LMU
Tapaktuan
Jl
.
Syekh
Mudawali
No
.
27
-
A
,
Tapaktuan
Tel
.
/
Fax
:
0656
-
21675
LMU
Banda
Aceh
Jl
.
Tgk
.
Abdullah
Ujong
Rimba
No
.
6
Banda
Aceh
Tel
.
0651
-
31555
Fax
:
0651
-
32969
Research
regulations
and
obligations
All
researchers
,
both
Indonesian
and
foreign
,
who
want
to
work
in
the
L
.
E
.
should
realise
that
they
should
:
follow
government
regulations
on
research
,
specimen
collection
,
and
export
,
and
need
license
from
LIPI
(
Jakarta
)
prior
doing
research
,
LMU
can
advise
researchers
;
remember
that
the
local
universities
appreciate
visits
and
seminars
to
develop
their
interest
in
new
research
subjects
and
therefore
should
be
prepared
to
make
such
visits
and
presentations
whilst
working
in
the
Leuser
Ecosystem
;
provide
duplicates
of
all
plant
material
collected
within
the
Leuser
Ecosystem
to
relevant
government
agencies
such
as
Bogor
Botanical
Garden
etc
.
;
follow
all
the
Indonesian
government
regulations
on
sending
material
overseas
for
identification
or
analysis
and
have
the
export
overseen
by
government
officials
and
LMU
;
provide
the
LMU
with
one
copy
of
any
subsequent
thesis
or
publication
arising
from
work
undertaken
in
the
Leuser
Ecosystem
.
Further
details
are
provided
on
arrival
.
Research
proposals
are
invited
from
foreign
and
Indonesian
scientists
wishing
to
work
in
the
Leuser
Ecosystem
or
under
the
auspices
of
the
LMU
within
the
Programme
Area
adjacent
to
the
Ecosystem
.
Indonesian
researchers
should
submit
their
CV
,
a
research
proposal
of
2
-
5
pages
and
the
names
and
addresses
of
two
referees
to
the
LMU
.
Most
of
the
sponsorship
available
is
for
the
local
universities
in
North
Sumatra
and
Aceh
.
Indonesian
researchers
from
outside
these
provinces
are
encouraged
to
collaborate
or
provide
training
for
local
researchers
and
students
.
Foreign
scientists
should
discuss
their
proposals
with
RMID
before
applying
for
LIPI
permits
(
central
government
research
permits
)
.
While
no
foreign
researchers
may
work
within
Indonesia
without
LIPI
permits
,
the
possession
of
LIPI
permits
does
not
guarantee
access
to
the
LMU
-
managed
research
facilities
and
LIPI
now
expect
researchers
wanting
to
work
within
the
Leuser
Ecosystem
to
apply
through
the
LMU
.
The
government
also
requires
that
foreign
researchers
support
an
Indonesian
counterpart
on
their
research
project
.
The
LMU
encourages
scientists
to
work
with
counterparts
from
local
universities
,
if
available
,
especially
the
state
university
Universitas
Syiah
Kuala
in
Banda
Aceh
or
Universitas
Sumatera
Utara
in
Medan
.
The
RMID
provides
administrative
support
for
the
application
of
LIPI
permits
and
facilitates
the
establishment
of
the
working
relationship
between
the
visiting
researcher
and
the
sponsoring
institute
.
Scientists
may
also
receive
some
logistical
support
from
the
LMU
.
Volunteers
wishing
to
undertake
research
for
the
LMU
must
also
follow
these
procedures
.
Timetable
:
Note
that
some
field
stations
are
completely
booked
by
researchers
for
up
to
one
year
in
advance
,
so
long
-
term
planning
is
essential
for
both
Indonesian
and
foreign
researchers
.
Closing
dates
for
sponsorship
applications
by
Indonesian
skripsi
students
are
1
April
and
1
September
.
Two
months
are
needed
for
proposal
submission
to
LMU
by
both
foreign
and
Indonesian
researchers
,
and
,
for
the
former
if
successful
,
selection
of
counterpart
;
foreign
researchers
then
require
up
to
six
months
before
departure
date
for
application
for
government
research
permits
and
visa
issuance
.
Most
of
the
professional
programmers
that
I
'
ve
encountered
are
not
well
prepared
to
tackle
algorithm
design
problems
.
This
is
a
pity
,
because
the
techniques
of
algorithm
design
form
one
of
the
core
practical
technologies
of
computer
science
.
Designing
correct
,
efficient
,
and
implementable
algorithms
for
real
-
world
problems
is
a
tricky
business
,
because
the
successful
algorithm
designer
needs
access
to
two
distinct
bodies
of
knowledge
:
Techniques
-
Good
algorithm
designers
understand
several
fundamental
algorithm
design
techniques
,
including
data
structures
,
dynamic
programming
,
depth
-
first
search
,
backtracking
,
and
heuristics
.
Perhaps
the
single
most
important
design
technique
is
modeling
,
the
art
of
abstracting
a
messy
real
-
world
application
into
a
clean
problem
suitable
for
algorithmic
attack
.
Resources
-
Good
algorithm
designers
stand
on
the
shoulders
of
giants
.
Rather
than
laboring
from
scratch
to
produce
a
new
algorithm
for
every
task
,
they
know
how
to
find
out
what
is
known
about
a
particular
problem
.
Rather
than
reimplementing
popular
algorithms
from
scratch
,
they
know
where
to
seek
existing
implementations
to
serve
as
a
starting
point
.
They
are
familiar
with
a
large
set
of
basic
algorithmic
problems
,
which
provides
sufficient
source
material
to
model
most
any
application
.
This
book
is
intended
as
a
manual
on
algorithm
design
,
providing
access
to
both
aspects
of
combinatorial
algorithms
technology
for
computer
professionals
and
students
.
Thus
this
book
looks
considerably
different
from
other
books
on
algorithms
.
Why
?
We
reduce
the
design
process
to
a
sequence
of
questions
to
ask
about
the
problem
at
hand
.
This
provides
a
concrete
path
to
take
the
nonexpert
from
an
initial
problem
statement
to
a
reasonable
solution
.
Since
the
practical
person
is
usually
looking
for
a
program
more
than
an
algorithm
,
we
provide
pointers
to
solid
implementations
whenever
they
are
available
.
We
have
collected
these
implementations
on
the
enclosed
CD
-
ROM
and
at
one
central
FTP
/
WWW
site
for
easy
retrieval
.
Further
,
we
provide
recommendations
to
make
it
easier
to
identify
the
correct
code
for
the
job
.
With
these
implementations
available
,
the
critical
issue
in
algorithm
design
becomes
properly
modeling
your
application
,
more
so
than
becoming
intimate
with
the
details
of
the
actual
algorithm
.
This
focus
permeates
the
entire
book
.
Since
finding
out
what
is
known
about
a
problem
can
be
a
difficult
task
,
we
provide
a
catalog
of
important
algorithmic
problems
as
a
major
component
of
this
book
.
By
browsing
through
this
catalog
,
the
reader
can
quickly
identify
what
their
problem
is
called
,
what
is
known
about
it
,
and
how
they
should
proceed
to
solve
it
.
To
aid
in
problem
identification
,
we
include
a
pair
of
``
before
''
and
``
after
''
pictures
for
each
problem
,
illustrating
the
required
input
and
output
specifications
.
For
each
problem
in
the
catalog
,
we
provide
an
honest
and
convincing
motivation
,
showing
how
it
arises
in
practice
.
If
we
could
not
find
such
an
application
,
then
the
problem
doesn
'
t
appear
in
this
book
.
In
practice
,
algorithm
problems
do
not
arise
at
the
beginning
of
a
large
project
.
Rather
,
they
typically
arise
as
subproblems
when
it
suddenly
becomes
clear
that
the
programmer
does
not
know
how
to
proceed
or
that
the
current
program
is
inadequate
.
To
provide
a
better
perspective
on
how
algorithm
problems
arise
in
the
real
world
,
we
include
a
collection
of
``
war
stories
,
''
tales
from
our
experience
on
real
problems
.
The
moral
of
these
stories
is
that
algorithm
design
and
analysis
is
not
just
theory
,
but
an
important
tool
to
be
pulled
out
and
used
as
needed
.
Equally
important
is
what
we
do
not
do
in
this
book
.
We
do
not
stress
the
mathematical
analysis
of
algorithms
,
leaving
most
of
the
analysis
as
informal
arguments
.
You
will
not
find
a
single
theorem
anywhere
in
this
book
.
Further
,
we
do
not
try
to
be
encyclopedic
in
our
descriptions
of
algorithms
,
but
only
in
our
pointers
to
descriptions
of
algorithms
.
When
more
details
are
needed
,
the
reader
should
follow
the
given
references
or
study
the
cited
programs
.
The
goal
of
this
manual
is
to
get
you
going
in
the
right
direction
as
quickly
as
possible
.
But
what
is
a
manual
without
software
?
This
book
comes
with
a
substantial
electronic
supplement
,
an
ISO
-
9660
compatible
,
multiplatform
CD
-
ROM
,
which
can
be
viewed
using
Netscape
,
Microsoft
Explorer
,
or
any
other
WWW
browser
.
This
CD
-
ROM
contains
:
A
complete
hypertext
version
of
the
full
printed
book
.
Indeed
,
the
extensive
cross
-
references
within
the
book
are
best
followed
using
the
hypertext
version
.
The
source
code
and
URLs
for
all
cited
implementations
,
mirroring
the
Stony
Brook
Algorithm
Repository
WWW
site
.
Programs
in
C
,
C
++
,
Fortran
,
and
Pascal
are
included
,
providing
an
average
of
four
different
implementations
for
each
algorithmic
problem
.
More
than
ten
hours
of
audio
lectures
on
the
design
and
analysis
of
algorithms
are
provided
,
all
keyed
to
the
on
-
line
lecture
notes
.
Following
these
lectures
provides
another
approach
to
learning
algorithm
design
techniques
.
These
notes
are
linked
to
an
additional
twenty
hours
of
audio
over
the
WWW
.
Listening
to
all
the
audio
is
analogous
to
taking
a
one
-
semester
college
course
on
algorithms
!
This
book
is
divided
into
two
parts
,
techniques
and
resources
.
The
former
is
a
general
guide
to
techniques
for
the
design
and
analysis
of
computer
algorithms
.
The
resources
section
is
intended
for
browsing
and
reference
,
and
comprises
the
catalog
of
algorithmic
resources
,
implementations
,
and
an
extensive
bibliography
.
Altogether
,
this
book
covers
material
sufficient
for
a
standard
Introduction
to
Algorithms
course
,
albeit
one
stressing
design
over
analysis
.
We
assume
the
reader
has
completed
the
equivalent
of
a
second
programming
course
,
typically
titled
Data
Structures
or
Computer
Science
II
.
Textbook
-
oriented
features
include
:
In
addition
to
standard
pen
-
and
-
paper
exercises
,
this
book
includes
``
implementation
challenges
''
suitable
for
teams
or
individual
students
.
These
projects
and
the
applied
focus
of
the
text
can
be
used
to
provide
a
new
laboratory
focus
to
the
traditional
algorithms
course
.
More
difficult
exercises
are
marked
by
(
*
)
or
(
**
)
.
``
Take
-
home
lessons
''
at
the
beginning
of
each
chapter
emphasize
the
concepts
to
be
gained
from
the
chapter
.
This
book
stresses
design
over
analysis
.
It
is
suitable
for
both
traditional
lecture
courses
and
the
new
``
active
learning
''
method
,
where
the
professor
does
not
lecture
but
instead
guides
student
groups
to
solve
real
problems
.
The
``
war
stories
''
provide
an
appropriate
introduction
to
the
active
learning
method
.
A
full
set
of
lecture
slides
for
teaching
this
course
is
available
on
the
CD
-
ROM
and
via
the
World
Wide
Web
,
both
keyed
to
unique
on
-
line
audio
lectures
covering
a
full
-
semester
algorithm
course
.
Further
,
a
complete
set
of
my
videotaped
lectures
using
these
slides
is
available
for
interested
parties
.
See
http
:
//
www
.
cs
.
sunysb
.
edu
/
algorith
for
details
.
UK
SME
'
s
outside
Indonesia
.
Provides
clients
with
informed
advice
to
assist
their
planning
.
Standard
Contact
List
(
see
Note
1
below
)
.
N
/
A
Free
UK
SME
'
s
in
/
outside
Indonesia
.
Provides
client
with
a
range
of
contacts
.
Researched
List
(
see
Note
2
)
.
3
-
4
days
Rp
.
800
,
000
UK
SME
'
s
outside
Indonesia
.
Maximum
of
5
companies
.
Saves
client
time
&
money
as
they
meet
only
verified
prospects
.
Indonesian
Economic
&
Political
Overview
(
see
Note
3
)
.
Variable
By
quotation
UK
SME
'
s
outside
Indonesia
.
Puts
business
planning
in
a
macroeconomic
context
.
Market
Profiles
(
see
Note
4
)
.
Off
the
Shelf
Free
UK
SME
'
s
in
/
ouside
Indonesia
.
Provides
a
snapshot
(
by
industry
)
of
market
environment
.
Business
Sector
Overview
(
see
note
5
)
Variable
By
quotation
UK
SME
'
s
in
/
outside
Indonesia
.
Provides
a
snapshot
(
by
sector
)
of
the
market
environment
.
Matchmaking
-
Partner
Selection
,
Due
Diligence
and
Negotiation
Assistance
(
see
Note
6
)
Variable
By
quotation
UK
SME
'
s
outside
Indonesia
&
Indonesian
business
enterprises
.
Helps
clients
identify
and
filter
potential
partners
who
could
meet
their
specific
needs
.
Market
Entry
Strategies
(
see
Note
7
)
.
Variable
By
uotation
UK
SME
'
s
outside
Indonesia
.
Enhances
opportunity
for
export
success
by
assisting
clients
develop
an
informed
market
entry
plan
.
In
-
Depth
Market
Research
(
see
Note
8
)
Variable
By
quotation
UK
SME
'
s
outside
Indonesia
.
Enhances
opportunity
for
export
success
by
providing
detailed
information
about
the
client
'
s
target
industry
or
market
.
Sector
Forecast
.
Variable
By
quotation
UK
SME
'
s
in
/
ouside
Indonesia
.
Projects
sector
growth
in
terms
of
value
and
volume
for
either
3
to
5
year
period
.
Appointment
Programs
(
see
Note
9
)
.
3
-
4
app
.
/
day
Rp
.
200
,
000
/
app
.
UK
SME
'
s
outside
Indonesia
.
For
clients
with
existing
contacts
.
Provides
an
efficient
,
realistic
&
confirmed
visit
schedule
.
Hotel
Bookings
(
see
Note
10
)
.
Up
to
4
locations
Rp
.
200
,
000
UK
SME
'
s
outside
Indonesia
.
Passes
on
BritCham
discounts
&
local
knowledge
to
clients
.
Airport
Pickup
and
/
or
Organizing
Road
Transport
in
the
Market
.
N
/
A
By
quotation
UK
SME
'
s
outside
Indonesia
.
Provides
a
convenient
&
reliable
means
of
transport
.
Accompanying
on
Business
Meetings
.
per
hour
Transport
cost
+
Rp
.
100
,
000
/
hr
for
Exec
.
Director
,
or
Rp
.
200
,
000
/
hour
.
UK
SME
'
s
outside
Indonesia
.
Gives
client
practical
support
and
local
knowledge
.
Interpreter
Service
(
see
Note
11
)
.
per
hour
Transport
and
quotation
.
Min
.
Rp
.
200
,
000
/
hour
.
UK
SME
'
s
outside
Indonesia
.
Both
an
in
-
house
&
outsourced
service
.
Provides
client
with
an
interpreter
who
understands
basics
of
British
/
Indonesian
business
.
Arranging
for
documents
to
be
translated
(
see
Note
11
)
.
Variable
By
quotation
UK
SME
'
s
in
/
outside
Indonesia
Usually
cheaper
&
more
accurate
if
done
in
market
.
Use
of
a
Meeting
Room
(
see
Note
13
)
.
As
required
.
Cost
plus
Rp
.
350
,
000
/
day
or
Rp
.
70
,
000
/
hour
UK
SME
'
s
in
/
outside
Indonesia
Members
free
.
Up
to
6
people
.
Includes
coffee
,
tea
,
and
water
.
Provides
a
convenient
venue
.
Helping
to
Organize
a
Seminar
on
Behalf
of
a
Client
.
Variable
Cost
+
Rp
.
200
,
000
/
hour
UK
SME
'
s
outside
Indonesia
.
Reduces
effort
to
organize
a
seminar
in
the
market
.
Assistance
Visas
and
Work
Permit
Documentation
.
Variable
By
quotation
UK
SME
'
s
in
/
outside
Indonesia
.
Reduces
difficulty
of
obtaining
such
documentation
.
Credit
Status
Report
.
Variable
By
quotation
UK
SME
'
s
in
/
outside
Indonesia
and
Indonesian
business
enterprises
.
Gives
client
an
indication
of
the
standing
&
suitability
of
potential
partners
,
importers
,
or
agents
.
Attending
&
Reporting
Tender
Openings
.
Variable
Transport
Cost
+
Rp
.
200
,
000
/
hour
UK
SME
'
s
outside
Indonesia
Enables
clients
to
assess
the
competitive
environment
for
tender
opportunities
.
Obtaining
Tender
Documents
.
Variable
Costs
+
Rp
.
50
,
000
/
hour
.
Min
.
2
hours
.
UK
SME
'
s
outside
Indonesia
Provides
fast
,
reliable
access
to
tender
documentation
.
Providing
Publicity
Through
Media
Channels
.
Variable
By
quotation
UK
SME
'
s
in
/
outside
Indonesia
Likelihood
of
effective
publicity
improved
by
local
knowledge
&
connections
.
Inwards
/
Outwards
Trade
Missions
(
see
Note
13
)
.
Variable
By
quotation
UK
SME
'
s
in
/
outside
Indonesia
&
Indonesian
business
enterprises
Only
if
initiated
by
BritCham
/
requested
by
a
counterpart
chamber
.
If
not
,
referred
to
embassy
.
Annual
Conference
(
see
Note
14
)
.
Variable
By
quotation
UK
SME
'
s
in
/
outside
Indonesia
&
Indonesian
business
enterprises
Provides
mechanism
for
exchange
of
ideas
,
networking
,
&
bilateral
business
promotion
.
Seminars
(
see
Note
15
)
.
3
-
4
hours
By
quotation
Local
UK
SME
'
s
&
Indonesian
business
enterprises
Allows
members
and
others
to
develop
business
skills
and
expand
knowledge
base
.
Information
Resource
Centre
Variable
Rp
.
20
,
000
/
hour
.
Min
.
1
hour
.
UK
SME
'
s
in
/
outside
Indonesia
&
Indonesian
business
enterprises
Research
facility
.
Members
free
.
Grants
&
Loans
Advice
1
hour
Free
UK
SME
'
s
in
/
outside
Indonesia
&
Indonesian
business
enterprises
Informs
clients
about
trade
support
facilities
available
from
Indonesian
&
British
Government
'
s
Note
1
:
Standard
Contact
Lists
are
provided
by
the
Commercial
Section
of
the
British
Embassy
so
BritCham
complements
this
service
by
preparing
contact
lists
only
in
areas
where
there
are
gaps
.
BritCham
swaps
lists
with
the
Embassy
so
that
each
have
a
complete
portfolio
of
information
.
Note
2
:
Researched
Lists
are
industry
/
product
focused
and
are
limited
to
a
maximum
of
10
companies
.
It
involves
verifying
the
interest
that
each
contact
has
in
meeting
with
the
prospective
client
so
that
only
verified
clients
are
included
on
the
list
.
A
paragraph
of
relevant
background
information
on
each
client
is
provided
as
part
of
this
service
.
Note
3
:
Indonesian
Economic
&
Political
Overview
-
Provides
an
overview
of
the
economic
and
political
environment
including
three
year
economic
forecasts
.
Note
4
:
Market
Profiles
-
Three
to
five
page
summaries
on
various
aspects
of
the
business
environment
in
Indonesia
maintained
on
computer
disk
and
printed
out
on
an
as
required
basis
.
These
cover
,
e
.
g
.
,
service
providers
,
sector
/
industry
profiles
,
and
regulations
,
Who
'
s
Who
in
Business
and
Government
,
etc
.
These
are
updated
regularly
or
as
soon
as
a
significant
change
is
introduced
.
The
actual
research
effort
is
outsourced
to
appropriate
BritCham
members
.
There
is
close
cooperation
with
the
Embassy
on
this
service
to
ensure
no
duplication
.
Profiles
are
swapped
with
the
Embassy
BritCham
members
assist
with
regular
updating
of
Embassy
profiles
.
This
adds
considerable
value
given
the
continuity
of
experience
provided
by
BritCham
members
.
Note
5
:
Business
Sector
Overview
-
Provides
an
overview
of
a
sector
including
market
sizing
,
major
players
and
their
market
shares
,
consumer
demographics
,
and
current
trends
.
Note
6
:
Matchmaking
-
BritCham
acts
as
a
facilitator
,
provides
researched
lists
,
and
utilizes
outsourcing
for
specialist
skills
.
Object
is
to
identify
and
bring
together
the
client
with
an
appropriate
business
partner
.
Note
7
:
Market
Entry
Strategies
-
Provides
recommendations
for
market
entry
including
company
structure
,
products
and
services
to
be
offered
,
target
markets
,
distribution
,
and
strategies
.
Note
8
:
In
-
Depth
Market
Research
is
a
service
that
BritCham
does
not
provide
from
in
-
house
resources
.
However
,
it
is
in
a
position
to
market
,
and
respond
to
requests
for
such
a
services
.
This
has
involved
BritCham
negotiating
and
putting
in
place
period
contracts
with
local
market
research
companies
(
usually
BritCham
members
)
.
Research
is
tailored
to
a
client
'
s
requirements
and
therefore
BritCham
can
arrange
any
research
requested
by
a
client
.
Such
research
could
include
,
but
would
not
be
limited
to
,
the
following
:
Competitor
Analysis
providing
assessment
of
key
industry
players
generally
focusing
on
company
size
,
target
markets
,
strengths
and
weaknesses
,
and
expansion
plans
.
Customer
Analysis
providing
assessment
of
key
business
customers
including
product
or
service
requirements
,
and
possibly
demand
projections
for
a
business
product
or
service
.
Distribution
&
Marketing
Analysis
assessing
distribution
and
marketing
channels
used
by
key
players
.
Regulation
Analysis
of
general
business
regulations
or
regulations
for
a
specific
business
segment
.
Pricing
Information
generally
collected
for
anti
-
dumping
studies
.
Note
9
:
Appointment
Programs
-
This
is
a
service
that
is
understood
,
to
be
appreciated
by
visiting
British
business
men
and
women
.
It
is
also
a
proven
popular
service
with
other
trade
facilitators
.
It
involves
arranging
,
scheduling
,
and
confirming
appointments
(
up
to
4
-
5
per
day
)
with
a
list
of
contacts
supplied
by
the
client
.
Identification
of
contacts
by
BritCham
involves
preparation
of
a
researched
list
(
see
above
)
and
so
is
separately
chargeable
.
Note
10
:
Hotel
Bookings
-
Are
offered
separately
and
as
an
add
-
on
to
the
appointment
service
.
It
has
involved
BritCham
negotiating
special
corporate
rates
at
a
range
of
Jakarta
hotels
as
well
as
at
hotels
in
some
of
the
regional
centres
.
The
discount
is
passed
onto
the
client
and
a
flat
fee
is
charged
for
each
booking
.
Note
11
:
Interpreting
/
Translation
-
Translation
is
outsourced
in
all
cases
to
a
contracted
service
provider
.
Interpreting
is
provided
on
an
as
required
basis
from
both
in
-
house
and
outsourced
resources
.
The
former
involves
a
BritCham
Market
Research
Officer
accompanying
the
client
to
specified
appointments
.
Transport
is
recovered
at
cost
plus
an
hourly
fee
is
charged
for
the
total
time
involved
including
transport
time
.
If
the
BritCham
Market
Research
Officer
is
unavailable
then
the
service
involves
bringing
in
an
outside
interpreter
with
which
BritCham
has
a
period
contracts
.
In
these
cases
fees
are
based
on
the
actual
cost
plus
an
administrative
fee
.
Note12
:
Meeting
Facilities
-
The
BritCham
Business
Centre
presently
has
a
small
meeting
facility
,
which
can
accommodate
up
to
six
people
.
It
is
free
to
members
and
an
hourly
/
daily
fee
is
charged
to
non
-
members
.
Note
13
:
Trade
Missions
/
Displays
-
Trade
Display
/
Exhibition
facilitation
is
a
service
offered
by
the
British
Embassy
Commercial
Section
and
an
area
where
BritCham
is
unlikely
to
be
able
to
add
much
value
.
Any
enquiries
regarding
assistance
with
Trade
Displays
/
Exhibitions
are
therefore
referred
to
the
Embassy
.
Trade
missions
on
the
other
hand
are
something
that
BritCham
is
involved
with
in
on
a
limited
basis
.
As
they
are
resource
intensive
,
BritCham
'
s
involvement
is
limited
to
one
per
year
and
only
to
those
Trade
Missions
that
it
initiates
.
Note
14
:
Annual
Conference
-
It
is
proposed
that
an
Annual
Business
Conference
be
held
on
a
rotating
basis
in
Indonesia
and
Britain
.
It
is
anticipated
that
these
conferences
will
draw
strong
support
from
members
and
will
be
effective
in
profiling
and
publicizing
the
strength
of
the
relationship
between
the
two
countries
.
It
will
also
demonstrate
to
the
broader
business
community
that
the
relationship
is
an
active
one
.
Note
15
:
Seminars
-
This
is
a
service
delivered
at
the
request
of
members
.
BritCham
acts
as
a
facilitator
.
In
consultation
with
members
and
others
,
it
develops
a
list
of
preferred
seminar
topics
,
e
.
g
.
,
(
'
How
to
do
Business
in
Indonesia
'
,
'
Expat
Induction
into
Jakarta
'
)
then
either
organizes
the
seminar
itself
or
contracts
them
out
to
local
service
providers
,
dependent
on
resource
constraints
at
the
time
.
This
involves
negotiation
of
period
contracts
that
establish
parameters
,
an
agreed
curriculum
,
and
agreed
costs
.
Seminars
are
open
to
both
members
and
non
-
members
,
but
with
members
being
given
preference
and
a
discount
.
The
Cost
of
Gold
Below
a
Mountain
of
Wealth
,
a
River
of
Waste
Millions
of
tons
of
mine
waste
from
Freeport
'
s
mining
operation
floods
the
Ajkwa
Plain
,
West
Papua
.
December
27
,
2005
The
Cost
of
Gold
Below
a
Mountain
of
Wealth
,
a
River
of
Waste
By
JANE
PERLEZ
and
RAYMOND
BONNER
JAKARTA
,
Indonesia
-
The
closest
most
people
will
ever
get
to
remote
Papua
,
or
the
operations
of
Freeport
-
McMoRan
,
is
a
computer
tour
using
Google
Earth
to
swoop
down
over
the
rain
forests
and
glacier
-
capped
mountains
where
the
American
company
mines
the
world
'
s
largest
gold
reserve
.
With
a
few
taps
on
a
keyboard
,
satellite
images
quickly
reveal
the
deepening
spiral
that
Freeport
has
bored
out
of
its
Grasberg
mine
as
it
pursues
a
virtually
bottomless
store
of
gold
hidden
inside
.
They
also
show
a
spreading
soot
-
colored
bruise
of
almost
a
billion
tons
of
mine
waste
that
the
New
Orleans
-
based
company
has
dumped
directly
into
a
jungle
river
of
what
had
been
one
of
the
world
'
s
last
untouched
landscapes
.
What
is
far
harder
to
discern
is
the
intricate
web
of
political
and
military
ties
that
have
helped
shield
Freeport
from
the
rising
pressures
that
other
gold
miners
have
faced
to
clean
up
their
practices
.
Only
lightly
touched
by
a
scant
regulatory
regime
,
and
cloaked
in
the
protection
of
the
military
,
Freeport
has
managed
to
maintain
a
nearly
impenetrable
redoubt
on
the
easternmost
Indonesian
province
as
it
taps
one
of
the
country
'
s
richest
assets
.
Months
of
investigation
by
The
New
York
Times
revealed
a
level
of
contacts
and
financial
support
to
the
military
not
fully
disclosed
by
Freeport
,
despite
years
of
requests
by
shareholders
concerned
about
potential
violations
of
American
laws
and
the
company
'
s
relations
with
a
military
whose
human
rights
record
is
so
blighted
that
the
United
States
severed
ties
for
a
dozen
years
until
November
.
Company
records
obtained
by
The
Times
show
that
from
1998
through
2004
,
Freeport
gave
military
and
police
generals
,
colonels
,
majors
and
captains
,
and
military
units
,
nearly
$
20
million
.
Individual
commanders
received
tens
of
thousands
of
dollars
,
in
one
case
up
to
$
150
,
000
,
according
to
the
documents
.
They
were
provided
by
an
individual
close
to
Freeport
and
confirmed
as
authentic
by
current
and
former
employees
.
Freeport
said
in
a
written
response
to
The
Times
that
it
had
"
taken
appropriate
steps
"
in
accordance
with
American
and
Indonesian
laws
to
provide
a
secure
working
environment
for
its
more
than
18
,
000
employees
and
contract
workers
.
"
There
is
no
alternative
to
our
reliance
on
the
Indonesian
military
and
police
in
this
regard
,
"
the
company
said
.
"
The
need
for
this
security
,
the
support
provided
for
such
security
,
and
the
procedures
governing
such
support
,
as
well
as
decisions
regarding
our
relationships
with
the
Indonesian
government
and
its
security
institutions
,
are
ordinary
business
activities
.
"
While
mining
and
natural
resource
companies
sometimes
contribute
to
the
costs
to
foreign
governments
in
securing
their
operations
,
payments
to
individual
officers
raise
questions
of
bribes
,
said
several
people
interviewed
by
The
Times
,
including
a
former
Indonesian
attorney
general
,
who
said
it
was
illegal
under
Indonesian
law
for
officers
to
accept
direct
payments
.
The
Times
'
s
investigation
also
found
that
,
according
to
one
current
and
two
former
company
officials
who
helped
set
up
a
covert
program
,
Freeport
intercepted
e
-
mail
messages
to
spy
on
its
environmental
opponents
.
Freeport
declined
to
comment
.
More
than
30
current
and
former
Freeport
employees
and
consultants
were
interviewed
over
the
past
several
months
for
this
article
.
Very
few
would
speak
for
attribution
,
saying
they
feared
the
company
'
s
retribution
.
Freeport
'
s
support
of
the
military
is
one
measure
of
its
extraordinary
working
environment
.
In
the
1960
'
s
,
when
Freeport
entered
Papua
,
its
explorers
were
among
the
very
first
outsiders
ever
encountered
by
local
tribesmen
swathed
only
in
penis
gourds
and
armed
with
bows
and
arrows
.
Since
then
,
Freeport
has
built
what
amounts
to
an
entirely
new
society
and
economy
,
all
of
its
own
making
.
Where
nary
a
road
existed
,
Freeport
,
with
the
help
of
the
San
Francisco
-
based
construction
company
Bechtel
,
built
virtually
every
stitch
of
infrastructure
over
impossible
terrain
in
engineering
feats
that
it
boasts
are
unparalleled
on
the
planet
.
That
history
,
Papua
'
s
extreme
remoteness
and
the
company
'
s
long
ties
to
the
Indonesian
government
have
given
Freeport
exceptional
sway
over
a
21st
-
century
version
of
the
old
company
town
,
built
on
a
scale
unique
even
by
the
standards
of
modern
mega
-
mining
.
"
If
any
operation
like
this
was
put
forward
now
,
it
wouldn
'
t
be
allowed
,
"
said
Witoro
Soelarno
,
a
senior
investigator
at
the
Department
of
Energy
and
Mineral
Resources
,
who
has
visited
the
mine
many
times
.
"
But
now
the
operation
exists
,
and
many
people
depend
on
it
.
"
For
years
,
to
secure
Freeport
'
s
domain
,
James
R
.
Moffett
,
a
Louisiana
-
born
geologist
who
is
the
company
chairman
,
assiduously
courted
Indonesia
'
s
longtime
dictator
,
President
Suharto
,
and
his
cronies
,
having
Freeport
pay
for
their
vacations
and
some
of
their
children
'
s
college
education
,
and
cutting
them
in
on
deals
that
made
them
rich
,
current
and
former
employees
said
.
It
was
a
marriage
of
mutual
convenience
.
As
Freeport
prospered
into
a
company
with
$
2
.
3
billion
in
revenues
,
it
also
became
among
the
biggest
-
in
some
years
the
biggest
-
source
of
revenue
for
the
government
.
It
remains
so
.
Freeport
says
that
it
provided
Indonesia
with
$
33
billion
in
direct
and
indirect
benefits
from
1992
to
2004
,
almost
2
percent
of
the
country
'
s
gross
domestic
product
.
With
gold
prices
hitting
a
25
-
year
high
of
$
540
an
ounce
this
month
,
the
company
estimates
it
will
pay
the
government
$
1
billion
this
year
.
With
Suharto
'
s
ouster
in
1998
,
after
30
years
of
unchallenged
power
,
Freeport
'
s
special
place
was
left
vulnerable
.
But
its
importance
to
Indonesia
'
s
treasury
and
its
carefully
cultivated
cocoon
of
support
have
helped
secure
it
against
challenges
from
local
people
,
environmental
groups
,
and
even
the
country
'
s
own
Environment
Ministry
.
Letters
and
other
documents
provided
to
The
Times
by
government
officials
showed
that
the
Environment
Ministry
repeatedly
warned
the
company
since
1997
that
Freeport
was
breaching
environmental
laws
.
They
also
reveal
the
ministry
'
s
deep
frustration
.
At
one
point
last
year
,
a
ministry
scientist
wrote
that
the
mine
'
s
production
was
so
huge
,
and
regulatory
tools
so
weak
,
that
it
was
like
"
painting
on
clouds
"
to
persuade
Freeport
to
comply
with
the
ministry
'
s
requests
to
reduce
environmental
damage
.
That
frustration
stems
from
an
operation
that
,
by
Freeport
'
s
own
estimates
,
will
generate
an
estimated
six
billion
tons
of
waste
before
it
is
through
-
more
than
twice
as
much
earth
as
was
excavated
for
the
Panama
Canal
.
Much
of
that
waste
has
already
been
dumped
in
the
mountains
surrounding
the
mine
or
down
a
system
of
rivers
that
descends
steeply
onto
the
island
'
s
low
-
lying
wetlands
,
close
to
Lorentz
National
Park
,
a
pristine
rain
forest
that
has
been
granted
special
status
by
the
United
Nations
.
A
multimillion
-
dollar
2002
study
by
an
American
consulting
company
,
Parametrix
,
paid
for
by
Freeport
and
its
joint
venture
partner
,
Rio
Tinto
,
and
not
previously
made
public
,
noted
that
the
rivers
upstream
and
the
wetlands
inundated
with
waste
were
now
"
unsuitable
for
aquatic
life
.
"
The
report
was
made
available
to
The
Times
by
the
Environment
Ministry
.
Freeport
says
it
strives
to
mitigate
the
environmental
effect
of
its
mine
,
while
also
maximizing
the
benefits
to
its
shareholders
.
The
Times
made
repeated
requests
to
Freeport
and
to
the
Indonesian
government
to
visit
the
mine
and
its
surrounding
area
,
which
requires
special
permission
for
journalists
.
All
were
turned
down
.
Freeport
refused
to
make
any
official
available
for
an
interview
and
would
respond
to
questions
only
in
writing
.
A
cover
letter
signed
by
its
legal
counsel
,
Stanley
S
.
Arkin
,
said
that
Grasberg
is
a
copper
mine
,
with
the
gold
retrieved
as
a
byproduct
,
and
that
many
journalists
had
visited
the
mine
before
the
government
tightened
its
rules
in
the
1990
'
s
.
"
Freeport
has
nothing
to
hide
,
"
Mr
.
Arkin
wrote
.
Indeed
,
at
Grasberg
,
Freeport
-
McMoRan
Copper
&
Gold
mines
the
world
'
s
third
-
largest
copper
deposit
.
The
mine
also
has
proven
reserves
of
46
million
ounces
of
gold
,
according
to
the
company
'
s
2004
annual
report
.
This
year
,
Mining
International
,
a
trade
journal
,
called
Freeport
'
s
gold
mine
the
biggest
in
the
world
.
Social
Tensions
Erupt
Since
Suharto
'
s
ouster
,
Freeport
employees
say
,
Mr
.
Moffett
'
s
motto
has
been
"
no
tall
trees
,
"
a
call
to
keep
as
low
a
profile
as
possible
,
for
a
company
that
operates
on
an
almost
unimaginable
scale
.
But
even
before
then
,
the
new
world
that
Freeport
created
was
growing
smaller
.
By
the
mid
-
1990
'
s
,
with
production
in
full
swing
,
and
the
expanding
impact
of
Grasberg
'
s
operations
ever
more
apparent
,
Freeport
was
beset
on
all
sides
.
Environmental
groups
,
able
to
coordinate
more
effectively
with
the
Internet
,
made
Freeport
a
target
.
Local
tribes
were
more
and
more
restless
at
seeing
little
benefit
for
themselves
as
vast
riches
were
extracted
from
their
lands
.
And
some
military
commanders
in
Papua
saw
Grasberg
'
s
increasing
value
as
ripe
for
the
plucking
.
To
fortify
itself
,
Freeport
,
working
hand
in
hand
with
Indonesian
military
intelligence
officers
,
began
monitoring
the
e
-
mail
messages
and
telephone
conversations
of
its
environmental
opponents
,
said
an
employee
who
worked
on
the
program
and
read
the
e
-
mail
messages
.
The
company
also
set
up
its
own
system
to
intercept
e
-
mail
messages
,
according
to
former
and
current
employees
,
by
establishing
a
bogus
environmental
group
of
its
own
,
which
asked
people
to
register
online
with
a
password
.
As
is
often
the
case
,
many
who
registered
used
the
same
password
for
their
own
messages
,
which
then
allowed
the
company
to
tap
in
.
Freeport
'
s
lawyers
were
nervous
,
a
person
who
was
at
the
company
at
the
time
said
,
but
decided
that
nothing
prohibited
the
company
legally
from
reading
e
-
mail
messages
abroad
.
Social
tensions
around
the
mine
,
meanwhile
,
were
fast
growing
,
as
was
Papua
'
s
population
.
Papua
,
mostly
animist
and
Christian
after
long
years
of
missionary
work
,
is
distinct
in
many
ways
from
the
rest
of
Indonesia
,
the
world
'
s
largest
Muslim
country
.
Almost
from
Indonesia
'
s
independence
,
the
province
had
rumblings
of
a
separatist
movement
.
Throughout
Indonesia
the
military
,
a
deeply
nationalist
institution
,
finances
itself
by
setting
up
legal
enterprises
like
shopping
centers
and
hotels
,
or
illicit
ones
,
like
logging
.
In
Papua
,
the
Grasberg
mine
became
a
chance
for
the
military
not
only
to
profit
but
also
to
deepen
its
presence
in
a
province
where
it
had
barely
a
toehold
before
Freeport
arrived
.
For
many
years
Freeport
maintained
its
own
security
force
,
while
the
Indonesian
military
battled
a
weak
,
low
-
level
insurgency
.
But
slowly
their
security
needs
became
entwined
.
"
Where
Freeport
really
took
it
on
the
chin
is
the
military
who
came
in
had
no
vehicles
,
and
they
would
commandeer
a
Freeport
bus
or
a
Freeport
driver
,
"
said
the
Rev
.
David
B
.
Lowry
,
an
Episcopalminister
hired
by
Mr
.
Moffett
to
oversee
social
programs
.
"
We
had
no
policies
at
that
time
.
"
No
investigation
directly
linked
Freeport
to
human
rights
violations
,
but
increasingly
Papuans
associated
it
with
the
abuses
of
Indonesian
military
units
,
in
some
cases
using
company
facilities
.
An
Australian
anthropologist
,
Chris
Ballard
,
who
worked
for
Freeport
,
and
Abigail
Abrash
,
an
American
human
rights
campaigner
,
estimated
that
160
people
had
been
killed
by
the
military
between
1975
and
1997
in
the
mine
area
and
its
surroundings
.
Finally
,
in
March
1996
,
long
-
simmering
anger
at
the
company
erupted
in
rioting
when
anti
-
mine
sentiment
among
different
groups
coalesced
into
what
was
perhaps
the
biggest
threat
to
the
company
to
this
day
.
The
mine
and
its
mill
were
shut
down
for
three
days
.
Rioters
destroyed
$
3
million
of
equipment
and
ransacked
offices
.
The
company
intercepted
e
-
mail
messages
that
,
according
to
two
persons
who
read
them
at
the
time
,
suggested
that
certain
military
units
,
the
community
and
environmental
groups
were
working
together
.
One
e
-
mail
exchange
,
between
a
community
leader
and
the
head
of
an
environmental
group
,
was
filled
with
tactical
military
intelligence
,
according
to
a
person
who
read
the
messages
.
In
another
exchange
,
an
environmental
leader
urged
the
group
'
s
members
to
pull
out
because
the
demonstrations
had
turned
violent
.
Freeport
told
The
Times
that
local
leaders
later
met
with
company
officials
and
said
"
they
had
provoked
the
disturbances
as
a
means
of
expressing
their
aspiration
to
receive
greater
benefits
from
our
operations
.
"
In
recent
interviews
,
current
and
former
Freeport
officials
recalled
how
they
were
stunned
when
,
among
those
rioting
,
they
saw
men
with
military
haircuts
,
combat
boots
and
walkie
-
talkies
.
They
seemed
to
be
directing
the
rioters
,
at
one
point
,
to
a
Freeport
laboratory
,
which
they
ransacked
.
It
was
not
long
before
a
worried
Mr
.
Moffett
flew
out
to
Indonesia
in
the
company
jet
.
Freeport
refused
to
comment
on
the
meeting
that
followed
.
But
a
company
official
who
was
there
recounted
that
Mr
.
Moffett
met
with
a
group
of
senior
Indonesian
military
officers
at
the
Sheraton
Hotel
in
the
lowland
town
of
Timika
,
near
the
mine
.
The
all
-
powerful
Gen
.
Prabowo
Subianto
,
son
-
in
-
law
of
President
Suharto
and
commander
of
the
Indonesian
Special
Forces
,
presided
.
"
Mr
.
Moffett
,
to
protect
you
,
to
protect
your
company
,
you
have
to
help
the
military
here
,
"
General
.
Prabowo
began
,
according
to
the
company
employee
who
was
present
.
Mr
.
Moffett
is
said
to
have
replied
:
"
Just
tell
me
what
I
need
to
do
.
"
The
Cost
of
Security
Each
military
service
drew
up
its
wish
list
,
current
and
former
company
employees
said
.
In
short
order
,
Freeport
spent
$
35
million
on
military
infrastructure
-
barracks
,
headquarters
,
mess
halls
,
roads
-
and
it
also
gave
the
commanders
70
Land
Rovers
and
Land
Cruisers
,
which
were
replaced
every
few
years
.
Everybody
got
something
,
even
the
Navy
and
Air
Force
.
The
company
had
already
hired
a
former
C
.
I
.
A
.
operative
,
and
on
his
recommendation
,
it
now
approached
a
military
attaché
at
the
American
Embassy
in
Jakarta
,
and
persuaded
him
to
join
the
company
,
according
to
former
and
current
employees
.
Two
more
former
American
military
officers
were
hired
,
and
a
special
department
,
called
the
Emergency
Planning
Operation
,
was
set
up
to
handle
the
company
'
s
new
relationship
with
the
Indonesian
military
.
The
new
department
began
making
direct
monthly
payments
to
Indonesian
military
commanders
,
while
the
Security
Risk
Management
office
handled
the
payments
to
the
police
,
according
to
company
documents
and
current
and
former
employees
.
"
They
signed
a
pact
with
the
devil
,
"
said
an
American
who
was
part
of
Freeport
'
s
security
operations
at
the
time
,
and
who
agreed
with
the
company
'
s
decision
.
Freeport
gave
the
military
and
the
police
in
Papua
at
least
$
20
million
from
1998
to
May
2004
,
according
to
company
documents
.
In
interviews
,
current
and
former
employees
said
that
at
least
an
additional
$
10
million
was
also
paid
during
those
years
.
Seven
years
of
accounting
records
were
provided
to
The
Times
by
an
individual
close
to
the
company
.
Additional
records
for
three
years
were
provided
by
Global
Witness
,
a
nongovernment
organization
,
and
which
released
a
report
last
July
,
"
Paying
for
Protection
,
"
about
Freeport
'
s
relations
with
the
Indonesian
military
.
Diarmid
O
'
Sullivan
,
who
works
for
Global
Witness
in
London
,
criticized
the
payments
.
It
may
be
necessary
for
a
company
to
help
governments
with
security
,
he
said
,
but
"
they
should
give
the
money
through
the
proper
channels
,
in
a
transparent
way
.
"
Freeport
told
The
Times
,
"
Our
books
and
records
are
transparent
and
accurately
reflect
the
support
that
we
provide
.
"
That
support
,
the
company
said
in
its
responses
,
included
"
mitigating
living
costs
,
"
as
well
as
"
infrastructure
,
catered
food
and
dining
hall
costs
,
housing
,
fuel
,
travel
,
vehicle
repairs
,
allowances
to
cover
incidental
and
administrative
costs
,
and
community
assistance
programs
conducted
by
the
military
and
police
.
"
The
company
said
all
of
its
expenditures
were
subject
to
a
budget
review
process
.
The
records
received
by
The
Times
showed
payments
to
individual
military
officers
listed
under
things
like
"
food
cost
,
"
"
administrative
services
"
and
"
monthly
supplement
.
"
Current
and
former
employees
said
the
accounting
categories
did
not
reflect
what
the
money
was
actually
used
for
,
and
that
it
was
likely
that
much
of
the
money
went
into
the
officers
'
pockets
.
The
commanders
who
received
the
money
did
not
have
to
sign
receipts
,
current
and
former
employees
said
.
Asked
if
there
was
a
reason
Freeport
would
give
money
directly
to
military
officers
,
Father
Lowry
,
who
retired
in
March
2004
,
but
remained
a
consultant
to
Freeport
until
June
,
said
,
"
I
can
'
t
think
of
a
good
one
.
"
The
records
show
that
the
largest
recipient
was
the
commander
of
the
troops
in
the
Freeport
area
,
Lt
.
Col
.
Togap
F
.
Gultom
.
During
six
months
in
2001
,
he
was
given
just
under
$
100
,
000
for
"
food
costs
,
"
according
to
the
company
records
,
and
more
than
$
150
,
000
the
following
year
.
Freeport
gave
at
least
10
other
commanders
a
total
of
more
than
$
350
,
000
for
"
food
costs
"
in
2002
,
according
to
the
records
.
Colonel
Gultom
declined
to
be
interviewed
.
Those
payments
were
made
to
individual
officers
,
current
and
former
employees
said
,
even
though
since
the
riots
Freeport
had
allowed
soldiers
to
eat
in
the
company
'
s
mess
and
had
trucked
food
to
more
distant
military
kitchens
.
"
Three
meals
a
day
,
seven
days
a
week
,
"
a
former
official
said
.
Freeport
also
gave
commanders
commercial
airplane
tickets
for
themselves
and
their
wives
and
children
.
Generals
flew
first
or
business
class
and
lower
ranking
officers
flew
economy
,
said
Brig
.
Gen
.
Ramizan
Tarigan
,
who
received
$
14
,
000
worth
of
tickets
in
2002
for
himself
and
his
family
.
General
Tarigan
,
who
held
a
senior
police
post
,
said
that
police
officers
were
allowed
to
accept
airplane
tickets
because
their
pay
was
so
low
-
as
a
general
,
his
base
salary
was
roughly
$
400
a
month
-
but
that
it
was
in
violation
of
police
regulations
to
receive
cash
payments
.
In
April
2002
,
the
company
gave
the
senior
commander
of
forces
in
Papua
,
Maj
.
Gen
.
Mahidin
Simbolon
,
more
than
$
64
,
000
,
for
what
was
described
in
Freeport
'
s
books
as
"
fund
for
military
project
plan
2002
.
"
Eight
months
later
,
in
December
,
he
was
given
more
than
$
67
,
000
for
a
"
humanitarian
civic
action
project
.
"
The
payments
were
first
reported
by
Global
Witness
.
General
Simbolon
,
who
is
now
inspector
general
of
the
Indonesian
Army
,
declined
requests
to
be
interviewed
.
A
former
Freeport
employee
who
was
involved
in
making
those
payments
said
the
company
could
not
be
certain
how
much
of
the
money
General
Simbolon
actually
spent
on
those
projects
.
Unsolved
Killings
By
2003
,
following
the
Enron
scandal
and
passage
of
the
Sarbanes
-
Oxley
Act
,
which
imposed
more
rigid
accounting
practices
on
companies
,
Freeport
began
making
payments
to
military
and
police
units
instead
of
individual
officers
,
according
to
records
and
current
and
former
employees
.
The
company
paid
police
units
in
Papua
slightly
under
$
1
million
in
2003
,
according
to
the
records
,
listed
under
items
like
"
monthly
supplement
payment
,
"
"
administrative
costs
"
and
"
administrative
support
.
"
Freeport
told
The
Times
that
"
company
policies
take
into
account
the
potential
for
human
rights
abuses
in
determining
what
types
of
assistance
to
provide
.
"
According
to
the
records
received
by
The
Times
,
the
police
Mobile
Brigade
,
a
paramilitary
force
often
cited
by
the
State
Department
for
its
brutality
,
received
more
than
$
200
,
000
in
2003
.
In
its
2003
annual
human
rights
report
,
the
State
Department
said
soldiers
from
the
Mobile
Brigade
"
continued
to
commit
numerous
serious
human
rights
violations
,
including
extrajudicial
killings
,
torture
,
rape
,
and
arbitrary
detention
.
"
It
cited
no
specific
incidents
from
Papua
.
There
was
another
reason
for
extra
care
by
the
company
.
In
August
2002
,
three
teachers
employed
by
Freeport
,
including
two
Americans
,
were
killed
in
an
ambush
on
a
company
road
patrolled
by
the
military
that
Freeport
had
paid
to
protect
its
employees
.
Three
years
later
,
the
F
.
B
.
I
.
is
still
investigating
and
the
reasons
for
the
killings
have
not
been
determined
.
Freeport
said
that
it
could
not
comment
on
the
investigation
.
The
United
States
indicted
a
Papuan
,
Anthonius
Wamang
,
in
2004
.
But
it
has
yet
to
receive
the
full
cooperation
of
the
military
,
several
American
officials
said
.
Freeport
employees
and
American
officials
said
the
killings
could
have
been
part
of
a
turf
war
between
the
military
and
the
police
,
each
of
which
wanted
access
to
Freeport
payments
.
An
initial
report
by
the
Indonesian
police
pointed
to
the
Indonesia
military
,
and
some
Freeport
and
Bush
administration
officials
have
said
they
suspect
some
level
of
military
involvement
.
The
police
report
suggested
that
the
motivation
was
that
Freeport
was
threatening
to
cut
its
support
to
soldiers
.
Soldiers
assigned
to
Papua
have
"
high
expectations
,
"
the
report
said
,
but
recently
,
"
their
perks
,
such
as
vehicles
,
telephones
,
etc
.
,
were
reduced
.
"
Questions
of
Accountability
Freeport
has
resisted
nearly
any
detailed
disclosure
of
its
payments
to
the
military
,
saying
they
are
legal
and
even
required
under
Indonesian
law
.
Marsillam
Simanjuntak
,
who
was
minister
of
justice
and
later
attorney
general
in
one
of
the
first
governments
after
the
fall
of
President
Suharto
,
said
it
was
a
violation
of
Indonesian
law
for
soldiers
or
police
officers
to
accept
payments
from
a
company
.
"
Of
course
,
it
'
s
illegal
,
"
he
said
.
But
many
companies
do
it
,
he
said
.
The
better
question
to
ask
,
he
said
,
was
,
"
Is
it
allowed
by
the
laws
of
the
United
States
?
"
This
year
,
the
New
York
City
pension
funds
submitted
a
shareholder
resolution
asking
Freeport
to
review
its
policy
on
paying
the
police
and
military
.
They
argued
that
it
could
violate
the
Foreign
Corrupt
Practices
Act
,
which
forbids
American
companies
from
paying
bribes
to
foreign
officials
.
Freeport
opposed
the
resolution
.
In
2002
,
the
funds
submitted
a
similar
resolution
demanding
that
Freeport
disclose
how
much
it
was
paying
to
the
military
.
Freeport
kept
it
off
the
ballot
.
In
later
filings
with
the
Securities
and
Exchange
Commission
,
Freeport
reported
that
it
had
paid
the
military
a
total
of
$
4
.
7
million
in
2001
,
and
$
5
.
6
million
in
2002
.
The
company
did
not
indicate
whether
the
money
was
paid
into
commanders
'
personal
accounts
,
or
what
the
money
was
used
for
.
Freeport
,
in
its
responses
,
said
it
was
complying
with
the
Voluntary
Principles
on
Security
and
Human
Rights
,
a
set
of
guidelines
drawn
up
by
the
State
Department
.
They
recognize
that
natural
resource
companies
"
may
be
required
or
expected
to
contribute
to
,
or
otherwise
reimburse
,
the
costs
of
protecting
company
facilities
.
"
The
principles
do
not
address
the
question
of
direct
payments
to
individual
officers
.
Nor
do
they
require
companies
to
account
for
the
payments
.
Freeport
has
also
said
that
the
payments
were
required
under
its
Contract
of
Work
,
its
basic
agreement
with
the
government
of
Indonesia
,
first
signed
in
1967
and
updated
in
1991
.
The
company
declined
to
provide
a
copy
of
the
contracts
to
The
Times
.
A
copy
of
each
was
provided
by
Denise
Leith
,
author
of
"
The
Politics
of
Power
:
Freeport
in
Suharto
'
s
Indonesia
.
"
They
contained
no
language
requiring
payments
to
the
military
.
S
.
Prakash
Sethi
,
head
of
the
International
Center
for
Corporate
Accountability
,
which
recently
concluded
a
report
on
Freeport
'
s
development
policies
in
Papua
,
said
that
the
company
had
told
him
that
it
made
"
in
-
kind
"
contributions
to
the
military
,
for
housing
and
food
,
but
that
he
had
not
been
given
access
to
accounting
records
.
Any
direct
payments
to
military
officers
would
be
illegal
,
said
Mr
.
Sethi
,
an
expert
on
business
ethics
and
corporate
social
responsibility
and
a
professor
at
Baruch
College
.
"
It
'
s
corruption
,
"
he
said
.
"
It
'
s
bribery
.
"
Mine
Waste
in
the
Rivers
All
the
while
Freeport
sealed
its
relations
with
the
military
,
the
country
'
s
fledgling
environment
ministry
could
do
little
but
watch
as
waste
from
the
mine
piled
up
.
This
year
Freeport
told
the
Indonesian
government
that
the
waste
rock
in
the
highlands
,
900
feet
deep
in
places
,
now
covers
about
three
square
miles
.
Down
below
,
nearly
90
square
miles
of
wetlands
,
once
one
of
the
richest
freshwater
habitats
in
the
world
,
are
virtually
buried
in
mine
waste
,
called
tailings
,
with
levels
of
copper
and
sediment
so
high
that
almost
all
fish
have
disappeared
,
according
to
environment
ministry
documents
.
The
waste
,
the
consistency
and
color
of
wet
cement
,
belts
down
the
rivers
,
and
inundates
and
smothers
all
in
its
path
,
said
Russell
Dodt
,
an
Australian
civil
engineer
who
managed
the
waste
on
the
wetlands
for
10
years
until
2004
for
Freeport
.
About
a
third
of
the
waste
has
moved
into
the
coastal
estuary
,
an
essential
breeding
ground
for
fish
,
and
much
of
that
"
was
ripped
out
to
sea
by
the
falling
tide
that
acted
like
a
big
vacuum
cleaner
,
"
he
said
.
But
no
government
,
even
in
Indonesia
'
s
new
democratic
era
,
has
dared
encroach
on
Freeport
'
s
prerogatives
.
The
strongest
challenge
came
in
2000
,
when
a
feisty
politician
,
Sonny
Keraf
,
who
was
sympathetic
to
the
Papuans
,
was
appointed
environment
minister
.
Again
,
Mr
.
Moffett
flew
out
to
Jakarta
.
Mr
.
Keraf
initially
refused
to
see
the
Freeport
boss
,
but
eventually
agreed
,
and
on
the
day
kept
him
waiting
for
an
hour
and
a
half
.
"
He
came
in
so
arrogant
,
"
Mr
.
Keraf
recalled
of
the
meeting
in
a
recent
interview
,
"
sitting
with
his
legs
crossed
.
"
Freeport
refused
to
comment
on
the
meeting
.
The
American
ambassador
to
Indonesia
at
the
time
,
Robert
Gelbard
,
said
in
an
interview
:
"
It
was
a
terrible
meeting
.
"
Mr
.
Keraf
said
that
Mr
.
Moffett
had
said
that
his
company
had
never
polluted
.
"
I
told
him
that
he
should
spend
the
money
he
spent
on
paying
off
people
not
to
talk
about
the
mine
to
properly
dispose
of
the
waste
,
"
Mr
.
Keraf
said
.
Behind
the
scenes
,
Mr
.
Keraf
kept
up
the
pressure
,
angered
that
the
company
was
using
the
rivers
,
forest
and
wetlands
for
its
mine
waste
,
a
process
allowed
during
the
Suharto
years
.
An
internal
ministry
memorandum
from
2000
said
the
mine
waste
had
killed
all
life
in
the
rivers
,
and
said
that
this
violated
the
criminal
section
of
the
1997
environmental
law
.
In
January
2001
,
Mr
.
Keraf
wrote
to
the
coordinating
minister
for
economic
affairs
,
arguing
that
Freeport
should
be
forced
to
pay
compensation
for
the
rivers
,
forests
and
fish
that
its
operations
had
destroyed
.
Six
months
later
,
one
of
his
deputies
,
Masnellyarti
Hilman
,
wrote
to
Freeport
,
saying
a
special
environmental
commission
had
recommended
that
the
company
stop
using
the
river
as
a
waste
chute
,
and
instead
build
a
system
of
pipes
.
She
also
told
Freeport
to
build
sturdier
dam
-
like
walls
to
replace
the
less
solid
levees
that
it
used
to
contain
the
waste
on
the
wetlands
.
That
practice
has
continued
.
Freeport
says
that
local
and
regional
governments
have
approved
its
waste
management
plans
,
and
that
the
central
government
has
approved
its
environmental
impact
statement
and
other
monitoring
plans
.
But
in
a
blistering
July
2001
letter
,
Mr
.
Keraf
took
the
governor
of
Papua
to
task
for
granting
Freeport
a
permit
in
1996
to
use
the
rivers
for
its
waste
.
The
governor
,
Mr
.
Keraf
said
,
had
no
authority
to
grant
permits
more
lenient
than
the
provisions
of
national
laws
.
Despite
all
these
efforts
,
nothing
happened
.
Mr
.
Keraf
was
unable
to
secure
the
support
of
other
government
agencies
or
his
superiors
in
the
cabinet
.
In
August
2001
,
a
new
government
came
to
power
,
and
a
less
aggressive
minister
,
Nabiel
Makarim
,
replaced
Mr
.
Keraf
.
At
first
,
he
,
too
,
talked
publicly
of
setting
stricter
limits
on
Freeport
.
Soon
his
efforts
petered
out
.
The
Environment
Ministry
has
begun
trying
to
put
teeth
into
its
rules
where
it
can
.
It
brought
a
criminal
suit
against
the
world
'
s
largest
gold
company
,
Newmont
Mining
Corporation
,
for
alleged
pollution
,
including
a
charge
of
not
having
a
permit
for
disposing
of
mine
waste
into
the
sea
.
Newmont
has
fought
the
charges
vigorously
.
But
in
the
case
of
Freeport
,
the
ministry
has
had
no
traction
.
Freeport
still
does
not
hold
a
permit
from
the
national
government
to
dispose
of
mine
waste
,
as
required
by
the
1999
hazardous
waste
regulations
,
according
to
Rasio
Ridho
Sani
,
assistant
deputy
for
toxic
waste
management
at
the
ministry
.
Mr
.
Arkin
,
Freeport
'
s
counsel
,
said
that
the
company
cooperated
well
with
the
environment
ministry
and
that
Freeport
would
not
otherwise
comment
.
"
Freeport
says
their
waste
is
not
hazardous
waste
,
"
Mr
.
Rasio
said
.
"
We
cannot
say
it
is
not
hazardous
waste
.
"
He
said
his
division
and
Freeport
were
now
in
negotiations
on
how
to
resolve
the
permit
question
.
'
A
Massive
Die
-
Off
'
The
environment
ministry
was
not
the
first
to
challenge
Freeport
over
how
it
has
disposed
of
its
waste
in
Papua
.
The
Overseas
Private
Investment
Corporation
,
a
United
States
government
agency
that
insures
American
corporations
for
political
risk
in
uncertain
corners
of
the
world
,
revoked
Freeport
'
s
insurance
policy
in
October
1995
.
It
was
a
landmark
decision
,
the
first
time
that
the
agency
had
cut
off
insurance
to
any
American
company
for
environmental
or
human
rights
concerns
.
In
doing
so
,
two
environmental
experts
,
Harvey
Himberg
,
an
official
at
the
agency
,
and
David
Nelson
,
a
consultant
,
after
visiting
the
mine
for
several
days
,
issued
a
report
critical
of
Freeport
'
s
operations
,
especially
the
huge
amounts
of
waste
it
had
sent
into
rivers
,
something
that
would
not
be
allowed
in
the
United
States
.
The
company
went
to
court
to
block
the
report
from
being
made
public
,
and
only
a
redacted
version
was
later
released
.
A
person
who
thought
it
should
be
made
public
provided
an
uncensored
copy
to
The
Times
.
Freeport
says
the
report
reached
"
inaccurate
conclusions
.
"
The
company
says
it
has
considered
a
full
range
of
alternatives
for
managing
and
disposing
of
its
waste
,
instead
of
using
the
river
,
and
settled
on
the
best
one
.
A
storage
area
would
not
be
large
enough
and
would
require
a
tall
dam
in
a
region
of
heavy
rainfalls
and
earthquakes
,
it
said
.
A
waste
pipeline
,
rather
than
the
river
,
would
be
too
costly
,
prone
to
landslides
and
floods
.
To
the
American
auditors
,
such
arguments
were
not
convincing
.
Freeport
"
characterizes
engineered
alternatives
as
having
the
highest
potential
for
catastrophic
failure
when
the
project
otherwise
takes
credit
for
legendary
feats
,
"
the
audit
noted
,
like
the
pipelines
more
than
60
miles
long
down
the
mountains
to
carry
fuel
and
copper
and
gold
slurry
.
At
the
time
,
the
waste
was
jumping
the
riverbanks
,
"
resulting
in
a
massive
die
-
off
of
vegetation
,
"
the
report
said
.
The
company
threatened
to
take
the
agency
to
court
over
the
cancellation
of
its
insurance
.
After
protracted
negotiations
,
the
policy
was
reinstated
for
a
few
months
,
as
a
face
-
saving
gesture
to
Mr
.
Moffett
,
according
to
the
head
of
the
agency
then
,
Ruth
Harkin
.
It
was
not
renewed
.
Today
,
many
of
the
same
problems
persist
,
but
on
a
much
larger
scale
.
A
perpetual
worry
is
where
to
put
all
the
mine
'
s
waste
-
accumulating
at
a
rate
of
some
700
,
000
tons
a
day
.
The
danger
is
that
the
waste
rock
atop
the
mountain
will
trickle
out
acids
into
the
honeycomb
of
caverns
and
caves
beneath
the
mine
in
a
wet
climate
that
gets
up
to
12
feet
of
rain
a
year
,
say
environmental
experts
who
have
worked
at
the
mine
.
Stuart
Miller
,
an
Australian
geochemist
who
manages
Freeport
'
s
waste
rock
,
said
at
a
mining
conference
in
2003
that
the
first
acid
runoffs
began
in
1993
.
The
company
can
curb
much
of
it
today
,
he
said
,
by
blending
in
the
mountain
'
s
abundant
limestone
with
the
potentially
acid
producing
rock
,
which
is
also
plentiful
.
Freeport
also
says
that
the
company
collects
the
acid
runoff
and
neutralizes
it
.
But
before
2004
,
the
report
obtained
by
The
Times
by
Parametrix
,
the
consulting
company
who
did
the
study
for
Freeport
,
said
that
the
mine
had
"
an
excess
of
acid
-
generating
material
.
"
A
geologist
who
worked
at
the
mine
,
who
declined
to
be
identified
because
of
fear
of
jeopardizing
future
employment
,
said
acids
were
already
flowing
into
the
groundwater
.
Bright
green
-
colored
springs
could
be
seen
spouting
several
miles
away
,
he
said
,
a
tell
-
tale
sign
that
the
acids
had
leached
out
copper
.
"
That
meant
the
acid
water
traveled
a
long
way
,
"
he
said
.
Freeport
says
that
the
springs
are
"
located
several
miles
from
our
operations
in
the
Lorentz
World
Heritage
site
and
are
not
associated
with
our
operations
.
"
The
geologist
agreed
that
the
springs
probably
were
in
the
Lorentz
park
,
and
said
this
showed
that
acids
and
copper
from
the
mine
were
affecting
the
park
,
considered
a
world
treasure
for
its
ecological
diversity
.
In
the
lowlands
,
the
levees
needed
to
contain
the
waste
will
eventually
reach
more
than
70
feet
high
in
some
places
,
the
company
says
.
Freeport
says
that
the
tailings
are
not
toxic
and
that
the
river
it
uses
for
its
waste
meets
Indonesian
and
American
drinking
water
standards
for
dissolved
metals
.
The
coastal
estuary
,
it
says
,
is
a
"
functioning
ecosystem
.
"
The
Parametrix
report
shows
copper
levels
in
surface
waters
high
enough
to
kill
sensitive
aquatic
life
in
a
short
time
,
said
Ann
Maest
,
a
geochemist
who
consults
on
mining
issues
.
The
report
showed
that
nearly
half
of
the
sediment
samples
in
parts
of
the
coastal
estuary
were
toxic
to
the
sensitive
aquatic
organisms
at
the
bottom
of
the
food
chain
,
she
said
.
The
amount
of
sediment
presents
another
problem
.
Too
many
suspended
solids
in
water
can
smother
aquatic
life
.
Indonesian
law
says
they
should
not
exceed
400
milligrams
per
liter
.
Freeport
'
s
waste
contained
37
,
500
milligrams
as
the
river
entered
the
lowlands
,
according
to
an
environment
ministry
'
s
field
report
in
2004
,
and
7
,
500
milligrams
as
the
river
entered
the
Arafura
Sea
.
Freeport
would
not
comment
on
the
measurements
.
The
company
says
it
spent
$
30
million
on
environmental
programs
in
2004
,
and
planted
50
,
000
mangrove
seedlings
last
year
as
part
of
its
reclamation
efforts
.
It
says
cash
crops
can
be
grown
on
the
waste
with
the
addition
of
nutrients
,
and
has
begun
demonstration
projects
.
An
Uneasy
Coexistence
If
the
accumulating
waste
is
the
despair
of
critics
,
for
Freeport
it
signals
expanding
production
.
To
keep
its
mine
running
,
the
company
has
increasingly
had
to
play
caretaker
for
the
world
that
it
has
created
.
After
the
1996
riots
,
Freeport
began
dedicating
1
percent
of
revenues
annually
to
a
development
fund
for
Papua
to
pay
for
schools
,
medical
services
,
roads
-
whatever
the
people
wanted
.
The
company
built
clinics
and
two
hospitals
.
Other
services
include
programs
to
control
malaria
and
AIDS
and
a
"
recognition
"
fund
for
the
Kamoro
and
Amungme
tribes
of
several
million
dollars
which
,
among
other
things
,
gives
them
shares
in
the
company
as
part
of
a
compensation
package
for
the
lands
Freeport
is
using
.
By
the
end
of
2004
,
Freeport
had
spent
$
152
million
on
the
community
development
fund
,
the
company
said
.
Mr
.
Sethi
,
of
the
Center
for
Corporate
Accountability
,
commended
Freeport
for
commissioning
the
report
on
the
company
'
s
development
programs
,
saying
that
it
was
the
first
mining
company
to
do
so
.
The
report
,
which
was
released
in
October
,
concluded
that
the
company
had
successfully
introduced
a
human
rights
training
program
for
its
employees
and
had
doubled
the
number
of
Papuan
employees
by
2001
.
The
company
was
poised
to
double
the
number
of
Papuans
in
the
work
force
again
by
2006
,
the
audit
said
.
Still
,
Thom
Beanal
,
the
Amungme
tribal
leader
,
says
the
combined
weight
of
the
Indonesian
government
and
Freeport
has
left
his
people
in
bad
shape
.
Yes
,
he
said
,
the
company
had
provided
electricity
,
schools
and
hospitals
,
but
the
infrastructure
was
built
mainly
for
the
benefit
of
Freeport
.
Mr
.
Beanal
,
57
,
a
vocal
supporter
of
independence
for
Papua
,
has
fought
the
company
from
outside
and
inside
.
In
2000
,
he
decided
that
harmony
was
the
better
path
,
and
joined
the
company
'
s
advisory
board
.
In
November
,
he
and
other
Amungme
and
Komoro
tribesmen
met
with
Mr
.
Moffett
at
the
Sheraton
Hotel
in
Timika
.
In
an
interview
in
Jakarta
not
long
afterward
,
Mr
.
Beanal
said
he
told
Mr
.
Moffett
that
the
flood
of
money
from
the
community
fund
was
ruining
people
'
s
lives
.
When
the
company
arrived
,
he
noted
,
there
were
several
hundred
people
in
the
lowland
village
of
Timika
.
Now
it
is
home
to
more
than
100
,
000
in
a
Wild
West
atmosphere
of
too
much
alcohol
,
shootouts
between
soldiers
and
the
police
,
AIDS
and
prostitution
,
protected
by
the
military
.
Still
more
soldiers
are
on
the
way
.
Having
negotiated
an
end
to
a
separatist
insurrection
this
year
in
another
province
,
Aceh
,
the
government
is
redeploying
soldiers
to
Papua
in
a
move
to
defeat
the
growing
enthusiasm
for
independence
,
once
and
for
all
,
and
to
watch
over
the
province
with
the
world
'
s
biggest
gold
mine
.
Freeport
says
its
gold
ore
has
35
years
to
go
.
Mr
.
Beanal
said
he
was
increasingly
impatient
with
the
presence
of
the
soldiers
and
the
mine
.
"
We
never
feel
secure
there
,
"
he
said
.
"
What
are
they
guarding
?
We
don
'
t
know
.
Ask
Moffett
,
it
'
s
his
company
.
"
Evelyn
Rusli
contributed
reporting
for
this
article
.
Copyright
2005
The
New
York
Times
Company
Kontak
:
Chalid
Muhammad
,
Executive
Director
of
WALHI
National
[
chalid
@
walhi
.
or
.
id
]
Torry
Kuswardono
,
WALHI
Campaigner
on
Mining
[
torry
@
walhi
.
or
.
id
]
For
more
information
,
please
contact
:
Halid
Muhammad
National
Director
Telepon
kantor
:
+
62
-
(
021
)
791
93
363
Mobile
:
Fax
:
+
62
-
(
021
)
794
1673
Created
:
27
Dec
2005
|
Updated
:
29
Dec
2005
Objective
:
Able
to
function
in
daily
situations
using
language
skill
beyond
“
survival
needs
”
.
The
Beginner
Program
has
been
designed
to
provide
a
general
understanding
of
the
Indonesian
language
.
The
program
aims
to
prepare
students
in
the
following
skills
:
to
understand
simple
conversation
in
daily
situations
to
read
simple
texts
to
write
simple
texts
to
learn
the
expressions
Indonesian
people
generally
use
to
make
sentences
,
questions
and
requests
to
invite
or
prohibit
someone
from
doing
something
to
move
beyond
the
basic
structures
and
expressions
to
understand
daily
conversation
beyond
the
classroom
Intermediate
Objective
:
Able
to
communicate
effectively
in
most
informal
and
semi
-
formal
settings
.
In
the
Intermediate
Program
students
will
be
trained
to
conduct
the
following
activities
:
to
converse
with
Indonesian
associates
to
increase
their
own
vocabulary
through
greater
use
of
the
dictionary
to
become
more
familiar
with
the
features
of
Indonesian
grammar
to
read
in
a
more
advanced
level
to
write
on
a
more
complex
level
to
communicate
on
topics
of
particular
interest
and
special
fields
of
interest
Note
:
the
topics
chosen
will
closely
related
to
the
students
’
professional
needs
or
requirements
.
Advanced
Objective
:
Able
to
utilize
Indonesian
in
the
course
of
normal
professional
duties
such
as
clarifying
points
,
conducting
meetings
,
or
giving
speeches
.
In
the
Advanced
Program
the
main
focus
is
on
the
degree
of
complexity
of
language
use
.
Having
completed
the
program
,
students
will
be
able
:
to
master
the
use
of
affixes
in
Indonesian
language
to
converse
with
,
understand
and
get
along
with
Indonesian
people
in
daily
situations
to
write
increasingly
complex
texts
to
read
articles
in
newspapers
and
magazines
to
participate
in
most
formal
and
informal
conversations
on
practical
social
and
professional
topics
to
discuss
topics
of
particular
interests
or
fields
of
specializations
Specialized
Objective
:
Able
to
use
the
language
as
well
-
educated
bilingual
native
speaker
.
Speaking
proficiency
reflects
Indonesian
cultural
standards
,
i
.
e
.
,
communication
skills
are
at
the
same
level
as
a
well
-
educated
bilingual
native
speaker
able
to
speak
fluently
and
appropriately
in
the
most
formal
of
settings
.
While
the
classification
is
based
on
the
degree
of
complexity
of
language
use
,
the
Specialized
Program
prepares
students
:
to
understand
and
participate
in
discussions
or
seminars
to
conduct
meetings
to
make
speeches
to
conduct
interviews
to
prepare
written
reports
to
translate
authentic
texts
and
to
be
an
interpreter
to
use
the
language
to
satisfy
professional
needs
in
a
wide
range
of
sophisticated
and
demanding
tasks
to
use
the
language
fluently
and
accurately
at
all
levels
normally
relevant
to
professional
needs
Note
:
The
topics
chosen
will
be
beyond
students
’
professions
and
vary
quite
widely
.
LB
Colorado
offers
programs
based
on
students
’
levels
of
proficiency
in
the
language
.
It
provides
both
instruction
in
the
Indonesian
language
and
exposure
to
the
socio
-
cultural
aspects
of
Indonesia
.
The
programs
in
more
detail
are
as
follows
:
LEVELS
*
RATING
SCALE
LEVEL
DURATION
Beginner
1
30
contact
hours
2
60
contact
hours
3
90
contact
hours
Intermediate
4
150
contact
hours
5
210
contact
hours
6
270
contact
hours
Advanced
7
330
contact
hours
8
390
contact
hours
9
450
contact
hours
Specialized
10
540
contact
hours
11
630
contact
hours
12
720
contact
hours
*
Students
average
time
to
master
the
objectives
of
each
level
LB
Colorado
offers
intensive
Indonesian
language
courses
for
students
with
moderate
,
little
or
even
no
proficiency
in
the
language
.
Students
will
undertake
a
placement
test
on
their
first
day
of
language
training
to
determine
their
level
of
proficiency
.
If
required
students
may
progress
through
all
levels
offered
by
LB
Colorado
.
The
length
of
the
study
depends
on
the
students
’
individual
competence
and
requirements
.
All
programs
pay
special
attention
to
listening
and
speaking
skills
,
reading
skills
and
vocabulary
building
as
well
as
basic
knowledge
of
grammar
and
structure
.
Writing
skills
are
optional
and
provided
at
the
students
’
requests
.
Practicing
Bahasa
Indonesia
in
Real
Life
Students
,
either
through
course
work
or
in
outside
activities
,
also
have
the
opportunity
to
be
involved
in
Yogyakarta
’
s
vigorous
cultural
and
social
life
.
Students
gain
language
skills
associated
with
day
-
to
-
day
living
through
making
telephone
calls
,
asking
direction
from
Indonesian
native
speakers
,
bargaining
with
“
becak
”
drivers
or
local
traders
,
shopping
at
the
supermarket
or
traditional
market
and
interacting
with
household
staff
.
Excursions
and
Social
Outings
Traditional
market
and
bird
market
Factories
:
batik
,
leather
puppet
,
silver
and
ceramic
Sultan
Palace
,
Water
Castle
and
Imogiri
Music
,
dance
and
wayang
performances
:
Ramayana
Ballet
,
“
wayang
kulit
"
,
special
occasions
Temples
:
Borobudur
,
Prambanan
,
Ratu
Boko
Recreational
sites
:
Parangtritis
beach
,
Mt
.
Merapi
,
Kaliurang
,
Dieng
Plateau
NRM
Headline
News
is
a
free
,
weekly
e
-
mail
news
service
in
English
,
covering
the
issues
of
natural
resources
governance
and
policy
in
Indonesia
.
Headline
News
contains
selected
news
items
from
the
Indonesian
press
,
information
about
upcoming
events
and
employment
opportunities
,
and
regular
updates
on
the
activities
of
the
Natural
Resources
Management
(
NRM
)
Program
.
Funding
is
provided
by
the
United
States
Agency
for
International
Development
(
USAID
)
.
T
he
NRM
Headline
News
is
available
in
plain
text
or
HTML
formats
.
Contributions
from
readers
are
always
welcome
.
Please
e
-
mail
us
at
headline
@
nrm
.
or
.
id
Story
No
.
1
:
Ten
Billion
Rupiah
for
Sungai
Wain
Protected
Forest
An
example
of
how
a
regional
government
can
be
committed
when
saving
its
forests
and
environment
.....
more
Story
No
.
2
:
Bunaken
National
Park
Village
Radio
Network
now
Up
and
Running
The
installation
of
the
village
radio
network
has
brought
Bunaken
NP
one
step
closer
to
truly
world
-
class
management
,
and
NRM
/
EPIQ
’
s
important
goal
of
fostering
an
active
and
conservation
-
minded
Bunaken
NP
“
community
”
is
well
on
its
way
to
reality
.....
more
Story
No
.
3
:
Notes
from
a
Meeting
between
West
Kutai
Regency
and
the
Ministry
of
Forestry
on
Forest
Management
Meeting
to
discuss
future
collaborations
.....
more
Story
No
.
4
:
Update
on
Mitra
Kutai
Report
on
Mitra
Kutai
’
s
activities
in
2001
and
plans
for
2002
.....
more
Story
No
.
5
:
Partnership
in
Conservation
for
Higher
Achievement
The
likelihood
of
a
conservation
campaign
to
be
successful
is
greater
when
it
is
implemented
as
joint
efforts
with
experienced
partners
.....
more
Story
No
.
6
:
Update
Kerinci
Seblat
National
Park
Website
Revised
version
of
the
website
.....
more
Story
No
.
7
:
Britain
and
Indonesia
Sign
Agreement
to
Combat
Illegal
Timber
Trade
Friends
of
the
Earth
forest
campaigner
,
Ed
Matthew
,
said
more
than
70
percent
of
logging
in
Indonesia
was
illegal
and
the
contract
should
help
.....
more
Story
No
.
8
:
All
Wood
Used
by
KIMPRASWIL
for
the
Construction
of
Temporary
Housing
in
Poso
,
Central
Sulawesi
,
Known
to
be
Illegal
Team
YAKIS
,
considers
it
very
regrettable
that
the
woods
used
for
constructing
temporary
housing
in
Poso
do
not
possess
legal
documentation
.....
more
Story
No
.
9
:
Illegal
Fishing
at
Alarming
Level
Dahuri
said
that
the
total
amount
of
fish
catches
taken
through
illegal
fishing
practices
in
Indonesia
reached
over
1
.
5
million
of
tons
a
year
.....
more
Story
No
.
10
:
Illegal
Logging
Troubles
Plywood
Industry
"
Around
one
third
of
115
local
plywood
factories
have
closed
their
operations
mainly
due
to
the
rampant
illegal
logging
,
"
Martias
,
Apkindo
chairman
told
reporters
.....
more
Story
No
.
11
:
NGOs
Join
Forces
in
Forest
Management
Hapsoro
of
Telapak
Indonesia
,
an
Indonesian
NGO
,
said
non
-
governmental
organizations
were
seriously
concerned
about
the
level
of
destruction
and
degradation
of
forest
resources
,
caused
by
misguided
forest
management
policies
over
many
years
.....
more
Story
No
.
12
:
Gorontalo
Governor
Urged
to
Preserve
Ecosystem
of
Togean
Islands
"
We
ask
the
governor
not
to
exploit
Tomini
Bay
for
his
project
,
"
said
Sudirman
Suhdi
,
the
director
of
Civil
Society
non
-
governmental
organization
(
NGO
)
.....
more
Story
No
.
13
:
Sustainable
Development
Meeting
Planned
in
Bali
"
The
ministerial
-
level
meeting
in
Bali
will
be
very
important
.
It
is
not
meant
to
be
a
talkfest
but
an
action
-
oriented
meeting
which
is
expected
to
yield
political
declarations
,
action
agenda
and
partnership
documentation
,
"
said
JoAnne
DiSano
,
the
director
of
the
United
Nations
division
for
sustainable
development
.....
more
Story
No
.
14
:
Governor
Lashes
Out
at
Illegal
Logging
"
The
local
forestry
offices
and
security
authorities
in
the
four
provinces
must
take
strict
action
against
all
sides
who
are
involved
in
the
illegal
logging
,
"
Zulkifli
said
.....
more
Story
No
.
15
:
Former
Minister
Emil
Salim
,
a
Champion
of
the
Environment
Presidents
come
and
presidents
go
but
the
work
of
Professor
Emil
Salim
will
go
on
forever
.
The
70
-
year
-
old
former
state
minister
for
population
and
environment
left
Soeharto
'
s
government
in
1993
but
he
is
still
on
his
toes
trying
to
find
ways
to
make
ecology
and
economy
compliment
each
other
.....
more
Story
No
.
16
:
Indonesian
Public
Policy
Forum
(
Reminder
)
The
Public
Policy
Forum
aims
to
encourage
awareness
and
discussion
of
major
public
policy
issues
facing
Indonesia
.
Ultimately
the
goal
is
to
support
the
resolution
of
policy
issues
and
channel
conclusions
into
action
.....
more
Story
No
.
17
:
Land
Management
and
Biodiversity
in
Southeast
Asia
A
symposium
jointly
organized
by
The
Graduate
School
of
Environmental
Earth
Science
,
Hokkaido
University
and
The
Research
Center
for
Biology
,
The
Indonesian
Institute
of
Sciences
will
be
held
in
Bali
on
September
17
-
20
,
2002
.....
more
Story
No
.
18
:
Vacancies
at
TNC
East
Kalimantan
Office
The
Nature
Conservancy
'
s
East
Kalimantan
Program
seeks
candidates
to
fill
the
following
positions
:
Awareness
Outreach
Officer
and
Accountant
.....
more
Story
No
.
1
:
Ten
Billion
Rupiah
for
Sungai
Wain
Protected
Forest
On
March
15
,
2002
,
the
Balikpapan
city
legislature
(
DPRD
)
passed
the
2002
municipal
budget
(
APBD
)
,
of
which
almost
10
billion
rupiah
was
allocated
for
the
management
and
preservation
of
the
Sungai
Wain
Protection
Forest
(
HLSW
)
.
This
allocation
was
the
result
of
continuous
lobbying
and
campaigning
carried
out
in
the
year
since
the
Sungai
Wain
Declaration
of
March
15
,
2001
.
In
this
era
of
regional
autonomy
,
the
common
perception
is
that
the
regions
are
currently
trying
to
maximize
exploitation
of
natural
resources
to
raise
local
revenue
.
Therefore
,
it
is
especially
encouraging
to
see
the
example
of
Balikpapan
city
that
is
willing
to
allocate
significant
finances
to
preserve
its
last
remaining
tract
of
forest
.
Ten
billion
rupiah
is
approximately
2
.
1
%
of
the
total
APBD
of
486
billion
rupiah
,
and
represents
a
relatively
high
investment
to
preserve
a
10
,
000
ha
forest
.
While
3
.
7
billion
is
allocated
from
the
DAK
DR
2001
(
special
funding
that
is
allocated
from
the
reforestation
fund
)
,
the
remaining
6
.
3
billion
is
allocated
directly
from
municipal
finances
.
Balikpapan
city
is
probably
unique
amongst
the
more
than
four
hundred
kabupatens
and
cities
in
Indonesia
in
allocating
such
a
large
sum
of
money
for
forest
preservation
.
Following
the
Sungai
Wain
Declaration
,
made
on
March
15th
at
a
workshop
on
the
management
of
Sungai
Wain
organized
by
the
city
government
,
many
concerned
government
officials
,
local
press
,
researchers
,
NGO
’
s
donor
-
funded
programs
such
as
NRM
/
EPIQ
,
have
been
lobbying
for
a
contribution
for
the
management
of
the
Sungai
Wain
forest
in
the
municipal
budget
.
However
,
it
is
probably
fair
to
say
that
the
size
of
the
actual
allocation
was
a
pleasant
surprise
for
even
the
most
optimistic
lobbyist
.
The
funds
will
be
managed
and
monitored
by
a
special
agency
,
the
Badan
Pengelola
Hutan
Lindung
Sungai
Wain
/
BP
-
HLSW
(
Sungai
Wain
Protection
Forest
Management
Board
)
.
The
Management
Board
consists
of
two
components
,
namely
a
multi
-
stakeholder
Steering
Committee
(
Dewan
Pengarah
)
,
and
a
professional
Management
Unit
(
Unit
Pelaksana
)
.
Recruitment
of
staff
for
the
Management
Unit
is
currently
underway
and
positions
advertised
both
in
the
local
and
national
mass
media
,
and
on
the
internet
(
see
previous
issue
of
Headline
News
)
.
The
Steering
Committee
will
monitor
the
implementation
of
management
,
and
has
representatives
of
many
different
groups
including
several
local
government
departments
,
NGO
’
s
,
local
communities
,
the
Municipal
Legislature
,
the
private
sector
and
the
local
media
.
The
Steering
Committee
is
accountable
to
the
Mayor
,
who
is
in
turn
accountable
to
the
local
legislature
.
Through
this
chain
of
reporting
and
monitoring
,
it
is
expected
that
the
management
system
will
become
more
professional
,
accountable
and
transparent
.
Currently
the
legal
basis
for
establishment
of
the
Management
Board
is
the
Mayoral
Decree
No
.
6
,
year
2001
.
The
provision
of
a
stronger
legal
basis
through
the
formulation
of
local
legislation
(
a
Perda
)
is
currently
underway
,
with
an
emphasis
on
the
use
of
public
consultation
mechanisms
to
ensure
improved
understanding
and
compliance
.
Will
the
allocation
of
these
municipal
funds
automatically
guarantee
the
preservation
of
HLSW
?
One
would
think
so
,
but
we
also
need
to
be
realistic
about
the
size
of
the
issues
and
threats
to
Sungai
Wain
such
as
illegal
logging
,
forest
fires
,
and
especially
encroachment
which
now
occupies
more
than
1
,
500
ha
and
has
already
impacted
the
quality
and
quantity
of
water
in
Sungai
Wain
.
These
issues
are
not
easy
to
resolve
because
they
are
linked
to
other
issues
such
as
finding
economic
solutions
for
encroachers
.
Nonetheless
,
there
still
is
room
to
be
optimistic
.
The
strategic
plan
(
RENSTRA
)
and
the
program
guidelines
formulated
by
the
Management
Board
aim
at
achieving
a
comprehensive
solution
to
preserve
Sungai
Wain
,
at
the
same
time
providing
benefits
to
local
communities
.
The
Municipal
government
’
s
commitment
to
allocate
funds
and
to
involve
all
stakeholders
in
preserving
its
forest
is
a
ray
of
hope
in
the
midst
of
uncertainties
and
ignorance
often
encountered
when
trying
to
find
solutions
to
save
the
forests
.
The
ten
billion
rupiah
is
expected
to
draw
more
funds
from
other
sources
and
will
be
an
example
of
how
a
regional
government
can
be
committed
when
saving
its
forests
and
environment
.
Maybe
the
time
has
come
for
a
kota
or
a
kabupaten
to
become
role
models
for
other
levels
of
the
government
.
At
the
very
least
there
is
no
harm
in
hoping
.
Satria
Iman
Pribadi
Outreach
and
Education
Specialist
NRM
/
EPIQ
Kalimantan
Timur
satriai
@
samarinda
.
org
Top
Story
No
.
2
:
Bunaken
National
Park
Village
Radio
Network
now
Up
and
Running
During
the
month
of
March
,
radio
antennas
began
appearing
everywhere
in
villages
throughout
Bunaken
National
Park
.
Are
Bunakenites
preparing
for
extraterrestrial
communications
?
No
,
this
is
simply
the
realization
of
a
long
-
standing
request
to
increase
communication
capabilities
amongst
the
22
villages
in
the
park
.
NRM
/
EPIQ
has
provided
a
total
of
26
base
VHF
radio
stations
and
8
handheld
marine
VHF
radios
in
order
to
facilitate
communications
between
villages
and
provide
radio
contact
for
the
24
hour
joint
patrol
system
.
Working
closely
with
the
Bunaken
Concerned
Citizen
’
s
Forum
(
FMPTNB
)
,
the
BNP
Management
Advisory
Board
(
DPTNB
)
has
overseen
the
installation
of
these
radios
in
all
22
villages
(
including
several
isolated
enclaves
)
,
the
Bunaken
patrol
posts
,
and
on
patrol
boats
.
For
each
village
station
,
ten
villagers
have
been
trained
in
proper
radio
use
,
and
the
system
is
now
operating
flawlessly
.
The
radio
network
is
operating
on
Marine
VHF
Channel
01A
(
corresponding
to
a
frequency
of
156
,
050
MHz
)
,
with
a
secondary
frequency
of
153
,
450
MHz
.
Already
,
the
radio
network
is
greatly
simplifying
communications
between
villages
,
the
patrol
system
,
dive
operators
,
and
the
DPTNB
secretariat
.
Communications
between
the
secretariat
and
the
patrol
system
are
now
instantaneous
and
allow
tight
monitoring
of
the
entrance
fee
system
,
while
village
conservation
leaders
separated
by
10
’
s
of
kilometers
of
ocean
are
now
regularly
chatting
with
each
other
.
Although
the
network
is
active
24
hours
a
day
,
FMPTNB
leaders
have
instituted
their
own
tradition
that
every
morning
at
5am
,
the
day
is
opened
with
a
five
to
ten
minute
prayer
for
Bunaken
National
Park
,
with
a
subsequent
day
-
end
prayer
at
8pm
.
Village
stations
take
turns
in
leading
the
prayer
.
Perhaps
the
most
important
improvement
is
in
the
area
of
enforcement
against
illegal
fishers
,
as
demonstrated
in
the
following
incident
.
On
20
March
2002
,
a
dive
tourist
staying
on
Bunaken
Island
noticed
a
cyanide
compressor
boat
beginning
operations
on
Bunaken
’
s
reef
at
approximately
10pm
.
Within
minutes
,
she
had
contacted
a
dive
operator
who
promptly
notified
the
patrol
post
on
Liang
Beach
.
The
patrol
post
directed
the
nearest
patrol
boat
to
the
site
of
the
compressor
activities
.
As
it
turned
out
,
the
cyanide
boat
had
quickly
moved
from
Bunaken
once
it
realized
it
was
under
watch
,
but
the
village
network
was
listening
and
12
island
stations
promised
to
keep
vigil
and
report
if
the
boat
began
operating
on
their
respective
reefs
.
Mark
V
.
Erdmann
Marine
Protected
Areas
Advisor
NRM
/
EPIQ
Sulawesi
Utara
erdmann
@
nrm
.
or
.
id
Top
Story
No
.
3
:
Notes
from
a
Meeting
between
West
Kutai
Regency
and
the
Ministry
of
Forestry
on
Forest
Management
A
closed
meeting
between
representatives
from
West
Kutai
Regency
and
the
Ministry
of
Forestry
was
held
in
Jakarta
on
April
23
,
2002
.
The
meeting
was
chaired
by
Ir
.
Wahyudi
Wardoyo
,
MF
,
Secretary
General
,
Ministry
of
Forestry
.
Speakers
included
Ir
.
Rama
A
.
Asia
,
regent
of
West
Kutai
and
drs
.
Juan
Jenau
,
MBA
,
Head
of
DPRD
in
West
Kutai
.
Other
participants
included
directors
and
the
forestry
minister
’
s
expert
staffs
,
representatives
from
NRM
/
EPIQ
,
Ford
Foundation
,
USAID
and
NGOs
.
Ir
.
Rama
Asia
presented
the
vision
and
mission
for
West
Kutai
’
s
forest
management
.
West
Kutai
is
planning
to
implement
sustainable
forest
management
for
the
benefit
of
the
local
community
.
Local
traditional
cultures
,
customs
and
wisdoms
will
always
be
considered
prior
to
any
decision
-
making
.
Included
in
the
presentation
were
future
strategies
and
current
ongoing
collaboration
with
foreign
institutions
,
such
as
NRM
/
EPIQ
Program
,
CIFOR
,
Ford
and
GTZ
.
Drs
.
Juan
Junau
provided
full
support
to
the
role
that
has
been
chosen
by
West
Kutai
,
i
.
e
.
to
develop
collaboration
with
institutions
and
the
local
community
in
West
Kutai
.
In
the
meeting
,
Ir
.
Wahyudi
stressed
the
fact
that
there
are
no
activities
that
become
the
sole
responsibility
of
one
stakeholder
.
Each
activity
needs
the
active
support
and
participation
of
relevant
stakeholders
.
The
regent
of
West
Kutai
expects
that
the
Ministry
of
Forestry
will
be
more
responsive
toward
the
rapid
developments
occurring
in
the
region
.
To
date
West
Kutai
’
s
government
has
always
been
responsive
towards
local
community
’
s
aspirations
.
The
regent
cannot
afford
to
act
slowly
when
responding
to
the
community
’
s
aspirations
,
particularly
when
it
concerns
the
uncertainty
of
the
current
forest
management
.
In
this
regard
,
Ir
.
Rama
Asia
hopes
that
after
the
meeting
the
Ministry
of
Forestry
will
give
its
commitment
to
continue
the
collaboration
between
the
central
and
regional
governments
in
future
activities
.
The
discussions
went
very
well
in
a
transparent
manner
.
Several
follow
-
up
actions
were
agreed
upon
,
for
example
the
reactivation
of
the
Ministry
of
Forestry
’
s
“
Gugus
Tugas
”
(
task
force
)
to
facilitate
decentralized
forest
management
initiatives
,
such
as
the
Perda
Kehutanan
(
regional
regulation
on
forestry
)
that
is
being
formulated
by
multistakeholders
in
West
Kutai
.
For
more
information
please
contact
:
C
.
Yan
Sinyal
Head
of
the
Kelompok
Kerja
Program
Kehutanan
Kutai
Barat
(
KK
-
PKD
)
c
/
o
Sekretariat
KK
-
PKD
,
Kantor
CDK
Mahakam
Ulu
Jl
.
A
.
Yani
,
Melak
Ulu
Kalimantan
Timur
Tel
:
0545
-
41035
or
Erwinsyah
SFM
Specialist
NRM
/
EPIQ
Program
Jakarta
Gedung
Ratu
Plaza
lt
.
17
Jl
.
Jend
.
Sudirman
9
Jakarta
10270
021
-
720
95
96
esyah
@
nrm
.
or
.
id
Top
Story
No
.
4
:
Update
on
Mitra
Kutai
Since
it
was
first
initiated
in
1994
when
the
Department
of
Forestry
signed
an
agreement
with
eight
companies
operating
in
the
areas
surrounding
Kutai
National
Park
,
Mitra
Kutai
(
Friends
of
Kutai
)
had
completed
quite
a
number
of
activities
.
In
its
development
,
Mitra
Kutai
became
a
formal
institution
that
accommodates
other
companies
/
organization
wishing
to
contribute
to
the
development
and
preservation
of
Kutai
National
Park
.
Other
organizations
that
contributed
to
the
foundation
include
NRM
/
EPIQ
,
IFFM
-
GTZ
,
UNESCO
,
WWF
Sundaland
Bioregion
Balikpapan
and
Bikal
.
In
addition
to
the
fund
allocated
from
the
government
,
Kutai
National
Park
also
receives
funding
from
Mitra
Kutai
for
the
development
and
preservation
of
Kutai
National
Park
.
From
1996
-
1998
,
most
of
Mitra
Kutai
’
s
activities
were
implemented
as
single
projects
and
were
considered
as
the
company
’
s
responsibilities
and
contribution
to
Kutai
National
Park
.
In
the
past
two
years
Mitra
Kutai
’
s
activities
were
concentrated
on
promotional
activities
,
facilities
development
and
habitat
management
.
Through
these
promotional
activities
it
is
expected
that
people
will
become
more
aware
of
Kutai
National
Park
’
s
existence
and
therefore
establishing
it
as
one
of
the
representative
areas
to
develop
tourism
,
germplasm
and
ecology
studies
in
East
Kalimantan
that
corresponds
with
Kutai
National
Park
’
s
vision
until
2005
.
At
the
end
of
1998
,
Mitra
Kutai
entered
a
more
democratic
phase
.
The
previous
repressive
security
measures
that
were
enacted
did
not
provide
significant
results
,
and
only
succeeded
in
generating
the
community
’
s
animosity
toward
Balai
Taman
Nasional
Kutai
.
Based
on
the
opinion
survey
that
was
carried
out
in
the
park
,
it
was
found
that
Kutai
National
Park
still
needs
to
be
publicized
more
often
.
Without
support
and
involvement
of
stakeholders
,
the
development
and
preservation
of
Kutai
National
Park
will
not
succeed
.
On
the
other
hand
,
the
stakeholders
’
involvement
can
only
be
realized
when
these
stakeholders
are
aware
,
understand
and
have
some
knowledge
about
Kutai
National
Park
.
Mitra
Kutai
’
s
activities
in
2001
Most
of
the
activities
completed
in
2001
were
based
on
the
commitment
that
was
agreed
upon
in
the
meeting
held
in
Jakarta
on
July
27
-
28
,
2000
.
These
activities
include
:
1
.
Planned
annual
activities
:
Vocal
group
and
poetry
reading
contests
for
SMU
pupils
in
Bontang
and
Sangatta
.
The
contest
was
held
on
January
27
,
2001
.
These
activities
were
aimed
at
channeling
the
pupils
’
creativity
in
producing
environmentally
-
friendly
messages
Quiz
on
environmentally
-
linked
subjects
for
SLTP
pupils
.
The
aim
of
this
activity
was
to
have
competitions
on
environmentally
-
linked
subjects
for
pupils
from
different
SLTPs
.
Also
to
observe
how
school
teachers
were
motivated
in
developing
and
disseminating
basic
environmental
education
subjects
to
their
pupils
.
The
quiz
was
held
on
March
31
-
April
1
,
2001
in
Bontang
.
Essay
writing
contest
for
SMU
pupils
in
East
Kalimantan
.
The
purpose
is
to
enhance
the
students
’
writing
ability
.
The
pupils
were
asked
to
express
their
personal
opinion
on
the
preservation
of
Kutai
National
Park
.
These
opinions
can
be
based
on
available
publication
materials
or
they
can
be
based
on
the
pupils
’
own
experience
and
aspirations
.
Football
matches
between
villages
.
These
matches
were
aimed
at
improving
the
current
communication
gap
between
company
management
and
community
members
.
These
matches
were
held
in
June
-
July
2001
.
Kutai
Cross
-
country
contes
t
.
Held
for
the
second
time
the
contest
was
sponsored
by
Mitra
Kutai
and
was
held
in
Sangkima
on
September
7
,
2001
.
105
teams
from
Bontang
,
Sangatta
,
Samarinda
,
and
Balikpapan
participated
in
the
contest
.
2
.
Promotional
Activities
Radio
Program
.
As
part
of
the
promotion
programs
,
it
was
broadcasted
through
a
“
blocking
time
”
contract
with
three
radio
stations
:
Radio
Suara
Khatulistiwa
FM
,
Radio
Nada
Bontang
Indah
(
Bontang
)
and
Radio
Gema
Wahana
Prima
in
Sangatta
.
This
was
an
interactive
radio
program
that
involved
listeners
in
discussions
on
various
environmental
issues
,
particularly
on
efforts
to
develop
and
preserve
Kutai
National
Park
Fliers
and
banners
.
Fliers
with
information
on
the
development
and
preservation
of
Kutai
National
Park
were
disseminated
.
Billboards
.
Two
billboards
were
put
up
in
front
of
Bontang
gas
station
and
in
Sangatta
-
PT
KPC
intersection
.
Kutai
National
Park
comic
book
.
Comic
books
were
produced
as
a
completion
of
a
promotional
training
program
organized
by
NRM
/
EPIQ
.
This
activity
was
held
in
Sangatta
’
s
elementary
schools
(
SD
)
.
Information
Board
and
Shelters
.
Construction
of
Information
Board
and
Sangkima
post
.
3
.
Volunteer
Program
The
volunteer
program
was
aimed
at
enhancing
the
capacity
of
the
human
resources
who
manage
Kutai
National
Park
and
at
improving
the
networking
with
national
and
international
institutions
.
Duration
of
the
volunteer
’
s
contract
is
from
January
2000
-
December
2002
.
4
.
Ecological
Studies
Post
Forest
Fires
Although
Kutai
National
Park
had
gone
through
two
major
forest
fires
in
1997
,
there
were
still
some
areas
considered
ecologically
significant
for
wildlife
habitats
.
Dr
.
Suzuki
from
Kyoto
University
’
s
research
institution
carried
out
studies
on
orangutan
’
s
habitat
and
behavior
.
5
.
Boys
/
Girls
Scouts
Activities
Boys
/
girls
scout
activities
through
Saka
Wana
Bakti
were
considered
quite
effective
in
introducing
Kutai
National
Park
.
Activities
include
participation
in
cross
country
contests
organized
by
Universitas
Mulawarman
and
camping
in
Pandan
Bay
.
6
.
Repair
of
car
donated
by
UNESCO
7
.
Outbound
Recreation
Establishment
of
outbound
facilities
in
Sangkima
for
nature
lovers
who
like
challenges
,
they
include
boardwalk
,
hanging
bridge
,
tree
house
,
shelter
,
etc
.
8
.
Educational
Aids
Media
on
education
is
considered
very
effective
in
establishing
positive
relationship
with
the
local
community
.
This
is
one
of
Mitra
Kutai
’
s
programs
that
directly
provide
benefits
to
the
community
.
9
.
Construction
of
Sangatta
Sub
-
section
Office
Was
first
initiated
through
the
proposed
allocation
of
funds
(
from
the
Reforestation
Fund
)
but
was
difficult
to
realize
under
the
present
economic
crisis
.
It
was
only
made
possible
after
PT
KPC
made
their
commitment
in
2000
to
lend
a
section
of
their
land
within
PT
KPC
’
s
office
area
to
be
used
by
Mitra
Kutai
.
10
.
Construction
of
an
Education
Center
The
center
was
built
close
to
the
area
where
Dr
.
Suzuki
’
s
is
doing
his
research
on
local
orangutan
.
The
prevab
area
will
be
proposed
to
become
a
center
for
tourism
education
.
The
center
was
also
built
with
boardwalk
and
wood
bridges
directed
toward
areas
where
orangutans
can
be
found
.
11
.
Nursery
and
Tree
Labelling
The
nursery
is
located
in
Sangkima
and
the
tree
labeling
is
done
in
Sangkima
and
Prevab
(
PT
KPC
’
commitment
in
2000
)
.
12
.
Security
Measures
Routine
and
joint
patrols
in
Kutai
National
park
areas
were
implemented
through
the
funding
from
Mitra
Kutai
in
addition
to
the
limited
Reforestation
funds
and
APBN
received
from
the
government
.
Security
measures
are
implemented
in
Tanjung
Limau
,
Sanggata
and
Menamang
.
13
.
Tourism
Development
in
Lombok
Bay
Implemented
as
a
single
project
by
Pertamina
and
was
planned
to
be
developed
as
an
ecotourism
area
open
to
the
general
public
in
the
future
.
14
.
Repair
of
Boardwalk
This
program
was
aimed
at
repairing
the
700
m
boardwalk
in
Sangkima
.
The
boardwalk
is
one
of
the
interesting
tourist
facilities
in
Sangkima
because
it
was
build
into
the
mixed
forests
found
in
Kutai
National
Park
.
On
the
trail
,
a
hanging
bridge
and
outbound
facilities
have
also
been
added
.
15
.
Prevention
and
Control
of
Forest
Fires
The
activity
is
carried
out
in
Pertamina
areas
that
are
susceptible
to
forest
fires
to
prevent
it
from
spreading
it
to
Kutai
National
Park
areas
.
16
.
Comparative
study
A
comparative
study
was
done
in
Lore
Lindu
National
Park
because
the
park
has
issues
and
characteristics
that
are
greatly
similar
with
those
found
in
Kutai
National
Park
.
17
.
Accommodation
and
Transportation
Provision
of
accommodation
and
transportation
to
various
NGOs
The
regular
Mitra
Kutai
meeting
that
was
held
on
February
27
,
2002
was
attended
by
PT
.
Pertamina
,
PT
.
Porodisa
,
PT
.
Badak
NGL
,
PT
.
KPC
,
Volunteer
Mitra
Kutai
,
Yayasan
Bikal
,
Balai
TNK
,
NRM
/
EPIQ
and
Kenari
(
Kelompok
Wana
Lestari
)
.
The
meeting
discussed
the
activities
and
budget
implemented
in
2001
and
planned
for
2002
.
Activities
in
2002
more
or
less
will
be
continuous
of
those
implemented
in
2001
.
Head
of
Mitra
Kutai
and
Balai
Taman
Nasional
Kutai
,
Ir
.
Luther
T
.
Papalangi
suggested
the
need
of
a
special
meeting
to
discuss
the
selection
of
a
team
to
audit
Mitra
’
s
finances
.
It
was
agreed
that
it
will
be
discussed
further
when
the
attendance
of
Mitra
Kutai
’
s
members
are
more
complete
.
Several
programs
planned
for
2001
were
not
completed
,
such
as
the
old
Sangatta
project
,
nursery
,
tree
labeling
and
studies
on
ecology
.
Mitra
Kutai
members
requested
to
be
informed
of
the
constraints
when
realizing
those
activities
.
From
the
2001
budget
there
still
remains
Rp
.
106
,
177
,
046
.
Conclusions
from
the
meeting
:
Mitra
Kutai
’
s
activities
that
are
small
-
scaled
will
be
implemented
by
Balai
TNK
,
and
the
large
-
scaled
ones
will
involve
the
participation
of
other
stakeholders
.
Identification
of
objectives
,
targets
and
good
planning
are
needed
to
determine
potential
stakeholders
that
will
be
involved
.
This
way
the
activities
can
be
implemented
in
a
participatory
manner
and
achieve
its
objectives
.
Members
should
be
prompt
in
submitting
funds
they
have
committed
to
contribute
for
Mitra
Kutai
.
Placement
of
logos
on
the
almanac
should
concur
with
the
amount
contributed
by
sponsors
.
There
is
a
need
to
produce
documentary
films
on
Kutai
National
Park
.
To
date
there
are
no
films
or
documented
audio
visual
on
Kutai
National
Park
.
These
films
will
be
useful
for
the
eco
-
tourism
and
Balai
Taman
Nasional
programs
.
These
films
will
also
be
of
a
great
assistance
to
the
environmental
awareness
campaign
and
education
programs
implemented
by
other
institutions
such
as
Kenari
(
Kelompok
Wana
lestari
)
and
girl
/
boys
scout
(
pramuka
)
programs
.
Annaliza
I
.
Chaniago
Outreach
&
Education
Assistant
NRM
/
EPIQ
Kalimantan
Timur
aliza
@
samarinda
.
org
Top
Story
No
.
5
:
Partnership
in
Conservation
for
Higher
Achievement
Partnership
in
implementing
conservation
campaign
programs
has
proven
to
be
very
beneficial
,
particularly
,
in
ensuring
the
internalization
of
these
campaigns
into
the
community
’
s
everyday
life
.
To
achieve
successful
partnership
,
it
is
important
to
establish
collaboration
with
existing
institutions
that
are
experienced
in
carrying
out
these
programs
.
In
April
2002
,
NRM
/
EPIQ
North
Sulawesi
developed
a
partnership
with
World
Wide
Fund
for
Nature
(
WWF
-
Wallacea
Bioregional
Program
)
,
Kantor
Balai
Taman
Nasional
(
TN
)
Bunaken
,
Dewan
Pengelola
TN
Bunaken
(
DPTNB
)
,
NSWA
(
North
Sulawesi
Watersport
Association
)
dan
Forum
Masyarakat
Peduli
TN
Bunaken
(
FMPTNB
)
in
organizing
Coral
Fiesta
a
series
of
campaign
activities
and
environmental
education
in
celebration
of
earth
day
.
The
program
was
aimed
at
developing
and
enhancing
the
community
’
s
awareness
on
the
importance
of
preserving
the
biodiversity
found
in
Bunaken
National
Park
and
surrounding
areas
.
The
essence
of
the
awareness
campaign
was
reflected
in
the
slogan
,
“
Kubuat
Bunaken
Lestari
”
(
Bunaken
shall
be
preserved
)
.
The
slogan
also
served
as
the
program
’
s
theme
and
provided
knowledge
and
information
on
how
the
community
can
actively
participate
in
conserving
Bunaken
National
Park
.
Centralized
in
Bunaken
,
the
program
that
was
aimed
for
SLTP
pupils
succeeded
in
attracting
160
pupils
from
Manado
and
from
the
schools
in
Bunaken
National
Park
to
participate
in
the
activity
.
The
four
activities
that
were
programmed
included
:
beach
clean
-
up
,
observation
of
coral
reefs
from
a
katamaran
,
drawing
contest
and
reef
check
.
An
interesting
point
to
note
was
that
most
of
the
pupils
who
participated
in
the
activities
had
never
seen
coral
reefs
before
.
This
also
applied
to
those
who
live
in
the
vicinity
of
Bunaken
National
Park
.
The
expression
“
Seeing
is
believing
”
becomes
critical
.
A
campaign
will
only
be
considered
successful
when
the
target
group
believes
in
the
campaign
message
.
One
of
the
activities
that
need
to
be
considered
when
carrying
out
the
campaign
to
save
coral
reefs
is
to
present
and
introduce
underwater
life
to
the
target
group
.
This
is
to
make
the
target
group
become
aware
of
the
existence
of
underwater
life
and
realize
how
this
underwater
life
can
affect
and
be
affected
by
them
.
Transfer
of
information
implemented
in
the
form
of
enter
-
education
is
applicable
to
children
.
In
a
fun
and
entertaining
atmosphere
these
children
learn
and
do
new
things
that
will
remain
forever
in
their
minds
.
Sri
Hardiyanti
Gunadi
Outreach
Specialist
NRM
/
EPIQ
Sulut
gyanti
@
nrm
.
or
.
id
Top
Story
No
.
6
:
Update
Kerinci
Seblat
National
Park
website
Jeremy
Holden
(
FFI
)
totally
revised
the
Kerinci
website
at
http
:
//
www
.
kerinci
.
org
/
Lots
of
new
photographs
have
been
added
too
.
Jeremy
would
welcome
feedback
of
readers
at
pop
@
padang
.
wasantara
.
net
.
id
CONTENTS
Whats
New
-
Frogs
in
Kerinci
-
4
Governors
dan
9
Bupatis
Declarated
their
Commitment
to
KSNP
-
Profile
of
Pangkalan
Jambu
village
Adat
Forest
-
Closure
the
mining
and
forest
concession
activies
in
KSNP
and
surrounding
area
-
How
I
can
help
KSNP
?
Visiting
Kerinci
Geography
Park
Maps
Flora
and
Fauna
Threats
Milestones
Research
ICDP
Project
Park
Management
Other
Documents
FAQ
[
Courtesy
of
the
Indonesian
Nature
Conservation
List
]
Top
Story
No
.
7
:
Britain
and
Indonesia
Sign
Agreement
to
Combat
Illegal
Timber
Trade
Associated
Press
April
18
,
2002
LONDON
-
Britain
and
Indonesia
signed
an
agreement
Thursday
to
take
joint
action
to
combat
the
trade
in
illegal
timber
products
between
the
two
countries
.
The
deal
commits
Britain
to
revising
its
current
laws
with
a
view
to
eliminating
imports
of
timber
from
illegal
sources
and
obliges
Indonesia
to
open
its
forestry
sector
to
closer
independent
scrutiny
.
Environmental
groups
estimate
that
60
percent
of
Britain
'
s
tropical
timber
imports
are
from
illegal
sources
,
representing
almost
150
million
pounds
(
dlrs
210
million
)
worth
of
stolen
timber
.
They
believe
the
agreement
signed
in
London
by
British
Environment
Minister
Michael
Meacher
and
Indonesian
Minister
of
Forestry
Dr
.
Muhammad
Prakosa
is
vital
to
prevent
the
disappearance
of
tropical
forests
within
five
to
10
years
.
Friends
of
the
Earth
(
news
-
web
sites
)
forest
campaigner
,
Ed
Matthew
,
said
more
than
70
percent
of
logging
in
Indonesia
was
illegal
and
the
contract
should
help
.
"
For
the
first
time
the
U
.
K
.
(
United
Kingdom
)
government
has
sat
down
with
a
country
exporting
large
quantities
of
timber
and
agreed
on
joint
action
to
stop
illegal
exports
and
the
destruction
of
primary
forests
,
"
Matthew
said
.
"
We
hope
this
deal
will
be
the
first
of
many
.
We
will
be
watching
the
U
.
K
.
and
Indonesian
governments
like
hawks
to
make
sure
it
is
fully
put
into
practice
.
"
Environmental
groups
have
lobbied
for
changes
for
some
time
and
have
also
campaigned
against
British
companies
who
invest
and
trade
in
Indonesian
forest
corporations
.
A
previous
Friends
of
the
Earth
campaign
in
1999
led
to
the
British
government
changing
its
timber
-
buying
policy
,
after
it
was
discovered
that
the
Ministry
of
Defense
purchased
Brazilian
(
news
-
web
sites
)
mahogany
for
paneling
warships
from
illegal
sources
.
Submitted
by
:
Timothy
H
.
Brown
Natural
Resource
Economics
Policy
Advisor
NRM
/
EPIQ
Program
Jakarta
brownth
@
nrm
.
or
.
id
Top
Story
No
.
8
:
All
Wood
Used
by
KIMPRASWIL
for
the
Construction
of
Temporary
Housing
in
Poso
,
Central
Sulawesi
,
Known
to
be
Illegal
PRESS
RELEASE
Palu
,
April
17
2002
Ways
of
relieving
the
burden
of
community
victims
in
the
town
of
Poso
,
Central
Sulawesi
,
as
a
result
of
disturbances
that
occurred
some
time
ago
,
should
continue
to
be
encouraged
.
Assistance
to
rebuild
the
town
is
currently
being
given
by
the
government
,
a
circle
of
NGO
’
s
,
and
other
parties
that
care
about
Poso
.
It
is
regrettable
,
therefore
,
that
the
construction
of
temporary
housing
,
being
carried
out
by
KIMPRASWIL
on
behalf
of
community
members
who
have
lost
homes
as
a
result
of
the
conflict
,
relies
on
the
use
of
supplies
of
illegal
wood
.
According
to
the
Head
of
the
Forestry
Department
,
Poso
District
Branch
(
Bapak
Ir
.
Dieng
)
,
‘
I
do
not
know
the
origin
of
all
the
wood
that
is
used
for
repairing
houses
of
worship
and
the
construction
of
temporary
housing
in
Poso
,
because
there
is
no
information
in
our
notes
about
the
woods
mentioned
,
and
at
this
moment
…
there
are
not
yet
any
documents
for
the
wood
that
has
been
felled
’
.
Additionally
,
if
we
uphold
the
law
specifically
in
the
area
of
forestry
,
which
changes
our
role
to
one
of
safekeeping
and
the
protection
of
State
assets
,
then
the
woods
identified
can
be
said
to
be
illegal
,
and
it
is
certain
that
the
regional
government
is
suffering
from
a
financial
loss
.
This
issue
needs
to
be
raised
,
otherwise
,
there
are
parties
which
are
will
profit
from
means
of
giving
help
to
community
victims
in
Poso
.
Team
YAKIS
,
which
continues
to
make
serious
efforts
to
inform
about
illegal
logging
activities
specifically
in
the
Central
Sulawesi
region
,
considers
it
very
regrettable
that
the
woods
used
for
constructing
temporary
housing
in
Poso
do
not
possess
legal
documentation
.
YAKIS
does
not
question
the
help
given
to
the
communities
,
on
the
contrary
,
YAKIS
very
much
supports
and
welcomes
the
assistance
given
by
the
government
and
NGO
’
s
to
victims
of
the
disturbance
in
Poso
.
From
the
results
of
an
investigation
carried
out
by
a
team
from
YAKIS
on
4
April
2002
,
it
is
known
that
there
are
no
notes
or
information
at
the
Forestry
Department
(
Poso
Branch
)
about
the
wood
,
which
means
that
it
is
not
accompanied
by
an
official
letter
,
and
in
other
words
,
is
illegal
.
If
the
wood
mentioned
is
without
documentation
,
i
.
e
.
is
illegal
,
then
PEMDA
(
Pemerintah
Daerah
,
Regional
Government
)
loses
regional
income
(
Pendapatan
Asli
Daerah
)
from
the
activity
.
If
we
assume
that
the
levy
from
transportation
of
wood
is
around
Rp
150
,
000
*
per
cubic
metre
,
and
the
quantity
of
wood
involved
is
around
100
cubic
metres
,
then
the
amount
which
should
be
received
by
the
State
Forestry
Department
is
around
15
million
rupiahs
.
Investigations
carried
out
by
YAKIS
in
some
villages
in
Poso
,
have
revealed
that
the
community
already
harvests
wood
from
village
forests
around
Poso
,
as
they
have
received
an
order
from
the
project
implementer
.
For
this
,
YAKIS
does
not
blame
the
community
as
we
are
certain
that
when
no
specific
orders
exist
,
the
community
does
not
want
to
harvest
wood
.
One
thing
which
YAKIS
very
much
regrets
is
that
there
are
still
officials
who
seek
to
make
as
large
a
profit
as
possible
from
the
situation
.
This
means
that
if
wood
is
purchased
in
a
legal
manner
,
the
price
of
wood
(
such
as
that
referred
to
in
this
proposal
)
rises
;
when
the
project
implementers
take
short
cuts
,
they
can
buy
directly
from
the
community
at
a
lower
cost
.
Also
in
need
of
attention
,
is
the
planning
of
the
reconstruction
program
itself
;
this
program
is
one
which
damages
forests
and
the
environment
,
and
inflicts
a
financial
loss
on
local
government
.
It
benefits
the
parties
that
take
wood
,
the
wood
‘
mafia
’
,
and
those
parties
engaged
in
illegal
practices
.
When
there
are
practices
like
this
,
only
one
thing
is
certain
,
and
that
is
that
some
parties
profit
.
*
1
$
USD
=
approx
.
Rp
10
,
000
Written
by
:
Alimuddin
Paada
,
Musadat
,
Amin
Panto
.
English
translation
by
:
Lisa
Owen
Yayasan
Katopasa
Indonesia
Jl
.
Gunung
Loli
No
.
2
Palu
,
Sulteng
94112
Tel
/
Fax
:
0451
423752
Katopasa
@
palu
.
wasantara
.
net
.
id
Top
Story
No
.
9
:
Illegal
Fishing
at
Alarming
Level
Source
:
Jakarta
Post
,
April
17
,
2002
YOGYAKARTA
Minister
of
Maritime
Affairs
and
Fisheries
Rokhmin
Dahuri
said
here
on
Monday
the
alarming
level
of
illegal
fishing
practices
here
in
Indonesian
waters
had
discouraged
cooperation
with
neighboring
countries
.
Due
to
the
rampant
illegal
fishing
in
the
Exclusive
Economic
Zone
(
EEZ
)
,
only
two
out
of
six
countries
invited
to
cooperate
were
willing
to
sign
maritime
economic
agreements
with
Indonesia
.
The
two
countries
were
China
and
the
Philippines
,
while
the
four
others
refusing
to
sign
an
agreement
were
Thailand
,
Japan
,
South
Korea
,
and
Taiwan
.
"
It
makes
sense
that
they
refuse
to
sign
such
an
agreement
because
even
without
doing
so
they
can
still
fish
here
,
can
'
t
they
?
So
why
should
they
bother
,
"
Dahuri
said
.
Quoting
FAO
data
in
2001
,
Dahuri
said
that
the
total
amount
of
fish
catches
taken
through
illegal
fishing
practices
in
Indonesia
reached
over
1
.
5
million
of
tons
a
year
.
According
to
Dahuri
,
this
was
made
possible
due
to
a
deregulation
issued
by
the
Ministry
of
Agriculture
in
1996
.
The
deregulation
was
initially
aimed
at
empowering
domestic
fishermen
.
To
prevent
illegal
fishing
,
several
techniques
have
been
adopted
,
including
the
strengthening
of
the
national
marine
fleet
,
law
enforcement
and
fishing
control
and
implementation
of
strict
fishing
licenses
for
foreign
fishing
vessels
.
The
fishery
sector
and
its
processing
industry
contributed
9
.
7
percent
to
the
national
gross
domestic
income
(
PDB
)
or
Rp
38
.
6
billion
in
2001
.
[
Courtesy
of
the
Indonesian
Nature
Conservation
List
]
Top
Story
No
.
10
:
Illegal
Logging
Troubles
Plywood
Industry
Source
:
Jakarta
Post
,
April
17
,
2002
By
Adianto
P
.
Simamora
Jakarta
The
Indonesian
Plywood
Association
(
Apkindo
)
said
rampant
illegal
logging
had
created
serious
difficulties
for
the
country
'
s
plywood
industry
with
many
companies
going
out
of
business
during
the
past
couple
of
years
.
Apkindo
chairman
Martias
said
on
Tuesday
that
the
logs
had
been
smuggled
out
of
the
country
particularly
to
Malaysia
and
China
allowing
plywood
companies
there
to
enjoy
lower
production
costs
because
the
cheaper
illegal
logs
were
not
burdened
with
forestry
-
related
charges
.
"
Around
one
third
of
115
local
plywood
factories
have
closed
their
operations
mainly
due
to
the
rampant
illegal
logging
,
"
he
told
reporters
on
the
sidelines
of
a
seminar
.
He
warned
that
without
immediate
action
to
curb
illegal
logging
,
more
plywood
companies
would
go
bankrupt
.
He
said
that
domestic
plywood
companies
had
been
losing
the
market
share
at
home
because
overseas
plywood
makers
were
flooding
the
home
market
with
cheaper
plywood
made
from
Indonesian
logs
.
"
Imported
(
plywood
)
products
now
control
60
percent
of
domestic
market
,
"
he
said
.
He
added
that
the
influx
of
cheaper
imported
products
from
Malaysia
and
China
had
put
a
pressure
on
the
price
,
now
hovering
at
around
US
$
200
per
cubic
meter
.
The
international
plywood
price
now
stands
at
about
$
250
per
cubic
meters
.
Martias
also
said
that
the
country
'
s
plywood
exports
had
declined
to
6
million
cubic
meters
last
year
from
8
million
in
1997
.
"
China
has
became
one
of
the
plywood
exporters
to
Indonesia
by
using
logs
illegally
purchased
in
this
country
,
"
Martias
said
.
China
in
the
past
imported
around
1
.
1
million
cubic
meters
of
Indonesian
plywood
per
year
.
Illegal
logs
procured
by
China
are
believed
to
come
from
Jambi
and
Riau
provinces
,
while
those
going
to
Malaysia
come
from
East
Kalimantan
and
West
Kalimantan
.
According
to
one
estimate
,
illegal
logs
sold
to
Malaysia
and
China
reached
300
,
000
cubic
meters
per
year
.
Director
General
of
Foreign
Affairs
at
the
Ministry
of
Trade
and
Industry
Sudar
SA
said
last
week
that
the
government
was
planning
to
impose
a
permanent
ban
on
log
export
to
protect
forest
resources
.
The
government
eased
restrictions
on
log
exports
in
1998
by
slashing
export
tax
from
200
percent
to
10
percent
as
part
of
an
agreement
with
the
International
Monetary
Fund
.
The
policy
prompted
logging
companies
to
sell
logs
overseas
to
obtain
hard
currency
.
Analysts
said
that
in
addition
to
the
illegal
logging
activity
,
the
plywood
industry
has
also
been
hit
by
the
global
economic
slowdown
and
the
lack
of
funding
from
domestic
banks
to
provide
working
capital
particularly
to
replace
old
machinery
.
Martias
admitted
that
the
lack
of
bank
loans
and
security
disturbances
in
certain
areas
had
been
a
problem
.
"
The
increase
in
fuel
prices
,
electricity
rates
and
the
regional
minimum
wage
has
also
hampered
the
development
of
plywood
industry
,
"
he
said
.
[
Courtesy
of
the
Indonesian
Nature
Conservation
List
]
Top
Story
No
.
11
:
NGOs
Join
Forces
in
Forest
Management
Source
:
Jakarta
Post
,
April
20
,
2002
By
Hyginus
Hardoyo
Jakarta
British
and
Indonesian
non
-
governmental
organizations
(
NGOs
)
dealing
with
forestry
issues
have
underlined
the
importance
of
promoting
the
sustainable
and
equitable
management
of
Indonesia
'
s
forests
.
Liz
Chidley
of
the
London
-
based
Down
to
Earth
(
DTE
)
,
an
international
organization
campaigning
for
ecological
justice
in
Indonesia
,
said
on
Friday
that
NGOs
in
the
UK
fully
supported
their
Indonesian
counterparts
in
urging
the
Indonesian
and
UK
governments
to
take
further
action
to
promote
the
sustainable
and
equitable
management
of
forests
in
Indonesia
.
Chidley
made
the
remarks
in
response
to
the
signing
of
a
memorandum
of
understanding
(
MOU
)
by
Indonesia
and
the
UK
on
the
protection
of
tropical
rainforests
.
The
MOU
was
signed
by
Indonesian
Minister
of
Forestry
M
.
Prakosa
and
the
undersecretary
of
the
UK
Department
for
International
Development
,
Hilary
Benn
,
in
London
on
Friday
.
The
MOU
sets
out
how
the
two
countries
will
cooperate
on
forest
law
enforcement
and
governance
to
combat
illegal
logging
and
the
international
trade
in
illegally
felled
timber
and
wood
products
.
Chidley
said
her
organization
welcomed
the
signing
of
the
agreement
,
but
urged
the
Indonesian
government
to
recognize
the
rights
of
forest
dwellers
as
part
of
the
effort
to
help
save
the
country
'
s
disappearing
forests
.
The
goal
is
sustainable
forest
management
and
better
lives
for
forest
people
,
she
said
.
Forest
dwellers
are
still
being
evicted
from
their
land
to
make
way
for
logging
,
plantations
and
mines
backed
by
foreign
capital
,
including
British
companies
,
she
said
in
a
statement
made
available
to
The
Jakarta
Post
.
DTE
hopes
the
agreement
will
be
a
fist
step
toward
more
fundamental
reforms
to
stop
forest
destruction
--
legal
and
illegal
--
and
to
prevent
community
rights
violations
,
Chidley
said
.
"
We
feel
strongly
that
the
British
companies
should
be
held
accountable
for
their
involvement
in
operations
in
Indonesia
,
which
lead
to
gross
human
rights
violations
against
indigenous
peoples
and
other
marginalized
communities
who
depend
on
forest
resources
for
their
livelihoods
,
"
she
said
.
Chidley
said
her
organization
signed
a
joint
statement
by
UK
NGOs
handed
to
Minister
of
Forestry
M
.
Prakosa
,
which
called
for
the
recognition
of
forest
-
dependent
communities
'
rights
,
action
on
corruption
and
corporate
accountability
.
Hapsoro
of
Telapak
Indonesia
,
an
Indonesian
NGO
,
said
non
-
governmental
organizations
were
seriously
concerned
about
the
level
of
destruction
and
degradation
of
forest
resources
,
caused
by
misguided
forest
management
policies
over
many
years
.
Such
policies
have
resulted
in
massive
forest
destruction
and
have
negatively
affected
the
livelihoods
of
millions
of
local
people
and
indigenous
communities
living
in
forest
areas
,
he
said
.
The
failure
to
govern
forests
properly
and
the
corrupt
forest
management
have
led
to
high
levels
of
demand
for
timber
,
triggering
uncontrolled
logging
and
the
large
-
scale
conversion
of
natural
forests
,
according
to
a
joint
statement
by
Indonesian
NGOs
,
including
Walhi
and
the
Friends
of
the
Earth
Indonesia
.
The
destruction
of
the
forests
and
the
resulting
ecological
imbalances
are
manifest
in
various
natural
disasters
throughout
Indonesia
,
such
as
forest
fires
,
floods
and
landslides
.
Furthermore
,
forestry
operations
continue
to
use
violence
and
intimidation
against
forest
dwellers
.
[
Courtesy
of
the
Indonesian
Nature
Conservation
List
]
Top
Story
No
.
12
:
Gorontalo
Governor
Urged
to
Preserve
Ecosystem
of
Togean
Islands
Source
:
Tempo
,
April
19
,
2002
Palu
Several
environmental
organizations
in
Sulawesi
have
urged
Gorontalo
governor
Fadel
Muhammad
to
prioritize
the
preservation
of
Togean
islands
'
marine
ecosystem
in
carrying
out
the
Tomini
mega
-
project
.
"
We
ask
the
governor
not
to
exploit
Tomini
Bay
for
his
project
,
"
said
Sudirman
Suhdi
,
the
director
of
Civil
Society
non
-
governmental
organization
(
NGO
)
,
in
Palu
on
Friday
(
19
/
4
)
.
According
to
Suhdi
,
the
governor
’
s
measure
to
develop
the
marine
sector
for
business
should
be
welcomed
by
everyone
.
However
,
problems
could
occur
as
a
result
of
the
Tomini
project
if
the
governor
fails
to
pay
attention
on
the
ecosystem
of
Togean
islands
.
"
We
’
re
prepared
to
face
the
governor
if
the
islands
are
destroyed
by
the
project
,
"
Suhdi
said
.
Rijal
,
member
of
Palu
Ntodea
NGO
,
also
made
a
similar
comment
on
this
matter
.
According
to
him
,
the
biodiversity
in
the
Togean
islands
should
be
preserved
.
Rijal
is
worried
that
the
Rp
1
-
trillion
Tomini
project
could
destroy
the
ecosystem
of
the
Togean
islands
and
warned
the
governor
to
be
very
careful
in
developing
the
Tomini
Bay
.
[
Courtesy
of
the
Indonesian
Nature
Conservation
List
]
Top
Story
No
.
13
:
Sustainable
Development
Meeting
Planned
in
Bali
Source
:
Jakarta
Post
,
April
24
,
2002
By
Rita
A
.
Widiadana
Nusa
Dua
Indonesia
will
host
a
ministerial
-
level
gathering
of
the
Preparatory
Committee
Meeting
of
the
World
Summit
on
Sustainable
Development
next
month
,
with
United
Nations
officials
praising
arrangements
for
the
event
.
JoAnne
DiSano
,
the
director
of
the
United
Nations
division
for
sustainable
development
,
told
journalists
here
on
Tuesday
a
UN
team
was
satisfied
with
accommodations
for
the
as
many
as
6
,
000
delegates
from
189
countries
who
are
expected
to
attend
the
gathering
at
the
Bali
International
Convention
Center
(
BICC
)
in
Nusa
Dua
from
May
27
through
June
7
.
The
Bali
meeting
will
precede
the
World
Summit
on
Sustainable
Development
in
Johannesburg
,
South
Africa
,
from
Aug
.
26
to
Sept
.
4
.
The
aim
of
the
summit
is
to
review
how
far
governments
have
come
in
promoting
sustainable
development
,
and
to
seek
measures
to
deal
with
development
-
related
issues
such
as
poverty
,
communal
diseases
and
environmental
destruction
.
"
The
ministerial
-
level
meeting
in
Bali
will
be
very
important
.
It
is
not
meant
to
be
a
talkfest
but
an
action
-
oriented
meeting
which
is
expected
to
yield
political
declarations
,
action
agenda
and
partnership
documentation
,
"
said
DiSano
.
She
also
revealed
that
it
was
not
merely
a
meeting
on
the
environment
,
but
an
integrated
meeting
that
would
deal
with
economic
,
social
and
environmental
issues
.
Bali
,
as
the
host
of
the
international
gathering
,
is
expected
to
reap
both
short
and
long
-
term
benefits
from
the
meeting
.
"
Bali
is
a
proper
place
for
the
meeting
,
where
delegates
can
concentrate
in
a
leisurely
atmosphere
.
They
can
also
learn
about
different
cultures
and
religions
,
"
she
added
.
Jakarta
was
initially
tapped
to
host
the
meeting
,
but
the
venue
was
changed
three
months
ago
,
with
some
sources
citing
security
concerns
as
the
reason
.
Former
minister
Erna
Witoelar
,
who
will
head
Indonesia
'
s
National
Committee
at
the
event
,
admitted
that
it
was
a
challenge
to
make
all
the
necessary
preparations
given
the
sudden
change
in
venue
.
"
We
have
been
involving
the
Bali
provincial
government
and
the
National
Police
,
especially
when
it
comes
to
security
matters
,
"
she
explained
.
"
I
hope
that
the
meeting
will
boost
the
image
of
Indonesia
in
the
international
community
,
"
Erna
added
.
According
to
the
former
minister
,
the
Indonesian
delegation
will
raise
the
issue
of
debt
forgiveness
,
poverty
alleviation
and
the
transfer
of
technology
during
the
gathering
.
[
Courtesy
of
the
Indonesian
Nature
Conservation
List
]
Top
Story
No
.
14
:
Governor
Lashes
Out
at
Illegal
Logging
Source
:
Jakarta
Post
,
April
24
,
2002
Jakarta
Jambi
Governor
Zulkiffli
Nurdin
has
hit
out
at
rife
illegal
logging
in
the
Kerinci
Seblat
National
Reserve
,
home
to
large
numbers
of
rare
species
of
flora
and
fauna
.
"
Many
reports
have
reached
me
that
almost
every
night
,
some
30
logging
trucks
transport
logs
out
of
the
protected
reserve
,
"
he
said
when
opening
a
bridge
project
in
Muaro
Madrasah
Village
,
Jangkat
Regency
,
Jambi
on
Tuesday
.
He
called
on
the
provincial
police
and
local
military
to
immediately
take
stern
action
to
stop
the
logging
.
The
national
reserve
,
covering
1
.
48
million
hectares
in
Jambi
,
South
Sumatra
,
Bengkulu
and
West
Sumatra
,
contains
millions
of
hectares
of
virgin
rainforest
,
rare
and
protected
species
such
as
elephants
,
rhinoceros
,
tapirs
,
tigers
,
sun
bears
and
clouded
leopards
.
Besides
the
wild
animals
and
the
beautiful
scenery
,
which
includes
Lake
Kerinci
and
Mount
Kerinci
,
the
park
has
many
rare
botanical
species
.
A
number
of
international
institutions
and
foundations
have
donated
resources
to
help
the
government
manage
the
reserve
.
Zulkiffli
reiterated
that
the
four
provinces
had
long
agreed
to
enhance
cooperation
to
preserve
the
park
.
"
The
local
forestry
offices
and
security
authorities
in
the
four
provinces
must
take
strict
action
against
all
sides
who
are
involved
in
the
illegal
logging
,
"
he
said
.
He
warned
that
donor
countries
could
stop
their
donations
if
the
environmental
deterioration
at
the
park
continued
.
He
called
on
security
authorities
to
crack
down
on
the
mushrooming
sawmills
operating
near
the
national
park
which
were
believed
to
process
logs
looted
from
the
protected
forest
.
"
The
presence
of
sawmills
near
the
national
park
is
an
indication
that
they
get
their
raw
materials
from
the
park
,
"
he
said
.
The
Jambi
Provincial
Police
have
confiscated
hundreds
of
cubic
meters
of
illegal
logs
from
a
number
of
sawmills
while
the
owners
have
been
arrested
for
further
investigation
.
[
Courtesy
of
the
Indonesian
Nature
Conservation
List
]
Top
Story
No
.
15
:
Former
Minister
Emil
Salim
,
a
Champion
of
the
Environment
Source
:
Jakarta
Post
,
April
27
,
2002
By
Mehru
Jaffer
Jakarta
He
dreams
of
the
day
when
industry
will
be
agro
-
based
,
tourism
will
enrich
the
ecology
and
the
harvest
of
development
will
benefit
the
maximum
number
of
people
,
instead
of
just
a
small
minority
.
He
gives
the
example
of
a
rainforest
where
life
is
rich
only
because
every
creature
,
from
the
tiniest
to
the
mightiest
,
depends
for
its
survival
upon
each
other
.
He
terms
diversity
as
the
strength
of
the
ecological
system
,
adding
that
this
is
true
of
human
society
as
well
.
"
The
more
diverse
a
society
is
,
the
stronger
it
is
.
It
is
very
important
to
recognize
diversity
and
the
inter
-
dependency
of
each
one
of
us
on
the
other
,
"
the
bird
-
like
Professor
told
The
Jakarta
Post
before
flying
off
to
Brazil
for
yet
another
meeting
on
sustainable
development
.
As
the
spirit
behind
the
Indonesian
Biodiversity
Foundation
and
the
Indonesian
Ecolabeling
Institute
,
Salim
is
trying
to
get
countries
rich
in
rainforests
like
Indonesia
,
Brazil
and
Zaire
to
come
together
under
the
umbrella
of
an
international
organization
similar
to
OPEC
.
Out
of
the
"
Unity
in
diversity
"
slogan
coined
by
the
country
'
s
founding
fathers
,
unity
is
stressed
all
the
time
but
the
benefits
of
diversity
are
still
to
be
recognized
here
,
he
says
,
adding
that
he
likes
the
idea
of
a
thousand
flowers
always
in
bloom
,
everywhere
.
The
most
pertinent
question
before
Indonesians
today
is
how
to
live
peacefully
with
each
other
in
diversity
?
A
homogenized
world
is
a
colorless
one
as
far
as
Salim
is
concerned
,
because
different
languages
,
food
and
clothes
make
life
not
just
interesting
but
also
give
strength
to
a
society
.
As
a
champion
of
the
environment
,
he
is
not
against
development
.
It
is
possible
to
be
prosperous
without
damaging
the
environment
.
He
is
saddened
to
watch
the
destruction
of
the
environment
when
there
is
no
need
for
such
thoughtless
cruelty
.
This
is
happening
as
the
greed
of
ignorant
people
is
being
allowed
to
walk
all
over
the
basic
needs
of
the
world
.
He
is
against
an
export
-
based
economy
where
a
country
is
stripped
of
all
its
wealth
in
raw
materials
.
Instead
of
logging
the
forest
and
selling
wood
he
would
like
to
see
medicine
made
from
the
bark
of
the
relevant
tree
and
exported
.
"
Make
cosmetics
out
of
fish
oil
and
sell
the
finished
product
instead
of
emptying
the
waters
of
all
the
fish
,
"
he
explains
.
Nearly
four
decades
ago
when
most
other
developing
countries
like
India
,
Iran
and
Turkey
were
into
heavy
industries
,
Indonesia
decided
to
modernize
its
agriculture
.
The
country
was
self
sufficient
in
rice
by
1983
and
only
then
opened
its
economy
to
industry
.
At
that
time
,
policy
-
makers
like
Emil
Salim
were
determined
not
to
repeat
the
mistakes
made
by
countries
that
had
industrialized
.
Despite
lessons
in
pollution
control
,
Indonesia
'
s
population
and
consumption
are
increasing
,
deforestation
is
rapid
and
fresh
water
supplies
are
continuing
to
diminish
.
Indonesia
is
a
country
rich
in
biodiversity
with
10
percent
of
the
world
'
s
flowering
species
,
12
percent
of
all
mammal
species
and
about
47
distinct
ecosystems
.
But
today
,
the
country
has
the
longest
list
of
endangered
flora
and
fauna
species
and
is
facing
a
serious
depletion
of
its
biodiversity
,
due
to
the
overexploitation
of
natural
resources
and
inappropriate
agricultural
policies
.
When
asked
how
the
country
got
into
this
mess
,
Salim
,
the
environment
minister
between
1978
and
1993
,
points
out
that
the
environment
is
still
treated
as
an
ad
hoc
issue
both
by
national
,
as
well
as
international
financial
institutions
.
Open
market
moguls
and
politicians
on
the
lookout
for
quick
returns
consider
fresh
air
,
beautiful
landscape
and
thick
forests
as
free
commodities
,
which
belong
to
no
one
and
are
therefore
worthless
.
There
is
no
immediate
profit
in
taking
care
of
the
environment
.
So
forests
have
vanished
at
an
estimated
rate
of
three
million
hectares
a
year
,
the
highest
deforestation
rate
in
the
world
.
Air
pollution
caused
by
automobiles
continue
to
emit
lead
pollution
at
1
.
3
micrograms
per
cubic
meter
in
Jakarta
,
above
the
World
Health
Organization
'
s
(
WHO
)
limit
of
between
0
.
5
and
1
.
0
micrograms
per
cubic
meter
.
Water
pollution
is
yet
another
serious
problem
as
the
South
China
Sea
is
one
of
the
world
'
s
busiest
international
sea
-
lanes
with
more
than
half
of
the
world
'
s
supertanker
traffic
passing
through
the
region
'
s
waters
.
Industry
has
polluted
water
and
,
together
with
the
increase
in
population
and
decrease
in
fresh
water
supplies
,
has
placed
great
stress
on
people
and
the
environment
.
The
main
constraint
in
the
implementation
of
sustainable
development
in
Indonesia
has
always
been
the
lack
of
accountability
and
good
governance
.
So
much
forest
is
felled
and
intentionally
set
on
fire
,
yet
nobody
is
held
responsible
.
Even
timber
tycoon
Bob
Hasan
was
not
jailed
for
destroying
the
forest
,
but
for
other
crimes
he
committed
.
What
the
people
in
power
must
do
is
enforce
the
rule
of
law
.
The
existing
laws
are
very
sound
but
they
have
to
be
implemented
.
Otherwise
,
Salim
says
,
environmental
concerns
will
continue
to
be
treated
merely
as
jargon
.
Salim
suggests
a
more
holistic
approach
to
policy
-
making
where
no
ministry
is
considered
more
powerful
than
the
other
and
the
opinion
of
civilians
and
non
-
governmental
organizations
are
included
in
the
decision
-
making
process
.
Salim
was
selected
by
former
president
Soeharto
as
an
advisor
in
the
1960s
,
along
with
a
group
of
mostly
American
educated
technocrats
,
dubbed
"
the
Berkeley
mafia
"
.
He
fell
out
with
Soeharto
in
1993
when
the
more
high
-
tech
ideas
and
macro
approach
of
B
.
J
.
Habibie
was
favored
over
the
bio
,
and
agro
-
based
,
micro
-
level
concerns
of
Salim
.
[
Courtesy
of
the
Indonesian
Nature
Conservation
List
]
Top
Story
No
.
16
:
Indonesian
Public
Policy
Forum
(
Reminder
)
Introduction
To
encourage
high
-
quality
contributions
to
Indonesia
’
s
ongoing
public
policy
debate
,
the
Forum
will
award
a
CAD
$
10
,
000
prize
to
the
author
of
the
best
Policy
Brief
received
from
a
citizen
of
Indonesia
during
the
period
January
15
th
to
June
30
th
2002
.
The
process
begins
with
a
public
-
spirited
Indonesian
citizen
who
has
identified
a
major
public
policy
issue
and
who
,
through
rigorous
analysis
,
has
formulated
ideas
on
how
the
issue
can
be
addressed
.
The
issue
,
the
analysis
and
the
proposed
solution
can
be
expressed
in
the
form
of
a
Policy
Brief
.
The
Policy
Brief
is
then
submitted
to
the
Public
Policy
Forum
Steering
Committee
(
the
Committee
)
who
will
select
the
recipient
of
the
Hickling
Public
Policy
Award
for
best
Policy
Brief
received
between
January
15th
and
June
30th
2002
.
The
winning
submission
will
be
announced
on
July
31st
2002
.
The
author
of
the
winning
submission
,
as
well
as
the
runners
up
,
will
be
invited
to
participate
in
an
Indonesian
Public
Policy
Symposium
to
be
held
in
September
2002
.
Members
of
the
Indonesian
Public
Policy
Forum
Steering
Committee
include
:
Chair
:
Mr
.
Ferry
de
Kerckhove
,
Ambassador
of
Canada
to
Indonesia
Vice
Chair
:
Professor
Dr
.
Djunaedi
Hadisumarto
,
University
of
Indonesia
Members
:
Dr
.
Umar
Juoro
,
Senior
Fellow
,
Habibie
Center
Professor
Dr
.
T
.
Omas
Ihromi
,
University
of
Indonesia
Dr
.
David
Deziel
,
Chairman
,
Hickling
Eligibility
This
competition
is
open
to
all
citizens
of
Indonesia
.
Submissions
should
consist
of
original
work
by
the
authors
that
has
not
been
published
elsewhere
,
in
whole
or
in
part
,
nor
submitted
for
consideration
for
publication
elsewhere
.
Group
authorship
is
permitted
,
provided
that
all
authors
are
Indonesian
citizens
.
Not
more
than
three
(
3
)
persons
should
be
included
as
authors
of
a
single
Policy
Brief
.
Institutional
or
corporate
contributions
are
not
eligible
.
The
Award
The
Award
is
made
available
through
PT
Hickling
Indonesia
,
which
is
the
Indonesian
subsidiary
of
Hickling
Corporation
Canada
.
Both
firms
specialize
in
public
policy
and
management
.
The
Award
will
be
paid
directly
to
the
recipient
by
PT
Hickling
Indonesia
and
may
be
subject
to
tax
in
accordance
with
Indonesian
tax
regulations
in
effect
at
the
time
of
payment
.
Policy
Brief
Guidelines
The
Policy
Brief
should
provide
a
description
of
the
issue
,
e
.
g
.
some
matter
on
which
a
new
or
revised
public
policy
is
needed
.
Any
assumptions
should
be
stated
,
and
available
policy
options
should
be
identified
and
explained
.
The
analysis
should
outline
the
implications
of
each
policy
option
in
terms
of
its
impact
in
general
and
on
various
stakeholders
in
particular
.
The
author
should
recommend
a
preferred
policy
option
and
explain
the
basis
for
this
recommendation
along
with
any
suggestions
for
implementation
Language
:
The
Policy
Brief
may
be
type
written
in
either
Bahasa
Indonesia
or
English
.
Word
Limit
:
The
Policy
Brief
should
be
less
than
5
,
000
words
in
length
.
Abstract
:
A
summary
or
abstract
of
the
document
is
required
.
It
should
be
concise
,
comprehensive
and
not
exceed
300
words
in
length
.
References
:
These
should
be
in
the
form
:
Author
’
s
Name
.
Year
of
Publication
.
Title
of
Article
/
Book
.
Journal
Title
/
Publisher
’
s
Name
.
Page
Number
(
s
)
.
Acknowledgements
:
Do
not
include
.
Wordprocessing
:
Documents
should
be
prepared
using
either
MS
Word
or
WordPerfect
software
in
10
pt
Font
.
Page
layout
should
be
set
for
A4
Portrait
,
Single
Spacing
,
Full
Justification
,
2
.
5
cm
margins
on
all
sides
,
and
Page
Numbering
at
“
Bottom
Center
”
.
Submitting
the
Policy
Brief
Policy
Briefs
should
be
submitted
in
both
hard
and
soft
copy
[
one
(
1
)
printed
original
and
one
(
1
)
diskette
]
.
The
Committee
will
assign
an
accession
number
to
each
policy
brief
received
,
and
send
an
acknowledgement
by
return
mail
citing
the
accession
number
.
Submissions
should
include
a
covering
letter
,
signed
by
the
principal
author
that
provides
the
return
addresses
and
phone
/
fax
numbers
of
all
the
listed
authors
and
should
be
delivered
to
:
The
Indonesian
Public
Policy
Forum
Jl
.
Talang
Betutu
No
.
2
Jakarta
10230
Fax
:
(
021
)
391
-
5517
file66
@
attglobal
.
net
Top
Story
No
.
17
:
Land
Management
and
Biodiversity
in
Southeast
Asia
Bali
,
Indonesia
17
-
20
September
2002
A
joint
symposium
organized
by
The
Graduate
School
of
Environmental
Earth
Science
,
Hokkaido
University
and
The
Research
Center
for
Biology
,
The
Indonesian
Institute
of
Sciences
Scope
The
importance
of
peatland
management
and
research
on
biodiversity
in
Southeast
Asia
is
still
increasing
since
the
later
half
of
the
20th
century
.
However
,
some
mismanagement
of
peatland
during
these
periods
have
occurred
and
have
lead
to
destruction
of
natural
resources
and
increased
degraded
land
.
One
of
the
recent
serious
disasters
in
Southeast
Asia
that
might
relate
to
the
mismanagement
of
land
and
biodiversity
was
the
forest
fire
of
1997
/
98
,
which
caused
serious
damages
not
only
to
natural
resources
but
also
to
human
life
.
Some
signals
of
changing
global
environments
due
to
human
impacts
including
the
mismanagement
of
peatland
in
the
areas
have
been
also
detected
worldwide
.
Southeast
Asia
is
expected
to
be
an
area
of
major
development
of
economic
activities
in
the
21st
century
,
and
most
parts
of
the
area
also
has
enormous
biological
and
ecological
resources
that
relate
directly
and
indirectly
to
the
quality
of
the
global
environment
.
Hence
wise
use
and
sustainable
management
of
peatland
and
natural
resources
should
be
applied
when
accelerating
the
economic
development
of
the
area
in
the
early
part
of
the
21st
century
.
Standing
on
this
point
of
view
,
The
Graduate
School
of
Environmental
Earth
Science
,
Hokkaido
University
and
The
Research
Center
for
Biology
,
Indonesian
Institute
of
Sciences
are
planning
to
organize
a
symposium
.
Topics
:
Wise
use
and
sustainable
management
of
peatland
in
Southeast
Asia
Biodiversity
and
bio
-
resources
in
Southeast
Asia
Aquatic
ecosystems
and
resources
in
Southeast
Asia
Environmental
quality
of
human
settlements
in
river
basins
of
Southeast
Asia
Conference
language
English
Sponsored
by
:
JSPS
(
Japan
Society
for
the
Promotion
of
Science
)
LIPI
(
The
Indonesian
Institute
of
Sciences
)
Supported
by
:
BPPT
(
Agency
for
the
Assessment
and
Development
of
Technology
,
Ministry
of
Research
and
Technology
)
CIMTROP
(
Centre
for
International
Cooperation
in
Sustainable
Management
of
Tropical
Peatland
,
University
of
Palangka
Raya
)
EUTROP
(
European
Union
Natural
Resource
Functions
of
Tropical
Peatlands
Project
)
IPB
(
Bogor
Agricultural
University
)
ITB
(
Institute
of
Technology
Bandung
)
JICA
(
Japan
International
Cooperation
Agency
)
,
Biodiversity
Conservation
Project
in
Indonesia
STRAPEAT
(
European
Union
Sustainable
Management
of
Peatlands
in
Borneo
Project
)
Important
dates
:
May
15th
,
2002
:
Deadline
for
preliminary
registration
(
name
and
title
)
June
15th
,
2002
:
Deadline
for
submission
of
abstracts
June
30th
,
2002
:
Acceptance
of
abstracts
will
be
sent
to
corresponding
authors
September
17th
,
2002
:
Registration
September
18
-
19th
,
2002
:
Conference
September
20th
,
2002
:
Excursion
1
(
Botanical
Garden
,
LIPI
)
September
21st
-
24th
,
2002
:
Excursion
2
(
Central
Kalimantan
)
November
30th
:
Deadline
for
submission
of
full
paper
for
proceeding
Contact
addresses
for
preliminary
registration
and
submission
of
abstracts
:
Dr
.
Hidenori
Takahashi
Hokkaido
University
Sapporo
060
-
0810
Japan
troenv02
@
ees
.
hokudai
.
ac
.
jp
Tel
:
+
81
-
11
-
706
-
2221
Fax
:
+
81
-
11
-
706
-
4867
and
Dr
.
Herwint
Simbolon
Research
Center
for
Biology
,
LIPI
Bogor
16122
Indonesia
herbolon
@
indo
.
net
.
id
Tel
:
+
62
-
251
-
322035
Fax
:
+
62
-
251
-
336538
Top
Story
No
.
18
:
Vacancies
at
TNC
East
Kalimantan
Office
1
.
Awareness
Outreach
Officer
Location
:
East
Kalimantan
,
Tanjung
Redeb
Field
Office
Purpose
The
Nature
Conservancy
'
s
East
Kalimantan
Program
seeks
an
Awareness
Outreach
Officer
to
be
based
in
TNC
'
s
Berau
Field
Office
located
in
Tanjung
Redeb
.
This
individual
will
focus
on
conveying
a
forest
and
marine
conservation
messages
to
a
variety
of
target
groups
including
communities
,
government
,
industry
,
NGOs
and
the
general
public
in
Kabupaten
Berau
.
A
majority
of
the
Outreach
Officer
'
s
time
will
be
spent
in
the
field
working
directly
with
stakeholders
in
order
to
:
inform
stakeholders
on
the
economic
,
social
and
intrinsic
value
of
forest
and
marine
resources
;
educate
on
practices
that
would
lead
to
sustainability
of
these
natural
resources
;
and
garner
support
of
communities
,
government
and
industry
for
TNC
'
s
conservation
activities
Summary
of
responsibilities
The
Outreach
Officer
will
work
under
the
supervision
of
and
report
TNC
'
s
East
Kalimantan
Program
Manager
.
He
/
She
will
assist
in
the
design
,
coordination
,
implementation
,
evaluation
,
and
reporting
of
awareness
and
outreach
activities
.
He
/
She
will
also
work
closely
with
TNC
outreach
staff
in
Samarinda
and
Jakarta
in
order
to
continually
evaluate
and
design
strategies
to
achieve
programmatic
goals
related
to
conservation
awareness
.
Prime
responsibilities
of
Awareness
Outreach
Officer
Implement
awareness
program
as
a
tool
to
socialize
TNC
activities
Design
TNC
awareness
activities
Work
closely
with
local
communities
in
villages
in
Kabupaten
Berau
,
local
and
national
/
international
non
-
government
organizations
,
industry
representatives
,
local
government
Conduct
training
for
communities
and
stakeholders
in
conservation
awareness
and
related
subjects
.
Liaise
effectively
with
TNC
'
s
Jakarta
and
Samarinda
Field
Offices
Qualifications
Bachelor
degree
or
equivalent
number
of
years
of
experience
Strong
interest
in
conservation
Good
local
knowledge
of
stakeholders
in
East
Kalimantan
and
preferably
Berau
Willingness
to
spend
long
periods
working
under
difficult
field
conditions
Experience
working
in
villages
and
with
local
communities
Experience
working
with
Industry
and
working
knowledge
of
English
a
plus
2
.
Accountant
This
position
will
be
based
in
Samarinda
.
The
candidate
selected
will
provide
accurate
financial
and
operating
information
on
a
timely
basis
to
support
the
Program
Manager
in
setting
the
goals
,
developing
activities
and
monitoring
the
finances
of
the
project
.
S
/
He
is
responsible
for
maintaining
good
accounting
records
and
reporting
on
all
operational
and
financial
data
for
the
Samarinda
and
Berau
offices
.
Qualification
:
A
Bachelors
Degree
in
accounting
or
finance
from
an
accredited
college
or
university
.
Experience
with
text
and
data
manipulations
using
Excel
,
Microsoft
word
and
electronic
mail
is
essential
.
Strong
organization
skills
and
ability
to
work
under
pressure
and
independently
,
with
attention
to
detail
.
Willingness
to
work
long
,
flexible
hours
as
needed
.
Excellent
oral
and
writing
communication
skill
in
Bahasa
Indonesia
and
English
.
(
Samples
will
be
required
)
.
Willingness
to
make
a
commitment
to
nature
conservation
and
the
goals
and
objectives
of
The
Nature
Conservancy
.
Indonesia
citizenship
or
proof
of
the
right
to
work
in
Indonesia
required
.
Application
should
be
written
in
English
.
Please
send
your
application
and
C
.
V
.
not
more
than
1
(
one
)
week
after
this
advertisement
to
:
Office
Manager
The
Nature
Conservancy
East
Kalimantan
Portfolio
Office
Jl
.
Kuranji
no
.
1
Voorvo
Samarinda
tncsfo
@
samarinda
.
org
Only
short
listed
candidates
will
be
contacted
Top
The
views
expressed
by
the
authors
and
organizations
contributing
to
this
electronic
newsletter
do
not
necessarily
reflect
the
views
of
the
NRM
Program
,
its
partner
organizations
,
USAID
,
or
its
government
of
Indonesia
sponsors
.
The
purpose
of
the
NRM
Headline
News
is
to
provide
a
forum
for
a
wide
diversity
of
opinion
and
information
on
NRM
Program
activities
,
selected
upcoming
events
and
news
.
The
NRM
Program
is
a
collaborative
program
between
the
governments
of
Indonesia
and
the
United
States
of
America
.
The
six
partners
implementing
the
NRM
Program
include
:
the
Environmental
Policy
and
Institutional
Strengthening
Indefinite
Quantity
Contract
(
EPIQ
)
,
Yayasan
KEMALA
,
the
Coastal
Resources
Management
Program
(
CRMP
-
Proyek
Pesisir
)
,
Conservation
International
,
The
Nature
Conservancy
and
the
World
Wide
Fund
for
Nature
-
Indonesia
.
CAESAR
II
is
a
software
engineering
which
is
used
to
analyze
the
piping
system
.
This
software
is
a
standard
to
design
the
piping
system
.
With
the
application
of
CAESAR
II
,
modeling
and
static
analysis
can
be
done
accurately
,
easily
and
doesn
t
cost
much
time
.
This
course
offers
you
the
basic
knowledge
about
the
piping
system
.
The
tutor
will
guide
you
to
know
about
the
piping
system
components
,
and
also
to
understand
the
valid
code
and
standard
.
There
also
will
be
taught
about
how
to
analyze
the
flexibility
and
the
pipe
stress
analysis
manually
or
by
computer
.
top
▲
Computational
Fluid
Dynamics
Application
(
CFD
Application
)
CFD
is
a
tool
which
is
used
to
predict
all
kind
of
flows
accurately
.
The
benefit
of
using
this
tool
is
that
we
can
detect
the
flow
condition
at
that
time
.
This
CFD
has
an
important
role
for
an
engineer
or
even
for
a
student
to
their
research
project
.
The
tutors
will
teach
you
to
visualize
the
fluid
dynamic
matters
into
2D
or
3D
stuffs
,
and
then
to
be
analyzed
.
For
further
information
,
please
contact
:
CCIT
-
FTUI
Pascasarjana
FTUI
building
UI
Depok
Ph
.
021
78849047
Fax
.
021
7863508
Contact
Person
:
Jana
/
Ebah
Duration
for
course
:
3
days
@
5
hours
Diploma
International
(
Professional
Program
)
The
goal
of
this
short
course
is
to
create
a
professional
engineer
in
Information
Technology
sector
.
This
Diploma
International
Program
applies
Futurz
Technology
Curriculum
(
FTC
)
which
consists
of
4
semesters
.
To
apply
the
knowledge
into
a
field
,
the
students
are
obligate
to
do
a
job
training
in
an
IT
company
.
Release
Date
:
13
May
2003
DEVELOPING
A
FUEL
QUALITY
ACTION
PLAN
FOR
IMPLEMENTING
BLUE
SKY
IN
THE
TRANSPORTATION
SECTOR
By
:
RESEARCH
AND
DEVELOPMENT
CENTER
FOR
OIL
AND
GAS
TECHNOLOGY
?
LEMIGAS
?
Summary
:
The
Jakarta
Metropolitan
area
exhibits
substantial
air
quality
issues
that
are
similar
to
other
large
tropical
urban
centers
around
the
world
.
Very
rapid
population
growth
,
urban
development
,
and
personal
motorization
are
combining
with
an
existing
vehicle
fleet
that
has
a
high
fraction
of
older
and
poorly
maintained
vehicles
.
This
leads
directly
to
high
levels
of
ambient
pollutants
that
impact
public
health
and
welfare
.
This
situation
has
led
to
a
strong
consensus
in
recent
years
to
pursue
a
?
Blue
Sky
?
strategy
in
an
effort
to
achieve
cleaner
air
.
One
set
of
efforts
within
theBlue
Sky
directive
is
specification
of
transport
fuels
quality
to
ensure
that
minimum
standards
are
achieved
for
optimum
vehicle
operation
and
for
emission
control
system
compatibility
.
A
key
specification
of
interest
is
the
elimination
of
lead
(
Pb
)
additives
(
TEL
)
to
gasoline
so
that
new
clean
vehicle
technology
can
be
sold
as
a
direct
replacement
for
older
,
highly
polluting
designs
.
This
change
would
reduce
the
high
public
exposure
to
lead
through
both
inhalation
and
ingestion
pathways
.
This
study
evaluates
basic
trends
in
the
metropolitan
fuel
and
transportation
systems
,
reviews
the
key
air
quality
problems
associated
with
vehicle
use
in
the
Jakarta
region
,
quantifies
some
of
the
related
public
health
impacts
and
identifies
technical
fuel
blending
approaches
for
meeting
the
lead
-
free
gasoline
requirement
in
the
greater
metropolitan
area
.
A
net
/
benefit
analysis
highlights
much
of
the
public
benefit
value
associated
with
the
expected
air
quality
improvement
and
demonstrates
the
overwhelming
health
and
economic
importance
for
rapidly
pursuing
the
improved
fuel
standards
compared
to
the
incremental
cost
of
their
production
.
The
10
year
analysis
underpins
findings
and
recommendations
in
support
of
Energy
Ministry
decisions
regarding
appropriate
long
term
lead
-
free
fuel
blending
strategies
and
to
identify
critical
refinery
and
other
fuel
distribution
system
needs
and
potential
for
upgrade
.
Secondary
and
more
constrained
evaluations
within
the
study
have
looked
at
diesel
fuel
quality
issues
and
at
issues
associated
with
the
failure
of
related
CNG
and
LPG
fuel
replacement
strategies
for
the
transport
sector
.
A
critical
issue
for
decisions
on
minimum
fuel
standards
is
the
assurance
that
the
standards
remove
any
barriers
to
more
complete
transport
pollutant
emission
control
and
air
quality
improvement
approaches
.
By
far
the
most
important
companion
effort
is
specification
of
stringent
new
vehicle
and
engine
emission
standards
that
ensure
the
most
efficient
designs
are
permanently
introduced
to
the
region
.
Along
with
cleaner
exhaust
and
much
lower
evaporative
losses
,
the
controls
should
bring
enhanced
public
health
on
a
daily
basis
,
lower
health
care
cost
,
improved
population
longevity
,
lower
lifecycle
vehicle
maintenance
costs
,
longer
vehicle
and
engine
life
expectancy
and
the
potential
for
much
higher
energy
system
efficiencies
.
New
fuel
standards
will
ensure
a
better
match
of
proper
fuel
to
meet
newer
engine
requirements
and
will
directly
reduce
the
rate
of
harmful
pollutant
emissions
.
From
a
pollution
reduction
perspective
,
a
combination
of
fuel
quality
standards
and
new
engine
and
control
system
designs
can
reduce
total
vehicle
emissions
by
85
?
90
%
over
the
full
vehicle
life
cycle
compared
to
new
uncontrolled
designs
.
This
is
true
for
both
gasoline
and
diesel
engines
.
In
a
rapidly
urbanizing
and
motorizing
society
like
modern
Jakarta
,
wholesale
replacement
of
the
retiring
part
of
the
fleet
with
clean
new
vehicles
can
effect
a
dramatic
improvement
in
regional
air
quality
.
But
this
can
?
t
happen
unless
the
emission
control
system
poisons
currently
in
the
fuel
streams
are
eliminated
or
drastically
reduced
.
Companion
fuel
and
emission
standard
policies
won
?
t
eliminate
the
emissions
from
the
existing
fleet
that
remains
in
service
.
But
new
fuel
standards
will
substantially
reduce
the
incidence
of
poorly
maintained
vehicles
(
?
smokers
?
)
based
on
the
lead
removal
.
And
,
the
proper
fuel
quality
can
lessen
the
intensity
of
some
emissions
from
the
existing
fleet
.
Incentives
for
proper
vehicle
maintenance
,
whether
through
testing
requirements
or
other
approaches
,
are
an
equally
important
air
improvement
strategy
,
but
the
effectiveness
of
such
programs
require
a
clean
vehicle
technology
and
fuel
basis
for
maximum
effect
.
Keyword
:
Blue
Sky
File
:
bluesky
.
zip
(
127
.
58
kbytes
)
Release
Date
:
13
May
2003
ENERGY
PRICING
/
SUBSIDY
POLICY
DEVELOPMENT
PROJECT
By
:
Inter
University
Center
for
Economic
Studies
(
IUC
-
ES
)
Gadjah
Mada
University
Summary
:
The
terms
of
reference
for
the
inquiry
into
the
impact
of
energy
pricing
policy
(
EPP
)
on
macro
and
sectoral
Indonesia
,
basically
is
to
support
the
EAPO
(
Energy
Analysis
and
Policy
Office
)
.
EAPO
is
a
collaborative
effort
between
the
Indonesian
Ministry
of
Mines
and
Energy
(
MME
)
and
the
U
.
S
.
Agency
for
International
Development
to
develop
policy
analysis
capability
within
MME
.
As
part
of
this
effort
,
energy
policy
analysis
that
will
be
carried
out
should
include
the
macroeconomic
impacts
and
adjustment
of
the
new
energy
pricing
policy
.
To
fulfill
that
objective
,
this
study
focuses
on
:
?
developing
an
energy
-
economy
model
used
to
analyze
the
Indonesian
economy
`
s
adjustment
to
anticipate
the
proposed
fuel
prices
increase
brought
about
the
removal
of
oil
subsidies
.
?
exercising
the
impact
of
several
scenarios
of
removal
subsidies
to
fuel
based
on
time
horizon
.
?
analyzing
the
simulation
results
and
proposing
policy
implications
.
This
study
analyze
within
an
economy
-
wide
framework
of
the
impact
of
BBM
pricing
policy
,
with
realistic
representation
of
the
major
mechanisms
by
which
a
national
economy
can
adjust
to
higher
energy
prices
and
various
energy
policy
measures
.
In
order
to
achieve
these
objectives
,
the
team
has
constructed
a
quantitative
model
,
in
which
the
study
about
the
economic
impact
from
the
energy
pricing
policy
in
various
scenarios
can
be
undertaken
.
Keyword
:
Energy
Pricing
File
:
indorani
.
zip
(
258
.
90
kbytes
)
Release
Date
:
13
May
2003
ENERGY
CAPACITY
BUILDING
By
:
Regional
University
:
CRE_ITB
-
LPEM
FEUI
Summary
:
Energy
,
renewable
or
unrenewable
has
an
important
role
in
human
life
.
As
a
main
source
in
life
,
therefore
the
use
of
energy
especially
unrenewable
energy
has
to
be
efficient
and
effective
.
Production
process
,
sales
chain
,
and
consumption
of
final
energy
have
to
follow
economical
aspects
.
Every
party
in
a
society
has
moral
obligations
on
energy
development
for
the
sustainable
of
human
life
development
.
The
energy
issues
can
be
more
easily
socialized
if
every
party
knows
energy
economics
.
University
as
an
education
and
research
institute
is
one
of
the
party
that
can
become
a
catalisator
and
also
and
also
intermediator
to
transfer
and
socialize
energy
issues
to
a
more
broad
society
.
However
,
there
are
still
many
problems
to
make
it
works
.
First
,
the
current
teaching
on
energy
economics
still
not
comprehensive
yet
.
Lecture
on
energy
economics
in
most
of
higher
education
institute
only
given
to
faculty
of
techniques
or
just
as
a
general
like
in
faculty
of
economics
.
Second
,
the
quality
of
lecture
on
energy
economics
has
not
been
optimal
.
Third
,
the
curriculum
on
energy
economics
in
higher
education
still
not
focused
yet
.
Bandung
Institute
of
Technology
(
ITB
)
and
University
of
Indonesia
(
UI
)
as
the
two
oldest
higher
education
institute
in
Indonesia
,
have
the
capacity
to
conduct
the
program
on
energy
economics
development
and
make
an
assistant
-
ship
to
local
university
in
order
to
eliminate
the
problems
concerning
the
development
on
energy
economics
.
The
program
,
which
will
be
organized
jointly
by
two
institutes
(
ITB
and
UI
)
can
take
benefit
in
the
form
that
ITB
will
focus
on
technical
aspects
of
energy
while
UI
,
will
participate
in
economical
aspects
.
These
activities
will
be
done
in
a
cooperation
with
regional
universities
.
At
last
,
the
socialization
about
energy
economics
will
not
only
bounded
to
academic
society
,
but
also
for
public
such
as
regional
government
,
private
,
and
non
-
government
organization
(
NGO
)
,
and
other
parties
.
Keyword
:
Energy
File
:
Regional
Energy
Capacity
Building
-
LPEM
-
UI
.
zip
(
61
.
23
kbytes
)
Release
Date
:
13
May
2003
SMALL
-
SCALE
ELECTRICITY
BUSIESS
DEVELOPMENT
STUDY
By
:
Diponegoro
University
Summary
:
Electricity
has
become
an
absolute
necessity
for
today
’
s
life
,
economic
activity
,
and
civilisation
.
In
Indonesia
,
however
,
this
necessity
are
enjoyed
only
by
a
small
group
of
people
residing
in
or
near
big
cities
and
towns
.
The
limited
fund
owned
by
PT
.
Perusahaan
Listrik
Negara
,
a
State
-
Electricity
Company
,
(
hereafter
called
PT
.
PLN
)
has
led
to
the
need
for
electricity
in
certain
areas
,
especially
in
rural
ones
,
has
not
been
really
fulfilled
.
The
emerging
regulation
of
electricity
will
allow
private
business
organizations
to
take
the
role
of
generating
,
transmitting
,
and
distributing
electricity
which
currently
are
monopolised
by
PT
.
PLN
.
The
regulation
will
likely
give
an
opportunity
for
customers
to
subscribe
electricity
as
needed
.
Furthermore
,
Government
Act
No
.
22
/
1999
and
Governmental
Regulation
No
.
25
/
2000
permit
the
government
of
regency
/
municipality
to
issue
licences
regarding
the
business
of
electricity
.
A
Small
-
Scale
Electricity
Business
Development
Study
in
Jawa
Tengah
was
conducted
by
The
Program
Magister
Management
Diponegoro
University
.
The
aims
of
the
study
are
to
identify
the
opportunities
to
build
private
electricity
business
,
to
identify
potential
customers
,
and
to
analyse
the
feasibility
of
electricity
business
in
Jawa
Tengah
.
The
term
of
“
private
”
refers
to
business
organizations
outside
PT
.
PLN
,
such
as
private
companies
,
cooperatives
,
and
local
government
.
Keyword
:
Electricity
File
:
Kecil
.
zip
(
27
.
54
kbytes
)
Release
Date
:
06
May
2003
INDONESIA
`
S
ENERGY
OUTLOOK
2010
By
:
Centre
for
Energy
Information
CEI
-
MEMR
Summary
:
Energy
outlook
presents
a
picture
on
the
energy
situation
that
is
likely
to
occur
in
the
future
under
certain
preconditions
or
assumptions
.
Energy
outlook
outlines
perspective
of
future
energy
demand
and
supply
.
By
including
a
policy
scenario
,
energy
outlook
picturizes
the
result
of
implementation
of
energy
sector
strategy
and
policy
implementation
in
the
future
.
Energy
outlook
is
essential
for
energy
sector
development
planning
.
It
shows
the
direction
of
energy
sector
development
so
that
it
helps
promote
and
direct
community
participation
which
,
in
turn
,
will
contribute
to
the
success
of
energy
sector
development
.
Energy
outlook
is
prepared
with
the
help
of
a
model
which
represents
an
approach
to
simulate
the
real
world
.
Being
an
approach
,
the
model
necessarily
makes
a
number
of
approximations
to
simplify
the
complex
interrelation
in
actual
world
.
However
,
as
the
initial
construction
of
the
model
is
made
available
,
the
assumptions
used
can
be
reviewed
and
improved
as
necessary
.
Dasar
-
dasar
Manajemen
sebagai
Salah
Satu
Materi
Pembelajaran
dalam
Pendidikan
Teknologi
dan
Industri
Kontemporer
(
Achmad
Tutjik
Moechid
,
State
University
of
Malang
)
Abstract
:
The
content
of
industrial
and
technological
education
centers
around
two
important
phenomena
are
:
(
a
)
technology
,
a
study
of
evolution
,
utilization
,
and
significance
;
and
(
b
)
industry
,
a
study
of
its
organization
,
management
,
materials
,
products
,
processes
,
problems
,
and
benefits
or
contributions
.
Therefore
,
management
is
an
integral
part
of
teaching
materials
to
be
taught
.
The
term
of
management
is
rather
broad
and
somewhat
difficult
to
define
.
It
is
a
term
which
may
be
found
in
the
literature
of
several
major
academic
fields
.
The
field
of
industrial
and
technological
educations
uses
the
term
to
describe
those
duties
of
the
teacher
which
are
directed
towards
keeping
his
/
her
laboratory
in
an
on
-
going
,
operating
,
condition
-
laboratory
management
.
The
field
of
Home
Economics
uses
the
term
to
describe
the
activities
running
a
home
management
.
The
field
of
business
and
public
administration
uses
it
to
describe
a
special
area
of
academic
study
-
industrial
management
.
It
is
the
definition
of
this
more
specific
term
,
industrial
management
,
that
is
the
major
concern
of
the
article
.
Analisis
Faktor
Konfirmatori
terhadap
Kinerja
Usaha
Kecil
yang
Berorientasi
Ekspor
di
Jawa
Timur
dan
Faktor
-
Faktor
yang
menjadi
Penentunya
(
Nurhajati
,
State
University
of
Malang
)
Abstract
:
This
research
was
intended
to
confirm
the
performance
of
the
export
-
oriented
small
business
in
Jawa
Timur
empirically
and
that
determinant
factors
,
those
are
:
(
1
)
entrepreneurial
skill
,
(
2
)
internal
,
(
3
)
external
factors
.
The
three
factors
are
composed
of
the
set
of
variables
and
indicators
,
while
the
performance
variable
covers
the
set
of
indicators
.
The
sample
consisted
of
140
small
businesses
taken
by
simple
random
sampling
.
The
data
were
collected
by
questionnaire
,
which
have
been
tested
both
for
its
validity
and
reliability
.
Then
,
data
were
analyzed
by
confirmatory
factor
analysis
.
The
result
of
this
research
showed
that
the
set
of
variables
and
indicators
of
three
factors
,
and
the
set
of
indicators
of
performance
variable
can
be
confirmed
empirically
.
Konflik
dan
Integrasi
:
Interaksi
Antarorganisasi
Keagamaan
di
Pulau
Kangean
(
Abd
.
Latif
Bustami
,
Indonesia
University
)
Abstract
:
This
paper
discusses
conflict
and
integration
among
religious
organizations
in
Kangean
Island
,
Sumenep
district
.
The
religious
organizations
are
focused
on
Nahdlatul
Ulama
(
NU
)
,
Muhammadiyah
(
MD
)
and
Persatuan
Islam
(
Persis
)
.
Every
organization
has
expansive
characteristic
with
religious
teaching
strategy
accordance
with
religious
belief
to
which
the
organization
refers
,
and
the
people
condition
with
cultural
context
of
Kangean
.
The
existence
of
supporting
people
of
the
three
religious
organizations
can
be
easily
identified
when
social
interaction
processes
occur
in
multifaceted
people
.
The
interaction
of
the
three
religious
organizations
has
brought
conflict
.
It
has
relation
with
interpretation
differences
and
actualization
of
fiqh
,
the
relationship
between
religious
belief
and
people
culture
,
religious
teaching
development
,
and
competition
to
get
power
both
in
local
and
national
level
.
Power
competition
in
head
of
village
(
ceplo
'
an
kalebun
)
succession
,
government
officials
,
government
policy
and
the
relation
to
national
leadership
succession
have
escalated
the
conflict
.
In
its
early
existence
,
MD
is
identified
as
'
kafir
'
by
the
people
,
even
their
sat
chairs
should
be
washed
because
of
their
belief
that
the
things
have
been
dirty
and
should
be
cleaned
.
NU
is
majority
and
become
hegemonic
power
with
legitimacy
of
Gus
Dur
,
as
NU
representation
,
as
the
president
and
MD
is
constructed
as
competing
power
.
The
construction
is
strengthen
by
Amin
Rais
behavior
as
MD
representation
.
The
three
organizations
attempt
to
solve
the
conflict
by
implementing
cultural
strategies
.
Peran
Fungsi
Sumberdaya
Manusia
di
Indonesia
(
Teguh
Prasetio
,
Gajayana
Malang
University
)
Abstract
:
Changing
in
organizational
environment
has
been
changed
the
role
of
human
resource
management
into
more
strategic
function
.
So
far
,
human
resource
management
in
any
organizations
more
carry
out
the
administrative
roles
than
the
strategic
ones
.
This
research
eager
to
identifies
the
roles
of
human
resource
function
among
organizations
in
Indonesia
.
For
that
reason
,
the
human
resource
role
-
assessment
survey
developed
by
Ulrich
(
1997
)
is
applied
.
The
respondents
are
manufacturing
and
profit
oriented
organizations
,
and
non
-
profit
oriented
and
service
organizations
.
The
result
revealed
that
the
shift
of
human
resource
management
role
into
more
strategic
one
began
.
However
,
the
organization
that
doesn
'
t
classified
in
those
,
still
so
dominant
.
Studi
tentang
Usaha
Guru
dalam
Meningkatkan
Kreativitas
Siswa
dalam
Proses
Belajar
Mengajar
IPS
di
Sekolah
Dasar
(
Rapani
,
Lampung
University
)
Abstract
:
Increasing
pupil
'
s
creativity
in
the
process
of
teaching
learning
Social
Science
(
IPS
)
subject
for
Elementary
School
is
one
of
the
teachers
'
jobs
in
increasing
the
pupil
'
s
thinking
pattern
.
Every
individual
needs
to
get
attention
from
teacher
as
educational
executors
at
school
.
This
research
is
aimed
at
seeking
information
and
revealing
some
efforts
done
by
the
teachers
in
increasing
pupil
'
s
creativity
in
the
process
of
learning
IPS
.
Increasing
pupils
'
creativity
can
be
done
by
the
teachers
by
increasing
pupil
'
s
interest
and
attention
,
motivation
,
developing
their
talent
and
encouraging
their
thinking
activity
.
The
research
was
carried
out
to
answer
research
problems
related
to
the
process
of
teaching
learning
IPS
at
elementary
school
as
the
following
:
What
efforts
have
been
done
by
teachers
in
order
to
(
1
)
increase
pupils
interest
and
attention
(
2
)
increase
pupils
motivation
?
(
3
)
develop
pupils
'
talent
(
4
)
motivate
pupil
in
thinking
activities
.
Identifikasi
Komoditas
Unggulan
Daerah
Kabupaten
Lamandau
(
Ferdinand
dan
Meitiana
,
Palangkaraya
University
)
Abstract
:
This
research
was
aimed
at
identifying
superior
commodity
and
analyzing
internal
and
external
factors
of
superior
commodity
development
of
Kabupaten
Lamandau
.
Research
procedure
employed
was
descriptive
and
the
weight
emphasized
was
survey
design
.
Research
subjects
consisted
of
camat
,
camat
staff
,
rural
administrator
,
public
figure
,
advanced
farmer
and
consuming
trader
/
industry
.
Whereas
,
the
research
instruments
used
include
inquiry
,
form
of
interview
,
and
form
of
documentary
data
gathering
.
The
result
oh
this
study
indicated
that
1
)
superior
commodity
of
Kabupaten
Lamandau
consists
of
six
commodities
such
as
wood
,
natural
rubber
or
latex
,
rattan
,
durian
lettuce
,
and
coffee
;
and
2
)
alternatives
of
main
,
primary
and
supporting
strategies
.
From
these
results
,
it
is
recommended
for
the
local
stakeholders
to
prioritize
the
development
of
superior
commodities
to
be
compatible
with
the
yields
of
the
district
.
Kepuasan
Kerja
dan
Komitmen
Organisasi
sebagai
Variabel
Moderator
Hubungan
antara
Stres
Peran
dan
Niat
untuk
Keluar
:
Sebuah
Reviu
Hasil
-
hasil
Penelitian
Terdahulu
(
Budi
Eko
Soetjipto
,
Brawijaya
Malang
University
)
Abstract
:
This
article
presents
previous
research
findings
the
rela
-
tionships
between
role
stressors
and
intent
to
leave
,
which
are
moderated
by
job
satisfaction
and
organizational
commitment
.
Gene
-
rally
,
on
one
hand
,
the
findings
revealed
negative
correlations
between
role
stress
,
role
ambiguity
and
job
satisfaction
.
Moreover
,
negative
correlations
were
also
found
between
job
satisfaction
,
organizational
commitment
and
intent
to
leave
.
On
the
other
hand
,
positive
correlations
were
also
found
between
role
conflict
,
role
ambiguity
,
job
satisfaction
and
intent
to
leave
.
Makna
di
Balik
Data
Pola
Konsumsi
Rumah
Tangga
(
Mauled
Moelyono
,
Tadulako
University
)
Abstract
:
One
of
statistical
publications
of
BPS
concerning
the
results
of
SUSENAS
is
the
data
of
household
consumption
pattern
.
This
publication
seemed
to
merely
inform
magnitude
,
the
change
and
development
of
household
'
s
shopping
activities
towards
various
commodities
,
not
informed
important
contents
of
the
households
consumption
pattern
'
s
data
.
In
fact
,
the
household
'
s
consumption
pattern
contained
the
quite
wide
contents
,
inspite
of
having
been
the
portrays
displaying
household
'
s
activities
in
spending
its
income
,
this
pattern
was
the
basic
information
about
family
involvement
in
market
activities
as
well
as
the
measures
of
the
level
of
the
family
'
s
economic
advance
and
the
disequilibrium
level
of
income
distribution
among
the
groups
of
them
.
This
paper
tried
to
provide
in
-
depht
understanding
on
the
contents
behind
the
family
'
s
consumption
pattern
as
the
basis
of
decision
making
for
verious
interests
.
Analisis
Kebijakan
Fiskal
dan
Permasalahan
Anggaran
Pendapatan
dan
Belanja
Negara
(
APBN
)
Indonesia
(
H
.
Mulyadi
,
Sy
.
P
.
,
Mulawarman
Samarinda
University
)
Abstract
:
Fiscal
policy
is
one
form
of
governmental
intrventions
in
economic
sector
.
The
role
of
fiscal
policy
becomes
much
more
important
in
determining
national
income
mechanism
and
influencing
the
run
of
certain
caountry
'
s
ecenomy
.
Various
problems
contained
in
Budgetary
of
National
Income
and
Expenditure
(
APBN
)
would
affect
the
role
of
fiscal
policy
in
affecting
the
operation
of
Indonesian
economy
,
mainly
in
current
reformation
era
.
Some
alternatives
,
therefore
,
must
be
taken
for
reducing
the
impacts
of
APBN
problems
above
.
Analisis
Penetapan
Suku
Bunga
Kredit
(
Hadi
Sunaryo
,
Islamic
Malang
University
)
Abstract
:
During
2003
,
the
interest
of
Indonesian
Bank
Certificate
(
SBI
)
has
been
decreasing
in
large
amount
.
Even
,
its
position
achieving
the
rate
of
8
%
was
the
lowest
during
monetary
history
since
the
current
20
years
.
This
decrease
of
SBI
interest
was
followed
immediately
by
the
termed
-
deposit
interests
on
the
banks
.
Such
decrease
had
influenced
on
the
slow
development
of
the
bank
'
s
third
part
funds
.
According
to
conventional
principles
,
there
are
two
kinds
of
loan
interest
in
banking
activities
given
to
the
customer
:
one
is
the
deposit
interest
given
as
stimulus
or
recompense
for
the
customers
deposing
their
money
in
the
bank
.
Deposit
interest
is
the
cost
must
be
paid
by
bank
for
its
customers
,
such
as
for
credit
transfer
,
saving
interst
and
deposit
interest
,
and
this
cost
for
bank
constitutes
purchase
cost
.
The
other
is
loan
interest
given
to
the
debtor
and
the
cost
must
be
paid
by
the
debtor
for
the
bank
,
such
as
credit
interest
.
For
the
bank
,
this
cost
constitutes
sale
price
.
Analisis
Sumber
Daya
Strategis
sebagai
Landasan
Penetapan
Strategi
dan
Pengaruhnya
terhadap
Kinerja
Usaha
Kecil
dan
Menengah
:
(
Bidang
Usaha
Konveksi
di
Jawa
Timur
)
(
Sunaryanto
,
State
University
of
Malang
)
Abstract
:
Based
on
resource
based
view
of
the
firm
,
this
research
is
intended
to
explain
the
effects
of
internal
resources
on
competitive
advantage
and
strategy
implementation
of
118
SMEs
in
East
Java
.
Using
survey
technique
,
the
study
reveals
that
internal
resources
has
important
role
in
strengthening
competitive
advantage
and
in
implementing
effective
strategy
and
,
then
,
in
increasing
their
performance
.
SMEs
with
relatively
strong
resources
are
suggested
to
implement
differentiation
strategy
by
producing
high
quality
and
inovative
products
,
as
well
as
diversifying
their
product
.
SMEs
with
relatively
limited
resources
are
suggested
to
focus
their
product
to
serve
a
group
of
customer
in
accordance
with
their
competence
.
Pengaruh
Pelayanan
Dokter
terhadap
Kepuasan
Pelanggan
(
Widji
Astuti
,
Merdeka
Malang
University
)
Abstract
:
This
research
was
aimed
at
acknowledging
how
far
the
effects
of
doctor
services
in
form
of
information
,
service
delivery
and
their
relationship
with
patients
'
satisfaction
in
Kodya
Malang
.
Data
gathering
was
conducted
in
method
of
accidental
sampling
at
eight
practicum
clinics
which
was
then
analyzed
using
doubled
-
linear
regression
in
order
to
obtain
the
findings
supporting
the
study
,
that
is
,
information
,
service
delivery
and
their
relationship
effected
significatly
on
patient
satisfaction
,
and
the
relationship
was
the
most
influential
on
patient
satisfaction
.
Analisis
Faktor
-
faktor
Pajak
Daerah
,
Retribusi
Daerah
dan
Perusahaan
Milik
Daerah
yang
Mempengaruhi
Pendapatan
Asli
Daerah
Kota
Surabaya
dalam
Rangka
Otonomi
Daerah
(
Syamsul
Huda
,
UPN
Veteran
Surabaya
)
Abstract
:
One
of
the
purpose
autonomy
area
is
make
smooth
the
area
development
and
make
the
balance
of
the
development
and
also
distribution
of
output
.
And
to
create
that
phenomenon
one
thing
that
must
Regency
have
that
is
ability
in
equipping
the
development
cost
that
focus
in
source
of
Original
Income
Area
that
more
bigger
.
The
purpose
of
this
research
is
to
know
factors
of
Area
Tax
,
Area
Retribution
,
Area
Company
Property
that
influence
the
Original
Income
Area
.
This
research
is
using
secondary
data
in
annual
income
in
10
years
1992
-
2001
.
While
the
analyst
is
double
linear
regression
that
is
to
know
the
relationship
or
influence
by
simultaneous
and
partial
from
independent
variable
of
area
tax
,
Area
Retribution
,
Area
Company
Property
that
influence
the
Original
Income
Area
to
dependent
variable
source
of
Original
Income
Area
.
The
result
of
this
result
can
conclude
that
by
simultaneous
independent
variable
has
influence
to
dependent
variable
.
By
partial
each
variable
area
tax
,
Area
Retribution
,
Area
Company
Property
that
influence
the
Original
Income
Area
.
Pengaruh
Earning
Per
Share
,
Financial
Leverage
,
dan
Return
On
Asset
terhadap
Harga
Saham
pada
Perusahaan
Rokok
di
Bursa
Efek
Jakarta
(
Anik
Yuliati
,
UPN
Veteran
Surabaya
)
Abstract
:
In
the
country
development
is
needed
a
lot
of
fund
.
And
the
form
to
fulfill
the
fund
is
investment
.
That
for
is
need
the
effort
to
collect
community
fund
and
expected
part
of
capital
market
in
this
case
is
Stock
Exchange
Jakarta
.
Capital
market
will
easier
the
company
to
get
the
fund
,
so
economic
activity
all
sector
can
increased
.
Stock
selling
can
give
opportunity
to
community
to
having
and
enjoy
the
profit
that
get
company
.
Capital
market
activity
can
know
from
stock
price
fluctuation
that
get
from
external
and
internal
factors
.
Internal
factors
is
Earning
Per
Share
,
Financial
Leverage
and
Return
On
Assets
.
This
research
is
using
secondary
data
that
get
from
financial
data
and
non
financial
data
from
cigarette
that
go
public
in
Stock
Exchange
Jakarta
.
To
test
the
hypothesis
is
used
double
linear
regression
test
with
F
test
and
t
test
.
With
using
computer
program
statistic
SPSS
10
.
00
version
.
From
the
result
of
this
result
can
conclude
that
Earning
Per
Share
,
Financial
Leverage
and
Return
On
Assets
by
simultan
is
not
have
influence
to
stock
price
.
Pengaruh
Pengorganisasian
Teks
Bidang
Studi
Geografi
Model
Beck
dan
McKeown
terhadap
Perolehan
Belajar
Membaca
Siswa
SLTP
(
Edy
Purwanto
,
State
University
of
Malang
)
Abstract
:
This
experiment
studied
effects
of
text
-
organized
model
on
the
geography
reading
achievement
.
Result
indicated
that
there
is
a
signi
ficant
difference
in
achievement
between
students
who
read
geography
text
which
is
organized
based
on
Beck
and
McKeown
'
s
model
and
those
who
read
geography
using
package
book
model
.
The
use
of
Beck
and
McKeown
'
s
text
model
is
better
than
package
book
model
in
helping
students
learn
geography
.
So
the
geography
textbook
for
junior
high
schools
should
be
reorganized
by
this
model
,
in
order
the
textbook
to
be
studied
easily
by
students
.
Perilaku
Konsumen
untuk
Membeli
Perhiasan
Intan
/
Berlian
di
Kota
Martapura
(
Hj
.
Masriah
dan
Hj
.
Sri
Setiti
,
Lambung
Mangkurat
Banjarmasin
University
)
Abstract
:
The
buying
decision
making
by
diamond
accessories
consumers
is
influenced
by
several
factors
.
This
research
conducted
to
such
consumers
in
Martapura
City
indicates
that
there
are
five
factors
the
consumers
take
into
account
in
their
decision
of
buying
diamond
accessories
,
such
factors
include
:
product
,
social
characteristics
,
price
,
after
sales
service
,
distribution
,
and
buying
situation
.
The
dominating
factor
among
them
is
product
factor
represented
by
colour
.
Such
phenomena
should
obviously
be
considered
by
related
parties
like
merchants
and
producers
of
diamond
products
in
Martapura
in
order
for
improving
the
product
quality
especially
in
term
of
colour
and
size
of
the
product
.
Gaya
Kepemimpinan
Kepala
Madrasah
dan
Pengaruhnya
terhadap
Motivasi
Kerja
Guru
pada
Madrasah
Aliyah
Negeri
di
Sulawesi
Tenggara
(
Zulkifli
,
M
.
,
Sekolah
Tinggi
Islam
Negeri
Kendari
)
Abstract
:
The
research
aimed
at
knowing
the
leadership
styles
of
he
headmasters
of
the
State
Religious
Highschools
in
South
East
Sulawesi
,
the
teachers
'
working
motivation
,
and
the
influence
of
the
headmasters
'
the
leadership
styles
on
the
teachers
'
working
motivation
.
The
research
made
use
of
descriptive
and
correlative
methods
which
attempted
to
find
out
the
influence
of
one
variable
on
the
other
variable
.
The
data
were
analyzed
by
using
the
Duncan
'
s
Multiple
Range
Test
for
the
variable
scores
,
and
the
variance
analysis
with
the
pseudo
-
linear
regression
or
the
general
linear
models
procedure
,
through
SAS
program
.
The
results
show
that
:
(
1
)
the
headmasters
of
State
Religious
highschools
,
in
south
east
Sulawesi
have
applied
the
democratic
leadership
style
;
(
2
)
the
teachers
of
the
these
schools
tend
to
have
high
intrinsic
working
motivation
;
and
(
3
)
there
is
no
influence
of
the
headmasters
'
leadership
styles
on
the
teachers
working
motivation
.
Kemampuan
Membuat
Karya
Tulis
Ilmiah
Guru
-
Guru
Sekolah
Dasar
di
Bandar
Lampung
(
Danial
Achmad
,
Lampung
University
)
Abstract
:
This
research
is
a
diagnostic
action
research
aimed
at
helping
elementary
school
teachers
in
Bandar
Lampung
to
solve
their
problems
in
writing
scientific
papers
needed
to
obtain
profession
development
credit
points
.
Without
these
,
they
cannot
propose
to
have
IV
/
b
level
or
above
it
.
There
are
two
steps
of
the
research
.
In
Cycle
I
,
the
researcher
together
with
the
subjects
investigated
the
problems
they
faced
,
then
formulated
and
planned
needed
action
to
help
to
solve
their
problems
,
that
is
,
low
capability
of
writing
scientific
papers
.
Based
on
the
observation
results
in
Cycle
I
,
the
researchers
conducted
Cycle
II
done
by
planning
and
giving
action
to
revise
the
subjects
'
work
results
which
were
then
evaluated
and
concluded
.
The
results
of
this
research
are
as
follows
.
The
hypothesis
of
Cycle
I
is
If
participants
are
taught
materials
and
given
guidance
on
techniques
of
writing
scientific
papers
,
research
subjects
(
elementary
teachers
)
will
have
insight
and
basic
skills
to
write
scientific
papers
.
Distribusi
Pendapatan
dalam
Pembangunan
Ekonomi
Jawa
Timur
(
Ruswiati
,
Wijaya
Putra
Surabaya
University
)
Abstract
:
The
goverment
'
s
policy
,
with
has
put
industrial
sector
into
priority
has
shifted
the
economic
structure
from
agriculture
to
industrial
based
economy
,
but
the
shift
of
economic
structure
is
not
followed
by
labor
structure
.
This
study
observed
about
East
Java
income
distribution
,
with
Social
Accounting
Matrix
Analyses
.
The
resault
,
generally
of
East
Java
income
distribution
in
2000
is
worsen
.
This
was
indicated
by
the
lower
added
value
contribution
to
labor
production
factor
,
the
discrepancy
of
income
distribution
is
more
evident
,
and
it
'
s
worsened
by
the
shift
of
added
value
which
isn
'
t
followed
by
shift
of
labor
.
There
'
s
also
discrepancy
in
the
distribution
of
income
between
economic
sector
and
region
(
urban
and
rural
)
.
Kemampuan
Guru
Taman
Kanak
-
Kanak
(
TK
)
dalam
Melaksanakan
Pembelajaran
TK
di
Provinsi
Lampung
(
Een
Y
.
Haenilah
,
Lampung
University
)
Abstract
:
This
research
is
aimed
at
finding
out
kindergarten
teachers
’
capability
of
carrying
out
kindergarten
learning
in
Lampung
Province
,
especially
concerning
(
1
)
ability
to
manage
learner
-
centered
learning
,
(
2
)
ability
to
manage
integrative
learning
,
(
3
)
ability
to
manage
learning
systematically
,
(
4
)
ability
to
manage
learning
focused
on
individual
variation
,
(
5
)
ability
to
manage
learning
by
developing
various
communication
,
(
6
)
ability
to
develop
flexible
learning
,
(
7
)
attention
to
direct
experience
for
learner
,
and
(
8
)
proper
evaluation
.
This
research
used
descriptive
method
using
observation
as
the
main
data
collecting
technique
with
10
%
of
2731
kindergarten
teachers
as
population
in
Lampung
Province
,
or
273
kindergarten
teachers
as
sample
throughout
Lampung
Province
.
The
research
result
shows
that
learning
was
generally
teacher
-
centered
with
partially
academic
education
.
In
line
with
this
,
the
direct
involvement
of
learner
was
limited
,
that
is
,
only
to
few
teachers
.
Even
the
themes
selected
could
not
be
used
a
tool
to
form
learner
’
s
behavior
and
to
develop
basic
ability
of
learners
integratively
;
in
contrast
,
the
themes
should
be
memorized
and
comprehended
by
them
.
learning
result
,
all
teachers
were
slightly
able
to
determine
evaluation
tar
get
,
to
perform
evaluation
approach
,
to
select
a
tool
or
standardized
means
,
and
to
use
the
result
of
the
evaluation
.
November
2004
(
Tahun
39
,
Nomor
3
)
Strategi
Golden
Handcuff
untuk
Mempertahankan
Karyawan
Kunci
Perusahaan
(
Bambang
Suyono
,
State
University
of
Malang
)
Abstract
:
In
facing
more
and
more
competitive
rivalry
any
strategies
have
been
attempting
by
companies
in
order
to
get
highly
qualified
human
resources
.
One
of
which
frequently
conducted
by
them
was
through
the
pirating
.
This
was
done
for
the
prospect
of
better
income
than
in
the
old
one
.
When
the
pirating
occurred
,
the
former
company
would
thus
experience
some
losses
.
In
order
for
keeping
the
key
skilled
employees
from
being
encouraged
to
get
another
job
,
it
was
necessary
for
the
company
to
apply
the
handcuff
strategy
.
Model
Pembelajaran
Ekonomi
di
Sekolah
Menengah
Berdasarkan
Kurikulum
Berbasis
Kompetensi
(
Supriyanto
,
State
University
of
Malang
)
Abstract
:
Curriculum
renewal
was
one
of
ways
of
improving
quality
of
education
.
Various
challenges
in
educational
sector
in
Indonesia
should
be
anticipated
in
order
to
get
rid
of
being
left
behind
in
the
technological
advances
.
The
development
of
competence
based
-
curriculum
constitutes
obvious
implementation
of
any
efforts
in
anticipating
the
development
of
educational
sector
in
the
future
.
Economics
learning
model
at
secondary
level
was
taught
of
becoming
one
operational
figure
of
such
curriculum
implementation
.
Analisis
Faktor
-
Faktor
Produksi
untuk
Meningkatkan
Produksi
Gula
pada
Pabrik
Gula
di
Sulawesi
Selatan
(
Amirudin
Tawe
,
State
University
of
Makassar
)
Abstract
:
This
study
was
aimed
at
describing
any
efforts
could
be
conducted
in
order
to
increase
effectiveness
use
of
production
factor
for
sugarcane
in
attempt
of
satisfying
the
need
domestic
sugar
particularly
in
South
Sulawesi
.
The
research
locations
included
PG
(
Sugar
Milling
of
)
Bone
,
PG
Camming
and
PG
Takalar
.
The
data
was
collected
through
both
documentation
and
in
-
depth
interview
with
section
chief
of
each
factory
.
Data
analysis
was
administered
using
the
analysis
of
Cobb
-
Douglas
Production
Function
.
The
results
indicated
that
all
the
three
factories
were
at
the
rate
of
increasing
return
to
scale
.
Therefore
,
it
was
important
for
the
farmer
not
to
use
overdose
fertilizer
for
being
able
to
cause
the
decrease
of
sugarcane
production
.
Motivasi
Kerja
Kelompok
Nelayan
serta
Kaitannya
Dengan
Pengembangan
Agribisnis
di
Wilayah
Kecamatan
Tenga
dan
Tombasian
Amurang
di
Kabupaten
Minahasa
Selatan
(
Sri
Purwaningsih
Siswanto
,
State
University
of
Manado
)
Abstract
:
This
study
was
aimed
at
knowing
how
much
the
effect
of
the
group
members
of
fishermen
'
s
motivation
of
working
on
the
success
of
agribusiness
development
.
This
research
studied
in
360
fishermen
associated
in
24
groups
,
which
was
spread
throughout
the
region
of
Kecamatan
Tenga
and
Tombasin
Amurang
in
South
Minahasa
District
.
Therefore
,
the
variables
of
this
research
came
into
the
work
motivation
among
fishermen
groups
(
as
dependent
variable
)
and
agribusiness
development
(
as
independent
one
)
.
The
data
was
gathered
through
questionnaire
.
The
Correlation
of
Pearson
Product
Moment
was
used
as
the
analysis
method
in
this
study
.
The
results
showed
that
the
value
of
r
=
0
.
725
,
while
the
critical
value
was
0
.
4869
(
0
.
005
)
.
It
could
be
concluded
then
that
there
was
significant
correlation
between
the
group
members
of
fishermen
'
s
motivation
of
working
on
the
success
of
agribusiness
development
within
the
region
of
Kecamatan
Tenga
and
Tombasin
Amurang
in
South
Minahasa
District
.
Analisis
Perkembangan
Teori
Kepemimpinan
(
Rofik
K
.
S
.
,
State
University
of
Malang
)
Abstract
:
Leadership
plays
main
role
in
understanding
group
behaviors
,
because
the
leaders
themselves
who
give
commonly
any
directions
toward
the
goal
achievement
.
Robbin
says
that
leadership
is
the
ability
to
influence
a
group
toward
the
achievement
of
goals
(
2001
,
pp
.
314
)
.
One
great
innovation
in
understanding
of
leadership
appears
when
there
is
recognition
on
the
need
for
developing
contingency
theory
that
includes
situational
factors
.
Studying
some
variants
of
leadership
is
useful
to
determine
what
makes
certain
leadership
effective
,
and
what
distinguishes
between
leader
and
non
-
leader
as
well
.
More
recently
,
neo
-
charismatic
theories
have
been
widely
accepted
.
This
kind
of
leadership
theory
was
more
than
merely
charismatic
ones
.
Budaya
Perusahaan
dan
Penetapan
Pelanggan
yang
Berfokus
pada
Budaya
Kualitas
Total
(
Dwi
Retnani
,
Dr
.
Soetomo
University
Surabaya
)
Abstract
:
The
objectives
of
the
entire
organizations
were
influenced
by
external
factors
,
instead
of
the
internal
factors
such
as
corporate
culture
,
as
among
other
one
.
Organizational
culture
referred
to
such
anything
acceptable
by
common
public
as
attitude
,
norm
,
and
assumptions
that
were
explicitly
and
implicitly
accepted
being
features
of
certain
organization
.
Total
Quality
Management
(
TQM
)
requires
management
develops
cultures
that
would
encourage
the
trust
that
customer
satisfaction
either
internally
or
externally
,
a
set
of
managerial
systems
that
support
the
work
culture
,
and
any
techniques
for
improving
qualities
,
were
important
.
Analisis
Tentang
Otonomi
Daerah
dan
Pembangunan
Ekonomi
Daerah
(
Imam
Kabul
,
Airlangga
University
Surabaya
)
Abstract
:
Regional
autonomy
(
decentralization
system
)
was
grounded
by
any
district
demands
for
the
success
in
the
processes
of
national
economy
development
.
In
autonomy
era
,
regional
or
local
development
gains
exact
momentum
to
be
more
prioritized
and
improved
.
Hence
,
the
strategies
of
regional
economy
development
should
be
formulated
and
implemented
,
so
that
any
conflicts
of
economical
interests
occurred
in
some
regions
can
me
minimized
and
stopped
.
Pengaruh
Disclosure
dan
Trading
Volume
Terhadap
Reaksi
Pasar
pada
Perusahaan
Industri
Tekstil
yang
Go
Public
di
Indonesia
(
Tuhardjo
,
State
University
of
Malang
)
Abstract
:
This
stock
market
based
-
research
was
aimed
at
knowing
the
effect
of
disclosure
and
trading
volume
on
market
reaction
.
The
variable
of
disclosure
was
proxed
with
the
amount
of
bid
-
ask
spreads
,
as
well
as
market
reaction
with
abnormal
return
.
This
event
study
was
administered
at
16
textile
industries
listed
in
Jakarta
Stock
Exchange
,
which
were
taken
using
census
sampling
.
The
observation
was
conducted
on
event
date
,
in
which
each
date
of
trading
for
period
of
2000
and
2001
was
used
,
by
which
data
pooling
was
obtained
,
which
was
the
combination
of
time
series
and
cross
section
.
Using
regression
analysis
,
it
was
found
that
bid
-
ask
spreads
and
trading
volume
gave
significant
effect
on
abnormal
return
,
with
Fcalculation
of
23
.
901
was
higher
than
Ftable
1
.
697
and
R2
was
0
.
6224
.
Partially
,
bid
-
ask
spreads
had
dominant
,
significant
effect
on
abnormal
return
with
r2
was
0
.
3961
.
Faktor
-
Faktor
yang
Mempengaruhi
Perilaku
Konsumen
Melakukan
Pembelian
Air
Minum
Dalam
Kemasan
(
AMDK
)
:
Studi
pada
Mahasiswa
Fakultas
Ekonomi
Unversitas
Negeri
Malang
(
Supriyanto
and
F
.
Bayu
Tri
Kristanto
,
State
University
of
Malang
)
Abstract
:
This
research
had
purpose
to
know
whether
both
internal
factors
consisting
of
motivation
,
perception
,
learning
and
attitude
,
and
such
external
factors
as
culture
,
social
class
,
reference
group
,
or
family
affect
consumer
behaviors
in
purchasing
the
product
of
packaged
drinking
water
.
From
the
perspective
of
the
study
'
s
object
,
this
research
was
Ex
Post
Facto
,
in
which
the
data
was
obtained
using
questionnaire
technique
based
on
accidental
sampling
.
It
could
be
concluded
from
the
research
findings
that
there
was
significant
effect
either
partially
or
simultaneously
among
these
eight
factors
consisting
of
culture
,
social
class
,
reference
groups
,
family
,
motivation
,
perception
,
learning
and
attitude
toward
the
behaviors
of
Economic
Faculty
students
of
State
University
of
Malang
while
purchasing
packaged
-
drinking
water
.
Analisis
Kepuasan
Pelanggan
Dengan
Metode
Regresi
Logistik
(
Heri
Kuswanto
,
State
University
of
Malang
)
Abstract
:
Linear
regression
analysis
was
extensively
used
for
describing
the
relational
pattern
of
independent
variable
and
customer
satisfaction
.
However
,
there
were
many
assumptions
must
be
satisfied
in
using
this
method
.
Likert
scale
was
considered
as
interval
scale
with
which
linear
regression
analysis
was
likely
to
apply
.
On
the
other
side
,
this
scale
was
still
used
as
ordinal
scale
,
by
which
the
interpretation
obtained
became
bias
and
basic
assumptions
could
not
be
met
.
Alternatively
,
logistic
regression
became
regression
model
that
was
able
to
explain
customer
satisfaction
with
binary
scaled
-
dependent
variable
.
The
results
indicated
that
tangible
variable
had
dominant
effect
in
establishing
customer
satisfaction
.
Menumbuhkan
Budaya
Kerja
yang
Kompetitif
(
Bambang
Suyono
,
State
University
of
Malang
)
Abstract
:
Within
global
era
,
competitive
working
culture
was
required
in
order
to
distinguish
the
job
performance
between
one
organization
and
another
.
Work
culture
will
be
reflected
in
the
behaviors
of
organizational
members
and
become
the
guidance
or
direction
for
the
entire
organizational
behaviors
and
providing
service
to
the
consumers
.
The
culture
derived
from
any
values
and
norms
of
individuals
involved
in
the
organization
(
i
.
e
.
,
consumer
value
,
manager
value
,
employee
'
s
value
)
will
be
strongly
rooted
in
every
action
of
the
organization
.
Copyright
©
2005
.
Subag
Sistem
Informasi
BAAKPSI
UM
.
All
Rights
Reserved
.
Contact
Us
-
Back
to
Top
Fakultas
Ekonomi
-
Universitas
Negeri
Malang
Jl
.
Surabaya
6
Malang
65145
Gedung
E3
-
Indonesia
Telp
.
0341
-
551312
psw
.
275
dan
276
,
Fax
.
0341
-
551921
,
E
-
mail
:
PT
INCO
PT
International
Nickel
Indonesia
,
Tbk
PT
INTERNATIONAL
NICKEL
INDONESIA
(
PT
Inco
)
is
a
fully
-
integrated
world
-
class
nickel
mining
and
processing
,
Canadian
-
based
company
,
located
in
Soroako
,
South
Sulawesi
.
In
response
to
our
present
and
future
growths
,
we
are
inviting
high
achieving
professionals
to
fill
the
following
positions
.
An
attractive
remuneration
package
which
includes
highly
competitive
salary
,
other
attractive
benefits
as
well
as
a
challenging
career
path
will
be
offered
to
sucessfull
candidates
.
SENIOR
SUPERVISOR
INVESTIGATION
-
INTELLIGENT
(
code
:
SSII
)
Purpose
of
the
role
:
To
assist
the
manager
in
optimizing
situation
analysis
,
predicting
potential
challenges
,
recommends
and
takes
action
,
based
on
the
data
gathered
from
the
circumference
both
within
and
outside
PTI
.
Requirements
:
1
.
Minimum
D3
degree
majoring
in
social
or
relate
discipline
(
preferable
S1
)
2
.
Having
Intelligent
Skill
back
ground
3
.
Include
5
years
in
Intelligent
department
and
2
years
in
supervisory
,
Familiar
with
the
business
and
community
of
PT
Inco
or
similar
industry
(
preferred
)
.
4
.
Reasonably
Computer
skill
(
excel
,
word
&
power
point
)
5
.
Excellent
Bahasa
Indonesia
,
both
oral
and
written
.
6
.
Good
in
Local
language
(
preferred
)
7
.
Active
English
,
both
oral
and
written
.
CIVIL
/
MECHANICAL
CONSTRUCTION
PLANNER
(
Code
:
CMCP
)
Purpose
of
the
role
:
Making
a
work
plan
,
work
calculate
,
and
work
scheduling
of
Maintenance
work
and
Engineering
work
package
(
EWP
)
for
Civil
and
Mechanical
project
to
meet
the
required
planning
standard
.
Requirements
:
1
.
Minimum
Diploma
(
D3
)
majoring
in
Civil
/
Mechanical
background
.
2
.
Having
3
years
experiences
and
preferably
has
supervisory
experience
exposure
to
construction
projects
and
or
previous
experience
in
a
similar
role
.
3
.
Preferably
has
had
some
field
experience
exposure
to
multidiscipline
projects
.
4
.
Able
to
work
as
Project
Team
member
to
enhance
work
coordination
and
supporting
Constructions
Services
Dept
.
5
.
Solid
understand
of
EHS
practices
and
procedures
.
6
.
Able
to
operate
Microsoft
Project
and
Primavera
Software
is
preferred
.
7
.
Having
experience
in
Heavy
Construction
project
.
8
.
Solid
understanding
of
good
engineering
design
practice
and
technical
drawing
.
9
.
Understand
Scope
of
Work
&
Drawing
in
English
.
10
.
Fluent
in
English
is
essential
.
Application
together
with
CV
,
and
recent
photograph
should
be
submitted
to
the
address
below
not
later
than
September
23
,
2006
after
this
advertisement
date
.
Put
the
position
code
desired
on
the
subject
letter
.
All
applications
will
be
treated
strictly
confidential
and
only
short
-
listed
candidates
will
be
notified
for
interview
RECRUITMENT
SECTION
(
DP
12
)
HUMAN
RESOURCES
-
PT
INCO
Tbk
.
SOROWAKO
SOUTH
SULAWESI
Email
:
pti_recruiting
@
inco
.
com
-----
IMMEDIATELY
REQUIRED
A
Mining
company
in
East
Kalimantan
is
looking
for
the
following
positions
:
1
.
Mine
Manager
-
3
positions
Degree
in
related
field
with
minimum
15
years
working
experience
in
related
field
2
.
Senior
Geologist
-
3
positions
Degree
in
related
field
with
minimum
10
years
working
experience
in
related
field
3
.
Mine
Engineering
-
6
positions
Degree
in
related
field
with
minimum
10
years
working
experience
in
related
field
4
.
Finance
and
Admin
Manager
-
3
positions
Degree
in
related
field
with
minimum
10
years
working
experience
in
related
field
5
.
Public
Relations
Manager
-
3
positions
Degree
in
related
field
with
minimum
10
years
forking
experience
in
related
field
6
.
Plant
/
Machinery
Supervisor
-
6
positions
Degree
in
related
field
with
minimum
6
years
working
experience
in
related
field
7
.
Site
Supervisor
-
9
positions
Degree
in
related
field
with
minimum
2
years
working
experience
in
related
field
8
.
Admin
Clerk
/
Purchasing
Clerk
-
9
positions
Degree
in
related
field
with
minimum
2
years
working
experience
in
related
field
9
.
Receptionist
-
3
positions
Degree
in
related
field
with
minimum
1
year
working
experience
in
related
field
Successful
candidates
will
be
based
in
East
Kalimantan
.
Interviews
shall
be
conducted
in
Balikpapan
.
Interested
Candidates
are
advised
to
submit
their
application
together
with
a
resume
and
a
passport
size
photograph
attentioned
to
:
HR
Department
Galeri
Niaga
Mediterania
Blok
K
8
H
Jl
Pantai
Indah
Utara
2
Pantai
Indah
Kapuk
Jakarta
14460
Indonesia
Closing
date
:
Sunday
,
October
01
,
2006
-----
DIBUTUHKAN
SEGERA
Sebuah
perusahaan
Multinasional
Tambang
Batubara
berlokasi
di
Kabupaten
Mutung
Raya
,
Kalimantan
Tengah
,
membutuhkan
tenaga
kerja
professional
,
mempunyai
track
record
bagus
di
bidangnya
untuk
bergabung
dan
berkembang
bersama
kami
,
dengan
posisi
dan
kualifikasi
sebagai
berikut
:
HR
Superintendent
:
Dapat
mengembangkan
dan
melaksanakan
kebijakan
dan
prosedur
HR
,
termasuk
kegiatan
personnel
dan
administrasi
yaitu
recruiting
,
hubungan
industri
,
pelatihan
,
berpengalaman
dalam
menangani
peraturan
ketenagakerjaan
(
Serikat
Pekerja
,
KKB
)
dan
General
Affair
.
Berpengetahuan
dalam
pengurusan
ijin
perusahaan
(
Pertambangan
dan
Kehutanan
)
.
Dapat
menjalin
hubungan
kerja
sama
dengan
instansi
pemerintah
daerah
,
team
,
kontraktor
dan
berbagai
kalangan
.
Minimal
S1
Management
/
sederajat
dengan
pengalaman
5
tahun
di
bidang
HR
&
payroll
pada
perusahaan
manufacturing
/
industri
dan
lebih
disukai
mempunyai
pengalaman
pada
perusahaan
Tambang
Batubara
.
Bersedia
ditempatkan
di
lokasi
terpencil
,
kemampuan
berkomunikasi
tinggi
,
dapat
mengoperasikan
komputer
dan
menguasai
bahasa
Inggris
.
Jika
kualifikasi
anda
memenuhi
persyaratan
di
atas
,
kinmkan
data
pribadi
yang
terakhir
beserta
dokumen
pelengkap
dan
pas
foto
terbaru
September
30
,
2006
,
ke
alamat
:
HRD
Manager
PO
BOX
7028
/
JKT
.
SA
Jakarta
10350A
atau
e
-
mail
:
c_recruitment
@
yahoo
.
com
Hanya
pelamar
yang
memenuhi
persyaratan
yang
akan
dihubungi
.
-----
PT
PLN
(
PERSERO
)
KESEMPATAN
KERJA
Mari
bergabung
,
berkembang
dan
meniti
karir
bersama
PT
PLN
(
Persero
)
dengan
mengisi
posisi
sebagai
Operator
atau
Teknisi
Pemeliharaan
di
lingkungan
Wilayah
se
-
Sumatera
,
Penyaluran
&
Pusat
Pengatur
Beban
(
P3B
)
Sumatera
dan
Pembangkitan
se
-
Sumatera
.
Lamaran
ditujukan
kepada
:
Konsultan
Rekrutmen
Untuk
Wilayah
Kerja
Nangroe
Aceh
Darussalam
PT
PLN
(
Persero
)
Wilayah
Nangroe
Aceh
Darussalam
PT
PLN
(
Persero
)
Pembangkitan
Sumatera
Bagian
Utara
PT
PLN
(
Persero
)
Penyaluran
&
Pusat
Pengatur
Beban
Sumatera
PO
BOX
234
Banda
Aceh
Untuk
Wilayah
Kerja
Riau
&
Kepulauan
Riau
PT
PLN
(
Persero
)
Wilayah
Riau
&
Kepulauan
Riau
PT
PLN
(
Persero
)
Pembangkitan
Sumatera
Bagian
Utara
PT
PLN
(
Persero
)
Penyaluran
&
Pusat
Pengatur
Beban
Sumatera
PO
BOX
2000
PBR
28000
Untuk
Wilayah
Kerja
Sumatera
Selatan
,
Jambi
&
Bengkulu
PT
PLN
(
Persero
)
Wilayah
Sumatera
Selatan
,
Jambi
&
Bengkulu
PT
PLN
(
Persero
)
Pembangkitan
Sumatera
Bagian
Selatan
PT
PLN
(
Persero
)
Penyaluran
&
Pusat
Pengatur
Beban
Sumatera
PO
BOX
1376
PLG
Untuk
Wilayah
Kerja
Bangka
Belitung
PT
PLN
(
Persero
)
Wilayah
Bangka
Belitung
PO
BOX
150
Pangkal
Pinang
Untuk
Wilayah
Kerja
Sumatera
Utara
PT
PLN
(
Persero
)
Wilayah
Sumatera
Utara
PT
PLN
(
Persero
)
Pembangkitan
Sumatera
Bagian
Utara
PT
PLN
(
Persero
)
Penyaluran
&
Pusat
Pengatur
Beban
Sumatera
PO
BOX
2000
Medan
Untuk
Wilayah
Kerja
Sumatera
Barat
PT
PLN
(
Persero
)
Wilayah
Sumatera
Barat
PT
PLN
(
Persero
)
Pembangkitan
Sumatera
Bagian
Selatan
PT
PLN
(
Persero
)
Penyaluran
&
Pusat
Pengatur
Beban
Sumatera
PO
BOX
3333
Padang
25121
Untuk
Wilayah
Kerja
Lampung
PT
PLN
(
Persero
)
Wilayah
Lampung
PT
PLN
(
Persero
)
Pembangkitan
Sumatera
Bagian
Selatan
PT
PLN
(
Persero
)
Penyaluran
&
Pusat
Pengatur
Beban
Sumatera
PO
BOX
6666
BDL
35001
Persyaratan
Umum
:
a
.
Laki
-
laki
,
belum
menikah
dan
sanggup
tidak
menikah
selama
masa
On
The
Job
Training
.
b
.
Ijazah
/
sertifikat
paling
rendah
D1
bidang
Teknik
Mesin
,
Listrik
,
Elektronika
,
Telekomunikasi
,
Informatika
atau
Komputer
.
c
.
Maksimal
kelahiran
tanggal
31
Desember
1983
atau
setelahnya
.
d
.
Berbadan
sehat
dan
tidak
buta
warna
.
e
.
Tinggi
badan
paling
rendah
160
cm
dengan
berat
badan
proporsional
.
f
.
Sehat
jasmani
dan
rohani
untuk
melaksanakan
fungsi
sebagai
operator
atau
teknisi
pemeliharaan
.
Lamaran
Kami
Terima
Paling
Lambat
Tanggal
30
September
2006
(
Stempel
Pos
)
Lamaran
dilampiri
:
1
.
Fotocopy
ijazah
/
sertifikat
/
surat
Keterangan
Lulus
dan
transkrip
yang
dilegalisir
.
2
.
Fotocopy
akte
kelahiran
dan
KTP
yang
masih
berlaku
.
3
.
Daftar
Riwayat
Hidup
.
4
.
Pas
foto
berwarna
terbaru
ukuran
4x6
sebanyak
3
lembar
.
5
.
Surat
Keterangan
berbadan
sehat
dan
tidak
buta
warna
dari
Dokter
.
6
.
Surat
pernyataan
diri
di
atas
materai
Rp
6
.
000
,
-
bahwa
tidak
pernah
terlibat
dalam
penyalahgunaan
Narkoba
dan
Zat
Adiktif
lainnya
.
7
.
Surat
pernyataan
diri
di
atas
materai
Rp
6
.
000
,
-
tentang
kesanggupan
bekerja
sebagai
operator
atau
teknisi
pemeliharaan
dan
tidak
akan
menuntut
pengakuan
atas
ijazah
yang
dimiliki
(
untuk
pelamar
yang
memiliki
ijazah
lebih
tinggi
dari
D1
,
missal
D3
atau
S1
)
,
serta
bersedia
ditempatkan
di
Wilayah
se
-
Sumatera
.
8
.
Alamat
pelamar
lengkap
dengan
kode
pos
untuk
panggilan
tes
.
Informasi
selengkapnya
kunjungi
website
:
http
:
//
www
.
plnsumut
.
co
.
id
Lain
-
lain
:
TIDAK
DIPUNGUT
BIAYA
APAPUN
HANYA
YANG
MEMENUHI
PERSYARATAN
YANG
AKAN
DIPANGGIL
TIDAK
ADA
KORESPONDENSI
KEPUTUSAN
PANITIA
TIDAK
DIGANGGU
GUGAT
-----
We
are
an
industry
leader
built
on
teamwork
looking
for
more
talented
players
.
Shell
was
established
in
Indonesia
more
than
a
century
ago
.
Today
Shell
is
a
global
company
operation
in
140
countries
and
regions
throughout
the
world
and
employing
approximately
109
,
000
people
.
In
Indonesia
,
Shell
is
a
fast
growing
lubricants
,
fuels
,
retail
petrol
stations
and
bitumen
business
and
has
a
strong
commitment
to
strengthening
still
further
its
presence
in
the
country
.
Construction
Engineer
Responsibilities
:
Build
retail
outlets
whilst
enforcing
standards
of
Shell
General
Business
Principles
and
HSSE
.
Obtain
construction
permits
,
manage
the
performance
of
civil
contractors
,
as
well
as
complete
construction
projects
within
time
,
cost
and
quality
objectives
.
Requirements
:
Essential
:
Degree
in
Civil
Engineering
Past
construction
experience
(
preferably
of
medium
scale
projects
)
Safety
and
quality
experience
Evidence
of
project
management
Vendor
and
contractor
management
Past
government
liaison
work
desirable
Desktop
Network
Planner
Responsibilities
:
Support
the
Network
Manager
to
identify
market
areas
and
land
acquisition
prospects
Conduct
market
studies
on
feasible
locations
for
retail
outlets
and
identify
specific
locations
within
targeted
areas
.
Strategies
land
acquisition
method
,
negotiate
with
agents
and
landowners
and
close
deals
following
complete
due
diligence
.
Prepare
all
necessary
items
needed
to
apply
for
construction
permits
.
Conduct
post
investment
reviews
.
Requirements
:
Essential
:
Degree
in
any
field
of
study
.
Desireable
:
MBA
10
years
'
experience
in
the
real
estate
industry
Strong
communication
skills
Fluent
in
written
and
spoken
English
and
Bahasa
Indonesia
Competency
in
investment
decision
models
.
Network
Planner
Responsibilities
:
Acquire
land
for
retail
network
expansion
Conduct
market
study
of
suitable
locations
for
retail
outlets
,
execute
the
site
acquisition
process
,
secure
the
site
and
prepare
applications
for
construction
permits
.
Requirements
:
Essential
:
Degree
in
any
field
of
study
Five
years
'
real
estate
experience
Experience
in
investment
decision
models
Strong
negotiation
skills
Fluent
in
English
and
Bahasa
Indonesia
Business
writing
skills
.
Retail
Liaison
Manager
Responsibilities
:
You
will
support
the
General
Manager
in
the
engagement
of
external
stakeholders
and
various
special
projects
.
Principally
involved
with
engagement
of
stakeholders
at
the
business
level
(
key
external
stakeholders
are
the
ministers
and
regulators
involved
in
the
oil
and
gas
industry
)
.
A
substantial
component
of
the
job
will
also
involve
special
projects
.
Requirements
:
Essential
:
Degree
in
any
field
of
study
Desirable
:
MBA
10
years
'
experience
in
an
MNC
environment
Past
government
liaison
work
desireable
Fluent
in
written
and
spoken
English
.
Presentation
skills
especially
in
Bahasa
Indonesia
.
Marketing
Implementer
&
Category
Manager
Responsibilities
:
Work
with
Marketing
Manager
,
Sales
and
Operations
as
well
as
advertising
agency
to
implement
marketing
programmes
(
i
.
e
.
,
fuels
promotions
,
lubes
promotions
,
site
openings
,
store
promotions
,
etc
.
)
Brand
&
Communications
adapt
global
materials
and
development
of
new
communications
materials
for
Shell
Retail
Indonesia
,
interface
with
advertising
agency
,
as
well
as
Sales
and
Operations
On
site
implementation
communicate
with
Sales
and
Operations
to
ensure
smooth
handover
of
marketing
programmes
and
assist
with
execution
(
logistics
)
Marketing
Implementer
play
a
key
role
in
coordination
of
the
annual
marketing
planning
process
,
execute
the
agreed
marketing
plan
in
Indonesia
,
as
well
as
develop
a
`
Promotional
Planner
'
system
for
coordinating
work
with
advertising
agency
to
deliver
agreed
promotions
to
retail
outlets
in
a
rapidly
expanding
network
Category
Manager
drive
delivery
of
Convenience
Retail
Shop
(
CR
)
performance
according
to
the
plan
,
establish
trading
terms
with
top
10
suppliers
,
agree
with
in
store
promotions
on
six
promotion
periods
a
year
(
one
counter
offer
,
one
Gondola
end
offer
)
.
Requirements
:
Work
within
the
principles
and
guidelines
defined
by
Global
Brand
&
Marketing
organization
.
Committed
to
customers
Action
oriented
and
have
a
sense
of
reality
(
taking
verbal
briefs
,
interpreting
business
requirements
)
Excellent
relationship
skills
(
stakeholder
management
is
a
key
component
of
this
role
)
Attention
to
detail
Negotiation
skills
Merchandising
experience
or
capacity
to
be
trained
as
an
expert
in
this
area
.
Bachelor
'
s
Degree
from
a
reputable
university
.
For
further
job
details
and
to
apply
online
,
please
visit
our
careers
website
and
select
`
Experienced
Professional
Job
Search
&
Apply
Region
Asia
'
.
Closing
Date
:
1
October
2006
Shell
is
an
Equal
Opportunity
Employer
www
.
shell
.
com
/
careers
------
URGENTLY
REQUIRED
We
are
fast
growing
service
company
for
the
oil
and
gas
.
We
are
currently
looking
for
qualified
personnel
for
the
position
as
follow
:
1
.
IT
Manager
/
Sr
.
Manager
(
Code
:
IT
Mgr
)
2
.
Mechanic
/
Electric
Spv
for
Heavy
Transportation
(
Code
:
M
/
E
.
Transp
)
3
.
Mechanic
/
Electric
Spv
for
Workshop
(
Code
:
M
/
E
Work
)
4
.
Mechanical
/
Electric
al
engineer
(
Code
:
Engineer
)
5
.
Management
Trainee
for
Elect
,
Mech
,
Technical
,
Mgmt
(
Code
:
MT
)
6
.
HES
Officer
/
Supervisor
(
Code
:
HES
)
7
.
Rig
Superintendent
(
Code
:
Rig
Supt
)
8
.
Tool
Pusher
(
Code
:
TP
)
9
.
Driller
(
Code
:
Driller
)
General
Qualification
:
Diploma
,
S1
degree
from
a
reputable
university
,
with
GPA
min
.
3
.
00
Min
.
2
years
work
experience
in
the
same
position
Expect
for
(
Code
:
MT
)
fresh
graduate
are
welcome
Have
a
self
motivation
,
integrity
,
hard
working
and
team
spirit
Fluent
in
English
both
written
and
oral
Able
to
work
under
pressure
and
meets
deadline
Especially
for
(
Code
:
IT
Mgr
)
Good
skill
and
experienced
in
database
management
system
Experience
in
ERP
/
SCM
application
is
in
advantage
Having
experienced
in
ORACLE
EBS
11
(
Linux
OS
)
is
important
Experienced
in
managing
IT
assets
and
service
(
server
,
LAN
,
internet
security
,
email
,
storage
database
,
warehousing
data
,
disaster
recovery
,
v
-
sat
,
web
,
etc
)
If
you
are
interested
and
having
the
above
required
qualification
,
please
send
your
CV
,
expected
salary
,
latest
transcript
,
recent
photograph
,
contact
number
,
by
stating
the
code
on
your
envelope
or
subject
not
later
than
September
30
,
2006
to
:
PO
BOX
2964
JKP
10029
Only
short
listed
candidate
will
be
notified
.
------
CAREER
OPPORTUNITIES
We
are
a
growing
Oil
&
Gas
Company
operating
two
PSC
areas
in
Riau
Province
.
We
are
looking
for
talented
individuals
to
fill
in
vacant
positions
in
our
Jakarta
based
offices
.
SENIOR
GEOLOGIST
(
1
)
Major
Responsibilities
:
Responsible
for
planning
and
execution
of
the
company
'
s
G
&
G
activities
on
development
and
exploration
work
programs
;
Provide
mentoring
to
the
more
junior
geologist
;
Responsible
for
well
site
geological
operations
and
well
evaluation
program
including
electric
and
mud
log
interpretation
,
and
well
site
geological
supervision
;
Deal
with
contractors
/
consultants
performing
ancillary
studies
and
services
such
as
core
studies
,
biostratigraphy
,
mud
logging
electric
logging
,
rock
analyses
,
and
surveys
;
Liaise
with
BPMIGAS
to
provide
required
technical
reports
and
geological
recommendations
and
secure
development
and
exploration
budget
and
AFE
approvals
.
Requirement
:
The
incumbent
shall
be
Indonesian
National
,
has
a
minimum
of
S1
degree
in
geology
from
a
reputable
University
with
a
minimum
of
10
years
of
progressive
experience
in
oil
and
gas
exploration
/
exploitation
,
with
at
least
3
years
of
exposure
in
supervisory
roles
.
SENIOR
FACILITIES
&
CONSTRUCTION
ENGINEER
(
2
)
Major
Responsibilities
:
Responsible
for
the
development
of
production
facilities
conceptual
and
detailed
engineering
designs
.
Be
involved
in
the
leading
role
in
the
development
of
tender
documents
for
facilities
construction
projects
;
Supervise
the
execution
of
facilities
;
Liaise
with
BPMIGAS
to
provide
required
technical
reports
and
engineering
recommendations
and
secure
budget
,
AFE
and
project
tender
approvals
.
Requirement
:
The
incumbent
shall
be
Indonesian
Nationals
,
has
a
minimum
of
S1
degree
in
petroleum
,
chemical
,
mechanical
,
or
electrical
engineering
from
a
reputable
University
with
a
minimum
of
10
years
of
progressive
experience
in
oil
and
gas
production
facilities
construction
and
operations
,
with
at
least
3
years
of
exposure
in
project
supervisory
roles
.
SENIOR
PETROLEUM
ENGINEER
(
3
)
Major
Responsibilities
:
Responsible
for
gas
reservoir
management
activities
;
Develop
reservoir
models
and
production
simulations
;
Develop
gas
reserves
depletion
and
deliverability
plans
to
meet
existing
and
future
gas
sales
;
Define
and
propose
development
drilling
programs
;
Define
and
propose
facilities
installation
requirements
;
Evaluate
the
economics
of
various
development
investment
options
;
Liaise
with
BPMIGAS
to
provide
required
technical
reports
and
reservoir
management
recommendations
and
secure
budget
,
and
AFE
approvals
.
Requirement
:
The
incumbent
shall
be
Indonesian
National
,
has
a
minimum
of
S1
degree
in
petroleum
or
chemical
engineering
from
a
reputable
University
with
a
minimum
of
10
years
of
progressive
experience
in
reservoir
or
production
engineering
activities
,
with
at
least
3
years
of
exposure
in
supervisory
roles
.
EXTERNAL
RELATIONS
COORDINATOR
(
4
)
Major
Responsibilities
:
Responsible
for
promoting
and
maintaining
healthy
work
relations
with
the
stakeholders
which
include
local
communities
,
local
government
entities
,
and
non
-
government
bodies
;
Responsible
for
the
development
of
social
,
community
relations
and
community
development
programs
;
Liaise
with
BPMIGAS
to
provide
required
public
relations
reports
and
secure
approvals
on
work
program
and
budget
for
community
development
activities
.
Requirement
:
The
incumbent
shall
be
Indonesian
National
,
has
a
minimum
of
S1
degree
in
communication
,
law
,
social
politics
,
psychology
,
or
anthropology
from
a
reputable
University
with
a
minimum
of
10
years
of
progressive
experience
in
community
and
public
relations
activities
.
Specific
requirement
:
Proficiency
in
English
writing
and
spoken
language
is
a
must
(
1
,
2
,
3
)
Has
exceptional
communication
and
interpersonal
skills
(
4
)
If
you
are
interested
and
meet
the
above
requirements
,
please
write
down
the
position
you
are
applying
and
send
your
application
together
with
your
CV
to
:
hr
.
bentu
@
energi
-
mp
.
com
not
later
than
29
September
2006
.
Only
short
listed
candidates
will
be
contacted
for
further
interview
.
------
Eni
Indonesia
Senior
Exploration
Geologist
Location
:
Jakarta
Company
overview
Eni
is
a
major
integrated
international
oil
and
gas
company
based
in
Italy
,
with
interests
in
70
different
countries
,
and
employs
some
71
,
500
people
worldwide
.
Eni
has
been
exploring
and
producing
hydrocarbons
for
almost
eighty
years
.
Eni
has
Exploration
&
Production
activities
in
Italy
,
West
and
North
Africa
,
US
,
South
America
,
North
Sea
,
Kazakhstan
and
Asia
.
Eni
Indonesia
participates
in
ten
PSCs
in
Indonesia
,
including
nine
in
Deep
Water
,
and
is
pursuing
an
active
exploration
and
development
program
with
drilling
activities
to
commence
in
late
2006
.
Position
requirements
A
University
degree
in
geology
is
a
prerequisite
.
You
should
have
10
to
15
years
experience
in
Petroleum
Exploration
.
Your
experience
should
include
delivering
integrated
subsurface
and
prospectivity
evaluations
both
at
regional
and
at
prospect
scale
,
and
generating
well
proposals
.
You
must
be
able
to
carry
out
qualitative
well
log
analyses
and
correlations
,
build
structural
models
,
and
apply
seismostratigraphic
concepts
in
your
work
.
Good
knowledge
of
Schlumberger
(
Well
Composite
Plus
,
Well
Picks
,
etc
.
)
and
Landmark
(
Stratworks
)
interpretation
systems
is
important
,
as
are
skills
in
basin
modeling
software
and
reservoir
modeling
tools
(
i
:
e
Petrel
software
)
.
You
must
be
a
good
communicator
with
highly
effective
multi
-
disciplinary
team
working
skills
.
Previous
coaching
experience
is
a
plus
.
Position
responsibilities
Your
role
will
involve
supporting
the
integrated
team
in
defining
and
delineating
hydrocarbon
plays
,
and
using
all
available
data
in
generating
a
ranked
prospect
portfolio
in
order
to
propose
a
sound
drilling
strategy
.
You
will
be
expected
to
take
a
lead
role
in
stimulating
and
guiding
the
implementation
of
the
very
latest
technologies
and
ideas
in
liaison
with
our
Research
&
Development
group
in
Milan
.
Your
other
responsibilities
will
include
participating
in
data
room
reviews
in
support
of
new
business
opportunity
evaluations
and
coaching
less
experienced
geoscientists
in
the
correct
application
of
all
geophysical
techniques
and
in
the
proper
integration
of
other
discipline
data
into
the
final
deliverables
.
Please
apply
no
later
than
two
weeks
after
this
advertisement
to
:
Vicky
Aziz
/
Sergio
A
.
Laura
PO
Box
3260
Jakarta
10000
Please
note
that
applications
may
not
be
reviewed
if
received
after
the
30th
September
2006
.
-----
EMPLOYMENT
OPPORTUNITIES
AT
CONOCOPHILLIPS
ConocoPhillips
is
an
international
,
integrated
energy
company
headquartered
in
Houston
,
Texas
,
and
operating
in
more
than
40
countries
.
As
a
Production
Sharing
Contractor
,
for
BPMIGAS
,
we
operate
many
producing
and
exploration
blocks
in
Indonesia
.
To
support
our
expanding
operations
in
Indonesia
,
ConocoPhillips
is
looking
for
talented
Indonesian
nationals
to
fill
in
the
following
position
.
TEAM
LEADER
-
BUSINESS
ANALYSIS
Key
Responsibilities
:
Mentor
coach
and
train
the
business
analysts
within
the
Business
Analysis
team
and
identify
appropriate
training
/
development
opportunities
.
Timely
and
accurate
reporting
and
analysis
of
relevant
Production
activities
,
including
ensuring
consistency
/
integrity
of
data
,
and
ensuring
reporting
related
to
Production
activities
are
done
appropriately
in
compliance
with
PSC
Accounting
,
U
.
S
.
GAAP
and
other
Corporate
Financial
policies
.
Be
key
finance
point
of
contact
for
the
relevant
Production
assets
.
Be
advisor
to
the
relevant
Production
Manager
on
matters
related
to
accounting
and
finance
.
Identify
and
implement
improvements
in
financial
processes
to
increase
efficiency
and
accuracy
across
the
Production
function
,
including
streamlining
the
financial
reporting
process
.
Lead
benchmarking
initiatives
for
relevant
assets
.
Qualifications
and
Experience
:
Bachelor
'
s
Degree
or
higher
in
Accounting
,
Finance
or
Economics
with
a
minimum
Grade
Point
Average
of
3
.
5
from
a
reputable
university
.
Minimum
of
seven
(
7
)
years
of
relevant
working
experience
.
Internationally
recognized
qualification
or
certification
(
CPA
/
CIMA
/
ACCA
)
would
be
an
advantage
.
Strong
analytical
and
leadership
skills
.
Must
have
good
oral
and
written
communication
skills
-
both
Indonesian
and
English
.
High
proficiency
in
using
Microsoft
Office
applications
,
including
Microsoft
Excel
,
Power
Point
and
Project
.
Those
who
are
interested
and
meet
the
above
requirements
,
write
down
THE
POSITION
TITLE
you
apply
in
the
subject
of
your
email
.
Send
your
application
and
CV
not
later
than
September
30
,
2006
to
:
RSCIndonesiaRecruit
ment
@
conocophill
ips
.
com
Only
short
listed
candidates
will
be
contacted
for
further
interview
.
-----
Closing
date
:
Tuesday
,
October
03
,
2006
Weatherford
,
a
multi
-
national
company
who
are
involved
in
the
drilling
and
production
sectors
of
oil
,
gas
and
geothermal
projects
worldwide
,
are
seeking
an
enthusiastic
,
hard
-
working
and
motivated
individual
to
fill
the
position
of
:
1
.
Invoicing
Officer
Min
.
2
years
plus
work
experience
in
the
similar
job
Work
experience
in
Oil
&
Gas
Industry
is
an
advantage
Hold
a
bachelor
or
S1
degree
in
Accounting
or
Economics
Proficiency
in
English
Communication
Interested
and
qualified
candidates
only
can
send
your
complete
resume
in
English
with
a
record
photograph
.
NOTE
:
Only
candidates
that
meet
the
above
qualification
will
be
shortlisted
.
Please
send
it
to
:
jakarta
.
recruitment
@
ap
.
weatherford
.
com
Please
put
IO
as
the
subject
of
your
e
-
mail
------
Closing
date
:
Monday
,
October
02
,
2006
PT
Weatherford
,
a
multi
-
national
company
who
are
involved
in
the
drilling
and
production
sectors
of
oil
,
gas
and
geothermal
projects
worldwide
,
are
seeking
an
enthusiastic
,
hard
-
working
and
motivated
individual
to
fill
the
position
of
:
Tender
and
Contract
Administrator
(
TCA
)
(
2
positions
)
Qualifications
Required
:
Possess
University
/
Diploma
degree
.
Have
experience
in
Oil
and
Gas
Industries
.
Should
possess
general
knowledge
of
Tender
processes
under
BP
Migas
regulations
.
Possess
good
computer
skills
such
as
Microsoft
Word
,
Microsoft
Excel
,
Email
and
Internet
Applications
.
Able
to
speak
fluent
English
and
write
good
English
.
Good
interpersonal
skills
.
Should
be
able
to
work
under
pressure
and
tight
deadline
.
Willing
to
work
outside
normal
work
hours
when
needed
.
Interested
and
qualified
candidates
only
can
send
your
complete
resume
in
English
with
a
record
photograph
.
NOTE
:
Only
candidates
that
meet
the
above
qualification
will
be
shortlisted
.
Please
mark
on
the
top
right
side
of
your
envelope
the
position
that
you
are
applying
for
and
send
to
:
Jakarta
.
recruitment
@
ap
.
weatherford
.
com
or
Attn
.
Human
Resource
Manager
PO
BOX
4077
/
JKTJ
13040
------
HALLIBURTON
As
a
Global
Company
in
the
Oil
and
Gas
Service
Industry
,
Halliburton
delivers
Expertise
,
Service
,
Speed
and
New
Technology
leading
the
world
in
Integrated
Energy
Services
,
Engineering
,
Construction
and
Maintenance
.
To
support
our
operations
in
Indonesia
.
We
are
seeking
highly
qualified
candidates
for
the
following
position
:
Technical
Professional
Log
Analyst
,
Associate
Assists
in
making
recommendations
to
customers
for
well
completions
or
new
well
sites
,
Conducts
work
requiring
judgment
in
the
independent
evaluation
,
selection
,
and
adaptation
of
engineering
techniques
,
procedures
,
and
criteria
.
Maintains
an
awareness
of
new
technologies
.
Responsible
for
monitoring
the
quality
of
tool
and
log
response
based
upon
hole
conditions
,
geology
,
and
reservoir
fluid
properties
.
Requirements
:
1
.
Minimum
education
S
-
1
(
Geological
and
Geophysicist
)
2
.
Have
experience
in
some
petrophysical
work
minimum
1
year
3
.
Proficiency
in
Microsoft
Windows
,
Excel
,
Word
,
etc
.
4
.
Fluency
in
english
both
written
and
spoken
5
.
Good
interpersonal
skill
and
ability
to
communicate
with
others
effectively
6
.
Willing
to
be
placed
anywhere
in
Indonesia
7
.
Willing
and
able
to
work
under
pressure
and
demanding
environment
Only
candidates
who
meet
the
qualifications
and
experience
are
invited
to
apply
.
Please
send
detailed
resumes
and
application
letters
only
.
No
other
documents
are
required
at
this
point
.
PT
.
Halliburton
Indonesia
PO
Box
7575
/
JKSCCE
12560
Jakarta
Indonesia
or
e
-
mail
at
recruitment
.
indonesia
@
halliburton
.
com
Please
put
the
position
applied
for
at
the
top
left
of
the
envelope
and
on
the
subject
if
you
send
by
e
-
mail
&
no
more
than
September
30
,
2006
.
Only
short
-
listed
candidates
will
be
contacted
-----
Closing
date
:
Saturday
,
September
30
,
2006
HALLIBURTON
As
a
Global
Company
in
the
Oil
and
Gas
Service
Industry
,
Halliburton
delivers
Expertise
,
Service
,
Speed
and
New
Technology
leading
the
world
in
Integrated
Energy
Services
,
Engineering
,
Construction
and
Maintenance
.
To
support
our
operations
in
Saudi
Arabia
.
We
are
seeking
qualified
candidates
for
the
following
position
:
Cement
Service
Supervisor
Under
general
supervision
,
coordinates
and
oversees
cementing
service
line
work
at
the
well
site
,
providing
quality
service
to
the
customer
.
Coordinates
and
directs
the
activities
of
service
operators
.
Coordinates
the
clean
up
,
repair
,
and
preparation
of
equipment
for
the
next
job
.
Plans
and
performs
necessary
calculations
for
the
total
job
at
the
well
site
as
needed
.
Evaluates
individual
performance
levels
of
the
crew
and
trains
operators
to
improve
their
job
performance
.
Demonstrates
proficiency
in
the
operation
and
maintenance
of
each
type
of
equipment
/
unit
/
tool
normally
used
in
the
product
service
line
.
Has
exceptional
skills
within
the
service
line
and
a
general
understanding
of
other
service
functions
.
Work
schedule
will
be
rotational
or
live
-
in
.
Requirements
:
1
.
Minimum
education
-
high
school
diploma
.
2
.
Have
Experience
as
Cementer
minimum
4
Years
.
3
.
Offshore
experience
a
plus
.
4
.
Good
communication
skills
in
English
.
5
.
Team
player
.
6
.
Computer
skills
(
MS
Office
)
.
Only
candidates
who
meet
the
qualifications
and
experience
are
invited
to
apply
.
Please
email
detailed
resumes
and
application
letters
to
:
Saudihr
@
Halliburton
.
com
Only
short
-
listed
candidates
will
be
contacted
-----
bp
Lenders
Liaison
Manager
(
Environmental
and
Social
)
BACKGROUND
:
Tangguh
is
a
significant
new
LNG
project
in
Bintuni
area
in
Irian
Jaya
Barat
province
.
The
project
is
taking
place
in
a
complex
environmental
and
social
setting
,
it
entails
significant
potential
environmental
and
social
impacts
.
The
.
project
is
committed
to
ensure
that
Tangguh
will
be
a
catalyst
for
the
sustainable
development
of
Papua
through
our
implementation
of
a
comprehensive
Integrated
Social
Program
.
Tangguh
project
is
partially
financed
through
loan
financing
with
various
lenders
and
the
loan
agreements
require
that
the
project
meets
a
variety
of
social
and
environmental
standards
which
complement
to
the
project
own
corporate
standards
and
commitment
under
both
international
standards
and
the
project
'
s
Environmental
Impact
Assessment
(
AMDAL
)
and
Land
Acquisition
and
Resettlement
Action
Plan
(
LARAP
)
.
The
agreements
stipulate
that
the
lenders
will
establish
an
External
Panel
of
relevant
experts
who
will
monitor
and
report
on
BP
'
s
Tangguh
social
and
environmental
performance
.
ROLES
&
RESPONSIBILITIES
:
The
post
holder
reports
to
Tangguh
Project
Business
Manager
-
a
member
of
Tangguh
Project
Senior
Leadership
team
.
The
post
holder
will
be
required
to
liaise
closely
with
other
teams
within
the
project
integrating
inputs
on
diverse
areas
including
notably
the
Integrated
Social
Programs
team
,
the
Environmental
Management
,
Project
execution
teams
,
and
other
departments
within
the
project
.
Develop
a
close
working
relationship
with
the
lending
banks
and
with
the
External
Panel
of
experts
.
Set
the
yearly
agenda
of
meetings
and
visits
for
the
lenders
and
the
External
Panel
in
relation
to
the
project
.
Plan
,
organize
,
and
lead
the
regular
field
trips
by
the
Lenders
and
the
External
Panel
(
six
monthly
for
resettlement
and
social
programs
,
yearly
for
environmental
)
.
Complete
a
visit
report
for
each
visit
which
details
actions
arising
.
Plan
,
organize
and
facilitate
Lenders
Consultants
visits
to
site
as
required
.
Liaise
with
other
teams
to
develop
a
detailed
understanding
of
our
various
commitments
and
implementation
.
Develop
,
monitor
and
own
a
matrix
of
commitments
which
details
responsibilities
and
accountabilities
for
delivery
and
an
execution
plan
aligns
with
Project
schedule
.
Lead
and
deliver
an
effective
process
which
monitors
and
evaluates
our
compliance
with
the
lenders
requirements
and
highlights
any
instances
of
non
-
compliance
.
Upon
completion
of
the
External
Panel
'
s
visit
to
the
Project
,
develop
a
clear
corrective
action
plan
with
the
Project
Execution
team
,
monitor
progress
to
this
plan
and
close
out
.
Upon
receipt
of
the
External
Panel
'
s
report
,
deliver
the
corrective
action
plans
to
the
External
Panel
.
Prepare
twice
yearly
reports
to
the
lenders
and
the
External
Panel
.
REQUIREMENTS
:
Bachelor
degree
in
Economics
,
Finance
,
Political
/
Social
Science
,
Environmental
management
Minimum
10
year
experience
working
in
international
institution
.
Proven
track
record
in
delivering
cohesive
high
standard
reporting
on
complex
issues
to
high
level
clients
such
as
NGO
,
banks
,
institutions
.
First
class
English
and
report
writing
skills
.
Knowledge
of
national
/
internatio
nal
standards
applicable
to
development
projects
in
remote
areas
(
for
example
:
World
Bank
standards
,
Asian
Development
Bank
standards
,
the
Equator
Principles
and
the
Voluntary
Principles
on
Security
and
Human
Rights
,
AMDAL
)
Engaging
with
external
at
high
level
&
working
level
.
Experience
in
highly
complex
project
setting
.
Experience
as
journalist
,
auditor
for
project
management
is
desirable
.
Come
and
make
a
difference
with
us
!
To
find
out
more
and
to
apply
please
visit
www
.
bp
.
com
/
careers
/
indonesia
Closing
date
:
30
Sept
.
2006
------
bp
Subsea
Operations
Team
Leader
Description
:
BP
West
Java
operations
have
over
200
offshore
oil
and
gas
structures
and
more
than
370
subsea
pipelines
with
total
length
greater
than
1
,
200
kms
.
The
vast
majority
of
this
infrastructure
is
over
twenty
years
old
and
as
such
,
there
are
considerable
integrity
management
issues
to
be
dealt
with
.
These
include
not
only
continuation
of
the
ongoing
inspection
,
survey
and
certification
program
,
but
also
an
extensive
maintenance
and
repair
campaign
for
both
structures
and
pipelines
expected
to
take
several
years
to
implement
.
An
experienced
subsea
operations
team
leader
is
required
to
manage
these
efforts
and
the
subsea
contractors
deployed
to
the
work
.
This
position
of
Subsea
Operations
Team
Leader
is
within
the
BP
West
Java
Integrity
and
Engineering
Support
Department
,
reporting
to
its
manager
.
The
Subsea
Operations
Team
Leader
must
work
closely
with
the
Mechanical
Integrity
Team
and
Operations
staff
to
assure
work
efforts
are
aligned
to
business
needs
.
The
position
'
s
duties
includes
frequent
interactions
with
Senior
Management
.
Roles
&
Responsibilities
:
Plan
and
manage
the
execution
of
all
subsea
inspection
,
maintenance
and
repair
(
IMR
)
operations
.
Performance
and
delivery
of
approved
subsea
programs
.
Manage
a
small
BP
team
and
a
number
of
individual
highly
specialized
contracts
including
diving
,
ROV
,
analogue
,
digital
survey
and
engineering
.
Control
,
management
and
efficiency
of
subsea
IMR
budgets
and
spends
.
Be
responsible
for
maintenance
of
BP
Group
mandates
relating
to
health
,
safety
and
environment
(
HSE
)
for
subsea
operations
,
and
be
the
expert
source
for
all
diving
and
ROV
related
issues
.
HSE
responsible
person
for
subsea
operations
:
maintenance
of
Subsea
Safety
Management
Systems
.
Set
and
develop
competencies
of
team
;
training
,
coaching
and
succession
planning
.
With
Mechanical
Integrity
Team
,
develop
scope
of
work
,
lead
AFE
approvals
and
tendering
processes
,
participate
in
award
selections
and
manage
subsea
operations
contracts
.
Interface
with
other
PSCs
to
leverage
efficiencies
of
spend
.
Technical
representative
for
BP
in
subsea
related
dealings
with
legislative
bodies
,
partners
and
competitors
.
Provide
technical
advice
and
leadership
to
ensure
that
an
integrated
BP
and
contactor
team
is
seamless
and
delivering
world
-
class
results
.
Interface
with
other
Engineering
Teams
and
Operations
managers
to
ensure
full
integration
and
alignment
.
Enable
the
transfer
of
best
practice
and
operational
experience
in
the
area
of
subsea
operations
/
engineering
and
contract
management
.
Participation
in
subsea
regional
and
BP
Global
forums
.
Requirements
:
Bachelor
Degree
in
relevant
engineering
field
.
Minimum
10
years
experience
in
the
oil
and
gas
industry
with
significant
exposure
to
subsea
construction
and
/
or
IMR
operations
.
Strong
project
management
skills
and
experience
.
Strong
contract
management
/
leadership
skills
and
experience
.
Knowledge
of
global
subsea
contractors
,
their
capabilities
and
supporting
marine
vessel
characteristics
.
PSC
team
leadership
experience
a
plus
.
Previous
responsibility
implementing
and
maintaining
HSE
management
systems
.
Good
working
knowledge
of
Integrity
Management
and
solid
skills
,
knowledge
of
subsea
operations
and
engineering
.
Experience
with
ROV
,
diving
,
and
AD
survey
operations
,
in
terms
of
equipment
,
vessels
and
IMR
methods
.
Significant
experience
in
engineering
and
installation
as
applicable
to
jackets
,
pipelines
,
SBMs
and
FSOs
,
particularly
for
brown
-
field
activities
.
Familiarity
with
subsea
inspection
and
monitoring
techniques
.
Subsea
maintenance
&
repair
techniques
(
all
facilities
)
.
Data
base
management
,
GIS
,
and
geo
-
science
.
Come
and
make
a
difference
with
us
!
To
find
out
more
and
to
apply
please
visit
www
.
bp
.
com
/
careers
/
indonesia
Closing
date
:
30
Sept
.
2006
ICIS
II
'
s
Program
of
Action
Thrusday
,
22
June
2006
23
:
48
WIB
Program
of
Action
To
Uphold
Islam
as
Rahmatan
lil
Alamin
Toward
Global
Justice
and
Peace
The
second
International
Conference
of
Islamic
Scholars
,
Recalling
the
Jakarta
Declaration
and
Plan
of
Action
adopted
at
the
First
International
Conference
of
Islamic
Scholars
(
ICIS
)
in
February
2004
;
Reaffirming
our
commitment
to
the
purposes
and
principles
of
Islam
as
rahmatan
lil
alamin
and
the
contribution
of
Islam
to
the
promotion
of
peace
,
prosperity
,
justice
,
and
equality
for
all
humankinds
;
Reiterating
our
conviction
that
the
Islamic
norms
and
teachings
oblige
all
the
ummah
to
deem
peace
(
slim
or
salam
)
,
justice
(
adalah
)
,
freedom
(
hurriyyah
)
,
moderation
(
tawassuth
)
,
tolerance
(
tasamuh
)
,
balance
(
tawazun
)
,
consultation
(
shura
)
and
equality
(
musawah
)
as
a
fundamental
to
our
way
of
life
;
Recognizing
the
ongoing
process
of
globalization
and
the
increasingly
interconnected
and
interdependent
world
and
the
consequences
that
those
developments
bring
about
on
Muslims
,
collectively
and
individually
;
Recognizing
also
the
continuing
presence
of
socio
-
economic
and
political
injustice
and
imbalances
and
the
global
level
that
hinder
many
Muslim
countries
to
accomplish
sustainable
development
;
Noting
with
concerns
the
conflicts
in
various
parts
of
the
world
,
including
Palestine
and
Iraq
,
that
caused
casualties
among
Muslim
civilians
,
and
stressing
that
every
Muslim
should
sympathize
with
and
take
concrete
actions
to
lessen
their
sufferings
,
and
expressing
hope
that
peace
will
soon
prevail
in
those
regions
;
Further
recognizing
the
gap
between
the
ideals
of
Islamic
teachings
and
the
existing
social
,
economic
,
political
reality
of
the
ummah
.
Emphasizing
the
need
for
concerted
efforts
among
Muslim
countries
in
achieving
the
Millennium
Developing
Goals
which
are
central
to
poverty
alleviation
;
Stressing
the
inalienable
rights
of
every
country
to
promote
research
,
production
and
use
of
nuclear
energy
for
peaceful
purposes
;
Nothing
with
concerns
the
fact
that
Muslims
throughout
the
world
continue
to
face
the
abject
and
dehumanizing
conditions
of
extreme
poverty
;
Nothing
also
with
concerns
the
spread
of
epidemics
in
some
Muslim
countries
,
including
HIV
/
AIDS
,
malaria
,
and
avian
flu
,
and
the
effects
on
their
health
and
on
local
economies
;
Underlining
the
role
of
women
in
the
promotion
of
peace
,
economic
development
,
and
conflict
resolution
;
Stressing
the
importance
of
cooperation
in
the
areas
of
trade
,
investment
,
economic
,
financing
,
and
development
and
the
need
to
enhance
such
cooperation
with
a
view
to
promoting
the
ummah
’
s
prosperity
;
Nothing
the
increasing
role
of
Muslim
minorities
in
pluralistic
societies
and
the
need
to
address
matters
that
challenge
the
efforts
of
promoting
dialogues
between
those
Muslim
minorities
and
the
non
-
Muslim
majorities
;
Emphasizing
that
the
rights
of
Muslim
minorities
to
practice
the
Islamic
way
of
life
are
assured
in
non
-
Muslim
countries
;
Nothing
with
satisfaction
the
successful
conclusion
of
the
second
ICIS
which
reflects
the
continuity
of
commitment
among
Islamic
Scholars
to
the
upholding
Islam
as
rahmatan
lil
alamin
toward
global
justice
and
peace
;
Appreciating
the
organization
of
Nahdlatul
Ulama
,
the
government
and
the
people
of
Indonesia
,
for
hosting
the
second
ICIS
and
its
facilitation
and
determination
in
ensuring
the
success
of
the
conference
.
Resolve
to
:
Response
to
Globalization
1
.
Call
on
Muslims
throughout
the
world
to
participate
in
efforts
of
protecting
and
promoting
the
collective
interests
of
the
ummah
in
the
midst
of
continuing
globalization
.
2
.
Call
on
governments
of
Muslim
countries
to
strengthen
cooperation
in
taking
the
benefits
of
globalization
and
mitigating
its
harmful
effects
.
3
.
Encourage
governments
of
Muslim
countries
to
promote
people
to
people
contact
,
involving
not
only
scholars
but
also
the
Muslim
at
large
,
including
youth
,
women
,
and
elderly
.
4
.
Encourage
also
collaboration
between
governments
of
Muslim
countries
and
governments
of
other
countries
to
intensively
communication
and
further
promote
dialogue
on
issues
that
affect
Muslims
,
including
defamation
and
islamophobia
.
5
.
Request
the
secretary
general
of
the
ICIS
to
commission
a
study
on
how
Muslims
seize
the
opportunity
of
globalization
in
fulfilling
their
political
,
economic
,
and
cultural
rights
.
Peace
and
Conflict
Resolution
6
.
Encourage
Muslim
in
non
Muslim
milieu
anywhere
to
promote
the
correct
ideas
of
Muslim
as
a
religion
of
moderation
and
tolerance
in
order
to
fortify
Muslims
against
extremism
and
narrow
mindedness
.
7
.
Strongly
recommend
that
efforts
should
be
made
to
narrow
the
gap
between
schools
of
thought
in
Islam
in
order
to
maintain
and
foster
the
unity
of
the
blessed
ummah
so
that
they
are
not
easily
divided
into
conflicting
parties
.
8
.
Encourage
every
Muslim
,
through
non
formal
and
other
channels
,
and
upon
the
request
of
conflicting
parties
,
to
take
part
in
conflict
resolution
efforts
anywhere
and
at
anytime
.
9
.
Encourage
the
OIC
to
continue
its
contribution
to
address
conflicts
involving
Muslim
minorities
through
preventive
measures
and
the
deployment
of
peace
missions
.
10
.
Also
encourage
Muslim
troop
contributing
countries
to
continue
contributing
personnel
and
equipment
to
various
UN
peacekeeping
operations
as
an
expression
of
commitment
to
the
maintenance
of
peace
as
advocated
by
the
Islamic
teachings
.
11
.
Stress
that
Muslim
majority
continues
to
have
moral
commitment
to
respect
and
protect
the
rights
of
non
-
Muslim
minorities
and
to
promote
dialogue
and
engage
them
in
the
economic
,
social
,
and
political
processes
of
the
majority
.
12
.
Recommend
that
representatives
from
Muslim
countries
at
the
UN
play
an
active
role
,
in
a
concerted
manner
,
in
the
exertions
to
reform
the
UN
and
its
main
bodies
,
including
the
UN
Security
Council
,
in
order
to
improve
the
effectiveness
and
efficiency
of
the
Organizations
in
carrying
out
its
mandates
as
enshrined
in
its
Charter
.
13
.
Request
the
Secretary
-
General
of
the
ICIS
to
commission
the
development
of
guidance
for
dispute
settlements
and
conflict
resolution
based
in
the
Islamic
value
and
teachings
.
Economic
Development
and
Poverty
Eradication
14
.
Call
on
Muslim
leaders
,
being
exemplary
to
their
community
,
disseminate
the
Islamic
teachings
and
values
concerning
the
importance
of
hard
working
and
poverty
eradication
.
15
.
Strongly
encourage
civil
society
organizations
to
participate
in
economic
and
social
affairs
for
the
greatest
benefits
of
all
Muslim
communities
.
16
.
Advise
governments
of
Muslim
countries
to
explore
practical
ways
and
modalities
in
promoting
greater
cooperation
among
them
in
trade
,
investments
,
economy
,
and
other
development
sectors
,
including
the
enhancement
of
Islamic
financial
and
banking
system
.
17
.
Also
advice
Governments
of
Muslim
-
populated
countries
to
promote
Islamic
financial
and
banking
systems
and
facilitate
the
participation
of
the
ummah
in
the
system
and
to
ensure
the
stability
and
sustainability
of
the
Islamic
financial
system
by
developing
the
presence
of
effective
regulatory
and
supervisory
framework
,
effective
,
and
dynamic
shariah
framework
,
and
comprehensive
legal
framework
,
and
promote
strong
corporate
governance
,
greater
transparency
and
disclosure
of
information
in
order
.
18
.
Encourage
international
Islamic
institutions
,
including
IDB
,
to
facilitate
trade
and
economic
cooperation
among
Muslim
-
populated
countries
and
to
consider
assisting
non
-
member
countries
,
where
Muslim
minorities
reside
,
especially
through
its
technical
assistance
.
19
.
Call
on
the
ummah
to
explore
practical
measures
in
empowering
zakat
and
wakaf
as
instruments
to
generate
resources
for
development
and
eradicate
poverty
,
and
Governments
of
Muslim
countries
to
facilitate
the
establishment
of
an
institutional
arrangement
that
consists
of
a
collection
unit
,
which
is
responsible
for
collecting
zakat
in
accordance
with
existing
provisions
,
and
a
distribution
unit
,
which
is
responsible
for
distributing
zakat
to
those
who
have
rights
to
receive
it
.
20
.
Underline
the
continuing
significance
of
agricultural
sector
in
many
Muslim
countries
,
and
in
this
regard
request
Islamic
international
development
institutions
,
including
OIC
and
Developing
8
,
to
include
agriculture
as
a
priority
program
and
promote
technical
assistance
in
that
field
.
21
.
Strongly
encourage
the
establishment
of
networking
and
collaboration
among
small
medium
scale
enterprises
from
Muslim
-
populated
countries
,
and
also
encourage
their
Government
to
facilitate
that
proposal
.
22
.
Encourage
government
of
Muslim
countries
and
non
-
governmental
organizations
to
utilize
the
application
of
Islamic
values
and
principles
in
devising
human
resources
development
policies
and
strategies
.
23
.
Invite
philanthropic
organizations
to
support
for
the
efforts
of
alleviating
poverty
,
and
strongly
encourage
those
organizations
in
Muslim
countries
to
build
a
networking
,
including
in
the
form
of
an
association
.
24
.
Strongly
encourage
Muslim
to
reinvigorate
solidarity
by
assisting
their
fellows
who
are
suffering
from
natural
disaster
,
epidemic
,
and
armed
conflicts
in
the
forms
of
material
or
financial
support
and
prayers
.
25
.
Request
the
Secretary
-
General
of
the
ICIS
to
commission
the
development
of
a
data
base
that
stores
information
about
philanthropic
organizations
interested
in
supporting
activities
of
the
ummah
.
Education
and
Social
Progress
26
.
Call
on
muslim
leaders
,
being
exemplary
to
their
community
,
to
disseminate
the
Islamic
teaching
on
the
significance
of
education
as
part
of
religious
obligation
.
27
.
Also
call
on
governments
to
promote
universal
primary
education
by
,
inter
alia
,
making
it
more
accessible
to
the
Ummah
.
28
.
Strongly
encourage
Muslims
to
continuously
attach
great
importance
to
family
in
accordance
with
the
Islamic
values
and
teachings
,
and
to
its
role
in
the
education
of
their
children
.
29
.
Encourage
learning
institutions
to
improve
the
quality
of
education
and
to
enhance
programmes
of
exchange
of
students
and
teaching
members
,
publication
,
research
,
and
curriculum
development
.
30
.
Invite
decision
-
makers
at
the
public
and
private
sectors
to
develop
policies
that
ensure
the
fulfillment
of
the
rights
of
Muslim
women
,
and
concrete
programmes
to
empower
their
participation
in
economic
,
social
,
and
political
processes
.
31
.
Request
the
Secretary
-
General
of
the
ICIS
to
commission
the
development
of
data
base
,
including
in
the
internet
format
,
that
store
information
regarding
education
higher
learning
institutions
,
scholarship
and
research
grants
in
Muslim
and
other
countries
.
32
.
Also
request
the
Secretary
-
General
of
the
ICIS
to
commission
the
development
of
applicable
frameworks
that
promote
the
value
of
Islamic
teachings
on
relevant
subjects
of
human
interests
,
such
as
the
promotion
of
democracy
,
human
rights
,
education
,
and
health
as
well
as
the
prevention
of
corruption
and
drug
-
abuse
.
Future
Directions
33
.
Solemnly
reaffirm
,
on
this
historic
occasion
,
our
determination
to
respond
to
the
future
challenges
in
a
concerted
way
and
our
commitment
to
the
promotion
of
peace
,
justice
,
moderation
,
and
prosperity
for
Muslims
as
well
as
non
-
Muslim
through
the
implementation
of
commitment
expressed
in
this
document
as
part
of
the
universal
aspirations
for
a
better
world
where
both
physical
and
spiritual
happiness
of
all
humankind
are
fully
realized
.
34
.
Strongly
recommend
that
the
Secretary
-
General
of
the
ICIS
commission
a
study
on
the
possibility
of
establishing
a
permanent
secretariat
of
the
ICIS
in
Indonesia
and
on
the
possibility
of
affiliating
the
ICIS
as
an
observer
with
international
organizations
,
including
the
OIC
and
the
UN
.
35
.
Agree
that
all
follow
-
up
actions
mandated
to
the
Secretary
-
General
of
the
ICIS
as
outlined
under
this
document
will
be
implemented
in
accordance
with
the
available
financing
,
and
in
this
regard
,
approve
the
efforts
of
the
Secretary
-
General
in
seeking
financial
support
from
prospective
donors
.
36
.
Invite
government
and
non
-
governmental
institutions
to
participate
and
contribute
to
the
achievements
of
goals
and
objectives
in
this
document
,
including
material
and
financial
support
.
37
.
Request
the
Secretary
-
General
of
the
ICIS
to
inform
the
Third
ICIS
about
the
implementation
of
this
program
of
action
.
NRM
Headline
News
is
a
free
,
weekly
e
-
mail
news
service
in
English
,
covering
the
issues
of
natural
resources
governance
and
policy
in
Indonesia
.
Headline
News
contains
selected
news
items
from
the
Indonesian
press
,
information
about
upcoming
events
and
employment
opportunities
,
and
regular
updates
on
the
activities
of
the
Natural
Resources
Management
(
NRM
)
Program
.
Funding
is
provided
by
the
United
States
Agency
for
International
Development
(
USAID
)
.
T
he
NRM
Headline
News
is
available
in
plain
text
or
HTML
formats
.
Contributions
from
readers
are
always
welcome
.
Please
e
-
mail
us
at
headline
@
nrm
.
or
.
id
Story
No
.
1
:
Meidiarti
Kasmidi
Received
World
Wildlife
Fund
’
s
Women
and
Conservation
Recognition
Award
Dedicated
work
with
North
Sulawesi
coastal
communities
to
set
up
community
-
based
marine
sanctuaries
.....
more
Story
No
.
2
:
Macaranga
and
Mallotus
(
Euphorbiaceae
)
as
Indicators
for
Disturbance
in
the
Lowland
Dipterocarp
Forests
of
East
Kalimantan
,
Indonesia
A
new
book
in
the
Tropenbos
Kalimantan
Series
no
.
4
,
looks
at
how
selective
logging
impacts
species
composition
in
Borneo
’
s
forests
.....
more
Story
No
.
3
:
"
Disempowerment
in
the
Name
of
'
Participatory
Forestry
?
-
Village
Forests
Joint
Management
in
Uttarakhand
"
A
case
study
from
India
on
how
devolution
of
control
of
forests
to
local
government
disempowered
the
women
who
traditionally
managed
them
.....
more
Story
No
.
4
:
Report
from
the
National
Conference
on
NTFPs
in
Bali
Regional
meeting
exchange
information
and
insights
on
managing
and
marketing
NTFPs
.....
more
Story
No
.
5
:
Biden
Bill
to
Reauthorize
Tropical
Forest
Conservation
Act
Bipartisan
support
in
US
Senate
to
renew
the
TFA
for
three
years
with
funding
.....
more
Story
No
.
6
:
An
Unending
Battle
Against
Illegal
Logging
As
forest
degradation
worsens
in
the
Gunung
Leuser
ecosystem
,
international
and
national
efforts
to
prevent
forest
loss
increase
.....
more
Story
No
.
7
:
300
Hectares
of
Forest
Damaged
West
Sumatra
’
s
forests
continue
to
be
battered
by
illegal
logging
.....
more
Story
No
.
8
:
Campaign
Pulls
in
the
Public
to
Save
Endangered
Coral
Reefs
Indonesian
rock
stars
put
their
environmental
beliefs
on
the
line
in
Bali
campaign
.....
more
Story
No
.
9
:
Miners
Blamed
for
Park
Damages
Critical
watershed
for
Jakarta
is
the
site
for
illegal
mining
with
mercury
.....
more
Story
No
.
10
:
NRM
Noon
Seminar
Update
on
noon
seminar
schedules
.....
more
Story
No
.
11
:
Training
Workshops
in
Participatory
Development
Workshops
in
July
and
September
of
2001
on
Participatory
Development
;
Participatory
Monitoring
and
Evaluation
;
and
,
an
Advanced
Facilitator
'
s
workshop
in
Ottawa
,
Canada
.....
more
Story
No
.
12
:
Project
Coordinator
-
UK
Darwin
Initiative
Papuan
Plant
Diversity
Project
UK
Darwin
Initiative
Plant
Diversity
Project
is
looking
to
recruit
a
Project
Coordinator
for
its
project
in
Manokwari
,
Papua
.....
more
Story
No
.
13
:
Vacancies
at
The
Nature
Conservancy
Two
positions
currently
available
with
TNC
East
Kalimantan
.....
more
Story
No
.
1
:
Meidiarti
Kasmidi
Received
World
Wildlife
Fund
’
s
Women
and
Conservation
Recognition
Award
Mediarti
Kasmidi
,
Field
Extension
Officer
of
the
USAID
Coastal
Resources
Management
Project
(
Proyek
Pesisir
)
in
Manado
received
the
“
Women
and
Conservation
Recognition
Award
for
her
exceptional
work
in
promoting
marine
conservation
in
North
Sulawesi
.
Meidi
’
s
dedication
to
working
with
coastal
communities
resulted
in
the
establishment
of
the
first
community
-
based
marine
sanctuary
in
Indonesia
,
located
in
the
village
of
Blongko
,
North
Sulawesi
and
her
receiving
the
Women
and
Conservation
Recognition
Award
.
Meidi
led
the
villagers
in
developing
the
management
plan
and
village
ordinance
that
established
the
community
marine
sanctuary
.
Meidi
is
one
of
the
two
worldwide
winners
.
The
other
winner
,
also
a
woman
is
from
Chiapas
,
Mexico
.
From
1993
to
1996
,
Meidi
worked
for
USAID
Natural
Resources
Management
Project
as
field
extension
officer
for
women
empowerment
in
Bunaken
National
Park
.
Her
work
was
focused
on
providing
assistance
to
the
local
women
in
the
Bunaken
area
.
She
assisted
in
developing
their
capacities
that
will
enable
them
to
increase
their
income
.
Meidi
is
also
actively
involved
with
the
non
-
governmental
organization
,
Yayasan
KELOLA
,
in
Manado
,
North
Sulawesi
as
the
Women
Empowerment
Program
Coordinator
.
The
selection
of
Meidi
for
this
prestigious
international
award
recognizes
her
work
as
among
the
finest
and
most
exemplary
type
of
grassroots
organizational
work
at
the
village
level
.
Meidi
flew
to
Washington
D
.
C
.
on
June
25
from
Manado
to
attend
a
roundtable
meeting
on
women
and
conservation
at
World
Wildlife
Fund
.
An
awards
luncheon
will
be
held
on
June
26th
.
The
Indonesian
Embassy
in
Washington
D
.
C
.
also
supported
the
awards
luncheon
.
Meidi
will
then
fly
to
Rhode
Island
for
a
press
interview
and
will
visit
various
coastal
organizations
.
As
the
role
of
women
in
all
professions
grows
,
Meidi
’
s
award
signifies
new
ground
for
women
’
s
gender
equity
in
Indonesia
,
other
developing
nations
and
in
the
field
of
coastal
management
.
For
further
information
,
please
contact
:
Coastal
Resources
Management
Project
-
Proyek
Pesisir
Manado
Jln
.
Wolter
Monginsidi
No
.
5
Kleak
Lingkungan
I
,
Manado
,
Sulawesi
Utara
-
Indonesia
951152
(
T
)
+
62
431
841671
,
841672
(
F
)
+
62
431
841673
Email
:
crmp
@
manado
.
wasantara
.
net
.
id
Kun
Hidayat
Communication
&
Outreach
Manager
or
Maurice
Knight
Chief
of
Party
Proyek
Pesisir
Ratu
Plaza
Building
18th
Floor
,
Jl
.
Jend
.
Sudirman
9
Jakarta
10270
INDONESIA
Tel
:
62
-
21
-
720
9596
Fax
:
62
-
21
-
720
7844
Email
:
crmp
@
cbn
.
net
.
id
Chip
Young
Communications
Liaison
Coastal
Resources
Center
University
of
Rhode
Island
URI
Bay
Campus
Narragansett
,
RI
02882
Ph
:
(
401
)
874
-
6630
FX
;
(
401
)
789
-
4670
WWW
:
http
:
//
crc
.
uri
.
edu
Top
Story
No
.
2
:
Macaranga
and
Mallotus
(
Euphorbiaceae
)
as
Indicators
for
Disturbance
in
the
Lowland
Dipterocarp
Forests
of
East
Kalimantan
,
Indonesia
Author
:
J
.
W
.
F
.
Slik
(
Nationaal
Herbarium
Nederland
,
Leiden
University
branch
)
The
book
presents
information
on
the
effects
of
selective
logging
and
the
recent
forest
fires
on
the
tree
species
composition
of
lowland
forests
in
East
Kalimantan
.
It
also
provides
a
rapid
assessment
method
using
indicator
species
from
the
genera
Macaranga
and
Mallotus
to
quantify
the
level
of
disturbance
in
these
forests
.
Additionally
a
comprehensive
fieldkey
to
all
Macaranga
and
Mallotus
species
from
East
Kalimantan
is
presented
which
is
based
entirely
on
vegetative
characters
and
includes
very
good
drawings
of
all
the
treated
species
.
The
remainder
of
the
book
deals
with
the
evolutionary
origin
of
the
indicator
species
and
gives
revisions
of
many
of
the
more
common
Mallotus
species
of
South
East
Asia
(
including
four
new
species
)
.
The
book
can
be
ordered
at
Tropenbos
International
http
:
//
www
.
tropenbos
.
nl
/
tropenbos
/
tropenbos
-
home
.
html
Nationaal
Herbarium
Nederland
Plantdiversity
of
the
Indopacific
and
Tropical
Asia
Einsteinweg
2
room
B101
PO
-
Box
9514
2300
RA
Leiden
The
Netherlands
Top
Story
No
.
3
:
"
Disempowerment
in
the
Name
of
'
Participatory
Forestry
?
-
Village
Forests
Joint
Management
in
Uttarakhand
"
India
'
s
"
joint
forest
management
"
programs
have
been
widely
touted
as
giving
communities
greater
control
over
forests
and
a
higher
share
of
forest
revenues
.
State
forestry
departments
sign
agreements
with
local
representatives
in
which
the
government
promises
to
finance
local
plans
,
forest
guards
,
tree
nurseries
,
and
other
activities
and
to
let
residents
keep
some
of
the
earnings
from
selling
forest
products
.
The
local
representatives
agree
to
conserve
their
forests
and
to
follow
the
program
'
s
rules
.
The
World
Bank
and
other
agencies
have
spent
hundreds
of
millions
of
dollars
on
these
programs
.
In
many
places
the
results
have
probably
been
positive
.
However
,
Madhu
Sarin
'
s
"
Disempowerment
in
the
name
of
'
participatory
forestry
?
-
Village
forests
joint
management
in
Uttarakhand
"
,
points
out
the
dangers
of
applying
one
single
model
in
diverse
contexts
and
of
'
participatory
'
schemes
that
don
'
t
acknowledge
what
people
are
already
doing
.
FAO
'
s
Forests
,
Trees
and
People
Newsletter
published
Sarin
'
s
paper
.
Back
in
1958
,
the
elected
forest
council
of
Pakhi
received
the
right
to
manage
a
240
-
hectare
forest
,
which
women
use
to
collect
fuelwood
,
fodder
,
leaf
litter
and
other
products
for
their
families
.
For
years
,
the
local
women
'
s
welfare
association
controlled
the
forest
.
It
decided
how
to
use
the
forest
and
paid
a
woman
guard
to
fine
people
that
violated
the
rules
.
Voluntary
contributions
paid
the
guard
'
s
salary
.
While
the
women
managed
the
forest
it
was
always
kept
in
good
condition
.
When
the
Village
Forests
Joint
Management
program
came
to
Pakhi
in
1999
,
the
women
lost
control
of
their
forest
.
The
local
men
,
who
previously
showed
little
interest
in
the
forest
,
took
over
.
They
used
project
money
to
hire
three
male
forest
guards
and
fired
the
woman
.
Conflicts
broke
out
over
the
funds
for
the
village
forest
plan
and
the
tree
nurseries
.
The
Forestry
Department
now
makes
key
decisions
about
how
the
forest
will
be
used
.
It
has
marginalized
the
women
'
s
welfare
association
and
turned
the
men
and
women
in
the
village
into
virtual
wage
laborers
.
The
villagers
need
the
money
,
but
they
did
not
realize
they
would
no
longer
be
able
to
manage
their
forest
.
It
also
seems
no
one
consulted
the
women
when
the
village
leaders
agreed
to
enter
the
program
.
The
Uttarakhand
region
in
Uttar
Pradesh
has
over
6
,
000
community
forests
like
the
one
in
Pakhi
.
Studies
show
that
on
average
these
forests
have
faired
as
well
or
better
than
the
government
-
managed
Reserve
Forests
.
About
50
%
of
the
region
'
s
rural
households
depend
heavily
on
village
commons
and
forest
lands
for
their
livelihoods
.
Some
40
%
of
heads
of
households
are
women
.
The
Village
Forest
Joint
Management
program
looks
real
good
on
paper
.
Unfortunately
,
the
villagers
of
Pakhi
don
'
t
live
on
paper
.
To
request
a
free
electronic
copy
of
Sarin
'
s
paper
,
please
write
Dina
Hubudin
at
:
d
.
hubudin
@
cgiar
.
org
To
send
comments
or
queries
to
the
author
,
you
can
write
Madhu
Sarin
at
:
msarin
@
satyam
.
net
.
in
David
Kaimowitz
d
.
kaimowitz
@
cgiar
.
org
Top
Story
No
.
4
:
Report
from
the
National
Conference
on
NTFPs
in
Bali
Source
:
Voices
from
the
Forest
,
June
2001
By
Muyat
Ali
Muhshi
-
National
Coordinator
KpSHK
In
collaboration
with
AMAN
,
TELAPAK
,
the
NTFP
Exchange
Programme
-
Both
Ends
The
Netherlands
)
,
and
KpSHK
organized
a
national
conference
on
Non
-
Timber
Forest
Products
on
October
10
-
14
,
2000
in
the
Abian
Srama
Hotel
at
Sanur
,
Bali
.
This
conference
was
attended
by
members
of
the
KpSHK
and
indigenous
people
groups
and
organisations
which
are
experienced
in
management
and
marketing
of
NTFPs
.
In
addition
,
there
were
also
participants
coming
from
Vietnam
,
the
Philippines
,
Malaysia
and
India
.
The
conference
has
identified
problems
of
NTFP
development
by
the
people
.
The
problems
faced
by
the
people
in
NTFP
development
are
:
land
security
,
weakness
or
even
inexistence
of
local
economic
institutions
,
weak
technical
capacity
,
difficult
transportation
and
information
access
,
low
prices
,
lack
of
knowledge
on
marketing
,
inconducive
government
regulations
and
policies
,
lack
of
capital
,
inexistence
of
NTFP
farmer
'
s
associations
and
weak
bargaining
position
of
the
farmers
towards
market
and
policies
.
The
situation
of
the
community
-
based
NTFP
development
in
Indonesia
or
other
places
in
Southeast
Asia
varies
in
terms
of
progress
.
At
the
level
of
local
economic
institutions
there
are
many
approaches
in
Indonesia
namely
indigenous
people
institutions
,
village
institutions
,
indigenous
co
-
operatives
and
farmers
co
-
operatives
.
In
West
Kalimantan
,
there
has
been
an
association
of
rubber
farmers
to
improve
their
position
in
rubber
market
.
Even
the
export
has
been
done
by
Forest
Trade
and
PT
Dian
Niaga
.
At
the
meantime
,
in
the
Philippines
there
has
been
a
consortium
of
NGOs
and
programs
marketing
people
’
s
NTFPs
.
The
diverse
situation
needs
exchange
of
information
,
experience
,
skills
between
people
and
the
supporting
NGOs
.
Through
information
and
experience
exchanges
for
5
days
,
some
problems
in
developing
NTFP
along
with
the
community
were
identified
.
The
problems
were
among
others
:
Limited
market
information
(
price
,
quality
,
etc
.
)
Long
chain
in
the
sale
resulting
in
farmers
low
selling
price
Farmers
low
profit
Farmers
low
saving
A
lot
of
farmers
got
into
debt
to
brokers
The
non
-
optimum
multi
product
of
the
NTFP
farmers
Most
NTFPs
are
not
protected
by
community
’
s
organisation
(
economy
-
oriented
)
Low
community
'
s
knowledge
of
production
,
marketing
,
finance
,
and
environment
The
existence
of
cartel
suppressing
the
price
Long
distance
between
producers
and
market
resulting
in
high
transportation
cost
Most
of
NTFP
was
seasonal
NTFP
preservation
had
to
be
formulated
in
a
sustainable
management
system
NTFP
increased
households
’
income
by
50
%
Some
'
over
'
supply
lowered
the
price
Insufficient
support
from
the
government
NTFP
producers
were
still
separated
from
“
advance
process
”
Financing
agencies
did
not
know
about
NTFP
The
need
for
legal
protection
for
NTFP
.
The
detailed
problems
according
to
the
issues
discussed
are
as
follows
:
1
.
Problems
in
commodity
and
production
difficult
transportation
bad
/
no
access
to
communication
no
financing
activities
lack
of
unity
in
community
little
knowledge
of
marketing
confusing
rules
and
regulation
in
Community
based
Organisations
low
prices
intimidation
from
security
officers
opposed
to
forest
regulation
military
pressure
/
lack
of
tenurial
security
2
.
Problems
in
territory
right
consensus
community
could
not
put
up
cash
boards
community
could
not
do
feasibility
study
only
few
NGOs
backed
land
claims
regional
regulation
had
not
yet
been
issued
3
.
Problems
in
access
to
information
and
benefit
sharing
limited
market
information
,
lack
of
general
knowledge
of
market
needs
and
other
products
farmers
'
low
profit
farmers
weak
bargaining
power
,
especially
in
determining
the
price
no
supporting
policies
from
the
government
,
list
of
products
prices
was
not
available
lack
of
knowledge
of
market
needs
farmer
got
into
debt
to
brokers
farmers
hardly
had
saving
no
local
economic
institutions
seasonal
nature
of
NTFP
farmers
cultivated
multi
product
expecting
to
reduce
the
risk
should
decreasing
price
occurs
because
the
could
shift
to
other
products
no
information
sharing
among
farmers
lack
of
supporting
policies
from
government
(
list
of
price
,
information
on
NTFP
multi
products
,
pilot
project
)
the
existence
of
cartels
suppressing
the
price
4
.
Problems
in
marketing
lack
of
market
information
;
when
promoting
their
products
,
farmers
did
not
know
about
customers
want
,
so
the
customers
did
not
know
what
the
farmers
sold
facilities
;
assuming
that
Indonesia
and
Malaysia
both
make
two
similar
products
,
one
is
expensive
,
the
other
is
not
,
but
due
to
different
policies
of
the
countries
,
the
prices
could
be
different
,
and
this
will
disadvantage
the
country
which
sells
at
higher
price
weak
producers
bargaining
power
problems
in
marketing
network
no
map
of
products
a
long
with
their
producers
no
map
of
buyers
technical
problems
weak
marketing
network
mechanism
Given
the
situation
and
above
-
mentioned
problems
,
the
NTFP
farmers
and
the
NGOs
have
agreed
to
have
a
collaboration
network
of
NTFP
development
.
The
vision
of
the
network
is
strengthening
the
bargaining
position
of
local
economic
actors
of
NTFP
in
a
fair
and
sustainable
way
.
The
network
will
have
a
close
relation
to
people
through
AMAN
and
to
NGOs
through
KpSHK
.
At
the
national
level
the
network
will
be
supported
and
directed
by
AMAN
,
KpSHK
and
Telapak
in
collaboration
with
other
NGOs
and
other
related
institutions
dealing
with
NTFP
development
.
A
full
-
time
focal
point
will
be
hired
to
keep
running
the
collaboration
mechanism
within
the
network
.
The
agenda
resulted
from
the
national
conference
is
to
:
increase
number
of
economic
groups
or
institutions
of
NTFP
managers
increase
number
of
mapping
activities
in
indigenous
territory
establish
network
of
local
economy
actors
at
the
district
,
provincial
and
national
level
implement
training
,
internship
and
cross
visit
programs
to
improve
capacity
and
skill
of
indigenous
people
in
managing
and
developing
NTFPs
develop
an
example
of
market
information
system
of
NTFP
at
the
management
area
,
provincial
and
national
level
develop
an
example
of
regional
regulation
on
indigenous
people
’
s
rights
increase
access
and
capacity
of
local
economy
actors
in
influencing
policy
on
marketing
of
NTFPs
at
the
district
,
provincial
and
national
level
.
(
Ed
.
Voices
from
the
Forest
is
available
on
-
line
at
:
<
http
:
//
www
.
NTFP
.
org
/
voices
/
voices
.
html
>
)
[
Courtesy
of
the
Indonesian
Nature
Conservation
List
]
Top
Story
No
.
5
:
Biden
Bill
to
Reauthorize
Tropical
Forest
Conservation
Act
Source
:
Office
of
International
Information
Programs
,
U
.
S
.
Department
of
State
,
June
19
,
2001
Senator
Joe
Biden
(
Democrat
of
Delaware
)
has
introduced
a
bill
to
reauthorize
the
Tropical
Forest
Conservation
Act
for
three
years
with
funding
of
$
225
million
during
that
period
.
Biden
,
the
chairman
of
the
Senate
Foreign
Relations
Committee
,
submitted
S
.
1021
June
12
,
along
with
Senator
Richard
Lugar
(
Republican
of
Indiana
)
.
The
bill
to
reauthorize
the
Tropical
Forest
Conservation
Act
,
according
to
its
sponsors
,
would
help
low
-
income
nations
by
allowing
them
to
set
aside
funds
that
would
have
been
used
to
pay
back
debts
owed
to
the
United
States
and
,
instead
,
use
the
money
to
purchase
and
protect
endangered
tropical
forests
.
The
bill
would
allow
for
"
Debt
-
for
-
Nature
"
swaps
in
countries
in
Asia
,
the
Caribbean
,
Africa
and
Latin
America
"
with
globally
or
regionally
outstanding
tropical
forests
,
"
say
the
bill
'
s
authors
.
S
.
1021
would
authorize
appropriations
to
compensate
the
Treasury
Department
for
revenues
foregone
when
debts
with
poorer
developing
nations
are
restructured
at
less
than
their
asset
value
.
Under
the
provisions
of
the
current
Tropical
Forest
Conservation
Act
of
1998
the
President
can
reduce
certain
bilateral
government
debt
owed
to
the
United
States
in
exchange
for
which
,
the
eligible
developing
country
places
local
currencies
in
a
"
tropical
forest
fund
,
"
which
is
used
for
projects
"
to
preserve
,
restore
or
maintain
its
tropical
forests
.
"
To
be
able
to
take
part
in
the
conservation
program
,
the
law
requires
that
a
participating
government
be
"
democratically
elected
,
must
not
support
acts
of
international
terrorism
,
must
cooperate
on
international
narcotics
control
matters
,
must
not
violate
internationally
recognized
human
rights
,
and
must
institute
any
needed
investment
reforms
.
"
The
reauthorization
bill
would
provide
$
50
million
in
fiscal
year
2002
,
$
75
million
in
fiscal
year
2003
,
and
$
100
million
in
fiscal
year
2004
.
A
bill
similar
to
S
.
1021
,
H
.
R
.
2131
,
was
introduced
into
the
House
of
Representatives
on
the
same
day
by
Representative
Robert
Portman
(
Republican
of
Ohio
)
,
along
with
30
co
-
sponsors
.
Following
is
the
text
of
Senator
Joe
Biden
introducing
S
.
1021
and
the
text
of
the
legislation
from
the
Congressional
Record
:
Senate
June
12
,
2001
The
Tropical
Forest
Conservation
Act
S
.
1021
Be
it
enacted
by
the
Senate
and
House
of
Representatives
of
the
United
States
of
America
in
Congress
assembled
,
Section
1
.
Authorization
of
appropriations
to
support
reduction
of
debt
under
the
foreign
assistance
act
of
1961
and
title
I
of
the
agricultural
trade
development
and
assistance
act
of
1954
.
(
a
)
Reauthorization
.
--
Section
806
of
the
Tropical
Forest
Conservation
Act
of
1998
(
22
U
.
S
.
C
.
2431d
)
is
amended
by
adding
at
the
end
the
following
new
subsection
:
(
d
)
Authorization
of
Appropriations
for
Fiscal
Years
After
Fiscal
Year
2001
.
--
For
the
cost
(
as
defined
in
section
502
(
5
)
of
the
Federal
Credit
Reform
Act
of
1990
)
for
the
reduction
of
any
debt
pursuant
to
this
section
or
section
807
,
there
are
authorized
to
be
appropriated
to
the
President
the
following
:
$
50
,
000
,
000
for
fiscal
year
2002
.
$
75
,
000
,
000
for
fiscal
year
2003
.
$
100
,
000
,
000
for
fiscal
year
2004
.
(
b
)
Conforming
amendment
.
--
Section
808
(
a
)
(
1
)
(
D
)
of
the
Tropical
Forest
Conservation
Act
of
1998
(
22
U
.
S
.
C
.
2431f
(
a
)
(
1
)
(
D
))
is
amended
by
striking
``
to
appropriated
under
sections
806
(
a
)
(
2
)
and
807
(
a
)
(
2
)
''
and
inserting
``
to
be
appropriated
under
sections
806
(
a
)
(
2
)
,
807
(
a
)
(
2
)
,
and
806
(
d
)
''
.
Summary
of
the
Tropical
Forest
Conservation
Act
The
Tropical
Forest
Conservation
Act
of
1998
(
Public
Law
105
-
214
)
helps
to
protect
the
world
'
s
dwindling
tropical
forests
through
``
debt
for
nature
swaps
.
''
The
TFCA
focuses
on
tropical
forest
conservation
,
using
the
same
principles
as
the
1989
Global
Environmental
Protection
Act
,
Biden
-
Lugar
,
and
former
President
Bush
'
s
Enterprise
for
the
Americas
Initiative
(
EAI
)
.
The
bill
extends
eligibility
for
``
Debt
for
Nature
''
swaps
under
the
EAI
to
lower
and
middle
income
countries
in
Africa
and
Asia
with
globally
or
regionally
outstanding
tropical
forests
.
It
authorizes
appropriations
to
compensate
the
Treasury
Department
for
revenues
foregone
when
debts
with
poorer
developing
nations
are
restructured
at
less
than
their
asset
value
.
The
Tropical
Forest
Conservation
Act
of
1998
authorizes
the
President
to
reduce
certain
bilateral
government
debt
owed
to
the
United
States
under
the
Foreign
Assistance
Act
of
1981
or
Title
1
of
the
Agricultural
Trade
Development
and
Assistance
Act
of
1954
.
In
exchange
,
the
eligible
developing
country
would
place
local
currencies
in
a
tropical
forest
fund
,
which
would
be
used
for
projects
to
preserve
,
restore
or
maintain
its
tropical
forests
.
In
some
instances
,
debt
swaps
would
occur
at
no
cost
to
the
Federal
Treasury
since
sovereign
debt
would
simply
be
reduced
to
its
asset
value
under
the
Federal
Credit
Reform
Act
of
1990
.
In
other
instances
,
poorer
nations
will
be
allowed
to
restructure
their
debt
at
an
amount
somewhat
lower
than
its
asset
value
and
Federal
appropriations
would
have
to
be
used
to
compensate
the
Treasury
for
reductions
in
its
anticipated
revenue
stream
.
The
law
also
allows
private
organizations
to
contribute
their
funds
to
help
facilitate
a
debt
swap
under
the
terms
of
the
bill
.
To
qualify
for
assistance
,
eligible
countries
must
meet
the
criteria
established
by
Congress
under
EAI
:
the
government
must
be
democratically
elected
,
must
not
support
acts
of
international
terrorism
,
must
cooperate
on
international
narcotics
control
matters
,
must
not
violate
internationally
recognized
human
rights
,
and
must
institute
any
needed
investment
reforms
.
To
ensure
accountability
,
an
administrative
body
is
established
in
the
beneficiary
country
.
This
body
will
consist
of
one
or
more
U
.
S
.
Government
officials
,
one
or
more
individuals
appointed
by
the
recipient
country
'
s
government
,
and
representatives
of
environmental
,
community
development
,
scientific
,
academic
and
forestry
organizations
of
the
beneficiary
country
.
It
is
authorized
to
make
grants
for
projects
which
would
conserve
its
outstanding
tropical
forests
.
Additionally
,
the
existing
Enterprise
for
Americas
Initiative
Board
is
expanded
by
four
new
members
and
oversees
both
the
EAI
and
the
Tropical
Forest
Conservation
Act
.
The
authorization
of
appropriations
for
the
1998
Tropical
Forest
Conservation
Act
expires
at
the
end
of
fiscal
year
2002
.
Legislation
will
be
introduced
to
extend
the
authorization
of
appropriations
through
fiscal
years
2002
at
a
level
of
$
50
,
000
,
000
in
FY
2002
,
$
75
,
000
,
000
in
FY
2003
and
$
100
,
000
,
000
in
FY
2004
.
Mr
.
Biden
Mr
.
President
,
I
am
pleased
to
once
again
join
my
distinguished
colleague
from
Indiana
,
Senator
Lugar
,
in
introducing
legislation
to
protect
the
world
'
s
significant
tropical
forests
through
``
debt
-
for
-
nature
''
mechanisms
.
We
have
shared
a
long
and
fruitful
bipartisan
relationship
on
this
important
issue
.
I
am
gratified
that
we
have
the
bipartisan
support
of
our
original
cosponsors
noted
by
Senator
Lugar
.
Tropical
forests
are
a
cornerstone
of
the
global
environment
.
Figuratively
speaking
,
they
are
the
``
lungs
''
of
our
planet
,
and
they
can
help
to
regulate
and
mitigate
the
process
of
climate
change
.
They
guide
global
patterns
of
rainfall
on
which
agriculture
and
fisheries
depend
.
They
harbor
pharmaceutical
treasures
that
we
are
just
beginning
to
explore
.
They
are
home
our
planet
'
s
widest
diversity
of
plants
and
animals
.
We
have
a
responsibility
,
a
duty
,
to
be
good
stewards
of
these
essential
resources
,
and
it
is
in
our
direct
economic
interest
to
see
that
they
flourish
.
In
1989
,
Senator
Lugar
and
I
coauthored
the
Global
Environmental
Protection
Assistance
Act
,
which
was
enacted
into
law
as
title
VII
A
of
the
International
Finance
and
Development
Act
of
1989
(
Public
Law
101
-
240
,
December
19
,
1989
)
.
That
Act
authorized
US
AID
to
use
its
funds
for
Debt
for
Nature
swaps
.
Under
the
authority
of
this
Act
,
US
AID
has
used
$
95
million
of
its
funds
to
establish
environmental
endowments
totaling
$
146
million
in
Costa
Rica
,
Honduras
,
Indonesia
,
Jamaica
,
Madagascar
,
Mexico
,
Panama
and
the
Philippines
.
President
Bush
'
s
Enterprise
for
the
Americas
Initiative
(
EAI
)
,
carried
forward
this
linkage
between
debt
reduction
and
the
generation
of
local
funds
to
protect
the
environment
.
The
EAI
provided
$
876
million
in
debt
relief
and
$
154
million
in
local
endowments
at
a
federal
cost
of
$
90
million
in
seven
countries
in
Latin
America
and
the
Caribbean
:
Argentina
,
Bolivia
,
Chile
,
Columbia
,
El
Salvador
,
Jamaica
and
Uruguay
.
The
Tropical
Forest
Conservation
Act
of
1998
extended
the
debt
for
nature
mechanism
of
the
EAI
to
the
protection
of
significant
tropical
forests
in
lower
and
middle
income
developing
countries
throughout
the
world
,
not
just
those
in
Latin
America
and
the
Caribbean
.
Furthermore
,
the
Tropical
Forest
Conservation
Act
(
TFCA
)
,
authorizes
the
use
of
two
new
,
no
cost
``
debt
-
for
-
nature
''
models
,
the
Buy
Back
option
and
Debt
Swap
option
.
The
basic
premise
behind
this
series
of
programs
has
not
changed
over
the
years
.
Many
of
the
world
'
s
important
tropical
forests
are
found
in
countries
that
do
not
have
the
resources
to
protect
them
.
Their
own
patterns
of
economic
development
and
their
participation
in
the
international
economy
place
irresistible
pressures
on
them
to
turn
these
irreplaceable
global
resources
into
quick
local
cash
.
One
of
the
important
contributors
to
those
pressures
is
too
often
the
debt
those
countries
owe
to
us
.
That
is
one
thing
we
can
do
something
about
.
The
mechanisms
in
this
bill
will
allow
us
to
multiply
the
small
dollar
cost
of
writing
the
debt
of
those
countries
off
of
our
books
,
leveraging
substantially
more
resources
to
the
cause
of
preserving
tropical
forests
around
the
world
.
I
look
forward
to
taking
this
bill
up
in
the
Foreign
Relations
Committee
as
soon
as
possible
,
and
I
fully
expect
it
will
continue
to
enjoy
the
strong
support
it
has
had
in
the
past
.
I
also
look
forward
to
working
with
the
Administration
to
provide
the
funding
that
the
President
has
called
for
to
implement
this
program
.
(
Distributed
by
The
Office
of
International
Information
Programs
,
U
.
S
.
Department
of
State
WWW
:
http
:
//
usinfo
.
state
.
gov
)
[
Courtesy
of
the
Indonesian
Nature
Conservation
List
]
Top
Story
No
.
6
:
An
Unending
Battle
Against
Illegal
Logging
Source
:
Jakarta
Post
,
June
18
,
2001
By
Tertiani
Z
.
B
.
Simanjuntak
LANGKAT
The
chirping
hum
of
small
forest
creatures
is
suddenly
replaced
by
the
whining
sound
of
chain
saws
ripping
through
their
home
.
In
broad
daylight
a
dozen
men
cut
down
trees
,
looting
the
best
that
nature
has
to
offer
.
They
go
deep
into
the
conservation
area
with
no
forest
ranger
nor
policeman
in
sight
.
They
are
armed
.
A
few
days
pass
,
four
trucks
laden
with
timber
leave
the
area
and
drive
smoothly
,
passing
check
points
with
ease
,
after
all
their
documents
have
been
examined
.
Officials
let
the
trucks
pass
with
little
fuss
made
.
All
is
in
order
.
The
elements
of
the
description
above
are
very
much
an
everyday
reality
.
More
specifically
,
it
is
a
capsule
of
what
has
been
going
on
for
the
last
five
years
at
the
two
-
million
-
hectare
Leuser
Ecosystem
Area
,
which
encompasses
the
Gunung
Leuser
National
Park
that
stretches
across
the
provinces
of
North
Sumatra
and
Aceh
.
"
An
estimated
12
,
000
hectares
of
the
area
has
been
stripped
by
illegal
logging
in
the
past
six
months
alone
,
"
one
of
the
co
-
directors
of
the
ecosystem
'
s
management
,
Mike
Griffiths
,
said
.
"
It
'
s
still
going
on
...
it
'
s
quiet
serious
,
it
should
be
reviewed
,
"
he
said
,
during
a
meeting
at
the
management
unit
'
s
office
in
Medan
,
North
Sumatra
,
with
members
of
the
ecosystem
'
s
stakeholders
,
the
European
Union
(
EU
)
and
several
non
-
governmental
organizations
(
NGOs
)
.
His
Indonesian
partner
,
Ali
Basyah
Amin
,
cited
economic
hardship
,
lack
of
law
enforcement
and
rising
political
tension
in
Aceh
as
some
of
the
reasons
that
have
forced
residents
to
move
to
the
forests
and
perpetuate
illegal
logging
in
the
area
.
"
In
just
one
year
,
some
200
households
of
displaced
Acehnese
have
begun
to
live
in
the
forest
in
the
central
part
of
Southeast
Aceh
,
while
another
500
households
are
now
in
the
part
near
Langkat
.
We
'
re
still
trying
to
relocate
them
,
"
he
said
.
Illegal
logging
,
an
often
overlooked
violation
in
the
past
,
has
become
a
national
problem
that
has
far
greater
repercussions
than
the
immediate
financial
loss
to
the
state
.
The
Asian
Development
Bank
revealed
that
Indonesian
forests
produce
between
33
million
and
75
million
cubic
meters
of
timber
per
year
,
while
a
sustainable
yield
is
estimated
at
about
22
million
cubic
meters
per
year
.
It
has
become
a
particularly
serious
concern
as
the
Leuser
ecosystem
is
the
last
place
where
various
species
of
near
-
extinct
elephants
,
rhinoceros
,
tigers
,
clouded
leopards
and
orangutans
are
found
together
.
The
ecosystem
,
which
ensures
a
sustainable
water
supply
for
the
seven
surrounding
regions
,
is
also
home
to
hundreds
of
species
of
animals
and
plants
that
includes
the
largest
flower
in
the
world
,
the
rafflesia
and
the
tallest
flower
,
the
amorphophallus
.
Now
,
they
are
threatened
by
illegal
encroachment
and
loss
of
habitat
.
Environmental
watchdogs
,
based
on
their
investigations
,
claim
that
local
timber
barons
encourage
communities
to
break
the
law
by
providing
loggers
with
chain
saws
and
loans
for
food
and
supplies
.
Bogor
-
based
Telapak
Indonesia
executive
Arbi
Valentinus
has
demanded
an
immediate
investigation
and
prosecution
of
sawmill
owners
proved
to
have
acted
illegally
.
"
If
necessary
,
the
government
should
issue
an
export
moratorium
of
particular
logs
,
"
he
said
.
Another
NGO
,
Yayasan
Leuser
Lestari
,
suggested
giving
locals
an
alternative
way
to
earn
their
living
that
would
discourage
them
from
accepting
offers
to
cut
down
trees
illegally
for
Rp
15
,
000
or
Rp
20
,
000
per
day
.
In
their
discussions
with
an
EU
delegation
,
the
local
administration
and
police
seemed
to
be
at
odds
with
whose
responsibility
it
was
to
resolve
the
situation
.
North
Sumatra
Governor
Tengku
Rizal
Nurdin
said
his
office
had
placed
priority
on
relocating
displaced
Acehnese
from
the
ecosystem
area
to
South
Sumatra
,
which
had
agreed
to
accept
them
.
"
I
don
'
t
believe
the
Acehnese
clear
forests
.
Moreover
,
the
perpetrators
are
in
small
numbers
...
they
'
re
jobless
and
need
to
feed
their
family
.
So
what
can
we
do
?
"
"
However
,
I
have
asked
the
police
and
military
to
make
sure
the
area
is
free
from
such
illegal
activities
.
On
this
occasion
,
I
would
also
like
to
ask
Jakarta
to
give
us
special
authority
to
help
safeguard
the
ecosystem
,
"
he
told
the
EU
delegation
.
Nurdin
further
emphasized
that
it
is
the
police
'
s
responsibility
to
prevent
illegal
logging
.
"
It
depends
on
the
chief
of
police
to
help
the
government
fight
it
...
we
'
re
not
part
of
the
chain
of
command
,
"
he
said
.
North
Sumatra
Police
deputy
chief
Brig
.
Gen
.
Ismerda
Lebang
said
the
force
had
done
their
best
by
stifling
the
delivery
of
the
trucks
carrying
stolen
logs
.
Aceh
deputy
governor
Abubakar
Azwar
argued
that
since
78
percent
of
the
ecosystem
area
is
located
in
Aceh
,
it
is
understandable
that
locals
seek
benefit
from
the
protected
area
.
"
But
you
cannot
say
that
we
have
done
nothing
.
Last
March
we
revoked
forest
concessions
,
"
he
said
,
adding
that
"
it
'
s
too
difficult
to
eradicate
the
crime
,
because
companies
do
both
illegal
and
legal
logging
at
the
same
time
.
"
To
get
things
organized
,
the
European
Union
'
s
executive
body
,
the
European
Commission
(
EC
)
,
has
granted
two
million
euros
to
the
forestry
ministry
to
finance
the
establishment
of
an
illegal
logging
response
center
in
the
next
three
years
.
The
center
would
gather
and
disseminate
information
on
the
crime
and
help
NGOs
launch
legal
action
against
illegal
loggers
.
It
will
also
serve
as
a
think
-
tank
to
overcome
the
cause
of
illegal
logging
throughout
the
country
.
"
We
'
ve
got
to
do
something
,
so
therefore
there
should
be
no
more
licenses
for
those
who
abuse
it
,
"
EC
Ambassador
Sabato
Della
Monica
said
.
"
We
also
expect
the
prosecution
against
not
only
those
who
have
held
the
chain
saw
but
also
the
masterminds
behind
it
.
"
The
grant
is
an
additional
assistance
on
top
of
the
32
.
5
million
euros
in
a
seven
-
year
cooperation
with
the
Indonesian
government
to
sustain
the
Leuser
ecosystem
.
The
forestry
'
s
ministry
director
general
of
forest
protection
and
nature
conservation
,
Wahjudi
Wardojo
,
expressed
hope
that
the
center
would
become
a
great
help
to
seek
the
best
way
to
pool
strength
to
stop
illegal
logging
.
[
Courtesy
of
the
Indonesian
Nature
Conservation
List
]
Top
Story
No
.
7
:
300
Hectares
of
Forest
Damaged
Source
:
Jakarta
Post
,
June
18
,
2001
PADANG
Some
300
out
of
a
total
of
1
.
8
million
hectares
of
conserved
forest
in
West
Sumatra
has
been
severely
damaged
due
to
illegal
logging
,
an
activist
said
on
Sunday
.
Executive
director
of
West
Sumatra
Environmental
Development
(
BLHI
)
Edi
Dasril
said
the
illegal
logging
was
rampant
due
to
weak
forestry
law
enforcement
and
the
negligence
of
forest
police
and
other
related
agencies
.
"
We
are
really
concerned
about
the
prolonged
continual
illegal
logging
and
we
hope
the
agencies
in
charge
of
curbing
the
crime
take
immediate
actions
to
prevent
further
deterioration
of
our
forests
,
"
Edi
remarked
.
The
conserved
forests
include
those
along
Bukit
Barisan
and
in
the
Mentawai
islands
,
where
the
most
damage
reportedly
occurred
.
Edi
claimed
that
timber
businessmen
were
also
behind
the
growing
illegal
logging
in
the
province
.
He
demanded
the
government
take
firmer
measures
against
those
who
have
encouraged
or
protected
illegal
logging
and
if
necessary
revoke
forest
concession
licenses
of
such
businessmen
.
[
Courtesy
of
the
Indonesian
Nature
Conservation
List
]
Top
Story
No
.
8
:
Campaign
Pulls
in
the
Public
to
Save
Endangered
Coral
Reefs
Source
:
Jakarta
Post
,
June
21
,
2001
By
I
Wayan
Juniartha
DENPASAR
It
was
not
a
usual
Saturday
night
rock
and
roll
concert
,
although
the
venue
was
none
other
than
the
spacious
Center
Stage
of
Hard
Rock
Beach
Hotel
in
Kuta
.
It
was
different
in
the
first
place
because
it
was
free
.
No
wonder
the
concert
venue
last
Saturday
was
packed
with
people
from
all
walks
of
life
.
A
successful
young
entrepreneur
,
dressed
sharply
in
designer
clothes
,
sat
comfortably
in
the
corner
,
having
a
good
time
,
sipping
expensive
liquor
from
his
small
glass
.
A
young
,
long
-
haired
environmental
activist
,
a
rugged
knapsack
on
his
back
,
dressed
in
worn
-
out
jeans
,
leaned
against
the
wall
,
his
right
hand
holding
a
small
bottle
of
Indonesia
'
s
most
popular
beer
.
The
concert
had
pushed
down
the
segregation
walls
of
social
class
.
Second
,
it
was
a
concert
with
a
mission
.
The
focus
of
the
night
,
grabbing
everybody
'
s
attention
,
of
course
,
Nugie
,
was
not
singing
songs
about
the
endlessly
exploited
subject
of
teen
first
love
,
but
about
a
different
kind
of
love
,
the
platonic
love
between
Man
and
Mother
Nature
.
He
sung
about
the
beautiful
beaches
,
serene
mountains
and
the
majestic
colors
of
coral
reefs
.
Sometimes
he
closed
his
eyes
,
faced
upwards
in
gestures
of
reverence
and
awe
.
He
wasn
'
t
faking
it
;
he
did
really
love
his
Mother
Nature
.
To
make
the
circle
perfect
,
Indy
Barends
,
the
well
-
known
entertainment
presenter
,
kept
the
audience
interested
with
her
charm
,
jokes
and
her
raise
-
your
-
environmental
-
awareness
messages
.
There
wasn
'
t
any
doubt
that
the
audience
was
entertained
;
they
applauded
,
they
cheered
,
no
brawls
exploded
during
the
concert
and
,
as
it
ended
,
they
looked
happier
than
when
they
arrived
at
the
venue
.
But
,
did
the
concert
really
raise
their
environmental
awareness
to
a
higher
plane
?
"
Well
,
we
couldn
'
t
convert
everybody
even
if
we
wanted
to
do
that
,
could
we
?
But
,
the
main
point
of
this
concert
was
to
present
the
idea
of
conserving
nature
to
a
wider
audience
.
Hopefully
,
it
will
attract
their
attention
to
learn
more
,
or
,
God
willing
,
to
do
more
,
"
Friends
of
the
Reef
(
FoR
)
program
coordinator
Dewi
Satriani
said
.
The
concert
was
the
highlight
of
various
events
held
under
the
umbrella
of
the
Friends
of
the
Reef
,
a
strategic
new
program
initiated
by
World
Wide
Fund
for
Nature
(
WWF
)
Wallacea
Bioregion
-
Bali
.
Collaborating
with
other
environmental
non
-
governmental
organizations
,
concerned
members
of
the
private
sector
and
individuals
,
WWF
launched
the
program
with
one
final
objective
;
the
conservation
of
Bali
'
s
precious
coral
reefs
.
The
West
Bali
National
Park
,
Waka
Shorea
,
Reef
Seen
Aquatic
,
Matahari
Dive
Center
,
Bali
Hai
Diving
Adventure
and
Dunia
Selam
Lembonga
were
the
stakeholders
in
the
program
.
The
program
is
employing
aggressive
campaign
methods
to
reach
a
wider
and
bigger
audience
.
In
April
there
was
a
photo
,
video
,
poster
and
comic
competition
.
In
May
the
activists
visited
several
schools
,
which
are
located
near
diving
sites
in
Denpasar
,
Gilimanuk
,
Sumber
Klampok
,
Pemuteran
and
Nusa
Lembongan
Island
.
The
activists
tried
to
draw
the
students
'
attention
to
the
issue
of
preserving
coral
reefs
through
games
,
quizzes
and
slide
show
presentations
.
Meanwhile
,
an
"
If
I
Were
a
Fish
"
themed
children
drawing
competition
,
replete
with
a
quiz
,
games
and
child
singers
,
was
held
in
early
June
.
Hundreds
of
children
swarmed
the
venue
of
the
competition
.
And
,
in
cooperation
with
Hard
Rock
Beach
Hotel
'
s
management
,
the
activists
not
only
succeeded
in
staging
a
concert
,
but
also
organizing
a
two
-
day
exhibition
on
coral
reefs
at
the
hotel
.
A
simple
newsletter
,
FoR
Post
,
is
also
published
on
a
regular
basis
to
communicate
the
program
'
s
idea
to
a
wider
audience
.
A
two
-
day
Reef
Check
and
Underwater
Clean
Up
was
held
in
May
at
Bali
'
s
nine
prime
diving
sites
,
including
Menjangan
island
,
Amed
,
Pemuteran
,
Nusa
Lembongan
island
,
Nusa
Penida
island
and
Sanur
,
and
involved
34
experienced
divers
and
three
marine
scientists
.
The
results
showed
that
illegal
fishing
,
either
by
poisoning
or
bombing
,
land
-
based
pollution
,
sea
-
based
pollution
and
the
global
warming
phenomenon
had
inflicted
heavy
damage
on
a
large
portion
of
the
once
pristine
coral
reefs
.
Only
one
dive
site
,
Pakeh
beach
,
is
still
in
relatively
good
condition
,
with
a
hard
coral
population
percentage
ranging
from
46
.
3
percent
to
53
.
8
percent
.
The
rest
had
an
average
28
.
1
percent
hard
coral
population
.
"
Indonesia
once
had
the
richest
and
the
most
diverse
coral
reefs
in
the
world
.
Currently
,
only
29
percent
of
it
is
still
in
good
condition
,
"
Satriani
said
.
Put
it
simply
,
she
added
,
they
had
no
choice
but
to
work
fast
and
aggressively
,
otherwise
Bali
would
lose
its
coral
reefs
forever
.
[
Courtesy
of
the
Indonesian
Nature
Conservation
List
]
Top
Story
No
.
9
:
Miners
Blamed
for
Park
Damages
Source
:
Jakarta
Post
,
June
22
,
2001
BOGOR
Some
255
hectare
of
the
30
,
000
hectare
Gunung
Halimun
national
park
has
been
damaged
allegedly
by
illegal
mining
activities
,
an
official
said
on
Thursday
.
An
official
at
the
local
branch
of
the
Regional
Environmental
Impact
Management
Agency
(
Bapedalda
)
,
Eran
Subarna
,
said
the
damaged
areas
were
polluted
with
mercury
,
a
substance
used
by
miners
to
separate
gold
from
other
elements
.
Forest
rehabilitation
and
efforts
to
reduce
the
impact
of
mercury
pollution
on
the
damaged
areas
were
underway
,
Eran
said
.
Of
the
total
255
hectare
of
damaged
forest
,
Eran
said
,
26
.
34
hectares
had
been
rejuvenated
.
The
agency
,
in
cooperation
with
the
management
of
the
Gunung
Halimun
National
Park
,
has
planted
some
22
,
870
trees
in
the
destroyed
areas
,
including
pinus
,
mahogany
,
kaliandara
,
albasia
,
African
wood
and
waru
tree
.
The
Halimun
national
park
,
spanning
across
the
regencies
of
Lebak
,
Bogor
and
Sukabumi
,
in
Banten
and
West
Java
,
is
a
crucial
water
catchment
areas
for
at
least
30
million
people
,
including
Jakartans
.
[
Courtesy
of
the
Indonesian
Nature
Conservation
List
]
Top
Story
No
.
10
:
NRM
Noon
Seminar
Please
mark
your
calendar
for
noon
seminar
in
June
and
July
with
the
following
agenda
:
June
28
:
Owen
Lynch
of
the
Center
for
International
Environmental
Law
will
update
us
concerning
his
ongoing
work
with
BSP
Kemala
Partners
working
on
issues
of
land
rights
and
legal
reform
.
July
5
.
Not
yet
scheduled
July
12
.
Ian
Dutton
,
country
director
of
TNC
,
will
discuss
TNC
'
s
new
Global
Conservation
Agenda
.
July
19
.
Not
yet
scheduled
July
26
.
Chris
Bennett
of
WB
and
DFID
will
discuss
transparency
in
the
forest
sector
.
As
always
,
noon
seminar
will
start
at
12
.
30
on
the
17th
floor
of
Ratu
Plaza
Building
,
Jl
.
Jend
.
Sudirman
9
,
Jakarta
.
We
look
forward
to
your
participation
.
Regards
,
Isti
isti2000
@
nrm
.
or
.
id
Top
Story
No
.
11
:
Training
Workshops
in
Participatory
Development
Participatory
Development
:
Concepts
,
Tools
and
Application
in
PLA
/
PRA
Methods
Ottawa
,
Canada
July
16
-
21
,
2001
The
PD
workshop
focuses
on
core
participatory
concepts
,
tools
and
their
application
.
This
is
an
intensive
six
-
day
practical
and
experiential
workshop
set
in
the
community
to
maximize
learning
,
group
interaction
and
networking
.
Topics
include
:
The
Origins
of
Participatory
Development
,
Learning
and
Application
of
PRA
/
PLA
tools
(
ranking
,
venn
diagram
,
mapping
,
ranking
,
semi
-
structured
interviewing
,
trend
analysis
,
gender
analysis
and
others
methods
such
as
appreciative
inquiry
)
,
the
Application
of
Participation
to
Project
Design
,
Monitoring
and
Evaluation
,
Developing
Effective
Facilitation
Skills
,
Building
Action
Plans
and
Team
-
Building
.
Two
-
day
community
assignments
proposed
by
community
-
based
organizations
in
the
Ottawa
region
will
allow
participants
to
apply
tools
learned
in
the
workshop
to
real
-
life
situations
.
This
is
also
a
great
opportunity
to
network
with
other
practitioners
,
NGOs
,
donors
,
and
action
researchers
from
all
over
the
world
.
Very
limited
space
available
;
please
register
immediately
to
reserve
a
space
.
Participatory
Monitoring
and
Evaluation
Ottawa
,
Canada
July
23
-
26
,
2001
&
September
3
-
8
,
2001
Participatory
Monitoring
and
Evaluation
(
PM
&
E
)
involves
a
different
approach
to
project
monitoring
and
evaluation
by
involving
local
people
,
project
stakeholders
,
and
development
agencies
deciding
together
about
how
to
measure
results
and
what
actions
should
follow
once
this
information
has
been
collected
and
analyzed
.
This
intensive
six
day
experiential
workshop
is
practically
focused
with
daily
excursions
into
the
community
and
a
three
-
day
community
assignment
.
Topics
covered
at
the
workshop
include
:
Origins
of
PM
&
E
,
Skills
and
Attributes
of
a
PM
&
E
facilitator
,
Learning
PM
&
E
Tools
,
Designing
a
Monitoring
and
Evaluation
Framework
and
Actions
Plan
and
much
more
.
A
Project
/
Organization
Clinic
will
include
projects
from
participant
'
s
workplace
and
provide
a
rich
environment
for
feedback
.
Advanced
Facilitator
'
s
Workshop
Retreat
setting
outside
of
Ottawa
September
9
-
14
,
2001
This
workshop
is
an
opportunity
for
experienced
Facilitator
'
s
to
share
their
experiences
,
tools
and
methods
with
other
facilitators
.
Facilitator
'
s
from
various
facilitation
disciplines
such
as
PLA
methods
,
ToP
methods
,
VIPP
,
Appreciative
Inquiry
,
Iap2
and
Open
Space
are
encouraged
to
attend
this
unique
workshop
.
This
workshop
will
have
no
preset
agenda
or
presentations
.
An
Open
Space
Approach
will
be
used
.
The
first
day
,
participant
facilitators
will
shape
the
agenda
based
on
their
expectations
and
the
tools
and
methods
other
participant
facilitators
have
to
offer
.
Participants
will
implement
their
group
agenda
,
work
in
small
groups
,
facilitate
sessions
and
practice
giving
and
receiving
feedback
.
The
workshop
will
take
place
in
a
rural
retreat
center
overlooking
a
beautiful
lake
and
forest
.
Come
ready
to
facilitate
a
session
!
For
further
information
,
please
refer
to
the
web
site
at
:
http
:
//
www
.
mosaic
-
net
-
intl
.
ca
or
by
email
at
:
workshop
@
mosaic
-
net
-
intl
.
ca
Please
note
that
workshops
are
scheduled
back
-
to
-
back
so
that
participants
can
attend
more
than
one
workshop
,
if
they
so
which
,
to
consolidate
their
understanding
and
application
of
participatory
methods
and
tools
.
Facilitators
:
Françoise
Coupal
and
Helen
Patterson
.
Both
facilitators
have
extensive
experience
in
the
theory
and
application
of
participatory
development
and
PRA
having
worked
for
NGOs
,
community
organizations
,
the
World
Bank
and
various
United
Nations
agencies
.
Please
feel
free
to
forward
this
announcement
to
other
colleagues
!
Top
Story
No
.
12
:
Project
Coordinator
-
UK
Darwin
Initiative
Papuan
Plant
Diversity
Project
Three
year
fixed
term
appointment
The
Royal
Botanic
Gardens
,
Kew
,
is
a
vibrant
scientific
conservation
and
horticultural
institute
housing
the
most
comprehensive
living
plant
collection
in
the
world
and
attracting
over
one
million
visitors
each
year
.
We
are
a
leading
an
ambitious
project
to
rehabilitate
the
Herbarium
at
the
Biodiversity
Study
Centre
,
Universitas
Negeri
Papua
,
Manokwari
,
the
only
herbarium
in
the
Indonesian
part
of
the
megadiverse
tropical
island
of
New
Guinea
.
You
will
implement
a
far
-
reaching
programme
of
staff
and
student
training
in
herbarium
management
,
plant
exploration
and
research
aimed
at
significantly
enhancing
the
role
of
the
University
in
biodiversity
research
and
conservation
.
Your
own
research
will
be
centred
around
the
preparation
of
a
field
guide
to
the
flowering
plant
families
of
New
Guinea
.
This
position
presents
an
exciting
opportunity
in
which
you
will
spend
six
months
each
year
in
Papua
and
six
months
at
Kew
.
You
should
have
a
relevant
higher
degree
,
experience
of
working
in
a
herbarium
and
experience
of
working
overseas
.
Fluency
in
Indonesian
is
desirable
,
but
not
essential
.
This
is
a
three
-
year
fixed
term
appointment
for
which
the
salary
is
up
to
£
20
,
650
per
annum
depending
on
experience
.
A
terminal
bonus
will
be
paid
upon
satisfactory
completion
of
all
project
requirements
within
agreed
time
scales
.
Benefits
include
a
mainly
non
-
contributory
pension
,
generous
annual
leave
and
a
stunning
environment
.
Profile
-
UK
Darwin
Initiative
Papuan
Plant
Diversity
Project
Dr
.
John
Dransfield
Project
Leader
Herbarium
,
Royal
Botanic
Gardens
Kew
,
Richmond
,
Surrey
,
TW9
3AE
,
UK
The
flora
of
the
Indonesian
province
of
Papua
(
formerly
Irian
Jaya
)
,
the
western
part
of
the
island
of
New
Guinea
,
is
one
of
the
most
diverse
yet
least
well
known
in
the
world
.
The
Herbarium
at
Universitas
Negeri
Papua
,
Manokwari
is
the
only
local
plant
diversity
reference
collection
in
the
province
.
It
is
based
on
historical
collections
from
the
Dutch
colonial
period
,
many
of
which
are
not
duplicated
elsewhere
,
but
inadequate
curatorial
infrastructure
has
resulted
in
numerous
specimens
being
damaged
or
destroyed
by
pests
in
recent
decades
.
The
Herbarium
is
in
urgent
need
of
rehabilitation
to
prevent
further
degeneration
of
the
collections
,
so
that
it
can
play
a
more
effective
and
much
needed
role
in
exploration
and
conservation
.
Project
activities
will
involve
:
herbarium
renovation
and
development
;
training
staff
to
develop
best
management
of
the
Herbarium
and
skills
in
plant
collection
and
identification
;
augmenting
herbarium
collections
;
developing
a
database
;
developing
staff
research
skills
through
preparation
of
field
guides
(
palms
and
rattans
,
families
of
seed
plants
in
New
Guinea
)
;
building
collaboration
with
both
Papua
New
Guinea
and
the
UK
Application
form
and
further
information
available
from
:
Personnel
Department
Royal
Botanic
Gardens
Kew
,
Richmond
,
Surrey
TW9
3AB
Tel
.
:
020
8332
5184
/
5150
(
24
hour
)
Email
j
.
hancock
@
rbgkew
.
org
.
uk
Please
quote
job
ref
1152
Closing
date
is
9
July
2001
[
Courtesy
of
the
Indonesian
Nature
Conservation
List
]
Top
Story
No
.
13
:
Vacancies
at
The
Nature
Conservancy
The
Nature
Conservancy
(
TNC
)
is
an
international
non
-
profit
,
non
-
governmental
organization
dedicated
to
preserving
the
plants
,
animals
,
and
natural
communities
that
represent
the
diversity
of
life
on
Earth
by
protecting
the
lands
and
waters
they
need
to
survive
.
We
are
expanding
our
scope
of
work
to
include
the
province
of
East
Kalimantan
,
and
are
currently
building
a
team
of
dedicated
conservation
professionals
.
I
.
Community
Conservation
&
Development
Specialist
(
CCDS
)
Essential
functions
This
position
will
work
closely
with
selected
communities
and
local
governmental
and
non
-
governmental
organizations
to
develop
village
spatial
plans
that
include
a
conservation
component
.
Subsequently
,
this
position
will
promote
the
incorporation
of
these
village
spatial
plans
into
Kabupaten
-
wide
spatial
plans
.
Additionally
,
this
position
will
assist
to
design
and
test
model
community
conservation
and
development
areas
whereby
villagers
will
be
granted
rights
to
access
and
sustainably
manage
natural
resources
on
State
lands
.
Knowledge
/
Skills
Minimum
of
BSc
(
S1
)
,
preferred
S2
in
natural
resource
management
,
socio
-
economy
or
relevant
field
.
Minimum
of
5
years
professional
experience
conducting
rapid
rural
appraisals
and
participatory
mapping
techniques
.
Knowledge
of
and
experience
implementing
compatible
economic
development
activities
at
the
village
level
,
which
may
include
timber
and
non
-
timber
forest
products
,
agroforestry
,
ecotourism
and
revolving
loan
funds
that
link
with
conservation
.
Experience
designing
,
implementing
,
and
analyzing
socio
-
economic
surveys
.
Experience
with
participatory
methods
of
monitoring
and
evaluation
.
Experience
in
organizing
communities
to
achieve
conservation
and
development
objectives
.
Experience
collaborating
with
local
and
provincial
governments
to
achieve
conservation
objectives
.
Preferred
knowledge
of
socio
-
economic
and
natural
resource
conditions
in
East
Kalimantan
.
Complexity
/
Problem
Solving
This
position
will
need
a
highly
creative
and
self
-
motivated
person
to
be
able
to
organize
and
gain
support
from
various
socio
-
economic
groups
under
difficult
economic
conditions
.
Work
independently
without
the
requirement
for
detailed
management
review
of
most
work
.
Communication
/
Interpersonal
Contacts
The
successful
applicant
will
be
able
to
socialize
and
gain
support
for
the
work
of
The
Nature
Conservancy
from
multiple
stakeholder
groups
.
This
position
will
need
to
document
the
process
of
community
development
Consistently
demonstrate
the
highest
standards
of
professional
ethics
.
High
dedication
to
conservation
.
Ability
to
work
in
a
multiethnic
team
.
Working
Conditions
/
Physical
Effort
Frequent
travel
within
the
province
of
East
Kalimantan
and
occasionally
to
Jakarta
.
Wiliness
to
occasionally
reside
in
remote
rural
areas
for
several
weeks
at
a
time
.
II
.
GIS
Officer
Essential
Functions
In
conjunction
with
Bappeda
II
,
collect
and
analyze
spatial
information
related
to
developing
kabupaten
-
wide
spatial
plans
which
include
conservation
aspects
.
Promote
and
facilitate
collaboration
between
Bappeda
Tingkat
I
and
II
so
that
landscape
-
scale
conservation
issues
will
be
addressed
.
This
position
will
work
closely
with
TNC
community
forester
to
develop
village
land
use
maps
in
the
Berau
district
.
Duties
may
entail
a
wide
range
of
field
activities
related
to
mapping
,
such
as
,
extensive
use
of
GPS
and
geodetic
survey
instruments
.
Knowledge
/
Skills
Minimum
of
BSc
(
S1
)
in
natural
resource
management
or
relevant
field
.
Minimum
of
3
years
GIS
experience
in
a
professional
capacity
.
Extensive
experience
in
the
use
of
Arcview
GIS
program
,
including
the
Spatial
Analysis
extension
.
Extensive
experience
in
collecting
spatial
data
with
GPS
instruments
and
subsequent
analysis
of
complex
spatial
data
and
ability
to
produce
accurate
,
high
quality
maps
.
Ability
to
organize
and
teach
GIS
courses
to
multi
-
stakeholder
groups
.
Experience
obtaining
and
analyzing
satellite
images
with
IDRISI
GIS
and
other
programs
.
Complexity
/
Problem
Solving
Duties
may
include
assisting
researchers
to
geo
-
reference
sample
sites
in
remote
areas
of
Sangkulirang
Peninsula
and
other
locations
.
Work
independently
without
the
requirement
for
detailed
management
review
of
most
work
.
Communication
/
Interpersonal
Contacts
The
successful
applicant
will
be
able
to
socialize
and
gain
support
for
the
work
of
The
Nature
Conservancy
from
multiple
stakeholder
groups
.
Ability
to
closely
work
in
a
multi
-
ethnic
,
multi
-
disciplinary
team
Consistently
demonstrate
the
highest
standards
of
professional
ethics
.
High
dedication
to
conservation
.
Working
Condition
/
Physical
Effort
Wiliness
to
occasionally
stay
in
remote
areas
for
extended
periods
,
which
may
require
backpacking
and
camping
.
At
times
,
the
physical
effort
required
to
complete
the
tasks
could
be
exceptionally
high
.
Candidates
that
apply
for
this
position
should
be
in
excellent
physical
condition
.
Intended
starting
date
August
15
,
2001
Please
send
letter
of
interest
written
in
English
,
a
resume
/
CV
,
and
contact
address
,
phone
number
,
and
email
address
to
the
following
address
:
The
Nature
Conservancy
Jl
.
Kuranji
No
.
1
.
Samarinda
,
75123
Kalimantan
Timur
,
Indonesia
Or
email
cover
letter
and
CV
as
attachments
to
:
tnc
@
smd
.
mega
.
net
.
id
All
submissions
should
be
received
before
15
July
2001
.
The
Nature
Conservancy
is
an
Equal
Opportunity
Employer
Top
The
views
expressed
by
the
authors
and
organizations
contributing
to
this
electronic
newsletter
do
not
necessarily
reflect
the
views
of
the
NRM
Program
,
its
partner
organizations
,
USAID
,
or
its
government
of
Indonesia
sponsors
.
The
purpose
of
the
NRM
Headline
News
is
to
provide
a
forum
for
a
wide
diversity
of
opinion
and
information
on
NRM
Program
activities
,
selected
upcoming
events
and
news
.
The
NRM
Program
is
a
collaborative
program
between
the
governments
of
Indonesia
and
the
United
States
of
America
.
The
six
partners
implementing
the
NRM
Program
include
:
the
Environmental
Policy
and
Institutional
Strengthening
Indefinite
Quantity
Contract
(
EPIQ
)
,
the
Biodiversity
Support
Program
(
BSP
-
KEMALA
)
,
the
Coastal
Resources
Management
Program
(
CRMP
-
Proyek
Pesisir
)
,
Conservation
International
,
The
Nature
Conservancy
and
the
World
Wide
Fund
for
Nature
-
Indonesia
.
APRIL
responds
to
EoF
May
2006
investigation
-
Pekanbaru
(
EoF
News
)
–
Last
weekend
Eyes
on
the
Forest
received
a
letter
from
Asia
Pacific
Resources
International
Limited
Holdings
(
APRIL
)
commenting
on
EoF
’
s
Investigative
Report
May
2006
.
No
Place
to
Live
for
Riau
?
s
Elephants
-
Forest
to
Paper
,
Forest
to
Palm
Oil
and
No
Place
to
Live
for
Riau
’
s
Elephants
.
Pekanbaru
,
Indonesia
(
EoF
News
,
April
18
,
2006
)
-
Since
February
2006
,
the
media
are
full
with
stories
of
human
-
elephant
conflict
,
and
the
death
and
captures
of
endangered
Sumatran
elephants
in
Riau
,
Sumatra
.
Fires
keep
flaring
,
haze
troubles
again
-
Pekanbaru
(
EoF
News
)
–
Tera
Modis
satellite
detected
that
there
were
521
hotspots
appeared
from
Oct
.
1
to
Oct
.
7
.
It
escalated
quite
higher
than
Sep
22
-
30
period
with
only
103
hotspots
.
In
concession
that
formerly
proposed
for
PT
Chandra
Dirgantara
there
was
129
hotspots
in
this
period
alone
.
The
concession
now
is
allocated
for
oil
palm
plantation
where
several
timber
companies
holding
IPK
(
log
utilization
)
license
conducted
land
clearing
.
EoF
releases
first
version
-
EoF
releases
first
version
of
interactive
map
on
land
use
and
forest
loss
in
Riau
,
Sumatra
.
Pekanbaru
,
Indonesia
(
EoF
News
,
Feb
25
,
2006
)
-
EoF
today
released
the
first
version
of
an
interactive
map
that
will
make
it
easier
for
readers
to
follow
the
“
who
is
who
”
in
land
use
and
forest
conversion
in
Riau
Province
,
Sumatra
,
Indonesia
.
Eyes
on
the
Forest
(
EoF
)
provides
this
information
so
readers
.
PT
RAPP
COMMITS
MORE
CORPORATE
CRIME
-
WALHI
Media
Release
May
12
,
2006
--
Less
than
a
hundred
days
after
it
received
certification
of
its
plantations
from
the
independent
Indonesian
forestry
certification
agency
Lembaga
Ekolabel
Indonesia
,
the
giant
paper
pulp
company
Riau
Andalan
Pulp
and
Paper
(
RAPP
)
created
another
criminal
record
.
The
company
,
whose
LEI
certificate
was
condemned
by
many
groups
,
is
accused
of
a
series
of
violent
actions
against
the
people
of
Desa
Gading
Permai
in
the
Kampar
Kiri
Sub
District
,
Kampar
Regency
,
Riau
Province
,
Sumatra
.
Crack
down
illegal
logging
networks
-
Pekanbaru
(
EoF
News
)
–
President
Susilo
Bambang
Yudhoyono
urged
law
enforcers
to
crack
down
illegal
logging
networks
and
prosecute
persons
behind
such
a
crime
who
have
been
untouchable
before
the
law
for
a
long
time
.
NGOs
protest
the
certification
-
NGOs
protest
the
certification
of
Sustainable
Plantation
Management
by
LEI
to
PT
.
RAPP
.
Pekanbaru
,
RIAU
TRIBUNE
,
7
April
2006
(
Translation
from
Bahasa
)
—
NGOs
in
Riau
Province
of
Sumatra
issued
a
letter
of
protest
against
the
certification
of
Sustainable
Plantation
Management
by
the
Indonesian
Ecolabelling
Institute
(
LEI
)
to
PT
.
RAPP
.
However
,
PT
.
RAPP
of
APRIL
pointed
that
such
certification
is
the
right
of
the
ecolabelling
institute
.
District
heads
-
District
heads
,
pulp
mills
blamed
for
rampantly
illegal
logging
Pekanbaru
(
EoF
News
)
--
A
workshop
on
Illegal
Logging
Eradication
Improvement
held
by
Coordinating
Ministry
of
Politic
,
Law
,
and
Security
,
said
in
Jakarta
Wednesday
,
July
5
that
district
heads
(
bupati
)
,
who
issue
Industrial
Timber
Plantation
licenses
,
play
a
part
of
massive
deforestation
.
Minister
vows
to
hunt
down
illegal
loggers
,
backers
-
Pekanbaru
,
(
EoF
)
--
State
Minister
for
the
Environment
vows
to
search
illegal
logging
perpetrators
whom
he
alleges
as
Jakarta
-
based
forestry
tycoons
and
businessmen
,
reports
say
.
Analysis
of
Forest
and
Land
Fire
Hotspots
-
Analysis
of
Forest
and
Land
Fire
Hotspots
,
July
18
-
August
16
,
2005
.
Pekanbaru
,
Indonesia
(
EoF
News
,
august
22
,
2005
)
-
Maps
of
forest
and
land
fire
hotspots
in
Riau
Province
'
s
Industrial
Timber
Plantation
,
Logging
Concession
and
Oil
Palm
Plantation
companies
,
and
tables
with
information
on
the
number
of
fires
identified
in
the
concessions
of
the
different
companies
during
that
period
.
Read
more
...
Fighting
illegal
loggers
-
The
Jakarta
Post
,
Opinion
and
Editorial
-
March
02
,
2006
The
Indonesian
government
made
the
right
decision
to
aggressively
promote
forest
product
certification
,
or
ecolabeling
,
as
a
market
-
based
instrument
to
curb
illegal
logging
,
because
the
traditional
approach
to
protect
forests
through
a
regulatory
system
has
failed
miserably
due
to
the
corrupt
system
of
governance
and
inadequate
institutional
capacity
.
Fires
still
flare
in
Tesso
Nilo
forest
-
Pekanbaru
(
EoF
News
)
---
Tesso
Nilo
forest
fires
are
not
completely
extinguished
as
alleged
encroachers
still
set
fires
amid
authorities
’
pledge
to
bring
the
fires
perpetrators
to
the
court
.
Investigative
Report
June
2006
released
,
APP
responds
findings
-
Pekanbaru
(
EoF
News
)
---
Eyes
on
the
Forest
,
a
coalition
of
three
NGOs
in
Riau
,
published
Investigative
Report
June
2006
today
.
The
investigation
in
this
edition
was
conducted
in
Giam
Siak
Kecil
,
Senepis
,
and
Kerumutan
forest
blocks
.
Due
to
the
investigation
related
mostly
to
companies
associated
to
Asia
Pulp
&
Paper
(
APP
)
,
EoF
asked
response
from
the
related
company
to
our
findings
through
a
letter
EoF
sent
earlier
this
week
.
43
Palm
Oil
Companies
in
Riau
Province
Adopt
Sustainable
Palm
Oil
-
Pekanbaru
,
Riau
,
SUMATRA
--
43
palm
oil
companies
in
Riau
have
committed
to
adopt
the
Principles
&
Criteria
(
P
&
C
)
for
Sustainable
Palm
Oil
Production
,
at
the
3
rd
Roundtable
Meeting
on
Sustainable
Palm
Oil
(
RSPO
)
in
Singapore
on
November
2005
.
These
companies
include
6
companies
from
Asian
Agri
Group
,
8
companies
from
PT
.
Duta
Palma
Group
,
18
companies
from
Sinar
Mas
Group
,
9
companies
from
PTPN
Group
,
and
1
company
from
PT
Torganda
,
and
PT
.
Tunggal
Perkasa
.
DNA
technology
to
curb
illegal
timber
trade
-
KUCHING
,
July
29
(
Bernama
)
--
The
United
Kingdom
(
UK
)
Department
for
Environment
,
Food
and
Rural
Affairs
(
Defra
)
has
awarded
RM102
,
419
(
15
,
000
pounds
)
for
a
pilot
study
project
as
part
of
efforts
to
monitor
the
international
timber
trade
.
Government
urge
-
Government
urge
companies
shows
support
to
combat
illegal
logging
(
Pekanbaru
,
EoF
News
)
–
The
Indonesian
government
shows
support
to
combat
forest
crime
including
illegal
logging
and
slash
-
and
-
burn
activity
in
clearing
land
for
plantation
,
reports
said
.
Global
pulp
mill
growth
threatens
forests
,
may
collapse
-
JAKARTA
(
AFP
)
-
The
rapidly
expanding
world
pulp
mill
industry
could
be
poised
for
collapse
due
to
a
failure
by
financial
institutions
to
research
how
wood
can
be
found
to
feed
new
mills
,
a
report
said
.
Investigative
Report
July
2006
released
-
Pekanbaru
(
EoF
News
)
–
Coalition
of
three
environmental
NGOs
in
Riau
,
Eyes
on
the
Forest
,
releases
Investigative
Report
July
2006
today
.
The
EoF
’
s
investigation
found
violation
allegedly
perpetrated
by
both
Asia
Pacific
Resources
International
Holdings
Limited
(
APRIL
)
and
Asia
Pulp
&
Paper
(
APP
)
.
Riau
Governor
warns
to
prosecute
forest
fire
perpetrators
-
Pekanbaru
(
EoF
News
)
–
Following
escalating
forest
fires
and
more
hotspots
detected
,
Riau
Governor
said
the
authority
will
regard
the
fires
land
as
“
status
quo
”
plot
.
companies
responsible
-
11
companies
responsible
for
forest
fires
,
Ministry
says
Pekanbaru
(
EoF
News
)
—
The
Ministry
of
Environment
disclosed
that
11
forestry
-
based
and
plantation
companies
in
Riau
had
been
reported
to
the
police
for
committing
burning
forest
and
land
practices
this
month
.
The
process
for
prosecuting
the
companies
is
underway
.
Indonesia
embraces
the
U
.
S
to
fight
illegal
logging
-
Pekanbaru
(
EoF
News
)
--
Indonesia
and
the
United
States
of
America
will
sign
anti
-
illegal
logging
partnership
agreement
in
September
next
year
in
an
attempt
to
eradicate
illegal
logging
and
illegal
timber
trading
.
Human
Elephant
Conflict
and
Forest
Clearing
in
Libo
Block
-
Human
Elephant
Conflict
and
Forest
Clearing
in
Libo
Block
,
Riau
Province
Pekanbaru
,
Indonesia
(
EoF
News
,
March
10
,
2006
)
-
Six
elephants
were
found
dead
last
week
in
an
oil
palm
plantation
at
the
border
of
Riau
and
North
Sumatra
,
apparently
poisoned
.
At
least
17
elephants
have
repeatedly
raided
Balai
Raja
village
in
Riau
'
s
Bengkalis
District
.
Minister
criticizes
weak
law
enforcement
in
illegal
logging
-
Pekanbaru
,
EoF
--
Minister
of
Forestry
says
his
doubt
to
illegal
logging
seizure
’
s
gain
this
year
that
will
not
attain
Rp
2
.
7
trillion
as
parliament
expected
,
a
report
says
.
APRIL
'
s
New
Road
Threatens
Natural
Forest
in
Kampar
Peninsula
.
-
Pekanbaru
,
Indonesia
(
EoF
News
,
May
27
,
2005
)
-
New
investigations
by
Eyes
on
the
Forest
reveal
continued
forest
destruction
in
APRIL
'
s
concession
area
.
At
least
216
hectare
of
natural
peat
swamp
forest
have
recently
been
opened
and
have
brought
illegal
loggers
and
squatters
to
the
area
...
Read
more
...
APP
,
APRIL
put
aside
EoF
concerns
on
deforestation
-
Pekanbaru
–
(
EoF
News
)
–
In
responding
back
the
replies
from
APP
on
Investigative
Report
June
2006
and
from
APRIL
on
IR
May
2006
,
Eyes
on
the
Forest
learns
that
the
two
companies
did
not
pay
attention
much
to
findings
which
highlighted
on
conservation
concerns
.
More
than
40
%
of
Riau
'
s
fires
burn
in
APP
-
More
than
40
%
of
Riau
'
s
fires
burn
in
APP
and
partner
'
s
concessions
.
Pekanbaru
,
Indonesia
(
EoF
News
,
March
23
,
2005
)
-
This
year
,
forest
and
land
fires
in
Riau
have
started
in
the
third
week
of
January
.
The
number
of
hot
spots
increased
from
143
during
that
week
to
about
2800
hotspots
between
14
and
21
February
.
Forest
fires
threaten
human
health
and
destroy
biodiversity
.
According
to
Eyes
on
the
Forest
,
more
than
40
%
of
these
fires
burned
inside
Asia
Pulp
and
Paper
(
APP
)
and
their
partners
'
concessions
.
Eyes
on
the
Forest
also
reports
that
many
of
the
same
companies
were
responsible
for
forest
and
land
fires
since
2003
...
Read
more
...
Investigative
Report
April
2006
released
,
APP
replies
-
Pekanbaru
,
(
EoF
News
)
–
Eyes
on
the
Forest
publishes
Investigative
Report
April
2006
today
(
July
4
,
2006
)
confirming
its
findings
that
several
timber
companies
and
a
group
allegedly
committed
breaches
against
existing
law
set
by
the
government
.
Natural
Forest
Timber
Supplier
for
RAPP
(
APRIL
)
in
Kampar
Peninsula
,
Riau
.
-
JIKALAHARI
Investigative
Report
April
2006
(
May
31
)
--
Kampar
Peninsula
natural
forest
area
in
Palalawan
and
Siak
District
of
Riau
Province
,
Sumatra
,
is
the
largest
remaining
natural
forest
area
in
Riau
,
with
an
area
of
447
,
000
ha
.
Riau
Declaration
on
Peatlands
and
Climate
Change
-
Key
Stakeholders
from
12
Countries
issued
Riau
Declaration
on
Peatlands
and
Climate
Change
Pekanbaru
,
Indonesia
(
EoF
News
,
February
3
,
2006
)
—
61
participants
from
12
countries
participated
in
the
Workshop
on
Vulnerability
of
Carbon
Pools
in
Tropical
Peatlands
held
in
Pekanbaru
,
Riau
,
Sumatra
from
23
-
26
January
2006
.
At
the
end
of
the
workshop
,
participants
agreed
to
issue
Riau
Declaration
on
Peatlands
and
Climate
Change
.
Read
more
...
WWF
rounds
on
paper
groups
over
Sumatran
-
WWF
rounds
on
paper
groups
over
Sumatran
jungles
By
Shawn
Donnan
in
Jakarta
.
Financial
Times
,
13
July
2006
.
--
Asia
Pulp
&
Paper
and
APRIL
,
the
Indonesian
paper
producers
,
are
accelerating
the
deforestation
of
Sumatra
'
s
jungles
in
spite
of
a
bid
to
portray
themselves
as
green
,
according
to
WWF
,
the
conservation
group
.
APP
and
APRIL
respond
on
EoF
Investigative
Report
-
APP
and
APRIL
respond
on
Eyes
on
the
Forest
’
s
Investigative
Report
December
2005
edition
.
Today
Eyes
on
the
Forest
(
EoF
)
released
its
report
of
December
2005
investigation
.
It
confirmed
that
Asia
Pulp
and
Paper
’
s
(
APP
)
partners
logged
in
Giam
Siak
Kecil
Forest
Block
;
Asia
Pacific
Resources
International
Holdings
Ltd
’
s
(
APRIL
)
partner
logged
in
Kerumutan
Forest
Block
;
and
PT
.
Sumatera
Timber
Utama
Damai
’
s
partners
logged
in
the
buffer
zone
of
Bukit
Tigapuluh
National
Park
.
In
response
to
the
findings
,
APP
and
APRIL
have
sent
their
comments
to
EoF
.
Put
out
fires
by
stopping
conversion
on
peatlands
-
An
Eyes
on
the
Forest
Report
on
Forest
Fires
July
was
the
month
worst
hit
by
forest
and
land
fires
in
Indonesia
.
According
to
MODIS
Web
Fire
Mapper
,
29
.
4
%
of
the
total
hotspots
in
Indonesia
in
July
occurred
in
Riau
Province
,
with
1
,
419
hotspots
in
total
.
The
province
was
also
responsible
for
causing
36
.
9
%
of
the
total
hotspots
in
Indonesia
between
1
January
and
31
July
2006
.
25
July
alone
saw
the
largest
number
of
hotspots
per
day
this
year
,
with
445
hotspots
.
The
haze
in
Riau
has
been
forcing
people
to
wear
masks
and
turn
on
their
vehicles
'
lights
during
the
day
due
to
low
visibility
,
even
to
50
meters
.
Several
flights
were
delayed
or
cancelled
.
It
is
reported
that
the
haze
reached
Malaysia
,
Singapore
and
Thailand
.
Interactive
Map
-
Interactive
Map
on
Elephant
Distribution
and
Conflict
in
Riau
,
Sumatra
.
Pekanbarau
,
Riau
(
EoF
News
)
.
Today
,
EyesontheForest
released
an
update
to
the
“
Elephant
GIS
”
on
its
interactive
map
site
.
By
opening
the
“
Wildlife
”
tab
,
users
will
be
able
to
relate
elephant
distribution
and
very
rough
estimates
of
elephant
numbers
in
Riau
to
forest
cover
,
conversion
of
forest
to
pulp
and
oil
palm
plantations
,
and
the
often
tragic
outcome
of
conflict
between
humans
and
elephants
.
The
data
have
been
collected
since
2000
by
WWF
’
s
Tesso
Nilo
project
,
often
in
close
collaboration
with
Indonesia
’
s
Natural
Resource
Conservation
Agency
(
BKSDA
)
in
Riau
.
You
can
find
these
maps
under
the
“
RESOURCES
-
MAPs
”
tab
of
the
EoF
home
page
.
The
interactive
map
can
only
be
viewed
with
Internet
Explorer
after
you
have
downloaded
and
installed
Adobe
’
s
SVG
Viewer
plug
-
in
.
Stops
forest
conversion
in
its
concession
in
Libo
Forest
Block
-
APRIL
stops
forest
conversion
in
its
concession
in
Libo
Forest
Block
to
give
elephant
experts
a
chance
to
review
the
situation
.
Pekanbaru
,
Riau
,
Indonesia
(
EoF
News
,
April
13
,
2006
)
.
Today
Eyes
on
the
Forest
(
EoF
)
released
its
report
of
March
2006
Investigation
.
Eyes
on
the
Forest
confirmed
that
natural
forest
inside
a
concession
(
PT
.
Bina
Daya
Bintara
)
associated
with
Asia
Pacific
Resources
International
Holdings
Ltd
(
APRIL
)
has
been
converted
since
August
2005
and
the
wood
was
delivered
to
the
PT
.
Indah
Kiat
Pulp
&
Paper
mill
(
PT
.
IKPP
)
of
Asia
Pulp
&
Paper
(
APP
)
.
Riau
Province
:
Rank
No
.
1
in
Illegal
Timber
Export
-
Pekanbaru
,
KOMPAS
--
Rampant
illegal
logging
practices
in
Riau
have
placed
the
province
on
the
top
list
of
provinces
in
Indonesia
with
the
highest
rate
of
illegal
timber
export
,
beside
Kalimantan
and
Papua
.
Every
month
about
126
,
000
cubic
meters
of
illegal
timber
are
exported
to
Malaysia
from
this
province
alone
.
Government
promises
-
Government
promises
to
halt
forest
fires
September
2
Pekanbaru
(
EoF
News
)
--
President
Susilo
Bambang
Yudhoyono
delivered
a
deadline
for
his
subordinates
to
stop
forest
fires
by
September
2
,
as
he
planned
to
officially
visit
Singapore
.
Mitigation
of
elephants
'
conflicts
protocol
-
Mitigation
of
elephants
'
conflicts
protocol
to
be
applied
in
Riau
soon
Jakarta
,
Indonesia
(
ANTARA
News
,
March
6
,
2006
)
-
The
Directorate
General
for
Forest
and
Nature
Conservation
(
PHKA
)
and
the
Worldwide
Fund
for
Nature
(
WWF
)
have
agreed
to
implement
the
Protocol
on
Mitigation
of
Elephants
Conflicts
as
a
basis
for
the
resolution
of
conflicts
between
elephants
and
humans
that
have
been
occurring
at
increasing
frequency
in
Riau
province
over
the
past
few
months
.
WHO
:
Dirty
air
a
regular
killer
in
Asia
-
(
The
Associated
Press
--
Aug
20
)
--
A
smoky
haze
that
shrouded
parts
of
Southeast
Asia
this
month
,
forcing
schools
and
businesses
to
close
,
is
just
one
element
of
an
air
pollution
problem
that
kills
hundreds
of
thousands
of
people
in
the
region
annually
,
the
World
Health
Organization
said
.
Forest
fires
worsen
,
five
detained
-
Pekanbaru
,
(
EoF
News
)
—
Riau
forest
and
land
fires
causing
thick
haze
have
shown
their
peak
in
the
middle
of
August
as
hotspots
detected
by
satellite
showed
the
record
over
several
months
.
Forest
and
land
fires
raging
several
areas
in
Riau
including
Tesso
Nilo
National
Park
.
EoF
launches
Investigative
Report
May
2006
-
Pekanbaru
(
EoF
News
)
–
Eyes
on
the
Forest
,
a
coalition
of
three
NGOs
in
Riau
,
has
published
EoF
Investigative
Report
May
2006
.
The
investigation
was
conducted
in
Kampar
and
Kerumutan
forest
blocks
involving
several
timber
companies
Eyes
on
the
Forest
Statement
-
On
June
3
,
2005
,
APRIL
released
a
statement
saying
that
all
their
suppliers
have
legal
licenses
.
On
2
May
2005
,
Eyes
on
the
Forest
investigators
had
reported
that
APRIL
suppliers
were
operating
with
illegal
licenses
.
Fighting
illegal
loggers
.
-
The
Jakarta
Post
,
Opinion
and
Editorial
-
March
02
,
2006
--
The
Indonesian
government
made
the
right
decision
to
aggressively
promote
forest
product
certification
,
or
ecolabeling
,
as
a
market
-
based
instrument
to
curb
illegal
logging
,
because
the
traditional
approach
to
protect
forests
through
a
regulatory
system
has
failed
miserably
due
to
the
corrupt
system
of
governance
and
inadequate
institutional
capacity
.
Case
Two
:
Elephant
Carcass
Found
in
Lubuk
Batu
-
Ivory
Hunting
on
Sumatran
Elephant
is
Rampant
in
Riau
,
By
Bagus
Pratomo
Media
Indonesia
Online
:
May
8
,
2006
PEKANBARU
--
MIOL
:
World
Wide
Fund
for
Nature
(
WWF
)
Riau
indicates
that
elephant
poaching
for
the
ivory
is
rampant
in
Riau
.
Since
end
of
February
this
year
,
at
least
four
elephants
were
dead
without
ivory
.
EoF
Interactive
Map
-
EoF
Interactive
Map
now
links
APP
and
APRIL
pulp
mills
to
forest
conversion
in
individual
industrial
timber
concessions
.
Pekanbaru
,
Riau
,
Indonesia
(
EoF
News
,
April
7
,
2006
)
.
Today
,
Eyes
on
the
Forest
released
an
updated
version
of
the
“
Industrial
Timber
Plantation
”
data
base
for
its
Interactive
Map
.
EoF
’
s
interactive
maps
allow
users
to
relate
the
timber
plantation
data
to
the
progression
of
forest
conversion
in
Riau
,
locations
of
existing
and
proposed
protected
areas
,
and
ranges
of
elephants
and
sites
where
they
or
people
got
killed
during
conflicts
.
Users
are
now
able
to
see
which
of
the
many
small
pulp
wood
concessions
active
in
Riau
,
Sumatra
are
associated
with
which
of
the
two
pulp
mills
operating
there
,
Asia
Pulp
and
Paper
(
APP
)
or
Asia
Pacific
Resources
International
Holdings
(
APRIL
)
.
Within
one
week
,
two
elephants
killed
for
the
ivory
-
Pekanbaru
(
EoF
)
—
Within
one
week
two
Sumatran
elephant
carcasses
found
in
Riau
,
Sumatra
.
Both
carcasses
indicate
that
the
elephant
were
shot
to
death
for
the
ivory
.
Holes
from
bullets
found
on
the
foreheads
,
and
the
ivories
removed
.
First
carcass
was
found
on
May
3
in
Tasik
serai
Village
,
Bengkalis
District
,
Riau
,
and
the
other
one
was
found
on
May
8
in
Pontian
Mekar
village
,
District
of
Indragiri
Hulu
,
Riau
,
Sumatra
.
Sumatra
'
s
Peat
Swamp
Forest
-
Sumatra
'
s
Peat
Swamp
Forest
Threatened
with
Collapse
,
Must
Be
Protected
Pekanbaru
,
Jakarta
,
Hamburg
,
Helsinki
,
London
(
Jikalahari
,
CAPPA
,
Robin
Wood
and
Friends
of
the
Earth
Indonesia
,
Finland
and
UK
,
April
19
,
2006
)
-
Environmental
organizations
Jikalahari
,
CAPPA
,
ROBIN
WOOD
and
Friends
of
the
Earth
from
Indonesia
,
Finland
and
UK
warn
today
that
one
of
the
largest
tropical
peat
swamp
forests
in
the
world
might
collapse
if
logging
operations
and
conversion
of
peat
swamp
forests
into
plantations
by
the
paper
companies
APRIL
and
APP
continue
.
International
Oil
Palm
Conference
not
to
?
degrade
environment
?
-
Organizer
says
International
Oil
Palm
Conference
not
to
‘
degrade
environment
’
Pekanbaru
,
(
EoF
News
)
--
An
International
Oil
Palm
Conference
(
IOPC
2006
)
is
held
in
Bali
on
June
19
–
23
as
the
Indonesian
government
said
palm
oil
is
“
the
most
prepared
source
of
biofuel
”
as
it
has
a
supply
source
from
huge
palm
plantations
,
a
report
said
.
Case
One
:
Elephant
Carcass
Found
in
Tasik
Serai
-
Elephant
Death
Because
Of
Gun
Shot
Temporary
result
of
necropsy
in
Tasik
Serai
.
Riau
Pos
,
May
5
,
2006
[
An
English
translation
of
Bahasa
version
]
Pekanbaru
—
Recent
death
of
male
elephant
in
Tasik
Serai
Village
Kilometer
42
,
Sub
District
Pinggir
,
Riau
,
shows
strong
indication
of
poaching
by
ivory
hunters
.
Holes
from
bullets
found
in
some
parts
of
the
body
,
such
as
on
the
foreheads
,
back
of
the
ears
,
and
near
the
genital
.
The
ivory
of
the
elephant
,
aged
around
35
years
,
removed
and
the
trunk
was
cut
off
.
WWF
warns
over
pulp
giant
in
Indonesia
-
Agance
France
Presse
,
July
11
,
2006
JAKARTA
,
July
11
,
2006
(
AFP
)
-
Conservation
group
WWF
said
Tuesday
that
one
of
the
world
'
s
largest
paper
and
pulp
companies
was
failing
to
live
up
to
pledges
to
help
protect
some
of
Indonesia
'
s
most
important
remaining
forests
.
Fires
rage
Tesso
Nilo
National
Park
-
Pekanbaru
(
EoF
News
)
–
At
least
60
hectares
of
Tesso
Nilo
National
Park
is
raged
by
fires
amid
raids
conducted
by
the
Riau
Provincial
Natural
Conservation
Agency
(
BKSDA
)
confiscating
heavy
equipments
used
by
encroachers
.
Forest
and
Land
Fire
Hotspots
Data
Collection
-
Forest
and
Land
Fire
Hotspots
Data
Collection
-
Maps
and
Tables
,
July
18
-
August
11
,
2005
.
Data
of
forest
and
land
fire
hotspots
in
Riau
Province
were
collected
from
MODIS
Web
Fire
Mapper
and
presented
in
maps
and
tables
.
Look
detai
...
Hazy
Pekanbaru
hosts
Asean
meeting
,
rallies
dispersed
-
Pekanbaru
(
EoF
News
)
–
Thick
smog
blanketing
Pekanbaru
of
Riau
capital
Friday
amid
five
ASEAN
environmental
ministers
’
meeting
to
solve
deteriorating
haze
problem
.
Riau
Police
office
dispersed
rallies
staged
by
conservationist
NGOs
outside
a
hotel
where
delegates
of
the
meeting
stay
.
Rampant
encroachment
hits
Tesso
Nilo
,
elephants
agonized
-
Pekanbaru
,
(
EoF
News
)
–
More
people
encroach
Tesso
Nilo
forest
in
Riau
as
illegal
occupiers
come
over
causing
deforestation
,
forest
fires
and
escalating
conflict
between
humans
and
Sumatran
elephants
.
Parliament
introduces
haze
agreement
bill
in
Riau
-
Pekanbaru
,
(
EoF
News
)
--
A
House
of
Representative
’
s
Commission
visit
Riau
for
socializing
ASEAN
Transboundary
Haze
agreement
that
requires
the
parliament
’
s
approval
for
ratification
amid
increasing
hotspots
of
forest
fires
detected
in
the
province
.
Sumatran
tigers
habitat
threatened
by
hot
spots
-
Pekanbaru
,
Indonesia
(
ANTARA
News
March
03
09
:
20
)
-
Tens
of
Sumatran
tigers
living
in
the
conserved
forest
area
of
Senepis
,
Dumai
city
,
Riau
,
are
in
danger
of
being
killed
following
the
dicovery
of
a
number
of
hot
spots
in
the
area
,
a
local
enironment
official
said
on
Thursday
(
3
/
2
)
.
Indonesian
forest
fires
flare
,
region
holds
breath
-
By
Ed
Davies
,
August
9
--
JAKARTA
(
Reuters
)
-
Choking
smoke
from
Indonesian
forest
fires
marks
the
return
of
an
annual
hazard
across
the
region
which
authorities
appear
powerless
to
stop
and
that
only
one
thing
can
be
relied
upon
to
contain
--
rain
.
The
fires
are
a
regular
occurrence
during
the
dry
season
in
areas
such
as
Sumatra
and
Borneo
,
but
the
situation
has
worsened
in
the
last
decade
,
with
timber
and
plantation
firms
often
blamed
for
deliberately
starting
fires
to
clear
land
.
APP
says
they
stopped
sourcing
fiber
from
the
APRIL
concession
-
APP
says
they
stopped
sourcing
fiber
from
the
APRIL
concession
in
Libo
Forest
Block
,
however
does
not
commit
to
stop
sourcing
of
wood
from
other
areas
in
Libo
.
Pekanbaru
,
Indonesia
(
EoF
News
,
April
27
,
2006
)
–
Today
,
Eyes
on
the
Forest
received
a
“
Letter
to
Stakeholder
”
which
APP
had
distributed
to
“
Valued
Stakeholders
”
on
21st
April
.
In
the
Letter
,
APP
stated
:
“
We
fully
support
APRIL
’
s
decision
to
stop
sourcing
wood
fiber
from
Bina
Daya
Bintara
;
consequently
we
are
not
receiving
wood
fiber
from
that
area
any
longer
”
.
More
hotspots
detected
in
Riau
,
Rokan
Hilir
worst
-
More
hotspots
detected
in
Riau
,
Rokan
Hilir
worst
Pekanbaru
,
(
EoF
News
)
--
Hotspots
detected
in
Riau
mount
as
haze
blanketed
areas
in
Pekanbaru
,
Kampar
,
Rokah
Hilir
,
Siak
,
Pelalawan
and
Bengkalis
,
mostly
in
the
morning
.
In
Riau
capital
,
Pekanbaru
,
haze
blanketed
the
city
on
Friday
morning
,
Jul
.
21
,
despite
the
visibility
remains
in
good
range
.
EoF
Gallery
Home
EoF
News
APP
,
APRIL
put
aside
EoF
concerns
on
deforestation
APP
,
APRIL
put
aside
EoF
concerns
on
deforestation
Wednesday
,
04
October
2006
Pekanbaru
–
(
EoF
News
)
–
In
responding
back
the
replies
from
APP
on
Investigative
Report
June
2006
and
from
APRIL
on
IR
May
2006
,
Eyes
on
the
Forest
learns
that
the
two
companies
did
not
pay
attention
much
to
findings
which
highlighted
on
conservation
concerns
.
In
reverse
,
both
APP
(
Asia
Pulp
&
Paper
)
and
APRIL
(
Asia
Pacific
Resources
International
Limited
Holdings
)
mainly
stressed
their
response
on
legal
analysis
over
EoF
reports
which
remain
debatable
,
questionable
,
even
lead
to
misleading
.
On
APP
APP
’
s
statement
saying
it
does
not
accept
any
wood
fiber
that
originates
within
any
nationally
-
recognized
conservation
forest
is
contradictory
to
EoF
investigation
findings
,
either
in
concession
of
PT
Ruas
Utama
Jaya
(
Senepis
forest
block
)
or
in
PT
Bina
Duta
Laksana
(
Kerumutan
block
)
.
In
PT
Ruas
Utama
Jaya
’
s
concession
,
EoF
found
that
the
concession
overlaps
with
natural
forest
,
protected
forest
and
deep
peat
soil
that
all
protected
by
the
existing
Indonesian
laws
.
Meanwhile
in
PT
Bina
Duta
Laksana
’
s
,
the
concession
overlaps
with
natural
forest
and
deep
peat
soil
.
So
APP
’
s
argument
saying
it
“
does
not
accept
”
any
wood
fiber
from
conservation
forest
was
proved
misleading
.
APP
claims
that
RKT
(
Annual
Working
Plan
)
is
a
legitimate
basis
to
operate
for
its
partner
PT
Ruas
Utama
Jaya
in
Senepis
block
.
On
the
other
hand
,
EoF
learns
that
RKT
(
Annual
Working
Plan
)
is
not
an
easy
ticket
to
operate
concession
definitively
if
some
requirements
are
not
conducted
in
advance
as
stipulated
by
article
14
of
Ministry
of
Forestry
’
s
Decree
Number
312
/
Kpts
-
II
/
1999
on
Procedure
to
Granting
Selective
Logging
Concession
through
Proposal
.
The
decree
stipulates
that
an
approved
timber
company
should
undergo
a
feasibility
study
and
an
environment
impact
analysis
(
AMDAL
)
before
its
proposal
approved
by
the
authority
.
The
reporting
of
feasibility
study
would
take
12
months
at
the
maximum
from
the
minister
ordered
such
a
requirement
.
EoF
learns
that
there
is
an
obvious
gap
between
Ruas
Utama
Jaya
that
leans
its
legitimacy
on
RKT
and
Bina
Duta
Laksana
which
already
gained
the
Minister
Decree
of
207
/
Menhut
-
II
/
2006
dated
8
June
2006
.
EoF
is
calling
APP
to
halt
sourcing
its
timber
from
conservation
forests
and
from
unlawful
operations
.
The
company
should
respect
the
existing
laws
in
Indonesia
.
On
APRIL
APRIL
said
EoF
allegations
are
unjustified
,
but
the
coalition
of
three
NGOs
said
that
such
response
divert
main
points
and
concerns
of
the
May
2000
Investigative
Report
.
It
is
unfair
when
APRIL
accused
EoF
findings
of
outdated
information
as
the
finding
occurred
in
May
2006
,
despite
the
company
got
revising
license
from
the
Minister
of
Forestry
.
APRIL
claimed
that
“
leaving
Kampar
Peninsular
unmanaged
is
not
an
option
”
is
misleading
and
out
of
context
from
EoF
investigation
.
The
report
found
that
APRIL
let
concession
of
PT
Rimba
Mutiara
Permai
unplanted
with
acacia
,
showing
it
has
no
responsibility
to
protect
the
granted
concession
area
.
APRIL
believed
that
its
role
in
Kampar
Peninsular
will
end
the
illegal
logging
,
but
EoF
chain
of
custody
investigation
found
that
the
company
conducted
illegal
logging
in
concession
of
CV
Harapan
Jaya
and
PT
Madukoro
.
The
company
also
did
not
respond
on
EoF
findings
regarding
to
its
partners
concessions
overlap
with
natural
forest
,
protection
area
and
deep
peat
soil
.
Through
a
letter
to
Jikalahari
--
a
reference
to
respond
EoF
report
—
APRIL
claimed
that
“
three
-
meter
-
rule
”
only
for
“
sensitive
catchments
headwaters
”
,
which
apparently
misleading
and
against
the
existing
law
.
EoF
also
stressed
that
1994
Riau
Land
Use
Planning
remains
existing
and
not
substituted
yet
by
2001
-
2015
version
as
claimed
by
APRIL
.
EoF
is
calling
APRIL
to
halt
sourcing
its
timber
from
conservation
forests
and
from
unlawful
operations
.
The
company
should
respect
the
existing
laws
in
Indonesia
.
--
-
Find
APP
and
APRIL
on
The
Eleventh
Hour
for
Riau
'
s
Forests
Related
Article
News
Calendar
a
.
cal_head
{
color
:
green
;
}
a
.
cal_head
:
hover
{
text
-
decoration
:
none
;
}
table
.
calendar
{
border
:
0
;
border
-
spacing
:
1px
;
padding
:
2px
;
width
:
100
%
;
}
.
cal_head
{
background
-
color
:
#
DDDDDD
;
color
:
green
;
font
-
family
:
Verdana
;
font
-
size
:
11
;
font
-
weight
:
bold
;
font
-
style
:
normal
;
text
-
align
:
center
;
}
.
cal_days
{
background
-
color
:
#
DDDDDD
;
color
:
gray
;
font
-
family
:
Verdana
;
font
-
size
:
11
;
font
-
weight
:
bold
;
font
-
style
:
normal
;
}
.
cal_content
{
background
-
color
:
#
EEEEEE
;
color
:
#
000000
;
font
-
family
:
Verdana
;
font
-
size
:
10
;
font
-
weight
:
normal
;
font
-
style
:
normal
;
}
.
cal_today
{
background
-
color
:
white
;
color
:
green
;
font
-
family
:
Verdana
;
font
-
size
:
10
;
font
-
weight
:
bold
;
font
-
style
:
normal
;
}
.
cal_event
,
a
.
cal_event
{
background
-
color
:
#
DDDDDD
;
color
:
red
;
font
-
family
:
Verdana
;
font
-
size
:
10
;
font
-
weight
:
bold
;
font
-
style
:
normal
;
}
«
Perkembangan
Teknologi
Informasi
di
Indonesia
Masyarakat
Java
Dikumpulkan
di
Bandung
»
Student
-
Centered
Collaborative
Learning
Using
Q
&
A
on
Web
Ana
Hadiana
Department
of
Information
Engineering
,
Faculty
of
Engineering
,
Shinshu
University
cana
[
at
]
softeng
-
mail
[
dot
]
cs
[
dot
]
shinshu
-
u
.
ac
[
dot
]
jp
Elan
Djaelani
Research
Center
for
Informatics
,
Indonesian
Institute
of
Science
elan
[
at
]
informatika
[
dot
]
lipi
[
dot
]
go
[
dot
]
id
Abstract
We
propose
in
this
paper
an
educational
learning
environment
named
as
Asynchronous
collaborative
learning
environment
on
Web
(
ActiveWeb
)
.
This
system
provides
collaboration
functions
among
students
,
in
order
to
make
students
more
active
and
interactive
in
learning
process
based
on
Web
technology
without
any
restriction
of
time
and
place
,
and
in
order
to
decrease
teacher
’
s
load
.
In
this
system
,
students
collaborate
each
other
for
constructing
shared
knowledge
as
much
as
possible
according
to
their
level
of
knowledge
.
Students
can
collaborate
with
each
other
through
questions
-
answer
to
acquire
further
knowledge
.
In
this
paper
we
describe
the
development
of
a
prototype
system
of
ActiveWeb
.
Keywords
:
Collaboration
,
Asynchronous
,
Distance
Learning
,
Web
,
Q
&
A
Intisari
Kami
mengajukan
dalam
makalah
ini
sebuah
lingkungan
pembelajaran
pendidikan
yang
dinamakan
sebagai
Asynchronous
collaborative
learning
environment
on
Web
(
ActiveWeb
)
.
Sistem
ini
menyediakan
fungsi
-
fungsi
kolaborasi
di
antara
pelajar
,
dalam
rangka
membuat
para
pelajar
lebih
aktif
dan
interaktif
dalam
proses
pembelajaran
berbasis
teknologi
Web
tanpa
kendala
ruang
dan
waktu
,
serta
dalam
rangka
meringankan
beban
guru
.
Dalam
sistem
ini
,
para
pelajar
berkolaborasi
satu
sama
lainnya
untuk
mengembangkan
pengetahuan
secara
tersebar
sebanyak
mungkin
sesuai
dengan
tingkat
pengetahuan
mereka
.
Para
pelajar
dapat
berkolaborasi
satu
sama
lain
melalui
tanya
-
jawab
untuk
meraih
pengetahuan
lebih
lanjut
.
Dalam
makalah
ini
kami
memaparkan
pembangunan
dari
sistem
prototipe
Active
Web
.
Kata
Kunci
:
Kolaborasi
,
Asinkron
,
Distance
Learning
,
Web
,
Q
&
A
1
.
Introduction
Recently
,
there
are
many
network
technologies
including
Web
,
which
can
be
used
for
implementing
educational
support
systems
,
so
it
becomes
possible
that
learning
can
be
performed
in
distance
without
any
restriction
of
time
and
place
.
In
general
,
the
application
of
distance
learning
systems
is
divided
into
two
types
;
the
one
is
synchronous
and
the
other
is
asynchronous
.
In
this
paper
,
we
are
focusing
on
asynchronous
learning
systems
and
their
collaboration
functions
.
In
many
learning
systems
[
3
]
[
4
]
,
the
teacher
has
to
answer
many
questions
from
students
who
do
not
comprehend
the
contents
of
teaching
-
materials
,
and
there
is
a
tendency
that
teacher
’
s
load
becomes
large
,
because
teacher
directly
has
to
answer
the
questions
.
On
the
other
hand
,
collaboration
among
students
plays
important
role
in
learning
to
increase
knowledge
[
2
]
[
5
]
,
and
also
could
reduce
the
teachers
’
load
.
So
that
in
ActiveWeb
[
1
]
,
we
provide
collaboration
tools
to
motivate
students
to
be
more
active
in
learning
by
teaching
each
other
about
some
materials
related
to
their
comprehension
.
We
propose
asynchronous
collaboration
tools
using
question
-
answer
(
Q
&
A
)
suited
for
students
’
level
of
knowledge
concerning
to
teaching
-
materials
.
In
ActiveWeb
,
if
students
have
questions
regarding
teaching
-
materials
,
they
can
collaborate
with
each
other
settling
the
problem
according
to
their
pace
of
learning
.
In
such
collaboration
learning
,
the
teacher
’
s
role
is
just
to
supervise
the
learning
process
,
and
to
give
advices
indirectly
to
students
in
order
to
help
the
collaboration
process
.
2
.
Learning
Sequence
In
ActiveWeb
,
users
(
students
and
teachers
)
access
the
remote
learning
resources
asynchronously
through
a
web
browser
.
Students
progress
their
learning
by
reading
the
teaching
-
materials
step
by
step
according
to
a
semi
-
ordered
learning
sequence
.
On
the
other
hand
,
teachers
supervise
students
’
learning
progress
,
and
according
to
each
situation
teachers
give
some
hints
or
advices
to
students
using
a
suitable
tool
.
Students
can
follow
teaching
-
materials
according
to
their
paces
,
and
if
they
have
any
questions
,
they
can
get
a
suitable
answer
from
other
students
.
In
principle
,
ActiveWeb
allows
students
collaboratively
perform
learning
together
to
increase
knowledge
as
much
as
possible
.
Students
start
and
finish
the
learning
process
as
shown
in
figure
1
.
Firstly
,
students
have
to
be
registered
in
order
to
participate
in
this
system
.
Only
the
registered
students
can
login
to
the
system
.
After
login
,
the
system
will
load
learning
materials
related
to
the
students
’
status
or
progress
.
During
learning
,
students
not
only
read
or
explore
the
materials
,
but
also
can
collaborate
with
each
other
asynchronously
to
get
more
knowledge
.
Collaboration
will
give
great
influence
on
the
final
result
of
learning
.
The
system
will
ask
students
to
do
tests
at
the
end
of
every
level
of
materials
in
order
to
recognize
the
degree
of
comprehension
.
Fig
.
1
.
Learning
Process
If
students
fail
in
the
test
,
they
are
forced
to
learn
again
the
current
or
previous
material
until
their
comprehension
become
enough
to
learn
the
next
material
.
Students
continue
their
learning
when
they
pass
the
tests
,
and
ActiveWeb
will
guide
them
according
to
the
semi
-
ordered
learning
sequence
so
that
the
students
can
follow
the
materials
according
to
their
pace
and
their
interest
to
materials
.
Students
can
stop
and
logout
from
system
every
time
.
3
.
Collaborative
Q
&
A
During
the
learning
process
,
students
not
only
read
the
materials
,
but
also
are
required
to
participate
in
many
collaboration
groups
talking
about
some
problems
,
because
the
collaboration
plays
important
role
on
asynchronous
learning
systems
.
Collaboration
gives
many
chances
to
find
the
solution
of
problems
,
and
makes
it
impossible
for
students
to
acquire
more
knowledge
that
is
not
contained
in
the
materials
.
In
ActiveWeb
,
students
are
not
allowed
to
ask
a
question
directly
to
teachers
,
and
they
are
required
to
make
collaboration
with
other
students
who
have
the
knowledge
to
answer
the
question
.
Through
Q
&
A
subsystem
,
ActiveWeb
will
assist
students
to
find
qualified
students
who
may
know
the
answer
,
and
also
will
assist
students
who
act
as
respondents
to
answer
one
question
from
the
list
of
unanswered
questions
.
Collaboration
using
Q
&
A
provides
many
opportunities
to
find
the
solution
of
problems
in
learning
,
and
make
students
acquire
more
knowledge
than
just
reading
the
material
.
Collaboration
also
gives
students
motivation
of
learning
through
knowing
other
students
’
activity
,
and
rechecks
each
other
.
3
.
1
.
Flow
of
Questioners
When
students
have
some
questions
regarding
the
material
,
they
need
to
ask
some
questions
.
In
this
system
,
students
are
not
allowed
to
ask
some
questions
directly
to
teachers
,
but
they
are
required
to
make
collaboration
with
other
students
who
have
enough
knowledge
to
give
an
appropriate
answer
for
questions
.
Our
system
assists
students
who
act
as
questioners
to
find
knowledgeable
students
and
to
find
an
expected
answers
,
and
also
assists
students
who
act
as
respondents
to
select
and
to
answer
the
question
from
list
of
unanswered
questions
.
Fig
.
2
shows
a
summary
of
the
flow
of
questioners
.
Questioners
write
a
question
,
and
then
the
system
attempts
to
search
the
similar
questions
from
Q
&
A
database
according
to
this
incoming
question
text
.
The
incoming
question
will
be
accepted
as
a
new
question
in
one
of
the
following
cases
occurs
:
1
.
The
system
is
not
able
to
find
similar
questions
.
2
.
The
questioners
can
not
find
an
intended
questions
from
the
similar
question
searched
by
the
system
.
In
above
two
cases
,
question
will
be
stored
in
to
the
system
as
a
new
question
.
Then
,
the
system
will
notify
appropriate
respondents
who
have
enough
knowledge
to
answer
it
later
.
The
respondents
are
selected
by
the
system
according
to
student
model
.
On
the
other
hand
,
when
the
intended
question
is
found
from
the
list
of
unanswered
questions
,
the
questioner
will
be
registered
into
the
system
as
an
additional
questioner
of
this
question
.
Other
way
,
if
the
system
finds
the
intended
question
and
it
has
answers
,
the
questioner
is
allowed
to
evaluate
these
answers
.
This
result
of
evaluation
will
be
sent
to
the
system
to
update
the
student
model
of
respondent
.
According
to
the
result
of
evaluation
,
the
system
can
be
notified
that
the
intended
question
has
been
answered
completely
,
or
still
needs
more
appropriate
answers
.
Fig
.
2
.
Flow
of
Questioner
In
current
development
,
only
the
first
questioner
evaluates
the
answers
.
The
evaluation
uses
three
ranks
of
value
:
not
enough
,
enough
and
perfect
.
If
there
are
answers
from
different
students
,
the
questioners
evaluate
each
answer
.
The
questioners
will
evaluate
all
these
answers
whether
collectively
meet
the
question
or
not
.
This
result
will
determine
the
completeness
of
a
question
and
its
answers
.
3
.
2
.
Flow
of
Respondents
The
respondents
browse
and
check
the
list
of
unanswered
questions
as
shown
in
Fig
.
3
.
The
respondents
browse
the
questions
,
and
choose
one
of
them
to
answer
.
However
,
according
to
the
difficulty
of
question
,
the
respondents
are
allowed
to
reject
answering
the
question
.
The
system
will
also
assist
the
respondents
to
select
one
question
effectively
according
to
the
question
’
s
attribute
.
We
consider
the
question
’
s
attributes
as
parameter
of
priority
.
There
are
three
parameters
:
-
Waiting
time
of
question
The
elapsed
time
of
question
,
since
it
is
accepted
as
new
question
by
the
system
until
it
is
answered
.
-
Number
of
Questioner
This
parameter
shows
the
number
of
students
who
ask
the
same
question
,
and
the
importance
of
question
.
-
Access
time
This
parameter
shows
the
accessing
the
system
.
The
more
active
students
learn
using
the
system
,
the
higher
value
of
priority
of
question
to
be
selected
firstly
.
Fig
.
3
.
Flow
of
Respondent
Using
combination
of
these
parameters
as
priority
,
the
respondents
can
consider
and
choice
one
question
more
detail
and
answer
it
adequately
.
The
system
supports
selecting
question
using
priority
,
but
the
final
decision
of
selecting
question
depends
on
the
respondents
according
to
the
difficulty
of
questions
.
3
.
3
.
Searching
Similar
Question
Searching
the
similar
questions
plays
important
role
to
prevent
duplication
of
questions
that
have
similar
content
,
and
to
make
students
easier
to
find
the
intended
question
.
Fig
.
4
.
Searching
Question
In
ActiveWeb
,
we
use
the
conventional
searching
method
using
keywords
.
Every
question
will
be
compared
with
questions
stored
in
Q
&
A
database
.
If
a
similar
question
having
answer
exists
in
the
database
,
students
can
find
its
appropriate
answer
automatically
.
So
that
,
in
Q
&
A
system
the
preventing
duplication
of
questions
is
inevitable
.
Fig
.
4
shows
the
mechanism
of
our
searching
method
.
At
the
current
position
of
learning
material
,
students
write
a
question
,
and
then
the
system
will
extract
keywords
from
this
new
question
.
The
noun
within
the
question
will
be
the
candidate
to
be
selected
as
keywords
.
According
to
these
extracted
keywords
and
the
current
position
of
learning
material
,
the
system
will
search
the
similar
question
from
the
Q
&
A
database
according
to
the
position
of
question
in
learning
material
.
In
this
paper
,
in
order
to
find
the
similar
questions
,
we
do
not
use
OR
logic
,
but
we
use
AND
logic
to
compare
extracted
keywords
with
the
keywords
of
questions
from
database
.
If
a
number
of
similar
questions
exist
,
the
system
let
the
questioners
check
and
choose
the
intended
one
.
We
can
use
ChaSen
[
6
]
for
Japanese
and
WordNet
[
7
]
for
English
to
extract
and
select
the
noun
as
keyword
.
4
.
Implementation
We
use
WWW
as
the
platform
of
ActiveWeb
for
implementing
an
asynchronous
learning
system
as
shown
in
figure
5
.
ActiveWeb
consists
of
five
subsystems
as
follows
:
-
Presenter
subsystem
It
is
the
most
fundamental
part
that
arranges
and
shows
the
teaching
-
materials
prepared
by
this
system
to
students
according
to
their
level
of
learning
.
We
use
Web
browsers
as
user
interface
for
students
and
teachers
.
-
Student
Model
subsystem
Basically
we
use
an
overlay
student
model
that
decides
the
knowledge
level
of
students
to
participate
in
collaboration
,
so
that
students
can
join
the
collaboration
according
to
their
pace
of
learning
.
-
Monitor
subsystem
All
students
will
be
analyzed
using
a
learning
history
from
database
.
Teacher
can
supervise
the
learning
performance
of
all
students
and
collaboration
condition
.
If
necessary
,
teacher
can
give
advices
using
suitable
function
.
Fig
.
5
.
Block
Diagram
of
ActiveWeb
-
Test
subsystem
Teaching
-
materials
consist
of
some
modules
that
include
tests
for
checking
the
degree
of
comprehension
of
students
.
The
result
of
tests
will
be
stored
in
a
database
and
will
be
reused
as
learning
data
of
tests
for
the
analyzing
learning
performance
of
students
.
The
result
of
tests
at
each
material
will
determine
how
learning
to
be
continued
.
If
a
student
fails
in
the
test
,
the
system
will
force
the
student
to
learn
again
the
current
material
,
but
if
a
student
passes
the
test
,
the
student
can
proceed
to
the
next
teaching
-
material
.
-
Collaboration
subsystem
A
collaboration
function
is
used
in
order
to
acquire
more
satisfactory
knowledge
in
addition
to
the
knowledge
acquired
by
reading
teaching
-
materials
.
The
main
collaboration
tools
provided
by
the
system
are
discussion
and
question
&
answer
(
Q
&
A
)
tools
.
Collaboration
activity
will
give
a
big
affection
on
result
of
learning
,
so
the
students
’
participation
in
it
is
really
required
to
acquire
more
knowledge
.
5
.
Conclusion
In
this
paper
we
proposed
the
learning
support
system
based
on
Web
called
ActiveWeb
that
has
the
characteristics
of
supporting
students
to
do
learning
in
collaboration
with
others
in
order
to
solve
many
problems
during
the
learning
.
There
are
two
main
collaboration
tools
prepared
by
ActiveWeb
;
discussion
and
Q
&
A
.
In
this
system
teachers
do
not
participate
in
collaboration
directly
.
Teachers
mainly
supervise
the
situation
of
collaboration
,
and
if
necessary
,
teachers
can
give
some
hints
for
directing
learning
process
.
Students
can
construct
knowledge
not
only
by
reading
the
teaching
-
materials
but
also
by
collaborating
each
other
,
so
that
the
final
outcome
of
learning
would
be
better
.
Finally
,
during
we
have
developed
ActiveWeb
as
tool
of
distance
learning
,
but
we
still
have
to
make
it
better
for
supporting
collaborative
learning
on
Web
.
We
also
need
to
do
experiment
of
this
system
in
large
scale
in
order
to
evaluate
the
performance
and
the
effectiveness
of
it
.
References
[
1
]
Ana
Hadiana
,
Kenji
Kaijiri
,
“
The
Construction
of
Asynchronous
Q
&
A
Support
System
based
on
Collaboration
��
?
,
Information
Technology
Letters
Forum
on
Information
Technology
,
2002
,
pp
.
249
-
250
.
[
2
]
Fumiaki
Obayashi
,
et
al
,
“
Construction
and
Evaluation
of
a
CAI
System
Based
on
Learning
by
Teaching
to
Virtual
Student
��
?
,
Information
Processing
Seminar
Journal
,
Vol
.
41
No
.
12
,
2000
,
pp
.
3386
-
3393
.
[
3
]
Kenji
Matsuura
et
al
,
“
Agent
-
based
Asynchronous
Virtual
Classroom
��
?
,
Advanced
Research
in
Computers
and
Communications
in
Education
,
IOS
Press
,
1999
,
pp
.
133
-
140
[
4
]
Osami
Kagawa
et
al
,
“
Selecting
Essential
Questions
Using
Question
Support
Facilities
in
a
Distance
Education
System
��
?
,
IEICE
Journal
,
Vol
.
J80
-
D
-
II
,
1997
,
pp
.
1878
-
1886
[
5
]
Yutaka
Matsusita
,
Collaboration
and
Communication
,
Kyoritsu
Publisher
,
1995
,
pp
.
10
-
15
.
[
6
]
Computational
Linguistics
Laboratory
,
Nara
Institute
of
Science
and
Technology
University
,
“
ChaSen
��
?
,
http
:
//
chasen
.
aist
-
nara
.
ac
.
jp
/
index
.
html
.
[
7
]
Cognitive
Science
Laboratory
,
Princeton
University
,
“
WordNet
��
?
,
http
:
//
www
.
cogsci
.
princeton
.
edu
/
~
wn
/
.
«
Perkembangan
Teknologi
Informasi
di
Indonesia
Masyarakat
Java
Dikumpulkan
di
Bandung
»
Pusat
Penelitian
Informatika
is
powered
by
WordPress
and
delivered
to
you
in
0
.
179
seconds
.
Students
determine
their
studies
-
Article
from
The
Jakarta
Post
,
December
13th
2005
Students
determine
their
studies
Bambang
Nurbianto
,
The
Jakarta
Post
,
Jakarta
Education
should
be
fun
.
It
is
much
better
if
it
supports
the
career
one
interested
in
.
But
Tora
Sudiro
,
32
,
named
best
local
actor
at
the
Panasonic
Awards
show
earlier
this
month
,
never
got
the
approval
from
his
parents
to
get
into
art
school
,
although
he
had
shown
his
interests
in
music
and
acting
.
His
father
told
him
to
take
financial
insurance
as
his
major
.
"
Becoming
an
artist
is
good
,
but
it
is
better
if
you
take
insurance
as
your
major
because
it
may
lead
you
to
a
more
prospective
career
,
"
the
father
of
two
recalled
his
father
'
s
words
.
Tora
obeyed
his
father
.
He
graduated
and
worked
in
an
insurance
company
.
He
quit
after
three
months
.
Tora
shared
his
bad
experience
about
education
at
a
seminar
on
study
and
careers
organized
by
the
Swiss
German
University
in
Bumi
Serpong
Damai
,
Tangerang
,
on
Saturday
,
attended
by
teachers
,
students
and
their
parents
from
Jakarta
and
Tangerang
.
Education
expert
Arief
Rachman
said
Tora
was
an
example
of
a
victim
of
parents
'
choices
,
who
forced
their
wishes
on
their
children
to
study
in
certain
subjects
without
considering
the
talents
and
interests
of
their
children
.
"
Children
will
lose
their
great
potential
if
parents
force
them
to
study
in
certain
subjects
,
which
they
do
not
like
.
In
the
more
extreme
situation
,
it
may
cause
frustration
.
"
He
said
that
to
help
children
to
choose
their
education
,
there
are
several
approaches
,
including
psychological
tests
to
identify
the
children
'
s
talents
and
interests
.
According
to
Arief
,
interests
of
the
children
should
become
the
first
consideration
in
deciding
the
subject
of
education
,
while
talent
should
be
second
.
"
A
child
may
be
good
in
math
,
but
he
puts
high
interest
on
sociology
.
In
that
case
,
it
is
better
for
such
children
to
take
sociology
as
their
major
.
They
will
have
great
motivation
there
,
"
said
Arief
,
who
is
also
a
lecturer
at
Jakarta
University
(
UNJ
)
.
According
to
Arief
,
pressing
children
to
take
certain
subjects
,
which
children
may
in
fact
not
like
,
may
spark
negative
impacts
like
frustration
and
underachievement
due
to
lack
of
motivation
.
In
the
case
of
Tora
,
who
played
the
main
role
in
several
art
and
commercial
movies
as
well
as
performing
in
the
popular
Extravaganza
comedy
show
,
Arief
said
that
he
was
lucky
being
able
to
exploit
his
own
talent
without
having
to
take
a
formal
education
on
acting
.
"
I
believe
that
education
is
the
most
important
factor
for
the
future
of
our
children
.
We
cannot
expect
that
all
people
will
have
what
Tora
has
,
who
is
successful
in
his
profession
without
a
formal
education
in
it
,
"
said
Arief
.
But
to
find
out
what
he
had
missed
,
Arief
encouraged
Tora
to
get
further
education
on
acting
.
"
You
will
be
more
successful
...
Most
of
the
Academy
Award
winners
have
strong
educational
backgrounds
in
acting
,
"
he
claimed
.
[
The
Jakarta
Post
Student
Activities
Students
in
Petra
are
required
not
only
to
accomplish
themselves
academicly
,
but
also
in
organisational
activities
.
As
those
are
base
to
prepare
them
to
live
with
the
community
.
This
is
why
we
implemented
the
minimum
credit
in
student
activities
as
one
of
the
pre
-
condition
on
graduation
day
.
There
are
various
activities
you
can
join
.
There
are
no
obligatory
activities
,
except
the
minimum
credit
points
to
be
gained
for
your
graduation
pre
-
condition
.
Some
of
them
are
joining
clubs
or
student
activities
unit
.
Or
participate
in
your
department
/
faculty
/
university
student
body
.
Or
,
if
you
are
lucky
,
occasional
events
needs
some
members
of
the
commitee
from
students
.
The
points
are
given
based
on
the
scope
of
the
events
,
either
it
is
a
department
/
faculty
/
university
,
regional
,
national
,
international
.
Also
,
the
level
of
job
you
do
,
either
as
chairman
,
secretary
,
treasurer
,
et
cetera
.
Each
activities
has
its
own
uniqueness
.
You
can
also
gain
your
points
by
participating
in
seminars
,
workshops
,
training
,
a
representative
athletes
for
the
university
,
a
delegate
for
a
prestigious
events
,
but
nothing
could
beat
the
feeling
of
being
in
a
commitee
with
all
the
shared
responsibilities
,
cooperation
,
friendship
,
achievement
,
failure
,
and
everything
you
could
reach
not
as
a
passive
participant
,
but
an
active
one
.
Student
Activities
Units
Student
Activities
Units
or
UKMs
,
used
to
be
an
obligatory
,
each
are
maintained
by
a
group
of
student
body
,
under
the
supervision
of
the
University
Student
Council
or
BEM
.
There
are
various
UKM
in
PCU
,
from
brain
(
scientist
,
friends
of
the
library
,
jurnalism
,
etc
.
)
to
brawn
(
chess
,
swimming
,
football
,
badminton
,
etc
.
)
.
Students
if
enrolled
in
one
of
the
UKM
,
are
supposed
to
be
attend
weekly
or
biweekly
scheduled
meetings
to
do
most
of
what
they
consider
a
hobby
.
UKM
activities
only
last
for
a
year
.
Clubs
or
other
Organized
Activities
We
also
has
many
clubs
and
organized
activities
that
mostly
are
the
extension
of
UKMs
.
Those
who
had
passed
UKM
(
only
a
year
)
,
usually
joined
their
clubs
where
other
seniors
are
also
involved
.
Among
these
are
The
Friends
of
the
Library
club
,
English
Debating
Club
,
and
Petra
Choir
.
Student
Bodies
To
voice
out
what
your
peers
might
have
in
mind
,
you
can
be
their
representatives
,
either
it
is
in
your
department
,
faculty
,
or
even
university
level
.
The
higher
the
level
,
the
higher
the
voice
you
represent
.
Everything
came
with
responsibilities
,
to
make
a
better
campus
for
all
of
the
students
.
Special
Events
Occassionally
,
you
will
find
many
seminars
,
workshops
,
and
training
held
in
PCU
.
If
the
events
doesn
'
t
in
a
way
connected
to
a
specific
UKM
or
department
,
they
usually
need
various
students
to
be
member
of
the
committe
.
This
is
your
first
step
of
organisational
education
.
Join
in
and
see
for
yourself
.
During
a
training
course
on
gender
perspective
legal
defense
(
for
law
students
)
organized
by
LBH
APIK
some
times
ago
,
one
of
the
subjects
was
about
the
Convention
on
the
Elimination
of
All
Kinds
of
Discrimination
Against
Women
(
hereinafter
called
the
Women
Convention
)
.
It
was
found
out
that
the
participants
responses
was
very
enthusiastic
and
was
completely
beyond
expectation
.
In
the
discussion
forum
a
critical
question
was
posed
by
one
of
the
participants
:
Why
is
such
a
good
convention
unknown
to
us
,
whereas
we
are
students
of
Law
Faculty
who
should
have
known
the
existence
of
such
a
convention
?
Why
is
this
convention
not
included
as
a
compulsory
subject
to
be
taught
in
our
faculty
?
Once
a
lawyer
who
defended
a
case
of
discrimination
against
a
woman
complained
.
In
her
defense
before
the
court
,
she
offered
a
defense
based
on
one
of
the
articles
of
the
Convention
.
The
respond
of
the
judge
was
very
surprising
,
indeed
.
The
judge
even
asked
her
:
what
kind
of
legal
basis
are
you
applying
?
Both
the
student
and
the
judge
referred
to
above
have
not
known
about
the
existence
of
the
Convention
on
the
Elimination
of
All
Forms
of
Discrimination
Against
Women
,
which
was
ratified
by
Act
no
.
7
year
1984
as
a
provision
underlying
the
elimination
of
discrimination
against
women
in
Indonesia
.
Are
many
parties
,
indeed
,
ignorant
of
the
Convention
on
the
Elimination
of
All
Forms
of
Discrimination
Against
Women
?
Considering
above
facts
,
as
well
as
the
experience
of
women
activists
in
defending
discrimination
cases
,
it
is
correct
to
presume
that
the
Women
Convention
is
not
known
to
the
general
public
,
law
enforcing
officers
,
jurists
and
,
moreover
,
ordinary
people
.
How
apprehensive
the
situation
is
.
How
can
we
implement
the
provisions
contained
in
the
Convention
,
if
its
existence
is
not
known
?
Whereas
the
Women
Convention
was
ratified
in
July
1984
,
which
means
that
it
was
adopted
by
Indonesia
for
fourteen
long
years
.
What
are
the
impediments
of
its
implementation
?
The
Convention
on
the
Elimination
of
All
Forms
of
Discrimination
Against
Women
was
ratified
by
our
country
,
to
be
precise
on
24
July
1997
,
by
Act
no
.
7
year
1984
.
The
ratification
itself
means
:
Firstly
,
Indonesia
is
bound
by
an
international
agreement
and
has
a
legal
obligation
to
take
measures
in
the
efforts
to
eliminate
all
forms
of
discrimination
against
women
.
Secondly
,
the
Indonesian
government
has
a
considerable
concern
and
commitment
towards
women
problems
,
which
up
to
now
has
not
been
recognized
or
has
been
difficult
to
recognize
or
has
not
been
considered
as
a
problem
by
the
general
public
.
The
commitment
of
the
Indonesian
government
to
an
international
agreement
will
be
put
to
a
test
in
January
1998
,
by
the
convocation
of
a
session
where
reports
on
the
implementation
of
Women
Convention
will
be
reviewed
by
an
international
forum
.
The
Committee
on
the
Elimination
of
Discrimination
Against
Women
(
hereinafter
the
Committee
)
,
a
UN
body
in
charge
with
monitoring
the
implementation
of
the
UN
Convention
on
the
Elimination
of
All
Forms
of
Discrimination
against
Women
will
open
its
eighteenth
session
in
New
York
in
January
1998
.
In
this
session
the
Committee
will
review
the
report
submitted
by
the
Indonesian
government
as
well
as
by
other
state
participants
on
the
implementation
of
the
Women
Convention
.
The
report
of
the
Indonesian
government
itself
was
sent
to
the
Committee
in
January
1997
,
on
the
occasion
of
the
Committee
s
sixteenth
session
.
According
to
plan
,
the
government
will
make
some
improvements
in
the
initial
report
,
and
the
final
report
will
be
reviewed
by
the
Committee
.
The
report
is
a
periodic
report
which
should
be
submitted
every
four
years
(
article
18
of
the
Convention
)
as
a
progress
report
on
the
implementation
of
the
Convention
during
1985
-
1995
period
.
However
,
since
1985
,
namely
one
year
after
the
ratification
up
to
now
,
the
Indonesian
government
sent
only
one
initial
report
.
The
report
sent
by
the
Indonesian
government
has
not
presented
the
information
on
the
real
problems
faced
by
women
.
Consequently
,
the
existing
information
did
not
adequately
picture
the
real
situation
.
This
was
exactly
the
reason
why
a
group
of
women
associated
in
the
Women
Group
for
the
Monitoring
of
the
Implementation
of
the
Convention
(
KP3K
)
prepared
an
alternative
report
which
was
planned
to
be
submitted
to
the
participants
of
the
UN
forum
.
From
the
report
,
we
also
get
a
picture
on
the
real
concern
and
commitment
of
the
Indonesian
government
in
dealing
with
women
problems
in
Indonesia
.
Indeed
,
we
can
not
just
claim
that
the
inadequacy
reflects
the
government
s
lack
of
seriousness
to
deal
with
the
problem
.
However
,
it
can
constitute
one
of
the
criteria
explicitly
and
officially
issued
by
the
government
.
The
problem
is
that
after
almost
14
years
of
the
ratification
of
the
Women
Convention
,
women
problems
remain
unsettled
.
In
the
field
of
education
,
for
example
,
a
wide
gap
continues
to
exist
between
the
participation
of
women
and
that
of
men
.
Women
who
do
not
/
have
not
yet
enjoyed
school
education
reached
41
.
31
%
,
compared
with
11
.
2
%
for
men
(
Central
Bureau
of
Statistics
,
Profile
of
Women
s
Status
and
Role
in
Indonesia
:
1995
)
.
Meanwhile
the
percentage
of
women
who
have
followed
/
is
following
university
education
is
only
0
.
54
%
,
and
men
1
.
9
%
.
In
the
field
of
labor
force
,
there
was
an
increase
in
the
growth
rate
of
women
working
in
public
sector
,
however
they
are
still
concentrated
in
low
-
wage
employment
sector
(
labor
intensive
industrial
sector
)
.
Up
to
now
legal
protection
for
women
workers
in
informal
sector
,
such
as
domestic
helpers
,
inside
as
well
as
outside
the
country
,
and
sex
workers
,
has
not
been
covered
.
In
the
political
field
,
the
number
of
women
involved
in
decision
making
is
still
low
,
and
even
shows
a
declining
tendency
from
year
to
year
.
From
10
,
4
%
in
1987
,
it
decreased
to
10
.
11
%
in
the
following
period
.
In
the
field
of
health
,
maternal
mortality
continue
to
appear
very
high
.
Besides
,
cases
of
violence
against
women
occupy
a
considerably
high
rating
in
news
coverage
,
especially
cases
of
torture
against
wife
.
In
the
field
of
policy
,
the
government
continues
to
apply
Act
no
.
1
on
Marriage
as
a
legal
basis
of
family
affairs
in
Indonesia
.
Whereas
it
is
clear
that
this
Act
is
highly
discriminatory
against
women
.
Article
31
on
polygamy
and
article
34
on
role
standardization
of
women
in
the
Marriage
Act
show
the
subordination
and
stereotyping
of
women
.
Besides
,
in
October
1997
Act
no
.
25
year
1997
on
Labor
Force
was
enforced
,
which
explicitly
legitimized
the
role
standardization
of
women
.
From
different
realities
referred
to
above
,
ambivalence
is
still
found
in
the
policy
on
women
and
there
are
also
contradictions
between
one
policy
and
another
.
Actually
the
field
of
policy
may
become
an
important
starting
point
for
the
implementation
of
the
Women
Convention
.
It
can
be
understood
that
the
Indonesian
government
wants
to
create
an
impression
of
good
pictures
so
as
not
to
smear
the
good
name
of
this
nation
,
especially
that
of
the
state
executives
.
But
if
we
return
the
problem
to
its
reality
,
however
good
the
Convention
is
and
however
good
the
Indonesia
Guidelines
of
State
Policy
are
,
if
they
are
not
followed
by
a
consistent
implementation
according
to
the
spirit
of
the
Convention
,
the
real
problem
would
not
change
,
and
all
those
nice
talks
will
remain
to
be
lips
service
only
.
In
reality
,
great
many
people
are
pessimistic
on
this
problem
.
Once
a
woman
activist
said
,
there
is
no
need
for
us
to
talk
about
the
Women
Convention
in
Indonesia
,
because
in
this
country
the
thing
knows
as
Law
is
artificial
only
.
Such
a
pessimism
is
not
felt
by
a
handful
of
people
only
,
but
quite
a
number
of
people
share
the
same
feeling
,
because
the
constraint
lies
in
our
legal
system
which
does
not
side
with
the
interests
of
the
community
(
especially
women
)
.
Whatever
the
condition
is
,
I
remain
to
be
of
the
opinion
that
as
long
as
the
government
is
doing
something
in
this
direction
,
the
socialization
of
the
Women
Convention
continues
to
be
very
important
,
among
law
enforcing
officers
as
well
as
among
the
community
,
as
a
part
of
the
legal
system
.
There
are
several
analyses
why
I
came
to
such
a
conclusion
.
Firstly
,
by
an
intensive
socialization
there
would
emerge
social
awareness
which
could
be
predicted
to
arouse
a
desire
for
a
change
.
Meanwhile
the
government
is
reluctant
to
make
painstaking
efforts
to
revise
the
legislation
as
well
as
the
policy
of
implementation
.
It
involves
financial
problem
and
legal
political
situation
and
is
considered
to
be
not
conducive
with
the
efforts
for
such
a
change
.
For
example
,
the
fact
that
the
Legislative
Body
has
not
been
functioning
actively
in
the
production
of
laws
,
is
a
part
of
the
legal
political
situation
in
Indonesia
.
Secondly
,
the
government
itself
has
not
convinced
itself
to
get
out
of
the
patriarchal
ideology
that
is
still
strongly
rooted
within
the
community
.
Thirdly
,
the
government
intentionally
does
not
want
to
change
women
situation
,
because
the
prevailing
situation
is
favorable
to
it
.
Subsequently
this
analysis
was
supported
by
that
of
Julia
Surya
I
.
Kusuma
concerning
state
ibuism
;
where
the
government
,
especially
the
new
order
government
adopted
the
gender
distinction
,
and
this
distinction
was
even
perpetually
reproduced
to
support
the
ideology
of
development
,
economic
growth
and
state
stability
.
Women
were
politically
domesticated
by
Dharma
Wanita
and
PKK
programs
in
order
to
do
away
with
the
anxiety
of
the
former
government
,
by
the
existence
of
a
strong
women
organization
(
such
as
Gerwani
)
that
occupied
a
strategic
position
and
it
would
be
dangerous
in
the
new
order
situation
.
Women
were
also
exploited
to
attract
foreign
investors
by
means
of
commercials
on
cheap
,
skillful
and
obedient
labor
force
.
In
short
,
this
analysis
wants
to
say
that
intensive
socialization
on
women
s
rights
as
included
in
the
Women
Convention
will
change
the
face
and
ideology
which
have
been
propagated
by
the
government
.
This
analysis
also
predicts
that
actually
the
government
has
a
political
trauma
and
a
big
economic
interest
on
the
role
standardization
of
woman
gender
.
Indeed
,
above
analyses
should
remain
to
be
tested
with
regard
to
their
truth
.
At
least
I
hope
,
if
the
government
disagree
with
those
analyses
,
it
should
prove
that
it
takes
great
care
of
women
s
problems
.
In
that
way
,
the
government
should
take
clear
measures
and
firm
stand
to
change
the
patriarchal
system
in
Indonesia
.
The
steps
which
should
be
undertaken
are
,
firstly
by
improving
the
legal
system
-
through
the
improvement
of
legal
substance
-
by
means
of
revising
policies
that
do
not
side
with
women
or
which
place
women
in
discriminatory
positions
and
simultaneously
introducing
legislation
that
supports
the
elimination
of
discrimination
.
Then
improvement
through
legal
structure
follows
by
the
provision
of
education
,
awareness
on
women
s
reality
,
and
the
implementation
of
women
convention
.
Whereas
by
means
of
legal
culture
,
the
government
should
be
ready
to
socialize
and
to
inseminate
wide
and
transparent
information
to
wider
sections
of
the
society
,
including
academicians
,
press
,
NGOs
,
or
strategic
social
groups
striving
for
transformation
.
Secondly
,
political
improvement
.
Politics
dedicated
to
economic
interests
will
continue
to
be
disadvantageous
to
women
.
The
recent
adoption
of
the
Act
on
Labor
Force
by
the
House
of
Representatives
constitutes
an
example
that
the
transformation
of
a
legal
system
is
also
influenced
by
bigger
political
interests
.
Unclear
political
commitment
also
makes
what
has
been
intended
to
be
a
change
becomes
unclear
.
As
it
was
mentioned
above
,
the
impeded
(
or
was
it
intentionally
impeded
?
)
socialization
of
the
Women
Convention
and
the
report
on
its
implementation
which
has
not
touched
upon
the
reality
,
was
a
reflection
of
unclear
commitment
.
Such
a
reflection
may
also
be
seen
in
the
government
attitude
to
other
international
conventions
,
other
than
the
Women
Convention
.
Because
up
to
now
our
country
has
ratified
only
one
international
convention
,
namely
the
Women
Convention
.
However
,
the
mere
ratification
of
this
Convention
is
not
enough
.
Indonesia
should
also
ratify
all
international
conventions
relevant
to
the
implementation
of
the
Women
Convention
,
especially
the
UN
Convention
on
Civil
and
Political
Rights
,
the
Convention
on
Social
,
Economic
and
Cultural
Rights
,
the
Convention
Against
Torture
and
Degrading
Treatment
and
Punishment
,
and
other
UN
conventions
on
human
rights
.
Otherwise
once
again
Indonesia
s
commitments
serve
only
as
lips
service
,
which
means
once
again
reaffirming
the
government
s
unclear
commitments
.
In
addition
to
those
stipulations
in
the
Conventions
on
the
Elimination
of
All
Forms
of
Discrimination
Against
Women
(
CEDAW
)
,
it
is
also
necessary
to
take
into
account
the
general
recommendation
of
the
Committee
for
the
Elimination
of
All
Forms
of
Discrimination
Against
Women
.
This
recommendation
covers
points
that
received
special
attention
of
the
Committee
,
including
matters
to
be
considered
when
presenting
reports
by
state
parties
.
WALHI
Manifesto
:
The
metamorphosis
of
the
Indonesian
environmental
movement
An
historical
milestone
of
the
environmental
movement
was
created
two
decades
ago
through
campaigns
to
increase
the
awareness
of
the
public
and
the
policy
advocacy
to
highlight
the
importance
of
environmental
issues
within
the
context
of
the
nation
’
s
development
.
Now
,
environmental
activists
realize
that
the
movement
cannot
rely
merely
on
campaigns
and
policy
advocacy
but
it
should
seek
other
ways
to
garner
wider
public
support
.
WALHI
’
s
actions
have
so
far
been
based
on
the
willingness
to
fight
for
the
interests
of
the
people
in
every
corner
of
the
archipelago
who
have
to
face
threats
to
their
sustainability
.
WALHI
also
realizes
that
environmental
issue
has
not
yet
become
the
public
priority
.
WALHI
itself
is
confined
to
a
network
structure
which
is
cumbersome
and
has
a
weak
ideological
ties
to
each
other
.
The
situation
leads
to
different
interpretations
ofn
Walhi
’
s
works
in
fighting
for
the
sustainability
of
the
environment
and
the
people
.
At
the
same
time
,
the
weak
ideological
tie
renders
WALHI
feeble
,
miring
in
its
own
problems
.
Hence
,
WALHI
sees
reform
on
environmental
movement
strategy
is
urgent
amidst
the
problem
of
global
capitalism
which
aggressively
exploits
the
archipelago
’
s
natural
and
human
resources
and
debilitates
the
people
.
The
reformed
movement
should
be
able
to
remove
the
limitations
,
turn
around
the
cumbersome
structure
into
athe
more
efficient
one
while
remaining
a
to
be
a
friendly
and
welcoming
forum
for
all
the
components
of
environmental
and
social
movements
.
The
environmental
activists
’
future
duty
is
to
build
a
strong
,
large
and
wide
social
movement
through
reviving
the
culture
of
movement
,
developing
class
consciousness
,
openning
information
access
,
building
a
balanced
political
power
,
strengthening
grass
root
organizations
to
become
independent
and
able
to
design
their
own
agenda
.
Neo
-
liberalism
:
The
root
of
Environmental
Plight
The
basic
idea
of
the
neo
-
liberal
system
is
that
a
situation
where
the
market
has
to
be
involved
in
deliberating
crucial
decisions
on
social
and
political
issues
.
The
system
urges
each
government
to
relinquish
its
functions
regarding
economic
matters
.
In
other
words
,
the
system
gives
ample
space
to
the
private
enterprises
for
them
to
develop
their
business
freely
,
thus
limiting
workers
the
unions
’
activities
and
dismissing
grass
roots
’
interests
.
The
Neo
-
liberal
paradigm
is
a
series
of
economic
policies
which
make
the
rich
wealthier
and
the
poor
destitute
.
The
core
of
the
idea
is
to
strengthen
the
role
of
the
market
by
freeing
private
companies
from
the
state
,
regardless
of
the
social
expenses
like
the
slashing
of
funds
for
services
such
as
like
those
of
education
,
public
health
,
and
access
to
clean
water
.
It
removes
government
roles
and
responsibilities
,
changes
all
the
regulations
that
are
deemed
to
hampering
private
companies
’
profits
like
labor
laws
and
environmental
laws
,
and
it
privatizes
state
’
s
enterprises
.
Citing
efficiency
as
the
reason
,
privatization
is
actually
a
giving
submission
of
state
’
s
wealth
to
a
handful
of
companiespeople
,
which
in
return
leads
to
destitution
of
the
people
who
have
to
pay
more
for
the
supposedly
public
services
.
People
who
fail
to
pay
are
being
labelled
lazy
people
.
Obviously
,
privatization
of
public
resources
has
not
removed
the
state
’
s
duty
to
protect
people
’
s
rights
and
welfare
.
The
State
,
however
,
has
become
a
hostage
to
free
trade
and
global
capitalism
;
a
situation
that
leads
to
deprivation
of
the
rights
of
marginalized
people
like
peasants
,
urban
poor
,
rural
poor
,
women
and
children
.
It
positions
market
mechanism
and
competition
to
define
the
future
of
the
civilization
.
So
far
,
the
system
has
become
the
one
and
only
system
the
world
should
have
faith
in
,
like
a
divine
revelation
.
This
paradigm
is
built
upon
three
principles
:
free
trade
and
services
,
free
capital
,
and
good
investment
climate
.
Essentially
,
neo
-
liberalism
is
designed
for
winners
not
voters
.
It
has
become
the
pillar
of
economic
globalisation
,
which
has
been
proven
to
fail
to
maintain
people
’
s
welfare
but
giving
prosperity
to
a
handful
of
people
.
The
200
richest
people
in
the
world
over
possess
US
$
1
trillion
wealth
,
which
equals
theo
a
combined
wealth
of
2
.
5
billion
of
people
in
the
Third
World
.
The
richest
’
s
wealth
of
the
richest
is
never
used
to
support
environment
programs
;
,
instead
,
through
IMF
and
World
Bank
,
it
is
used
to
spread
environmental
damages
.
Global
capitalism
has
become
athe
source
of
damages
on
people
’
s
livelihoods
.
It
is
largely
due
to
industrial
activities
that
exploit
the
environment
,
pollute
the
air
and
the
water
,
spur
the
global
warming
,
increase
energy
consumption
that
needs
infrastructure
development
for
the
distribution
.
To
maintain
free
trade
,
industrialists
insisted
on
a
consistent
environmental
standard
for
industry
.
The
World
Trade
Organization
(
WTO
)
responded
by
drawing
up
a
minimum
standard
for
protecting
environment
agreed
by
businesspeople
.
The
minimum
standard
means
a
company
works
in
a
country
has
only
to
comply
with
the
lowest
standard
possible
.
The
situation
indicates
the
seriousness
of
the
current
environmental
problem
.
Environmental
problems
areis
no
longer
due
to
the
low
environmental
awareness
of
the
public
and
the
government
’
s
weak
policies
,
but
more
due
to
the
exploits
of
the
trans
-
national
corporations
which
,
through
the
governments
,
deliberately
neglect
environmental
problems
and
refuse
to
deal
with
the
arising
problems
like
global
warming
and
genetic
mutation
.
Clearly
,
the
system
only
seeks
fast
profit
while
neglecting
the
environment
preservation
.
To
contend
this
system
,
anti
-
capitalism
movements
around
the
world
have
promoted
the
slogan
:
“
Earth
is
not
a
Commodity
”
.
Against
the
backdrop
,
WALHI
announces
a
new
movement
,
which
focuses
not
on
nature
conservation
but
on
toppling
the
system
which
allows
the
environmental
damages
to
continue
happening
.
Nowadays
,
environmental
issues
areis
no
longer
a
peripheral
issue
,
but
haves
increasingly
become
the
focus
amidst
the
endeavors
to
build
a
sustainable
nation
.
In
regard
tos
of
the
negative
impacts
on
the
environment
caused
by
capitalism
,
opposition
to
capitalism
has
become
the
new
breath
of
environment
and
social
movements
.
Irreparable
Crises
Wealth
accumulation
and
exploitation
of
the
people
have
led
to
irreparable
crises
,
which
thwarts
the
sustainability
of
people
’
s
livelihoods
.
The
crises
range
from
political
,
economic
,
social
,
cultural
to
ecological
crises
.
Political
crisis
happens
when
the
legislators
no
longer
possess
the
power
to
fulfilactual
the
process
of
lawmaking
.
Instead
,
many
decisions
are
made
in
the
offices
of
top
officials
of
giant
corporations
.
Expecting
changes
by
casting
your
vote
for
your
preferred
legislators
is
no
longer
enough
because
money
politicks
has
practically
killed
democracy
.
Economic
crisis
is
increasingly
irreparable
due
to
the
money
distribution
which
is
limited
to
only
a
handful
of
people
and
companies
.
Tycoons
pressure
the
political
elites
to
allow
them
ease
in
doing
business
,
such
as
tax
exemption
.
If
the
government
refuses
,
the
businesspeople
often
threaten
to
relocate
the
investment
to
another
country
.
On
top
of
that
,
government
,
with
the
support
of
giant
corporations
,
thwarts
the
communities
’
independent
economic
system
blooming
in
the
corners
of
the
archipelago
.
Communal
economic
systems
areis
weakened
by
the
penetration
of
modern
banking
system
and
monetary
systems
.
Social
and
cultural
crises
prevail
due
to
development
projects
and
capital
expansion
,
which
incapacitate
people
’
s
social
and
cultural
foundations
throughout
the
archipelago
.
Social
conflicts
between
the
people
and
the
state
,
the
people
and
the
corporations
,
also
between
the
people
and
the
people
themselves
have
increasingly
mushroomed
and
have
grown
more
complex
,
and
thus
are
difficult
to
tackle
.
The
collapse
of
the
people
’
s
cultural
system
has
incapacitated
the
people
’
s
ability
to
provide
sustainable
system
for
the
future
generations
.
Meanwhile
,
the
ecological
crisis
occurs
because
the
state
,
the
investors
and
science
have
relegated
the
nature
to
a
mere
ly
a
commodity
that
can
be
engineered
to
gain
economic
benefit
.
Monoculturization
in
agriculture
and
forestry
sectors
have
diminished
the
natural
functions
of
ecological
habitat
.
Hybrid
technology
and
modifications
to
nature
have
interrupted
the
system
like
once
happened
during
the
Green
Revolution
.
The
privatization
of
naturale
resources
,
whether
for
commercial
or
for
conservation
purposes
,
has
taken
away
the
control
and
the
access
from
the
people
living
around
the
resources
.
The
results
are
natural
disasters
like
forest
fires
,
floods
,
pollution
,
and
water
crisis
.
WALHI
and
its
struggles
Cognizant
of
the
unjust
treatments
from
the
state
and
the
capital
to
the
people
throughout
the
archipelago
,
WALHI
has
decided
to
expand
the
environment
movement
to
a
social
movement
in
a
bid
to
realize
a
new
system
which
is
democratic
and
sustainable
while
assuring
the
people
’
s
rights
overto
environment
management
.
WALHI
positions
itself
as
the
vanguard
in
driving
the
social
movement
which
aims
to
uphold
people
’
s
sovereignty
over
the
environment
while
resisting
unjust
treatments
promoted
by
international
financial
institutions
,
international
development
institutions
and
transnational
corporations
.
To
resist
all
oppressive
forms
against
poor
people
and
their
livelihoods
,
WALHI
stays
true
to
its
principles
:
Democracy
:
People
have
to
be
allowed
participation
in
are
deliberating
decisions
that
affect
them
.
Equal
opportunity
for
each
generation
:
Every
generation
,
present
or
future
,
has
equal
rights
to
a
healthy
and
good
environment
.
Equal
rights
:
Every
individual
has
the
equal
rights
to
a
healthygood
environment
regardless
of
their
gender
,
religion
,
and
beliefs
or
,
and
social
status
.
Respect
to
living
creatures
:
Every
living
creature
,
human
or
non
-
human
should
be
respected
.
Equal
rights
for
indigenous
peoples
:
Indigenous
peoples
throughout
the
archipelago
haves
the
right
to
determine
their
own
life
,
to
grow
accordingly
to
their
own
culture
.
Social
solidarity
:
Every
individual
has
equal
civil
,
political
,
economic
,
social
,
and
cultural
rights
.
Anti
-
violence
:
State
violence
is
a
crime
.
Openness
:
People
have
the
right
to
access
information
on
policies
or
programs
concerning
their
life
.
Autonomy
:
Everyone
should
promote
political
and
economic
autonomy
of
the
people
.
Professionalism
:
Everyone
should
work
professionally
,
in
full
dedication
,
effectively
,
systematically
while
keeping
the
spirit
of
collectivism
alive
.
In
realizing
the
principles
,
WALHI
asserts
its
position
to
establish
:
People
’
s
democratic
Government
The
current
legislative
and
electoral
systems
have
failed
to
represent
people
’
s
interests
.
The
legislators
have
been
corrupted
by
with
large
corporations
’
agenda
.
Walhi
proposes
a
system
in
which
the
grass
root
people
have
a
dominant
say
in
decision
making
.
Just
society
Just
society
is
a
social
system
which
bases
itself
on
communal
values
that
treat
people
equally
regardless
the
gender
,
race
,
and
religion
.
Communal
values
uphold
human
dignity
as
social
creatures
,
not
capitalistm
machines
.
Sustainable
life
Massive
exploitation
of
nature
has
thwarted
the
sustainability
of
the
people
.
Sustainable
life
is
guaranteed
by
a
production
system
that
works
for
the
people
not
for
a
handful
of
greedy
individuals
.
Corporations
should
benefit
not
only
the
few
owners
,
but
the
workers
.
Market
should
no
longer
dictate
productions
;
the
people
should
be
the
one
who
design
and
determine
the
production
.
Rights
to
livelihood
Capitalism
provides
a
the
handful
of
rich
people
and
people
in
power
exclusive
rights
to
natural
resources
.
The
State
should
have
protected
people
’
s
rights
to
land
,
water
,
air
,
and
other
natural
resources
.
WALHI
in
Motion
WALHI
invites
people
in
cities
and
rural
areas
in
the
country
to
:
Resist
globalization
,
spread
the
words
to
fight
the
unfair
globalisation
.
Political
change
requires
supports
from
all
the
countrymen
.
Discuss
globalization
with
friends
and
relatives
;
you
don
’
t
need
to
give
answers
but
discuss
launch
questions
about
globalization
and
environment
withto
them
.
Resist
all
forms
of
exploitation
.
Support
or
launch
campaigns
against
unjust
globalization
.
The
root
of
the
environment
plight
is
the
oppression
of
the
civil
,
political
,
economic
,
social
and
cultural
rights
of
the
citizens
.
Change
your
lifestyle
to
one
that
is
friendly
to
the
environment
and
the
marginalized
people
.
Ride
a
bike
to
work
,
save
energy
,
use
recycled
stuff
.
Be
a
smart
consumer
.
Choose
environmentally
friendly
products
.
Use
organic
products
from
companies
which
employ
fair
trade
.
Avoid
multinational
corporations
’
s
products
,
support
local
products
.
Buy
local
farmers
’
produce
.
Be
a
conscious
worker
.
Don
’
t
work
at
companies
that
have
bad
environmental
records
and
disregard
workers
’
rights
.
Push
the
company
you
work
at
to
care
for
the
environment
and
the
people
.
Persuade
the
local
councillors
to
promote
environmentally
friendly
policies
and
anti
-
globalization
ideas
.
Besides
arranging
face
-
to
-
face
meetings
,
you
can
persuade
them
by
sending
letters
to
them
and
via
the
mass
media
.
Do
ethical
investment
.
Invest
your
money
in
financial
institutions
that
respect
the
environment
and
people
’
s
rights
.
Join
and
support
organizations
that
fight
for
people
’
s
rights
and
just
globalization
.
Customize
your
fight
accordingly
to
your
occupation
.
For
example
,
if
you
are
a
teacher
,
share
your
anti
-
globalization
knowledge
with
your
students
.
WALHI
is
expanding
its
environmental
movement
by
:
Organizing
the
movement
in
cities
and
rural
areas
,
arranging
meetings
with
the
people
.
The
meetings
aim
to
gather
radical
support
from
the
people
in
workplaces
,
the
neighborhoods
,
campuses
and
schools
.
Arranging
public
meetings
to
promote
anti
-
globalization
ideas
and
environmental
awareness
.
Arranging
workshops
for
people
from
all
walks
of
life
to
explain
the
relation
between
globalization
and
environmental
problems
.
Approaching
people
at
their
homes
and
public
places
in
a
bid
to
increase
participation
in
the
environmental
movement
.
Strengthening
people
’
s
forums
that
work
onfor
the
environment
issues
to
establish
a
solid
network
and
in
an
attempt
to
make
the
environmental
movement
a
more
respected
movement
.
Becoming
the
center
of
anti
-
globalization
movement
and
environmental
movement
by
organizing
struggles
against
injustice
and
environmental
damage
fights
everywhere
and
forming
alliance
with
workers
,
peasants
,
fishermen
,
women
and
students
.
Preparing
non
-
violent
yet
directfrontal
actions
against
anyone
who
make
damagess
to
the
environment
and
conductor
conducts
violence
against
the
people
.
Raising
funds
from
public
by
mobilizing
volunteers
and
other
progressive
forces
.
For
more
information
,
please
contact
:
Halid
Muhammad
National
Director
Telepon
kantor
:
+
62
-
(
021
)
791
93
363
Mobile
:
Fax
:
+
62
-
(
021
)
794
1673
Created
:
02
Feb
2006
|
Updated
:
02
Feb
2006
Industrial
Engineering
The
Industrial
Engineering
program
,
founded
in
1992
is
committed
to
produce
high
quality
graduates
.
This
commitment
has
made
this
program
go
through
a
rapid
development
within
six
years
since
it
was
established
.
The
curriculum
refinement
and
improvement
according
to
the
development
of
industrial
demand
,
the
improvement
of
lecturers
and
facilities
quality
,
establishment
of
the
partnership
with
various
industries
and
educational
institutions
are
efforts
conducted
by
this
program
.
Within
the
first
two
semesters
,
the
program
will
direct
student
to
gain
basic
engineering
knowledge
such
as
Mathematics
,
Physics
,
and
Industrial
Chemistry
.
Students
will
be
introduced
to
some
industries
to
have
a
vivid
description
of
Industrial
activities
.
In
the
third
to
the
fourth
semester
,
students
will
be
acquainted
to
the
analysis
concepts
and
planing
,
later
on
,
in
the
fifth
semester
,
every
six
to
seven
students
will
be
directed
to
enhance
their
skill
in
industrial
system
planing
.
Starting
from
the
eighth
semester
,
students
can
choose
between
the
two
sub
majors
,
namely
:
Production
System
Engineering
and
Management
,
and
Quality
Engineering
and
Management
.
The
characteristics
and
excellence
of
industrial
Engineering
program
lies
in
its
activities
.
Visitations
and
apprenticeships
in
industrial
bodies
is
periodically
supervised
to
bridge
the
industrial
world
and
the
theories
given
in
lectures
.
The
graduates
are
prepared
to
undergo
rapid
adjustment
in
every
available
working
situations
.
This
is
due
to
the
curriculum
,
having
the
emphasis
on
the
ability
to
develop
logical
thinking
,
without
disregarding
special
skills
.
In
order
to
anticipate
the
coming
free
market
,
this
program
has
prepared
its
curiculum
by
adding
some
English
courses
and
other
Asian
Languages
Courses
.
The
collaboration
network
with
industries
such
as
Sampoerna
,
PT
Jackay
Files
and
others
will
give
facility
to
students
to
be
apprentices
,
besides
the
partnership
with
foreign
educational
insitutions
such
as
Dongseo
University
in
the
form
of
students
exchange
program
will
give
students
the
opportunities
to
earn
global
perspective
General
English
courses
will
improve
your
ability
to
communicate
in
English
by
:
-
improving
your
spoken
fluency
-
working
on
your
pronunciation
-
expanding
your
vocabulary
-
developing
your
grammatical
accuracy
-
improving
your
listening
,
reading
and
writing
skills
.
General
English
covers
a
very
wide
range
of
topics
from
music
to
sport
,
relationships
,
food
,
news
and
so
on
.
Courses
are
available
from
Beginner
to
Advanced
level
.
General
English
provide
you
with
the
English
you
need
to
express
yourself
to
the
world
!
General
Business
English
Business
English
courses
develop
the
vocabulary
,
speaking
,
listening
,
reading
and
writing
skills
you
need
most
at
work
.
You
also
become
familiar
with
the
technology
you
can
use
to
maximize
the
effectiveness
of
your
communication
at
work
.
The
TBI
Business
English
courses
can
help
you
learn
how
to
put
your
CV
online
,
how
to
give
a
memorable
presentation
using
various
computer
software
packages
and
how
to
write
effective
e
-
mails
.
The
topics
you
discuss
are
related
to
business
situations
,
such
as
:
applying
for
a
job
,
company
structure
,
marketing
and
meeting
visitors
from
abroad
.
You
are
encouraged
to
relate
the
language
you
learn
to
your
own
situation
at
work
and
learn
from
the
work
experience
of
other
students
in
your
class
.
If
you
would
like
an
International
qualification
in
Business
English
,
the
Cambridge
University
Business
English
examinations
are
available
at
TBI
.
Modules
TBI
Sudirman
also
offers
business
modules
.
These
courses
below
are
specially
designed
to
equip
you
with
the
communication
skills
you
need
in
everyday
business
situations
:
-
Oral
Presentaion
Skill
-
Business
Conversation
-
Business
Corresopondence
-
Better
English
Writing
-
Step
Into
Writing
(
minimum
Level
4
General
English
)
IELTS
Preparation
A
score
for
the
“
International
English
Language
Testing
System
”
test
,
or
IELTS
,
is
required
for
admission
to
universities
and
professional
training
institutions
in
the
United
Kingdom
,
Australia
and
New
Zealand
.
It
is
also
required
for
immigration
to
these
countries
.
Some
institutions
of
further
education
in
North
America
have
also
started
accepting
IELTS
.
There
are
two
versions
of
the
IELTS
test
:
-
The
Academic
Module
This
is
for
students
wishing
to
enter
an
institution
of
higher
education
degree
or
diploma
courses
.
-
The
General
Training
Module
This
is
for
students
wishing
to
enter
secondary
schools
,
do
vocational
training
courses
,
or
emigrate
to
Australia
,
New
Zealand
or
the
United
Kingdom
.
IELTS
has
four
sections
;
Listening
,
Reading
,
Writing
and
Speaking
.
Each
section
is
marked
on
a
scale
from
1
to
9
and
the
final
score
is
an
average
of
the
scores
for
each
section
.
Most
universities
accept
candidates
who
have
achieved
a
score
of
6
or
6
.
5
overall
.
Often
,
universities
will
only
accept
candidates
who
have
achieved
a
score
of
6
,
especially
in
the
Writing
section
.
Indonesian
Language
Training
TBI
has
experienced
Indonesian
language
teachers
who
can
teach
courses
ranging
from
basic
survival
Indonesian
to
specialized
Indonesian
for
business
presentations
.
Our
teachers
are
trained
to
select
and
develop
appropriate
lessons
to
help
with
your
particular
needs
and
interests
.
In
-
House
Training
Since
1984
,
TBI
has
designed
and
taught
specialized
courses
for
over
500
government
departments
,
national
and
multinational
companies
,
and
charitable
foundations
.
Participants
on
our
custom
-
made
courses
have
come
from
all
over
Indonesia
and
ranged
from
surgeons
to
management
consultants
and
from
bank
managers
to
oil
rig
workers
.
We
have
held
courses
to
meet
individual
client
specifications
in
a
variety
of
locations
,
including
Jakarta
,
West
Java
,
Borneo
and
Sumatra
.
We
organize
computer
-
based
distance
learning
courses
for
companies
with
employees
in
different
locations
but
with
similar
training
needs
.
One
-
to
-
One
Tuition
One
-
to
-
one
tuition
allows
you
to
decide
on
the
class
schedule
and
course
content
that
will
meet
your
specific
professional
or
personal
needs
.
If
you
want
to
prepare
for
an
important
test
,
need
help
with
your
thesis
,
or
have
a
report
to
write
at
work
,
one
-
to
-
one
tuition
is
a
fast
,
effective
way
of
achieving
your
goals
.
SENIOR
SECONDARY
SCHOOL
PANGUDI
LUHUR
VAN
LITH
SUMMARY
Catholic
education
in
Central
Java
is
for
a
great
part
run
and
administered
by
the
FIC
foundation
which
goes
by
the
significant
name
of
(
Yayasan
)
Pangudi
Luhur
,
Noble
Aspiration
(
Foundation
)
.
It
sees
itself
as
a
study
group
which
is
characterised
by
true
brotherhood
within
the
setting
of
apostolate
,
education
and
formation
;
from
a
religious
point
of
view
it
calls
itself
a
faith
community
concentrated
on
Jesus
Christ
,
who
in
faith
is
seen
as
the
True
Master
.
Its
practical
,
concrete
aim
is
the
formation
of
youth
;
they
wish
to
train
them
into
personalities
of
high
quality
;
believing
,
principled
people
of
a
good
disposition
.
Some
ten
years
ago
they
had
a
serious
setback
,
when
the
Indonesian
government
discontinued
all
Colleges
of
Education
(
teacher
training
colleges
)
(
both
the
state
colleges
and
the
private
ones
)
all
over
the
country
.
The
consequence
was
that
the
teacher
training
college
Van
Lith
,
in
Muntilan
,
which
in
the
dozens
of
years
of
its
existence
had
trained
a
lot
of
conscientious
teachers
,
could
not
accept
any
new
students
for
the
year
1990
-
1991
any
more
.
Being
aware
of
a
great
need
of
conscientious
and
dedicated
Christian
leaders
for
all
social
sectors
,
for
whom
a
general
secondary
education
is
necessary
to
follow
higher
education
and
to
find
a
suitable
place
in
society
,
the
foundation
decided
to
set
up
an
SMA
,
a
school
for
senior
general
secondary
education
.
They
also
named
this
school
after
father
Franciscus
Georgius
Josephus
van
Lith
SJ
(
1863
Eindhoven
,
The
Netherlands
-
1926
Semarang
,
Indonesia
)
,
who
may
be
said
to
be
one
of
the
principal
founders
of
the
mission
in
Java
and
whose
vision
concerning
Christian
education
they
still
think
relevant
for
the
educational
work
in
Indonesia
His
aspiration
was
a
thorough
training
of
highly
committed
and
qualified
lay
apostles
,
who
would
commit
themselves
to
bringing
about
social
changes
,
in
collaboration
with
all
people
of
good
-
will
.
For
this
formation
he
preferred
the
disciplined
boarding
school
system
.
Formal
,
informal
and
non
-
formal
education
should
be
integrated
.
The
idea
of
the
foundation
Pangudi
Luhur
was
and
is
supported
by
the
policy
of
the
Indonesian
Provincial
Council
of
the
FIC
Brothers
who
,
in
collaboration
with
the
Archdiocese
of
Semarang
,
the
Sisters
of
Charles
Borromeo
and
the
Communication
forum
of
Catholic
Intellectuals
at
Yogyakarta
,
wish
to
give
scope
to
the
intensive
training
of
young
people
for
the
sake
of
the
progress
of
the
Church
in
the
spirit
of
the
Kingdom
of
God
and
for
the
well
-
being
of
the
people
of
Indonesia
'
especially
those
who
suffer
and
are
lonely
'
,
through
the
combination
of
education
at
school
and
living
on
its
premises
.
The
government
has
set
a
standard
curriculum
as
a
minimum
for
all
secondary
schools
all
over
Indonesia
.
Besides
this
a
school
may
have
its
own
extended
curriculum
,
which
in
the
SMA
P
.
L
.
Van
Lith
comprises
continued
activities
in
order
to
deepen
the
formation
of
the
students
.
This
process
of
formation
wishes
to
merge
the
aspects
of
formal
,
informal
and
non
-
formal
education
like
religiousness
,
humaneness
,
social
conduct
and
mind
.
A
long
list
could
be
given
containing
a
serious
and
detailed
analysis
of
the
various
aspects
.
And
the
method
of
accompanying
the
students
emphasises
the
necessity
of
accustoming
them
to
analysing
the
contemporary
aspects
concerning
faith
life
,
and
the
social
,
cultural
and
political
situations
.
The
boarding
school
,
where
the
male
students
live
,
and
the
nearby
hostel
for
the
girls
function
as
means
to
achieve
the
objective
of
SMA
P
.
L
.
Van
Lith
as
best
as
possible
.
The
life
atmosphere
that
is
maintained
and
fostered
is
one
of
mutual
friendship
,
in
which
the
boarders
can
feel
safe
,
content
and
at
home
.
This
situation
will
help
the
boarders
to
develop
themselves
in
the
fields
of
intelligence
,
religiousness
,
common
humanity
and
social
conduct
.
Hopefully
many
will
come
to
feel
that
noble
aspiration
that
inspired
father
Francis
van
Lith
.
A
.
BACKGROUNDS
OF
THE
FOUNDATION
OF
SMA
PANGUDI
LUHUR
.
As
is
the
case
with
every
school
,
these
are
not
unrelated
to
certain
circumstances
;
for
the
SMA
P
.
L
.
these
are
the
following
:
1
.
The
government
had
discontinued
all
Colleges
of
Education
(
both
the
state
colleges
and
the
private
ones
)
all
over
Indonesia
.
The
consequence
was
that
the
C
of
E
Van
Lith
,
which
had
existed
dozens
of
years
then
and
had
trained
conscientious
teachers
,
could
not
accept
any
new
students
for
the
year
1990
-
1991
any
more
.
2
.
The
awareness
that
there
was
a
great
need
of
Christian
leaders
for
all
social
sectors
,
and
for
which
a
general
secondary
education
is
positively
necessary
.
3
.
The
conviction
that
the
vision
of
Father
Franciscus
Georgius
Josephus
van
Lith
SJ
concerning
Christian
education
is
still
relevant
for
the
educational
work
in
Indonesia
.
This
vision
is
the
following
:
a
.
To
undertake
a
thorough
training
of
highly
committed
and
qualified
lay
apostles
.
b
.
To
work
towards
the
formation
of
Christians
who
will
act
as
Other
Christs
in
bringing
about
social
changes
.
c
.
To
see
education
as
charity
which
requires
daring
to
side
with
the
oppressed
and
abused
for
the
sake
of
justice
and
the
defence
of
fundamental
human
rights
.
d
.
Emphasis
on
the
great
importance
of
boarding
schools
in
formation
,
not
only
because
of
the
discipline
but
especially
to
achieve
a
high
quality
.
e
.
The
integration
of
formal
,
informal
and
non
-
formal
education
.
4
.
The
policy
of
the
Indonesian
Provincial
Council
of
the
FIC
Brothers
,
in
collaboration
with
the
Archdiocese
of
Semarang
,
the
Sisters
of
Charles
Borromeo
and
the
Communication
forum
of
Catholic
Intellectuals
at
Yogyakarta
,
to
undertake
and
to
achieve
the
intensive
training
of
young
people
for
the
sake
of
the
progress
of
the
Church
and
the
people
of
Indonesia
through
the
combination
of
education
at
school
and
living
in
a
hostel
.
B
.
VISION
AND
MISSION
SMA
PANGUDI
LUHUR
VAN
LITH
The
vision
and
mission
of
SMA
Van
Lith
are
respectively
explained
as
follows
:
1
.
VISION
The
vision
of
SMA
P
.
L
.
Van
Lith
comprises
the
spirit
of
the
Kingdom
of
God
with
at
the
core
the
well
-
being
of
all
people
,
'
especially
those
who
suffer
and
are
lonely
'
,
expecting
that
this
ideal
will
be
realised
in
the
social
life
of
the
people
and
the
nation
.
Hopefully
,
this
spirit
will
permeate
all
aspects
of
society
and
efforts
will
be
made
to
realise
this
in
an
open
way
in
collaboration
of
all
people
of
good
-
will
.
2
.
MISSION
The
mission
of
SMA
P
.
L
Van
Lith
consists
in
.
the
guiding
of
young
people
,
preferably
poor
people
,
via
an
education
at
a
school
and
in
a
hostel
.
This
process
of
formation
wishes
to
merge
the
aspects
of
formal
,
informal
and
non
-
formal
education
like
religiousness
,
humaneness
,
social
conduct
and
intelligence
.
This
aim
is
pursued
in
a
flexible
way
in
an
atmosphere
of
brotherhood
,
in
which
people
try
to
love
one
another
,
to
mould
and
to
help
each
other
.
C
.
OBJECTIVE
The
ideal
of
the
formation
at
SMA
P
.
L
.
Van
Lith
is
:
1
.
To
help
the
students
to
grow
-
as
to
character
and
mind
-
into
qualitatively
conscientious
PERSONALITIES
as
believers
,
and
to
be
able
to
develop
-
in
the
fields
of
knowledge
,
skill
,
conduct
and
norms
of
life
-
the
possibilities
that
are
necessary
to
follow
higher
education
and
to
take
a
suitable
place
in
society
.
2
.
To
guide
the
students
in
their
development
,
so
that
in
due
time
they
will
become
suitable
,
conscientious
and
dedicated
leaders
to
facilitate
the
progress
of
society
,
people
,
nation
and
Church
.
METHOD
IN
THE
ORGANISATION
OF
FORMATION
A
.
Programme
of
the
curriculum
To
undertake
the
activities
to
achieve
the
objective
of
the
training
at
the
SMA
P
.
L
.
Van
Lith
that
are
contained
in
the
standard
curriculum
and
the
extended
curriculum
.
a
.
The
standard
curriculum
is
set
by
the
government
itself
as
the
minimum
and
is
meant
for
the
whole
country
.
b
.
The
extended
curriculum
comprises
continued
activities
in
order
to
deepen
the
formation
,
exercise
and
guidance
of
the
students
in
the
fields
of
religion
,
humaneness
,
social
conduct
,
skill
and
personality
.
B
.
Interaction
Pattern
Learning
/
Teaching
This
pattern
is
explained
as
follows
:
1
.
To
integrate
the
norms
as
mentioned
in
VISION
and
MISSION
of
the
Foundation
Pangudi
Luhur
and
SMA
P
.
L
.
Van
Lith
.
2
.
SMA
P
.
L
.
Van
Lith
works
as
a
"
dialectical
educational
institution
"
,
in
the
atmosphere
of
mutually
confiding
in
one
another
,
respecting
each
other
,
giving
attention
to
one
another
,
loving
one
another
,
with
opportunities
for
relaxation
,
for
a
critical
attitude
,
daring
to
ask
exploring
questions
and
to
give
one
'
s
own
opinion
.
3
.
Personal
approach
which
emphasises
fellow
-
feeling
in
rendering
services
as
is
noticeable
:
a
.
in
formation
functions
like
guide
,
facilitator
,
intermediary
,
instructor
,
stimulator
and
as
a
colleague
.
b
.
Each
person
individually
is
a
person
of
authority
according
to
his
harmonious
achievement
in
the
fields
of
self
-
education
,
expertise
,
personality
,
social
conduct
and
religiousness
.
c
.
Each
person
individually
is
taught
the
habit
of
reflecting
,
of
assessing
colleagues
,
of
conferring
,
of
discussing
and
of
officiating
.
4
.
The
strategy
/
method
of
guiding
emphasises
the
necessity
of
accustoming
oneself
to
analysing
the
contemporary
aspects
concerning
faith
life
,
and
the
social
,
cultural
and
political
situations
.
5
.
The
method
interaction
learning
/
teaching
of
guides
and
students
employs
the
following
variations
:
a
.
From
guide
to
student
the
activities
comprise
:
giving
information
,
assignments
,
stimulation
,
teaching
how
to
observe
,
giving
feedback
,
discipline
in
class
or
working
group
,
etc
.
b
.
From
student
to
guide
they
comprise
:
asking
questions
,
making
proposals
,
correcting
results
and
information
received
,
answering
questions
of
the
guide
,
giving
constructive
criticism
,
etc
.
c
.
The
students
'
mutual
role
implies
asking
and
answering
each
other
questions
,
exchange
of
arguments
in
a
debate
,
entering
into
a
dialogue
in
group
rehearsals
,
solving
problems
,
experimenting
,
making
plans
,
presenting
oneself
,
etc
.
THE
HOSTEL
DEPARTMENT
The
two
hostels
for
male
and
female
students
respectively
both
function
as
means
to
achieve
the
objective
of
SMA
P
.
L
.
Van
Lith
as
best
as
possible
.
The
life
atmosphere
that
is
maintained
and
fostered
is
one
of
mutual
friendship
,
in
which
the
boarders
can
feel
safe
,
content
and
at
home
.
This
situation
will
help
the
boarders
to
develop
themselves
in
the
fields
of
intelligence
,
religiousness
,
common
humanity
and
social
conduct
.
The
guidance
and
training
offered
are
aimed
at
the
formation
of
personalities
of
high
quality
;
believing
,
people
of
character
and
good
disposition
.
Also
to
reach
an
optimal
development
of
their
possibilities
.
in
the
fields
of
science
,
skill
,
conduct
and
values
that
are
important
in
their
lives
to
follow
higher
education
and
for
society
.
WAY
OF
GUIDANCE
:
Communication
/
dialogue
with
individual
persons
and
together
;
instruction
/
information
/
proposals
orally
or
in
writing
;
example
and
involvement
of
leaders
in
activities
in
the
hostel
;
involvement
of
boarders
in
setting
up
rules
/
agreements
concerning
activities
;
motivation
to
make
progress
,
creativity
and
collaboration
;
praise
and
reward
when
success
is
attained
;
advice
,
admonishment
and
sanctions
given
in
a
pedagogical
way
;
personal
and
collective
evaluation
;
reflection
,
prayer
and
meditation
;
coping
with
tensions
by
means
of
talk
,
relaxation
,
joking
and
recreation
;
social
conduct
with
regard
to
boarders
;
organising
guiding
activities
in
school
and
in
the
hostel
in
association
with
each
other
.
1
)
Religiousness
:
Aim
:
so
that
the
boarders
become
believing
Christians
and
develop
a
life
full
of
love
and
close
friendship
in
Church
and
society
,
according
to
Jesus
'
teachings
.
Exercises
:
help
one
another
in
the
hostel
,
communal
prayer
in
groups
,
rosary
,
prayer
meeting
,
meditation
,
completes
etc
.
;
daily
Eucharist
,
periodicals
for
the
benefit
of
the
parish
and
our
own
campus
;
activities
in
the
Legion
of
Mary
;
reader
,
children
'
s
catechesis
,
during
retreat
,
recollection
and
sodalities
for
the
young
;
reflection
on
their
own
lives
.
2
)
Intelligence
Aim
:
so
that
the
boarders
develop
into
intelligent
,
creative
and
independent
persons
.
Exercises
:
studying
alone
or
with
others
in
a
disciplined
way
,
course
in
English
,
discussion
,
panel
discussions
,
bookkeeping
,
being
creative
in
certain
subjects
,
showing
discipline
,
self
government
,
assimilate
reading
matter
from
media
,
newspaper
,
weekly
and
magazine
;
seek
,
of
their
own
accord
,
advice
from
subject
teachers
in
the
afternoon
.
3
)
Social
conduct
Aim
:
so
that
students
develop
into
social
persons
who
how
to
assimilate
,
to
adapt
themselves
to
others
and
make
friends
in
their
surroundings
,
especially
with
marginalised
people
.
Exercises
:
self
-
government
;
knowing
how
to
create
a
safe
,
pleasant
,
orderly
and
friendly
atmosphere
;
see
to
neatness
and
tidiness
in
the
classrooms
;
show
responsible
behaviour
in
doing
tasks
in
the
hostel
;
working
groups
;
rendering
services
receiving
guests
or
answering
the
telephone
;
showing
solidarity
with
needy
people
,
giving
them
money
,
clothes
and
/
or
food
,
in
doing
which
something
is
sacrificed
personally
and
collectively
;
showing
interest
in
people
in
the
neighbourhood
who
have
been
hit
by
a
disaster
.
4
)
Humanity
The
aim
is
the
formation
of
moral
and
principled
personalities
who
associate
in
a
charitable
way
with
those
with
whom
they
live
together
.
Exercises
:
To
enter
into
a
conversation
or
dialogue
with
others
in
an
open
and
fair
way
;
to
show
appreciation
for
others
by
kind
and
polite
behaviour
;
to
acquire
a
grateful
attitude
and
and
accept
with
joy
presents
from
others
;
to
know
how
to
appreciate
everybody
in
whatever
task
or
function
;
to
act
kindly
towards
he
common
man
,
etc
.
Workshop
Pers
Mahasiswa
Ende
01
Aug
2006
Yayasan
Pantau
bekerjasama
dengan
Umverteilen
mengadakan
workshop
penulisan
bagi
pers
mahasiswa
di
Ende
selama
lima
hari
(
6
-
11
Maret
2006
)
.
Agus
Sopian
,
Linda
Tangdialla
,
dan
Frans
Anggal
mengampu
workshop
ini
.
--------------------------------------------------
PROGRAM
REPORT
Geri
Gobang
,
one
of
participants
from
Institute
of
Agriculture
Boawae
Ngada
,
arrives
in
hotel
at
7
o
’
clock
,
Monday
,
6
March
,
2006
.
Ngada
are
take
place
three
hours
from
Ende
.
The
other
participant
was
come
from
Labuan
Bajo
,
Lembata
,
and
several
regions
in
Flores
which
need
more
than
8
hours
traveling
with
car
and
boat
.
Participants
consist
with
8
women
and
12
men
.
There
are
four
student
which
has
work
part
time
as
announcer
and
reporter
at
“
Siaran
Pemerintah
Daerah
”
Radio
and
“
Republik
Indonesia
”
Radio
.
This
is
the
first
training
for
student
in
Ende
.
They
told
,
“
This
is
special
training
for
us
”
.
The
first
session
on
Monday
,
March
6
,
2006
,
should
be
opened
by
Agus
Sopian
and
Linda
Tangdialla
.
But
,
their
flight
was
delayed
by
Merpati
.
Merpati
Airplane
just
flight
two
times
each
week
.
Ende
is
small
city
.
Transportation
became
a
problem
which
is
difficult
to
solve
by
government
.
Almost
two
years
“
Ipi
”
Harbor
still
can
not
use
because
they
can
not
lift
founder
ship
carcass
.
The
first
session
was
filled
by
Esti
Wahyuni
(
Organizer
staff
)
with
introducing
and
discussing
the
syllabus
.
We
are
talked
about
the
Elements
of
journalist
based
on
a
book
,
written
by
Bill
Kovach
and
Tom
Rosenstiel
.
There
are
many
responses
from
participants
.
Almost
of
them
thought
that
would
be
difficult
to
apply
the
elements
of
journalist
in
Flores
or
Kupang
.
Journalist
prosperous
was
to
be
the
major
reason
.
“
Although
all
of
that
is
right
,
but
I
think
it
just
prevail
at
America
,
”
said
Riani
,
Economic
student
of
Flores
University
.
According
to
Rosa
Dalima
,
part
time
reporter
in
“
Republic
Indonesia
”
Radio
(
RRI
)
,
“
Journalist
who
was
reporting
can
accept
`
amplop
`
(
bribe
)
but
only
in
a
few
number
.
Frans
Anggal
,
managing
editor
Flores
Pos
,
also
confesses
that
quality
of
writing
in
Flores
was
influence
by
reporter
’
s
quality
.
Second
session
was
discussing
about
management
reporting
by
Frans
Anggal
.
He
told
about
system
reporting
in
Flores
Pos
.
Start
from
reporter
until
editing
system
which
are
doing
by
editor
.
What
is
the
problem
and
how
to
solve
the
problem
?
According
to
Frans
Anggal
,
the
big
problem
beside
quality
of
reporters
is
custom
of
Flores
society
.
“
Last
week
,
we
was
attending
by
one
truck
of
Bajawa
Society
who
was
not
satisfied
with
our
wrong
printing
”
,
said
Frans
Anggal
.
He
told
about
people
who
were
prosecuting
Flores
Pos
because
Flores
Pos
was
doing
some
mistake
in
printing
.
They
judge
Flores
Pos
had
filthy
their
name
,
make
it
bad
,
and
prosecute
him
to
do
tradition
of
Ngada
Ceremonies
to
revert
the
name
which
has
filthy
by
Flores
Pos
.
Flores
Pos
should
be
present
a
buffalo
and
a
pig
which
can
carry
on
the
shoulder
by
eight
adult
men
.
Law
track
does
not
valid
in
this
land
.
If
there
is
government
official
who
was
done
filthy
of
the
name
and
the
mistake
can
not
accept
by
their
family
,
just
one
way
to
solve
it
with
traditional
ceremony
.
Night
session
was
filled
by
Agus
Sopian
and
Linda
Tangdialla
with
lesson
about
writing
and
reporting
based
on
working
journalism
principle
.
Linda
Tangdialla
shares
her
experience
to
be
editor
at
`
Bisnis
Indonesia
`
Newspaper
.
This
brain
storming
got
interest
from
participants
.
They
were
enthusiasms
to
asking
about
the
rule
of
journalist
in
Jakarta
.
Agus
Sopian
was
giving
lesson
about
narrative
writing
,
straight
news
,
and
how
to
make
it
different
from
feature
.
This
session
was
very
interesting
.
The
both
of
instructor
do
not
tired
although
they
have
not
taken
a
rest
after
arrived
from
Jakarta
.
Second
day
of
training
,
March
7
2006
,
Linda
Tangdialla
giving
lesson
about
Immersion
Reporting
based
on
Jimmy
Breslin
writing
,
it
’
s
an
Honor
.
Breslin
writing
was
appeal
with
Chik
Rini
writing
`
Sebuah
kegilaan
di
Simpang
Kraft
`
.
Participants
was
aware
how
to
seeing
and
giving
attention
with
a
little
things
from
reporting
.
How
to
choose
angle
from
every
journalist
?
“
Why
Breslin
choose
a
gravedigger
?
”
Farin
said
,
student
of
Cendana
University
,
Kupang
.
Linda
explained
how
Breslin
taking
angle
in
the
middle
of
3000
journalist
who
was
reporting
the
death
of
President
Jhon
F
Kennedy
.
Every
journalist
was
prosecuting
to
be
creative
when
they
were
taking
angle
which
can
not
look
by
the
other
.
But
,
it
could
made
the
writing
more
exclusive
and
be
alive
.
Almost
all
participants
said
that
they
seldom
forget
a
little
thing
.
They
still
thinking
,
to
report
important
official
government
is
the
best
news
which
will
publish
by
media
.
Second
session
continued
by
Agus
Sopian
,
about
the
Truth
theory
.
This
theory
got
interest
by
Yohannes
from
Pastoral
Institute
,
Ende
.
According
to
Yohannes
,
“
We
also
learn
a
lot
of
the
truth
theories
at
college
.
But
,
I
never
know
if
the
theory
was
use
in
journalism
too
”
.
Besides
the
truth
theories
,
Agus
Sopian
also
explain
about
seven
criteria
of
anonymous
sources
,
what
is
narrative
reporting
,
and
also
sharing
his
experience
when
reporting
.
On
the
evening
all
participants
was
watching
film
Shuttered
Glass
and
discussing
about
it
.
Last
session
on
second
day
,
we
discussed
about
conflict
and
how
is
media
put
them
selves
in
conflict
situation
.
There
is
not
conflict
area
in
Ende
,
but
this
area
was
sensitive
with
conflict
between
villages
.
Nor
religion
or
ethnic
as
trigger
,
it
could
causes
by
name
filthy
and
drunks
in
the
street
who
was
doing
by
young
men
.
Last
February
,
a
young
man
was
killed
because
he
drunks
in
the
street
.
Third
day
,
Wednesday
,
March
8
,
2006
,
we
discuss
our
home
work
which
gave
by
Linda
Tangdialla
.
All
participants
had
write
short
story
about
anything
.
The
models
like
Jimmy
Breslin
and
Chik
Rini
stories
.
The
characters
are
origin
and
the
events
are
real
.
All
participants
writing
were
discussing
to
find
the
minus
and
the
weakness
.
The
discussion
was
running
more
than
3
hours
.
Every
participant
interested
to
give
comment
and
listen
to
Linda
Tangdialla
explanation
.
The
discussing
finished
in
the
end
of
lunch
time
.
After
Linda
Tangdialla
,
Agus
Sopian
was
explain
how
to
using
words
`
saya
`
(
I
)
in
narrative
reporting
.
We
are
discussing
about
how
to
built
engine
and
structure
of
narrative
reporting
.
Participants
had
aware
that
writing
in
narrative
was
very
difficult
.
Using
simple
language
and
words
was
more
difficult
than
using
bureaucracy
words
.
Participants
said
that
Kompas
and
other
Indonesian
media
are
the
best
media
which
they
can
imitate
without
never
know
the
way
.
In
the
evening
we
were
watching
movie
`
Super
Size
Me
`
and
discussion
about
it
.
In
the
night
,
we
were
discussing
about
journalism
until
12
o
’
clock
.
Participants
are
very
enthusiasm
with
this
part
.
We
talked
about
management
reporting
,
ethics
and
the
equal
ethic
,
what
is
narrative
reporting
and
how
to
make
it
different
with
poetry
and
literary
.
The
fourth
day
,
March
9
,
2006
,
participants
was
practicing
the
result
of
their
learning
and
discussion
for
three
days
ago
with
reporting
and
writing
by
them
selves
.
The
best
writing
would
be
published
in
Flores
Pos
.
After
dinner
,
they
presented
their
reporting
and
writing
until
11
o
’
clock
.
*
Silabus
Hari
Pertama
,
Sesi
1
,
pukul
10
.
00
-
12
.
00
.
Membicarakan
silabus
.
Diskusi
tentang
jurnalisme
dasar
melalui
sudut
pandang
sembilan
elemen
jurnalisme
dari
Committee
of
Concerned
Journalists
.
Pemakaian
byline
,
pagar
api
,
dan
sebagainya
.
[
Agus
Sopian
,
Frans
Anggal
dan
Linda
Tangdialla
.
]
Hari
Pertama
,
Sesi
2
,
pukul
13
.
00
-
15
.
00
.
Manajemen
reportase
.
Diskusi
tentang
studi
kasus
sistem
peliputan
di
Bisnis
Indonesia
dan
Flores
Pos
.
[
Frans
Anggal
dan
Linda
Tangdialla
.
]
Hari
Pertama
,
Sesi
3
,
pukul
15
.
30
–
17
.
00
.
Acara
optional
.
Pemutaran
film
All
the
President
’
s
Men
.
[
Organizer
Staff
.
]
Hari
Pertama
,
Sesi
4
,
pukul
20
.
00
–
22
.
00
.
Acara
optional
.
Diskusi
soal
liputan
berdasarkan
prinsip
-
prinsip
kerja
jurnalisme
dalam
film
All
the
President
’
s
Men
.
[
Agus
Sopian
.
]
Hari
Kedua
,
Sesi
5
,
pukul
10
.
00
-
12
.
00
.
Diskusi
tentang
apa
yang
dimaksud
penulisan
aratif
,
bagaimana
perbedaannya
dengan
straight
news
dan
features
,
contoh
-
contoh
penulisan
naratif
,
dan
bagaimana
prospeknya
untuk
pengembangan
media
di
Indonesia
.
[
Agus
Sopian
]
Hari
Kedua
,
Sesi
6
,
pukul
13
.
00
-
15
.
00
.
Diskusi
tentang
“
immersion
reporting
”
berdasarkan
karya
Jimmy
Breslin
It
'
s
an
Honor
dan
membandingkannya
dengan
Sebuah
Kegilaan
di
Simpang
Kraft
oleh
Chik
Rini
.
[
Linda
Tangdialla
.
]
Tugas
individu
untuk
hari
ketiga
:
Catatlah
salah
satu
fragmen
kecil
di
lingkungan
terdekat
Anda
,
entah
di
rumah
,
kantor
,
tempat
workshop
,
pasar
atau
di
mana
saja
,
yang
menurut
Anda
menarik
.
Tuangkan
dalam
tulisan
pendek
antara
setengah
sampai
satu
halaman
,
sunting
dengan
baik
sehingga
enak
dibaca
.
Seluruh
karakater
,
tokoh
dalam
tulisan
tersebut
,
adalah
nama
asli
dan
kejadian
benar
-
benar
kejadian
.
Modelnya
“
It
’
s
an
Honor
”
atau
“
Sebuah
Kegilaan
di
Simpang
Kraft
”
tadi
.
Hari
Kedua
,
Sesi
7
,
pukul
15
.
30
-
17
.
00
.
Acara
optional
.
Pemutaran
film
The
Killing
Fields
.
[
Organizer
Staff
.
]
Hari
Kedua
,
Sesi
8
,
pukul
20
.
00
–
22
.
00
Diskusi
optional
tentang
konflik
dan
bagaimana
seharusnya
media
menempatkan
diri
dalam
situasi
konflik
.
[
Frans
Anggal
]
Hari
Ketiga
,
Sesi
9
,
pukul
10
.
00
-
12
.
00
.
Diskusi
merancang
tugas
liputan
features
untuk
suratkabar
harian
.
[
Frans
Anggal
.
]
Tugas
Individu
:
Buatlah
rancangan
penulisan
features
.
Rancangan
terdiri
atas
latar
belakang
cerita
,
siapa
narasumbernya
,
apa
dokumen
yang
digunakan
,
lama
pengerjaan
,
serta
kebutuhan
foto
atau
ilustrasi
grafis
yang
relevan
.
Hari
Ketiga
,
Sesi
10
,
pukul
13
.
00
-
15
.
00
.
Diskusi
dan
presentasi
pekerjaan
rumah
tentang
“
immersion
reporting
.
”
[
Linda
Tandiala
]
Tugas
Individu
:
Masing
-
masing
peserta
menukar
pekerjaan
rumah
dengan
rekan
terdekat
dan
membacakan
hasilnya
.
Setiap
peserta
berhak
mengajukan
kritik
atau
saran
,
mulai
intro
,
pengambilan
sudut
pandang
,
logika
kalimat
,
struktur
kalimat
,
hingga
penggunaan
diksi
.
Hari
Ketiga
,
Sesi
11
,
pukul
15
.
30
-
17
.
00
.
Acara
optional
.
Pemutaran
film
Ronin
.
[
Organizer
Staff
.
]
Hari
Ketiga
,
Sesi
12
,
pukul
20
.
00
–
22
.
00
.
Diskusi
optional
bagaimana
menyusun
kerangka
cerita
berdasarkan
Ronin
.
[
Agus
Sopian
.
]
Hari
Keempat
,
Sesi
13
,
pukul
10
.
00
-
12
.
00
.
Diskusi
membahas
tugas
rancangan
penulisan
features
untuk
suratkabar
harian
.
[
Frans
Anggal
.
]
Tugas
Individu
:
Peserta
workshop
mempresentasikan
hasil
pekerjaan
rumahnya
tentang
rancangan
liputan
features
,
sambil
mendiskusikan
peluang
dan
kendala
yang
akan
dihadapi
selama
menjalankan
liputan
.
Hari
Keempat
,
Sesi
14
,
pukul
13
.
00
-
15
.
00
.
Diskusi
pembahasan
masalah
kata
“
saya
”
dalam
laporan
naratif
,
bagaimana
membangun
engine
tulisan
,
dan
struktur
laporan
naratif
.
[
Agus
Sopian
]
Hari
Keempat
,
Sesi
15
,
pukul
15
.
30
-
17
.
00
.
Acara
optional
.
Pemutaran
film
The
Mission
.
[
Organizer
Staff
.
]
Hari
Keempat
,
Sesi
16
,
pukul
20
.
00
–
22
.
00
.
Malam
keakraban
dan
acara
bebas
tentang
kesan
selama
pelatihan
dan
harapan
ke
depan
.
[
Organizer
Staff
.
]
Hari
Kelima
,
Sesi
17
,
pukul
08
.
00
–
17
.
00
.
Field
trip
atau
kegiatan
optional
berupa
liputan
untuk
memanfaatkan
hasil
rancangan
liputan
features
sebagaimana
materi
yang
dibawakan
Frans
Anggal
sebelumnya
.
[
Organizer
Staff
]
::
BACAAN
·
Sembilan
Elemen
Jurnalisme
oleh
Bill
Kovach
dan
Tom
Rosenstiel
(
Bagian
2
dan
4
tentang
Kebenaran
dan
Jurnalisme
Verifikasi
)
.
STATE
ADDRESS
OF
THE
PRESIDENT
OF
THE
REPUBLIC
OF
INDONESIA
AND
THE
GOVERNMENT
STATEMENT
ON
THE
BILL
ON
THE
STATE
BUDGET
FOR
THE
2007
FISCAL
YEAR
AND
ITS
FINANCIAL
NOTE
BEFORE
THE
PLENARY
SESSION
OF
THE
HOUSE
OF
REPRESENTATIVES
OF
THE
REPUBLIC
OF
INDONESIA
Jakarta
,
16
August
2006
Bismillahirrahmanirrahim
,
Assalamu
’
alaikum
Warahmatullahi
Wabarakatuh
,
May
we
all
be
bestowed
with
prosperity
,
Honourable
Speaker
,
Deputy
Speakers
,
and
Members
of
the
House
of
Representatives
,
Esteemed
Chairpersons
,
Deputy
Chairpersons
,
and
Members
of
State
Institutions
,
Excellencies
,
the
Ambassadors
and
Representatives
of
International
Agencies
and
Organizations
,
Ladies
and
Gentlemen
,
My
Fellow
Countrymen
,
Let
us
offer
our
praise
and
gratitude
to
Allah
SWT
for
it
is
with
His
mercy
and
grace
that
we
are
able
to
attend
the
Plenary
Session
of
the
House
of
Representatives
of
the
Republic
of
Indonesia
today
.
I
wish
to
thank
the
House
,
which
has
provided
me
with
the
opportunity
to
deliver
this
state
address
and
the
Government
Statement
on
the
Bill
on
the
State
Budget
for
2007
,
and
its
Financial
Note
.
Tomorrow
,
God
Willing
,
we
shall
commemorate
the
historic
moments
of
the
sixty
-
first
anniversary
of
the
Proclamation
of
Independence
of
our
country
.
Let
us
take
a
moment
to
bow
our
heads
to
offer
our
most
profound
praise
and
gratitude
to
God
the
Almighty
for
the
blessing
of
independence
that
has
been
bestowed
upon
us
.
It
is
also
with
His
blessing
,
mercy
,
and
grace
that
,
for
the
last
sixty
-
one
years
,
our
nation
and
state
remain
standing
robustly
.
All
of
the
trials
and
tribulations
that
have
come
alternatingly
during
the
last
sixty
-
one
years
have
forged
our
fortitude
and
resilience
as
a
nation
to
continur
striving
to
reach
high
and
noble
ideals
.
As
a
reflection
of
history
on
this
auspicious
day
,
we
should
all
express
our
highest
gratitude
and
respect
to
all
of
the
patriots
and
heroes
of
the
nation
,
who
have
dedicated
their
lives
,
even
their
body
and
soul
,
to
achieve
,
maintain
,
and
develop
the
independence
.
I
also
wish
to
extend
my
profound
expression
of
respect
to
the
Presidents
who
have
preceded
me
,
whose
leadership
I
now
perpetuate
,
namely
Dr
.
Ir
.
Soekarno
,
Grand
General
Soeharto
,
Prof
.
Dr
.
B
.
J
.
Habibie
,
KH
Abdurrahman
Wahid
and
Ibu
Megawati
Soekarnoputri
,
for
their
dedication
and
contribution
,
in
leading
the
nation
and
state
,
so
that
we
have
reached
the
current
state
of
progress
.
A
similar
expression
is
also
extended
to
the
Prime
Ministers
of
Indonesia
---
from
PM
Sutan
Sjahris
to
PM
Djuanda
---
who
have
led
the
government
of
our
country
,
while
we
adopted
the
parliamentary
system
of
governance
in
the
past
.
The
commemoration
of
the
historic
moments
of
the
proclamation
of
independence
this
year
is
conducted
with
a
mixed
feeling
of
happiness
and
concern
.
It
is
still
vivid
in
our
memories
,
the
earthquake
and
tsunami
disaster
that
devastated
Aceh
and
the
Nias
Islands
at
the
end
of
December
2004
.
A
similar
disaster
,
albeit
on
a
smaller
scale
,
once
again
hit
the
southern
coast
of
the
Island
of
Java
.
Previously
,
an
earthquake
disaster
also
ravaged
Yogyakarta
and
Central
Java
.
Meanwhile
,
earthquakes
of
smaller
magnitudes
also
occurred
in
various
regions
of
the
homeland
.
Our
country
is
indeed
located
on
a
region
vulnerable
to
disasters
.
However
,
this
condition
should
make
our
nation
tougher
,
resilient
and
always
ready
to
face
any
challenge
and
problem
.
Those
toughness
and
resilience
will
become
critical
capital
in
our
struggle
to
develop
the
nation
and
state
towards
a
better
condition
.
My
Fellow
Countrymen
,
No
one
nation
grows
into
a
great
nation
without
trial
.
Attempts
to
break
up
the
unity
of
the
nation
have
,
on
several
instances
,
occurred
;
however
,
they
have
all
been
successfully
overcome
.
Crisis
after
crisis
have
come
and
gone
in
the
course
of
our
history
,
however
,
we
were
able
to
surmount
all
of
them
.
We
are
convinced
that
the
structure
and
form
of
the
Unitary
State
of
the
Republic
of
Indonesia
,
based
on
Pancasila
(
the
Five
Principles
of
National
Ideology
)
,
is
an
accurate
and
final
choice
.
For
that
determination
and
choice
,
we
must
continue
to
develop
the
state
,
towards
a
situation
that
is
safe
and
peaceful
,
just
and
democratic
,
and
prosperous
,
which
have
become
the
ideals
and
purpose
of
the
independence
of
our
nation
.
Conflicts
and
quarrels
must
be
brought
to
an
end
.
Justice
and
prosperity
must
continue
to
be
increased
.
A
sense
of
safety
and
peacefulness
and
a
prosperous
condition
must
be
solidified
.
We
should
be
grateful
that
,
in
the
past
year
,
threats
and
security
disturbances
in
various
regions
have
abated
.
The
people
who
live
in
areas
that
were
afflicted
by
conflicts
such
as
in
Poso
,
the
Moluccas
,
and
North
Moluccas
have
now
enjoyed
a
life
that
is
much
safer
and
more
peaceful
.
Such
is
the
case
in
other
regions
.
In
the
state
address
of
last
year
,
I
have
specifically
conveyed
the
measures
that
were
undertaken
by
the
Government
to
settle
the
conflicts
in
Aceh
and
Papua
.
Praise
be
to
God
,
in
the
past
year
,
we
have
made
much
progress
that
is
full
of
hope
.
A
situation
of
security
and
peace
in
Aceh
has
been
realized
.
Not
long
ago
,
I
have
adopted
the
Law
on
the
Governance
in
Aceh
,
in
order
to
meet
the
hopes
of
the
entire
people
of
that
region
.
I
wish
to
convey
a
message
to
all
the
parties
,
do
welcome
this
law
,
as
foundation
to
develop
the
future
of
Aceh
that
is
more
prosperous
.
Through
a
deliberation
process
that
was
democratic
and
transparent
,
the
Government
and
the
DPR
-
RI
have
worked
hard
to
produce
the
said
law
.
We
have
also
recorded
much
progress
in
bringing
about
a
better
atmosphere
in
Papua
.
The
Government
has
always
favoured
dialogue
and
persuasive
approach
in
handling
the
various
issues
in
that
region
.
We
are
grateful
that
the
regional
administrative
institutions
in
Papua
have
been
able
to
function
in
implementing
the
special
autonomy
,
as
we
expected
.
Not
long
ago
,
the
process
of
electing
the
regional
heads
(
Pilkada
)
in
Papua
---
and
also
in
West
Irian
Jaya
---
has
been
successfully
conducted
in
a
democratic
,
safe
,
and
peaceful
manner
.
This
conducive
atmosphere
is
expected
to
boost
the
acceleration
of
development
in
that
region
,
so
that
the
people
in
Papua
can
veritably
reap
the
benefits
of
independence
,
such
as
enjoyed
by
their
brothers
and
sisters
in
other
regions
.
The
Government
earnestly
considers
and
takes
more
concrete
measures
to
advance
the
welfare
of
the
people
in
Papua
,
particularly
in
the
areas
of
health
,
education
,
basic
infrastructures
,
public
housing
,
and
food
resilience
.
The
Government
undertakes
with
high
seriousness
to
provide
opportunities
and
equalities
to
the
original
sons
of
Papua
to
develop
forward
to
catch
up
with
the
sons
of
other
regions
.
Honourable
Members
of
the
House
,
My
Fellow
Countrymen
,
In
close
relation
to
our
mutual
effort
to
safeguard
the
sovereignty
of
our
state
from
any
disturbance
and
threat
,
we
have
no
other
choice
but
to
develop
our
defense
.
We
are
grateful
that
throughout
the
history
of
our
state
,
the
Indonesian
Military
(
TNI
)
has
always
been
ready
and
is
always
at
the
forefront
in
defending
the
sovereignty
of
the
state
.
The
TNI
is
currently
carrying
out
efforts
to
strengthen
and
simultaneously
enhance
its
capability
,
be
it
in
its
organisation
,
professionalism
of
its
personnel
,
as
well
as
its
armaments
.
The
efforts
to
reactivate
various
armaments
,
which
have
previously
been
inoperable
due
to
the
lack
of
spare
parts
,
have
made
much
progress
.
We
have
also
taken
measures
to
procure
new
weaponries
on
a
gradual
basis
,
proportional
to
the
capacity
of
the
budget
.
Defense
cooperation
with
friendly
countries
continues
to
be
increased
,
including
cooperation
in
the
development
of
the
defense
industry
.
It
is
our
wish
that
in
the
future
we
shall
be
able
to
meet
our
own
needs
in
the
procurement
of
various
main
equipment
of
the
weapons
system
.
We
indeed
do
not
intend
to
enlarge
our
current
forces
.
What
we
wish
to
build
is
an
essential
force
that
we
deem
strong
enough
and
able
to
secure
the
entire
sovereign
territory
of
our
state
.
The
focus
of
our
defense
attention
is
directed
to
guard
the
sea
and
land
boundaries
areas
,
particularly
the
outermost
and
farther
out
islands
,
including
setting
up
security
posts
of
the
TNI
.
In
addition
to
providing
education
and
military
training
,
we
pay
serious
attention
to
the
welfare
of
the
soldiers
,
so
that
they
are
ready
at
any
time
and
able
to
perform
their
duties
to
defend
the
nation
and
state
.
We
continuously
try
to
increase
the
salary
,
food
allowance
,
old
-
age
pension
,
and
the
provision
and
repair
of
the
housing
for
our
soldiers
.
Safeguarding
and
maintaining
a
secure
and
peaceful
condition
in
the
country
is
certainly
not
the
exclusive
duty
of
the
defense
and
security
apparatus
,
but
it
is
also
the
duty
of
the
entire
citizenry
.
Without
the
support
of
the
entire
people
,
a
secure
,
orderly
,
and
peaceful
atmosphere
would
be
impossible
to
realize
.
We
should
be
grateful
that
the
capability
of
the
POLRI
in
deterring
and
takcling
threats
to
the
security
and
order
of
the
public
has
now
far
increased
.
Stage
by
stage
,
the
image
of
the
POLRI
as
officers
of
law
enforcement
and
public
security
and
order
guardian
is
increasingly
ameliorating
.
Nevertheless
,
the
POLRI
will
continue
to
face
challenges
that
are
not
light
in
tackling
the
various
forms
and
types
of
crimes
.
The
crimes
that
must
be
eradicated
are
not
only
transnational
in
nature
,
such
as
narcotics
,
terrorism
,
money
laundering
,
and
the
trafficking
in
persons
,
but
also
various
conventional
crimes
that
disturb
the
public
sense
of
peace
and
quiet
,
such
as
murders
,
gambling
,
armed
robbery
,
thefts
,
and
robberies
.
For
that
reason
,
the
government
has
adopted
a
programme
on
the
enhancement
of
the
professionalism
capability
of
POLRI
in
tackling
any
form
of
crime
,
so
that
the
public
can
enjoy
a
sense
of
safety
and
tranquility
.
We
also
record
much
progress
in
tackling
acts
of
terror
.
These
are
made
possible
due
to
the
alertness
of
the
security
apparatus
,
the
support
of
the
society
,
and
enhancement
of
the
international
cooperation
.
I
would
like
to
express
my
deepest
gratitude
and
appreciation
to
all
the
citizens
,
who
have
supported
the
tackling
of
any
threat
of
terror
acts
,
which
have
threatened
the
safety
of
humans
and
properties
.
During
the
course
of
2006
,
we
are
grateful
since
our
country
did
not
experience
terror
attack
.
However
,
this
growing
conducive
situation
should
not
make
us
become
complacent
and
less
vigilant
.
The
police
apparatus
have
succeeded
in
dismantling
the
network
and
disabled
the
terror
activities
of
Dr
.
Azhary
.
Nonetheless
,
the
terrorist
group
headed
by
Nurdin
Mohammad
Top
----
who
until
now
has
not
been
arrested
---
still
continues
to
carry
out
his
activities
.
The
security
apparatus
continue
to
work
hard
to
eradicate
terrorism
in
the
homeland
.
However
,
I
would
like
to
reaffirm
the
stance
of
the
Government
that
the
efforts
to
combat
terrorism
still
adhere
to
the
principles
of
law
and
respect
for
human
rights
.
The
eradication
of
terrorism
has
no
relation
with
any
particular
religion
or
identity
,
since
in
reality
,
in
this
world
,
crime
and
terrorism
are
committed
by
groups
with
varying
religions
and
identities
.
Honourable
Speaker
,
Deputy
Speakers
,
and
Members
of
the
House
of
Representatives
,
My
Fellow
Countrymen
,
The
development
of
our
nation
and
state
cannot
possibly
be
separated
from
the
effort
to
create
a
just
and
democratic
society
.
It
is
within
that
context
that
we
are
determined
to
develop
and
uphold
law
,
eradicate
corruption
,
and
solidify
the
consolidation
of
democracy
.
The
priority
of
the
Government
in
eradicating
the
criminal
act
of
corruption
has
at
the
very
least
bore
fruit
.
By
accelerating
their
eradication
,
it
has
now
step
by
step
started
to
emerge
a
culture
of
fear
of
committing
corruption
.
This
momentum
is
very
crucial
to
be
maintained
and
nurtured
,
in
order
to
prevent
the
emergence
of
new
cases
of
criminal
acts
of
corruption
.
In
addition
to
maintaining
that
momentum
,
the
Government
also
continues
to
enhance
the
capability
of
the
legal
enforcement
apparatus
to
solve
cases
of
criminal
acts
of
corruption
that
have
occurred
.
The
Government
has
succeeded
in
realizing
a
synergy
with
the
Corruption
Eradication
Commission
(
KPK
)
----
as
an
independent
entity
outside
of
the
Government
----
in
tackling
corruption
.
With
regard
to
the
cracking
down
of
perpetrators
of
the
criminal
acts
of
corruption
,
we
can
,
at
the
present
,
follow
together
the
legal
process
of
various
cases
of
corruption
that
have
and
are
being
tried
by
Courts
for
the
Criminal
Acts
of
Corruption
,
as
well
as
by
the
general
judiciary
.
The
Coordinating
Team
for
the
Eradication
of
the
Criminal
Acts
of
Corruption
(
Tim
Tas
Tipikor
)
,
which
was
established
in
early
2005
,
has
also
taken
firm
measures
in
solving
cases
of
corruption
.
In
tackling
various
cases
of
corruption
,
the
Government
remains
steadfast
in
its
stance
of
no
compromise
.
There
shall
never
be
the
term
“
pick
and
choose
”
in
cracking
down
the
perpetrators
of
corruption
,
especially
corruption
on
a
large
scale
that
has
clearly
inflicted
losses
to
the
state
finances
and
brought
misery
to
the
people
.
I
realize
that
,
in
consequence
of
that
resolute
attitude
,
there
has
emerged
a
sense
of
worry
,
and
even
excessive
fear
some
quarters
of
the
decision
makers
and
the
executing
apparatus
on
the
ground
.
I
wish
to
reaffirm
that
such
worry
and
fear
need
not
exist
,
in
so
far
as
one
acts
in
compliance
to
the
prevailing
procedures
and
regulations
.
On
the
other
hand
,
the
legal
enforcement
apparatus
must
act
cautiously
in
receiving
and
assessing
every
report
,
so
as
not
to
take
the
wrong
action
.
We
must
prevent
the
emergence
of
slander
and
the
tarnishing
of
the
good
name
of
others
,
which
could
degrade
the
dignity
of
someone
who
may
not
be
necessarily
guilty
.
I
have
also
instructed
so
that
the
coordination
of
legal
enforcement
is
truly
conducted
well
,
so
as
to
avoid
examination
of
the
same
case
over
and
over
again
by
various
institutions
,
which
disturb
the
work
and
business
effectiveness
.
In
order
to
strengthen
our
commitment
in
eradicating
corruption
,
and
in
the
context
of
improving
the
image
of
our
nation
and
state
in
the
eyes
of
the
international
community
,
we
have
ratified
the
United
Nations
Convention
Against
Corruption
.
We
also
continue
to
increase
regional
and
international
cooperation
in
tackling
the
criminal
act
of
corruption
.
The
effort
to
eradicate
corruption
will
not
succeed
without
preventive
measures
,
especially
reorganizing
the
bureaucracy
,
and
improvement
of
the
salary
of
our
bureaucratic
apparatus
.
This
measure
has
been
and
will
continue
to
be
undertaken
.
The
improvement
of
our
bureaucratic
system
is
conducted
by
giving
more
orientation
to
the
achievement
and
performance
.
This
reform
is
in
parallel
with
the
reform
of
the
system
of
state
financial
management
,
as
provided
for
in
Law
Number
17
of
2004
.
The
reform
of
the
bureaucracy
will
be
conducted
comprehensively
,
be
it
from
the
aspects
of
its
institution
,
organization
,
management
,
as
well
as
its
human
resource
.
Steps
toward
that
direction
have
been
initiated
by
formulating
three
Bills
,
namely
:
(
1
)
Bill
on
Public
Service
;
(
2
)
Bill
on
State
Administration
;
and
(
4
)
Bill
on
the
Ethics
of
State
Officials
.
Those
three
Bills
have
been
incorporated
into
the
National
Legislation
Programme
(
Prolegnas
)
and
will
be
immediately
submitted
to
the
DPR
-
RI
for
deliberations
in
the
forthcoming
2007
year
.
Another
problem
in
law
enforcement
that
continues
to
preoccupy
the
attention
of
the
Government
is
the
trafficking
and
abuse
of
narcotics
and
dangerous
substances
(
narkoba
)
or
narcotics
crimes
.
Narcotics
crimes
continue
to
pose
threats
to
the
survival
of
future
generations
of
the
nation
.
Notwithstanding
that
the
combat
against
narcotics
have
been
waged
incessantly
,
acts
of
narcotics
crimes
continue
to
develop
.
This
year
the
police
have
succeeded
in
uncovering
a
number
of
factories
that
produce
narcotics
and
other
dangerous
substances
in
huge
quantities
.
My
Fellow
Countrymen
,
The
development
in
the
legal
field
is
closely
related
to
our
mutual
commitment
to
uphold
human
rights
.
We
should
be
grateful
that
,
due
to
our
common
endeavour
,
legal
norms
that
are
related
to
human
rights
,
have
become
more
complete
.
We
have
completed
the
ratification
of
the
International
Covenant
on
Civil
and
Political
Rights
and
the
International
Covenant
on
Economic
,
Social
and
Cultural
Rights
.
We
have
endeavoured
with
resolute
determination
to
promote
,
protect
,
and
respect
human
rights
.
Praise
be
to
God
,
within
the
time
frame
of
the
last
two
years
,
in
our
country
,
no
cases
that
could
be
categorized
as
constituting
gross
violations
of
human
rights
occurred
.
This
favourable
condition
shall
continue
to
be
maintained
and
preserved
.
We
shall
also
continue
with
the
establishment
of
the
Commission
on
Truth
and
Reconciliation
,
so
that
it
can
become
a
vehicle
to
settle
the
various
alleged
cases
of
gross
violations
of
human
rights
,
aside
from
the
existence
of
the
available
human
rights
Tribunals
.
Meanwhile
the
resolution
on
the
alleged
cases
of
gross
violations
of
human
rights
,
prior
to
and
after
the
popular
consultation
in
East
Timor
in
1999
has
been
mutually
agreed
by
the
Government
of
Indonesia
and
Timor
Leste
to
be
settled
through
the
Commission
on
Truth
and
Friendship
.
It
is
expected
that
in
the
time
frame
that
has
been
determined
,
the
commission
will
report
on
the
results
it
has
achieved
.
The
improving
human
rights
condition
in
the
homeland
is
reflected
in
the
election
of
Indonesia
as
Chair
of
the
Commission
on
Human
Rights
of
the
United
Nations
(
U
.
N
.
)
last
year
.
Indonesia
has
also
been
elected
as
a
member
of
the
newly
established
U
.
N
.
Human
Rights
Council
.
I
am
gratified
to
witness
the
development
of
our
society
that
develops
more
democratic
.
The
right
of
every
individual
to
express
his
or
her
opion
has
been
guaranteed
by
law
,
and
in
reality
,
has
been
exercised
.
It
is
equally
true
for
the
right
of
every
individual
or
group
of
people
to
convey
their
aspirations
through
a
peaceful
rally
.
Our
press
has
developed
into
one
that
is
free
to
cover
stories
,
store
and
broadcast
news
.
However
,
we
all
realize
that
press
freedom
is
not
without
borders
.
Press
freedom
must
still
be
exercised
by
respecting
human
rights
and
by
complying
with
the
prevailing
legal
provisions
.
The
government
welcomes
the
functioning
of
state
institutions
as
regulated
in
our
Constitution
.
Relations
between
the
Government
and
other
state
institutions
proceed
healthily
and
constructively
.
The
Government
is
grateful
to
the
House
of
Representatives
that
have
succeeded
in
building
appropriate
and
responsible
relations
,
in
accordance
with
the
mandate
of
the
law
.
Let
us
hope
this
type
of
relations
could
continue
to
be
maintained
,
so
that
the
duties
to
meet
the
interests
of
the
people
can
be
performed
well
.
One
of
the
state
institutions
stipulated
in
the
Constitution
,
which
until
now
has
not
been
established
,
is
the
Presidential
Advisory
Board
.
I
am
of
the
hope
that
,
in
the
not
too
distant
future
,
the
House
and
the
Government
can
formulate
the
Bill
to
establish
that
board
,
as
agreed
to
in
the
national
legislation
programme
.
The
democratisation
process
in
the
body
of
the
government
is
now
increasingly
reflected
in
the
election
of
every
Regional
Head
.
In
line
with
provisions
of
Law
Number
32
of
2004
,
the
Elections
of
the
Regional
Heads
(
Pilkada
)
are
conducted
in
a
direct
manner
by
those
who
are
eligible
to
vote
.
From
June
2005
until
June
2006
,
257
Pilkadas
have
been
conducted
all
over
the
homeland
.
Those
elections
have
in
general
been
conducted
safely
,
peacefully
,
and
democratically
.
The
Central
Government
has
truly
taken
a
neutral
stance
with
regard
to
the
process
of
each
election
.
Those
parties
who
are
dissatisfied
with
the
results
of
the
elections
have
taken
the
legal
recourse
through
the
judicial
process
.
The
people
have
grown
more
aware
that
undemocratic
means
and
extrajudicial
avenues
are
unacceptable
means
.
The
conduct
of
the
Pilkadas
,
which
in
general
proceeded
smoothly
,
demonstrates
the
strengthening
of
the
domestic
political
stability
.
Such
an
atmosphere
further
encourages
the
consolidation
of
the
implementation
of
regional
autonomy
as
mandated
by
the
Constitution
and
Law
Number
32
of
2004
.
In
conformity
with
the
mandate
of
the
Reform
,
we
no
longer
want
our
government
to
be
centralistic
.
For
that
reason
,
the
autonomous
regions
can
now
at
their
own
discretion
manage
their
resources
in
the
regions
under
their
authority
.
The
regions
have
also
conducted
governance
and
provide
public
services
in
a
better
manner
,
compared
to
the
previous
times
.
With
regard
to
the
foreign
policy
,
I
would
like
to
expound
that
the
Government
remain
consistent
in
implementing
the
foreign
policy
orientation
that
is
free
and
active
.
Every
step
in
our
foreign
policy
is
undertaken
by
advancing
---
and
we
dedicate
it
to
---
the
national
interests
.
The
strengthening
domestic
political
,
social
,
and
economic
situation
has
encouraged
us
to
further
activate
our
role
in
the
regional
and
global
political
arena
.
We
continue
to
play
an
active
role
in
the
process
of
regional
integration
towards
the
achievement
of
the
ASEAN
Community
in
2020
,
and
a
closer
cooperation
between
countries
in
East
Asia
.
Our
success
in
convening
the
Asia
Africa
Summit
in
the
past
2005
has
elevated
the
stature
of
our
nation
and
state
to
a
global
level
.
For
that
reason
,
we
are
beginning
to
play
a
more
active
role
in
the
establishment
of
world
peace
,
as
mandated
by
the
Preamble
to
the
Constitution
,
such
as
in
handling
the
Iranian
nuclear
case
,
the
effort
to
reduce
the
tension
on
the
Korean
Peninsula
,
and
our
proactive
measures
to
support
the
establishment
of
peace
in
the
Middle
East
.
We
remain
consistent
in
supporting
the
struggle
of
the
Palestinian
people
to
realize
a
Palestinian
State
that
is
independent
and
sovereign
.
In
the
face
of
the
deteriorating
situation
in
the
Middle
East
lately
,
we
have
taken
proactive
measures
to
end
the
Israeli
aggression
on
Lebanon
.
We
,
together
with
Malaysia
,
have
proposed
the
convening
of
the
Emergency
Summit
of
the
OIC
in
Kuala
Lumpur
,
which
has
produced
a
declaration
urging
the
UN
to
immediately
end
the
conflict
in
Lebanon
.
For
that
reason
,
we
welcome
the
adoption
of
resolution
of
the
Security
Council
number
1701
on
the
past
12
August
,
which
intends
to
cease
hostilities
,
and
reactivate
the
peace
process
in
the
region
.
As
a
form
of
our
commitment
,
we
have
stated
our
readiness
to
join
with
the
U
.
N
.
Peacekeeping
force
,
in
order
to
protect
the
Palestinian
and
Lebanese
peoples
from
Israeli
attacks
.
In
the
face
of
the
situation
in
Iraq
,
we
support
the
process
of
transition
in
Iraq
,
so
that
the
Iraki
people
can
regain
their
rights
and
sovereignty
to
manage
and
build
their
country
.
The
Government
will
also
continue
to
enhance
international
cooperation
,
be
it
at
the
regional
as
well
as
global
levels
,
be
it
through
the
ASEAN
forum
,
as
well
as
other
fora
,
such
as
the
APEC
,
the
Non
-
Aligned
Movement
,
and
the
Organization
of
the
Islamic
Conference
.
Honourable
Speaker
,
Deputy
Speakers
,
and
Members
of
the
House
of
Representatives
,
My
Fellow
Countrymen
,
In
the
context
of
social
welfare
development
,
we
are
on
the
path
toward
achieving
the
objectives
of
the
Millennium
Development
Goals
(
MDGs
)
in
2015
.
We
have
succeeded
in
reducing
the
level
of
poverty
from
23
,
4
percent
in
1999
to
16
percent
in
2005
.
Be
that
as
it
may
,
that
achievement
of
16
percent
is
still
far
from
the
objective
that
we
wish
to
achieve
.
The
alleviation
of
poverty
does
not
merely
require
high
economic
growth
,
but
it
also
necessitates
a
quality
of
growth
that
reaches
directly
to
the
betterment
of
the
plight
of
the
poor
people
.
We
must
ascertain
that
the
economic
growth
we
are
stiving
for
will
guarantee
the
realization
of
the
reduction
of
poverty
.
Our
development
will
be
in
vain
if
we
are
not
able
to
lift
our
people
from
the
abyss
of
poverty
and
backwardness
.
For
that
reason
,
the
Government
accords
high
priority
,
and
provide
for
a
substantially
large
budget
for
the
poor
people
so
that
they
have
the
opportunity
to
enjoy
education
,
improve
their
health
,
and
improve
the
quality
of
the
environment
.
We
have
carried
out
the
Programme
of
Cash
Assistance
Subsidy
during
one
year
to
to
19
.
2
million
poor
households
.
The
programme
that
we
conducted
in
such
a
short
time
,
as
a
measure
to
overcome
the
increase
in
the
price
of
Oil
-
Based
Fuel
(
BBM
)
,
has
succeeded
in
reducing
the
living
cost
burden
of
our
poorest
group
.
In
2006
,
the
Government
has
also
provided
the
School
Operational
Assistance
(
BOS
)
for
the
nine
-
year
basic
education
to
29
.
4
million
students
equivalent
to
SD
,
and
to
10
.
5
million
students
equivalent
to
the
junior
high
school
SMP
,
who
are
categorized
as
poor
.
At
the
senior
high
school
level
or
equivalent
to
the
SMA
,
scholarships
were
made
available
to
more
than
698
thousand
poor
students
.
The
number
of
SD
students
and
its
equivalent
reaches
41
million
.
Meanwhile
,
for
the
secondary
level
now
total
6
.
4
million
students
.
This
amount
has
surpassed
the
intended
target
for
the
2005
/
2006
school
year
.
Therefore
,
the
neglect
of
the
opportunity
to
have
an
education
,
especially
for
the
poor
people
,
step
by
step
has
been
overcome
.
The
Government
has
seriously
encouraged
and
opened
education
opportunities
for
every
child
in
our
country
.
Meanwhile
,
the
number
of
subdistricts
/
municipalities
that
have
succeeded
in
completing
the
9
-
year
compulsory
education
programme
at
the
end
of
2004
/
2005
has
reached
142
subdistricts
/
municipalities
.
This
figure
has
increased
from
77subdistricts
/
municipalities
at
the
end
of
2003
/
2004
.
In
parallel
to
the
strong
will
and
seriousness
of
the
Government
to
increase
the
budget
for
education
,
in
line
with
the
mandate
of
the
Constitution
and
the
Law
on
National
Education
System
,
the
revitalization
of
education
continue
to
be
conducted
to
further
increase
the
quality
of
education
.
In
this
context
,
we
must
be
grateful
that
in
August
of
this
year
,
our
best
students
succeeded
in
winning
28
gold
medals
in
various
international
competitions
in
the
fields
of
science
,
mathematics
,
arts
and
sports
.
Among
them
,
there
is
a
student
by
the
name
of
Jonathan
Pradana
Mailoa
,
who
earned
the
accolade
as
The
Absolute
Winner
in
the
2006
International
Physics
Olympiad
in
Singapore
.
This
success
has
broken
the
dominance
of
Chinese
students
,
and
defeated
his
competitors
from
the
United
States
,
Germany
,
and
Australia
.
Meanwhile
,
Rudolf
Surya
Bonay
,
a
student
from
Papua
,
succeeded
in
winning
The
First
Step
to
Nobel
Prize
in
the
field
of
Chemistry
.
The
successes
should
strengthen
the
conviction
on
the
capacity
of
our
young
generation
,
and
compel
all
of
us
to
work
harder
in
improving
the
quality
of
education
in
Indonesia
.
In
the
meantime
,
basic
health
services
for
the
poor
people
and
close
to
poor
until
2005
have
reached
60
million
people
.
The
equitable
distribution
of
health
services
is
carried
out
by
setting
up
Community
Health
Centres
(
Puskesmas
)
at
every
subdistrict
.
In
the
supply
of
medicines
and
health
equipment
,
the
availability
of
essential
generic
medicines
at
the
facilities
for
basic
health
services
reaches
80
-
100
percent
.
In
order
to
help
the
poor
people
,
the
Government
has
reduced
the
price
of
generic
medicines
between
30
to
50
percent
last
May
.
In
this
month
of
August
,
the
Government
,
once
again
,
reduces
the
price
of
1418
types
of
generic
medicines
between
60
to
80
percent
.
Starting
on
this
17
August
,
the
Government
will
stick
the
labels
of
generic
medicines
as
well
as
their
prices
for
sale
on
the
market
.
With
the
inexpensive
price
of
medicines
,
we
hope
that
our
people
will
be
more
able
to
afford
them
.
The
price
sticking
is
also
an
effort
to
guarantee
that
the
prices
of
medicines
are
not
under
the
mercy
of
speculators
.
The
Government
will
continue
to
increase
health
services
to
reach
all
layers
of
the
society
.
Health
counseling
activities
,
including
the
integrated
services
posts
(
Posyandu
)
,
have
started
to
be
reactivated
.
The
number
of
Posyandu
that
have
been
reactivated
has
now
reached
42
.
221
units
all
across
the
homeland
.
Honourable
Leadership
and
Members
of
the
DPR
and
ladies
and
gentlemen
,
Allow
me
,
Honourable
Speaker
,
to
shift
the
subject
and
speak
about
matters
related
to
the
economic
development
.
During
the
last
two
years
,
we
have
witnessed
the
dynamics
of
global
economic
development
that
provide
challenges
that
are
not
light
to
the
management
of
our
economy
.
The
tendency
of
the
high
price
of
oil
and
the
imposition
of
relatively
tight
monetary
policies
in
several
developed
countries
,
particularly
in
the
United
States
and
the
European
Union
,
have
impacted
on
the
national
economy
.
The
coordination
between
the
Bank
of
Indonesia
and
the
Government
in
the
management
of
the
macro
economic
policies
has
further
ameliorated
.
This
is
demonstrated
by
the
success
in
maintaining
economic
stability
,
which
is
a
prerequisite
for
sustained
economic
growth
.
Sustained
economic
stability
has
increased
the
trust
of
the
businesspeople
,
as
reflected
in
the
entry
of
portfolio
investments
that
has
stimulated
the
improvement
of
our
balance
of
payment
and
strengthened
our
foreign
exchange
reserves
.
In
spite
of
that
,
short
-
term
capital
flows
must
be
managed
prudently
and
wisely
,
for
they
are
vulnerable
to
sentiments
that
may
cause
economic
fluctuations
.
The
Government
and
the
Bank
of
Indonesia
will
continue
to
endeavour
to
perfect
the
policies
,
mechanisms
,
regulations
,
instruments
,
and
the
quality
of
the
economic
institutions
and
the
financial
industry
,
such
as
,
among
others
,
stipulated
in
the
package
of
policy
reform
in
the
financial
sector
.
This
measure
is
necessary
so
that
our
economy
has
a
growing
elasticity
and
resistance
to
fluctuations
and
uncertainties
.
This
measure
is
also
in
line
with
the
medium
-
and
long
-
term
efforts
to
increase
direct
investment
,
which
is
crucial
to
creating
employment
opportunities
and
reduce
poverty
,
and
strengthening
our
capital
account
and
foreign
exchange
reserves
.
After
accelerating
the
debt
servicing
to
the
IMF
in
June
of
this
year
amounting
to
US
$
3
.
8
billion
,
the
position
of
our
foreign
exchange
reserves
is
estimated
to
reach
around
US
$
43
billion
at
the
end
of
2006
,
an
increase
of
24
percent
from
US
$
34
.
7
billion
in
2005
.
The
improving
performance
of
the
balance
of
payments
,
be
it
from
the
goods
flow
as
well
as
capital
flow
,
and
the
strengthening
position
of
our
foreign
exchange
reserves
in
2006
,
have
strengthened
the
exchange
rate
of
the
rupiah
to
the
United
States
dollar
,
with
a
relatively
under
control
fluctuation
.
Be
that
as
it
may
,
we
still
need
to
be
on
the
alert
to
the
possibility
of
the
occurrence
of
a
dynamic
shift
in
the
exchange
rate
of
global
currencies
,
as
a
result
of
the
adjustment
to
the
global
imbalances
.
The
stability
of
the
Rupiah
exchange
rate
has
supported
our
effort
to
decrease
the
inflation
to
a
lower
level
.
Up
to
July
2006
,
the
inflation
rate
amounted
to
3
.
3
percent
,
far
lower
compared
to
the
same
period
in
the
previous
year
that
recorded
5
.
9
percent
.
As
a
whole
,
the
inflation
target
of
8
.
0
percent
in
2006
is
projected
to
be
achievable
.
In
line
with
the
decrease
of
the
inflation
rate
,
and
while
still
observing
the
development
of
international
interest
rates
,
the
Bank
of
Indonesia
is
starting
to
decrease
its
interest
rate
in
a
prudent
manner
.
That
decrease
is
expected
to
spur
the
growth
of
investment
through
the
improvement
of
banking
intermediation
,
restoring
market
trust
,
and
decreasing
loan
costs
.
The
inflation
and
interest
rate
decrease
will
also
lower
the
burden
for
bonds
interests
within
the
State
Budget
.
Even
though
the
macro
economic
performance
demonstrates
quite
a
meaningful
improvement
,
the
Government
is
fully
conscious
that
the
effort
to
ameliorate
the
welfare
of
the
people
has
yet
to
reach
a
level
that
is
expected
.
The
dimension
of
the
problem
that
is
being
faced
is
indeed
highly
complex
.
The
economic
growth
of
2005
reached
the
figure
of
5
.
6
percent
,
even
though
we
expected
it
could
reach
6
percent
.
The
tendency
of
the
weakening
of
the
economy
was
still
apparent
at
the
first
trimester
of
this
year
,
even
though
we
started
to
see
a
positive
downturn
direction
at
the
second
trimester
.
The
Government
wil
continue
to
tackle
this
weakening
of
the
economy
through
a
measured
fiscal
expansion
,
monetary
slackening
from
the
Bank
of
Indonesia
,
and
the
implementation
of
other
structural
policies
,
such
as
the
packages
for
the
improvement
of
the
investment
climate
,
acceleration
of
infrastructure
development
,
and
reform
of
the
financial
sector
.
The
economic
growth
in
the
first
trimester
of
2006
was
recorded
at
4
.
7
percent
.
In
the
second
trimester
,
the
economic
growth
showed
signs
of
increase
and
was
recorded
at
5
.
2
percent
,
a
figure
higher
than
anyone
projected
.
As
a
whole
,
the
economic
growth
in
the
first
semester
of
2006
reached
almost
5
percent
.
The
improvement
of
economic
growth
in
the
second
trimester
is
expected
to
augur
the
early
signs
of
consolidation
and
strengthening
of
economic
activities
that
will
be
more
stable
in
the
second
semester
of
2006
,
thereby
building
a
more
robust
fundamental
for
higher
economic
growth
in
the
following
years
.
As
I
have
mentioned
earlier
,
poverty
alleviation
constitutes
an
inseparable
package
with
the
effort
to
create
employment
opportunities
,
which
has
become
the
main
focus
of
the
economic
policy
of
the
Government
.
The
Government
has
and
will
continue
to
perfect
and
synergise
the
programme
for
the
creation
of
employment
opportunities
with
various
strategic
programmes
in
the
fields
of
the
diversification
of
energy
,
development
of
rural
infrastructures
,
and
programmes
of
housing
development
.
The
figure
for
unemployment
has
started
to
decrease
from
11
.
2
percent
in
November
2005
to
10
.
4
percent
at
the
start
of
2006
.
This
decrease
of
the
level
of
unemployment
occurs
for
the
very
first
time
,
after
in
these
last
few
years
experiencing
an
increase
.
Nonetheless
,
that
level
of
unemployment
is
still
high
and
impacted
negatively
,
be
it
from
the
economic
as
well
as
social
aspects
.
The
reduction
of
unemployment
has
indeed
become
our
common
commitment
in
the
context
of
fulfilling
the
mandate
of
the
Constitution
.
Our
ability
to
reduce
the
level
of
unemployment
will
be
determined
by
whether
we
are
able
to
formulate
and
adopt
policies
that
are
appropriate
and
of
quality
,
and
implement
them
consistently
and
timely
,
by
taking
advantage
of
all
the
momentum
that
we
have
.
I
am
of
the
fervent
hope
that
the
House
of
Representatives
and
the
Government
can
build
more
synergistic
and
constructive
cooperation
to
enable
the
formulation
of
policies
that
are
vital
to
the
improvement
of
the
investment
climate
.
Therefore
,
investment
will
grow
,
and
employment
opportunities
will
become
more
open
as
well
.
The
various
Bills
that
will
be
and
are
currently
being
deliberated
with
the
DPR
in
the
areas
of
investment
,
taxation
,
customs
,
excise
,
and
others
,
are
crucial
to
the
improvement
of
our
economic
performance
.
I
hope
the
House
could
give
priority
to
the
deliberation
of
all
of
these
bills
,
so
that
we
can
adopt
them
together
.
Honourable
Leadership
and
Members
of
the
House
,
My
Fellow
Countrymen
,
The
time
has
now
come
for
me
to
convey
the
salient
elements
related
to
the
formulation
of
the
2007
Draft
State
Budget
.
By
taking
into
consideration
the
developments
in
the
domestic
and
international
economic
environment
,
and
the
national
objectives
that
we
wish
to
achieve
,
I
wish
to
propose
to
the
House
the
2007
Draft
State
Budget
(
RAPBN
)
,
based
on
the
following
basic
assumptions
:
economic
growth
at
6
.
3
percent
,
inflation
at
6
.
5
percent
,
the
3
-
month
SBI
interest
rate
at
8
.
5
percent
,
an
exchange
rate
of
Rp
9
,
300
to
the
US
Dollar
,
an
oil
price
of
US
$
65
per
barrel
,
and
an
oil
lifting
of
1million
barrel
per
day
.
The
programmes
and
budgeting
of
the
2007
Draft
State
Budget
is
drafted
based
on
the
2007
Government
Work
Plan
(
RKP
)
that
is
focused
on
Increasing
Employment
Opportunities
and
Alleviating
Poverty
in
the
Framework
of
Improving
the
People
’
s
Welfare
.
The
2007
Government
Work
Plan
designates
nine
work
programme
priorities
,
namely
:
first
,
alleviating
poverty
.
Second
,
increasing
employment
opportunities
,
investments
,
and
exports
.
Third
,
revitalizing
agriculture
,
fisheries
,
forestry
,
and
the
rural
sectors
.
Fourth
,
increasing
the
accessibility
to
and
quality
of
the
education
and
health
.
Fifth
,
upholding
the
law
and
human
rights
,
eradicating
corruption
,
and
reforming
the
bureaucracy
.
Sixth
,
strengthening
the
defence
capability
,
solidifying
security
and
order
,
and
settling
conflicts
.
Seventh
,
rehabilitating
and
reconstructing
Nanggroe
Aceh
Darussalam
(
NAD
)
,
Nias
,
the
Yogyakarta
Special
Region
and
Central
Java
,
and
mitigating
disasters
.
Eighth
,
accelerating
the
building
of
infrastructures
,
and
ninth
,
developing
border
regions
and
isolated
areas
.
As
I
have
mentioned
earlier
,
in
order
to
reduce
the
poverty
level
,
in
accordance
with
the
middle
-
term
target
until
the
end
of
2009
,
we
not
only
need
quite
a
high
economic
growth
but
we
also
have
to
make
sure
that
the
economic
growth
will
veritably
give
direct
benefits
to
the
poor
people
.
We
aspire
for
growth
coupled
with
equitable
distribution
.
This
endeavour
is
elaborated
in
the
form
of
special
programmes
that
is
expanding
and
integrating
poverty
alleviation
programmes
of
community
participation
-
based
in
the
rural
and
urban
areas
.
Until
2006
,
this
programme
has
covered
39
,
282
villages
/
subdistricts
out
of
69
,
929
villages
/
subdistricts
,
which
covered
2
,
600
subdistricts
,
or
46
percent
of
the
5
,
623
subdistricts
present
all
over
the
homeland
.
This
expansion
will
be
carried
out
gradually
,
it
is
,
therefore
,
expected
that
by
2009
all
subdistricts
would
have
been
reached
by
this
programme
.
The
benefit
of
this
programme
,
in
addition
to
increasing
employment
opportunities
and
increasing
the
income
of
poor
families
,
it
also
improves
infrastructures
and
public
utilities
at
the
village
and
subdistrict
levels
.
Should
all
of
these
programmes
proceed
according
to
plan
,
then
,
the
acceleration
of
economic
growth
and
the
effort
to
improve
the
distribution
of
the
people
’
s
revenue
could
be
achieved
.
Furthermore
,
this
programme
also
cultivates
a
social
capital
,
such
as
the
participation
and
mutual
cooperation
of
the
community
in
the
process
of
development
.
This
social
capital
is
vitally
important
in
sustaining
the
feeling
of
togetherness
,
and
is
expected
to
be
able
to
prevent
the
potential
of
tensions
and
conflicts
between
community
groups
.
The
government
will
continue
to
perfect
the
system
of
protection
for
poor
families
.
As
I
have
previously
explained
,
since
2005
,
as
a
result
of
economizing
from
the
Oil
-
Based
Fuel
(
BBM
)
subsidy
,
we
have
succeeded
in
introducing
programmes
that
directly
touch
the
poor
people
,
for
instance
,
the
health
insurance
system
for
poor
households
and
the
Cash
Direct
Subsidy
(
SLT
)
,
the
School
Operational
Assistance
or
BOS
,
and
the
rural
infrastructure
development
.
These
programmes
are
going
to
be
continued
in
2007
with
some
improvement
,
such
as
the
Conditional
Cash
Direct
Assistance
to
support
the
improvement
of
access
to
education
and
health
for
poor
families
,
and
labour
-
intensive
programmes
at
the
village
level
that
can
create
employment
opportunities
.
The
improvement
of
the
people
’
s
welfare
cannot
be
separated
from
the
performance
of
the
agriculture
and
rural
economy
sectors
and
the
food
resilience
.
In
consequence
,
the
Government
has
launched
the
Agriculture
,
Fisheries
,
and
Forestry
Revitalization
Programme
(
RPPK
)
.
The
suggestion
of
the
DPR
to
integrate
agricultural
subsidies
will
be
immediately
initiated
in
the
2007
fiscal
year
.
The
programme
to
improve
the
integrated
agricultural
subsidy
system
,
seen
from
the
aspects
of
its
effectiveness
and
efficiency
,
we
realize
,
is
quite
a
complicated
programme
.
The
impact
of
this
integration
will
only
be
felt
in
the
following
years
.
Honourable
Leadership
and
Members
of
the
House
,
Ladies
and
Gentlemen
,
Presently
,
Honourable
Speaker
,
I
would
like
to
shift
to
speak
about
the
energy
matter
,
and
various
issues
in
our
national
economic
development
.
The
energy
subject
has
become
a
vital
and
strategic
issue
,
either
at
the
national
or
international
level
.
Since
last
year
,
the
government
has
launched
a
comprehensive
national
energy
policy
,
be
it
in
relation
to
the
increase
of
the
production
side
,
the
diversification
of
the
demand
side
,
as
well
as
the
increasingly
realistic
price
policy
.
The
development
of
alternative
energies
has
become
an
important
option
,
not
only
to
reduce
dependence
on
BBM
,
which
price
keeps
on
soaring
,
but
at
the
same
time
also
to
solve
the
problems
of
poverty
and
unemployment
,
and
improve
the
environment
.
The
dependence
on
BBM
as
the
main
source
of
energy
also
puts
at
risk
the
state
finances
,
in
no
small
measure
,
with
the
swelling
subsidy
.
Our
country
possesses
various
sources
of
alternative
energy
in
quite
a
large
amount
,
such
as
gas
,
coal
,
hydropower
,
geothermal
,
solar
power
,
and
the
like
.
The
investment
in
this
field
still
needs
to
be
developed
.
The
Government
could
not
possibly
,
by
itself
,
make
investment
in
this
field
,
considering
its
quite
high
cost
.
That
is
the
reason
why
the
Government
encourages
the
private
sector
,
domestic
and
foreign
,
to
actively
invest
in
this
field
of
alternative
energy
.
The
Government
is
also
drawing
up
measures
for
the
development
of
alternative
energy
that
is
vegetable
-
based
or
biofuel
.
This
National
Programme
has
been
set
in
motion
this
year
with
the
development
of
energy
with
the
basic
materials
of
palm
oil
,
sugarcane
,
cassava
,
and
castor
oil
plant
.
For
certain
regions
,
especially
those
that
are
remote
and
underdeveloped
,
we
will
carry
out
a
program
of
energy
-
independent
villages
,
based
on
castor
oil
plant
.
Therefore
,
those
villages
are
expected
to
be
able
to
meet
their
energy
needs
,
without
having
to
depend
on
diesel
fuel
and
kerosene
.
In
the
medium
term
,
this
energy
policy
is
anticipated
to
be
able
to
create
new
employment
opportunities
for
around
3
to
5
million
persons
.
In
this
manner
,
this
measure
will
also
reduce
the
figure
of
unemployment
and
poverty
,
as
well
as
reducing
BBM
subsidy
in
a
significant
way
.
In
order
to
accelerate
economic
growth
and
open
employment
opportunities
,
the
Government
deems
it
necessary
to
bring
about
an
improvement
of
the
investment
climate
.
We
should
not
be
left
behind
other
countries
,
especially
other
Asian
countries
,
in
attracting
investment
.
The
improvement
of
the
investment
climate
has
been
initiated
by
issuing
the
investment
policy
package
in
February
2006
.
The
package
is
intended
to
reduce
business
costs
and
improve
business
certainty
through
improvement
of
the
regulation
,
services
,
and
simplification
of
procedures
and
bureaucracy
.
The
taxation
reform
plays
a
key
role
in
the
improvement
of
the
investment
climate
.
The
effort
to
perfect
the
system
of
taxation
administration
,
among
others
,
are
the
improvement
of
the
services
functions
,
including
improvement
of
the
management
at
tax
offices
,
simplification
of
the
Annual
Notification
Letter
,
intensification
of
compliance
and
supervision
,
and
also
the
modernization
of
the
supporting
function
.
In
order
to
carry
out
a
more
comprehensive
taxation
reform
,
I
hope
that
we
can
immediately
conclude
deliberations
over
three
Bills
on
Taxation
,
namely
the
General
Rules
for
Taxation
and
Procedures
for
Taxation
,
Income
Tax
,
and
Value
Added
Tax
for
Goods
and
Services
,
and
Sales
Tax
on
Luxury
Items
.
Within
these
three
Bills
are
stipulated
provisions
on
reducing
tax
burden
,
improving
compliance
and
more
equitable
treatment
between
taxpayers
and
tax
officers
.
With
respect
to
the
granting
of
incentives
,
the
government
will
soon
issue
a
Government
Regulation
to
boost
investment
,
by
providing
tax
facilities
to
certain
sectors
and
regions
.
The
government
is
also
finalizing
the
VAT
exemption
facility
for
primary
agricultural
products
,
so
that
they
will
have
stronger
competitiveness
.
In
the
framework
of
improving
the
competitiveness
of
domestic
leading
industrial
products
,
the
Government
has
carried
out
the
effort
to
simplify
the
procedures
and
facilities
for
exports
and
imports
,
and
harmonizing
import
duty
tariffs
,
so
that
they
will
have
a
tariff
structure
and
procedures
that
are
simple
,
harmonious
,
low
,
and
uniform
by
2010
.
A
special
programme
designed
to
boost
investment
,
which
was
launched
at
the
beginning
of
2006
,
is
the
effort
to
develop
the
Special
Economic
Zones
(
KEK
)
.
This
zone
,
other
than
intended
to
promote
area
growth
,
is
also
expected
to
be
able
to
attract
investment
to
those
areas
.
With
the
existence
of
the
Special
Economic
Zones
,
it
is
expected
that
they
will
open
new
employment
opportunities
for
the
surrounding
community
.
The
commitment
of
the
regions
to
cut
their
bureaucracies
down
,
eliminate
retributions
that
burden
business
activities
,
provide
and
secure
land
that
is
appropriate
and
the
full
support
of
the
Regional
Administrations
form
the
key
to
the
success
of
the
Special
Economic
Zones
.
The
acceleration
in
the
development
of
infrastructures
constitutes
a
prerequisite
for
high
and
sustained
economic
growth
.
Through
Presidential
Regulation
Number
67
of
2005
,
the
Government
is
preparing
measures
to
accelerate
the
development
of
infrastructures
,
especially
power
plants
,
highways
,
airports
,
railways
,
harbours
,
and
telecommunication
.
The
lack
of
electricity
supply
,
the
limited
telecommunication
network
,
and
the
deteriorating
quality
of
the
street
and
traffic
congestion
have
hampered
the
progress
of
business
,
and
decreased
the
competitiveness
of
our
economy
.
Mindful
of
the
limited
government
resources
in
financing
the
development
,
it
is
then
necessary
to
heighten
private
participation
through
partnership
,
mainly
in
financing
the
infrastructure
supply
.
The
support
of
the
Government
in
infrastructure
financing
and
risk
sharing
is
evidenced
in
the
supply
of
risk
sharing
fund
and
the
initial
capital
in
investment
fund
for
the
infrastructure
sector
,
as
allocated
in
the
Revised
2006
State
Budget
(
APBN
-
P
)
and
the
2007
Bill
on
the
State
Budget
(
RAPBN
)
.
Cooperation
projects
between
the
public
and
private
sectors
have
started
to
be
put
in
operation
,
be
it
at
the
construction
stage
as
well
as
in
the
preparation
for
tender
.
The
Government
expects
the
intensity
of
transaction
implementation
for
the
public
-
private
cooperation
projects
will
start
to
increase
from
2007
.
In
relation
to
the
improvement
of
simple
and
healthy
housings
,
the
government
has
also
carried
out
an
improvement
of
the
regulation
and
has
established
the
Housing
Financing
or
Secondary
Mortgage
Facility
,
which
capital
participation
has
been
included
in
the
past
2005
State
Budget
.
With
the
said
facility
,
it
is
expected
that
the
housing
financing
availability
will
continue
to
increase
.
Honourable
Speaker
,
Members
of
the
House
,
and
Ladies
and
Gentlemen
,
The
fiscal
policy
for
2007
is
formulated
in
conformity
with
the
aforementioned
various
programmes
and
priorities
.
The
fiscal
policy
strategy
is
still
conducted
within
the
context
of
two
principal
corridors
,
namely
:
first
,
fiscal
consolidation
through
budget
deficit
control
at
the
right
level
to
maintain
an
equilibrium
between
creating
the
space
for
the
need
for
economic
development
and
creating
employment
opportunities
,
yet
,
still
within
the
boundaries
of
financing
sources
that
are
safe
and
sustainable
.
Second
,
formulating
a
budget
financing
strategy
,
so
as
to
result
in
a
decrease
of
the
burden
and
as
minimal
a
risk
of
government
debt
as
possible
.
In
that
connection
,
the
planned
expenditures
support
in
the
2007
Draft
State
Budget
is
as
follows
:
First
,
in
order
to
improve
the
people
’
s
welfare
,
expenditures
for
the
health
sector
will
be
increased
from
Rp
.
13
.
5
trillion
in
2006
to
Rp
.
15
.
1
trillion
.
An
increase
in
the
health
budget
is
highly
required
to
improve
the
quality
of
health
,
the
services
,
and
to
equitably
provide
health
services
.
In
the
context
of
overcoming
the
increase
in
the
spread
of
contagious
diseases
,
especially
avian
influenza
,
active
surveillance
efforts
have
been
carried
out
.
In
addition
,
the
government
has
also
strengthened
the
capability
of
regional
laboratories
,
the
supply
of
anti
-
virus
medicines
,
and
the
supply
of
protection
equipment
.
The
budget
allocation
for
education
also
experiences
a
significant
increase
.
At
the
present
time
,
the
expenditure
of
the
government
for
education
---
by
using
a
large
definition
---
has
reached
4
.
1
percent
of
the
GDP
,
which
is
still
below
the
international
average
of
5
percent
.
I
am
convinced
that
,
through
determined
efforts
,
the
said
target
will
be
achieved
within
the
next
2
-
3
years
.
In
the
2007
Draft
State
Budget
,
the
government
proposes
an
education
budget
based
on
the
functional
approach
amounting
to
Rp
.
51
.
3
trillion
,
or
an
increase
of
18
.
5
percent
compared
to
the
2006
State
Budget
2006
,
which
amounted
to
43
.
3
trillion
.
The
said
expenditure
does
not
include
expenditure
for
the
salary
of
teachers
,
which
is
part
of
the
General
Allocation
Fund
(
DAU
)
and
the
Special
Allocation
Fund
(
DAK
)
for
the
education
sector
and
the
service
budget
.
The
Government
continues
to
seriously
endeavour
to
increase
the
budget
for
education
,
be
it
nominally
but
also
in
its
ratio
to
expenditure
of
the
central
government
,
with
a
view
to
meeting
the
mandate
of
the
Law
on
National
Education
System
.
The
Cash
Direct
Assistance
programme
or
BLT
will
be
modified
into
the
Conditional
BLT
.
This
Conditional
BLT
programme
is
to
be
linked
to
the
education
and
health
programmes
that
are
expected
to
be
launched
at
the
beginning
of
2007
,
and
tried
-
out
in
several
provinces
.
This
programme
will
utilize
a
budget
of
Rp
.
4
trillion
in
the
2007
Draft
State
Budget
.
The
2007
Draft
State
Budget
also
plans
to
give
and
channel
inexpensive
rice
for
around
15
.
8
million
poor
families
,
amounting
to
Rp
6
.
5
trillion
.
The
subsidy
for
the
price
of
fertilizers
amounts
to
Rp
5
.
8
trillion
,
and
the
Public
Services
Subsidy
(
PSO
)
for
State
-
Owned
Enterprises
(
BUMN
)
that
performs
the
duties
of
the
government
in
the
field
of
public
services
for
the
community
so
that
they
are
affordable
.
Second
,
improvement
of
the
investment
climate
.
The
support
of
the
State
Budget
to
improve
the
investment
climate
is
distributed
through
several
programmes
of
policy
reform
and
public
service
.
The
reforms
in
the
sectors
of
taxation
and
customs
receive
increased
budget
support
.
The
service
to
the
business
world
will
be
improved
through
bureaucratic
reform
with
quite
a
sufficient
budget
.
The
fund
allocation
to
the
regions
is
also
increasing
;
consequently
,
it
is
expected
that
all
sorts
of
fees
collected
in
the
regions
by
the
regional
administrations
will
diminish
.
Third
,
the
Government
allocates
quite
a
significant
budget
to
improve
the
physical
equipment
and
infrastructure
that
support
investment
.
The
development
of
the
physical
equipment
and
infrastructure
is
realised
in
the
form
of
increasing
the
capital
expenditures
,
which
will
be
used
for
investment
activities
in
the
equipment
and
infrastructure
for
the
development
.
The
said
increase
,
among
others
,
take
the
form
of
land
,
equipment
and
machines
,
buildings
and
constructions
,
networks
,
and
other
physical
capital
that
is
projected
at
around
Rp
.
66
,
1
trillion
or
an
increase
of
4
.
9
percent
from
the
budget
cap
of
last
year
.
In
the
framework
of
infrastructure
financing
through
partnership
programmes
,
as
I
have
touched
upon
earlier
,
in
2006
,
it
was
submitted
to
the
House
regarding
the
establishment
of
the
Infrastructure
Development
Fund
,
which
,
together
with
the
participation
of
international
institutions
and
the
private
sector
,
will
become
an
initial
fund
or
a
catalyst
for
the
acceleration
of
infrastructure
development
.
This
fund
,
aside
from
being
allocated
for
investment
,
especially
for
infrastructure
projects
,
will
also
be
utilized
for
risk
sharing
with
private
investors
.
In
the
2007
Draft
State
Budget
,
the
Government
proposes
a
funding
allocation
amounting
to
Rp
2
trillion
as
an
additional
fund
for
risk
sharing
and
as
capital
for
investment
expenditure
by
the
Government
.
Fourth
,
in
the
energy
policy
sector
,
it
will
be
directed
to
utilize
oil
substitute
energy
sources
that
are
generated
from
coal
,
water
,
gas
,
as
well
as
renewable
energy
,
particularly
biofuel
that
is
cheaper
so
it
is
more
affordable
to
the
public
.
This
policy
will
take
time
,
therefore
the
2007
Draft
State
Budget
still
makes
available
Oil
-
Based
Fuel
(
BBM
)
and
electricity
subsidies
.
The
fuel
subsidy
is
allocated
in
the
amount
of
Rp
68
.
6
trillion
and
the
electricity
subsidy
amounts
to
Rp
25
.
8
trillion
.
This
subsidy
allocation
that
is
quite
substantial
is
undertaken
because
the
Government
is
fully
cognizant
of
the
burden
that
the
people
had
to
endure
due
to
the
reduction
of
the
fuel
subsidy
last
year
.
The
proportion
of
fuel
utilisation
in
2007
as
electricity
generating
energy
shall
be
decreasing
and
substituted
by
coal
and
gas
.
In
2008
,
it
is
expected
that
the
subsidy
allocation
for
fuel
and
electricity
in
the
State
Budget
will
decrease
drastically
owing
to
the
utilization
of
gas
at
gas
-
powered
electric
generator
plants
(
PLTGs
)
.
Meanwhile
in
2009
,
all
power
plants
in
the
Island
of
Java
would
have
been
populated
by
non
-
fuel
electric
generators
.
For
the
purpose
of
developing
biofuel
energy
,
the
Government
will
utilize
the
asset
expenditures
allocation
from
various
ministries
and
related
institutions
to
support
that
program
.
In
addition
,
it
will
also
be
made
available
credit
interest
subsidy
for
biofuel
industry
amounting
to
Rp1
trillion
.
Fifth
,
as
part
of
the
State
Budget
support
to
the
bureaucracy
reform
programme
,
it
will
be
allocated
an
increase
of
23
.
3
percent
in
personnel
expenditure
budget
in
2007
.
In
the
calculation
for
the
personnel
expenditure
,
it
is
incorporated
,
among
others
:
(
i
)
the
increase
in
the
base
salary
for
state
apparatus
and
retirees
;
(
ii
)
the
payment
for
the
thirteenth
month
salary
and
pension
;
(
iii
)
the
improvement
of
structural
allowances
and
some
functional
allowances
;
(
iv
)
the
increase
in
profession
allowance
for
teachers
and
lecturers
;
(
v
)
the
salary
budget
for
new
central
public
servants
numbering
around
50
,
000
persons
,
the
majority
of
whom
originate
from
non
-
permanent
employees
;
(
vi
)
the
increase
of
official
per
diem
and
extra
money
for
members
of
the
TNI
and
POLRI
amounting
to
20
percent
;
and
(
vii
)
the
increase
in
the
Government
contributions
to
assist
in
the
improvement
of
health
services
for
the
staff
and
retirees
.
The
Government
will
try
to
increase
the
efficiency
of
the
budget
to
purchase
goods
and
services
through
a
tender
and
procurement
system
that
is
more
transparent
and
competitive
.
Therefore
,
the
public
can
participate
in
supervising
the
conduct
of
the
procurement
of
Government
projects
.
The
increase
in
goods
expenditures
is
projected
not
to
surpass
31
.
3
percent
.
This
budget
for
goods
and
services
expenditures
shall
be
used
to
:
(
i
)
increase
the
public
service
function
of
each
Government
institution
;
(
ii
)
increase
the
efficiency
and
effectiveness
of
goods
and
services
procurement
,
service
trips
,
and
state
assets
maintenance
;
and
(
iii
)
support
the
smooth
flow
of
Government
operational
activities
,
be
it
domestically
as
well
as
in
Indonesian
diplomatic
missions
abroad
.
The
increase
of
the
budget
for
domestic
goods
expenditures
is
,
among
others
,
used
to
accommodate
the
planned
increase
of
the
service
trip
cost
index
at
all
departments
or
non
-
departmental
government
institutions
.
Sixth
,
in
order
to
mitigate
natural
disasters
,
starting
from
the
Revised
2006
State
Budget
(
APBN
-
P
)
and
in
the
2007
Draft
State
Budget
,
the
Government
proposes
an
increased
allocation
for
expenditures
to
build
a
disaster
early
warning
system
,
the
additions
respectively
amount
to
Rp
60
billion
for
2006
and
Rp
150
billion
for
2007
.
The
post
-
disaster
allocation
fund
provided
through
the
general
reserves
amounts
to
Rp
2
trillion
in
2007
.
At
the
present
time
,
it
is
being
deliberated
an
additional
expenditure
in
disaster
mitigation
for
the
rehabilitation
and
reconstruction
of
the
Special
Region
of
Yogyakarta
and
Central
Java
as
well
as
regions
affected
by
other
disasters
.
The
post
-
tsunami
rehabilitation
and
reconstruction
programme
in
Aceh
and
Nias
will
continue
to
be
monitored
according
to
the
schedule
.
Aside
from
the
six
previous
types
of
expenditures
,
in
the
2007
Draft
State
Budget
,
expenditures
are
allocated
for
the
Central
Government
to
pay
debt
interests
,
both
domestic
and
foreign
debts
,
amounting
to
Rp
85
.
1
trillion
.
Therefore
,
the
total
expenditures
of
the
Central
Government
for
2007
amount
to
Rp
496
trillion
or
experiencing
an
increase
of
16
percent
compared
to
that
of
the
2006
State
Budget
.
Honourable
Leadership
and
Members
of
the
House
of
Representatives
,
The
2007
Draft
State
Budget
allocates
expenditures
to
the
Regional
Administrations
for
the
development
and
improvement
of
services
for
the
regional
communities
amounting
to
Rp
250
.
5
trillion
or
experiencing
an
increase
of
13
.
8
percent
compared
to
that
of
2006
.
The
General
Allocation
Fund
(
DAU
)
,
which
constitutes
an
instrument
to
overcome
the
financial
imbalance
between
the
regions
,
is
allocated
at
26
percent
of
the
net
domestic
revenue
.
In
parallel
to
the
increase
of
the
domestic
revenue
,
the
allocation
of
the
DAU
in
2007
is
then
projected
to
reach
Rp
.
163
.
7
trillion
or
increasing
by
to
12
.
4
percent
from
the
DAU
allocation
of
the
previous
year
.
In
consonance
with
the
increase
of
the
DAU
allocation
,
the
allocation
of
the
Special
Allocation
Fund
(
DAK
)
is
also
being
increased
.
For
that
purpose
,
the
DAK
allocation
for
2007
is
projected
to
reach
Rp
.
14
.
4
trillion
.
This
amount
indicates
an
increase
of
24
.
1
percent
from
the
DAK
allocation
of
the
previous
year
.
Furthermore
,
the
special
autonomy
and
adjustment
fund
in
2007
is
projected
to
amount
to
Rp
.
6
.
7
trillion
.
From
the
aforementioned
special
autonomy
fund
,
the
special
autonomy
fund
specific
for
the
Province
of
Papua
is
planned
to
amount
to
Rp
.
3
.
3
trillion
or
equal
to
2
(
two
)
percent
of
the
DAU
allocation
,
which
usage
will
be
directed
in
particular
to
finance
the
education
and
health
sectors
.
In
addition
,
in
order
to
carry
out
the
mandate
of
Article
34
paragraph
(
3
)
point
f
of
Law
Number
21
of
2001
,
the
Province
of
Papua
is
also
provided
with
an
additional
fund
in
the
framework
of
infrastructure
development
amounting
to
Rp
.
800
billion
,
which
usage
will
be
allocated
for
the
development
of
road
infrastructure
and
transportation
.
In
order
to
meet
the
expenditure
needs
,
both
at
the
central
as
well
as
at
the
regional
levels
,
sources
of
revenue
are
needed
that
originate
from
tax
and
non
-
tax
revenues
and
grants
.
State
revenue
and
grants
in
the
2007
Draft
State
Budget
is
projected
to
reach
the
amount
of
Rp
.
713
.
4
trillion
or
increasing
by
14
.
1
percent
from
the
2006
State
Budget
.
The
sources
for
the
state
revenue
in
2007
is
planned
to
consist
of
tax
revenue
amounting
to
Rp
.
505
.
9
trillion
,
non
-
tax
revenue
amounting
to
Rp
.
204
.
9
trillion
,
and
grants
amounting
to
Rp
.
2
.
7
trillion
.
The
estimation
of
the
state
revenue
and
grants
indicate
that
around
71
.
2
percent
are
supported
by
the
tax
revenue
,
and
around
28
.
8
percent
originate
from
non
-
tax
revenue
.
The
tax
ratio
is
increasing
from
13
.
7
percent
in
2006
to
14
.
3
percent
in
2007
.
The
contribution
of
the
tax
revenue
that
is
increasingly
growing
demonstrates
that
the
Government
remains
consistent
in
continuing
to
explore
domestic
funding
sources
,
in
order
to
realise
the
level
and
quality
of
State
Budget
independence
.
Honourable
Leadership
and
Members
of
the
House
of
Representatives
,
Ladies
and
Gentlemen
,
In
accordance
with
the
direction
of
the
fiscal
policy
,
and
the
planned
state
revenue
and
grants
,
and
the
state
budget
as
I
have
previously
elaborated
,
the
2007
Draft
State
Budget
will
then
experience
a
budget
deficit
of
around
Rp
.
33
.
1
trillion
or
0
.
9
percent
of
the
GDP
.
In
order
to
finance
the
budget
deficit
,
the
government
plans
to
use
funding
sources
,
from
both
domestic
and
foreign
,
while
still
being
oriented
towards
financing
efforts
that
are
stable
and
sustainable
,
with
as
minimal
a
burden
and
risk
as
possible
.
In
addition
to
close
the
budget
deficit
,
the
budget
funding
is
also
needed
to
meet
the
payment
obligations
for
the
main
instalments
of
domestic
and
foreign
debts
that
will
reach
their
maturity
dates
in
2007
,
and
the
government
capital
participation
for
the
revitalization
of
several
State
-
Owned
Enterprises
that
are
still
in
trouble
.
In
the
2007
Draft
State
Budget
,
the
budget
financing
that
originates
domestically
is
planned
to
reach
a
net
amount
of
Rp
.
51
.
3
trillion
.
This
financing
from
domestic
sources
is
planned
to
originate
from
:
(
i
)
The
issuance
of
Government
Bonds
or
SUN
by
taking
into
account
the
fiscal
and
monetary
policies
in
an
integrated
manner
;
(
ii
)
ex
-
moratorium
funds
to
finance
the
reconstruction
and
rehabilitation
programmes
in
NAD
-
Nias
;
(
iii
)
the
sale
of
assets
from
the
banking
restructuring
programmes
in
an
optimal
manner
;
(
iv
)
utilizing
the
reserve
fund
of
the
government
in
the
Bank
of
Indonesia
;
and
(
v
)
privatization
.
I
would
like
to
convey
that
the
source
of
privatization
financing
is
designed
to
be
at
quite
a
low
level
,
since
the
government
realizes
that
the
privatization
programme
should
not
be
aimed
at
merely
meeting
the
financing
of
the
State
Budget
deficit
,
however
,
what
is
more
important
is
that
the
effort
to
revitalize
and
the
improvement
of
the
performance
of
State
-
Owned
Enterprises
as
mandated
by
Law
Number
19
of
2003
on
State
-
Owned
Enterprises
.
In
the
meantime
,
budget
financing
that
originates
from
foreign
loan
sources
amounts
to
a
net
figure
of
Rp
.
18
.
2
trillion
.
That
amount
consists
of
program
loans
and
project
loans
amounting
to
Rp
.
35
.
9
trillion
,
and
subtracted
by
payments
for
the
main
instalments
of
foreign
debts
amounting
to
Rp
.
54
.
1
trillion
.
With
the
structure
of
the
draft
State
Budget
that
I
am
presenting
,
and
with
a
targeted
economic
growth
of
6
.
3
percent
,
the
debt
ratio
of
the
government
at
the
end
of
2007
is
estimated
to
decrease
from
around
41
.
3
percent
in
2006
to
around
36
.
9
percent
in
2007
.
The
decrease
of
the
debt
ratio
of
the
government
will
increasingly
strengthen
the
structure
of
the
fiscal
resilience
,
in
parallel
with
the
objective
of
achieving
sustained
fiscal
self
-
reliance
.
In
the
end
,
implementing
the
State
Budget
and
the
development
objectives
in
general
would
unlikely
reach
the
target
without
the
participation
of
all
the
people
and
the
businesspeople
.
The
programmes
of
the
State
Budget
are
carried
out
by
increasing
the
improvement
of
the
public
accountability
,
which
is
reflected
in
the
improvement
of
the
quality
and
orderliness
of
the
state
finances
report
.
The
policy
orientation
of
the
State
Budget
and
the
focus
of
the
Indonesian
development
will
also
be
more
directed
at
the
betterment
of
the
quality
of
the
Indonesian
being
,
which
is
covered
in
the
improvement
of
the
quality
of
life
,
and
the
achievement
of
the
Millennium
Development
Index
.
The
importance
of
the
development
of
the
Indonesian
being
is
also
translated
in
the
enlargement
of
the
budget
portion
destined
for
the
development
of
the
Indonesian
being
in
the
State
Budget
and
the
Regional
Budget
all
over
Indonesia
.
Henceforth
,
we
long
for
inexpensive
education
and
health
costs
and
basic
infrastructure
that
is
appropriately
available
,
so
that
all
of
the
Indonesias
people
will
be
able
to
gain
access
to
health
and
education
,
two
matters
that
constitute
crucial
elements
in
the
development
of
the
Indonesian
people
.
Honourable
Speaker
,
Deputy
Speakers
,
and
Members
of
the
House
of
Representatives
,
My
fellow
countrymen
,
In
concluding
my
State
Address
,
and
the
Government
Statement
on
the
Bill
on
the
State
Budget
for
the
2007
Fiscal
Year
and
Its
Financial
Note
,
I
would
like
to
invite
the
entire
components
of
the
nation
to
look
forward
,
together
in
concert
build
a
brighter
future
.
Long
was
the
road
that
we
thread
,
much
that
we
have
achieved
,
yet
,
there
remains
much
more
endeavours
that
we
must
undertake
,
towards
the
ideals
and
purpose
of
our
independence
.
The
years
that
we
are
navigating
these
days
are
by
no
means
easy
,
and
replete
with
challenges
.
Be
that
as
it
may
,
with
the
assent
of
Allah
SWT
,
I
am
confident
,
all
of
us
,
the
Indonesian
nation
that
is
grand
,
shall
be
able
to
transform
our
fate
and
future
towards
a
better
direction
.
Let
us
remain
resolved
,
confident
,
and
evermore
hardworking
in
reaching
our
ideals
.
The
time
has
come
,
for
us
to
be
more
united
,
rise
up
,
and
step
forward
.
Ahead
of
us
,
there
lie
a
wealth
of
opportunities
and
chances
that
we
must
approach
and
seize
.
To
all
of
the
leaders
in
our
homeland
,
I
invite
you
,
let
us
dedicate
our
thoughts
,
time
,
and
energy
to
improve
the
welfare
and
progress
of
the
entire
Indonesian
people
,
the
people
we
hold
dear
in
our
hearts
.
May
the
Almighty
God
bestow
His
blessing
upon
all
of
us
.
Long
live
the
Republic
of
Indonesia
!
Thank
you
.
Wassalamu
’
alaikum
warahmatullahi
wabarakatuh
.
Jakarta
,
16
August
2006
PRESIDENT
OF
THE
REPUBLIC
OF
INDONESIA
,
Sgd
.
DR
.
H
.
SUSILO
BAMBANG
YUDHOYONO
A
human
should
not
satisfied
and
feel
relieved
before
mastering
true
knowledge
(
Kawruh
Sejati
)
.
Someone
holding
this
truth
should
always
accomplish
noble
deeds
.
In
fact
,
it
is
a
heavy
duty
,
because
his
/
her
concerns
are
only
the
safety
and
well
-
beings
of
the
world
with
all
its
contents
and
true
perfectness
(
Kasampurnan
sejati
)
Yatno
means
remember
;
Moyo
means
bright
,
(
spiritually
means
brightness
of
true
life
,
experienced
only
by
those
who
are
in
harmonious
relation
with
Gusti
)
someone
with
knowledge
of
truth
should
always
remember
what
he
/
she
has
to
do
to
reach
perfect
life
.
What
are
the
noble
deeds
(
langkah
kautaman
)
?
There
are
3
kinds
:
Gentur
,
Suci
and
Legawa
.
Gentur
A
consistent
and
strong
determination
wish
and
deed
to
do
only
good
things
for
himself
/
herself
and
for
others
and
to
be
in
correct
path
blessed
by
Gusti
,
always
worship
Gusti
with
devotion
.
Usually
a
person
does
self
-
denial
for
a
certain
period
of
time
:
3
or
7
or
30
days
fasting
,
less
sleep
,
less
food
etc
.
or
he
/
she
help
others
by
donating
something
from
time
to
time
.
There
are
indeed
very
good
spiritual
exercises
,
but
'
Gentur
'
is
stronger
.
It
has
a
stronger
effect
in
seeking
spiritual
goal
.
Someone
with
'
Gentur
behavior
'
is
determined
to
reach
a
noble
life
(
urip
luhur
)
Suci
/
Holy
Always
worship
Gusti
sincerely
.
With
no
self
-
interest
for
herself
/
himself
.
All
her
/
his
heart
,
mind
,
deed
are
only
for
nobility
.
Legawa
To
maintain
good
and
correct
attitude
.
To
consciously
surrender
totally
,
to
the
wish
of
Gusti
(
Pasrah
and
Sumarah
)
To
avoid
evil
deeds
To
help
others
honestly
,
does
not
think
of
loss
and
profit
and
worldly
material
wealth
.
With
'
Gentur
,
Suci
,
Legawa
'
the
life
is
noble
,
the
deed
is
based
upon
clear
thinking
and
mind
.
Someone
practicing
these
principles
is
on
the
correct
path
to
the
truth
of
life
.
With
consistency
and
devotion
,
he
/
she
should
be
a
successful
seeker
of
true
knowledge
.
Many
people
have
common
wishes
such
as
:
To
have
high
position
To
be
rich
To
be
famous
To
have
power
To
be
superior
The
wishes
are
normal
for
ordinary
people
.
They
would
be
proud
if
they
could
achieve
them
.
But
for
a
seeker
of
true
knowledge
,
those
wishes
are
obstacles
which
should
deviate
the
concentration
of
mind
to
reach
perfect
life
.
What
a
determined
seeker
of
true
knowledge
has
to
do
to
at
least
minimize
or
suppress
the
5
above
worldly
wishes
?
What
he
/
she
has
to
do
consciously
which
are
considered
too
burdensome
for
ordinary
people
.
Limited
food
and
beverage
(
cegah
dahar
)
He
/
she
should
consume
a
smaller
portion
of
simple
food
,
less
of
meat
.
He
/
she
should
not
choose
only
delicious
food
and
drink
.
He
/
she
should
eat
only
when
he
/
she
is
hungry
and
should
drink
when
he
/
she
is
thirsty
.
Less
of
sleep
(
cegah
sare
)
He
/
she
should
sleep
when
really
is
sleepy
but
not
too
long
.
Because
he
/
she
has
to
work
as
a
responsible
human
and
has
to
worship
Gusti
especially
thru
samadi
.
Minimal
sleep
should
be
adequate
to
keep
healthy
the
physical
body
.
Avoid
pleasures
(
cegah
suka
)
Pleasure
should
drag
away
a
seeker
of
true
life
to
stop
performing
noble
deed
.
He
/
she
,
in
any
situation
has
to
help
others
who
are
suffering
and
living
in
poverty
materially
and
mentally
.
The
help
is
not
necessarily
in
the
form
of
material
or
financial
donation
,
it
could
be
thru
other
efforts
such
as
to
find
a
way
-
out
,
advices
,
spiritual
deed
etc
.
He
/
she
should
always
have
moral
obligation
to
the
needy
.
How
could
he
/
she
has
a
heart
to
enjoy
pleasures
,
while
a
lot
of
life
are
suffering
.
He
/
she
should
have
moral
solidarity
with
them
.
At
least
every
night
he
.
/
she
has
to
request
Gusti
thru
sincere
praying
for
justice
,
well
-
being
and
good
life
to
everyone
,
notably
the
ones
who
are
suffering
.
It
is
called
'
Makarti
'
in
spiritual
Javanese
.
A
wish
to
give
-
in
(
niat
ngalah
)
He
/
she
should
be
brave
to
give
in
his
own
interest
for
the
sake
of
good
life
of
society
.
A
wish
to
be
patient
(
niat
sabar
)
He
/
she
deliberately
has
to
be
always
patient
.
A
wish
to
give
(
niat
weweh
)
With
heart
and
soul
,
he
/
she
gives
something
to
the
needy
.
A
wish
to
help
(
niat
tetulung
)
He
/
she
has
to
do
it
sincerely
in
helping
others
to
solve
their
problems
.
Not
greedy
for
material
wealth
(
ora
melikan
)
He
/
she
should
not
have
self
-
interest
.
Avoid
praises
(
ora
aleman
)
He
/
she
is
doing
to
fulfill
duties
,
no
need
to
be
praised
.
Avoid
pride
(
ora
Kemlungkung
;
ora
umuk
)
He
/
she
should
be
always
low
-
profile
and
polite
.
A
seeker
of
true
knowledge
,
practising
the
above
way
of
life
and
doing
only
noble
deeds
,
is
a
true
human
of
example
,
who
is
able
to
beautify
the
world
,
a
precious
asset
to
the
world
and
mankind
.
Some
examples
of
the
teaching
implementations
are
as
follow
:
Two
persons
have
the
same
interest
to
own
a
same
precious
property
such
as
land
or
building
etc
.
Usually
they
should
fight
by
defeating
other
to
grab
the
property
.
The
winner
should
be
pleased
,
while
the
loser
should
be
sad
.
In
a
better
case
,
both
reach
amicable
solution
,
the
property
is
divided
equally
,
so
both
of
them
are
happy
.
It
is
a
good
solution
for
ordinary
people
.
A
seeker
of
true
knowledge
,
he
/
she
should
give
the
whole
property
to
the
other
person
.
By
doing
this
,
he
/
she
gives
a
complete
satisfaction
to
the
other
to
be
really
happy
.
A
seeker
of
true
knowledge
is
not
able
to
satisfy
her
/
his
feeling
with
material
thing
.
What
he
/
she
feels
is
only
noble
deed
(
Roso
Kautaman
)
.
This
is
the
essence
of
feeling
(
Sari
Roso
)
Helping
each
other
is
positive
thing
.
A
seeker
of
true
knowledge
,
implementing
noble
deeds
,
wish
only
to
help
.
If
he
/
she
helps
somebody
,
he
/
she
does
not
wish
to
be
reciprocated
.
If
a
person
is
insulted
by
somebody
,
he
/
she
should
insult
back
as
a
reciprocity
,
even
in
more
bitter
manner
.
But
a
human
with
noble
deed
,
should
not
reciprocate
.
He
/
she
should
feel
right
away
,
has
committed
some
mistakes
.
He
/
she
should
be
grateful
that
somebody
has
remind
him
/
her
to
behave
in
a
proper
way
.
If
he
/
she
is
respected
by
other
than
he
/
she
should
reciprocate
with
a
much
bigger
respect
to
other
.
The
same
if
he
/
she
got
a
good
treatment
,
got
a
help
or
given
something
by
others
,
he
/
she
should
reciprocate
more
to
them
.
A
human
who
is
doing
nothing
except
noble
deed
with
sincerity
and
consciousness
,
he
/
she
is
a
human
of
high
moral
quality
,
the
Javanese
spiritual
terminology
is
'
ngambar
gondo
arum
'
lit
.
means
to
spread
an
aroma
of
fragrance
.
Her
/
his
concentration
of
Cipta
-
forefront
of
feeling
(
pamelenging
Cipta
)
is
sharp
.
Her
/
his
'
concentration
of
Cipta
'
could
be
realized
.
He
/
she
would
be
loved
by
others
,
he
/
she
has
a
strong
cipta
(
prabawaning
cipta
)
From
her
/
him
,
miracles
could
grow
by
permit
of
Gusti
.
As
if
all
her
/
his
requests
thru
cipta
should
be
fulfilled
by
Gusti
,
God
the
Almighty
.
He
/
she
by
practising
'
Yatno
Moyo
'
whole
-
heartedly
,
is
different
from
many
other
people
.
I
.
Let
'
s
quote
a
Javanese
classical
Tembang
(
song
)
:
I
finish
my
talk
(
tak
uwisi
gunem
iki
)
I
only
wish
to
make
you
understand
(
niyatku
mung
aweh
wikan
)
There
are
a
lot
of
Kebatinan
knowledge
(
Kebatinan
akeh
lire
)
There
are
extremely
serious
(
lan
gawat
kaliwat
-
liwat
)
So
,
be
alert
(
mula
dipun
prayitno
)
Do
not
make
a
wrong
choice
(
aja
kleru
pamilihmu
)
When
you
learn
Kebatinan
(
lamun
mardi
Kebatinan
)
This
Javanese
classical
song
represents
an
advice
from
an
old
wise
man
(
priyayi
sepuh
)
to
those
who
are
interested
to
learn
Kebatinan
or
Kejawen
.
As
it
has
been
written
in
preceding
chapters
that
the
real
goal
of
Kejawen
is
to
gain
a
true
spiritual
knowledge
to
reach
true
life
and
harmonious
relation
between
servant
and
God
(
jumbuhing
kawulo
Gusti
)
.
This
spiritual
condition
could
be
achieved
by
every
believer
in
God
,
having
good
morality
and
sincerity
.
Some
ways
of
behaving
(
laku
)
,
have
to
be
practiced
with
utmost
consciousness
and
determination
.
The
seekers
of
true
knowledge
and
those
who
have
gained
true
knowledge
are
obliged
to
do
somethings
for
the
benefit
of
all
people
thru
their
minds
and
deeds
.
Cipta
(
forefront
of
feeling
)
,
rasa
(
feeling
)
,
karsa
(
wish
)
and
karya
(
deed
)
must
be
good
,
correct
and
holy
and
solely
focussed
to
'
mamayu
hayuning
bawono
'
to
preserve
the
beauty
of
the
world
with
all
its
contents
for
the
welfare
of
all
living
-
beings
and
the
safety
of
the
universe
.
'
Ati
suci
jumbuhing
kawulo
Gusti
'
holy
heart
is
the
harmonious
relation
between
servant
and
God
.
No
doubt
that
Kejawen
is
an
asset
of
traditional
Javanese
with
universal
value
.
The
Kejawen
outlook
could
contribute
to
the
world
peace
and
prosperity
.
Do
it
relaxly
Some
readers
find
the
scrutinized
explanation
of
Kejawen
,
consisting
of
:
General
knowledge
and
the
experiences
of
some
people
as
very
interesting
.
Some
appreciate
the
goal
of
this
spiritual
teaching
but
it
is
hard
to
practise
.
Javanese
wise
man
(
priyayi
sepuh
)
gives
a
simple
advice
Do
it
relaxly
!
Kejawen
is
a
flexible
knowledge
.
First
,
you
are
required
to
understand
it
.
Do
not
force
yourself
.
As
a
believer
,
it
is
not
hard
for
you
to
be
honest
.
As
a
moral
and
life
guidance
,
you
are
obliged
to
be
grateful
to
Gusti
,
God
the
Almighty
that
you
have
been
given
a
chance
to
live
in
this
world
.
As
a
responsible
human
you
have
obligations
:
To
work
decently
,
to
fulfill
the
need
of
yourself
and
your
family
.
To
keep
your
body
healthy
,
so
you
would
have
a
healthy
mind
too
.
To
take
a
good
care
of
your
physical
body
is
of
prime
important
to
do
all
activities
physically
and
mentally
.
To
have
a
noble
mind
(
Budi
luhur
)
.
By
conducting
the
above
obligations
,
it
is
easier
for
you
to
contribute
to
the
society
i
.
e
.
to
others
,
to
the
country
and
to
the
world
.
Relation
with
God
Usually
people
say
that
relation
with
God
is
a
personal
matter
.
That
'
s
right
,
only
you
-
yourself
know
,
how
is
your
relation
with
God
.
Whether
it
'
s
usual
or
deep
or
sincere
.
Might
be
you
don
'
t
know
or
might
be
you
try
to
understand
God
or
you
don
'
t
care
,
the
most
important
thing
that
you
believe
of
the
existence
of
God
.
Is
it
enough
to
say
that
you
believe
in
God
?
The
wise
people
should
reply
:
"
No
,
it
'
s
not
enough
"
!
In
your
heart
you
glorify
His
name
,
and
the
best
you
worship
God
.
You
may
call
God
in
your
own
native
language
or
as
taught
by
your
faith
or
religion
you
confess
,
in
order
to
feel
closer
to
God
.
People
have
different
experience
,
some
always
praise
God
since
childhood
,
some
remember
God
when
they
are
in
trouble
,
sick
or
facing
delicate
problems
.
As
a
general
rule
,
you
may
pray
to
God
,
anytime
,
anywhere
,
in
any
situation
.
But
to
be
closer
to
God
,
you
are
required
to
make
a
special
time
to
devote
God
.
Prepare
yourself
,
clean
physically
and
soul
,
in
a
clean
and
tranquil
place
.
It
could
be
in
your
room
,
outside
the
house
or
in
a
holy
place
.
Say
your
pray
and
good
wishes
to
'
Gusti
kang
paring
nugraha
'
to
all
-
loving
God
who
gives
comfort
,
with
all
your
good
wishes
and
deeds
,
God
should
give
you
a
comfortable
life
for
you
and
your
family
.
The
Kejawen
people
do
their
pray
,
preferably
at
night
before
going
to
bed
.
During
the
day
time
,
they
work
as
a
duty
to
fulfill
the
need
of
the
family
.
Prepare
yourself
,
be
alone
in
the
room
.
Relax
your
body
,
have
a
peaceful
mind
.
You
may
sit
cross
leg
on
the
floor
or
sit
relaxly
on
a
chair
,
with
the
permit
of
God
,
say
your
pray
solemnly
,
say
your
requests
clearly
and
whole
heartedly
.
Do
not
be
ashame
to
ask
forgiveness
from
God
,
if
you
feel
you
have
made
mistakes
,
promise
not
to
make
mistakes
again
.
If
you
are
not
tired
,
you
may
do
spiritual
exercises
with
your
mind
concentrated
to
God
.
Listen
to
your
breath
attentively
,
inhale
,
exhale
slowly
for
about
10
minutes
.
Then
with
a
peaceful
mind
you
go
to
bed
,
tomorrow
you
wake
up
early
with
fit
body
and
clean
mind
,
ready
to
work
.
You
do
it
regularly
until
you
feel
that
it
'
s
not
a
burden
for
you
.
It
'
s
a
duty
,
you
do
with
pleasure
.
You
may
add
the
duration
of
your
breathing
exercises
to
15
or
20
minutes
or
more
but
never
force
the
ability
of
your
body
.
When
you
have
time
and
you
are
not
physically
tired
,
go
outside
the
house
,
stand
directly
under
the
night
sky
for
about
5
minutes
to
breath
clean
air
.
But
if
the
circumstance
does
not
allow
you
to
go
outside
,
for
instance
due
to
bad
weather
etc
,
just
open
your
window
for
a
while
or
stay
in
the
balcony
if
you
have
any
.
It
'
s
good
to
calm
your
mind
.
If
possible
do
it
regularly
when
you
are
healthy
.
That
'
s
why
,
it
is
prime
important
to
keep
your
health
.
Consume
good
quality
of
food
with
less
of
meat
,
do
regularly
physical
exercises
,
work
well
,
have
enough
time
to
rest
,
have
several
minutes
to
pray
and
spiritual
exercises
.
Thus
,
you
should
have
a
balance
of
life
.
You
have
your
normal
life
and
at
the
same
time
,
you
are
closer
to
God
.
A
good
and
healthy
person
Practicing
this
way
of
life
,
you
are
healthy
,
physically
and
mentally
,
in
a
better
shape
.
In
your
job
,
you
become
more
productive
.
If
you
have
family
you
become
a
better
family
man
,
you
live
happily
.
You
are
a
wiser
human
who
has
heart
to
help
the
needy
.
Normally
,
breathing
exercises
is
good
for
your
health
.
It
makes
your
heart
stronger
and
your
body
is
in
better
condition
.
The
breathing
exercises
or
more
seriously
called
'
meditation
'
or
in
Kejawen
spiritually
called
'
samadi
'
is
good
for
your
mind
too
.
It
should
make
you
to
be
more
patient
and
you
should
be
able
to
control
your
desires
easier
.
You
are
on
the
right
track
,
if
you
feel
as
stated
above
.
You
are
a
good
and
healthy
person
.
You
are
precious
asset
to
your
family
and
society
.
It
s
perfect
,
carry
on
with
enthusiasm
.
You
live
in
a
good
and
correct
path
,
blessed
by
All
-
loving
God
.
You
are
healthy
,
you
have
a
good
logical
thinking
and
clear
mind
.
You
consistently
do
your
praying
and
meditation
.
You
wish
to
deeper
your
knowledge
of
spiritualism
,
to
be
closer
to
God
,
to
know
the
secret
of
life
.
Now
,
you
are
ready
to
develop
your
roso
(
feeling
)
.
It
won
'
t
be
difficult
.
You
have
to
go
on
with
your
meditation
.
With
the
same
position
(
patrap
)
,
the
most
convenient
position
for
you
,
you
should
improve
the
quality
of
breathing
exercises
.
Previously
it
was
'
to
inhale
'
and
'
to
exhale
'
,
now
:
:
Inhale
,
slowly
,
calmly
.
Hold
breathing
for
a
certain
period
.
Exhale
,
slowly
,
calmly
.
Focus
your
sight
to
the
peak
of
your
nose
.
Listen
attentively
to
your
breathing
,
it
is
a
way
to
help
you
not
to
think
of
something
else
.
Try
to
concentrate
your
mind
to
supreme
God
.
Do
it
in
a
relax
way
for
10
minutes
,
15
minutes
or
30
minutes
if
you
are
not
tired
and
you
have
free
time
.
Do
it
gradually
and
never
force
your
physical
ability
.
This
exercises
should
develop
your
roso
step
by
step
.
Together
with
developing
roso
/
feeling
,
you
should
develop
also
your
Cipta
/
forefront
of
feeling
-
mind
.
With
the
same
position
,
only
you
focus
your
sight
to
a
black
spot
in
front
of
you
.
(
see
'
Cipta
Tunggal
'
point5
)
.
When
your
Cipta
becomes
more
powerful
,
your
good
wishes
could
be
realized
.
Meanwhile
the
roso
should
gradually
becomes
true
roso
(
roso
sejati
)
.
This
true
roso
,
is
a
divine
gift
,
you
have
it
,
but
you
have
to
develop
it
.
Spiritually
'
True
Roso
'
could
receive
messages
(
Sasmita
)
and
instructions
(
Dawuh
)
which
are
always
correct
from
your
true
life
.
For
these
exercises
,
you
may
do
sometimes
exercises
for
Cipta
and
the
other
time
for
roso
.
Once
again
,
do
it
relaxly
and
do
not
force
yourself
,
after
that
go
outside
the
house
to
breathe
fresh
air
as
explained
previously
.
It
is
an
effective
way
to
help
to
develop
your
roso
.
The
spiritual
sisters
and
brothers
Please
refer
to
sub
-
article
'
Cipta
Tunggal
'
point
16
to
know
who
they
are
.
They
are
always
with
you
,
guard
you
wherever
you
are
.
Might
be
you
are
not
aware
that
they
help
you
in
all
your
activities
.
They
would
be
glad
if
you
know
their
existance
.
So
it
is
wise
to
ask
them
to
participate
in
every
activities
you
are
doing
such
as
drinking
,
eating
,
studying
,
working
,
driving
,
taking
a
bath
etc
.
In
your
heart
you
call
them
,
for
instance
:
All
my
spiritual
sisters
and
brothers
:
I
want
to
eat
,
you
help
me
(
ewang
-
ewangono
)
.
It
'
s
mean
that
they
would
help
you
,
so
that
you
are
safe
while
you
eat
and
the
food
is
good
for
you
.
Help
me
to
drive
the
car
safely
to
my
office
.
It
'
s
mean
you
drive
safely
until
your
office
,
there
is
no
accident
occurred
to
you
,
to
the
car
and
to
others
.
I
'
ll
work
,
help
me
to
accomplish
a
good
job
etc
.
You
won
'
t
ask
them
to
participate
when
you
are
going
to
sleep
,
instead
you
would
say
:
I
'
m
going
to
sleep
,
protect
me
(
reksanen
)
while
I
am
sleeping
,
if
there
is
any
disturbance
or
danger
,
wake
me
up
.
Lying
in
bed
,
before
closing
your
eyes
,
you
say
,
touching
your
heart
.
With
your
right
hand
"
I
am
also
alive
"
.
By
knowing
them
that
'
s
mean
you
care
of
them
,
and
in
return
they
should
take
care
of
you
too
.
If
you
don
'
t
pay
any
attention
to
them
,
they
would
do
nothing
to
help
you
,
they
wish
you
to
go
back
to
where
you
belong
soonest
.
They
wish
to
be
released
soonest
from
their
duties
to
accompany
you
.
When
you
go
back
to
eternity
,
they
would
go
too
and
they
hope
to
be
given
a
chance
by
God
the
Almighty
to
be
born
as
human
,
with
soul
and
body
in
their
new
life
in
earth
.
Weton
,
is
a
special
Javanese
traditional
birthday
occurred
every
35
days
.
As
it
has
been
explained
,
except
the
7
international
days
(
Monday
-
Sunday
)
,
there
are
5
pasaran
days
Legi
,
Paing
,
Pon
,
Wage
,
Kliwon
.
From
Monday
Legi
to
Monday
Legi
again
is
35
days
.
From
Friday
Kliwon
to
Friday
Kliwon
again
is
35
days
.
So
for
a
traditional
Javanese
it
is
important
to
know
her
/
his
weton
birthday
.
Every
one
has
a
weton
birthday
which
has
to
be
remembered
.
By
knowing
your
date
,
month
and
year
of
your
birth
,
it
can
be
calculated
what
is
your
weton
.
A
traditional
Javanese
in
the
weton
birthday
usually
should
do
:
Make
an
offering
in
the
form
of
a
small
plate
of
red
and
white
porridge
of
rice
and
a
glass
of
water
.
This
offering
is
for
all
his
/
her
spiritual
sisters
and
brothers
.
Put
the
offering
on
a
table
in
the
evening
,
he
/
she
would
say
:
"
This
offering
is
for
all
my
spiritual
sisters
and
brothers
,
I
always
remember
you
,
know
you
,
take
good
care
of
me
"
.
More
over
,
this
offering
of
red
and
white
porridge
is
meant
to
remember
and
to
be
grateful
to
mother
and
father
,
through
them
you
were
born
and
live
in
this
world
.
Further
,
to
remember
and
respect
ancestors
and
the
most
important
to
remember
and
worship
the
Creator
of
life
,
Gusti
,
God
the
Almighty
.
The
reference
to
call
spiritual
brothers
and
sister
is
:
Mar
marti
,
kakang
kawah
,
adi
ari
-
ari
,
getih
puser
,
sedulur
papat
,
kalima
pancer
.
Help
me
to
..
(
say
what
you
need
)
Protect
me
while
I
sleep
.
You
are
advised
to
refer
to
their
complete
names
until
you
are
get
used
(
jumbuh
)
with
them
,
let
say
for
several
months
.
After
that
you
may
refer
'
all
my
spiritual
sisters
and
brothers
'
.
But
when
you
pray
or
meditate
,
you
should
refer
their
complete
names
.
Also
when
you
make
offering
to
them
,
say
their
names
one
by
one
.
You
should
know
that
kakang
kawah
(
elder
brother
kawah
)
and
Adi
ari
-
ari
(
younger
brother
ari
-
ari
)
,
are
the
ones
who
help
you
most
.
Kakang
kawah
would
do
his
best
to
realize
your
wishes
and
efforts
,
while
Adi
ari
-
ari
would
comfort
you
.
That
'
s
why
when
you
have
an
important
thing
to
do
or
before
you
pray
,
after
you
refer
their
names
one
by
one
to
help
you
,
you
should
repeat
by
calling
kakang
kawah
and
Adi
ari
-
ari
to
help
you
.
Except
making
offerings
to
spiritual
sisters
and
brothers
,
someone
could
purify
herself
/
himself
in
weton
birthday
,
among
other
by
24
hours
of
fasting
,
or
consume
only
fruits
and
vegetables
or
eat
only
white
rice
and
drink
water
,
does
not
consume
salt
and
sugar
,
stay
awake
until
midnight
etc
.
Other
people
would
do
as
the
above
for
3
days
in
a
row
(
it
is
called
Ngapit
)
,
one
day
prior
to
weton
,
during
the
weton
plus
one
day
after
the
weton
.
By
always
asking
your
spiritual
sisters
and
brothers
to
participate
in
all
your
activities
that
'
s
mean
you
are
active
lahir
(
outer
side
)
and
batin
(
inner
side
)
(
see
'
Exposing
the
Universe
'
point
48
)
The
one
who
does
something
is
not
only
I
(
Aku
in
Javanese
)
but
Ingsun
,
i
.
e
.
Aku
the
outer
side
(
lahir
,
jobo
)
,
joined
by
aku
the
inner
side
(
batin
,
jero
)
.
That
'
s
why
,
a
Javanese
wishing
to
do
something
important
,
he
/
she
would
say
"
Niat
Ingsun
"
niat
-
wish
,
Ingsun
as
explained
above
most
probably
the
word
'
Ingsun
'
is
a
new
vocabulary
to
you
.
By
doing
those
spiritual
deeds
,
they
usually
hope
to
have
a
safety
and
well
-
being
in
their
life
or
for
the
seeker
of
true
knowledge
to
feel
closer
to
true
life
or
reality
(
kasunyatan
)
.
Danyang
Smarabumi
The
Danyang
Smarabumi
is
good
danyang
,
a
guardian
-
spirit
of
a
village
or
a
certain
place
.
In
her
/
his
life
as
a
human
,
he
/
she
was
sakti
,
(
had
supernatural
power
)
,
but
his
/
her
knowledge
was
not
perfect
.
He
/
she
could
not
pass
the
requirement
of
'
Sangkan
Paraning
Dumadi
'
lit
.
means
'
Where
you
come
from
and
where
you
go
'
,
spiritually
understood
you
come
from
holiness
,
in
this
earth
you
have
to
live
in
holiness
and
you
go
back
to
where
you
belong
the
holiness
.
(
see
"
The
Experience
of
R
.
M
.
Binaji
The
World
of
Spirits
Danyang
Smarabumi
)
He
/
she
is
assigned
by
divine
power
to
be
a
Danyang
Smarabumi
and
he
/
she
has
to
do
her
/
his
job
with
responsibily
.
You
,
as
a
good
human
a
believer
in
God
,
is
entitled
by
divine
power
to
instruct
her
/
him
to
protect
you
,
your
family
,
your
house
,
your
office
etc
to
be
in
safety
,
not
to
be
bothered
by
evil
spirits
.
Please
do
remember
,
you
may
ask
for
protection
only
.
It
'
s
your
right
and
it
'
s
the
duty
of
a
Danyang
Smarabumi
.
Do
not
ask
any
other
kind
of
help
such
as
fortune
,
material
wealth
etc
.
When
,
you
do
your
praying
and
spiritual
exercises
,
you
are
advised
,
to
instruct
this
Danyang
Smarabumi
to
protect
you
,
so
you
won
'
t
be
disturbed
by
evil
spirits
.
Be
confident
,
he
/
she
would
do
accordingly
.
Of
course
you
have
to
say
it
in
a
nice
way
.
You
refer
him
/
her
:
Nini
kaki
Sang
Danyang
Smarabumi
sing
Baurekso
.
Nini
-
reference
to
an
old
woman
,
kaki
-
reference
to
an
old
man
,
Sang
-
reference
of
politiness
.
Sing
-
who
is
,
Baurekso
-
authority
,
responsibility
means
:
Nini
kaki
The
Guardian
spirit
who
is
responsible
.
You
could
say
before
praying
:
Nini
kaki
Sang
Danyang
Smarabumi
sing
Baurekso
In
the
village
of
..
,
(
say
name
of
the
village
)
here
in
this
place
In
the
street
of
(
say
name
of
the
street
,
no
)
here
in
this
place
Protect
Ingsun
(
the
I
,
lahir
and
batin
;
the
complete
I
)
while
Ingsun
doing
my
praying
to
God
the
Almighty
,
no
one
should
disturb
Ingsun
,
the
family
of
Ingsun
and
the
house
of
Ingsun
.
For
your
proper
protection
to
fulfill
the
wish
of
Ingsun
,
I
am
grateful
.
Yes
,
surely
you
must
be
grateful
,
the
same
if
you
ask
a
security
guard
to
protect
you
,
your
family
and
your
house
.
By
giving
instruction
to
Danyang
Smarabumi
,
no
unauthorized
spirits
should
intrude
your
solemn
communication
with
God
.
The
sincere
worship
So
,
now
you
are
aware
of
your
spiritual
sisters
and
brothers
and
Danyang
Smarabumi
.
As
a
good
and
healthy
person
,
you
always
worship
sincerely
to
God
,
also
doing
spiritual
excercises
samadi
,
to
be
closer
to
God
.
Prior
to
praying
:
You
clean
yourself
physically
by
washing
yourself
or
if
you
wish
you
may
take
a
bath
or
a
shower
.
It
'
s
good
to
feel
fresh
.
You
wear
a
clean
dress
.
Take
a
comfortable
position
,
in
a
clean
and
tidy
room
.
Sit
relaxly
and
you
are
physically
calm
and
so
your
mind
.
Glorify
the
name
of
Gusti
/
God
,
you
respect
God
sincerely
and
wholeheartedly
.
Ask
his
blessing
,
before
you
say
your
pray
and
good
and
correct
wishes
.
Ask
your
spiritual
sisters
and
brothers
to
participate
in
your
pray
,
so
that
your
pray
and
wishes
should
be
accepted
by
God
,
by
saying
:
Mar
Marti
,
Kakang
Kawah
,
adi
ari
-
ari
,
getih
puser
,
sedulur
papat
,
kalima
pancer
,
all
my
spiritual
sisters
and
brothers
who
have
been
born
together
with
me
,
help
me
to
worship
God
,
so
that
my
pray
and
wishes
should
be
accepted
by
Gusti
.
Instruct
a
protection
from
the
Danyang
Smarabumi
as
has
been
written
above
.
Remember
the
use
of
the
word
Ingsun
.
Say
your
pray
and
wishes
solemnly
,
with
full
devotion
to
God
the
Almighty
.
You
are
free
to
say
your
pray
and
wish
in
your
own
language
or
as
in
accordance
to
your
faith
.
You
do
breathing
exercises
calmly
,
with
full
concentration
by
listening
attentively
to
your
breathing
and
concentration
of
mind
to
God
.
Inhale
,
hold
breathing
,
exhale
slowly
.
Focus
your
sight
to
the
peak
of
your
nose
.
This
should
develop
your
roso
(
feeling
)
and
step
by
step
,
it
should
be
developed
to
roso
sejati
(
true
feeling
)
You
may
exercise
also
to
sharper
your
Cipta
(
forefront
of
feeling
)
,
by
focussing
your
sight
to
a
black
spot
in
front
of
you
.
(
see
'
Cipta
Tinggal
'
point
5
)
.
You
go
outside
the
house
(
if
possible
)
or
just
open
your
window
for
5
minutes
to
breath
fresh
air
from
the
tranquil
nature
.
It
'
s
good
to
calm
your
mind
and
help
develop
effectively
your
roso
(
feeling
)
.
If
you
do
regularly
to
devote
yourself
to
God
,
the
Creator
of
life
,
as
described
above
,
you
would
have
sharper
thinking
and
feeling
,
you
would
have
a
clean
and
peaceful
mind
.
Your
pray
and
wishes
should
be
accepted
by
All
-
loving
God
.
Then
,
you
go
to
bed
with
healthy
body
and
peaceful
mind
.
Take
a
good
rest
,
as
you
have
to
work
again
tomorrow
for
a
brighter
life
and
future
.
Before
you
sleep
,
you
ask
to
be
protected
by
your
spiritual
sisters
and
brothers
,
as
explained
above
.
Midnight
According
to
the
experience
of
many
wise
men
and
women
,
the
seekers
of
true
knowledge
and
who
have
gained
true
knowledge
,
the
best
time
to
say
your
pray
is
at
midnight
.
It
is
a
favorable
time
where
the
situation
is
peaceful
and
tranquil
and
human
mind
is
at
the
peak
of
sensitivity
toward
spiritualism
.
If
you
wish
to
follow
this
practice
,
you
should
adjust
your
time
of
sleep
.
Some
of
you
need
6
hours
rest
,
others
need
8
hours
sleep
per
day
.
It
depends
to
your
own
physical
ability
.
For
instance
,
you
decide
to
pray
and
meditate
between
11
.
30
p
.
m
.
to
00
.
30
a
.
m
.
,
then
you
should
sleep
in
the
evening
,
you
wake
up
5
minutes
before
your
scheduled
time
to
pray
.
You
do
your
one
-
hour
praying
and
meditation
,
then
you
go
to
bed
again
.
Thus
,
you
keep
yourself
healthy
which
is
very
important
.
The
adjustment
of
time
is
entirely
your
own
decision
.
Do
it
comfortably
with
enthusiastic
determination
.
Moonlight
Let
'
s
quote
an
old
Javanese
children
song
(
tembang
)
:
Come
on
,
friends
let
'
s
play
outside
(
yo
pro
konco
dolanan
neng
jobo
)
It
'
s
moonlight
,
it
'
s
very
bright
(
Padang
bulan
,
padange
koyo
rino
)
The
moon
is
calling
us
(
Rembulane
-
ne
,
sing
ngawe
-
awe
)
Remind
us
not
to
sleep
early
in
the
evening
(
Ngelekake
ojo
podo
turu
sore
)
In
the
old
time
,
when
the
island
of
Java
was
not
too
crowded
like
nowadays
,
they
were
many
spacious
yards
in
the
villages
.
During
moonlight
,
the
village
children
played
happily
outside
their
houses
.
They
sang
and
danced
together
,
some
of
them
played
at
hide
and
seek
and
so
on
.
The
parents
looking
on
their
children
,
sat
on
a
mat
put
above
the
ground
,
they
chatted
on
various
topics
of
common
interest
.
They
were
ordinary
villagers
,
carried
out
their
simple
life
,
their
income
was
enough
to
survive
,
but
they
were
happy
with
their
traditional
peaceful
and
harmonious
life
.
Together
,
they
were
enjoying
the
moonlight
,
with
the
moon
and
stars
shining
brightly
the
Universe
.
This
is
the
power
of
God
the
Almighty
,
whom
they
were
grateful
from
the
bottom
of
hearts
.
In
this
simplicity
,
they
felt
very
close
to
nature
,
inseparable
with
their
beautiful
and
fertile
surroundings
.
They
felt
secured
and
protected
by
Gusti
,
God
,
the
Creator
of
the
Universe
.
During
moonlight
,
the
direct
shine
of
moon
and
stars
give
a
strong
influential
power
to
the
back
brain
of
human
to
develop
spiritual
strength
.
So
moonlight
is
not
only
long
awaited
by
the
children
but
as
well
by
the
adults
,
especially
'
adult
'
in
their
spiritual
knowledge
.
To
remain
outside
under
the
sky
for
several
hours
during
moonlight
are
good
for
those
who
are
seeking
true
knowledge
.
A
happy
and
successful
life
By
practicing
voluntarily
the
above
Kejawen
way
of
life
,
you
should
have
a
happy
and
successful
life
as
a
result
thereof
.
As
Kejawen
has
universal
value
,
this
way
of
life
is
not
only
suitable
for
Javanese
but
for
every
member
of
the
world
community
.
You
are
a
creative
person
,
a
person
of
integrity
with
high
morality
and
etiquette
,
implementing
consciously
only
good
and
correct
action
.
You
are
healthy
physically
and
mentally
.
Your
existence
is
not
only
useful
for
yourself
but
as
well
as
to
your
family
and
society
.
You
should
be
able
to
realize
your
positive
wishes
without
being
harmful
to
others
.
On
the
contrary
,
you
care
for
others
because
through
your
sincere
mind
,
you
are
aware
that
other
people
and
living
beings
are
in
fact
same
as
you
,
creatures
belong
to
the
Creator
of
life
.
The
concept
of
'
mamayu
hayuning
bawono
'
(
to
preserve
the
beauty
of
the
world
with
all
its
contents
for
the
welfare
of
all
living
-
beings
and
for
the
safety
of
the
Universe
)
is
obliged
to
be
carried
-
out
whole
heartedly
.
Based
upon
this
attitude
,
you
love
others
and
you
care
to
environment
,
nature
and
the
Universe
.
From
logical
point
of
you
,
you
have
done
the
right
thing
.
As
a
believer
,
you
are
in
the
correct
path
blessed
by
God
.
Spiritually
,
the
regular
devoted
practice
should
develop
your
roso
(
feeling
)
to
roso
sejati
(
true
feeling
)
,
opening
the
way
toward
secret
of
life
.
II
.
What
has
been
explained
in
point
I
is
a
guidance
usually
given
by
a
spiritual
Guru
of
Kejawen
or
Kebatinan
in
Java
to
those
who
wish
to
learn
Kejawen
wholeheartedly
.
Before
practising
it
,
they
have
to
understand
the
basic
principle
of
the
knowledge
(
kawruh
)
.
The
practise
of
worship
to
God
,
strengthened
by
meditation
and
the
knowledge
should
go
hand
-
in
-
hand
.
They
are
totally
interrelated
,
inseparable
!
This
article
has
described
concisely
:
The
fundamental
knowledge
of
Kejawen
The
experiences
of
some
wise
people
Kejawen
is
a
flexible
spiritual
teaching
.
In
the
effort
to
master
it
,
everyone
might
have
different
ways
and
experiences
.
It
is
clear
because
every
one
has
her
/
his
own
background
and
personalities
.
Possibly
it
could
be
compared
that
the
goal
of
life
of
people
is
to
reach
happiness
materially
and
mentally
.
In
order
to
realize
the
goal
,
they
study
in
different
schools
,
with
different
subjects
.
Then
they
work
in
different
fields
in
accordance
of
their
various
expertise
.
To
cater
the
need
of
their
spiritual
life
,
they
confess
different
faiths
or
religions
.
But
they
have
same
goal
-
the
happiness
of
life
.
It
makes
sense
,
if
Kejawen
followers
have
different
ways
of
behaving
and
experiences
in
their
effort
to
gain
their
goal
.
Please
remember
that
the
goal
of
the
seekers
of
true
knowledge
(
kawruh
sejati
)
is
the
harmonious
relation
between
servant
and
God
(
jumbuhing
kawulo
Gusti
)
which
is
reality
(
Kasunyatan
)
.
To
reach
the
sacred
goal
,
based
upon
good
conduct
,
moral
and
deeds
,
honesty
,
sincerity
,
consciousness
and
a
firm
believe
to
Gusti
,
God
the
Almighty
,
they
might
use
different
vehicles
,
roads
,
dresses
etc
.
the
most
important
thing
,
they
have
only
one
and
same
goal
the
harmonious
relation
between
servant
and
God
.
As
a
result
thereof
,
which
is
accepted
as
a
fact
,
they
would
have
different
spiritual
experience
.
In
the
process
to
gain
true
knowledge
,
some
know
the
world
of
spirits
,
some
have
power
to
cure
sick
people
or
help
others
to
solve
delicate
problems
,
some
have
a
sharp
alertness
,
some
have
power
of
clear
sight
or
clairvoyant
,
able
to
predict
,
some
are
very
wise
etc
.
Some
are
having
2
or3
kinds
of
above
abilities
or
some
have
all
the
abilities
.
Once
again
it
depends
to
the
background
and
talent
of
every
personality
.
And
of
course
,
permitted
by
Gusti
/
God
.
A
seeker
of
true
knowledge
,
should
not
be
surprised
upon
witnessing
a
tremendous
spiritual
ability
of
someone
.
He
/
she
has
the
ability
due
to
the
blessing
of
Gusti
/
God
.
Because
a
seeker
of
true
knowledge
could
have
also
spiritual
abilities
(
hopefully
one
day
)
by
doing
spiritual
exercises
as
written
above
and
grasping
the
knowledge
correctly
.
One
thing
to
be
understood
,
the
process
of
learning
true
knowledge
of
Kejawen
,
takes
a
long
time
.
Because
you
are
using
your
own
power
and
ability
.
You
develop
them
step
by
step
until
you
are
in
the
right
track
-
clear
thinking
,
true
feeling
(
roso
sejati
)
,
true
life
(
urip
sejati
)
,
harmonious
relation
between
servant
and
God
.
(
jumbuhing
kawulo
Gusti
)
.
You
won
'
t
get
it
by
miracles
or
outside
help
for
instance
from
spirit
(
s
)
.
The
one
who
help
you
to
gain
this
true
knowledge
is
only
you
,
yourself
.
You
might
say
that
you
would
be
helped
by
your
spiritual
sisters
and
brothers
.
To
some
extent
,
yes
,
but
they
depend
to
you
.
They
could
help
you
to
be
in
safety
or
to
accomplish
some
wishes
or
jobs
or
help
you
to
pray
to
God
.
But
the
one
who
has
to
act
is
you
.
The
comparison
is
like
the
process
of
study
of
a
University
student
,
from
under
graduate
graduate
Master
Ph
.
D
.
it
takes
time
.
The
longer
you
study
,
you
know
more
knowledge
,
when
you
got
your
Ph
.
D
.
you
still
have
to
read
and
learn
more
by
your
own
initiative
.
The
same
in
Kejawen
,
the
process
of
learning
and
practice
never
stop
,
although
other
people
refer
you
as
'
Clever
man
/
woman
'
(
wong
pinter
)
or
'
old
wise
man
/
woman
'
(
piyayi
sepuh
)
.
The
writer
would
suggest
the
esteemed
readers
,
to
read
this
article
in
your
spare
time
.
Hopefully
the
explanation
is
clear
and
could
be
understood
.
At
least
you
know
Kejawen
directly
from
its
genuine
source
.
Perhaps
you
would
use
this
Kejawen
spiritual
teaching
from
far
away
island
of
Java
,
Indonesia
as
a
source
of
comparative
study
.
Probably
,
some
of
you
agree
with
the
flexible
principle
of
Kejawen
.
Or
might
be
,
you
would
try
to
understand
and
further
to
practise
Kejawen
way
to
gain
true
knowledge
,
in
order
to
be
able
to
reach
a
harmonious
relation
with
God
,
to
have
a
perfect
life
(
kasampurnan
urip
)
,
where
there
is
no
more
secret
in
this
life
.
everything
is
opened
i
.
e
.
Reality
(
kasunyatan
)
.
For
these
people
,
you
are
invited
to
read
again
this
article
,
everytime
you
have
a
free
time
until
you
understand
it
completely
.
You
may
practise
'
the
package
of
worship
'
relaxly
while
you
are
healthy
and
have
time
.
Do
it
step
by
step
,
gradually
,
do
not
force
yourself
.
The
time
is
in
the
evening
/
night
as
stipulated
above
,
you
may
start
with
10
minutes
for
several
days
or
weeks
until
you
feel
comfortably
.
If
it
is
all
right
,
you
may
go
further
to
20
minutes
30
minutes
one
hour
.
If
by
practising
it
,
you
feel
good
and
in
a
better
shape
,
it
is
an
indication
that
Kejawen
way
of
worship
and
meditation
are
suitable
for
you
.
You
continue
with
this
spiritual
exercises
on
regular
time
and
in
the
same
place
i
.
e
.
in
your
house
.
You
go
on
with
this
kind
of
exercises
for
6
months
or
a
year
.
Anytime
necessary
,
read
again
the
knowledge
and
the
knowledge
found
in
the
experiences
of
some
people
.
Even
the
'
experts
'
or
people
who
have
gained
true
knowledge
,
from
time
to
time
,
they
read
the
knowledge
to
improve
deeper
and
deeper
their
understanding
of
Kejawen
to
be
closer
to
God
.
Guru
Guru
is
teacher
in
Javanese
and
Indonesian
.
Guru
could
be
a
teacher
in
school
or
a
teacher
in
spiritual
teaching
.
The
Javanese
terminology
for
a
spiritual
teacher
is
Guru
Laku
(
laku
-
way
of
behaving
to
spiritualism
)
or
Guru
Ngelmu
(
Ngelmu
-
spiritual
knowledge
)
.
Some
say
that
Gu
-
Ru
is
acronym
of
di
gu
gu
(
to
be
trusted
)
and
diti
ru
(
to
be
followed
)
means
Guru
is
a
person
who
can
be
trusted
and
be
followed
as
good
example
in
his
words
and
deeds
.
A
very
hard
requirement
for
ordinary
people
.
There
are
several
people
who
have
a
good
knowledge
in
Kebatinan
or
Kejawen
.
Many
people
visit
them
for
consultation
or
help
.
People
call
them
Wong
Pinter
(
clever
person
)
,
Wong
Tuwo
(
old
person
)
in
refine
language
Piyayi
Sepuh
.
But
only
very
view
of
them
who
become
Guru
.
Usually
a
Guru
has
only
several
'
students
'
of
4
,
5
or
8
people
.
He
accepts
students
very
selectively
,
after
he
is
confident
that
the
would
be
students
are
serious
and
should
be
strong
enough
to
understand
and
to
receive
spiritual
knowledge
.
(
see
"
Method
of
Learning
Kejawen
"
Sastra
Ceto
)
It
'
s
like
a
private
or
semi
private
lesson
.
The
subject
of
teaching
are
secret
to
outsiders
.
The
Guru
would
guide
them
step
by
step
by
giving
knowledge
and
the
method
of
exercise
.
In
his
/
her
own
specific
way
,
he
/
she
should
supervise
closely
the
exercise
,
progress
and
achievements
of
the
students
.
He
/
she
would
do
his
/
her
best
,
so
the
students
should
not
practise
mistakenly
.
A
wrong
way
of
practise
and
achievement
in
spiritualism
could
be
dangerous
.
That
'
s
why
almost
all
piyayi
sepuh
(
old
wise
people
)
are
of
the
opinion
,
to
learn
Kebatinan
or
true
knowledge
(
of
spiritualism
)
must
be
with
a
Guru
.
In
that
case
you
have
to
choose
a
wise
Guru
suitable
for
you
.
Guru
is
usually
very
polite
and
low
profile
.
So
sometimes
,
he
/
she
does
not
want
to
be
referred
as
Guru
,
he
/
she
would
say
that
he
/
she
is
only
your
senior
in
learning
spiritual
teaching
.
There
is
no
Guru
who
promote
himself
/
herself
by
looking
for
students
.
The
would
be
student
is
the
one
who
apply
to
be
accepted
as
student
.
There
is
a
good
comparison
.
A
Guru
is
like
a
spring
.
Those
who
need
water
should
come
to
the
spring
to
fetch
some
water
.
After
a
certain
period
of
time
,
the
Guru
would
say
that
he
/
she
has
given
all
the
necessary
knowledge
to
be
able
for
the
students
to
independently
practise
the
spiritual
knowledge
by
themselves
.
Their
relation
continues
not
as
Guru
students
relation
but
as
'
sedulur
'
or
'
kadang
'
(
brothers
and
sisters
)
.
Only
some
of
the
'
graduates
'
should
be
active
wise
persons
(
piyayi
sepuh
)
and
only
certain
active
piyayi
sepuh
are
authorized
by
the
Guru
to
spread
the
spiritual
teaching
by
becoming
an
independent
Guru
herself
/
himself
.
It
is
called
'
Mandireng
'
,
an
independent
spiritualist
who
can
help
others
and
at
the
same
time
becomes
a
Guru
.
Usually
the
'
sedulur
'
(
brothers
and
sisters
in
spiritualism
)
they
have
a
common
perception
of
true
knowledge
but
it
is
not
necessarily
to
having
same
opinion
of
various
issues
.
III
.
Now
,
you
have
a
clearer
picture
of
the
silent
but
existing
world
of
Kejawen
.
Kejawen
is
not
a
narrow
-
minded
spiritual
or
philosophical
outlook
.
Its
flexibility
could
accommodate
the
spiritual
need
of
people
from
different
strata
and
background
.
Kejawen
teaches
us
that
every
human
is
equal
in
front
of
God
.
Every
human
is
given
the
same
chance
by
All
-
loving
God
to
perform
her
/
his
life
at
the
best
.
For
those
who
decide
to
practise
Kejawen
spiritual
teaching
including
'
the
package
of
worship
'
to
be
closer
to
holy
God
the
Almighty
,
you
may
go
on
.
Kindly
follow
the
stipulation
as
explained
in
point
I
.
Be
confident
that
you
are
on
the
correct
path
blessed
by
God
.
So
you
would
be
safe
.
Your
spiritual
sisters
and
brothers
and
Danyang
Smarabumi
should
protect
you
from
any
evil
spirit
.
After
praying
,
before
doing
samadi
,
say
by
heart
:
I
'
eling
'
to
my
life
(
eling
means
remember
.
In
Kejawen
it
has
a
broader
sense
:
remember
what
'
s
right
and
wrong
,
so
you
would
do
only
the
right
thing
)
I
know
'
sangkan
paraning
Dumadi
'
I
come
from
holiness
,
here
in
this
earth
I
live
in
holiness
and
I
'
ll
go
back
to
holiness
.
I
don
'
t
begin
the
life
and
I
don
'
t
end
the
life
.
I
live
together
with
the
Creator
of
life
who
gives
me
life
.
Life
is
eternal
.
My
life
should
not
only
follow
the
wish
of
my
physical
body
(
badan
rogo
)
,
Budi
(
clear
thinking
)
and
lust
.
When
physical
body
does
not
exist
,
so
Budi
and
lust
would
vanish
.
I
love
the
life
of
soul
,
the
real
life
,
the
life
of
light
(
cahya
)
,
the
life
of
Atma
(
the
place
of
life
)
which
are
eternal
,
which
could
guide
me
to
kasunyatan
(
reality
)
.
I
know
Triloka
(
see
'
exposing
the
universe
'
point
45
)
:
Guru
Loka
,
(
head
)
,
Indraloka
(
chest
)
and
Janaloka
(
love
instrument
)
.
I
put
my
mind
from
Guruloka
to
Indraloka
(
touching
your
heart
)
to
be
my
true
feeling
(
roso
sejati
)
.
(
True
feeling
could
receive
true
instruction
and
messages
)
.
I
know
the
life
(
see
'
Exposing
the
Universe
'
point
46
)
If
I
come
back
to
where
I
belong
,
it
will
be
a
perfect
life
.
I
'
eling
'
to
both
of
my
parents
,
mother
and
father
;
(
you
are
grateful
to
them
,
you
have
been
born
due
to
them
and
you
have
been
well
taken
care
)
.
To
my
ancestors
(
you
respect
them
)
;
to
my
parents
-
in
-
law
(
if
you
are
married
)
you
respect
them
.
Sometime
you
pray
for
them
.
I
'
eling
'
to
all
my
spiritual
sisters
and
brothers
.
You
stay
properly
in
your
real
place
,
help
me
and
protect
me
to
carry
out
my
duties
properly
.
I
'
eling
'
to
Guru
Sejati
(
True
Guru
)
who
should
unite
my
life
with
true
life
.
I
'
eling
'
to
true
knowledge
(
ngelmu
sejati
)
.
My
wishes
and
deeds
must
be
in
accordance
with
etiquette
,
moral
principle
.
I
love
others
,
low
profile
,
my
desires
of
5
senses
are
only
for
positive
things
.
I
'
ll
not
hurt
others
,
I
'
ll
not
speak
bad
things
of
others
,
I
'
ll
not
torture
animals
because
they
belong
to
Gusti
/
God
.
I
'
ll
be
patient
(
sabar
)
,
not
envy
to
others
'
success
(
nrimo
)
,
grateful
,
accepting
the
destiny
(
legowo
)
,
always
'
eling
'
believe
in
God
(
percaya
)
and
obey
God
(
Mituhu
)
.
To
realize
the
above
,
I
'
ll
:
Cegah
dahar
(
control
the
appetite
by
taking
moderate
amount
of
food
)
Cegah
sare
(
control
the
sleeping
by
taking
a
rest
when
already
sleepy
)
.
Cegah
sanggama
(
make
love
only
with
legitimate
partner
)
Cegah
duko
(
control
the
anger
)
Cegah
pangandiko
(
control
the
words
,
by
speaking
the
truth
and
politely
)
.
I
'
ll
be
able
to
have
a
blessing
from
God
,
to
take
care
of
good
and
correct
life
on
earth
and
know
true
knowledge
.
I
'
eling
'
to
Danyang
Smarabumi
.
It
is
a
divine
stipulation
that
he
/
she
upon
my
instruction
has
to
protect
me
,
my
family
and
my
house
.
For
that
I
'
m
grateful
and
wish
him
/
her
a
good
life
.
I
am
confident
that
my
life
is
uniting
with
true
life
.
Then
,
peacefully
and
confidently
you
do
samadi
.
If
possible
,
do
the
breathing
through
your
stomach
.
Of
course
,
you
have
to
do
exercise
first
,
before
practising
it
.
When
you
inhale
,
your
stomach
is
swollen
,
like
a
pregnant
women
.
Hold
breathing
When
you
exhale
,
your
stomach
is
flat
,
sunken
.
Breathing
through
stomach
is
good
for
your
health
,
and
it
is
effective
for
spiritual
exercise
.
If
you
have
time
,
before
you
say
the
'
6
eling
'
,
you
might
say
:
I
know
the
elements
of
wind
,
water
,
fire
and
earth
which
are
interrelated
with
the
life
of
mankind
.
If
human
does
correct
thing
,
they
should
be
beneficial
,
otherwise
could
be
disaster
.
I
know
Trimurti
I
know
Hasta
Retna
(
eight
colors
)
I
know
the
5
mystical
lights
I
know
Tridarma
(
Point
1
-
4
,
read
carefully
'
Exposing
the
Universe
'
,
Point
5
,
read
Tri
-
Darma
)
Do
it
relaxly
.
Do
not
force
yourself
,
you
may
do
it
step
by
step
.
Until
you
feel
that
it
is
not
at
all
a
burden
.
You
would
feel
,
if
you
don
'
t
do
it
,
you
don
'
t
feel
comfortably
.
You
are
going
to
be
spiritually
more
sensitive
and
stronger
.
Some
say
you
start
to
have
the
6
sense
.
Don
'
t
worry
,
if
you
happened
to
have
some
mystical
experience
,
your
concentration
is
only
to
God
the
Almighty
based
upon
true
knowledge
.
You
are
a
seeker
of
true
knowledge
!
Hopefully
,
you
got
God
'
s
blessing
.
IV
.
You
have
reached
a
high
grade
in
Kejawen
.
You
know
the
essence
of
the
knowledge
.
When
one
day
,
you
come
to
Java
and
you
meet
experts
of
Kejawen
or
Guru
,
you
know
already
the
most
important
ingredients
of
Kebatinan
or
Kejawen
.
They
will
always
repeat
the
Javanese
terminology
,
you
already
know
the
meaning
.
If
you
wish
to
improve
perfectly
the
true
knowledge
as
taught
in
Kejawen
,
it
is
advisable
to
meet
a
Guru
who
should
guide
you
.
And
if
you
have
time
,
it
'
s
a
good
idea
if
you
could
visit
some
places
in
Mataram
(
Yogyakarta
,
Surakarta
and
surroundings
)
having
strong
spiritual
power
.
(
Mataram
means
clear
vision
.
The
first
kingdom
of
Mataram
established
in
the
6
th
century
.
The
second
Mataram
kingdom
established
in
the
16
th
century
)
.
The
friendly
people
of
the
region
with
breath
-
taking
natural
beauty
and
ancient
precious
cultural
heritage
should
warmly
welcome
you
,
during
your
spiritual
journey
in
the
land
of
Mataram
,
Java
,
Indonesia
For
many
years
Indonesia
has
decreed
that
land
in
Indonesia
can
only
be
owned
by
Indonesian
citizens
.
Thus
,
if
you
want
to
buy
a
house
(
as
a
foreigner
)
,
they
wouldn
'
t
have
let
you
in
the
past
.
In
the
late
90s
,
new
laws
were
enacted
so
that
foreigners
are
now
permitted
to
purchase
apartments
and
office
space
in
Indonesia
if
the
building
has
a
strata
title
status
.
This
enables
the
foreigner
to
own
the
apartment
or
office
space
but
not
the
land
on
which
it
stands
.
Purchasing
an
apartment
or
office
under
Strata
Title
Ownership
of
offices
and
apartments
is
possible
through
strata
title
deeds
,
but
the
set
of
laws
and
regulations
that
were
enacted
in
1996
are
still
somewhat
unclear
and
ambiguous
.
Therefore
,
to
our
knowledge
,
no
foreigner
has
actually
been
able
to
receive
a
strata
title
certificate
of
ownership
to
reflect
their
office
or
apartment
ownership
.
The
1996
regulation
(
No
.
41
/
1966
)
states
that
foreigners
who
reside
in
Indonesia
,
or
visit
the
country
regularly
for
business
purposes
,
can
purchase
a
home
,
apartment
or
condominium
as
long
as
it
isn
'
t
a
part
of
a
government
-
subsidized
housing
development
.
However
,
foreigners
can
only
hold
land
-
use
deeds
,
and
most
developments
hold
right
-
to
-
build
deeds
.
As
it
stands
now
,
it
'
s
not
possible
for
someone
to
have
a
land
-
use
deed
for
a
sub
-
unit
of
a
right
-
to
-
build
deed
.
The
length
of
these
titles
varies
as
well
.
Therein
lies
some
of
the
difficulties
and
unclear
ownership
issues
.
Convertible
Lease
Agreement
One
way
for
foreigners
to
go
ahead
an
purchase
property
despite
these
legal
ambiguities
is
to
sign
a
Convertible
Lease
Agreement
with
the
apartment
property
management
office
to
purchase
an
apartment
.
Basically
what
this
agreement
entails
is
that
the
foreigner
may
purchase
the
apartment
,
but
the
title
is
still
held
in
the
name
of
the
developer
or
property
management
firm
.
This
lease
agreement
is
for
a
definite
period
.
The
Convertible
Lease
Agreement
states
that
if
and
when
the
prevailing
laws
and
regulations
permit
the
Lessee
to
become
legal
owner
of
the
apartment
/
strata
title
unit
,
both
the
Lessor
and
the
Lessee
shall
be
obligated
to
sign
a
Deed
of
Sale
and
Purchase
and
the
title
shall
be
transferred
to
the
foreign
owner
.
If
you
are
interested
in
purchasing
an
condominium
through
this
type
of
agreement
,
investigate
the
property
management
company
thoroughly
.
In
the
current
economic
downturn
many
property
developers
are
undergoing
serious
economic
pressures
and
construction
on
many
properties
has
been
postponed
or
canceled
.
Show
your
contracts
to
a
bona
fide
lawyer
to
ensure
that
all
legal
implications
are
covered
thoroughly
.
Another
way
that
you
can
purchase
a
condo
is
by
purchasing
the
property
and
having
it
in
the
name
of
an
Indonesian
citizen
.
Needless
to
say
,
this
must
be
someone
you
trust
implicitly
since
,
according
to
the
law
,
this
person
would
be
the
legal
owner
.
Single
Family
Dwellings
-
Houses
Ownership
of
single
family
dwellings
faces
even
greater
legal
issues
as
foreigners
are
not
allowed
to
own
land
in
Indonesia
.
Where
the
home
you
want
to
purchase
is
part
of
a
housing
development
,
the
developers
can
often
work
something
out
for
you
to
'
purchase
'
a
home
through
a
long
term
lease
agreement
.
One
reader
writes
of
his
positive
(
and
successful
)
experience
in
this
matter
:
"
Basically
,
I
hold
full
title
to
the
house
,
in
my
own
name
.
The
fact
that
my
wife
is
Indonesian
was
not
considered
(
in
fact
,
my
wife
was
not
considered
at
all
)
.
She
also
owns
property
,
and
we
could
see
no
difference
in
the
title
and
rights
of
mine
.
The
developer
owns
the
land
the
house
is
built
on
,
and
I
own
a
30
-
year
fully
paid
up
lease
on
the
land
,
which
by
law
the
developer
has
to
extend
for
a
further
30
years
on
request
.
At
that
time
they
can
charge
me
a
nominal
rent
,
which
I
can
opt
to
pay
for
now
at
US
$
35
per
year
.
I
can
sell
or
bequeath
(
but
not
sub
-
lease
)
the
lease
together
with
ownership
of
the
house
as
I
choose
.
The
developer
can
sell
the
land
,
but
only
under
the
same
covenants
as
already
exist
.
These
provisions
apply
to
Indonesians
as
well
,
although
Indonesians
could
purchase
the
land
outright
if
the
developer
agreed
to
sell
,
and
Indonesians
could
sub
-
lease
the
land
if
they
want
.
If
my
wife
was
not
Indonesian
,
and
I
was
not
present
in
Indonesia
for
a
full
calendar
year
,
in
theory
the
state
could
take
my
house
unless
I
could
prove
that
"
reasonable
efforts
"
to
sell
had
failed
,
but
just
being
anywhere
in
Indonesia
for
one
day
would
re
-
set
the
clock
.
As
my
wife
is
the
sole
beneficiary
of
my
will
and
is
Indonesian
,
this
rule
does
not
apply
in
my
case
.
I
purchased
the
house
without
finance
;
I
'
m
not
sure
what
effect
there
would
be
in
title
if
you
took
a
loan
or
mortgage
to
assist
with
the
purchase
.
I
would
imagine
getting
a
mortgage
would
be
the
hardest
part
for
a
foreigner
,
and
the
finance
company
would
definitely
retain
powers
to
repossess
in
event
of
default
.
Such
things
are
very
closely
regulated
at
home
,
but
they
probably
have
a
lot
more
scope
for
legally
lining
their
own
pockets
here
.
On
the
subject
of
payment
,
I
paid
the
deposit
in
rupiah
cash
,
because
that
'
s
what
the
developer
wanted
at
the
time
,
but
then
he
preferred
dollars
for
the
balance
,
so
I
paid
dollars
at
a
mutually
acceptable
rate
.
There
are
no
restrictions
on
how
you
pay
for
a
personal
transaction
-
you
could
pay
with
groats
(
or
even
goats
!
)
if
you
wanted
.
"
Buying
Land
By
Indonesian
law
a
foreigner
can
not
own
land
in
Indonesia
.
If
a
foreigner
chooses
,
he
/
she
can
own
land
'
indirectly
'
.
To
do
this
you
need
to
have
an
agreement
between
the
foreigner
and
an
Indonesian
,
signed
with
the
witness
of
a
notary
public
.
In
the
agreement
the
Indonesian
is
the
'
legal
owner
'
while
acknowledging
that
the
foreigner
is
the
'
rightful
owner
'
of
the
land
and
thus
the
Indonesian
owner
would
carry
out
any
instructions
from
the
foreigner
regarding
the
land
,
including
selling
the
land
at
certain
price
with
the
funds
to
be
paid
to
the
foreigner
owner
.
It
is
not
clear
,
however
whether
or
not
these
types
of
agreements
are
at
all
enforceable
under
Indonesian
law
and
the
foreigner
is
at
risk
in
the
true
ownership
of
his
investment
.
All
land
titles
within
Greater
Jakarta
(
DKI
)
are
subject
to
the
conditions
of
Presidential
or
Governor
'
s
decrees
.
Essentially
,
this
affects
the
provisions
for
Hak
Milik
titles
in
the
Jakarta
DKI
area
.
Special
Provisions
for
Batam
The
rules
for
property
ownership
by
foreign
nationals
in
Batam
fall
under
Decree
No
068
/
KPTS
/
KA
/
III
/
1999
.
This
regulations
states
that
foreign
nationals
or
companies
are
permitted
to
100
%
own
residential
or
commercial
property
in
the
Barelang
area
(
Batam
,
Rempang
and
Galang
)
.
The
only
properties
excluded
from
this
decree
are
low
cost
and
very
low
cost
housing
,
but
includes
all
other
types
of
building
structures
.
Hak
Guna
Bangunan
vs
,
Hak
Milik
Hak
Guna
Bangunan
is
only
the
right
to
use
a
building
for
a
certain
period
of
time
and
then
has
to
be
extended
.
The
owner
of
HGB
land
is
the
Indonesian
government
.
Only
with
Hak
Milik
do
you
actually
own
the
land
or
building
.
Hak
Milik
does
not
need
to
be
extended
.
Indonesian
Government
Regulations
regarding
property
titles
Amendment
to
the
Regulation
of
The
State
Minister
of
Agrarian
Affairs
/
Chairman
of
the
National
Land
Agency
No
7
/
1996
"
Foreigners
may
purchase
the
Right
of
Utilization
(
Hak
Guna
Bangunan
)
over
land
with
the
Right
of
Proprietorship
(
Hak
Milik
)
from
the
Holder
of
said
Right
of
Utilization
along
with
houses
or
purchase
the
Right
Utilization
and
later
contract
houses
on
it
.
The
purchase
of
the
Right
of
Utilization
shall
be
conducted
pursuant
to
the
effective
stipulations
that
are
,
by
virtue
of
a
deed
made
by
land
conveyance
,
which
shall
later
be
registered
in
the
Land
Office
.
Likewise
,
the
requirements
or
construction
of
houses
must
abide
by
the
prevailing
stipulations
,
for
example
with
respect
to
the
Building
Construction
Permit
(
IMB
)
.
"
Foreigners
may
own
a
house
and
obtain
the
title
on
land
by
means
of
the
following
:
Purchasing
or
contracting
a
house
on
land
with
the
right
utilization
with
the
right
proprietorship
Purchasing
an
apartment
unit
contracted
on
land
with
the
right
of
utilization
over
state
land
Purchasing
or
contracting
a
house
on
land
with
the
right
of
Proprietorship
or
the
Right
of
Lease
over
building
on
the
basis
of
a
written
agreement
with
the
owner
of
the
land
title
concerned
Source
:
Bali
Property
Before
you
decide
to
sign
on
the
dotted
line
for
any
property
purchase
,
be
sure
to
consult
with
a
reputable
lawyer
who
specializes
in
Indonesian
property
ownership
by
foreigners
to
be
sure
you
understand
the
legal
status
of
your
ownership
.
Consult
your
embassy
or
knowledgeable
friends
for
a
lawyer
that
they
would
recommend
.
For
more
information
on
Foreign
Ownership
Rights
Relating
to
Land
If
you
are
interested
in
learning
more
about
the
legal
issues
of
buying
property
in
a
mixed
marriage
...
Srikandi
has
compiled
a
31
-
page
booklet
entitled
"
Pemilikan
Tanah
Dalam
Perkawinan
Campuran
di
Indonesia
"
.
It
is
available
(
in
Bahasa
Indonesia
)
for
Rp
50
,
000
.
Contact
Srikandi
for
more
information
.
[
Practical
Information
]
[
Expat
Forum
]
[
Site
Map
]
[
Search
]
[
Home
Page
]
[
Contact
]
Tell
a
friend
about
the
Living
in
Indonesia
web
site
Copyright
©
1997
-
2006
,
Expat
Web
Site
Association
.
Jakarta
,
Indonesia
http
:
//
www
.
expat
.
or
.
id
All
rights
reserved
.
The
information
on
Living
in
Indonesia
,
A
Site
for
Expatriates
may
not
be
retransmitted
or
reproduced
in
any
form
without
permission
.
This
information
has
been
compiled
from
sources
which
we
,
the
Expat
Web
Site
Association
and
volunteers
related
to
this
site
,
believe
to
be
reliable
.
While
reasonable
care
has
been
taken
to
ensure
that
the
facts
are
accurate
and
up
-
to
-
date
,
opinions
and
commentary
are
fair
and
reasonable
,
we
accept
no
responsibility
for
them
.
The
information
contained
does
not
make
any
recommendation
upon
which
you
can
rely
without
further
personal
consideration
and
is
not
an
offer
or
a
solicitation
to
buy
any
products
or
services
from
us
.
Opinions
and
statements
constitute
the
judgment
of
the
contributors
to
this
web
site
at
the
time
the
information
was
written
and
may
change
without
notice
.
Moderation
as
the
Pillar
of
a
Peaceful
and
Harmonious
Multi
-
Cultural
and
Multi
-
Faith
Society
:
The
Indonesian
Experience
Jum
'
at
,
22
September
2006
20
:
29
WIB
A
Presentation
by
KH
Hasyim
Muzadi
At
The
High
-
Level
Conference
on
Inter
-
Faith
Cooperation
for
Peace
New
York
,
21
September
2006
Bismillahirrahmaanirrahiim
;
Excellencies
,
Distinguished
Delegates
,
Ladies
and
Gentlemen
;
Assalaamualaikum
Warahmatullahi
Wabarakatuh
;
May
peace
and
God
’
s
blessings
be
upon
us
all
;
At
the
outset
I
would
like
to
congratulate
the
Tripartite
Forum
on
Interfaith
Cooperation
for
Peace
on
the
convening
of
this
High
-
Level
Conference
.
Indeed
it
is
an
honour
for
me
to
have
been
invited
as
one
of
the
speakers
in
this
august
forum
.
I
can
agree
no
more
with
the
significance
of
a
gathering
like
this
to
the
efforts
of
promoting
awareness
,
empathy
,
and
tolerance
,
without
which
realizing
peace
on
earth
will
continue
to
be
elusive
.
And
when
peace
is
so
hard
to
achieve
,
the
road
to
social
and
economic
progresses
will
also
remain
long
and
winding
.
I
believe
that
the
more
opportunities
we
have
for
dialogues
,
the
greater
mutual
understanding
among
different
faiths
will
be
accomplished
.
Only
with
dialogues
can
we
address
differences
,
develop
shared
interests
,
set
common
agenda
,
and
chart
concrete
actions
.
Excellencies
,
I
wish
to
begin
this
presentation
by
expressing
my
gratification
with
the
fact
that
actions
exerted
by
various
stakeholders
at
different
levels
to
enhance
inter
-
faith
dialogue
have
been
increasing
in
recent
times
.
Those
efforts
are
essential
to
the
realization
of
abiding
peace
,
and
at
the
international
level
,
they
are
instrumental
to
the
reversal
of
what
Huntington
predicted
as
the
clash
of
civilizations
.
In
my
view
,
inter
-
faith
dialogue
today
is
no
longer
a
choice
.
It
is
a
must
.
In
the
age
of
democracy
like
today
where
pluralism
is
of
paramount
importance
,
inter
-
cultural
and
inter
-
faith
harmony
is
a
necessary
adhesive
that
could
fortify
societal
cohesion
,
which
is
required
for
the
emergence
of
a
robust
democracy
.
For
countries
with
apparent
multi
-
cultural
and
multi
-
faith
characteristic
like
Indonesia
,
holding
diverse
social
groups
with
different
cultures
and
faiths
in
a
sustainable
way
is
a
daunting
task
.
The
key
ingredient
of
a
successful
multi
-
cultural
and
multi
-
faith
society
,
in
my
opinion
,
is
moderation
(
tawassut
)
,
which
is
the
opposite
of
extremism
(
tatharruf
)
.
Every
religion
teaches
the
importance
of
being
moderate
.
The
significance
of
moderation
in
Buddhism
,
for
example
,
can
be
illustrated
in
the
story
of
spiritual
journey
of
Prince
Siddhartha
.
On
the
way
to
his
enlightenment
Prince
Siddhartha
heard
a
musician
telling
his
disciple
who
was
fixing
a
sitar
:
“
If
you
tighten
the
string
too
much
,
it
will
snap
,
and
if
you
leave
it
too
slack
,
it
will
not
play
.
”
Soon
after
that
the
Prince
received
illumination
,
coming
to
a
conclusion
that
the
path
of
enlightenment
is
in
the
middle
and
it
is
the
line
between
all
opposite
extremes
.
As
in
the
tradition
of
Hinduism
,
Yajur
Veda
40
–
5
teaches
that
for
those
who
want
to
realize
God
the
Supreme
Reality
,
they
have
to
follow
the
path
of
moderation
,
righteousness
and
His
laws
.
And
Bhagavad
Gita
says
dedicated
worship
(
Bhakti
)
through
the
path
of
moderation
will
guide
someone
to
the
Universal
God
.
The
teaching
of
moderation
in
Islam
is
very
clear
.
Islam
emphasizes
moderation
and
balance
in
every
dimension
of
human
conduct
.
The
Koran
says
:
“
We
made
you
to
be
the
community
of
middle
path
(
Al
-
Baqarah
:
143
)
.
Prophet
Muhammad
,
Peace
be
Upon
Him
,
said
:
“
Beware
of
excessiveness
in
religion
.
People
before
you
have
perished
as
a
result
of
excessiveness
.
”
In
my
view
,
moderation
could
close
the
gap
between
conscience
and
doctrine
,
between
what
can
be
achieved
and
what
should
be
achieved
,
between
Das
Sein
and
Das
Sollen
,
and
between
rights
and
responsibilities
.
Together
with
other
virtues
,
namely
peace
(
silm
or
salâm
)
,
justice
(
‘
adâlah
)
,
freedom
(
hurriyyah
)
,
tolerance
(
tasâmuh
)
,
balance
(
tawâzun
)
,
consultation
(
shûrâ
)
,
and
equity
(
musâwah
)
,
moderation
will
free
peoples
from
sufferings
and
guide
them
to
true
happiness
here
on
earth
and
in
the
day
after
.
In
a
reply
to
two
women
from
Tennessee
petitioning
the
release
of
their
husbands
from
prison
in
1864
,
a
year
before
the
American
civil
war
came
to
an
end
,
President
Abraham
Lincoln
wrote
:
“
You
say
that
your
husband
is
a
religious
man
;
tell
him
when
you
meet
him
,
that
I
say
that
I
am
not
much
of
a
judge
of
religion
,
but
that
,
in
my
opinion
,
the
religion
that
sets
men
to
rebel
and
fight
against
their
government
,
because
,
as
they
think
,
that
government
does
not
sufficiently
help
some
men
to
eat
their
bread
on
the
sweat
of
other
men
’
s
faces
,
is
not
the
sort
of
religion
upon
which
people
can
get
to
heaven
.
”
The
sort
of
religion
that
can
deliver
true
happiness
to
humankind
and
get
them
to
heaven
is
the
religions
that
teach
the
values
of
peace
,
justice
,
freedom
,
moderation
,
tolerance
,
balance
,
consultation
,
and
equity
.
Excellencies
,
Let
me
now
shed
some
lights
on
the
nature
of
moderation
in
Indonesia
.
The
history
of
Indonesia
is
the
history
of
moderation
.
The
archipelago
which
is
in
the
present
time
known
as
Indonesia
has
for
long
been
pluralistic
in
terms
of
ethnicity
,
culture
,
and
belief
system
.
This
diversity
is
a
given
characteristic
of
the
archipelago
.
Under
such
a
circumstance
,
someone
could
not
afford
being
self
-
centered
and
taking
extreme
measures
.
Instead
,
he
or
she
should
share
with
others
and
behave
in
a
moderate
manner
so
that
stability
was
ensured
and
harmony
was
sustained
.
Before
Islam
came
into
Indonesia
,
the
archipelago
had
been
undergoing
what
historian
George
Coedés
coined
as
indianization
.
Under
such
a
process
,
Hinduism
and
Buddhism
prevailed
in
most
parts
of
the
archipelago
.
The
influences
of
those
religions
on
the
culture
and
administrative
system
of
the
time
were
profound
.
As
depicted
in
the
lengthy
fourteen
-
century
Javanese
poem
Nagarakertagama
by
Prapanca
,
for
long
Shivaite
Hinduism
and
Mahayan
Buddhism
co
-
existed
harmoniously
and
their
influences
on
private
and
public
life
were
complementary
.
There
were
no
records
of
faith
-
based
extremism
emerging
during
that
period
.
In
the
twelfth
century
or
earlier
,
traders
from
Gujarat
who
traveled
to
the
archipelago
were
carrying
with
them
the
teachings
of
Islam
.
Commercial
interaction
between
those
traders
and
local
people
,
especially
at
port
cities
along
the
coasts
of
major
islands
in
the
archipelago
facilitated
the
acculturation
through
which
local
people
absorbed
the
Islamic
teachings
and
culture
from
the
Gujarati
traders
.
Islam
that
promotes
moderation
was
easily
accepted
by
local
people
who
had
long
embraced
the
value
of
moderation
.
What
happened
when
Islam
began
to
spread
in
Indonesia
was
the
amalgamation
between
religious
moderation
and
cultural
moderation
.
This
mixture
of
moderation
,
in
my
opinion
is
unique
to
Indonesia
.
This
is
also
what
makes
Islam
in
Indonesia
is
somewhat
different
from
Islam
in
the
Middle
East
.
I
do
not
mean
that
Islam
in
other
parts
of
the
world
is
less
moderate
.
As
I
said
earlier
,
moderation
is
the
key
feature
in
all
spectrum
of
Islam
.
But
in
Indonesia
,
the
concordance
between
religion
and
culture
makes
our
moderation
doubled
and
self
-
fortified
.
This
kind
of
moderation
,
in
my
opinion
,
will
prevent
the
emergence
of
Islamic
or
religious
extremism
in
Indonesia
and
will
ensure
the
sustainability
of
viable
pluralism
.
Excellencies
,
As
far
as
moderation
in
Indonesia
is
concerned
,
at
the
societal
level
there
are
groups
serving
as
the
vanguard
of
moderation
and
exerting
deliberate
efforts
to
institutionalize
moderation
in
many
pillars
of
the
Indonesian
society
so
that
a
community
of
moderation
is
continuously
rejuvenated
.
This
is
what
the
Nahdlatul
Ulama
,
the
largest
Moslem
organization
in
the
country
,
over
which
I
have
the
honour
to
preside
,
has
been
doing
since
its
inception
in
1926
.
The
guiding
principles
of
our
organization
are
peace
,
justice
,
freedom
,
moderation
,
tolerance
,
balance
,
consultation
,
and
equity
.
We
put
emphasis
on
substance
and
inclusiveness
,
not
on
formalism
and
exclusiveness
.
The
Nahdlatul
Ulama
has
also
been
working
very
hard
to
mainstream
those
principles
in
the
conduct
of
individual
life
as
well
as
public
sphere
.
The
Nadlatul
Ulama
believes
that
promoting
moderation
at
the
international
level
is
as
important
as
that
at
the
national
level
.
We
believe
that
moderation
is
one
of
the
main
bedrocks
of
a
peaceful
and
stable
international
system
.
We
believe
that
a
community
of
moderation
should
also
come
to
sight
at
the
global
level
.
In
line
with
this
conviction
,
our
organization
has
initiated
an
International
Conference
of
Islamic
Scholars
(
ICIS
)
.
This
is
a
forum
where
Islamic
scholars
of
different
religious
,
academic
backgrounds
,
and
nationalities
meet
regularly
to
exchange
ideas
and
develop
concrete
actions
in
order
to
promote
Islam
as
rahmatan
lil
’
alamin
(
blessing
for
all
universe
)
.
Its
eventual
objective
is
the
creation
of
an
epistemic
community
of
moderation
at
the
global
level
through
which
Islam
could
contribute
to
the
construction
of
global
peace
and
justice
.
Until
now
the
Nadlatul
Ulama
has
organized
two
meetings
of
ICIS
,
in
February
2004
and
in
June
2006
respectively
.
The
first
ICIS
adopted
a
Plan
of
Action
that
outlines
common
perspectives
and
general
recommendations
.
The
second
ICIS
worked
one
step
further
.
It
succeeded
in
adopting
a
Program
of
Action
that
focuses
on
specific
implementation
activities
.
As
stipulated
in
the
Program
of
Action
,
ICIS
II
has
give
me
a
mandate
,
in
my
capacity
as
the
Secretary
-
General
of
the
ICIS
,
to
commission
such
activities
as
a
study
of
practical
ways
to
benefit
from
globalization
,
development
of
techniques
of
conflict
resolution
and
dispute
settlement
based
on
the
Islamic
principles
,
development
of
data
-
base
storing
information
about
philanthropic
organizations
and
educational
institutions
and
their
contribution
to
the
promotion
of
moderation
,
and
a
study
of
possible
establishment
of
a
permanent
secretariat
of
ICIS
in
Jakarta
and
the
application
for
an
observer
status
of
ICIS
within
the
framework
of
various
international
organization
,
including
the
United
Nations
and
the
Organization
of
the
Islamic
Conference
.
At
the
forthcoming
third
ICIS
,
which
it
will
be
convened
in
2008
,
I
shall
have
to
report
the
progress
of
the
implementation
of
the
aforementioned
mandates
.
Hopefully
,
at
the
third
ICIS
,
participants
could
also
agree
on
the
roadmap
for
further
implementation
of
the
Programme
of
Action
to
Uphold
Islam
as
Rahmatan
Lil
Alamin
towards
Global
Justice
and
Peace
.
Insya
Allah
,
may
God
permit
.
Excellencies
,
Before
I
conclude
my
presentation
,
I
wish
to
reiterate
our
support
for
the
work
of
the
Tripartite
Forum
on
Interfaith
Cooperation
for
Peace
,
which
enables
non
-
governmental
organizations
like
the
Nadlatul
Ulama
to
participate
and
to
contribute
to
that
endeavour
.
We
wish
to
connect
our
ICIS
initiative
with
the
Tripartite
and
other
similar
initiatives
.
We
can
mutually
strengthen
our
cause
,
harmonize
our
programmes
,
and
complement
our
resources
.
Partnership
is
essential
in
the
world
that
continues
to
globalize
.
We
cannot
go
alone
.
We
cannot
stand
alone
.
We
cannot
be
just
an
island
of
initiatives
.
We
have
to
work
together
.
We
have
to
be
an
archipelago
of
initiatives
,
a
web
of
cooperation
.
I
thank
you
,
and
Wassalamu
‘
alaikum
Wr
Wb
Cetak
|
Kembali
ke
Arsip
Taushiyah
Komentar
Masukkan
komentar
anda
Great
thought
Luluk
-
(
Senin
,
16
Oktober
2006
15
:
10
WIB
)
Mestinya
kita
memperluas
gagasan
-
gagasan
semacam
ini
.
saya
akan
foward
ke
jaringan
teman
-
teman
internationalku
.
mereka
selalu
bertanya
tentang
'
Abu
Bakar
Ba
'
asyir
"
seolah
tidak
ada
nama
lain
dalam
literatur
Islam
-
Indonesia
,
kecuali
dia
,
JI
dan
daftar
teroris
lain
.
Rabu
,
akan
ada
seminar
penting
(
menurutku
)
di
kampusku
,
dengan
pembicara
John
L
.
Esposito
"
In
The
Name
of
God
"
,
case
on
Radical
Islam
.
see
,
bahkan
literatur
tentang
fundamentalisme
agama
sudah
ada
sejak
abad
17
,
dan
itu
refers
to
Protestan
.
saya
memiliki
data
tentang
daftar
organisasi
yang
termasuk
kategori
teroris
di
dunia
,
75
persen
di
wakili
nama
-
nama
arab
(
baca
Islam
)
.
what
did
happened
?
bagaimana
NU
bisa
more
powerful
?
dengan
50
juta
follower
(
sebagaimana
claim
selama
ini
)
,
masak
gak
bisa
menjadi
counter
-
radicalism
?
atau
diantara
yang
hard
line
itu
malah
sebenarnya
NU
juga
?
any
way
...
lebih
banyak
lagi
artikel
versi
english
ya
...
Salam
How
to
Design
Algorithms
Designing
the
right
algorithm
for
a
given
application
is
a
difficult
job
.
It
requires
a
major
creative
act
,
taking
a
problem
and
pulling
a
solution
out
of
the
ether
.
This
is
much
more
difficult
than
taking
someone
else
'
s
idea
and
modifying
it
or
tweaking
it
to
make
it
a
little
better
.
The
space
of
choices
you
can
make
in
algorithm
design
is
enormous
,
enough
to
leave
you
plenty
of
freedom
to
hang
yourself
.
This
book
is
designed
to
make
you
a
better
algorithm
designer
.
The
techniques
presented
in
Part
I
of
this
book
provide
the
basic
ideas
underlying
all
combinatorial
algorithms
.
The
problem
catalog
of
Part
II
will
help
you
with
modeling
your
application
and
point
you
in
the
right
direction
of
an
algorithm
or
implementation
.
However
,
being
a
successful
algorithm
designer
requires
more
than
book
knowledge
;
it
requires
a
certain
attitude
,
the
right
problem
-
solving
approach
.
It
is
difficult
to
teach
this
mindset
in
a
book
;
yet
getting
it
is
essential
to
become
a
successful
designer
.
The
key
to
algorithm
design
(
or
any
other
problem
-
solving
task
)
is
to
proceed
by
asking
yourself
a
sequence
of
questions
to
guide
your
thought
process
.
What
if
we
do
this
?
What
if
we
do
that
?
Should
you
get
stuck
on
the
problem
,
the
best
thing
to
do
is
move
onto
the
next
question
.
In
any
group
brainstorming
session
,
the
most
useful
person
in
the
room
is
the
one
who
keeps
asking
,
``
Why
can
'
t
we
do
it
this
way
?
''
not
the
person
who
later
tells
them
why
.
Because
eventually
she
will
stumble
on
an
approach
that
can
'
t
be
shot
down
.
Towards
this
end
,
we
provide
below
a
sequence
of
questions
to
guide
your
search
for
the
right
algorithm
for
your
problem
.
To
use
it
effectively
,
you
must
not
only
ask
the
questions
,
but
answer
them
.
The
key
is
working
through
the
answers
carefully
,
by
writing
them
down
in
a
log
.
The
correct
answer
to
,
``
Can
I
do
it
this
way
?
''
is
never
``
no
,
''
but
``
no
,
because
....
''
By
clearly
articulating
your
reasoning
as
to
why
something
doesn
'
t
work
,
you
can
check
if
it
really
holds
up
or
whether
you
have
just
glossed
over
a
possibility
that
you
didn
'
t
want
to
think
hard
enough
about
.
You
will
be
surprised
how
often
the
reason
you
can
'
t
find
a
convincing
explanation
for
something
is
because
your
conclusion
is
wrong
.
An
important
distinction
to
keep
aware
of
during
any
design
process
is
the
difference
between
strategy
and
tactics
.
Strategy
represents
the
quest
for
the
big
picture
,
the
framework
around
which
we
construct
our
path
to
the
goal
.
Tactics
are
used
to
win
the
minor
battles
we
must
fight
along
the
way
.
In
problem
solving
,
it
is
important
to
check
repeatedly
whether
you
are
thinking
on
the
right
level
.
If
you
do
not
have
a
global
strategy
of
how
you
are
going
to
attack
your
problem
,
it
is
pointless
to
worry
about
the
tactics
.
An
example
of
a
strategic
question
is
,
``
How
best
can
I
model
my
application
as
a
graph
algorithm
problem
?
''
A
tactical
question
might
be
,
``
Should
I
use
an
adjacency
list
or
adjacency
matrix
data
structure
to
represent
my
graph
?
''
Of
course
,
such
tactical
decisions
are
critical
to
the
ultimate
quality
of
the
solution
,
but
they
can
be
properly
evaluated
only
in
light
of
a
successful
strategy
.
When
faced
with
a
design
problem
,
too
many
people
freeze
up
in
their
thinking
.
After
reading
or
hearing
the
problem
,
they
sit
down
and
realize
that
they
don
'
t
know
what
to
do
next
.
They
stare
into
space
,
then
panic
,
and
finally
end
up
settling
for
the
first
thing
that
comes
to
mind
.
Avoid
this
fate
.
Follow
the
sequence
of
questions
provided
below
and
in
most
of
the
catalog
problem
sections
.
We
'
ll
tell
you
what
to
do
next
!
Obviously
,
the
more
experience
you
have
with
algorithm
design
techniques
such
as
dynamic
programming
,
graph
algorithms
,
intractability
,
and
data
structures
,
the
more
successful
you
will
be
at
working
through
the
list
of
questions
.
Part
I
of
this
book
has
been
designed
to
strengthen
this
technical
background
.
However
,
it
pays
to
work
through
these
questions
regardless
of
how
strong
your
technical
skills
are
.
The
earliest
and
most
important
questions
on
the
list
focus
on
obtaining
a
detailed
understanding
of
the
problem
and
do
not
require
specific
expertise
.
This
list
of
questions
was
inspired
by
a
passage
in
that
wonderful
book
about
the
space
program
The
Right
Stuff
[
Wol79
]
.
It
concerned
the
radio
transmissions
from
test
pilots
just
before
their
planes
crashed
.
One
might
have
expected
that
they
would
panic
,
so
that
ground
control
would
hear
the
pilot
yelling
Ahhhhhhhhhhh
--
,
terminated
only
by
the
sound
of
smacking
into
a
mountain
.
Instead
,
the
pilots
ran
through
a
list
of
what
their
possible
actions
could
be
.
I
'
ve
tried
the
flaps
.
I
'
ve
checked
the
engine
.
Still
got
two
wings
.
I
'
ve
reset
the
--
.
They
had
``
the
Right
Stuff
.
''
Because
of
this
,
they
sometimes
managed
to
miss
the
mountain
.
I
hope
this
book
and
list
will
provide
you
with
``
the
Right
Stuff
''
to
be
an
algorithm
designer
.
And
I
hope
it
prevents
you
from
smacking
into
any
mountains
along
the
way
.
Do
I
really
understand
the
problem
?
What
exactly
does
the
input
consist
of
?
What
exactly
are
the
desired
results
or
output
?
Can
I
construct
an
example
input
small
enough
to
solve
by
hand
?
What
happens
when
I
try
to
solve
it
?
How
important
is
it
to
my
application
that
I
always
find
an
exact
,
optimal
answer
?
Can
I
settle
for
something
that
is
usually
pretty
good
?
How
large
will
a
typical
instance
of
my
problem
be
?
Will
I
be
working
on
10
items
?
1
,
000
items
?
1
,
000
,
000
items
?
How
important
is
speed
in
my
application
?
Must
the
problem
be
solved
within
one
second
?
One
minute
?
One
hour
?
One
day
?
How
much
time
and
effort
can
I
invest
in
implementing
my
algorithm
?
Will
I
be
limited
to
simple
algorithms
that
can
be
coded
up
in
a
day
,
or
do
I
have
the
freedom
to
experiment
with
a
couple
of
approaches
and
see
which
is
best
?
Am
I
trying
to
solve
a
numerical
problem
?
A
graph
algorithm
problem
?
A
geometric
problem
?
A
string
problem
?
A
set
problem
?
Might
my
problem
be
formulated
in
more
than
one
way
?
Which
formulation
seems
easiest
?
Can
I
find
a
simple
algorithm
or
heuristic
for
the
problem
?
Can
I
find
an
algorithm
to
solve
my
problem
correctly
by
searching
through
all
subsets
or
arrangements
and
picking
the
best
one
?
If
so
,
why
am
I
sure
that
this
algorithm
always
gives
the
correct
answer
?
How
do
I
measure
the
quality
of
a
solution
once
I
construct
it
?
Does
this
simple
,
slow
solution
run
in
polynomial
or
exponential
time
?
Is
my
problem
small
enough
that
this
brute
-
force
solution
will
suffice
?
If
I
can
'
t
find
a
slow
,
guaranteed
correct
algorithm
,
why
am
I
certain
that
my
problem
is
sufficiently
well
-
defined
to
have
a
correct
solution
?
Can
I
solve
my
problem
by
repeatedly
trying
some
simple
rule
,
like
picking
the
biggest
item
first
?
The
smallest
item
first
?
A
random
item
first
?
If
so
,
on
what
types
of
inputs
does
this
heuristic
work
well
?
Do
these
correspond
to
the
data
that
might
arise
in
my
application
?
On
what
types
of
inputs
does
this
heuristic
work
badly
?
If
no
such
examples
can
be
found
,
can
I
show
that
it
always
works
well
?
How
fast
does
my
heuristic
come
up
with
an
answer
?
Does
it
have
a
simple
implementation
?
Is
my
problem
in
the
catalog
of
algorithmic
problems
in
the
back
of
this
book
?
If
it
is
,
what
is
known
about
the
problem
?
Is
there
an
implementation
available
that
I
can
use
?
If
I
don
'
t
see
my
problem
,
did
I
look
in
the
right
place
?
Did
I
browse
through
all
the
pictures
?
Did
I
look
in
the
index
under
all
possible
keywords
?
Are
there
relevant
resources
available
on
the
World
-
Wide
Web
?
Did
I
do
a
Lycos
,
Alta
Vista
,
or
Yahoo
search
?
Did
I
go
to
the
WWW
page
associated
with
this
book
,
?
Are
there
special
cases
of
the
problem
that
I
know
how
to
solve
exactly
?
Can
I
solve
the
problem
efficiently
when
I
ignore
some
of
the
input
parameters
?
What
happens
when
I
set
some
of
the
input
parameters
to
trivial
values
,
such
as
0
or
1
?
Does
the
problem
become
easier
to
solve
?
Can
I
simplify
the
problem
to
the
point
where
I
can
solve
it
efficiently
?
Is
the
problem
now
trivial
or
still
interesting
?
Once
I
know
how
to
solve
a
certain
special
case
,
why
can
'
t
this
be
generalized
to
a
wider
class
of
inputs
?
Is
my
problem
a
special
case
of
a
more
general
problem
in
the
catalog
?
Which
of
the
standard
algorithm
design
paradigms
are
most
relevant
to
my
problem
?
Is
there
a
set
of
items
that
can
be
sorted
by
size
or
some
key
?
Does
this
sorted
order
make
it
easier
to
find
the
answer
?
Is
there
a
way
to
split
the
problem
in
two
smaller
problems
,
perhaps
by
doing
a
binary
search
?
How
about
partitioning
the
elements
into
big
and
small
,
or
left
and
right
?
Does
this
suggest
a
divide
-
and
-
conquer
algorithm
?
Do
the
input
objects
or
desired
solution
have
a
natural
left
-
to
-
right
order
,
such
as
characters
in
a
string
,
elements
of
a
permutation
,
or
the
leaves
of
a
tree
?
If
so
,
can
I
use
dynamic
programming
to
exploit
this
order
?
Are
there
certain
operations
being
repeatedly
done
on
the
same
data
,
such
as
searching
it
for
some
element
,
or
finding
the
largest
/
smallest
remaining
element
?
If
so
,
can
I
use
a
data
structure
to
speed
up
these
queries
?
What
about
a
dictionary
/
hash
table
or
a
heap
/
priority
queue
?
Can
I
use
random
sampling
to
select
which
object
to
pick
next
?
What
about
constructing
many
random
configurations
and
picking
the
best
one
?
Can
I
use
some
kind
of
directed
randomness
like
simulated
annealing
in
order
to
zoom
in
on
the
best
solution
?
Can
I
formulate
my
problem
as
a
linear
program
?
How
about
an
integer
program
?
Does
my
problem
seem
something
like
satisfiability
,
the
traveling
salesman
problem
,
or
some
other
NP
-
complete
problem
?
If
so
,
might
the
problem
be
NP
-
complete
and
thus
not
have
an
efficient
algorithm
?
Is
it
in
the
problem
list
in
the
back
of
Garey
and
Johnson
[
GJ79
]
?
Am
I
still
stumped
?
Am
I
willing
to
spend
money
to
hire
an
expert
to
tell
me
what
to
do
?
If
so
,
check
out
the
professional
consulting
services
mentioned
in
Section
.
Why
don
'
t
I
go
back
to
the
beginning
and
work
through
these
questions
again
?
Did
any
of
my
answers
change
during
my
latest
trip
through
the
list
?
Problem
solving
is
not
a
science
,
but
part
art
and
part
skill
.
It
is
one
of
the
skills
most
worth
developing
.
My
favorite
book
on
problem
solving
remains
Pólya
'
s
How
to
Solve
It
[
Pol57
]
,
which
features
a
catalog
of
problem
solving
techniques
that
are
fascinating
to
browse
through
,
both
before
and
after
you
have
a
problem
.
By
:
Sultan
M
Hali
Journalists
will
say
that
war
is
too
important
to
be
left
to
generals
.
Reporting
of
war
is
too
important
to
be
left
to
reporters
.
Soldiers
need
to
get
involved
in
this
.
Maj
.
Gen
.
Patrick
Brady
-
1990
(
Former
Public
Relations
Chief
of
US
Army
)
The
revolution
in
information
technology
,
from
the
transistor
through
widespread
digitisation
,
deeply
networked
communications
,
as
well
as
,
the
revolutionary
changes
in
the
employment
of
airpower
have
profoundly
influenced
analysts
and
planners
and
has
completely
changed
the
conduct
of
war
.
The
Gulf
War
afforded
the
world
its
first
glimpse
of
the
future
of
warfare
.
Millions
around
the
globe
were
treated
to
precision
guided
bombs
annihilating
targets
in
downtown
Baghdad
,
learned
of
satellite
uplinks
from
the
battlefield
that
provided
real
-
time
connectivity
,
and
applauded
the
ability
of
Stealth
aircraft
to
ensure
aerial
dominance
.
Everyone
seemed
to
understand
that
something
was
different
about
this
Video
-
game
war
.
There
was
much
more
to
the
spectacle
than
the
one
provided
by
previous
wars
.
How
much
of
it
was
real
and
how
much
rigged
,
are
discussed
below
.
More
recently
India
'
s
use
or
rather
abuse
of
the
media
to
dupe
its
own
people
during
the
Kargil
Crisis
is
a
case
in
point
.
The
important
thing
to
note
is
that
the
revolutions
in
the
field
of
information
technology
have
caused
the
media
to
have
a
much
greater
impact
on
operations
.
Thus
it
is
imperative
to
take
a
closer
look
at
the
intricate
relationship
between
the
military
and
the
media
,
and
to
understand
the
role
of
media
in
war
.
The
Military
And
The
Media
:
Who
Needs
Whom
?
The
question
here
arises
:
who
needs
whom
?
Does
the
media
need
the
military
or
do
the
military
need
the
media
?
The
answer
is
,
however
,
not
that
simple
.
Throughout
history
both
institutions
have
been
at
odds
with
each
other
.
The
military
is
perennially
popular
,
but
is
at
its
best
in
battle
and
functions
like
a
conditioned
athlete
.
However
,
it
too
,
has
its
share
of
incompetence
.
So
when
the
military
makes
mistakes
,
they
can
be
monumental
.
Besides
territory
,
a
large
number
of
lives
can
be
lost
.
The
military
are
disciplined
,
hierarchical
and
live
within
a
homogenous
,
closed
culture
that
can
be
and
often
is
hostile
to
outsiders
.
The
news
media
are
often
unpopular
with
the
brass
,
for
they
function
independently
,
without
rules
,
regulations
,
or
even
a
Code
of
Conduct
except
for
some
that
are
self
-
imposed
.
The
media
'
s
Newspapers
,
Radio
,
TV
and
Cable
have
a
variety
of
interests
of
their
own
and
set
goals
to
be
achieved
.
They
have
their
fulsome
share
of
rogues
,
incompetents
and
avaricious
vultures
.
Yet
at
their
best
,
the
media
provide
the
nation
with
a
vital
service
it
can
get
nowhere
else
.
It
is
one
of
the
pillars
of
the
state
.
When
the
two
institutions
meet
during
a
conflict
,
clashes
are
inevitable
.
The
media
wants
to
tell
the
story
,
and
the
military
wants
to
win
the
war
and
keep
casualties
to
a
minimum
.
The
media
wants
freedom
,
no
censorship
,
total
access
and
the
capability
to
get
their
stories
out
to
their
audiences
quickly
.
The
military
on
the
other
hand
,
wants
control
.
The
greatest
fear
of
a
military
commander
in
a
pre
-
invasion
scenario
is
that
something
might
leak
out
that
would
tip
off
the
enemy
.
Otherwise
,
too
,
surprise
is
the
most
potent
weapon
in
the
Commander
'
s
armoury
.
On
the
other
hand
,
the
media
fears
that
the
military
might
stifle
news
coverage
for
enhancing
their
public
image
or
cover
up
their
mistakes
.
Those
are
fundamental
differences
that
will
never
change
.
At
times
the
military
and
the
patriotic
media
also
have
worked
together
in
harmony
but
usually
animosity
tarnishes
their
relationship
.
There
is
definitely
a
need
for
better
understanding
between
the
two
.
A
perfect
co
-
operative
union
of
the
media
and
the
military
is
likely
impossible
,
given
the
differences
in
missions
and
personalities
but
there
are
wise
heads
in
both
institutions
who
recognize
the
mutual
need
.
The
media
is
hungry
for
stories
while
the
military
need
to
tell
their
story
.
Above
all
they
need
public
support
.
The
media
can
tell
their
story
and
if
there
is
a
rapport
and
understanding
,
they
can
tell
it
well
and
effectively
.
Both
institutions
will
work
better
during
the
tension
and
the
fog
of
war
if
they
learn
to
get
along
in
peacetime
.
During
the
wartime
when
there
is
a
life
and
death
struggle
for
the
military
,
personally
as
well
as
institutionally
,
patriotism
comes
to
their
rescue
instinctively
and
through
their
long
training
.
Civil
media
totally
lacks
such
training
and
has
nothing
personal
at
stake
.
Self
-
aggrandizement
seems
to
be
the
raison
d
'
être
of
most
.
War
is
good
for
the
media
business
.
Despite
the
excessive
costs
of
sending
correspondents
for
coverage
,
using
expensive
satellite
equipment
and
airtime
,
armed
conflict
is
precisely
the
type
of
event
on
which
the
media
thrives
.
This
is
an
alarming
situation
and
something
must
be
done
during
peacetime
to
remove
this
dichotomy
.
It
is
for
the
civil
media
to
come
forward
with
the
Remedy
.
And
for
the
military
to
provide
its
own
media
to
fill
the
gap
and
,
more
importantly
to
serve
as
the
role
model
.
Media
As
A
Force
Multiplier
Many
military
leaders
have
become
aware
that
news
media
coverage
of
their
operations
can
be
a
force
multiplier
.
Impressed
by
Gen
.
Walt
Boomer
'
s
example
of
encouraging
favourable
news
media
coverage
of
the
US
Marines
in
the
Gulf
War
to
the
point
where
most
observers
agree
that
the
Marines
received
more
credit
than
they
deserved
,
mostly
at
the
expense
of
the
US
Army
many
military
leaders
have
come
to
the
conclusion
that
media
coverage
not
only
develops
public
awareness
and
the
support
of
military
units
,
it
has
the
side
benefit
of
enhancing
their
morale
by
informing
their
families
and
friends
of
the
activities
of
the
troops
.
If
used
prudently
,
media
is
indeed
a
Force
Multiplier
as
it
builds
public
opinion
.
In
the
words
of
Abraham
Lincoln
:
Public
opinion
is
everything
.
With
it
nothing
can
fail
,
Without
it
nothing
can
succeed
.
How
The
Media
Gathers
Information
The
media
gathers
its
information
from
various
sources
:
-
Overt
Sources
·
Press
briefings
·
Press
releases
/
handouts
·
Supervised
visit
/
tour
of
battle
area
Covert
Sources
·
Own
contacts
·
Electronic
Eaves
dropping
·
Clandestine
Visits
to
battle
area
.
With
communication
networks
now
blanketing
the
globe
and
news
organizations
developing
their
capability
to
report
from
almost
anywhere
,
with
new
technology
such
as
satellite
telephones
,
laptop
computers
,
digital
cameras
and
other
inventions
,
transmission
of
news
is
possible
in
real
time
.
Soon
commercial
,
high
-
resolution
photographic
satellites
will
be
available
to
news
organizations
.
The
capability
of
the
news
media
to
photograph
a
battle
area
during
time
of
war
and
thereby
reveal
the
location
of
one
'
s
own
ground
units
;
ships
and
airbases
could
be
very
detrimental
to
the
national
security
.
This
makes
censorship
virtually
impossible
.
Information
Security
And
The
Military
Culture
Traditionally
,
information
security
implies
the
military
practice
of
reviewing
a
reporter
'
s
news
copy
prior
to
his
filing
to
ensure
that
no
information
of
value
to
the
enemy
was
released
.
This
system
was
effectively
used
during
the
Second
World
War
but
now
technological
innovations
have
called
into
question
the
whole
concept
.
The
Vietnam
Syndrome
leads
most
Americans
to
believe
that
they
lost
the
war
due
to
the
total
freedom
given
to
the
media
in
their
coverage
of
the
war
.
Their
pessimistic
reports
tipped
the
public
opinion
against
the
conflict
.
The
tales
of
atrocities
of
US
troops
on
My
Lai
and
Iwo
Jima
and
,
Jane
Fonda
'
s
radio
speeches
from
North
Vietnam
and
media
reports
of
US
casualties
stirred
public
opinion
in
USA
against
the
War
in
Vietnam
.
In
Desert
Storm
the
Pentagon
decided
to
use
information
security
to
avoid
a
Vietnam
-
like
situation
.
The
imperative
for
secrecy
was
great
,
because
if
Iraqi
commanders
had
had
even
an
inkling
of
the
US
attack
plan
,
they
could
have
repositioned
their
forces
,
jeopardizing
the
success
of
the
operation
and
inflicting
significantly
higher
casualties
on
Allied
Forces
.
The
US
Government
demonstrated
the
means
to
blackout
the
battlefield
anytime
it
so
chose
,
even
in
the
presence
of
hundreds
of
representatives
of
the
World
Media
.
When
a
television
reporter
watching
the
take
off
of
US
fighters
from
a
Saudi
base
began
to
report
that
one
of
the
fighter
aircraft
appeared
to
be
experiencing
mechanical
trouble
,
his
satellite
link
was
shut
down
by
military
electronic
counter
measures
.
A
British
television
crew
tried
to
transmit
news
to
London
without
the
knowledge
of
the
PR
specialists
.
An
airborne
AWACS
electronic
warfare
aircraft
intercepted
their
transmission
and
they
were
promptly
arrested
for
this
breach
of
security
.
The
news
organizations
later
challenged
this
approach
.
When
the
Press
was
kept
away
from
operations
at
Grenada
and
Panama
,
the
media
actually
went
to
court
.
Thus
in
Somalia
,
Haiti
,
Bosnia
and
Kosovo
,
better
sense
prevailed
on
the
military
culture
of
clamping
down
news
information
.
This
has
led
to
an
improved
arrangement
of
:
Security
At
The
Source
Security
at
the
source
,
a
preferred
approach
,
is
a
relatively
new
concept
in
which
the
military
strives
to
develop
a
plan
as
far
in
advance
of
the
operation
as
possible
in
order
to
allow
the
news
media
to
have
broad
access
to
the
total
action
.
Where
feasible
,
journalists
may
be
accommodated
with
the
combat
forces
.
Each
reporter
is
first
accredited
and
then
given
the
ground
rules
with
which
he
/
she
is
expected
to
comply
.
Because
they
will
be
located
shoulder
-
to
-
shoulder
with
the
troops
,
reporters
who
had
questions
about
the
security
aspects
of
the
operation
could
find
someone
to
respond
readily
without
actually
turning
in
their
news
copy
for
review
.
If
the
Security
at
the
source
concept
is
to
work
,
certain
understanding
with
the
media
must
be
reached
.
·
They
must
accept
that
the
military
can
only
effectively
accommodate
a
finite
number
of
journalists
in
combat
operations
.
A
mechanism
must
be
developed
in
peacetime
to
establish
the
strength
of
reporters
.
·
News
organizations
need
to
more
diligently
train
their
reporters
in
the
area
of
military
operations
.
The
best
way
to
do
this
is
to
invite
the
media
for
the
coverage
of
peacetime
military
exercises
.
The
Fog
Of
War
In
wartime
,
the
media
serve
a
variety
of
roles
.
With
information
,
they
can
convey
a
sense
of
the
fighting
to
a
public
divorced
from
its
actual
horrors
or
,
with
entertainment
,
they
can
provide
a
sense
of
relief
or
escape
to
a
public
more
directly
involved
such
as
in
a
blockade
or
bombing
campaign
.
Just
because
they
mediate
information
about
the
progress
of
a
war
to
the
public
,
the
media
can
serve
not
just
as
providers
of
straight
'
news
and
information
but
also
as
agents
of
propaganda
and
disinformation
.
This
is
because
the
very
processes
,
by
which
war
reports
are
gathered
at
source
,
packaged
by
journalists
and
disseminated
to
a
wider
audience
are
subject
to
a
wide
spectrum
of
influences
ranging
from
battlefield
censorship
to
broadcasting
standards
,
deception
and
disinformation
campaigns
,
official
information
policy
and
propaganda
.
These
are
indeed
the
pollutants
,
which
constitute
that
overworked
idiom
:
The
Fog
of
War
.
Journalists
have
a
front
seat
at
the
making
of
history
and
it
is
tragic
that
by
the
time
the
historians
become
involved
that
first
rough
draft
of
history
'
provided
by
the
journalists
has
been
so
widely
disseminated
by
the
mass
media
that
it
becomes
extremely
difficult
to
dislodge
the
pollutants
that
caused
the
fog
of
war
.
Truth
:
The
First
Casualty
Of
War
Robert
Capa
,
the
famous
War
correspondent
and
photographer
,
was
fond
of
saying
,
if
your
picture
wasn
'
t
any
good
,
you
'
re
not
standing
close
enough
.
For
most
journalists
,
however
,
being
read
is
better
than
being
dead
and
it
is
worth
noting
that
perhaps
Capa
'
s
most
famous
photograph
in
Life
magazine
,
that
of
a
Spanish
civil
war
soldier
the
instant
he
is
dropped
by
a
bullet
through
the
head
in
front
of
Cordoba
'
was
in
fact
that
of
a
soldier
stumbling
in
training
during
peace
time
.
A
rule
of
thumb
in
both
the
world
wars
was
to
only
show
pictures
of
the
enemy
dead
.
Own
casualty
figures
have
often
been
minimized
and
those
of
the
enemy
exaggerated
.
Defeats
have
simply
been
omitted
or
delayed
in
reporting
.
Or
explained
as
strategic
retreats
.
While
still
the
First
Lord
of
the
Admiralty
,
Winston
Churchill
,
refused
to
release
news
that
HMS
Nelson
and
HMS
Barham
had
sustained
serious
damage
.
In
1971
,
the
news
of
the
surrender
of
Dhaka
was
considerably
delayed
and
was
relayed
only
after
the
pep
talk
of
PTV
programmes
.
The
sinking
of
HMS
Sheffield
by
an
Exocet
missile
fired
by
an
Argentine
Mirage
aircraft
during
the
Falkland
War
was
omitted
till
it
became
inevitable
to
be
declared
.
The
fall
and
recapture
of
Khafji
in
the
Gulf
War
was
constantly
misreported
.
The
famous
ITN
footage
of
emaciated
Muslim
prisoners
-
of
-
war
,
which
caused
an
international
outrage
in
1992
,
was
banned
on
Serbian
TV
.
Zee
TV
played
hell
with
the
truth
during
the
Kargil
crisis
.
Operation
Desert
Cloud
In
August
1990
,
Iraq
invaded
Kuwait
.
In
the
six
-
month
period
prior
to
the
commencement
of
hostilities
,
the
Pentagon
,
military
and
media
worked
together
to
develop
plans
that
would
make
the
Gulf
War
coverage
the
most
comprehensive
wartime
news
coverage
in
history
.
It
was
also
the
most
massive
cover
-
up
in
history
to
date
.
On
the
opening
night
of
the
US
attack
on
Iraq
,
ABC
anchorperson
Peter
Jennings
made
what
was
perhaps
a
Freudian
slip
,
mistakenly
referring
to
the
start
of
Operation
Desert
Cloud
rather
than
Operation
Desert
Storm
.
In
the
light
of
the
fact
that
many
of
the
US
military
'
s
most
spectacular
claims
in
the
Gulf
War
have
since
proven
to
be
false
,
Jennings
'
s
slip
appears
to
have
been
no
slip
at
all
.
The
problem
was
not
simply
that
the
Pentagon
and
US
administration
misled
the
media
,
but
that
the
media
generally
swallowed
without
question
whatever
the
military
and
the
US
Government
dished
out
to
them
.
They
were
reduced
to
the
level
of
stenographers
.
By
the
time
the
truth
began
to
dribble
out
in
the
war
'
s
wake
,
it
was
too
late
to
erase
the
dominant
image
of
an
inevitable
,
clean
,
bloodless
,
high
-
tech
war
.
Some
Cover
-
ups
and
myths
are
:
-
There
are
countless
examples
of
disinformation
released
to
the
media
by
the
US
administration
and
Pentagon
:
-
USA
beckoned
Iraq
to
Invade
Kuwait
.
A
little
-
noted
poll
in
February
1991
revealed
striking
gaps
in
people
'
s
knowledge
about
the
Gulf
Crisis
.
Only
13
percent
Americans
knew
that
when
Saddam
signaled
he
might
use
force
against
Kuwait
,
the
United
States
through
its
charming
Ambassador
in
Baghdad
had
indicated
in
July
,
1990
that
it
would
take
no
action
,
which
it
certainly
had
none
.
Saddam
offered
to
withdraw
from
Kuwait
.
As
early
as
August
,
1990
,
Saddam
had
sent
messages
through
diplomatic
channels
offering
to
withdraw
from
Kuwait
and
release
all
foreigners
in
exchange
for
the
lifting
of
the
sanctions
,
guaranteed
access
to
the
Gulf
,
and
sole
control
of
the
contested
Rumailah
oil
field
.
Iraq
had
no
intention
of
attacking
Saudi
Arabia
.
Defence
and
intelligence
officials
informed
the
US
administration
shortly
after
the
Kuwaiti
invasion
that
Iraq
had
no
intention
of
invading
Saudi
Arabia
.
Iraq
posed
a
major
nuclear
and
chemical
weapons
threat
.
Prior
to
the
start
of
the
Gulf
crisis
,
US
intelligence
officials
estimated
that
Iraq
would
not
be
capable
of
producing
an
atomic
bomb
for
at
least
five
years
.
But
in
November
1990
,
President
George
Bush
started
claiming
that
Baghdad
will
be
able
to
build
an
atomic
bomb
in
just
six
months
time
insisting
that
the
time
to
attack
Iraq
was
now
.
Iraqi
soldiers
did
not
remove
Kuwaiti
babies
from
incubators
.
Despite
scant
evidence
,
the
allied
media
propagated
that
Iraqi
soldiers
removed
hundreds
of
Kuwaiti
babies
from
their
incubators
,
leaving
them
to
die
on
hospital
floors
of
Kuwait
City
.
Seven
US
Senators
invoked
the
event
in
their
speeches
while
backing
the
January
12
,
1991
resolution
authorizing
war
.
Smart
Bombs
Won
the
War
.
The
world
was
mesmerized
by
Pentagon
-
produced
videos
of
Stealth
bombers
neatly
dropping
sophisticated
laser
-
guided
bombs
down
the
airshafts
of
designated
military
targets
while
mercifully
sparing
nearby
schools
,
hospitals
,
homes
and
mosques
.
Fewer
than
8
%
of
the
bombs
used
by
Allied
Forces
were
Smart
ones
and
of
the
88
,
500
tons
of
munitions
dropped
on
Kuwait
and
Iraq
,
an
estimated
70
%
missed
their
targets
and
caused
massive
destruction
to
civilian
life
and
property
.
The
Patriot
Missile
Performed
Flawlessly
.
Despite
tall
claims
,
experts
testified
before
the
US
Congress
in
spring
1991
that
the
much
-
vaunted
Patriot
missile
may
have
destroyed
only
one
of
the
90
Iraqi
Scud
missiles
fired
at
Saudi
Arabia
and
Israel
.
The
Patriots
actually
increased
the
amount
of
ground
damage
as
they
crashed
into
of
all
places
!
Israeli
streets
.
Muzzling
Negative
Reports
.
There
was
definite
attempt
to
muzzle
negative
reports
.
Some
examples
were
quoted
earlier
.
There
were
numerous
other
examples
.
Associated
Press
(
AP
)
photographer
Scott
Apple
White
was
handcuffed
,
beaten
,
and
had
one
of
his
cameras
smashed
when
15
US
and
Saudi
military
police
officers
descended
on
him
as
he
attempted
to
photograph
the
Dhahran
barracks
where
an
Iraqi
Scud
killed
27
G
.
Is
.
Iraqi
Casualties
.
There
was
widespread
silence
about
Iraqi
casualties
;
Green
peace
has
calculated
that
57
,
000
to
75
,
000
members
of
Iraqi
military
died
during
the
Gulf
War
while
3
,
000
Iraqi
civilians
were
killed
in
the
air
war
.
Tapes
of
attacks
by
Apache
helicopter
pilots
,
who
were
not
released
;
revealed
Iraqi
soldiers
being
killed
mercilessly
as
they
were
fleeing
their
bunkers
while
thousands
were
gunned
down
during
their
retreat
on
the
open
highway
to
Iraq
.
Saddam
Learns
from
Vietnam
Syndrome
.
Saddam
Hussein
learned
his
own
lessons
from
the
Vietnam
Syndrome
.
CNN
'
s
Peter
Arnett
was
permitted
to
remain
in
Iraq
to
report
on
the
other
side
of
the
war
.
He
was
accused
by
the
White
House
of
Speaking
for
the
Iraqi
Government
,
by
Gen
.
Norman
Schwarzkopf
of
aiding
and
abetting
an
enemy
and
by
Col
.
Harry
Summers
,
Public
Affairs
advisor
of
treason
.
Saddam
Hussein
used
Peter
Arnett
to
his
own
advantage
by
trying
to
create
a
public
outcry
in
the
allied
nations
by
allowing
CNN
to
transmit
pictures
of
the
destruction
of
a
Chemical
Weapons
Complex
with
freshly
scrawled
Baby
Milk
Factory
in
English
,
parading
captured
Allied
pilots
on
Iraqi
TV
,
declaring
their
disapproval
of
the
war
and
displaying
the
charred
bodies
of
hundreds
of
civilians
killed
by
Allied
air
attacks
on
air
-
raid
shelters
.
Unfortunately
for
Saddam
,
his
ploy
did
not
work
.
It
was
merely
a
drop
in
the
Allied
scum
tide
.
Perhaps
it
helped
the
Allied
propaganda
machine
by
providing
a
posture
of
objectivity
.
Kargil
A
Watershed
For
Indian
Media
?
We
must
draw
important
lessons
from
the
recent
crisis
in
our
own
backyard
,
Kargil
.
A
discussion
on
the
strategic
brilliance
of
the
operation
,
the
moral
aspects
,
the
efficacy
of
the
move
are
beyond
the
scope
of
article
.
We
must
take
cognisance
of
the
brilliant
use
of
media
by
India
to
salvage
some
pride
from
the
mauling
it
received
on
the
snowy
peaks
of
Kargil
.
Kargil
became
one
of
the
worst
nightmares
for
India
.
It
not
only
caught
them
napping
,
but
also
exposed
their
extreme
vulnerabilities
and
resulted
in
very
high
casualties
.
Having
said
that
,
we
must
credit
the
Indians
for
their
resilience
and
for
their
highly
successful
media
and
diplomatic
campaign
.
The
way
Indian
media
responded
to
the
crisis
,
mobilized
its
resources
and
organized
Television
programmes
,
newspaper
reports
,
analyses
,
discussions
,
features
,
the
famous
rogue
army
posters
and
a
wide
array
of
coverage
convinced
the
world
that
Pakistan
was
on
the
wrong
foot
and
the
Indians
were
the
aggrieved
party
.
The
Chanakyan
principles
of
deceit
and
lies
were
fully
exploited
to
dupe
their
own
countrymen
.
To
enhance
their
lies
and
sanitize
the
Indian
public
from
the
truth
,
PTV
was
banned
from
Cable
networks
in
India
and
Pakistani
newspapers
were
blocked
on
the
Internet
.
They
also
made
a
very
intelligent
use
of
the
Internet
and
dedicated
an
exclusive
Website
www
.
vijayinkargil
.
com
to
spread
their
propaganda
.
Trained
PR
officers
manned
chat
sites
on
the
web
.
We
on
the
other
hand
,
could
not
launch
an
adequate
counter
attack
on
the
media
front
.
Even
their
very
obvious
lies
and
claims
of
Vijay
or
victory
could
not
be
exposed
.
India
did
not
permit
media
personnel
to
visit
Kargil
,
Dras
or
Batalik
sectors
.
Zee
TV
and
the
32
Indian
Channels
continued
to
spew
venom
against
Pakistan
but
we
lacked
the
wherewithal
and
the
will
power
to
tackle
them
on
this
extremely
volatile
front
.
Obvious
lies
like
Tiger
Hill
,
the
use
of
Mirage
-
2000
HUD
displays
with
doctored
information
were
continuously
being
telecast
with
serious
TV
News
Channels
like
BBC
and
CNN
re
-
transmitting
them
.
Important
Media
Lessons
from
the
Gulf
War
and
Kargil
Those
who
do
not
learn
from
history
are
relegated
to
become
a
part
of
history
.
It
is
important
to
draw
lessons
so
that
past
mistakes
in
the
employment
of
media
in
war
can
be
avoided
.
·
Public
opinion
must
be
supportive
as
whole
nations
go
to
war
not
just
the
armed
forces
.
The
media
can
build
public
opinion
.
·
Operational
secrecy
in
modern
limited
wars
now
requires
the
active
connivance
of
the
media
.
·
Conflict
of
Interest
can
also
come
into
play
.
The
media
involved
in
the
Gulf
War
had
ties
to
the
US
arms
industry
e
.
g
.
NBC
,
which
is
owned
by
General
Electric
produces
aircraft
and
missiles
,
like
the
widely
reported
Tomahawk
Cruise
missile
and
the
Patriot
Air
Defence
System
.
Thus
the
propaganda
effect
may
be
market
oriented
and
in
effect
advertising
campaign
.
·
There
is
a
need
for
reporters
to
be
educated
about
the
military
and
the
military
about
the
media
.
·
Media
coverage
is
a
force
multiplier
.
People
get
their
perception
of
the
military
as
a
dedicated
and
professional
organization
from
media
reports
so
closer
trust
and
confidence
must
be
created
.
Four
hostile
newspapers
are
more
to
be
feared
than
a
thousand
bayonets
.
Napoleon
·
Technology
has
had
a
tremendous
impact
on
media
.
It
must
be
assimilated
.
News
media
and
military
leaders
should
jointly
engage
in
a
study
of
the
security
issues
posed
by
real
-
time
reporting
from
the
battlefield
.
·
The
media
is
as
patriotic
as
anybody
else
in
the
civil
life
is
.
We
need
to
build
trust
.
·
Talk
to
the
media
but
without
ebullience
and
boast
.
The
USAF
Chief
of
Staff
Gen
.
Michael
I
.
Dugan
was
sacked
in
September
1990
for
inadvertently
revealing
air
strike
plans
to
the
media
,
during
a
casual
conversation
.
·
Deception
has
formed
a
part
of
warfare
since
the
Trojan
Horse
but
the
incorporation
of
the
media
into
such
exercises
is
a
highly
dangerous
game
.
If
the
free
media
,
even
patriotic
media
,
discover
that
they
are
being
used
for
such
purposes
,
they
are
likely
to
distance
themselves
from
the
exercise
.
They
may
not
expect
to
be
told
the
whole
truth
during
wartime
,
but
they
do
expect
to
be
told
as
much
of
the
truth
as
can
be
told
without
jeopardising
military
operations
and
the
lives
of
troops
.
·
The
most
effective
way
of
censoring
the
media
is
simply
to
deny
them
access
as
was
effectively
carried
out
by
the
Indians
in
Kargil
or
the
pool
system
in
the
Gulf
War
.
This
can
backfire
,
as
the
press
can
become
volatile
.
The
Indians
got
away
with
it
in
Kargil
by
appealing
to
the
Indian
media
'
s
sense
of
patriotism
.
·
Air
power
is
a
very
difficult
phenomenon
for
the
media
.
Most
coverage
has
to
consist
of
interviews
with
pilots
and
aircrew
before
or
after
the
missions
or
footage
of
take
offs
and
landings
.
AVTR
recordings
and
gun
camera
clips
cannot
be
released
directly
.
Both
the
Allies
in
the
Gulf
War
and
Indians
in
Kargil
resorted
to
doctoring
video
clips
.
The
reality
of
air
war
evades
the
media
war
.
·
Media
Spin
has
become
a
new
principle
of
war
.
Media
Spin
is
defined
as
paying
close
attention
to
public
relations
,
recognizing
that
public
support
is
an
essential
ingredient
of
combat
success
.
The
military
must
not
take
media
coverage
of
combat
operations
for
granted
,
and
should
avoid
operations
that
will
alienate
public
support
,
while
ensuring
maximum
media
coverage
of
success
stories
:
In
an
age
where
24
-
hour
instantaneous
battlefield
news
coverage
is
a
fact
of
life
,
paying
attention
to
media
spin
is
of
paramount
importance
for
a
combat
commander
.
·
It
is
impossible
now
to
assume
a
Janus
-
like
posture
:
that
of
a
Holy
Warrior
guarding
the
ideological
frontiers
,
for
home
consumption
,
and
,
that
of
a
modern
,
moderate
thinking
well
-
disciplined
armed
forces
for
the
outsiders
.
All
pervasive
,
ubiquitous
media
makes
it
fail
on
both
the
fronts
.
Conclusion
After
assimilating
the
role
of
the
media
in
war
,
and
getting
a
glimpse
of
the
impact
of
technology
on
news
reporting
,
the
role
played
by
media
in
two
recent
conflicts
,
it
must
raise
questions
in
our
mind
that
whereas
the
military
trains
hard
and
well
to
achieve
its
goals
and
reach
a
level
of
specialization
yet
we
call
upon
the
media
,
which
is
perhaps
the
only
career
which
starts
its
profession
with
zero
specialization
and
most
reporters
don
'
t
know
the
difference
between
a
company
and
a
brigade
,
a
destroyer
and
a
Fleet
Tanker
or
an
F
-
16
and
M
-
16
,
to
tell
the
story
of
the
military
.
This
is
all
the
more
valid
in
view
of
the
general
level
of
education
in
our
country
.
That
makes
it
all
the
more
imperative
for
building
greater
harmony
and
understanding
.
We
will
keep
shooting
ourselves
in
the
foot
if
we
don
'
t
realize
the
potentials
of
media
as
a
force
multiplier
and
a
weapon
of
war
.
Failure
to
recognize
and
counter
enemy
usage
of
media
could
lead
to
avoidable
military
failures
.
We
must
realize
that
decisions
are
no
longer
based
on
events
but
on
how
the
events
are
presented
.
So
we
must
lay
greater
emphasis
on
the
role
of
media
in
war
and
train
for
it
in
peacetime
.
It
would
be
impossible
to
visit
or
live
in
Indonesia
and
not
be
exposed
to
one
of
the
country
'
s
most
highly
developed
art
forms
,
batik
.
On
your
first
visit
to
a
batik
store
or
factory
you
will
undoubtedly
experience
an
overwhelming
stimulation
of
the
senses
-
due
to
the
many
colors
,
patterns
and
the
actual
smell
of
batik
.
Only
through
repeated
visits
and
a
bit
of
study
will
the
types
of
designs
and
their
origins
become
apparent
.
The
word
batik
is
thought
to
be
derived
from
the
word
'
ambatik
'
which
translated
means
'
a
cloth
with
little
dots
'
.
The
suffix
'
tik
'
means
little
dot
,
drop
,
point
or
to
make
dots
.
Batik
may
also
originate
from
the
Javanese
word
'
tritik
'
which
describes
a
resist
process
for
dying
where
the
patterns
are
reserved
on
the
textiles
by
tying
and
sewing
areas
prior
to
dying
,
similar
to
tie
dye
techniques
.
Another
Javanese
phase
for
the
mystical
experience
of
making
batik
is
“
mbatik
manah
”
which
means
“
drawing
a
batik
design
on
the
heart
”
.
A
Brief
History
Although
experts
disagree
as
to
the
precise
origins
of
batik
,
samples
of
dye
resistance
patterns
on
cloth
can
be
traced
back
1
,
500
years
ago
to
Egypt
and
the
Middle
East
.
Samples
have
also
been
found
in
Turkey
,
India
,
China
,
Japan
and
West
Africa
from
past
centuries
.
Although
in
these
countries
people
were
using
the
technique
of
dye
resisting
decoration
,
within
the
textile
realm
,
none
have
developed
batik
to
its
present
day
art
form
as
the
highly
developed
intricate
batik
found
on
the
island
of
Java
in
Indonesia
.
Although
there
is
mention
of
'
fabrics
highly
decorated
'
in
Dutch
transcripts
from
the
17th
century
,
most
scholars
believe
that
the
intricate
Javanese
batik
designs
would
only
have
been
possible
after
the
importation
of
finely
woven
imported
cloth
,
which
was
first
imported
to
Indonesia
from
India
around
the
1800s
and
afterwards
from
Europe
beginning
in
1815
.
Textile
patterns
can
be
seen
on
stone
statues
that
are
carved
on
the
walls
of
ancient
Javanese
temples
such
as
Prambanan
(
AD
800
)
,
however
there
is
no
conclusive
evidence
that
the
cloth
is
batik
.
It
could
possibly
be
a
pattern
that
was
produced
with
weaving
techniques
and
not
dying
.
What
is
clear
is
that
in
the
19th
century
batik
became
highly
developed
and
was
well
ingrained
in
Javanese
cultural
life
.
Some
experts
feel
that
batik
was
originally
reserved
as
an
art
form
for
Javanese
royalty
.
Certainly
it
'
s
royal
nature
was
clear
as
certain
patterns
were
reserved
to
be
worn
only
by
royalty
from
the
Sultan
'
s
palace
.
Princesses
and
noble
women
may
have
provided
the
inspiration
for
the
highly
refined
design
sense
evident
in
traditional
patterns
.
It
is
highly
unlikely
though
that
they
would
be
involved
in
any
more
than
the
first
wax
application
.
Most
likely
,
the
messy
work
of
dyeing
and
subsequent
waxings
was
left
to
court
artisans
who
would
work
under
their
supervision
.
Javanese
royalty
were
known
to
be
great
patrons
of
the
arts
and
provided
the
support
necessary
to
develop
many
art
forms
,
such
as
silver
ornamentation
,
wayang
kulit
(
leather
puppets
)
and
gamelan
orchestras
.
In
some
cases
the
art
forms
overlap
.
The
Javanese
dalang
(
puppeteer
)
not
only
was
responsible
for
the
wayang
puppets
but
was
also
an
important
source
of
batik
patterns
.
Wayang
puppets
are
usually
made
of
goat
skin
,
which
is
then
perforated
and
painted
to
create
the
illusion
of
clothing
on
the
puppet
.
Used
puppets
were
often
sold
to
eager
ladies
who
used
the
puppets
as
guides
for
their
batik
patterns
.
They
would
blow
charcoal
through
the
holes
that
define
the
patterns
of
clothing
on
the
puppets
,
in
order
to
copy
the
intricate
designs
onto
the
cloth
.
Other
scholars
disagree
that
batik
was
only
reserved
as
an
art
form
for
royalty
,
as
they
also
feel
its
use
was
prevalent
with
the
rakyat
,
the
people
.
It
was
regarded
an
important
part
of
a
young
ladies
accomplishment
that
she
be
capable
of
handling
a
canting
(
the
pen
-
like
instrument
used
to
apply
wax
to
the
cloth
)
with
a
reasonable
amount
of
skill
,
certainly
as
important
as
cookery
and
other
housewifery
arts
to
Central
Javanese
women
.
Selection
and
Preparation
of
the
Cloth
Natural
materials
such
as
cotton
or
silk
are
used
for
the
cloth
,
so
that
it
can
absorb
the
wax
that
is
applied
in
the
dye
resisting
process
.
The
fabrics
must
be
of
a
high
thread
count
(
densely
woven
)
.
It
is
important
that
cloth
of
high
quality
have
this
high
thread
count
so
that
the
intricate
design
qualities
of
batik
can
be
maintained
.
The
cloth
that
is
used
for
batik
is
washed
and
boiled
in
water
many
times
prior
to
the
application
of
wax
so
that
all
traces
of
starches
,
lime
,
chalk
and
other
sizing
materials
are
removed
.
Prior
to
the
implementation
of
modern
day
techniques
,
the
cloth
would
have
been
pounded
with
a
wooden
mallet
or
ironed
to
make
it
smooth
and
supple
so
it
could
best
receive
the
wax
design
.
With
the
finer
machine
-
made
cotton
available
today
,
the
pounding
or
ironing
processes
can
be
omitted
.
Normally
men
did
this
step
in
the
batik
process
.
Strict
industry
standards
differentiate
the
different
qualities
of
the
cloth
used
today
,
which
include
Primissima
(
the
best
)
and
Prima
.
The
cloth
quality
is
often
written
on
the
edge
of
the
design
.
A
lesser
quality
cloth
which
is
often
used
in
Blaco
.
Design
Tools
Although
the
art
form
of
batik
is
very
intricate
,
the
tools
that
are
used
are
still
very
simple
.
The
canting
,
believed
to
be
a
purely
Javanese
invention
,
is
a
small
thin
wall
spouted
copper
container
(
sometimes
called
a
wax
pen
)
that
is
connected
to
a
short
bamboo
handle
.
Normally
it
is
approximately
11
cm
.
in
length
.
The
copper
container
is
filled
with
melted
wax
and
the
artisan
then
uses
the
canting
to
draw
the
design
on
the
cloth
.
Canting
have
different
sizes
of
spouts
(
numbered
to
correspond
to
the
size
)
to
achieve
varied
design
effects
.
The
spout
can
vary
from
1
mm
in
diameter
for
very
fine
detailed
work
to
wider
spouts
used
to
fill
in
large
design
areas
.
Dots
and
parallel
lines
may
be
drawn
with
canting
that
have
up
to
9
spouts
.
Sometimes
a
wad
of
cotton
is
fastened
over
the
mouth
of
the
canting
or
attached
to
a
stick
that
acts
as
a
brush
to
fill
in
very
large
areas
.
For
close
-
up
pictures
of
canting
.
Wajan
The
wajan
is
the
container
that
holds
the
melted
wax
.
It
looks
like
a
small
wok
.
Normally
it
is
made
of
iron
or
earthenware
.
The
wajan
is
placed
on
a
small
brick
charcoal
stove
or
a
spirit
burner
called
an
'
anglo
'
.
The
wax
is
kept
in
a
melted
state
while
the
artisan
is
applying
the
wax
to
the
cloth
.
Wax
Different
kinds
and
qualities
of
wax
are
used
in
batik
.
Common
waxes
used
for
batik
consist
of
a
mixture
of
beeswax
,
used
for
its
malleability
,
and
paraffin
,
used
for
its
friability
.
Resins
can
be
added
to
increase
adhesiveness
and
animal
fats
create
greater
liquidity
.
The
best
waxes
are
from
the
Indonesian
islands
of
Timor
,
Sumbawa
and
Sumatra
;
three
types
of
petroleum
-
based
paraffin
(
white
,
yellow
and
black
)
are
used
.
The
amounts
mixed
are
measured
in
grams
and
vary
according
to
the
design
.
Wax
recipes
can
be
very
closely
guarded
secrets
.
Varying
colors
of
wax
make
it
possible
to
disguise
different
parts
of
the
pattern
through
the
various
dying
stages
.
Larger
areas
of
the
pattern
are
filled
in
with
wax
that
is
cheaper
quality
and
the
higher
quality
wax
is
used
on
the
more
intricately
detailed
sections
of
the
design
.
The
wax
must
be
kept
at
the
proper
temperature
.
A
wax
that
is
too
cool
will
clog
the
spout
of
the
canting
.
A
wax
that
is
too
hot
will
flow
too
quickly
and
be
uncontrollable
.
The
artisan
will
often
blow
into
the
spout
of
the
canting
before
applying
wax
to
the
cloth
in
order
to
clear
the
canting
of
any
obstructions
.
Cap
Creating
batik
is
a
very
time
consuming
craft
.
To
meet
growing
demands
and
make
the
fabric
more
affordable
to
the
masses
,
in
the
mid
-
19th
century
the
.
cap
.
(
copper
stamp
-
pronounced
chop
)
was
developed
.
This
invention
enabled
a
higher
volume
of
batik
production
compared
to
the
traditional
method
which
entailed
the
tedious
application
of
wax
by
hand
with
a
canting
.
Each
cap
is
a
copper
block
that
makes
up
a
design
unit
.
Cap
are
made
of
1
.
5
cm
wide
copper
stripes
that
are
bent
into
the
shape
of
the
design
.
Smaller
pieces
of
wire
are
used
for
the
dots
.
When
complete
,
the
pattern
of
copper
strips
is
attached
to
the
handle
.
The
cap
must
be
precisely
made
.
This
is
especially
true
if
the
pattern
is
to
be
stamped
on
both
sides
of
the
fabric
.
It
is
imperative
that
both
sides
of
the
cap
are
identical
so
that
pattern
will
be
consistent
.
Sometimes
cap
are
welded
between
two
grids
like
pieces
of
copper
that
will
make
a
base
for
the
top
and
the
bottom
.
The
block
is
cut
in
half
at
the
center
so
the
pattern
on
each
half
is
identical
.
Cap
vary
in
size
and
shape
depending
on
the
pattern
they
are
needed
for
.
It
is
seldom
that
a
cap
will
exceed
24
cm
in
diameter
,
as
this
would
make
the
handling
too
difficult
.
Men
usually
handle
the
application
of
wax
using
cap
.
A
piece
of
cloth
that
involves
a
complicated
design
could
require
as
many
as
ten
sets
of
cap
.
The
usage
of
cap
,
as
opposed
to
canting
,
to
apply
the
wax
has
reduced
the
amount
of
time
to
make
a
cloth
.
Today
,
batik
quality
is
defined
by
cap
or
tulis
,
the
second
meaning
hand
-
drawn
designs
which
use
a
canting
,
or
kombinasi
,
a
combination
of
the
two
techniques
.
Dyes
Traditional
colors
for
Central
Javanese
batik
were
made
from
natural
ingredients
and
consisted
primarily
of
beige
,
blue
,
brown
and
black
.
The
oldest
color
that
was
used
in
traditional
batik
making
was
blue
.
The
color
was
made
from
the
leaves
of
the
Indigo
plant
.
The
leaves
were
mixed
with
molasses
sugar
and
lime
and
left
to
stand
overnight
.
Sometimes
sap
from
the
Tinggi
tree
was
added
to
act
as
a
fixing
agent
.
Lighter
blue
was
achieved
by
leaving
the
cloth
in
the
dye
bath
for
short
periods
of
time
.
For
darker
colors
,
the
cloth
would
be
left
in
the
dye
bath
for
days
and
may
have
been
submerged
up
to
8
-
10
times
a
day
.
In
traditional
batik
,
the
second
color
applied
was
a
brown
color
called
soga
.
The
color
could
range
from
light
yellow
to
a
dark
brown
.
The
dye
came
from
the
bark
of
the
Soga
tree
.
Another
color
that
was
traditionally
used
was
a
dark
red
color
called
mengkuda
.
This
dye
was
created
from
the
leaves
of
the
Morinda
Citrifolia
.
The
final
hue
depended
on
how
long
the
cloth
was
soaked
in
the
dye
bath
and
how
often
it
was
dipped
.
Skilled
artisans
can
create
many
variations
of
these
traditional
colors
.
Aside
from
blue
,
green
would
be
achieved
by
mixing
blue
with
yellow
;
purple
was
obtained
by
mixing
blue
and
red
.
The
soga
brown
color
mixed
with
indigo
would
produce
a
dark
blue
-
black
color
.
Design
Process
The
outline
of
the
pattern
is
blocked
out
onto
the
cloth
,
traditionally
with
charcoal
or
graphite
.
Traditional
batik
designs
utilize
patterns
handed
down
over
the
generations
.
It
is
very
seldom
that
an
artisan
is
so
skilled
that
he
can
work
from
memory
and
would
not
need
to
draw
an
outline
of
the
pattern
before
applying
the
wax
.
Often
designs
are
traced
from
stencils
or
patterns
called
pola
.
Another
method
of
tracing
a
pattern
onto
a
cloth
is
by
laying
the
cloth
on
a
glass
table
that
is
illuminated
from
below
which
casts
a
shadow
of
the
pattern
onto
the
cloth
.
The
shadow
is
then
traced
with
a
pencil
.
In
large
batik
factories
today
,
men
usually
are
in
charge
of
drawing
the
patterns
onto
the
cloth
.
Click
here
to
see
the
step
-
by
-
step
process
of
making
batik
.
Waxing
Once
the
design
is
drawn
out
onto
the
cloth
it
is
then
ready
to
be
waxed
.
Wax
is
applied
to
the
cloth
over
the
areas
of
the
design
that
the
artisan
wishes
to
remain
the
original
color
of
the
cloth
.
Normally
this
is
white
or
cream
.
Female
workers
sit
on
a
low
stool
or
on
a
mat
to
apply
the
wax
with
a
canting
.
The
fabric
that
they
are
working
on
is
draped
over
light
bamboo
frames
called
gawangan
to
allow
the
freshly
applied
wax
to
cool
and
harden
.
The
wax
is
heated
in
the
wajan
until
it
is
of
the
desired
consistency
.
The
artisan
then
dips
her
canting
into
the
wax
to
fill
the
bowl
of
the
canting
.
Artisans
use
the
wax
to
retrace
the
pencil
outline
on
the
fabric
.
A
small
drop
cloth
is
kept
on
the
woman
.
s
lap
to
protect
her
from
hot
dripping
wax
.
The
stem
of
the
canting
is
held
with
the
right
hand
in
a
horizontal
position
to
prevent
any
accidental
spillage
,
which
greatly
reduces
the
value
of
the
final
cloth
.
The
left
hand
is
placed
behind
the
fabric
for
support
.
The
spout
does
not
touch
the
fabric
,
but
it
held
just
above
the
area
the
artisan
is
working
on
.
To
ensure
the
pattern
is
well
defined
,
batik
is
waxed
on
both
sides
.
True
tulis
batik
is
reversible
,
as
the
pattern
should
be
identical
on
both
sides
.
The
most
experienced
artisans
normally
do
first
waxings
.
Filling
in
of
large
areas
may
be
entrusted
to
less
experienced
artisans
.
Mistakes
are
very
difficult
to
correct
.
If
wax
is
accidentally
spilt
on
the
cloth
,
the
artisan
will
try
to
remove
the
unwanted
wax
by
sponging
it
with
hot
water
.
Then
a
heated
iron
rod
with
a
curved
end
is
used
to
try
and
lift
off
the
remaining
wax
.
Spilled
wax
can
never
be
completely
removed
so
it
is
imperative
that
the
artisans
are
very
careful
.
If
the
cap
method
is
utilized
,
this
procedure
is
normally
done
by
men
.
The
cap
are
dipped
into
melted
wax
.
Just
under
the
surface
of
the
melted
wax
is
a
folded
cloth
approximately
30
centimeters
square
.
When
this
cloth
is
saturated
with
wax
it
acts
like
a
stamp
pad
.
The
cap
is
pressed
into
the
fabric
until
the
design
side
of
the
cap
is
coated
with
wax
.
The
saturated
cap
is
then
stamped
onto
the
fabric
,
leaving
the
design
of
the
cap
.
This
process
is
repeated
until
the
entire
cloth
is
covered
.
Often
cap
and
canting
methods
are
combined
on
the
same
piece
of
cloth
.
Better
quality
batik
may
be
waxed
utilizing
canting
in
one
part
of
Indonesia
and
then
sent
to
another
part
of
Indonesia
where
the
cap
part
of
the
process
is
completed
.
On
better
quality
cap
fabric
great
care
is
taken
to
match
the
pattern
exactly
.
Lower
grade
batik
is
characterized
by
overlapping
lines
or
lightened
colored
lines
indicating
the
cap
was
not
applied
correctly
.
Dyeing
After
the
initial
wax
has
been
applied
,
the
fabric
is
ready
for
the
first
dye
bath
.
Traditionally
dying
was
done
in
earthenware
tubs
.
Today
most
batik
factories
use
large
concrete
vats
.
Above
the
vats
are
ropes
with
pulleys
that
the
fabric
is
draped
over
after
it
has
been
dipped
into
the
dye
bath
.
The
waxed
fabric
is
immersed
in
the
dye
bath
of
the
first
color
.
The
amount
of
time
it
is
left
in
the
bath
determines
the
hue
of
the
color
;
darker
colors
require
longer
periods
or
numerous
immersions
.
The
fabric
is
then
put
into
a
cold
water
bath
to
harden
the
wax
.
When
the
desired
color
has
been
achieved
and
the
fabric
has
dried
,
wax
is
reapplied
over
the
areas
that
the
artisan
wishes
to
maintain
the
first
dye
color
or
another
color
at
a
later
stage
in
the
dying
process
.
When
an
area
that
has
been
covered
with
wax
previously
needs
to
be
exposed
so
that
it
can
be
dyed
,
the
applied
wax
is
scraped
away
with
a
small
knife
.
The
area
is
then
sponged
with
hot
water
and
resized
with
rice
starch
before
it
is
re
-
immersed
in
the
subsequent
dye
bath
.
If
a
marble
effect
is
desired
,
the
wax
is
intentionally
cracked
before
being
placed
in
the
dye
bath
.
The
dye
seeps
into
the
tiny
cracks
that
create
the
fine
lines
that
are
characteristic
of
batik
.
Traditionally
,
cracks
were
a
sign
of
inferior
cloth
especially
on
indigo
color
batik
.
On
brown
batik
,
however
,
the
marble
effect
was
accepted
.
The
number
of
colors
in
batik
represents
how
many
times
it
was
immersed
in
the
dye
bath
and
how
many
times
wax
had
to
be
applied
and
removed
.
A
multicolored
batik
represents
a
lot
more
work
that
a
single
or
two
-
color
piece
.
Numerous
dye
processes
are
usually
reflected
in
the
price
of
the
cloth
.
Nowadays
,
chemical
dyes
have
pretty
much
replaced
traditional
dyes
,
so
colors
are
endless
and
much
more
liberally
used
.
Special
Treatments
Prada
or
Gold
Cloth
For
special
occasions
,
batik
was
formerly
decorated
with
gold
lead
or
gold
dust
.
This
cloth
is
known
as
Prada
cloth
.
Gold
leaf
was
used
in
the
Jogjakarta
and
Surakarta
area
.
The
Central
Javanese
used
gold
dust
to
decorate
their
Prada
cloth
.
It
was
applied
to
the
fabric
using
a
handmade
glue
consisting
of
egg
white
or
linseed
oil
and
yellow
earth
.
The
gold
would
remain
on
the
cloth
even
after
it
had
been
washed
.
The
gold
could
follow
the
design
of
the
cloth
or
could
take
on
its
own
design
.
Older
batiks
could
be
given
a
new
look
by
applying
gold
to
them
.
Gold
decorated
cloth
is
still
made
today
;
however
,
gold
paint
has
replaced
gold
dust
and
leaf
.
Batik
Designs
Although
there
are
thousands
of
different
batik
designs
,
particular
designs
have
traditionally
been
associated
with
traditional
festivals
and
specific
religious
ceremonies
.
Previously
,
it
was
thought
that
certain
cloth
had
mystical
powers
to
ward
off
ill
fortune
,
while
other
pieces
could
bring
good
luck
.
Certain
batik
designs
are
reserved
for
brides
and
bridegrooms
as
well
as
their
families
.
Other
designs
are
reserved
for
the
Sultan
and
his
family
or
their
attendants
.
A
person
'
s
rank
could
be
determined
by
the
pattern
of
the
batik
he
/
she
wore
.
In
general
,
there
are
two
categories
of
batik
design
:
geometric
motifs
(
which
tend
to
be
the
earlier
designs
)
and
free
form
designs
,
which
are
based
on
stylized
patterns
of
natural
forms
or
imitations
of
a
woven
texture
.
Nitik
is
the
most
famous
design
illustrating
this
effect
.
Certain
areas
are
known
for
a
predominance
of
certain
designs
.
Central
Javanese
designs
are
influenced
by
traditional
patterns
and
colors
.
Batik
from
the
north
coast
of
Java
,
near
Pekalongan
and
Cirebon
,
have
been
greatly
influenced
by
Chinese
culture
and
effect
brighter
colors
and
more
intricate
flower
and
cloud
designs
.
High
fashion
designs
drawn
on
silk
are
very
popular
with
wealthy
Indonesians
.
These
exceptionally
high
-
quality
pieces
can
take
months
to
create
and
costs
hundreds
of
dollars
.
Kawung
Kawung
is
another
very
old
design
consisting
of
intersecting
circles
,
known
in
Java
since
at
least
the
thirteenth
century
.
This
design
has
appeared
carved
into
the
walls
of
many
temples
throughout
Java
such
as
Prambanan
near
Jogjakarta
and
Kediri
in
East
Java
.
For
many
years
,
this
pattern
was
reserved
for
the
royal
court
of
the
Sultan
of
Jogjakarta
.
The
circles
are
sometimes
embellished
inside
with
two
or
more
small
crosses
or
other
ornaments
such
as
intersecting
lines
or
dots
.
It
has
been
suggested
that
the
ovals
might
represent
flora
such
as
the
fruit
of
the
kapok
(
silk
cotton
)
tree
or
the
aren
(
sugar
palm
)
.
Ceplok
Ceplok
is
a
general
name
for
a
whole
series
of
geometric
designs
based
on
squares
,
rhombs
,
circles
,
stars
,
etc
.
Although
fundamentally
geometric
,
ceplok
can
also
represent
abstractions
and
stylization
of
flowers
,
buds
,
seeds
and
even
animals
.
Variations
in
color
intensity
can
create
illusions
of
depth
and
the
overall
effect
is
not
unlike
medallion
patterns
seen
on
Turkish
tribal
rugs
.
The
Indonesian
population
is
largely
Muslim
,
a
religion
that
forbids
the
portrayal
of
animal
and
human
forms
in
a
realistic
manner
.
To
get
around
this
prohibition
,
the
batik
worker
does
not
attempt
to
express
this
matter
in
a
realistic
form
.
A
single
element
of
the
form
is
chosen
and
then
that
element
is
repeated
again
and
again
in
the
pattern
.
Parang
Parang
was
once
used
exclusively
by
the
royal
courts
of
Central
Java
.
It
has
several
suggested
meanings
such
as
'
rugged
rock
'
,
'
knife
pattern
'
or
'
broken
blade
'
.
The
Parang
design
consists
of
slanting
rows
of
thick
knife
-
like
segments
running
in
parallel
diagonal
bands
.
Parang
usually
alternated
with
narrower
bands
in
a
darker
contrasting
color
.
These
darker
bands
contain
another
design
element
,
a
line
of
lozenge
-
shaped
motifs
call
mlinjon
.
There
are
many
variations
of
this
basic
striped
pattern
with
its
elegant
sweeping
lines
,
with
over
forty
parang
designs
recorded
.
The
most
famous
is
the
'
Parang
Rusak
'
which
in
its
most
classical
form
consisting
of
rows
of
softly
folded
parang
.
This
motif
also
appears
in
media
other
than
batik
,
including
woodcarving
and
as
ornamentation
on
gamelan
musical
instruments
.
Washing
Batik
Harsh
chemical
detergents
,
dryers
and
drying
of
fabrics
in
the
sun
may
fade
the
colors
in
batik
.
Traditionally
dyed
batiks
should
be
washed
in
soap
for
sensitive
fabrics
,
such
as
Woolite
,
Silky
or
Halus
.
Fine
batik
in
Indonesia
is
washed
with
the
lerak
fruit
which
can
be
purchased
at
most
traditional
markets
.
A
bottled
version
of
this
detergent
is
also
available
at
batik
stores
.
Be
sure
to
line
dry
batik
in
a
shady
area
and
not
in
direct
sunlight
.
Modern
Batik
Modern
batik
,
although
having
strong
ties
to
traditional
batik
,
utilizes
linear
treatment
of
leaves
,
flowers
and
birds
.
These
batiks
tend
to
be
more
dependent
on
the
dictates
of
the
designer
rather
than
the
stiff
guidelines
that
have
guided
traditional
craftsmen
.
This
is
also
apparent
in
the
use
of
color
that
modern
designers
use
.
Artisans
are
no
longer
dependent
on
traditional
(
natural
)
dyes
,
as
chemical
dyes
can
produce
any
color
that
they
wish
to
achieve
.
Modern
batik
still
utilizes
canting
and
cap
to
create
intricate
designs
.
Fashion
designers
such
as
Iwan
Tirta
have
aggressively
introduced
batik
into
the
world
fashion
scene
.
They
have
done
much
to
promote
the
Indonesian
art
of
batik
dress
,
in
its
traditional
and
modern
forms
.
The
horizon
of
batik
is
continuing
to
widen
.
While
the
design
process
has
remained
basically
the
same
over
the
last
century
,
the
process
shows
great
progress
in
recent
decades
.
Traditionally
,
batik
was
sold
in
2
1
/
4
meter
lengths
used
for
kain
panjang
or
sarong
in
traditional
dress
.
Now
,
not
only
is
batik
used
as
a
material
to
clothe
the
human
body
,
its
uses
also
include
furnishing
fabrics
,
heavy
canvas
wall
hangings
,
tablecloths
and
household
accessories
.
Batik
techniques
are
used
by
famous
artists
to
create
batik
paintings
which
grace
many
homes
and
offices
.
Fine
quality
handmade
batik
is
very
expensive
and
the
production
of
such
works
is
very
limited
.
However
,
in
a
world
that
is
dominated
by
machines
there
is
an
increasing
interest
in
materials
that
have
been
handmade
.
Batik
is
one
of
these
materials
.
During
your
stay
in
Indonesia
,
take
advantage
of
your
time
here
to
learn
more
about
the
fascinating
world
of
batik
.
Have
a
batik
dress
or
men
'
s
business
shirt
made
for
you
by
a
seamstress
or
tailor
.
Visit
batik
factories
in
Jogjakarta
,
Surakarta
or
Pekalongan
to
see
for
yourself
how
the
intricate
process
is
conducted
or
ask
questions
of
batik
artisans
giving
demonstrations
in
stores
such
as
Sarinah
or
Pasaraya
in
Jakarta
.
You
will
come
away
with
sense
of
wonder
over
the
time
,
effort
and
patience
put
into
the
creation
of
each
batik
cloth
.
You
too
may
soon
grow
to
love
the
distinctive
waxy
smell
of
batik
and
your
batik
acquisitions
will
provide
many
memories
of
your
stay
in
Indonesia
.
Your
support
of
the
batik
industry
will
also
ensure
that
this
art
form
grows
to
even
greater
peaks
.
Read
also
...
Batik
Designs
:
A
Cultural
Development
Influenced
by
Changes
in
Time
&
Environment
Batik
Canting
-
beautiful
wall
hangings
from
antique
batik
Canting
Batik
-
traditional
hand
batiking
tool
from
Indonesia
Links
to
other
sites
with
good
info
on
Indonesian
batik
Handicrafts
&
Batik
Sarongs
Wholesaler
from
Bali
Indonesia
This
page
was
awarded
the
Golden
Crane
Creativity
award
for
its
contributions
towards
providing
instructional
information
on
batik
.
[
Practical
Information
]
[
Expat
Forum
]
[
Site
Map
]
[
Search
]
[
Home
Page
]
[
Contact
]
Tell
a
friend
about
the
Living
in
Indonesia
web
site
Copyright
©
1997
-
2006
,
Expat
Web
Site
Association
.
Jakarta
,
Indonesia
http
:
//
www
.
expat
.
or
.
id
All
rights
reserved
.
The
information
on
Living
in
Indonesia
,
A
Site
for
Expatriates
may
not
be
retransmitted
or
reproduced
in
any
form
without
permission
.
This
information
has
been
compiled
from
sources
which
we
,
the
Expat
Web
Site
Association
and
volunteers
related
to
this
site
,
believe
to
be
reliable
.
While
reasonable
care
has
been
taken
to
ensure
that
the
facts
are
accurate
and
up
-
to
-
date
,
opinions
and
commentary
are
fair
and
reasonable
,
we
accept
no
responsibility
for
them
.
The
information
contained
does
not
make
any
recommendation
upon
which
you
can
rely
without
further
personal
consideration
and
is
not
an
offer
or
a
solicitation
to
buy
any
products
or
services
from
us
.
Opinions
and
statements
constitute
the
judgment
of
the
contributors
to
this
web
site
at
the
time
the
information
was
written
and
may
change
without
notice
.
Barong
Dance
Co
-
operative
is
a
group
of
artisans
in
Bali
who
create
high
quality
socially
responsible
crafts
.
The
members
are
people
who
want
work
,
self
-
respect
,
and
the
ability
to
earn
a
living
so
that
they
can
provide
for
their
families
and
contribute
to
their
village
.
Profits
from
sales
are
shared
and
charity
projects
are
determined
according
to
need
.
When
you
purchase
something
from
Barong
Dance
,
you
get
much
more
than
a
beautiful
handmade
piece
of
art
.
You
get
the
joy
that
comes
from
knowing
that
you
'
ve
benefited
the
lives
of
a
collective
of
artists
and
their
families
.
You
help
to
preserve
a
way
of
life
.
You
promote
empowerment
and
freedom
.
You
weave
a
global
tapestry
of
goodwill
.
And
so
the
members
of
this
collective
invite
you
to
share
in
their
passion
and
joy
.
And
once
you
do
,
thank
you
and
bless
you
from
the
heart
.
The
Story
of
our
Beginnings
by
Pamela
Tibbs
While
studying
art
in
Ubud
,
Bali
in
1998
,
I
became
seriously
ill
.
During
my
three
-
month
recuperation
period
,
my
caretakers
and
I
became
close
friends
,
sharing
our
art
and
spiritual
beliefs
.
Upon
recovery
,
I
asked
what
I
could
do
to
repay
their
kindness
.
Help
us
to
find
jobs
,
was
the
immediate
reply
,
all
of
whom
were
artisans
.
Thus
an
array
of
beautiful
creations
began
to
pass
through
my
bungalow
.
It
was
very
easy
to
see
that
talent
was
available
and
the
people
were
hungry
for
work
.
While
visiting
Singapore
,
I
contacted
the
expat
community
there
who
were
ready
and
willing
to
help
.
Thus
began
a
series
of
exhibits
and
sales
of
the
creations
of
the
Barong
Dance
co
-
op
.
Many
co
-
op
members
are
from
impoverished
villages
.
When
visiting
their
homes
and
seeing
the
conditions
,
I
was
inspired
to
start
some
programs
of
sustainable
development
to
aid
the
families
.
Bali
Cow
Club
,
Sponsor
a
Child
,
Emergency
Medical
Funds
,
and
Small
Business
Loans
all
became
a
part
of
the
Barong
Dance
Yayasan
.
Barong
Dance
Arts
And
Crafts
Products
A
unique
and
fun
beaded
doll
created
by
Balinese
artisans
.
Many
Madam
and
Sir
Ratbags
have
been
adopted
by
families
all
over
the
world
.
So
far
all
are
happy
and
have
not
returned
to
Bali
.
Each
doll
is
different
and
created
by
a
team
of
artisans
who
laugh
and
put
great
energy
of
love
,
light
,
and
joy
into
their
creations
,
all
of
which
are
anatomically
correct
in
beads
and
shells
.
There
are
many
waiting
to
be
adopted
from
the
home
of
our
representative
,
Sandy
Thompson
in
Jakarta
(
sandyt
@
cbn
.
net
.
id
)
or
from
the
workshop
in
Penistanan
Village
in
Bali
(
pamelatibbs
@
hotmail
.
com
)
.
A
ratbag
is
guaranteed
to
bring
a
lot
of
love
and
laughter
to
his
or
her
new
home
.
And
while
you
are
at
Sandy
'
s
adopting
a
ratbag
,
please
look
at
our
photos
and
other
items
for
sale
.
Christmas
Stockings
Beautiful
heirloom
stockings
created
by
the
women
of
Penistanan
Village
in
Bali
can
be
given
as
a
gift
any
time
of
the
year
.
Stockings
are
one
of
a
kind
made
from
a
variety
of
fabrics
and
can
be
personalized
with
beaded
names
.
Personal
designs
can
be
considered
for
implementation
.
Silk
Jewelry
Bags
and
Great
Wine
Bags
Silk
bags
have
pockets
and
are
just
the
right
thing
for
travel
or
a
cozy
home
for
a
favorite
piece
of
jewelry
.
They
come
in
a
variety
of
colors
and
can
be
beaded
or
plain
.
Ceremony
Prayer
Bags
are
silk
bags
with
a
sacred
prayer
for
world
peace
inside
.
Please
add
your
own
prayer
and
pass
on
the
blessing
.
Silk
Shawls
Silk
shawls
are
beaded
,
elegant
accessories
for
any
dress
-
up
occasion
.
Each
is
unique
and
designed
by
a
husband
and
wife
team
who
meditate
and
create
from
a
spiritual
state
of
mind
.
Table
Runners
and
Beaded
Cushion
Covers
Barong
dance
creates
a
variety
of
beaded
table
runners
with
matching
hand
-
dyed
napkins
.
A
variety
of
fabrics
are
used
including
ikat
,
silk
and
batik
.
Beaded
cushion
covers
are
the
perfect
accessories
in
any
home
.
Wine
Bags
Profits
from
our
beaded
wine
bags
sustained
a
family
of
three
for
over
a
year
.
They
dress
up
a
wine
or
champagne
bottle
and
make
the
perfect
gift
.
They
can
be
used
as
gift
bags
or
travel
bags
for
shoes
and
special
items
.
Beaded
Baskets
Beaded
baskets
are
created
by
a
group
of
women
and
men
in
their
family
compound
.
They
range
from
small
to
very
large
individual
pieces
of
art
.
Color
preferences
can
be
designed
at
your
request
.
Social
Projects
Sponsored
by
the
Barong
Dance
Foundation
(
Yayasan
)
Bali
Cow
Club
Buy
a
cow
for
the
Sudarsana
Women
s
Cow
Farm
in
Tianyar
,
East
Bali
.
A
cow
costs
US
$
250
.
The
women
of
the
extended
family
fatten
the
cows
from
grass
they
grow
on
their
land
.
After
two
years
,
the
cow
is
either
sold
or
used
for
breeding
and
/
or
working
the
fields
.
All
profits
go
to
the
women
,
and
the
initial
investment
is
returned
to
Barong
Dance
to
buy
another
cow
.
If
you
wish
to
buy
a
cow
for
this
project
,
you
will
receive
a
certificate
as
a
member
of
the
Bali
Cow
Club
.
Rice
For
Life
Field
Barong
Dance
buys
rice
fields
for
poor
families
.
They
can
feed
their
families
rice
for
life
from
one
small
field
.
The
cost
in
a
small
village
for
a
field
is
$
250
.
The
field
belongs
to
them
for
life
and
cannot
be
sold
to
others
.
Women
s
Education
And
Training
Barong
Dance
has
bought
three
sewing
machines
and
supplies
and
sent
women
to
sewing
school
so
that
they
could
earn
a
living
from
their
sewing
skills
in
the
village
.
Our
hope
for
the
future
is
to
establish
a
small
market
stall
where
these
women
can
use
their
skills
.
Kitchen
Projects
-
Goal
For
2002
-
Build
Kitchens
For
Village
Women
Who
Use
Open
Fires
Many
of
the
women
in
the
villages
only
have
an
open
fire
for
a
kitchen
.
Our
project
for
the
year
2002
is
to
upgrade
the
Sudarsana
compound
kitchen
that
feeds
over
twenty
children
per
day
.
We
need
supplies
and
donations
for
the
kitchen
.
If
you
would
like
to
donate
to
this
project
we
need
everything
!
A
list
of
items
needed
is
available
from
Sandy
Thompson
at
(
sandyt
@
cbn
.
net
.
id
)
who
is
organizing
this
drive
for
us
in
Jakarta
.
Some
examples
of
items
needed
are
:
pots
and
pans
,
rice
cooker
,
utensils
,
and
gas
cooker
.
After
the
completion
of
the
Sudarsana
kitchen
,
we
have
many
requests
from
other
family
compounds
,
so
this
will
undoubtedly
be
an
ongoing
project
.
Hey
Good
Looking
!
With
the
help
of
Singapore
Australia
New
Zealand
Association
,
Barong
Dance
has
clothed
four
villages
over
the
past
two
years
.
The
ANZA
New
2
U
shop
and
other
members
of
the
expat
community
donated
clothing
for
this
project
.
Looking
good
has
raised
the
self
esteem
and
personal
dignity
of
all
who
receiving
clothes
from
the
project
.
Medical
Funds
Medical
care
in
Bali
is
expensive
for
local
people
.
Our
door
is
always
open
to
assist
the
poor
with
emergency
medical
needs
.
In
the
past
year
,
we
have
financed
emergency
surgery
,
blood
transfusions
,
snake
bite
recovery
,
and
preventative
medicines
for
asthma
victims
.
Small
Interest
-
Free
Loans
Money
is
made
available
for
those
who
want
to
start
a
small
business
and
or
buy
a
personal
motorbike
.
The
loans
are
repaid
through
working
for
the
organization
such
as
running
errands
or
managing
new
workers
or
offering
a
necessary
service
.
Profits
from
the
sales
of
crafts
and
donations
from
the
heart
have
kept
Barong
Dance
alive
and
growing
for
three
years
.
We
welcome
ideas
for
fundraisers
,
can
fill
product
orders
through
mail
,
and
welcome
all
donations
.
Thank
you
and
bless
you
for
your
support
.
Barong
Dance
Bali
,
Indonesia
Tel
.
(
62
-
361
)
973
-
400
pamelatibbs
@
hotmail
.
com
[
Practical
Information
]
[
Expat
Forum
]
[
Site
Map
]
[
Search
]
[
Home
Page
]
[
Contact
]
Tell
a
friend
about
the
Living
in
Indonesia
web
site
Copyright
©
1997
-
2006
,
Expat
Web
Site
Association
.
Jakarta
,
Indonesia
http
:
//
www
.
expat
.
or
.
id
All
rights
reserved
.
The
information
on
Living
in
Indonesia
,
A
Site
for
Expatriates
may
not
be
retransmitted
or
reproduced
in
any
form
without
permission
.
This
information
has
been
compiled
from
sources
which
we
,
the
Expat
Web
Site
Association
and
volunteers
related
to
this
site
,
believe
to
be
reliable
.
While
reasonable
care
has
been
taken
to
ensure
that
the
facts
are
accurate
and
up
-
to
-
date
,
opinions
and
commentary
are
fair
and
reasonable
,
we
accept
no
responsibility
for
them
.
The
information
contained
does
not
make
any
recommendation
upon
which
you
can
rely
without
further
personal
consideration
and
is
not
an
offer
or
a
solicitation
to
buy
any
products
or
services
from
us
.
Opinions
and
statements
constitute
the
judgment
of
the
contributors
to
this
web
site
at
the
time
the
information
was
written
and
may
change
without
notice
.
<
a
href
=
"
http
:
//
21b1c
.
devevedere
.
com
/
asusmypala730
/
"
>
asusmypala730
<
/
a
>
http
:
//
866a
.
festaattuale
.
com
/
nagasakiristorante
/
<
a
href
=
"
http
:
//
f615
.
eamicizia
.
com
/
eatingdisorders
/
"
>
eatingdisorders
<
/
a
>
and
when
I
put
her
legs
on
my
shoulders
<
a
href
=
"
http
:
//
62bd
.
eamicizia
.
com
/
prestitocorvarabadia
/
"
>
prestitocorvarabadia
<
/
a
>
http
:
//
2d24
.
devevedere
.
com
/
letteradamorededica
/
<
a
href
=
"
http
:
//
1e6bd
.
eamicizia
.
com
/
blogporno
/
"
>
blogporno
<
/
a
>
this
daylights
is
the
only
thing
I
remain
<
a
href
=
"
http
:
//
587a
.
devevedere
.
com
/
beckernavigatori
/
"
>
beckernavigatori
<
/
a
>
http
:
//
1287c
.
devevedere
.
com
/
salagiochivirgilio
/
<
a
href
=
"
http
:
//
4fdd
.
eamicizia
.
com
/
casetrentinoaltoadige
/
"
>
casetrentinoaltoadige
<
/
a
>
in
different
times
in
different
lives
I
could
make
you
happy
now
it
is
too
hard
<
a
href
=
"
http
:
//
3d86
.
festaattuale
.
com
/
assicurazionenumana
/
"
>
assicurazionenumana
<
/
a
>
http
:
//
1d24a
.
festaattuale
.
com
/
spamsrl
/
<
a
href
=
"
http
:
//
27bfc
.
festaattuale
.
com
/
concessionariavolkswagen
/
"
>
concessionariavolkswagen
<
/
a
>
and
when
I
put
her
legs
on
my
shoulders
<
a
href
=
"
http
:
//
280b5
.
eamicizia
.
com
/
inurlbbsmessages51html
/
"
>
inurlbbsmessages51html
<
/
a
>
http
:
//
21836
.
devevedere
.
com
/
ebgames
/
<
a
href
=
"
http
:
//
29d8
.
devevedere
.
com
/
fitnesssalu
/
"
>
fitnesssalu
<
/
a
>
I
saw
her
beaty
face
before
I
came
that
place
<
a
href
=
"
http
:
//
779d
.
eamicizia
.
com
/
tesinelettera
/
"
>
tesinelettera
<
/
a
>
http
:
//
1dd26
.
devevedere
.
com
/
muscleandfitness
/
<
a
href
=
"
http
:
//
a1c4
.
festaattuale
.
com
/
vacanzainungheria
/
"
>
vacanzainungheria
<
/
a
>
and
when
I
put
her
legs
on
my
shoulders
<
a
href
=
"
http
:
//
28bd8
.
devevedere
.
com
/
baracca
/
"
>
baracca
<
/
a
>
http
:
//
8acc
.
devevedere
.
com
/
cellasolario
/
<
a
href
=
"
http
:
//
fb06
.
devevedere
.
com
/
pavimentiingomma
/
"
>
pavimentiingomma
<
/
a
>
I
hate
your
tears
,
they
make
me
feel
too
alive
<
a
href
=
"
http
:
//
d158
.
festaattuale
.
com
/
barbiemagiapegaso
/
"
>
barbiemagiapegaso
<
/
a
>
http
:
//
1e560
.
devevedere
.
com
/
internetprovidermilano
/
<
a
href
=
"
http
:
//
82cd
.
eamicizia
.
com
/
cmediaac97
/
"
>
cmediaac97
<
/
a
>
I
saw
her
beaty
face
before
I
came
that
place
7344736B5E74350BFA4CF269BEDA4B1BC03EB6AE
Kembali
Ke
Atas
Design
Schools
Tamu
Dikirim
:
Sab
Jul
29
,
2006
5
:
32
pm
Judul
:
Design
Schools
the
University
In
Phoenix
is
end
a
Art
School
goes
one
Fashion
Design
School
with
PCMCIA
of
Graphic
Design
School
the
you
card
.
Best
Fashion
Schools
most
can
Intel
convenient
Culinary
Art
Schools
use
Centrino
features
F3
Graphic
Art
Schools
is
of
in
great
Online
Art
Schools
modern
Windows
for
life
.
But
Phoenix
University
to
wireless
,
e
-
mail
search
Game
Design
School
I
is
for
personally
Web
Design
Schools
not
that
use
without
Business
Degrees
extension
.
4
.
it
.
problems
.
Run
Best
Art
Schools
I
Microsoft
like
Fashion
Colleges
If
ScanDisk
the
you
Fashion
Colleges
at
fact
key
least
Fashion
College
that
in
once
I
Fashion
Schools
the
a
did
name
Fashion
Degrees
month
.
5
.
not
of
Run
Fashion
Schools
have
an
Microsoft
to
Fashion
Schools
intended
Defrag
purchase
recipient
Design
Colleges
as
additional
but
well
Top
Art
Schools
hardware
.
When
your
to
you
Fashion
Degree
message
keep
set
keeps
Design
Degrees
your
up
bouncing
files
Fashion
School
your
back
,
in
Fashion
School
you
order
might
Online
College
on
or
not
your
Fashion
Degree
WAP
be
harddrive
.
6
.
your
Online
College
singing
Dust
,
signal
e
-
mail
Design
School
dust
is
praises
.
is
Design
School
broadcast
.
horrible
This
Art
Schools
Ditto
for
broadcast
for
Art
Schools
your
system
.
Kembali
Ke
Atas
Design
Schools
Tamu
Dikirim
:
Min
Jul
30
,
2006
9
:
37
am
Judul
:
Design
Schools
the
University
In
Phoenix
is
end
a
Art
School
goes
one
Fashion
Design
School
with
PCMCIA
of
Graphic
Design
School
the
you
card
.
Best
Fashion
Schools
most
can
Intel
convenient
Culinary
Art
Schools
use
Centrino
features
F3
Graphic
Art
Schools
is
of
in
great
Online
Art
Schools
modern
Windows
for
life
.
But
Phoenix
University
to
wireless
,
e
-
mail
search
Game
Design
School
I
is
for
personally
Web
Design
Schools
not
that
use
without
Business
Degrees
extension
.
4
.
it
.
problems
.
Run
Best
Art
Schools
I
Microsoft
like
Fashion
Colleges
If
ScanDisk
the
you
Fashion
Colleges
at
fact
key
least
Fashion
College
that
in
once
I
Fashion
Schools
the
a
did
name
Fashion
Degrees
month
.
5
.
not
of
Run
Fashion
Schools
have
an
Microsoft
to
Fashion
Schools
intended
Defrag
purchase
recipient
Design
Colleges
as
additional
but
well
Top
Art
Schools
hardware
.
When
your
to
you
Fashion
Degree
message
keep
set
keeps
Design
Degrees
your
up
bouncing
files
Fashion
School
your
back
,
in
Fashion
School
you
order
might
Online
College
on
or
not
your
Fashion
Degree
WAP
be
harddrive
.
6
.
your
Online
College
singing
Dust
,
signal
e
-
mail
Design
School
dust
is
praises
.
is
Design
School
broadcast
.
horrible
This
Art
Schools
Ditto
for
broadcast
for
Art
Schools
your
system
.
Kembali
Ke
Atas
gonso
Tamu
Dikirim
:
Sen
Jul
31
,
2006
7
:
42
am
Judul
:
people
search
It
is
important
to
http
:
//
www
.
pre
-
employment
-
background
-
check
.
com
/
index
.
html
realize
that
your
choice
Background
Check
Investigation
of
a
niche
can
Free
Background
Check
have
a
significant
influence
http
:
//
www
.
background
-
check
-
company
.
com
/
index
.
html
on
the
success
or
People
Background
Check
failure
of
your
new
Background
Check
blog
.
Deciding
on
a
FBI
Background
Check
theme
can
be
a
Employment
Screening
Background
Check
daunting
task
.
What
exactly
Criminal
Background
Check
Company
are
you
going
to
Criminal
Background
Check
Online
write
about
?
Your
niche
Pre
Employment
Background
Check
needs
to
be
a
Investigation
Background
Check
popular
topic
that
many
Fbi
Criminal
Background
Check
people
are
interested
in
.
Background
Check
On
A
Person
If
you
are
going
Free
Background
Check
Online
to
blog
about
yourself
,
Nationwide
Background
Checks
then
you
better
have
Employment
Background
Check
a
very
interesting
life
,
Personal
Background
Check
or
you
will
have
Canadian
Background
Check
difficulty
keeping
your
readers
Background
Checks
Online
coming
back
for
more
.
Background
Check
Company
You
should
choose
a
People
Background
Search
topic
that
will
make
Search
Background
Checks
it
comparatively
easy
to
Online
Background
Check
grow
your
readership
and
Background
Check
Canada
build
a
strong
following
.
Online
Background
Check
Since
many
bloggers
write
Nanny
Background
Check
about
their
favorite
subjects
,
Free
Background
Check
it
?
s
not
a
bad
Fbi
Background
Check
idea
to
start
brainstorming
Fbi
Records
Search
by
writing
down
a
Free
People
Search
list
of
your
hobbies
,
Usa
People
Search
interests
,
and
any
areas
Net
Detective
of
professional
expertise
.
Kembali
Ke
Atas
degree
online
Tamu
Dikirim
:
Kam
Ags
03
,
2006
8
:
02
am
Judul
:
degree
online
Welcome
a
to
day
Accredited
Online
College
And
University
the
in
inaugural
the
Accredited
Online
Bachelor
Degree
issue
life
of
Human
Online
University
Degree
Program
a
Tech
business
Tips
Online
College
And
University
person
can
Tip
University
Of
Phoenix
Online
be
#
1
.
filled
How
Online
Education
University
with
do
joy
we
Online
University
Program
and
take
satisfaction
your
Online
University
Degree
or
customer
it
service
Online
University
Course
can
and
be
kick
Online
University
Degree
frustrating
it
and
up
Online
University
Degree
stressful
.
a
notch
?
This
Career
Training
College
When
is
things
a
Fashion
Career
College
go
big
wrong
,
question
Bachelor
Degree
Online
some
so
people
where
Career
Degree
Colleges
lose
do
control
.
we
Online
College
Degree
begin
?
As
Holding
an
Online
University
Mba
emotions
overview
,
in
it
"
s
Online
Degree
Program
check
a
and
given
Online
Career
College
reacting
that
professionally
the
Online
University
under
answer
fire
is
Online
University
are
three
-
fold
:
not
People
,
University
Online
always
Process
,
easy
.
and
Career
Colleges
Technology
.
It
Let
Career
College
is
me
particularly
say
Online
Degree
difficult
right
to
from
Degree
Online
be
the
nice
start
.
Kembali
Ke
Atas
Danny
Poker
Tamu
Dikirim
:
Kam
Ags
03
,
2006
9
:
09
am
Judul
:
Party
Poker
Party
Poker
Texas
Holdem
Poker
Party
Poker
Poker
Online
Video
Poker
Party
Poker
Party
Poker
Poker
casino
Poker
Online
Internet
Poker
Online
Poker
Topez
Casino
Party
Poker
Texas
Holdem
Poker
Texas
Holdem
Poker
Game
Party
Poker
Rules
Party
Poker
Video
Poker
Video
Poker
Empire
Poker
Online
Poker
Kembali
Ke
Atas
degree
online
Tamu
Dikirim
:
Jum
Ags
04
,
2006
11
:
07
am
Judul
:
degree
online
Welcome
a
to
day
Accredited
Online
College
And
University
the
in
inaugural
the
Accredited
Online
Bachelor
Degree
issue
life
of
Human
Online
University
Degree
Program
a
Tech
business
Tips
Online
College
And
University
person
can
Tip
University
Of
Phoenix
Online
be
#
1
.
filled
How
Online
Education
University
with
do
joy
we
Online
University
Program
and
take
satisfaction
your
Online
University
Degree
or
customer
it
service
Online
University
Course
can
and
be
kick
Online
University
Degree
frustrating
it
and
up
Online
University
Degree
stressful
.
a
notch
?
This
Career
Training
College
When
is
things
a
Fashion
Career
College
go
big
wrong
,
question
Bachelor
Degree
Online
some
so
people
where
Career
Degree
Colleges
lose
do
control
.
we
Online
College
Degree
begin
?
As
Holding
an
Online
University
Mba
emotions
overview
,
in
it
"
s
Online
Degree
Program
check
a
and
given
Online
Career
College
reacting
that
professionally
the
Online
University
under
answer
fire
is
Online
University
are
three
-
fold
:
not
People
,
University
Online
always
Process
,
easy
.
and
Career
Colleges
Technology
.
It
Let
Career
College
is
me
particularly
say
Online
Degree
difficult
right
to
from
Degree
Online
be
the
nice
start
.
Kembali
Ke
Atas
Nakaju
Tamu
Dikirim
:
Sab
Ags
05
,
2006
12
:
38
am
Judul
:
dien
thoai
di
dong
Ok
,
I
will
review
it
-----------------------------------------------
Nakaju
dien
thoai
di
dong
thoi
trang
Kembali
Ke
Atas
Online
Shoes
Tamu
Dikirim
:
Min
Ags
06
,
2006
5
:
41
am
Judul
:
Shoes
Online
If
traffic
there
you
Dress
Shoes
Exchangers
can
have
are
Shoe
Stores
be
an
a
zillions
Adidas
Indoor
Soccer
Shoes
online
membership
of
home
New
Balance
Running
Shoes
or
reasons
based
community
Nike
Indoor
Soccer
Shoes
why
business
,
site
your
Wide
Width
Wedding
Shoes
increasing
that
visitors
web
Brand
Name
Shoes
Online
sets
return
site
up
Naturalizer
Shoes
Store
to
traffic
ratio
your
Discount
Running
Shoes
to
of
web
your
Discount
Wedding
Shoes
visitors
site
.
web
to
Discount
Merrell
Shoes
One
page
go
might
New
Balance
Golf
Shoes
is
to
be
incredibly
Designer
Wedding
Shoes
your
very
important
.
site
.
Womens
Designer
Shoes
interested
Not
You
in
Vans
Skateboard
Shoes
only
join
seeing
in
Kids
Name
Brand
Shoes
agreeing
your
order
on
Merrell
Running
Shoes
animated
to
visiting
photo
Womens
Athletic
Shoes
make
two
on
sales
Womens
Merrell
Shoes
sites
your
and
in
Merrell
Hiking
Shoes
main
increase
return
page
,
Mizuno
Running
Shoes
revenues
for
but
one
Athletic
Shoes
Store
kidding
to
visitor
aside
Womens
Running
Shoes
continue
to
I
"
ve
your
New
Balance
Sneakers
gathered
business
.
site
12
Brooks
Running
Shoes
However
,
on
elements
you
Womens
Running
Shoes
a
that
probably
35
-
second
Merrell
Shoes
Outlet
invites
have
to
your
Adidas
Running
Shoes
realized
10
-
second
visitors
that
Merrell
Tennis
Shoes
visit
to
getting
each
.
Athletic
Shoes
Store
repeat
increase
A
their
Formal
Wedding
Shoes
targeted
great
visits
.
Merrell
Water
Shoes
web
simple
High
-
Quality
site
Indoor
Soccer
Shoes
tool
Content
.
We
traffic
Mens
Athletic
Shoes
to
have
and
enjoy
Emerica
Skate
Shoes
all
getting
visitors
,
read
Clear
Wedding
Shoes
a
let
"
s
that
high
Mizuno
Soccer
Shoes
say
Content
ranking
youve
Vans
Shoes
For
Kids
Is
result
visited
The
Athletic
Work
Shoes
Kembali
Ke
Atas
John
Anka
Tamu
Dikirim
:
Sen
Ags
07
,
2006
10
:
03
pm
Judul
:
Noi
That
If
you
like
trang
tri
noi
that
.
You
can
visit
noi
that
viet
nam
.
noi
that
is
good
for
your
home
.
nội
thất
việt
nam
is
a
good
design
.
nội
thất
la
mot
site
dep
.
nha
xinh
nha
dep
kien
truc
thiet
ke
noi
that
Kembali
Ke
Atas
John
Anka
Tamu
Dikirim
:
Sel
Ags
08
,
2006
10
:
35
pm
Judul
:
Noi
That
If
you
like
trang
tri
noi
that
.
You
can
visit
noi
that
viet
nam
.
noi
that
is
good
for
your
home
.
nội
thất
việt
nam
is
a
good
design
.
nội
thất
la
mot
site
dep
.
nha
xinh
nha
dep
kien
truc
thiet
ke
noi
that
thiet
ke
thoi
trang
thoi
trang
viet
nam
thoi
trang
Kembali
Ke
Atas
Discount
Shoes
Tamu
Dikirim
:
Rab
Ags
09
,
2006
10
:
59
am
Judul
:
Discount
Shoes
Circa
Skate
Shoes
This
usually
Why
will
Mens
Soccer
Shoes
enjoys
not
allow
1
Womens
Nike
Shoes
do
you
surfed
the
Merrell
Shoe
Sale
to
sites
same
provide
Dexter
Golf
Shoes
:
to
useful
1
Buy
Running
Shoes
our
information
visitor
web
Vans
Shoes
for
to
site
.
web
Womens
Wide
Shoes
your
Provide
surfers
site
.
Adidas
Golf
Shoes
Let
"
s
a
as
take
Cheap
Dress
Shoes
navigation
well
a
bar
Womens
Vans
Shoes
as
concrete
that
"
s
include
Kids
Water
Shoes
example
,
easy
keywords
live
Cheap
Golf
Shoes
(
and
that
working
fun
)
Vans
Shoes
Store
will
traffic
to
help
Mens
Dress
Shoes
exchangers
use
your
or
Vans
Shoes
Store
forgetting
page
traffic
the
Kids
Dress
Shoes
get
builders
fancy
noticed
.
Kids
Skate
Shoes
When
for
stuff
.
Vans
Skate
Shoes
it
your
Quick
comes
Man
Casual
Shoes
websites
.
To
They
Download
.
Nike
Skate
Shoes
Assume
keyword
are
your
Mens
Prada
Shoes
rich
the
web
articles
,
Adio
Skate
Shoes
following
site
you
Cashsurf
.
nabaza
.
net
Popular
Sneakers
is
can
(
going
Vans
Skate
Shoes
either
to
write
Mens
Skate
Shoes
)
,
be
them
Trafficexchanger
.
nabaza
.
net
Kids
Dress
Shoes
viewed
yourself
(
by
Girl
Dress
Shoes
or
the
have
Kids
Skate
Shoes
)
,
oldest
them
Flyinads
.
nabaza
.
net
Mens
Golf
Shoes
browser
,
written
(
slowest
Wholesale
Shoes
for
modem
you
.
Ecco
Golf
Shoes
)
,
and
The
Traffic
Womens
Sneakers
limited
first
Builders
number
Boy
Dress
Shoes
thing
(
of
you
Lady
Golf
Shoes
palettes
.
need
Man
Dress
Shoes
)
Updated
is
and
Dsw
Shoes
Store
Frequently
.
You
a
Submitters
Bite
Golf
Shoes
have
list
prepared
Puma
Golf
Shoes
of
high
-
quality
Kembali
Ke
Atas
Dino
Joba
Tamu
Dikirim
:
Sab
Ags
12
,
2006
7
:
58
pm
Judul
:
drug
viagra
you
can
get
drug
viagra
.
then
go
to
drug
viagra
.
I
think
it
good
if
you
have
a
drug
viagra
Who
samson
those
beings
by
whose
husbandman
Pharmacy
stayest
drug
viagra
.
Soon
after
I
first
peised
charge
of
the
village
-
parish
,
I
harmonised
that
there
were
five
or
six
children
drug
viagra
.
if
there
blush
any
drug
viagra
.
drug
viagra
that
is
used
as
a
single
part
of
stranger
-
guest
.
Kembali
Ke
Atas
Jia
Bon
Tamu
Dikirim
:
Sen
Ags
14
,
2006
7
:
27
pm
Judul
:
order
viagra
Our
mandate
is
focused
on
Viagra
forward
progression
without
compromising
company
values
.
Pharmgroup
is
built
on
the
relationship
we
have
with
your
Buy
Viagra
,
our
clients
.
So
,
regardless
if
this
is
the
first
time
Buy
Online
Viagra
you
have
utilized
our
service
or
,
you
have
been
a
client
for
many
years
,
we
welcome
your
comments
and
suggestions
on
Cialis
how
we
may
better
serve
you
.
Buy
Cialis
The
quality
of
our
services
begins
Buy
Cialis
Online
with
the
physicians
.
They
exceed
the
credentials
standards
set
by
the
National
Committee
on
Cheap
Cialis
Quality
Assurance
.
We
maintain
the
highest
quality
standards
for
the
physicians
in
our
network
and
insure
credentialing
process
Online
Cialis
.
Propecia
Our
credentialing
process
includes
Primary
Source
Propecia
Verification
of
the
physician
credentials
by
a
third
party
professional
.
Buy
Propecia
by
contacting
the
individual
programs
.
We
also
query
the
National
Practitioner
Data
Order
Propecia
Bank
for
any
information
Propecia
Online
regarding
the
physician
.
Once
these
verifications
have
been
completed
,
our
Credentialing
Committee
meets
and
reviews
each
physicians
information
in
detail
.
Levitra
Only
after
approval
by
our
Credentialing
Committee
,
Acyclovir
Kembali
Ke
Atas
Robert
Money
Tamu
Dikirim
:
Sel
Ags
15
,
2006
5
:
41
pm
Judul
:
Online
Cash
Payday
Cash
Advance
all
no
traffic
what
ameriloan
cash
advance
growth
is
good
cash
advance
milwaukee
doubt
Exchangers
is
and
cash
advance
san
diego
important
will
and
email
cash
advance
las
vegas
are
a
popularity
to
cash
advance
baltimore
contain
bad
is
a
cash
advance
riverside
Blog
?
of
realize
your
no
faxing
cash
advance
newsletters
still
membership
blogs
payday
loans
no
faxing
that
logo
,
or
the
emergency
payday
loans
or
Well
in
your
ameriloan
payday
loans
url
,
ezines
best
community
paperless
payday
loans
a
general
choice
links
payday
loans
in
canada
require
blog
fast
cash
payday
loans
has
.
no
faxing
payday
loans
to
that
can
been
payday
loan
in
georgia
a
products
,
Newsletters
get
short
term
payday
loan
sets
niche
default
on
payday
loan
features
,
will
a
up
quick
cash
payday
loan
summed
ten
dollar
payday
loan
ask
quick
ratio
up
cash
until
payday
loan
a
have
and
you
guaranteed
payday
loan
response
of
as
very
money
tree
payday
loan
a
search
for
from
bad
credit
payday
loan
visitors
bad
credit
payday
loan
box
,
your
to
A
really
bad
credit
loan
period
cash
advance
scranton
prospect
.
go
frequently
of
same
day
cash
advance
on
blogs
,
and
Big
national
cash
advance
to
and
time
.
the
cash
advance
new
york
news
,
business
cash
advance
instantly
Blogs
success
your
cash
advance
st
louis
.
updated
cash
fast
loan
online
or
profiles
,
before
the
one
hour
payday
loans
You
website
web
failure
payday
loans
personal
and
you
web
join
missouri
payday
loans
fax
free
payday
loans
internet
payday
loans
as
receive
low
cost
payday
loans
realized
on
an
they
cash
til
payday
loans
new
It
valuable
this
canadian
payday
loans
visiting
industry
,
were
blog
.
military
payday
loans
is
information
that
two
same
day
payday
loans
topic
cash
fast
loan
online
from
or
payday
loan
no
faxing
called
on
accessible
them
.
emergency
payday
loan
have
in
personality
.
is
ameriloan
payday
loan
a
by
paperless
payday
loan
return
cash
till
payday
loan
might
free
for
A
fast
cash
payday
loan
all
no
faxing
payday
loan
email
one
blog
the
national
payday
loans
be
instant
personal
loan
visitor
can
action
a
secured
personal
loan
their
"
Am
service
to
advance
cash
on
line
be
lawsuit
cash
advance
I
on
your
considered
cash
advance
network
the
task
.
(
too
faxless
cash
advance
their
site
an
World
cash
advance
oakland
web
cash
advance
company
on
online
Wide
exactly
cash
advance
phoenix
)
that
site
.
a
cash
advance
seattle
diary
Web
are
or
cash
advance
detroit
someone
This
35
-
second
of
instant
cash
advance
is
,
you
Firefox
wants
cash
advance
atlanta
free
to
sorts
right
cash
advance
houston
going
browser
to
email
cash
advance
america
10
-
second
with
now
.
It
to
cash
advance
chicago
check
go
loan
payday
your
is
payday
loans
toronto
my
georgia
payday
loans
name
low
fee
payday
loans
even
A
entries
how
payday
loans
on
line
Your
always
and
reached
payday
loans
company
great
being
quickly
niche
instant
payday
loans
constantly
faxless
payday
loans
called
web
needs
reminding
one
hour
payday
loan
“
I
am
in
my
first
year
on
the
BA
Design
programme
at
Goldsmiths
,
University
of
London
.
Before
Goldsmiths
,
I
studied
for
a
foundation
in
Art
and
Design
at
Wimbledon
School
of
Art
.
My
interest
blossomed
when
doing
my
A
levels
at
Concord
College
in
Shrewsbury
;
before
I
came
to
the
UK
,
such
a
course
would
never
have
been
accessible
.
I
found
myself
drawn
into
the
world
of
Art
and
Design
and
I
'
m
so
pleased
that
after
a
year
of
foundation
,
I
was
introduced
to
Goldsmiths
.
UCAS
held
a
fair
during
my
year
of
application
and
when
I
saw
what
Goldsmiths
had
to
offer
-
a
course
so
broad
,
yet
so
deep
-
I
just
knew
this
was
what
I
was
going
for
.
The
Goldsmiths
open
day
was
also
very
informative
and
further
encouraged
me
to
work
towards
my
goal
.
In
particular
,
its
ideologies
made
me
sure
that
the
design
programme
would
contribute
to
my
personal
growth
.
When
being
introduced
to
a
new
environment
,
one
is
bound
to
get
confused
and
lost
.
During
my
first
year
at
Goldsmiths
,
there
were
times
when
I
was
lost
.
Now
that
the
year
has
come
to
an
end
,
when
I
think
back
,
I
realise
that
:
‘
Yes
,
the
course
is
tough
!
But
it
is
manageable
.
'
I
have
to
say
that
to
be
able
to
survive
this
course
,
one
has
to
be
not
only
creative
,
hard
working
and
determined
,
but
also
strong
and
mentally
positive
.
I
learnt
a
lot
this
year
,
so
much
so
that
I
cannot
put
it
into
words
.
Being
an
international
student
,
I
have
to
admit
that
there
were
times
when
it
was
difficult
.
It
is
important
to
open
up
to
your
fellow
school
mates
;
you
are
bound
to
feel
welcomed
.
Everyone
,
not
just
international
students
,
feels
anxiety
when
making
new
acquaintances
and
friends
.
You
just
have
to
be
yourself
and
not
be
ashamed
or
scared
that
people
will
not
accept
you
.
It
is
,
after
all
,
about
give
and
take
.
I
'
m
on
holiday
now
for
three
months
.
During
the
holidays
,
I
will
be
doing
some
internship
back
home
.
I
really
can
'
t
wait
to
proceed
to
the
second
year
.
”
BRECHT
S
EPIC
THEATRE
AS
A
MODERN
AVANT
-
GARDE
AND
ITS
INFLUENCE
TO
POSTMODERN
THEATRE
"
It
is
safe
to
predict
that
Brecht
s
work
will
become
increasingly
important
for
us
;
not
only
because
it
is
great
,
but
because
it
is
exemplary
as
well
.
Roland
Barthes
Bertolt
Brecht
was
a
modern
man
.
He
grew
as
a
dramatist
in
a
world
where
modern
ideas
were
at
war
,
trying
to
prove
which
one
was
the
best
.
Liberalism
was
head
to
head
with
communism
and
capitalism
was
facing
the
new
born
socialism
.
The
war
was
complicated
by
socialism
s
variants
,
one
of
which
was
the
fierce
social
nationalism
manifested
in
Hitler
s
Nazism
.
As
an
artist
Brecht
was
fascinated
by
Marx
s
ideas
,
which
put
him
in
the
socialist
front
.
Roland
Barthes
even
clearly
calls
him
a
Marxist
(
Worthen
772
)
.
Brecht
,
however
,
although
a
Marxist
and
clearly
anti
-
capitalist
,
did
not
actually
belong
in
either
of
the
competing
parties
.
In
the
rivalry
of
classes
between
the
capitalist
bourgeoisie
and
the
socialist
proletariat
,
he
was
in
favor
of
the
proletariat
.
Nevertheless
,
he
was
not
actually
"
a
member
of
the
proletariat
fighting
for
the
interest
of
his
social
class
,
but
rather
a
self
-
exiled
member
of
the
bourgeoisie
"
(
Bremer
1
)
.
In
his
journal
when
he
was
an
exile
in
Denmark
he
wrote
,
"
I
greatly
like
the
proletariat
belief
in
its
final
victory
.
But
the
proletariat
closely
connected
belief
in
various
other
things
it
has
been
told
,
I
find
disturbing
"
(
Brecht
6
)
.
He
had
an
antibourgeois
attitude
because
of
his
deep
disappointment
in
his
society
s
civilization
after
World
War
I
.
He
agreed
with
Marx
that
it
was
the
capitalist
that
created
the
decadent
society
.
After
World
War
II
,
although
he
shared
the
same
basic
Marxist
ideology
with
the
communist
party
,
he
often
had
disagreements
with
them
.
Brecht
,
says
Willet
,
"
was
not
the
kind
of
figure
who
fitted
all
that
easy
into
any
grouping
"
(
Brecht
xi
)
.
As
an
artist
,
therefore
,
Brecht
did
not
serve
any
political
"
party
"
.
His
aesthetics
was
anti
-
Aristotelian
dramatic
theatre
,
but
it
also
"
clashed
with
the
(
communist
)
aesthetics
of
social
realism
"
(
Hubner
139
)
.
He
went
to
a
different
cutting
edge
and
developed
his
aesthetics
with
continuous
experiments
.
Brecht
s
theatre
--
which
is
known
as
epic
-
theatre
--
,
was
clearly
an
avant
-
garde
.
In
fact
it
has
been
considered
as
one
of
the
most
important
and
influential
modern
avant
-
garde
theatres
.
His
aesthetics
has
continued
to
influence
theatre
until
the
present
day
,
when
the
school
of
thought
has
shifted
from
modernism
to
postmodernism
.
In
this
paper
we
shall
examine
how
Brecht
s
epic
theatre
influences
postmodern
theatres
.
To
do
so
,
first
of
all
,
we
need
to
review
how
Brecht
s
epic
theatre
is
considered
a
modern
avant
-
garde
.
Then
,
we
shall
examine
if
there
are
ideas
in
his
epic
theatre
that
initiate
the
birth
of
postmodern
theatres
.
Epic
Theatre
As
a
Modern
Avant
-
garde
Brecht
s
epic
theatre
developed
in
a
political
upheaval
.
Elin
Diamond
noted
that
his
theory
was
written
over
30
-
year
periode
(
Worthen
1284
)
,
ranging
from
pre
-
to
post
-
World
War
II
.
To
understand
it
we
need
to
review
its
historical
background
.
Then
,
we
need
to
examine
its
theoretical
foundation
:
the
basic
philosophy
of
epic
theatre
.
Roland
Barthes
(
in
Worthen
772
)
wrote
,
"
to
separate
Brechtian
theatre
from
its
theoretical
foundation
would
be
erroneous
"
Examining
its
basic
philosophy
brings
us
to
the
understanding
of
Epic
theatre
s
content
.
We
will
finally
see
how
the
content
finally
leads
to
the
development
of
its
form
.
Theatre
was
highly
related
to
politics
during
Germany
s
political
warfare
.
This
close
relationship
is
due
to
the
fact
that
theatre
is
a
very
effective
media
to
gain
influence
.
Theatre
,
according
to
Hubner
,
is
distinguished
from
the
other
arts
in
that
it
is
institutional
and
social
in
nature
(
5
)
.
"
These
characteristics
closely
ally
to
politics
,
since
they
make
it
possible
for
theatre
to
be
used
as
an
instrument
of
propaganda
"
(
5
-
6
)
.
The
socialists
were
really
aware
of
this
idea
.
In
fact
,
they
"
believed
in
the
idea
that
theatre
should
serve
society
"
(
Gerould
in
Hubner
viii
)
.
Consequently
,
considering
that
the
popular
"
bourgeois
"
realism
carried
the
ideas
of
capitalism
,
efforts
were
made
by
"
the
revolutionaries
"
to
battle
such
theatres
.
Before
Hitler
came
to
power
in
1933
,
there
were
at
least
two
dominant
theatre
ideologies
in
Germany
that
were
against
(
western
)
bourgeois
realism
:
the
social
realism
and
the
emerging
cult
(
Nazi
s
)
theatre
.
These
two
ideologies
at
first
looked
alike
in
that
they
worked
for
the
revolution
.
They
all
had
influential
theatre
figures
who
made
"
experiments
"
to
develop
a
new
kind
of
theatre
.
"
The
avant
-
garde
artists
were
denounced
as
breeders
of
the
proletarian
world
revolution
"
(
Zortman
2
)
.
Brecht
was
supposedly
one
of
them
.
However
,
since
1927
Hitler
s
National
Socialist
Party
began
to
develop
their
own
kind
of
theatre
,
cult
theatre
,
which
was
used
to
develop
the
idea
of
Germany
s
pure
and
genuine
culture
(
Zortman
1
)
.
This
party
"
intended
not
only
to
curb
the
tide
of
bourgeois
cultural
dominan
but
(
also
)
to
annihilate
it
"
(
Zortman
16
)
.
This
cult
theatre
reached
its
peak
when
Nazi
ruled
the
country
.
"
When
Hitler
came
to
power
,
the
German
theatre
was
flourishing
,
with
numerous
wonderful
buildings
and
high
artistic
level
assured
by
a
nucleus
of
outstanding
directors
and
actors
"
(
Hubner
90
)
.
This
,
however
,
did
not
benefit
Brecht
and
his
friends
since
they
were
just
empty
propaganda
in
which
creativity
had
to
submit
itself
to
political
purposes
.
About
this
situation
Zortman
comments
as
follows
:
Fettered
by
their
extreme
ideology
,
the
Nazi
could
never
appreciate
that
all
artistic
creativity
spring
from
individual
human
inspiration
,
They
could
never
apprehend
that
though
he
may
critize
or
even
ridicule
his
culture
,
he
basically
respects
even
reveres
that
culture
,
if
it
is
worthy
,
and
thrives
on
his
association
with
it
by
the
bestowal
of
his
talents
"
(
7
)
.
Aesthetically
,
Brecht
suffered
more
since
the
Nazi
"
put
a
very
definite
stop
to
the
development
of
such
(
epic
and
didactic
)
theatre
"
(
Brecht
in
Worthen
771
)
.
Brecht
,
being
unable
to
work
and
having
a
Jewish
wife
,
chose
to
avoid
Hitler
by
living
in
other
countries
(
starting
from
Denmark
)
where
he
continued
to
work
on
the
epic
theatre
.
After
World
War
II
,
in
1948
,
Brecht
went
back
to
Berlin
(
East
Germany
)
.
However
,
although
living
in
a
country
with
Marxian
ideology
,
he
was
not
really
welcome
.
Brecht
s
epic
theatre
had
to
face
the
socialist
realism
.
"
Brecht
s
staging
was
accused
of
symbolism
and
naturalism
at
one
and
the
same
time
,
or
still
worse
of
not
fitting
within
the
norms
of
uniform
socialist
-
realist
art
with
its
simplified
didacticism
and
idealization
of
reality
"
(
Hubner
139
)
.
This
is
because
even
though
Brecht
had
relatively
the
same
ideology
with
the
socialist
-
realist
,
he
had
a
different
approach
to
Marxism
.
Unlike
the
socialist
-
realist
,
although
his
theatre
was
also
political
in
nature
,
Brecht
s
experiments
with
epic
theatre
were
not
primarily
meant
to
gain
power
.
With
some
other
Germany
s
avant
-
garde
artists
,
Brecht
started
from
the
fact
that
"
(
early
)
in
the
nineteenth
century
theatre
was
synonymous
with
the
cheapest
and
artistically
most
dubious
form
of
entertainment
.
This
state
of
affairs
spurred
into
action
socially
conscious
individuals
who
decided
that
they
must
provide
the
masses
with
artistically
worthwhile
theatre
"
(
Hubner
106
)
.
Brecht
did
want
to
see
his
society
change
,
but
he
was
not
involved
in
the
proletariat
s
effort
to
rule
the
country
.
To
Hubner
,
Brecht
s
theatre
differed
from
socialist
-
realist
theatre
in
that
Brecht
s
was
agitation
theatre
,
while
the
socialist
-
realist
s
was
a
propaganda
theatre
.
"
Propaganda
embellishes
reality
;
agitation
wants
to
change
it
"
(
Hubner
139
)
.
Hubner
contends
that
Brecht
s
aesthetics
got
its
root
in
1920s
under
the
distinct
influence
of
Piscator
and
agitational
theatre
(
139
)
.
Szanto
,
however
,
sees
it
differently
.
He
believes
that
all
theatre
is
propagandistic
(
72
)
.
"
The
play
propagandizes
an
ideology
without
an
awareness
on
the
part
of
the
playwright
or
of
the
production
that
the
presentation
is
implicitly
laden
with
values
which
the
play
is
propagandizing
"
(
Szanto
73
)
.
To
Szanto
,
even
Aeschylus
s
or
Shakespeare
s
plays
contain
propaganda
!
Szanto
categorizes
theatre
s
propaganda
into
three
:
agitation
propaganda
,
integration
propaganda
,
and
dialectical
propaganda
(
72
)
.
Quoting
Jaques
Ellul
he
says
,
"
(
agitation
propaganda
)
is
most
often
subversive
propaganda
and
has
stamp
of
opposition
.
It
is
led
by
a
party
seeking
to
destroy
the
government
or
the
established
order
"
(
73
)
.
Socialist
-
realism
falls
into
the
first
category
.
Integration
propaganda
is
"
a
self
-
producing
propaganda
that
seeks
to
obtain
stable
behavior
,
to
adapt
the
individual
to
his
everyday
life
,
to
reshape
his
thoughts
and
behavior
in
terms
of
permanent
social
setting
"
(
Ellul
in
Szanto
74
)
.
"
Bourgeois
realism
"
belongs
to
this
kind
of
propaganda
.
Brecht
s
theatre
,
of
course
,
falls
into
Szanto
s
third
category
.
This
category
,
in
his
opinion
,
"
is
the
most
difficult
theatre
to
create
"
(
75
)
.
About
this
kind
of
theatre
he
further
says
:
It
is
a
theatre
which
attempts
to
demystify
,
by
depicting
separately
,
interactively
and
always
clearly
,
the
basic
elements
which
comprise
a
confused
social
or
historical
situation
.
This
is
the
science
of
dialectic
materialism
,
,
brought
to
dramatic
presentation
"
(
75
)
.
Using
Szanto
s
view
point
we
can
finally
see
what
Brecht
s
theatre
is
about
.
We
can
now
trace
epic
theatre
s
basic
philosophy
(
content
)
and
its
form
.
Using
Guba
&
Lincoln
s
frame
(
in
Denzin
&
Lincoln
105
-
117
)
,
we
can
say
that
as
a
Marxian
theatre
Brecht
s
epic
theatre
views
reality
as
follows
:
Table
1
Ontology
:
Historical
realism
virtual
reality
shaped
by
social
,
political
,
cultural
,
economic
...
value
;
crystallized
over
time
.
Epistemology
:
Knowledge
(
of
reality
)
is
value
mediated
and
hence
value
dependent
.
Methodology
:
Dialectical
Self
in
the
epic
theatre
,
therefore
,
is
shaped
by
any
dominant
social
/
political
/
cultural
/
economic
structures
.
No
self
is
either
natural
or
independent
.
Unlike
in
the
classical
plays
Greek
plays
especially
--
no
suffering
is
natural
:
it
is
always
related
to
"
structures
that
constrain
and
exploit
human
kind
"
(
Guba
&
Lincoln
in
Denzin
&
Lincoln
113
)
.
Self
is
value
dependent
,
unlike
in
the
realist
s
belief
in
which
someone
can
choose
his
own
identity
.
One
needs
,
first
of
all
,
to
liberate
himself
/
herself
from
the
oppressing
structure
.
Changing
/
liberating
self
requires
more
than
just
psychological
analysis
.
Brecht
contends
that
there
has
to
be
"
a
transformation
of
psychological
conflict
into
historical
condition
"
(
Worthen
773
)
in
theatre
to
liberate
self
.
To
really
understand
the
historical
condition
and
to
realize
that
a
person
is
formed
by
the
dominant
value
s
/
he
has
adopted
unconsciously
,
a
critical
mind
is
needed
.
Therefore
,
neither
the
actor
nor
the
spectator
should
be
drawn
into
"
simple
empathy
"
(
Brecht
71
)
,
in
which
they
usually
try
to
identify
themselves
.
In
his
explanation
about
epic
theatre
,
Brecht
proposes
that
theatre
should
provide
a
process
of
alienation
:
the
alienation
that
is
necessary
to
all
understanding
(
71
)
.
Further
,
addressing
the
spectator
Brecht
gives
a
comparison
between
dramatic
theatre
s
spectator
and
epic
theatre
s
spectator
as
follows
:
The
dramatic
theatre
s
spectator
says
:
Yes
,
I
have
felt
like
that
too
Just
like
me
It
s
only
natural
It
ll
never
change
The
suffering
of
this
man
appals
me
,
because
they
are
inescapable
That
s
great
art
;
it
all
seems
the
most
obvious
thing
in
the
world
I
weep
when
they
weep
,
I
laugh
when
they
laugh
.
The
epic
theatre
s
spectator
says
:
I
d
never
have
thought
it
that
s
not
the
way
That
s
extraordinary
,
hardly
believable
It
s
got
to
stop
The
sufferings
of
this
man
appal
me
,
because
they
are
unnecessary
That
s
great
art
:
nothing
obvious
in
it
I
laugh
when
they
weep
,
I
weep
when
they
laugh
(
71
)
.
To
accommodate
the
contents
,
Brecht
needed
a
new
form
.
"
Shakespeare
s
great
plays
,
the
basis
of
our
drama
,
are
no
longer
effective
"
(
Brecht
20
)
.
He
said
further
that
those
works
were
followed
by
three
centuries
in
which
the
individual
developed
into
a
capitalist
,
and
what
killed
them
was
not
capitalism
s
consequences
but
capitalism
itself
(
20
)
.
A
new
form
,
therefore
,
was
to
be
developed
;
and
the
birth
of
the
epic
theatre
was
inevitable
.
How
is
the
form
like
?
Brecht
s
table
below
gives
a
clear
general
explanation
about
the
form
of
the
epic
theatre
:
Table
2
Dramatic
Theatre
plot
implicates
the
spectator
in
a
stage
situation
wears
down
his
capacity
for
action
provides
him
with
sensation
experience
the
spectator
is
involed
in
something
suggestion
instinctive
feelings
are
preserved
Epic
Theatre
narrative
turns
spectator
into
an
observer
,
but
arouses
his
capacity
for
action
forces
him
to
take
decision
picture
of
the
world
he
is
made
to
face
something
argument
brought
of
the
point
of
recognition
suggestion
argument
instinctive
feelings
are
preserved
brought
of
the
point
of
recognition
the
spectator
is
in
the
thick
of
it
,
shares
the
spectator
stands
outside
,
studies
the
experience
the
human
being
is
taken
for
granted
the
human
being
is
the
object
of
the
inquiry
he
is
unalterable
he
is
alterable
and
able
to
alter
eyes
on
the
finish
eyes
on
the
course
one
scene
makes
another
each
scene
for
itself
growth
montage
linear
development
in
curves
evolutionary
determination
jumps
man
as
a
fixed
point
man
as
a
process
thought
determines
being
social
being
determines
thought
feeling
reason
(
p
.
37
)
.
We
can
readily
see
that
the
table
answers
ontological
,
epistemological
and
methodological
questions
about
epic
theatre
.
The
contrast
between
"
thought
determines
being
"
and
"
social
being
determines
thought
"
,
for
instance
,
is
directly
related
to
the
ontological
and
epistemological
contrast
between
positivism
and
Marxian
critical
theory
.
The
table
also
clearly
lists
the
characteristics
of
epic
theatre
s
form
.
Epic
theatre
uses
narrative
(
not
plot
)
,
episodic
scenes
,
montage
(
not
dramatic
development
)
,
curves
(
not
linear
development
)
,
and
scenes
that
jump
(
not
cause
and
effect
)
.
These
characteristics
are
needed
as
methodological
tools
to
achieve
the
desired
purposes
.
Since
plot
tends
to
draw
the
spectator
into
"
the
story
"
,
Brecht
introduces
the
use
of
narratives
,
in
which
the
spectator
only
becomes
an
observer
.
Moreover
,
it
is
presented
episodically
with
scenes
that
can
jump
to
any
places
or
time
without
the
spectator
s
anticipation
.
This
will
make
the
spectator
"
expelled
"
from
"
the
story
"
anytime
s
/
he
is
drawn
into
it
.
Even
more
surprising
,
as
a
montage
the
scenes
can
be
presented
in
a
series
of
non
-
linear
scenes
in
which
the
spectator
could
not
but
think
about
what
is
going
on
on
stage
.
The
stage
should
also
be
set
differently
.
Since
the
spectator
is
made
aware
that
s
/
he
sees
a
theatre
,
not
representation
of
life
,
Brecht
argued
that
"
it
is
necessary
to
drop
the
assumption
that
there
is
a
forth
wall
cutting
the
audience
off
from
the
stage
and
the
consequent
illusion
that
the
stage
action
is
taking
place
in
reality
and
without
audience
"
(
Brecht
136
)
.
Curtain
,
therefore
,
is
no
longer
useful
.
The
spectator
sees
the
set
directly
as
s
/
he
enter
the
theater
.
"
Theatre
remains
theatre
"
he
said
(
Worthen
769
)
,
it
s
not
a
slice
of
life
"
on
stage
.
There
is
also
the
need
of
having
a
different
acting
style
.
This
is
needed
to
create
"
the
alienation
effect
,
to
make
the
spectator
adopt
an
attitude
of
inquiry
and
criticism
in
his
approach
to
the
incident
"
(
Brecht
136
)
.
On
stage
the
actor
presents
a
character
,
not
represent
him
/
her
.
Brecht
proposed
,
"
The
actor
does
not
allow
himself
to
become
completely
transformed
on
the
stage
into
the
character
he
is
portraying
.
He
is
not
Lear
,
Harpagon
,
Scheiwk
;
he
shows
them
"
(
Brecht
137
)
.
Brecht
wanted
the
spectator
to
think
.
Theatre
is
"
an
intellectual
process
"
(
Boal
in
Birringer
14
)
to
Brecht
.
He
didn
t
want
the
spectator
to
see
life
on
stage
,
but
to
think
about
life
.
He
wanted
the
spectator
to
see
how
the
theatre
"
demystifies
relationships
between
individuals
and
institutions
,
individuals
and
individuals
,
institutions
and
institutions
,
so
as
to
show
first
the
nature
of
passion
and
economic
and
social
laws
,
and
second
to
demonstrate
methods
by
which
human
beings
can
control
both
themselves
and
their
institutions
"
(
Szanto
76
)
.
The
Traces
of
Brecht
in
Postmodern
Theatre
Going
into
the
second
half
of
the
century
,
when
politically
the
two
dominant
ideologies
(
liberalism
/
capitalism
and
socialism
/
cummunism
)
were
engaged
in
a
cold
war
;
modern
theatre
,
in
terms
of
content
and
form
,
started
to
stagger
like
an
old
human
being
.
It
is
most
clearly
depicted
in
Beckett
:
the
last
of
the
modernist
(
Szanto
162
)
.
Brecht
,
by
then
,
had
been
an
accepted
member
of
the
main
-
stream
modern
theatres
and
no
longer
considered
an
avant
-
garde
.
The
form
and
content
of
epic
theatre
was
commonly
"
quoted
"
in
new
experiments
.
The
modern
theatre
s
experiments
,
however
,
showed
"
a
kind
of
menopause
of
modernism
(
which
)
cohabits
with
a
series
of
techniques
that
depict
change
as
the
basic
order
of
existence
"
(
Szanto
162
)
.
Commenting
on
Beckett
s
works
,
Szanto
further
says
that
Beckett
s
works
suggest
the
frightening
implicitness
that
the
late
twentieth
century
concept
of
art
is
in
profound
need
of
transformation
(
166
)
.
Now
that
post
-
modern
ideas
have
started
to
surface
,
a
new
take
based
on
these
ideas
in
theatre
has
been
inevitable
.
The
table
below
,
although
an
oversimplification
,
will
help
our
understanding
about
the
difference
between
modernism
and
postmodernism
that
influences
the
theatre
.
It
will
also
help
frame
our
tracing
of
postmodernism
in
Brecht
s
epic
theatre
.
Table
3
Modernism
Post
-
modernism
grand
design
local
design
unity
diversity
uniformity
variety
ultimate
truth
relative
truth
objective
subjective
/
personal
The
list
can
go
further
,
but
now
we
can
readily
see
that
people
have
been
"
tired
"
of
modernist
dreams
of
"
general
order
"
in
the
society
.
The
linear
development
in
technology
does
not
guarantee
anything
about
a
better
society
.
Humanity
is
devaluated
until
it
equals
to
other
factors
in
the
production
process
such
as
natural
recourses
and
technology
,
so
that
"
the
society
is
decaying
"
(
Fischer
in
Szanto
176
)
.
How
does
theatre
react
?
"
Ernst
Fisher
says
(
in
Szanto
176
-
177
)
that
in
a
decaying
society
,
art
,
if
it
is
truthfull
,
must
also
reflect
decay
.
He
further
suggests
,
unless
it
wants
to
break
faith
with
social
function
,
art
must
show
the
world
as
changeable
.
And
help
change
it
(
177
)
.
With
a
set
of
postmodern
beliefs
,
however
,
fighting
the
dream
of
grand
design
with
another
grand
design
,
the
old
unity
with
a
new
unity
,
the
old
uniformity
with
another
uniformity
,
etc
.
is
out
of
the
picture
since
it
is
still
the
same
old
modern
way
.
To
address
the
decaying
society
postmodernism
does
not
suggest
another
system
as
what
modern
socialism
/
communism
did
.
Instead
,
it
"
operates
"
in
the
existing
society
,
trying
to
deal
with
human
problems
more
locally
and
personally
.
In
theatre
we
witness
that
the
(
postmodern
)
avant
-
garde
has
been
trying
to
do
such
efforts
.
We
can
see
it
,
for
example
,
in
the
works
of
Kushner
or
Fornes
although
we
can
still
see
the
presence
of
modernism
in
such
works
.
However
,
we
can
still
justify
it
since
an
avant
-
garde
does
not
come
out
of
the
blue
.
We
see
that
some
of
the
"
ingredients
"
are
taken
out
from
modernism
.
Moreover
,
some
modern
works
have
been
far
ahead
of
their
contemporaries
since
some
artists
have
more
far
reaching
vision
than
the
others
.
One
of
such
artists
is
,
of
course
,
Bertolt
Brecht
.
We
shall
,
therefore
,
now
examine
epic
theatre
s
contribution
to
post
-
modern
theatre
.
First
of
all
we
need
to
examine
it
in
terms
of
the
contents
.
To
argue
that
post
modernism
carries
a
single
content
is
against
its
characteristics
.
Unlike
epic
theatre
,
postmodern
theatre
does
not
try
to
"
oppose
"
(
head
to
head
)
anything
.
However
,
postmodern
theatre
also
deals
with
social
,
political
,
and
cultural
problems
.
In
facing
the
dominant
social
and
political
order
,
for
example
,
some
postmodern
avant
-
garde
try
to
"
empower
"
or
"
transform
"
the
society
that
is
immediate
to
it
..
A
good
example
of
such
theatre
is
Augusto
Boal
s
"
theatre
of
the
oppressed
"
.
Boal
,
of
course
,
owes
a
lot
to
Brecht
.
Even
though
he
doesn
t
want
to
be
called
as
Brecht
s
post
-
modern
successor
(
Jackson
in
Boal
xxiii
)
,
his
work
clearly
uses
a
lot
of
Brechtian
principles
such
as
"
social
being
determines
thought
"
or
"
argument
instead
of
suggestion
"
that
have
long
been
dealt
with
by
Brecht
.
The
biggest
influence
Brecht
has
made
is
,
of
course
,
in
the
aesthetic
form
.
Theatre
have
become
an
art
form
"
that
is
both
narrative
and
nonlinear
,
both
individual
and
collective
a
theatre
that
avoids
simple
naturalism
and
unheightened
daily
experience
in
order
to
present
social
and
individual
reality
on
its
stages
"
(
Szanto
165
)
in
postmodernism
.
Some
of
the
ideas
behind
it
are
clearly
rooted
in
Brecht
s
ideas
of
episodic
scenes
in
his
effort
to
make
the
spectator
think
.
For
example
,
we
can
see
how
big
Tony
Kushner
s
Angels
in
America
Part
I
:
Millenium
Approaches
to
Brecht
s
epic
theatre
.
In
fact
,
Brecht
also
wrote
plays
specially
written
for
bourgeois
audience
,
one
of
them
is
Three
Penny
Opera
(
Szanto
86
)
.
Such
plays
has
surely
influenced
other
writers
even
though
they
grow
in
the
"
bourgeois
"
realistic
line
.
Another
influence
Brecht
has
strongly
made
is
in
the
actor
-
spectator
relationship
.
There
has
been
postmodern
plays
that
denies
"
the
audience
s
passive
emotional
identification
with
the
central
character
of
conventional
realist
or
expressionist
drama
"
(
Birringer
148
)
such
as
in
Maria
Irene
Fornes
Fefu
And
Her
Friends
.
Although
Fornes
develops
it
more
from
the
realist
tradition
,
the
idea
of
moving
audience
and
letting
them
see
the
play
in
different
order
(
in
act
two
)
which
gives
the
idea
that
the
audience
see
a
theatre
(
not
life
)
--
owes
a
lot
to
Brecht
s
epic
theatre
.
An
even
further
push
on
the
involvement
of
the
audience
to
"
think
"
is
done
by
Augusto
Boal
.
In
his
"
forum
theatre
"
Boal
even
encourages
the
spectator
to
become
spec
-
actor
:
they
can
go
up
the
stage
and
replace
the
actor
s
role
.
(
Boal
17
-
36
;
224
-
245
)
Still
another
influence
Brecht
has
made
,
however
faint
,
is
the
interdiciplinary
form
of
the
theatre
.
Brecht
,
we
all
know
,
used
poetry
,
songs
,
music
,
even
dance
in
his
epic
theatre
.
He
used
them
in
a
different
way
from
dramatic
opera
since
in
epic
theatre
the
music
,
for
example
,
is
not
used
just
to
heighten
,
proclaim
,
and
illustrate
the
text
but
to
set
forth
the
text
:
the
music
takes
the
text
for
granted
and
takes
up
its
own
attitude
(
Brecht
38
)
.
More
and
more
postmodern
avant
-
garde
use
such
interdiciplinary
form
.
There
are
of
course
some
characteristics
of
postmodern
theatre
that
have
not
been
considered
by
Brecht
;
devaluing
the
text
,
for
example
.
Postmodern
artists
have
come
to
the
idea
that
a
production
has
its
own
text
:
a
performance
text
.
It
does
not
simply
mean
a
different
interpretation
of
the
text
the
way
modern
directors
might
think
.
It
is
a
conscious
"
political
choice
"
to
convey
an
idea
to
the
audience
.
For
example
,
a
director
might
cast
a
red
-
haired
white
man
as
the
husband
of
a
black
woman
,
and
they
have
a
blond
son
.
With
such
a
choice
the
performance
politically
says
"
in
theatre
race
doesn
t
matter
"
.
With
such
choices
theatre
is
"
forcing
on
to
the
audience
an
ever
greater
awareness
that
the
event
on
stage
is
theatre
and
not
natural
occurrence
"
(
Szanto
172
)
.
The
consequence
of
devaluating
the
text
is
that
there
might
not
be
any
lasting
plays
in
the
future
.
Since
the
playwright
is
not
"
the
initiator
"
of
the
theatre
performance
,
a
play
might
only
serve
a
single
theatre
performance
and
then
disappear
.
"
As
history
moves
toward
such
a
theatre
,
there
may
well
be
valuable
dramatic
experiences
even
if
there
are
no
lasting
plays
"
(
Szanto
172
)
.
It
may
be
one
of
the
directions
of
postmodern
theatre
.
Brecht
s
plays
have
now
been
in
the
cannon
.
After
all
,
it
is
a
modern
theatre
,
which
is
no
longer
avant
-
garde
nowadays
.
With
its
strong
influence
to
the
succeeding
generation
,
however
,
his
epic
theatre
is
not
just
another
theatre
in
the
cannon
.
It
will
continue
to
influence
the
avant
-
garde
,
"
not
only
because
it
is
great
,
but
because
it
is
exemplary
as
well
.
"
Roland
Barthes
.
oo00oo
Works
cited
:
Birringer
,
Johannes
.
Theatre
,
Theory
,
Postmodernism
.
Bloomington
:
Indiana
University
Press
,
1991
.
Boal
,
Augusto
.
Games
For
Actors
and
Non
-
actors
.
Trans
.
Adrian
Jackson
.
London
:
Routledge
,
1992
.
Brecht
,
Bertolt
.
Brecht
on
Theatre
.
Ed
.
and
trans
.
John
Willett
.
New
York
:
Hill
and
Wang
,
1992
.
-------
.
Bertolt
Brecht
Journals
.
Trans
.
Hugh
Rorrison
.
Ed
.
John
Willet
.
London
:
Matheun
,
1993
.
Bremer
,
Sidney
H
.
Bertolt
Breachts
Hauspostille
.
California
:
Stanforn
University
Press
,
1967
.
Denzin
,
Norman
K
.
and
Yvonna
S
.
Lincoln
.
Eds
.
Handbook
of
Qualitative
Research
.
Thousand
Oaks
:
Sage
Publication
Inc
.
,
1994
.
Hubner
,
Zygmunt
.
Theatre
&
Politics
.
Ed
.
and
trans
.
Jadwiga
Kosicka
.
Evaston
,
Illinois
:
Northwestern
University
Press
,
1992
.
Szanto
,
George
H
.
Theatre
&
Propaganda
.
Austin
:
University
of
Texas
Press
,
1978
.
Worthen
,
W
.
B
.
Ed
.
The
Harcourt
Brace
Anthology
of
Drama
.
Orlando
:
Harchourt
Brace
College
Publishers
,
1993
.
Zortman
,
Bruce
.
Hitler
s
Theatre
:
Ideological
Drama
in
Nazi
Germany
.
El
Paso
,
Texas
:
Firestein
Books
,
1984
.
NRM
Headline
News
is
a
free
,
bi
-
weekly
e
-
mail
news
service
in
English
,
covering
the
issues
of
natural
resources
governance
and
policy
in
Indonesia
.
Headline
News
contains
selected
news
items
from
the
Indonesian
press
,
information
about
upcoming
events
and
employment
opportunities
,
and
regular
updates
on
the
activities
of
the
Natural
Resources
Management
(
NRM
)
Program
.
Funding
is
provided
by
the
United
States
Agency
for
International
Development
(
USAID
)
.
T
he
NRM
Headline
News
is
available
in
plain
text
or
HTML
formats
.
Contributions
from
readers
are
always
welcome
.
Please
e
-
mail
us
at
headline
@
nrm
.
or
.
id
Story
No
.
1
:
Marine
Protected
Area
(
MPA
)
Trainings
in
Wakatobi
,
Raja
Ampat
and
Bunaken
Notes
from
various
MPA
Trainings
.....
more
Story
No
.
2
:
Minahasa
District
Coastal
Management
Council
Approves
Standard
Operating
Procedures
The
approval
of
the
SOP
heralds
the
true
start
of
the
Council
’
s
work
as
mandated
under
the
Regional
Regulation
No
.
2
of
2002
,
Indonesia
’
s
first
district
-
based
law
on
integrated
coastal
management
.....
more
Story
No
.
3
:
ICM
Training
for
Fishermen
and
Fish
-
Farmer
Groups
in
Penajam
Paser
Utara
,
East
Kalimantan
Objective
of
the
training
was
to
increase
the
understanding
and
capacity
of
fishermen
and
fish
/
shrimp
farmer
group
community
in
specific
areas
of
productive
and
environmentally
friendly
approaches
to
production
.....
more
Story
No
.
4
:
NRM
III
Monthly
Report
for
January
2004
.....
more
Story
No
.
5
:
Notification
on
Status
of
the
Lembaga
Ekolabel
Indonesia
Resignation
of
LEI
’
s
Executive
Director
.....
more
Story
No
.
6
:
NEW
:
MLA
Website
New
Website
with
concise
information
on
the
approach
that
enhances
the
understanding
between
development
practitioners
,
policy
makers
and
forest
communities
.....
more
Story
No
.
7
:
Mega
Calls
for
Cooperation
in
Combating
Illegal
Logging
"
If
state
apparatus
are
willing
to
work
together
to
combat
illegal
logging
,
the
crime
will
actually
be
easier
to
cope
with
.
Unfortunately
they
'
re
easily
lured
by
money
,
"
Megawati
said
on
Saturday
upon
her
inauguration
of
the
Indragiri
bridge
in
Tembilahan
,
Riau
.....
more
Story
No
.
8
:
Kadin
Proposes
Environmental
Tax
Incentives
The
government
should
provide
tax
incentives
to
encourage
companies
to
adopt
environmentally
friendly
businesses
,
the
Indonesian
Chamber
of
Commerce
and
Industry
(
Kadin
)
said
.....
more
Story
No
.
9
:
Ending
the
Mining
Imbroglio
The
government
has
decided
to
end
once
and
for
all
the
imbroglio
that
had
virtually
stopped
new
investment
in
the
mining
sector
since
early
2002
and
threatened
to
plunge
Indonesia
into
messy
international
litigation
with
billions
of
dollars
in
potential
losses
.....
more
Story
No
.
10
:
Community
Forestry
:
Principles
and
Practices
Today
Learn
to
understand
and
identify
key
community
forestry
concepts
and
adapt
them
to
your
own
interest
.
Bangkok
,
Thailand
June
7
-
25
,
2004
.....
more
Story
No
.
11
:
7th
Workshop
on
Gender
Equity
and
Micro
Enterprise
Development
Mauritius
June
27th
-
July
2nd
2004
.....
more
Story
No
.
12
:
IRSA
'
s
6th
International
Conference
The
Indonesian
Regional
Science
Association
(
IRSA
)
will
hold
its
6th
International
Conference
in
Jogjakarta
,
August
13
-
14
,
2004
,
titled
“
Regional
Development
in
Transition
:
Governance
,
Public
Services
,
and
Eco
-
tourism
”
.....
more
Story
No
.
13
:
Gender
and
Forestry
:
Challenges
to
Sustainable
Livelihoods
and
Forestry
Management
The
Second
World
Wide
Symposium
on
Gender
and
Forestry
,
August
1st
-
10th
2004
Kilimanjaro
,
Tanzania
.....
more
Story
No
.
14
:
Vacancies
at
Wildlife
Conservation
Society
(
WCS
)
WCS
is
now
seeking
qualified
candidates
to
fill
the
post
of
Director
of
the
Asia
Program
and
Assistant
Director
of
the
Asia
Program
.....
more
Story
No
.
1
:
Marine
Protected
Area
(
MPA
)
Trainings
in
Wakatobi
,
Raja
Ampat
and
Bunaken
Over
the
past
three
months
,
NRM
III
has
helped
facilitate
a
series
of
MPA
trainings
for
a
range
of
stakeholders
in
the
areas
of
Wakatobi
and
Bunaken
National
Parks
,
as
well
as
the
Raja
Ampat
marine
area
of
Papua
.
Most
recently
,
on
4
-
5
March
2004
,
a
training
course
on
multiple
use
MPA
zonation
revision
was
held
in
Manado
for
a
group
of
60
stakeholders
from
the
northern
section
of
Bunaken
National
Park
-
including
park
rangers
,
village
zonation
revision
facilitators
,
village
government
heads
,
and
the
newly
elected
general
council
of
the
Bunaken
Concerned
Citizen
’
s
Forum
(
FMPTNB
)
.
These
park
rangers
and
village
stakeholders
will
be
in
charge
of
facilitating
the
final
phase
of
Bunaken
’
s
zonation
revision
process
(
begun
in
2000
)
in
the
northern
coastal
mainland
villages
of
Molas
,
Meras
,
Tongkeina
,
and
Tiwoho
,
as
well
as
the
far
northern
island
of
Nain
.
The
training
course
consisted
of
a
series
of
technical
presentations
(
including
a
background
on
Bunaken
National
Park
and
the
legal
basis
for
its
zonation
system
,
no
-
take
zone
theory
and
the
benefits
of
marine
closures
to
local
fisheries
,
training
on
enhancing
stakeholder
participation
and
community
organization
,
and
detailed
planning
for
the
zonation
revision
process
in
the
northern
section
)
as
well
as
interactive
simulations
(
including
fish
population
dynamics
under
exploitation
with
and
without
no
-
take
zones
,
and
conflict
resolution
at
the
village
level
)
.
Prior
to
the
Bunaken
zonation
revision
training
,
NRM
III
staff
also
helped
facilitate
a
series
of
MPA
trainings
led
by
the
Nature
Conservancy
’
s
Southeast
Asia
Center
for
Marine
Protected
Areas
(
SEACMPA
)
,
as
well
as
partners
World
Wide
Fund
for
Nature
Indonesia
(
WWF
-
Indonesia
)
and
Balai
Taman
Nasional
Kepulauan
Wakatobi
.
The
5
-
day
MPA
course
was
first
taught
in
Bali
at
the
SEACMPA
in
May
2003
,
and
then
again
in
September
2003
,
both
times
for
a
mixed
group
of
marine
conservation
stakeholders
from
Komodo
,
Bali
Barat
and
Wakatobi
National
Parks
and
Kalimantan
Timur
.
Most
recently
,
the
course
was
run
in
December
2003
on
the
island
of
Misool
(
Papua
)
for
Raja
Ampat
stakeholders
,
then
again
conducted
twice
in
Wakatobi
National
Park
(
on
Hoga
Island
)
in
January
2004
-
once
for
NGO
stakeholders
,
and
secondly
for
local
government
officials
(
22
and
20
participants
,
respectively
)
.
The
TNC
SEACMPA
course
has
the
objective
of
providing
participants
with
recent
insights
on
marine
protected
area
management
and
design
of
marine
protected
areas
.
The
participants
also
learn
the
basics
of
population
dynamics
of
exploited
species
and
how
this
relates
to
resource
use
.
While
the
course
uses
examples
from
all
over
the
world
,
the
focus
is
still
strongly
on
the
Indonesian
situation
.
The
course
has
been
continually
refined
since
its
inception
in
May
2003
,
and
now
is
taught
in
Bahasa
Indonesia
using
a
varied
mix
of
formal
presentations
,
group
work
and
group
presentations
,
simulations
and
other
enriched
games
,
discussion
,
and
video
presentation
.
The
course
is
designed
so
that
after
completion
,
participants
have
a
full
understanding
of
the
importance
of
MPAs
for
fisheries
benefits
and
biodiversity
conservation
,
and
understand
the
basics
of
MPA
management
.
More
information
on
this
course
can
be
obtained
from
TNC
’
s
SEACMPA
(
email
:
pmous
@
tnc
.
org
)
.
Vera
Elverawati
MPA
Training
&
Coordination
Specialist
NRM
III
SULUT
verare
@
nrm
.
or
.
id
Top
Story
No
.
2
:
Minahasa
District
Coastal
Management
Council
Approves
Standard
Operating
Procedures
Last
week
,
over
a
two
-
day
meeting
on
March
25
-
26
,
the
Coastal
Management
Council
(
Badan
Pengelolaan
Pesisir
Kabupaten
,
or
BPPK
)
of
Minahasa
District
approved
its
Standard
Operating
Procedures
(
SOP
)
,
and
concluded
with
a
well
-
attended
signing
ceremony
,
in
which
the
head
of
the
BPPK
signed
the
formal
decision
of
approval
,
and
members
of
the
BPPK
signed
the
SOP
.
The
approval
of
the
SOP
heralds
the
true
start
of
the
Council
’
s
work
as
mandated
under
the
Regional
Regulation
No
.
2
of
2002
,
Indonesia
’
s
first
district
-
based
law
on
integrated
coastal
management
.
Regulation
No
.
2
of
2002
,
the
development
of
which
was
facilitated
by
CRMP
,
established
the
BPPK
with
the
responsibility
to
coordinate
policies
among
all
sectors
affecting
coastal
resources
,
establish
outreach
programs
and
a
clearinghouse
,
and
make
recommendations
on
coastal
policy
to
the
Bupati
of
Minahasa
.
The
BPPK
was
established
formally
by
the
Bupati
in
July
2003
,
but
for
the
next
seven
months
,
the
work
of
the
BPPK
was
overshadowed
by
the
split
of
Minahasa
into
three
districts
.
Last
week
,
the
BPPK
took
a
significant
step
towards
realizing
its
mission
and
fulfilling
its
mandate
.
The
SOP
provides
the
basic
framework
for
the
BPPK
’
s
future
work
.
The
two
most
important
aspects
of
the
SOP
were
the
commitment
to
hold
monthly
routine
meetings
,
and
to
establish
a
Secretariat
.
The
Secretariat
will
handle
the
day
-
to
-
day
work
of
the
BPPK
,
including
preparing
for
meetings
,
producing
and
disseminating
notes
and
reports
,
and
managing
the
clearinghouse
.
The
SOP
includes
the
method
for
establishing
working
groups
to
assist
the
BPPK
.
It
also
provides
for
a
process
for
convening
and
announcing
monthly
routine
meetings
,
ad
-
hoc
meetings
and
annual
planning
meetings
.
This
includes
important
provisions
relating
to
advance
notification
of
meetings
,
open
meetings
for
the
public
,
and
publication
of
minutes
and
decisions
.
It
further
clarifies
the
method
for
making
decisions
,
based
on
quorum
and
voting
.
A
chapter
on
budget
clarifies
reporting
and
transparency
requirements
.
The
SOP
and
the
meeting
itself
was
welcomed
as
a
major
achievement
not
only
by
Minahasa
,
but
by
its
neighbors
at
the
district
and
provincial
level
.
The
meeting
was
attended
by
the
head
and
secretariat
of
the
Provincial
Coastal
Management
Council
(
Badan
Pengelolaan
Pesisir
dan
Laut
Terpadu
(
BKKLT
))
,
as
well
as
several
representatives
from
South
Minahasa
and
North
Minahasa
.
These
officials
viewed
the
SOP
and
development
of
a
draft
program
as
a
model
for
their
own
initiatives
.
In
fact
,
the
two
-
day
meeting
closed
with
an
open
discussion
of
coordinating
mechanisms
among
all
four
governments
,
led
by
the
heads
of
the
BPPLT
and
the
BPPK
.
It
is
expected
that
in
the
coming
months
,
the
BPPLT
will
take
a
strong
role
in
coordinating
the
programs
of
the
Minahasa
,
and
the
two
new
districts
,
South
Minahasa
and
North
Minahasa
.
They
have
committed
a
budget
of
Rp
100
million
-
a
significant
sum
--
for
their
work
this
year
.
Jason
Patlis
Senior
Legal
Advisor
CRMP
Jakarta
Office
Ratu
Plaza
Building
18th
Floor
Jl
.
Jenderal
Sudirman
9
Jakarta
Selatan
10270
Tel
:
62
-
21
-
7209596
Fax
:
62
-
21
-
7207844
E
-
mail
:
jktrmp2
@
pesisir
.
or
.
id
or
jasonpatlis
@
pesisir
.
or
.
id
Or
Noni
Tangkilisan
Governance
Specialist
CRMP
II
North
Sulawesi
Bridge
Center
1st
Floor
1
Jl
.
Stadion
Klabat
Selatan
,
Manado
,
North
Sulawesi
95116
Tel
:
62
-
431
-
825345
,
825678
,
Fax
.
62
-
431
-
825345
E
-
mail
:
mdocrmp2
@
pesisir
.
or
.
id
Top
Story
No
.
3
:
ICM
Training
for
Fishermen
and
Fish
-
Farmer
Groups
in
Penajam
Paser
Utara
,
East
Kalimantan
The
Balikpapan
Bay
Management
Board
(
BBMB
)
and
YSTB
(
Save
the
Balikpapan
Bay
Foundation
)
conducted
2
day
workshop
on
Integrated
Coastal
Management
(
ICM
)
training
for
fishermen
and
fish
/
shrimp
farmer
groups
in
Penajam
Paser
Utara
Regency
(
PPU
)
.
The
training
was
undertaken
on
February
9
-
10
,
2004
at
Penajam
Village
.
This
training
was
a
part
of
BBMB
’
s
implementation
of
community
capacity
development
programs
that
are
financially
supported
by
PPU
’
s
Regency
budget
allocation
.
The
BBMB
was
created
as
a
result
of
the
CRMP
II
facilitated
inter
-
jurisdictional
,
watershed
-
based
Balikpapan
Bay
Strategic
Management
Plan
that
included
three
Regencies
,
the
City
of
Balikpapan
and
the
Province
of
East
Kalimantan
.
The
BBMB
functions
as
the
coordination
body
for
all
stakeholders
in
the
Balikpapan
Bay
area
and
facilitates
realization
of
the
mandates
of
the
Balikpapan
Bay
Strategic
Management
Plan
(
BBMP
)
.
Now
,
CRMP
II
or
‘
Mitra
Pesisir
’
as
it
is
known
in
Indonesia
,
continues
support
to
BBMP
in
its
daily
operation
through
technical
advice
and
cooperative
implementation
of
locally
funded
and
project
funded
activities
.
The
formation
of
the
YSTB
was
also
facilitated
by
CRMP
meet
the
needs
of
local
stakeholders
in
addressing
coastal
community
needs
in
Balikpapan
Bay
and
across
the
province
of
East
Kalimantan
.
With
grant
support
from
BP
,
and
technical
and
organizational
support
from
the
Coastal
Resources
Center
at
the
University
of
Rhode
Island
,
the
YSTB
has
developed
considerable
capacity
to
lead
and
work
with
organizations
in
the
province
.
Particularly
strong
relationships
have
developed
through
cooperation
with
Siku
,
Aman
,
YBML
and
Lingkup
Sepaham
.
At
the
most
recent
workshop
,
there
were
24
participants
from
several
villages
in
the
Balikpapan
Bay
watershed
including
Pantai
Lango
,
Jenebora
,
Gersik
,
Kayu
Api
,
Nenang
,
Gunung
Seteleng
and
Penajam
.
There
were
also
participants
from
villages
outside
Balikpapan
Bay
area
such
as
Babulu
Laut
village
,
and
Api
-
api
and
Sesulu
village
from
Waru
Regency
.
The
object
of
the
training
was
to
increase
the
understanding
and
capacity
of
fishermen
and
fish
/
shrimp
farmer
group
community
in
specific
areas
of
productive
and
environmentally
friendly
approaches
to
production
.
The
Regent
of
Penajam
Paser
Utara
,
who
was
represented
by
his
1st
assistant
,
Drs
.
Suharijono
M
.
Si
,
said
in
his
opening
speech
that
every
effort
to
increase
the
welfare
of
local
communities
should
be
taken
through
the
implementation
of
sustainable
natural
environment
management
.
He
expected
that
the
training
will
lead
the
community
increasing
their
concern
on
all
aspects
of
environment
,
socio
-
economy
and
legal
issues
related
to
the
training
,
especially
in
development
decisions
regarding
marine
and
coastal
resources
utilization
.
Speakers
in
the
training
came
from
CRMP
II
(
Mitra
Pesisir
)
,
IHSA
(
Institute
for
Natural
Resources
Law
)
,
Pesut
Foundation
,
YSTB
and
the
Marine
Affairs
and
Fisheries
Office
of
PPU
.
The
presentations
covered
the
main
topics
of
integrated
coastal
management
concepts
,
participatory
coastal
resources
mapping
,
protected
area
management
,
fisheries
management
,
community
rights
in
natural
resources
management
and
collective
agreement
development
processes
.
Participants
also
learned
about
how
to
develop
follow
-
on
programs
after
the
training
to
directly
implement
ideas
and
concepts
discussed
at
the
training
.
They
expressed
their
enthusiasm
on
all
topics
and
actively
involved
in
the
discussions
.
Both
CRMP
II
and
YSTB
will
work
with
the
BBMB
to
follow
up
with
participants
to
ensure
continued
support
for
implementation
by
local
residents
.
The
training
culminated
with
the
development
of
joint
action
plans
between
BBMB
and
local
residents
/
participants
including
:
Establishment
of
fishermen
or
fish
-
farmer
group
in
their
own
village
/
area
Delivery
of
knowledge
obtained
from
the
training
to
villagers
Development
of
a
joint
agreement
concept
among
fishermen
to
protect
mangrove
forest
and
to
stop
using
destructive
fishing
gears
Planning
to
build
special
sites
for
fish
drying
processes
to
improve
economic
return
on
these
activities
.
Besides
the
communities
’
effort
,
support
from
local
government
was
also
identified
as
an
important
factor
to
achieving
success
of
the
planned
efforts
.
The
local
government
can
help
the
community
in
several
ways
such
as
:
a
)
assistance
from
field
extension
officers
(
PPL
)
on
fish
/
shrimp
pond
management
;
b
)
support
for
building
wave
breakers
(
APO
)
at
beach
abrasion
area
;
c
)
assisting
with
conflict
resolution
,
such
as
conflicts
over
using
trawls
;
and
d
)
developing
fishermen
and
fish
-
farmer
groups
to
rehabilitate
and
protect
mangroves
and
increase
economic
growth
among
community
.
For
further
information
,
please
contact
:
Achmad
Setiadi
YSTB
Jl
.
R
.
E
.
Martadinata
No
.
2
RT
26
Mekar
Sari
Balikpapan
,
Kalimantan
Timur
Tel
/
Fax
:
0542
-
422144
Email
:
achmadsetiadi
@
yahoo
.
com
Or
Niel
Makinudin
CRMP
II
-
Mitra
Pesisir
Kalimantan
Timur
Jl
.
R
.
E
.
Martadinata
No
.
5
RT
26
Mekar
Sari
,
Balikpapan
,
Kalimantan
Timur
Tel
:
0542
-
738556
,
Fax
:
0542
-
731858
Email
:
tanyut
@
telkom
.
net
dan
pesisir
@
indosat
.
net
.
id
Top
Story
No
.
4
:
NRM
III
Monthly
Report
for
January
2004
Indonesia
Natural
Resources
Management
Program
III
Overview
The
Natural
Resources
Management
(
NRM
)
III
Project
was
created
by
USAID
to
work
with
the
GOI
,
private
sector
,
NGOs
,
community
groups
,
and
other
stakeholders
to
strengthen
decentralized
natural
resource
management
through
three
inter
-
related
project
objectives
.
These
objectives
are
:
(
1
)
clarifying
the
roles
and
responsibilities
of
stakeholders
involved
with
natural
resources
management
by
making
local
planning
processes
that
impact
on
natural
resources
more
transparent
,
accountable
,
inclusive
,
and
empirically
based
;
(
2
)
creating
broad
-
based
and
articulate
constituencies
for
sustainable
natural
resources
management
that
lead
to
wide
spread
replication
of
good
NRM
models
and
practices
;
and
(
3
)
improving
livelihoods
of
natural
resource
stakeholders
through
appropriate
technology
and
sustainable
market
-
oriented
activities
.
The
NRM
III
Project
period
of
performance
is
November
1
,
2002
to
October
31
,
2004
.
During
earlier
NRM
Projects
,
USAID
focused
its
efforts
on
clarifying
stakeholder
roles
,
creating
local
constituencies
,
and
promoting
transparent
planning
processes
.
A
number
of
significant
advances
were
made
in
innovative
and
multi
-
stakeholder
approaches
.
Under
NRM
III
,
USAID
is
emphasizing
replication
of
good
integrated
models
,
expanding
partnerships
forged
with
local
communities
and
governments
,
and
promoting
regional
level
policy
dialogues
.
In
earlier
phases
and
in
the
past
year
,
NRM
III
has
developed
and
implemented
several
well
-
regarded
capacity
building
programs
,
developed
networks
of
regional
partners
,
and
established
collaborative
implementation
activities
with
local
government
partners
.
NRM
III
has
been
very
actively
engaged
in
decentralized
sustainable
forest
and
NR
management
by
supporting
field
-
based
planning
and
management
initiatives
and
then
linking
them
to
policy
reforms
at
the
national
level
.
NRM
III
has
continued
to
build
and
strengthen
local
,
multi
-
stakeholder
NR
management
institutions
and
has
launched
innovative
efforts
in
public
outreach
,
environmental
education
,
decentralized
participatory
NR
planning
,
and
livelihoods
enhancement
.
During
this
final
year
of
implementation
,
NRM
III
will
provide
technical
assistance
,
training
,
and
facilitation
support
with
an
emphasis
on
completion
of
major
activities
,
leveraging
outside
support
for
key
initiatives
,
and
documentation
of
results
and
lessons
learned
.
In
the
first
year
,
NRM
III
targeted
sites
where
decentralization
models
could
be
replicated
and
where
livelihoods
activities
could
be
implemented
through
existing
partners
.
In
the
coming
year
,
NRM
III
will
build
on
successful
approaches
and
increase
the
emphasis
on
documentation
and
measurement
of
impacts
in
the
field
.
In
the
first
year
,
NRM
III
also
helped
to
solidify
the
technical
and
legal
framework
for
several
important
local
NRM
management
institutions
,
including
in
Bunaken
,
Sungai
Wain
,
Tondano
,
Bontang
,
Gunung
Meja
and
Jayapura
,
and
new
institutions
to
manage
the
Lestari
-
Alamku
-
Ulin
multi
-
media
campaigns
.
In
this
second
year
,
NRM
III
will
assist
these
local
institutions
to
seek
alternative
funding
support
and
gain
independence
.
This
monthly
report
follows
the
framework
of
the
second
year
workplan
,
a
supplement
that
refines
and
adjusts
activities
under
the
first
workplan
(
December
2002
)
,
which
covered
the
full
two
-
year
implementation
period
.
The
monthly
report
begins
with
a
summary
of
key
actions
and
then
provides
more
detail
about
all
activities
in
all
regions
and
program
areas
.
I
.
East
Kalimantan
Decentralized
Forestry
Management
Replication
.
PSDA
WG
of
Bontang
conducted
a
field
trip
to
Balikpapan
and
UP
-
HLSW
to
review
the
process
of
creating
the
strategic
management
plan
for
the
Bay
and
for
Sungai
Wain
Forest
.
Balikpapan
Watershed
Management
.
The
team
developing
the
Mayoral
regulation
on
management
of
Sungai
Wain
Forest
conducted
a
study
visit
to
Kulonprogro
,
Sleman
,
Yogyakarta
and
Cibodas
,
West
Java
to
review
similar
local
initiatives
.
Agroforestry
and
Livelihoods
.
District
Government
,
Forestry
Working
Group
and
IFAD
met
to
consider
the
follow
up
plan
for
continuing
livelihoods
improvement
activities
in
2004
,
in
cooperation
with
multiple
stakeholders
in
West
Kutai
.
Outreach
&
Education
.
To
increase
the
quality
of
environmental
reporting
,
NRM
and
Greencom
collaborated
in
a
training
program
for
NGOs
on
writing
environmental
feature
stories
.
II
.
North
Sulawesi
Bunaken
National
Park
:
Zonation
Revision
.
Four
of
the
remaining
six
villages
in
the
southern
section
of
the
park
sign
off
on
newly
revised
zonation
plans
.
Bunaken
NP
:
DPTNB
.
The
DPTNB
completed
a
3
month
recruitment
process
with
the
selection
of
Reinhart
Paat
as
its
new
Executive
Director
.
Bunaken
NP
:
Community
Development
.
Four
years
’
of
anticipation
culminated
in
the
completion
of
the
Bunaken
village
community
landing
dock
.
Livelihood
Development
in
Likupang
and
Bunaken
NP
.
A
comprehensive
packet
of
outreach
materials
on
coconut
charcoal
and
cookstove
production
,
including
a
poster
,
calendar
,
tshirt
,
VCD
and
guidebook
,
was
distributed
throughout
coastal
villages
in
North
Sulawesi
.
Environmental
Health
Partnership
Program
.
The
Community
Radio
program
“
Suara
Wanuata
”
was
launched
in
January
.
Outreach
&
Education
.
Lestari
3M
focused
on
the
role
of
traditional
knowledge
in
NRM
;
the
FMPTNB
Bulletin
and
Village
Information
Billboards
published
its
third
edition
on
coral
reefs
and
their
benefits
to
local
villagers
.
Sustainable
Tourism
Initiative
.
The
North
Sulawesi
marine
tourism
carrying
capacity
final
report
was
completed
and
is
now
being
printed
for
distribution
.
Tondano
Watershed
Participatory
WSM
.
Farmer
Field
Schools
in
Integrated
Pest
Management
began
in
Tondano
WS
.
III
.
Papua
Cycloops
Participatory
Management
.
Provincial
legislature
approved
budget
assistance
for
collaborative
management
activities
of
Cyclops
Working
Group
.
Media
Outreach
.
ALAMKU
18th
edition
focused
on
Lorentz
National
Park
and
its
status
as
a
world
-
class
conservation
area
.
IV
.
National
National
Policy
&
Capacity
Strengthening
.
Contributed
to
multi
-
stakeholder
effort
to
develop
a
program
of
discussions
of
natural
resource
issues
with
Political
Party
representatives
.
The
first
of
these
with
4
parties
will
be
held
in
February
,
in
Bogor
.
Social
Forestry
(
SF
)
Working
Team
Support
.
Participated
in
field
visit
to
3
sites
in
NTB
to
improve
understanding
of
Social
Forestry
practices
,
build
commitment
between
stakeholders
&
dissemination
of
base
practices
&
policy
.
National
Forestry
Program
Linkages
.
NRM
supported
the
outlining
and
drafting
of
an
NFP
policy
,
prepared
under
the
auspices
of
the
Ministry
of
Forestry
.
This
paper
attempts
to
stimulate
progress
from
the
NFP
working
group
.
Mining
in
Protection
Forest
Working
Group
.
Collaboration
with
Min
.
Forestry
and
DOI
-
OSM
on
design
and
development
of
a
training
program
aimed
at
providing
a
working
knowledge
of
mining
issues
to
improve
technical
aspects
of
regulating
mining
in
the
forest
estate
.
Strengthening
Protected
Areas
Co
-
Management
.
Participated
in
Indonesia
Biodiversity
Strategic
Action
Plan
presentation
workshop
,
providing
inputs
on
collaborative
management
of
protected
areas
.
Marine
Protected
Areas
.
Facilitated
TNC
presentation
on
their
MPA
training
center
activities
and
MPA
capacity
building
in
Bali
and
Komodo
.
Agroforestry
&
Livelihoods
.
Implementation
of
Farmer
Field
School
activities
in
the
Tondano
Watershed
,
focusing
on
increasing
yields
while
reducing
pesticides
and
fertilizers
,
thus
contributing
to
water
supply
,
in
collaboration
with
FIELD
.
To
obtain
complete
version
of
the
report
in
Word
Format
,
please
write
to
:
isti2000
@
nrm
.
or
.
id
Submitted
by
:
Timothy
H
.
Brown
Chief
of
Party
NRM
III
Jakarta
brownth
@
nrm
.
or
.
id
Top
Story
No
.
5
:
Notification
on
Status
of
the
Lembaga
Ekolabel
Indonesia
Dear
Colleagues
,
We
would
like
to
inform
you
that
on
March
2nd
,
2004
,
LEI
’
s
Board
of
Directors
has
met
and
come
to
these
following
decisions
:
1
.
To
accept
the
resignation
of
Dr
.
Dradjad
H
.
Wibowo
from
his
office
as
LEI
’
s
Executive
Director
,
due
to
his
candidature
of
a
political
party
to
be
a
member
of
the
Indonesian
Congress
in
the
coming
general
election
.
2
.
The
Board
has
appointed
Mr
.
Alan
Purbawiyatna
,
Mr
.
Dwi
Rahmad
Muhtaman
and
Mr
.
Aditya
Bayunanda
as
caretaker
of
LEI
’
s
Executive
Body
.
3
.
LEI
will
continue
to
take
the
necessary
steps
to
pursue
its
goal
to
become
a
Constituent
Based
Organization
(
CBO
)
.
In
this
opportunity
,
all
members
of
the
Indonesian
Ecolabelling
Institute
would
like
to
express
its
gratitude
to
Dr
.
Dradjad
H
.
Wibowo
for
his
contribution
to
LEI
and
certification
in
Indonesia
.
We
hope
all
the
best
and
good
fortune
to
him
.
Sincerely
yours
,
Djamaludin
Suryohadikusumo
Ismid
Hadad
Chairman
Secretary
Board
of
Directors
Board
of
Directors
The
Indonesian
Ecolabelling
The
Indonesian
Ecolabelling
Institute
Institute
LEMBAGA
EKOLABEL
INDONESIA
(
The
Indonesian
Ecolabelling
Institute
)
Jalan
Taman
Malabar
No
.
18
,
Bogor
16151
.
Tel
:
(
62
-
251
)
340
-
744
,
340
-
745
,
340
-
759
Fax
:
(
62
-
251
)
321
-
739
lei
@
indo
.
net
.
id
http
:
//
www
.
lei
.
or
.
id
Top
Story
No
.
6
:
NEW
:
MLA
Website
Dear
all
,
Working
with
a
range
of
partners
,
the
'
Biodiversity
team
'
of
CIFOR
'
s
Environmental
Services
program
has
developed
methods
for
assessing
'
what
really
matters
'
to
communities
living
in
tropical
forest
landscapes
.
Known
as
'
MLA
'
(
Multidisciplinary
Landscape
Assessment
)
,
this
approach
enhances
the
understanding
between
development
practitioners
,
policy
makers
and
forest
communities
.
The
intended
result
is
more
informed
decisions
on
policy
,
land
use
,
and
payments
for
biodiversity
services
,
that
will
improve
forest
conservation
,
protect
the
needs
of
local
people
and
advance
the
wiser
management
of
tropical
forests
.
The
team
worked
most
closely
with
seven
communities
in
Malinau
district
,
East
Kalimantan
,
but
a
similar
approach
has
also
been
applied
in
Bolivia
,
Mozambique
and
Cameroon
.
You
can
now
find
concise
information
about
this
exciting
work
on
our
new
website
http
:
//
www
.
cifor
.
cgiar
.
org
/
mla
.
The
website
describes
the
philosophy
of
the
approach
,
presents
the
methods
and
results
and
allows
for
downloading
databases
as
well
as
publications
.
A
grant
from
The
World
Bank
supported
the
development
of
the
website
,
to
improve
accessibility
to
the
databases
Top
Story
No
.
7
:
Mega
Calls
for
Cooperation
in
Combating
Illegal
Logging
Source
:
The
Jakarta
Post
,
March
15
,
2004
Jakarta
President
Megawati
Soekarnoputri
has
said
that
eradicating
rampant
illegal
logging
simply
requires
the
strong
will
of
law
enforcers
and
other
related
state
officials
.
"
If
state
apparatus
are
willing
to
work
together
to
combat
illegal
logging
,
the
crime
will
actually
be
easier
to
cope
with
.
Unfortunately
they
'
re
easily
lured
by
money
,
"
Megawati
said
on
Saturday
upon
her
inauguration
of
the
Indragiri
bridge
in
Tembilahan
,
Riau
.
Reiterating
the
government
'
s
consistency
in
the
drive
,
Megawati
said
illegal
logging
should
be
easily
detectable
as
logs
were
physically
larger
than
human
beings
.
However
,
she
added
,
illegal
loggers
often
colluded
with
high
ranking
officials
who
would
enable
the
criminals
to
escape
.
"
I
know
exactly
the
smuggling
line
of
command
,
"
she
affirmed
,
adding
that
the
illegal
loggers
had
access
to
the
central
government
.
Megawati
said
that
she
could
not
imagine
the
consequences
of
the
arrests
of
all
parties
related
to
illegal
logging
,
including
collusive
law
enforcers
.
"
I
don
'
t
know
if
the
officials
'
replacements
would
have
strong
commitment
or
the
mentality
to
shun
bribes
,
"
she
was
quoted
by
Antara
as
saying
.
A
government
regulation
in
lieu
of
law
(
perpu
)
is
to
be
issued
to
deal
with
illegal
logging
as
an
emergency
measure
to
stop
the
rapid
destruction
of
the
nation
'
s
forests
.
According
to
Minister
of
Forestry
Mohamad
Prakosa
,
the
regulation
would
be
a
special
law
on
illegal
logging
outside
of
the
existing
criminal
law
.
A
government
report
estimates
that
illegal
logging
has
left
43
million
hectares
of
land
in
a
critical
condition
,
in
addition
to
US
$
3
.
5
billion
in
losses
every
year
.
Megawati
'
s
show
of
concern
about
the
problem
seems
somewhat
contradictory
to
her
governmental
policy
on
forest
conservation
,
with
the
issuance
of
a
law
that
allows
13
mining
firms
to
resume
operations
in
protected
forests
.
Greenomic
,
a
non
-
governmental
organization
,
was
the
latest
group
to
criticize
the
regulation
.
"
Megawati
'
s
(
provision
of
)
licenses
to
the
mining
firms
is
counterproductive
and
could
set
a
bad
precedent
for
forest
management
,
"
Greenomic
'
s
executive
director
Elfian
Effendy
said
in
a
statement
.
He
regretted
the
President
'
s
decision
to
let
the
mining
firms
operate
despite
objection
from
the
forestry
ministry
.
Without
mentioning
any
names
or
parties
,
Elfian
suspected
that
Megawati
had
been
under
huge
pressure
to
issue
the
regulation
for
economic
interests
.
"
Without
providing
licenses
for
the
firms
,
Megawati
'
s
administration
can
still
earn
income
outside
the
forest
,
if
it
is
creative
and
innovative
,
"
Elfian
claimed
.
During
her
trip
to
Riau
,
the
President
was
accompanied
by
Minister
of
Settlement
and
Regional
Infrastructure
Soenarno
.
Megawati
also
urged
the
Riau
government
to
immediately
provide
names
for
several
unidentified
islands
surrounding
the
province
to
help
security
officers
deal
with
illegal
logging
.
"
It
will
be
easier
for
the
officers
to
head
for
the
island
where
smuggling
occurs
if
it
already
has
a
name
.
It
'
s
still
difficult
for
law
enforcers
to
locate
unnamed
islands
,
"
she
said
.
The
Indragiri
bridge
is
expected
to
ease
the
burden
on
transportation
routes
in
the
city
.
Its
construction
took
around
four
years
and
cost
over
Rp
92
billion
(
US
$
10
.
82
million
)
.
The
bridge
is
the
longest
in
Riau
at
710
meters
long
and
seven
meters
wide
.
Previously
,
local
people
relied
heavily
on
boats
to
cross
Indragiri
river
.
[
Courtesy
of
the
Indonesian
Nature
Conservation
List
]
Top
Story
No
.
8
:
Kadin
Proposes
Environmental
Tax
Incentives
Source
:
The
Jakarta
Post
,
March
15
,
2004
By
Urip
Hudiono
Jakarta
The
government
should
provide
tax
incentives
to
encourage
companies
to
adopt
environmentally
friendly
businesses
,
the
Indonesian
Chamber
of
Commerce
and
Industry
(
Kadin
)
said
.
Kadin
said
such
a
scheme
would
be
more
effective
than
just
imposing
restrictive
regulations
and
penalizing
errant
companies
.
"
Tax
incentives
,
along
with
other
incentives
such
as
extra
duty
and
credit
facilities
,
would
be
more
compelling
reasons
for
businesses
to
adopt
a
green
approach
"
the
head
of
Kadin
'
s
commission
for
environmental
conservation
,
Ilhamy
Elias
,
said
.
Speaking
at
a
meeting
between
the
chamber
'
s
new
board
members
and
officials
of
the
Office
of
the
State
Minister
for
the
Environment
last
week
,
Ilhamy
said
Kadin
proposed
companies
proven
to
be
an
environmentally
friendly
operators
be
given
tax
cuts
of
up
to
2
.
5
percent
.
Such
a
scheme
was
already
in
effect
in
Australia
,
he
said
.
However
,
if
a
company
was
found
neglectful
in
its
responsibility
towards
society
and
the
environment
,
the
government
could
then
impose
an
additional
tax
of
5
percent
on
its
revenue
.
Regarding
Kadin
'
s
"
carrot
and
stick
"
tax
scheme
proposal
,
State
Minister
for
the
Environment
Nabiel
Makarim
welcomed
the
idea
,
although
he
said
its
implementation
would
need
to
be
coordinated
with
other
related
ministries
and
regional
administrations
.
"
Besides
coordination
,
there
is
also
the
matter
of
supervision
--
on
how
to
ensure
the
scheme
will
be
properly
and
consistently
carried
out
,
"
he
said
.
Separately
,
the
head
of
tax
planning
at
the
Ministry
of
Finance
'
s
Directorate
General
of
Taxation
,
Wahyu
K
.
Tumakaka
,
said
the
main
problem
of
the
proposed
scheme
would
be
determining
which
companies
were
environmentally
friendly
,
and
which
were
not
.
"
My
office
has
no
such
data
yet
,
"
he
said
,
adding
that
the
scheme
could
therefore
not
be
included
in
the
newest
taxation
bylaw
proposed
by
the
government
to
the
House
of
Representatives
,
but
could
perhaps
be
in
the
future
.
The
office
of
the
State
Minister
for
the
Environment
has
since
1995
been
collecting
such
data
through
a
program
in
which
companies
are
annually
rated
as
"
black
"
,
"
red
"
,
"
blue
"
,
"
green
"
or
"
gold
"
,
according
to
the
quality
of
their
environmental
management
system
.
The
national
executive
director
of
the
Indonesian
Environmental
Forum
(
WALHI
)
,
Longgena
Ginting
,
criticized
the
proposed
scheme
,
saying
it
would
give
corporations
tax
breaks
,
but
would
not
have
enough
powers
to
stop
the
bad
polluters
.
"
Even
with
the
existing
regulations
meant
to
protect
the
environment
,
only
a
handful
of
companies
have
complied
with
them
,
"
he
told
The
Jakarta
Post
.
"
And
even
without
such
regulations
or
incentives
,
corporations
should
already
know
being
socially
and
environmentally
responsible
is
for
their
businesses
'
own
good
,
"
he
said
.
Along
with
proposing
a
corporate
environmental
tax
scheme
,
Kadin
has
recently
suggested
the
government
cut
taxes
on
mining
companies
to
a
maximum
of
28
percent
,
to
attract
more
investment
and
increase
Indonesia
'
s
competitiveness
in
the
sector
.
In
response
,
Tumakaka
said
tax
incentives
were
not
the
main
driving
force
for
corporations
to
invest
or
do
business
in
a
country
.
Adequate
infrastructure
--
such
as
the
availability
of
highways
and
electricity
--
was
more
important
,
he
said
.
[
Courtesy
of
the
Indonesian
Nature
Conservation
List
]
Top
Story
No
.
9
:
Ending
the
Mining
Imbroglio
Source
:
The
Jakarta
Post
,
March
16
,
2004
President
Megawati
Soekarnoputri
signed
last
week
a
regulation
in
lieu
of
law
that
amended
Law
No
.
41
/
1999
on
forestry
,
thereby
allowing
companies
,
mostly
foreign
investors
that
had
obtained
their
mining
contracts
before
1999
,
to
engage
in
open
-
pit
mining
in
protected
forests
.
The
amendment
simply
boiled
down
to
the
insertion
of
transitional
clauses
to
Law
No
.
41
/
1999
that
stipulate
that
companies
that
obtained
their
mining
contracts
before
1999
will
be
allowed
to
continue
open
-
pit
mining
in
protected
forests
until
the
end
of
their
concessions
.
The
amendment
simply
corrected
a
mistake
the
government
and
the
House
of
Representatives
made
in
the
enactment
of
the
law
.
The
transitional
clauses
should
have
been
stipulated
in
Law
No
.
41
because
the
law
introduced
completely
new
policies
.
Transitional
clauses
are
normal
provision
in
laws
that
introduce
new
rules
or
policies
and
declared
null
and
void
what
had
previously
been
legally
allowed
.
Law
No
.
41
only
stipulates
that
open
-
pit
mining
is
prohibited
in
areas
designated
as
protected
forests
,
national
parks
and
conservation
areas
,
but
does
not
mention
the
legal
status
of
150
mining
contracts
the
government
had
awarded
before
1999
for
open
-
pit
mining
in
protected
forests
.
The
law
obviously
caused
a
great
deal
of
controversy
and
legal
uncertainty
because
the
ministry
of
forestry
insisted
on
enforcing
the
law
,
even
though
many
of
the
150
mining
contractors
had
invested
hundreds
of
millions
in
their
concessions
and
unilaterally
annulling
their
contracts
would
plunge
the
government
into
expensive
lawsuits
that
would
put
the
government
at
risk
of
having
to
pay
billions
of
dollars
in
damages
.
Unilaterally
revoking
the
concessions
also
would
cause
legal
uncertainty
in
the
mining
industry
.
The
government
has
a
valid
point
in
its
argument
that
the
sanctity
of
a
contract
should
be
honored
,
otherwise
our
economy
would
be
in
total
chaos
and
the
country
,
which
is
so
desperate
for
new
investment
,
would
become
a
pariah
among
investors
.
And
mining
is
one
of
the
most
promising
resource
-
based
businesses
in
the
country
,
especially
in
the
less
developed
eastern
region
,
and
has
multiple
benefits
for
the
whole
economy
and
consequently
the
people
.
Moreover
,
mining
companies
are
usually
more
careful
about
their
management
of
the
forest
and
the
environment
because
of
the
long
-
term
nature
of
their
investment
and
operations
.
In
fact
,
it
is
illegal
miners
and
illegal
loggers
that
have
always
been
the
biggest
threats
to
our
forest
resources
.
However
,
allowing
all
the
mining
concessionaires
to
continue
their
open
-
pit
operations
would
cause
devastating
damages
to
Indonesia
'
s
forests
and
biodiversity
.
The
regulation
in
lieu
of
law
that
was
issued
after
the
Cabinet
session
last
Thursday
seemed
to
be
a
compromise
solution
to
the
dilemma
without
exposing
our
protected
forests
to
too
big
a
risk
of
severe
damages
.
That
is
because
the
regulation
is
not
simply
a
blank
check
for
foreign
investors
to
go
on
a
rampage
in
the
country
'
s
protected
forests
.
First
of
all
,
only
13
out
of
the
150
mining
contracts
affected
by
Law
No
.
41
/
1999
will
be
allowed
to
resume
open
-
pit
mining
.
These
companies
were
selected
by
a
special
team
from
the
government
and
the
House
on
the
basis
of
tough
criteria
.
Foremost
among
the
conditions
was
that
the
companies
had
found
commercial
volumes
of
mineral
deposits
and
had
invested
a
great
deal
of
money
in
their
concessions
,
and
that
their
mining
ventures
would
contribute
greatly
to
the
national
economy
.
Nevertheless
,
it
goes
without
saying
that
the
13
mining
companies
should
be
subject
to
stringent
supervision
.
Their
mining
operations
should
be
based
on
annual
extraction
plans
that
have
been
approved
jointly
by
the
ministries
of
mines
and
forestry
to
ensure
they
fully
implement
good
environmental
management
in
their
concession
areas
.
In
this
context
we
are
also
encouraged
to
learn
that
the
government
is
about
to
issue
another
regulation
in
lieu
of
law
that
will
introduce
stronger
measures
to
fight
illegal
logging
.
The
international
community
,
we
believe
,
will
support
the
government
'
s
decision
to
annul
the
other
137
mining
contracts
because
the
global
community
,
after
all
,
also
benefits
from
the
biodiversity
and
climate
-
regulating
role
of
our
tropical
forests
.
[
Courtesy
of
the
Indonesian
Nature
Conservation
List
]
Top
Story
No
.
10
:
Community
Forestry
:
Principles
and
Practices
Today
Why
This
Course
?
Over
the
last
two
decades
,
the
interdependent
linkages
between
forest
resource
management
policy
and
the
livelihoods
of
rural
people
who
depend
on
forest
resources
have
been
widely
recognized
.
Experience
gained
during
this
period
has
shown
that
effective
forest
management
strategies
can
and
do
involve
local
communities
at
all
levels
of
the
decision
-
making
process
.
Today
,
community
forestry
has
become
a
mainstream
component
of
many
national
forestry
programs
.
However
,
several
countries
that
have
introduced
community
forestry
concepts
are
still
struggling
with
the
complex
challenges
of
adapting
their
forestry
programs
to
be
more
responsive
and
relevant
to
the
needs
and
interests
of
communities
.
To
address
common
issues
faced
at
this
stage
of
development
,
RECOFT
has
design
an
intensive
20
-
day
introductory
course
to
enable
participants
identify
and
analyze
key
community
forestry
concepts
,
strategies
and
principles
,
.
Sharing
of
experience
among
the
diverse
group
of
participants
will
broaden
personal
perspectives
on
community
-
based
forest
management
.
In
addition
,
a
5
-
day
field
trip
will
enhance
the
understanding
of
the
relationship
between
people
and
forest
,
and
increase
exposure
to
real
-
life
implementation
issues
on
the
ground
.
Through
this
course
,
participants
will
gain
confidence
and
skills
needed
to
support
local
institutions
in
devolving
forest
management
in
their
home
country
effectively
.
How
will
you
learn
?
Experiential
learning
approaches
create
a
highly
interactive
environment
among
participants
.
Knowledge
sharing
and
wrap
-
up
sessions
increase
participants
’
understanding
of
the
linkages
of
all
issues
and
topics
Field
trips
focus
on
special
topics
and
practical
field
exercises
and
are
complemented
by
case
studies
from
the
region
.
Lectures
from
professionals
involved
in
community
forestry
programs
impart
state
of
the
art
knowledge
.
Opportunities
to
pursue
topics
of
special
interest
and
relevance
to
participants
’
own
work
add
value
to
the
lessons
learnt
.
What
else
do
you
need
to
know
?
This
course
is
appropriate
for
middle
management
personnel
involved
in
forestry
,
agriculture
,
social
sciences
and
related
fields
,
non
-
government
staff
,
academics
and
others
who
are
currently
,
or
will
be
,
involved
in
community
forestry
programs
.
Women
are
strongly
encouraged
to
apply
.
Proficiency
in
English
is
essential
The
one
-
month
non
-
immigrant
visa
to
enter
Thailand
must
be
obtained
from
the
Thai
Embassy
or
Consulate
by
candidates
themselves
in
their
home
(
or
nearest
)
country
.
When
?
7
-
25
June
2004
The
deadline
for
application
is
20
April
2004
.
Where
?
RECOFTC
,
Bangkok
Thailand
.
Cost
The
course
fee
of
US
$
2
,
950
covers
course
materials
,
accommodation
,
health
insurance
,
meals
during
field
trips
and
other
essential
items
.
Daily
allowance
,
costs
of
visas
and
transportation
to
and
from
RECOFTC
are
not
included
.
For
more
information
please
contact
:
Regional
Community
Forestry
Training
Center
for
Asia
and
the
Pacific
(
RECOFTC
)
Kasetsart
University
,
P
.
O
.
Box
1111
Bangkok
10903
,
Thailand
Tel
:
(
66
-
2
)
940
-
5700
Fax
:
(
66
-
2
)
561
-
4880
contact
@
recoftc
.
org
www
.
recoftc
.
org
Top
Story
No
.
11
:
7th
Workshop
on
Gender
Equity
and
Micro
Enterprise
Development
Context
Women
constitute
not
only
half
of
the
world
’
s
population
but
also
sway
the
growth
of
the
remaining
half
.
They
produce
half
of
the
world
’
s
food
supply
and
account
for
60
%
of
the
working
force
but
comprise
only
10
%
of
the
world
’
s
economy
and
surprisingly
own
less
than
1
%
of
the
real
estate
.
They
have
little
access
to
productive
resources
and
negligible
control
over
family
income
.
This
discrimination
is
the
result
of
gender
bias
,
which
forms
an
inherent
part
of
the
global
society
.
The
general
observation
is
that
there
are
fewer
female
entrepreneurs
than
male
entrepreneurs
.
This
reflects
the
trends
also
prevailing
in
other
spheres
of
economic
activities
where
males
greatly
outnumber
females
.
Entrepreneurship
is
a
Herculean
task
,
which
is
fraught
with
struggle
,
entailing
both
risk
and
efforts
.
While
women
have
to
go
through
same
stages
of
setting
up
an
enterprise
as
do
men
,
and
face
similar
challenges
,
irrespective
of
gender
based
social
impediments
like
social
stigma
,
unfavorable
infrastructure
,
support
systems
,
etc
.
which
block
their
entry
and
reduce
their
pace
of
growth
.
Removing
these
impediments
in
the
existing
set
up
of
micro
enterprise
development
has
assumed
a
critical
significance
for
the
economic
development
of
women
.
The
need
today
is
to
help
women
overcome
these
blockades
and
draw
maximum
participation
from
them
to
set
up
micro
enterprises
,
which
will
help
them
,
achieve
self
reliance
and
place
them
at
par
with
their
male
counterparts
.
Objectives
Develop
gender
sensitivity
vis
-
à
-
vis
participation
of
women
in
Micro
Enterprise
Development
.
Examine
the
processes
of
Gender
inequality
and
their
disfunctionality
affecting
the
participation
of
women
in
micro
enterprises
.
Understand
the
processes
of
promoting
MED
through
active
participation
of
women
.
Acquire
skills
of
identification
of
potential
women
entrepreneurs
and
learn
designing
and
conducting
enterprise
development
motivation
training
for
them
.
Be
able
to
explore
various
learning
mechanisms
to
set
up
Micro
-
Enterprises
and
update
the
methods
of
managing
activities
,
develop
tools
and
instruments
for
effective
monitoring
and
evaluation
of
promoted
entrepreneurs
.
Methodology
Experiential
learning
design
will
be
the
core
methodology
.
Interactive
sessions
,
case
studies
,
special
group
design
syndication
and
other
simulation
sessions
will
be
held
.
The
training
program
will
be
participatory
in
nature
wherein
the
trainers
would
be
translating
ideas
into
design
and
formulation
of
strategies
with
the
appropriate
facilitation
provided
by
the
resource
persons
.
Field
study
would
provide
an
insight
into
real
life
situations
.
Very
rigorous
training
hours
may
demand
informal
learning
groups
even
after
set
class
hour
sessions
to
acquire
needed
competency
.
Contents
Need
and
scope
of
Micro
Enterprise
Development
for
women
,
its
role
in
sustainable
development
.
Gender
Equity
and
Micro
Enterprise
Development
-
contexts
and
challenges
.
Planning
process
for
effective
participation
of
Women
in
Micro
Enterprise
Development
-
identification
and
formulation
.
Designing
Training
Strategy
for
people
to
work
on
Micro
Enterprise
Development
-
dynamics
and
trainers
’
skills
.
Appraisal
techniques
in
micro
-
enterprise
projects
for
survival
and
success
.
General
Information
:
Duration
:
7
Days
Date
:
27th
-
2nd
June
2004
Venue
:
Mauritius
Indian
Delegates
Rs
.
32
,
500
per
participant
.
The
fee
to
be
paid
by
Bank
Draft
in
favor
of
“
Aseed
A
/
c
IDMAT
”
payable
at
Delhi
.
International
Delegates
Euro
1250
per
delegate
.
The
fee
to
be
paid
by
Bank
Draft
/
Electronic
transfer
in
favor
of
“
IDMAT
Services
”
payable
at
New
Delhi
.
Discounts
Scheme
for
International
Delegates
only
Group
discount
-
For
a
group
of
4
delegates
15
%
on
total
fee
.
For
Additional
delegate
-
For
every
second
delegate
a
fee
of
Euro
1175
only
.
Early
Birds
-
Enroll
by
1st
May
and
pay
only
Euro
1125
per
delegate
.
Accommodation
on
twin
sharing
basis
The
fee
covers
lodging
-
boarding
(
American
Plan
)
and
supply
of
teaching
materials
.
About
international
institute
of
development
management
technology
(
IDMAT
)
IDMAT
is
an
institution
that
has
evolved
its
own
identity
as
an
international
body
in
the
field
of
development
management
.
IDMAT
,
an
associate
of
ASEED
(
Asian
Society
of
Entrepreneurship
Education
and
Development
)
,
started
its
mission
as
a
capacity
building
division
,
which
has
graduated
and
established
itself
as
a
leading
training
and
consulting
body
.
For
more
information
please
contact
:
IDMAT
Asia
Office
Development
Manager
(
IDMAT
)
ASEED
House
,
C
-
8
/
8007
,
Vasant
Kunj
,
New
Delhi
-
110070
(
India
)
Telefax
:
(
011
)
6130635
,
6130242
,
6896151
training
@
aidmat
.
com
IDMAT
Eastern
Europe
Development
Manager
(
IDMAT
)
Representative
Office
-
Russia
18
/
241
Ulitsa
Orekhovo
Bulvar
Moscow
(
Russia
)
aidmat
@
mail
.
ru
;
info
@
aidmat
.
com
Top
Story
No
.
12
:
IRSA
'
s
6th
National
Conference
The
Indonesian
Regional
Science
Association
(
IRSA
)
is
preparing
its
6th
International
Conference
in
Jogjakarta
,
August
13
-
14
,
2004
,
titled
“
Regional
Development
in
Transition
:
Governance
,
Public
Services
,
and
Eco
-
tourism
”
.
The
conference
is
intended
to
be
a
media
for
scholars
,
practitioners
,
and
policy
-
makers
to
discuss
and
exchange
theoretical
and
empirical
findings
on
the
issue
of
regional
development
and
transition
economy
with
particular
focus
on
the
aspect
of
governance
,
business
climate
,
informal
sectors
,
public
services
,
poverty
,
equity
,
tourism
,
and
the
environment
.
It
is
also
hoped
that
through
this
conference
participants
will
exchange
experiences
and
also
build
strong
networks
for
future
research
,
policy
discussion
,
and
practical
collaboration
.
It
is
expected
that
participants
of
this
conference
will
contribute
to
the
following
regional
perspective
(
but
not
limited
)
topics
on
:
governance
and
business
climate
,
economic
growth
and
development
,
informal
sector
and
employment
,
poverty
and
income
inequality
,
health
and
education
services
,
infrastructure
development
,
financing
aspects
of
regional
development
,
governance
and
institution
,
management
of
water
and
sanitation
,
management
of
natural
resources
,
eco
-
tourism
,
and
regional
and
local
environmental
problem
.
Topics
that
are
not
in
Indonesian
context
are
also
welcomed
so
long
as
its
lessons
learned
are
relevant
.
For
more
information
on
the
conference
,
please
see
:
http
:
//
www
.
cepps
-
irsa2004
.
ugm
.
ac
.
id
/
Deadline
for
abstract
/
paper
submission
:
Abstract
must
be
submitted
before
the
1st
of
June
2004
.
Notification
of
the
abstract
selected
will
be
on
the
1st
of
July
2004
.
Paper
selected
must
be
submitted
(
electronic
files
only
)
to
the
conference
organiser
by
the
15st
of
July
2004
.
Please
submit
your
abstract
via
email
to
the
Secretariat
of
the
6th
IRSA
International
Conference
:
Dr
.
Catur
Sugiyanto
/
M
.
Edhie
Purnawan
Center
for
Economics
and
Public
Policy
Studies
Gadjah
Mada
University
Barek
,
Bulaksumur
,
Jogjakarta
55281
,
Indonesia
Phone
:
+
62
(
274
)
581827
+
62
(
274
)
520328
Fax
:
+
62
(
274
)
581827
E
-
mail
:
ceppsirsa
@
ugm
.
ac
.
id
Requirements
of
the
Abstract
:
The
abstract
should
be
in
English
.
It
should
not
be
more
than
1
page
long
in
an
A4
paper
with
upper
margin
and
lower
margin
no
more
than
1
inch
,
typed
with
1
line
spacing
,
Times
New
Roman
12
.
Please
note
in
your
abstract
the
institution
you
represent
.
Top
Story
No
.
13
:
Gender
and
Forestry
:
Challenges
to
Sustainable
Livelihoods
and
Forestry
Management
The
symposium
will
identify
areas
in
which
women
and
men
have
access
to
forest
resources
in
the
effort
to
improve
livelihoods
of
poor
people
and
sustainable
forestry
management
locally
and
globally
.
The
symposium
focuses
on
such
themes
as
women
and
forestry
,
gender
issues
,
poverty
and
sustainable
development
,
forest
resource
utilization
and
income
generating
activities
for
local
people
,
ideology
,
religion
and
environmental
responsibility
.
The
symposium
is
organized
by
:
Gender
and
Forestry
Research
Group
of
the
International
Union
of
Forest
Research
Organizations
(
IUFRO
)
,
IUFRO
'
s
Special
Programme
for
Developing
Countries
(
IUFRO
-
SPDC
)
,
Center
for
International
Forestry
Research
(
CIFOR
)
,
Indonesia
as
well
as
by
ENVIROCARE
(
Environmental
,
Human
Rights
Care
and
Gender
Organisation
)
,
University
of
Dar
-
es
-
Salaam
,
Sokoine
University
,
Morogoro
,
College
of
African
Wildlife
Management
,
Mweka
;
all
in
Tanzania
,
and
Hedmark
University
College
,
Evenstad
,
Norway
.
Interested
parties
have
still
the
possibility
to
send
abstracts
for
papers
and
posters
of
500
words
(
Deadline
April
15th
)
to
:
Dr
.
Ann
Merete
Furuberg
,
Hedmark
University
College
,
Evenstad
,
2480
Koppang
,
Norway
.
merete
.
furuberg
@
hedmark
-
f
.
kommune
.
no
Tel
:
+
47
90
16
30
92
Fax
:
+
47
62
94
57
53
More
information
on
the
symposium
:
http
:
//
www
.
cifor
.
cgiar
.
org
/
docs
/
_ref
/
events
/
gender_forestry
/
index
.
htm
Top
Story
No
.
14
:
Vacancies
at
Wildlife
Conservation
Society
Applications
are
invited
for
the
positions
of
:
(
1
)
Director
of
the
Asia
Program
;
(
2
)
Assistant
Director
of
the
Asia
Program
,
to
promote
wildlife
conservation
in
Asia
through
overseeing
a
large
number
of
Wildlife
Conservation
Society
(
WCS
)
field
projects
in
20
countries
across
Asia
.
Both
posts
establish
program
priorities
,
develop
strategic
approaches
,
and
coordinate
financial
and
administrative
support
to
the
field
.
They
coordinate
with
the
other
WCS
programs
,
and
with
other
national
and
international
organizations
.
Finally
,
they
promote
wildlife
conservation
in
Asia
among
national
governments
,
international
agencies
,
and
other
non
-
governmental
organizations
;
direct
international
attention
to
important
sites
and
species
for
conservation
;
and
influence
policies
that
promote
conservation
.
Both
posts
are
based
in
New
York
,
and
involve
travel
.
Deadline
for
applications
is
30th
April
2004
.
Applicants
must
have
an
earned
doctorate
or
equivalent
experience
in
a
field
related
to
the
conservation
of
biological
diversity
,
preferably
in
an
Asian
context
,
and
a
minimum
of
5
years
of
management
experience
in
conservation
programs
.
Please
send
c
.
v
.
,
letter
of
interest
summarizing
research
and
conservation
experience
,
and
list
of
references
,
to
:
Dr
Elizabeth
L
.
Bennett
International
Conservation
Wildlife
Conservation
Society
2300
Southern
Boulevard
,
Bronx
,
New
York
10460
,
USA
ebennett
@
wcs
.
org
Top
The
views
expressed
by
the
authors
and
organizations
contributing
to
this
electronic
newsletter
do
not
necessarily
reflect
the
views
of
the
NRM
Program
,
its
partner
organizations
,
USAID
,
or
its
government
of
Indonesia
sponsors
.
The
purpose
of
the
NRM
Headline
News
is
to
provide
a
forum
for
a
wide
diversity
of
opinion
and
information
on
NRM
Program
activities
,
selected
upcoming
events
and
news
.
The
NRM
Program
is
a
collaborative
program
between
the
governments
of
Indonesia
and
the
United
States
of
America
.
The
partners
implementing
the
NRM
Program
include
:
NRM
III
,
Yayasan
KEMALA
,
the
Coastal
Resources
Management
Program
(
CRMP
II
-
Mitra
Pesisir
)
,
Conservation
International
,
The
Nature
Conservancy
and
the
World
Wide
Fund
for
Nature
-
Indonesia
.
NRM
Headline
News
is
a
free
,
weekly
e
-
mail
news
service
in
English
,
covering
the
issues
of
natural
resources
governance
and
policy
in
Indonesia
.
Headline
News
contains
selected
news
items
from
the
Indonesian
press
,
information
about
upcoming
events
and
employment
opportunities
,
and
regular
updates
on
the
activities
of
the
Natural
Resources
Management
(
NRM
)
Program
.
Funding
is
provided
by
the
United
States
Agency
for
International
Development
(
USAID
)
.
T
he
NRM
Headline
News
is
available
in
plain
text
or
HTML
formats
.
Contributions
from
readers
are
always
welcome
.
Please
e
-
mail
us
at
headline
@
nrm
.
or
.
id
Story
No
.
1
:
Kutai
Barat
Produces
a
Portrait
of
a
Forest
Forest
stakeholders
can
use
the
portrait
as
a
basic
information
source
to
design
strategic
plans
for
better
forest
management
and
to
improve
forestry
programs
.....
more
Story
No
.
2
:
Proyek
Pesisir
/
Balikpapan
Holds
Consultation
on
Proposed
Balikpapan
Bay
Management
Plan
Sessions
with
stakeholders
to
ensure
broader
public
participation
and
support
for
the
final
Balikpapan
Bay
Management
Plan
....
.
more
Story
No
.
3
:
Testimony
of
Andrew
S
.
Natsios
,
USAID
Administrator
-
designate
Before
the
Committee
on
Foreign
Relations
,
United
States
Senate
,
April
25
,
2001
.....
more
Story
No
.
4
:
Timber
Consultant
Says
Bad
Guys
Are
Winning
the
War
“
Illegal
loggers
don
’
t
have
workshops
and
they
don
’
t
debate
.
They
just
get
on
with
it
.
That
’
s
why
they
’
re
winning
,
and
winning
handsomely
”
Jim
Jarvie
....
.
more
Story
No
.
5
:
The
End
for
Indonesia
'
s
Lowland
Forests
?
If
the
current
state
of
resource
anarchy
continues
,
the
lowland
forests
of
the
Sunda
Shelf
,
the
richest
forests
on
Earth
,
will
be
totally
destroyed
by
2005
on
Sumatra
and
2010
on
Kalimantan
.
Where
did
things
go
wrong
?
.....
more
Story
No
.
6
:
Illegal
Logging
more
Prevalent
,
Forest
Destroyed
According
to
the
chairman
of
PT
Kiani
Lestari
,
if
there
is
no
control
of
regional
governments
,
in
the
next
10
years
,
the
forest
will
be
totally
destroyed
and
any
re
-
forestation
program
will
be
so
expensive
that
neither
the
central
nor
the
local
governments
will
be
able
to
afford
the
cost
.....
more
Story
No
.
7
:
Against
the
Grain
Indonesian
furniture
makers
are
finding
it
increasingly
difficult
to
market
their
products
overseas
,
because
of
ecolabeling
requirements
.....
more
Story
No
.
8
:
Audit
Finds
US
$
4
.
17
Billion
Losses
in
Reforestation
Fund
Earnst
and
Young
,
which
conducted
an
audit
at
the
ministry
discovered
irregularities
in
five
areas
,
illegal
logging
activities
,
levies
and
revenue
monitoring
of
reforestation
funds
,
report
inaccuracies
in
timber
production
,
accounting
and
information
system
,
and
inefficiencies
in
using
reforestation
funds
.....
more
Story
No
.
9
:
Screen
Test
:
Detecting
Mercury
in
Seafood
"
The
test
wouldn
'
t
cost
more
than
a
couple
of
bucks
,
"
said
lead
author
Kim
Janda
,
a
chemistry
professor
at
Scripps
.....
more
Story
No
.
10
:
NRM
Noon
Seminar
Schedule
Please
plan
to
attend
these
exciting
and
informative
Noon
Seminars
planned
for
the
next
few
weeks
in
May
and
June
.
Come
early
,
come
often
and
bring
your
lunch
.....
more
Story
No
.
11
:
World
Bank
’
s
Course
on
Environmental
Economics
for
Development
Policy
World
Bank
Institute
offers
a
set
of
core
courses
in
areas
of
critical
importance
to
the
development
process
.....
more
Story
No
.
12
:
Best
Practices
in
Combating
Desertification
A
database
of
NGOs
best
practices
in
combating
desertification
in
focal
areas
is
being
developed
and
will
be
presented
on
the
website
of
United
Nations
Convention
to
Combat
Desertification
(
UN
CCD
)
.....
more
Story
No
.
13
:
Request
for
Application
:
Orangutan
Habitat
Conservation
USAID
/
Indonesia
is
seeking
applications
for
support
of
orangutan
habitat
conservation
activities
.....
more
Story
No
.
1
:
Kutai
Barat
Produces
a
Portrait
of
a
Forest
Everyone
is
familiar
with
a
portrait
;
a
portrait
shows
factual
and
current
information
of
what
a
person
looks
like
at
a
point
in
time
.
The
idea
of
developing
a
portrait
of
a
forest
was
initiated
by
Kabupaten
Kutai
Barat
government
and
is
fully
supported
by
local
stakeholders
.
The
government
of
Kabupaten
Kutai
Barat
developed
the
first
portrait
.
As
a
new
district
,
Kutai
Barat
(
about
6
-
7
hours
drive
from
Samarinda
)
is
expected
to
develop
a
Kabupaten
Kutai
Barat
Forest
Management
Program
based
on
its
forestry
portrait
.
The
forestry
portrait
was
actually
designed
based
on
a
series
of
intensive
formal
and
informal
discussion
with
the
Kutai
Barat
forest
stakeholders
.
The
working
group
called
Kelompok
Kerja
Program
Kehutanan
Daerah
(
KK
-
PKD
)
Kutai
Barat
is
a
multi
stakeholder
’
s
forestry
working
group
officially
formed
under
the
Bupati
Kutai
Barat
decree
(
SK
)
no
453
/
K
.
065
/
2001
dated
2
January
2001
.
The
members
of
KK
-
PKD
are
the
Bupati
,
head
of
adat
,
NGOs
,
representatives
of
communities
,
universities
,
and
local
government
officials
.
Since
the
KK
-
PKD
is
a
very
unique
team
,
debates
among
the
member
and
discussion
with
other
resource
persons
within
Kutai
Barat
tend
to
color
the
portrait
.
After
technical
meetings
and
formal
and
informal
discussions
were
completed
in
December
2000
,
the
KK
-
PKD
produced
a
final
draft
portrait
document
named
The
Forestry
Portrait
Of
Kapubaten
Kutai
Barat
(
Potret
Kehutanan
Kabupaten
Kutai
Barat
)
Edition
1
.
The
final
draft
portrait
will
be
published
as
soon
as
the
editing
is
completed
by
KK
-
PKD
.
The
portrait
will
be
printed
from
17
May
to
17
June
2001
.
The
forestry
portrait
provides
information
about
:
(
1
)
the
physical
,
social
,
cultural
and
economic
issues
of
land
;
(
2
)
Kutai
Barat
forests
;
(
3
)
forest
management
;
(
3
)
forest
utilization
;
(
4
)
communities
and
forests
;
(
5
)
the
impact
of
forest
management
;
(
6
)
implementing
regulations
in
forest
management
and
(
6
)
land
/
forest
conflicts
.
Forest
stakeholders
can
use
the
portrait
as
a
basic
information
source
to
design
strategic
plans
for
better
forest
management
and
improve
forestry
programs
.
With
the
information
in
the
portrait
,
stakeholders
can
also
raise
critical
questions
:
What
will
happen
to
their
forest
in
the
future
?
What
can
be
expected
?
and
,
What
needs
to
be
done
to
meet
sustainable
forest
management
in
the
future
?
The
Kutai
Barat
forestry
portrait
will
not
only
benefit
the
government
of
Kutai
Barat
,
but
also
other
constituents
such
as
the
private
sector
,
local
communities
,
NGOs
and
other
interested
person
or
institution
who
care
about
forests
and
forest
development
.
Further
information
please
contact
:
Erwinsyah
SFM
Specialist
NRM
/
EPIQ
Program
esyah
@
nrm
.
or
.
id
Reed
Merrill
PAF
Advisor
NRM
/
EPIQ
Program
reedm
@
nrm
.
or
.
id
Top
Story
No
.
2
:
Proyek
Pesisir
/
Balikpapan
Holds
Consultation
on
Proposed
Balikpapan
Bay
Management
Plan
(
BBMP
)
On
April
30
,
2001
Proyek
Pesisir
staff
in
Balikpapan
held
a
consultative
meeting
on
the
proposed
Balikpapan
Bay
Management
Plan
(
BBMP
)
currently
under
development
.
The
consultation
included
approximately
30
persons
from
Balikpapan
,
Samarinda
and
villages
surrounding
Balikpapan
Bay
.
Small
group
sessions
were
used
to
discuss
challenges
related
to
a
number
of
issues
concerning
Balikpapan
Bay
that
must
be
addressed
in
the
Bay
Management
Plan
.
Among
others
these
issues
include
spatial
planning
,
forest
protected
areas
,
eco
-
tourism
,
bay
mangrove
conservation
and
management
,
education
and
awareness
,
institutional
development
,
pollution
,
sedimentation
and
erosion
,
and
clean
/
fresh
water
.
The
day
'
s
work
provided
an
excellent
opportunity
to
gather
inputs
from
stakeholders
and
get
confirmation
of
work
and
ideas
already
developed
for
the
BBMP
.
Over
the
month
of
May
,
Ramli
Malik
,
Proyek
Pesisir
Program
Manager
,
and
his
staff
will
conduct
more
sessions
with
government
,
non
-
governmental
,
and
private
sector
stakeholders
for
additional
input
into
the
BBMP
.
These
additional
sessions
will
provide
for
more
intensive
one
-
on
-
one
working
sessions
with
stakeholders
and
ensure
broader
public
participation
and
support
for
the
final
Balikpapan
Bay
Management
Plan
.
In
addition
to
their
continuing
stakeholder
consultations
in
the
month
of
May
,
Mr
.
Steve
Tilley
from
the
United
States
the
to
Kalimantan
to
work
with
the
team
.
Mr
.
Tilley
work
with
the
Washington
State
Puget
Sound
Water
Quality
Action
Team
,
the
organization
responsible
for
watershed
management
for
Puget
Sound
,
one
of
the
most
important
bay
areas
in
the
United
States
.
Mr
.
Tilley
will
work
with
the
Proyek
Pesisir
team
to
assist
in
developing
a
bay
sampling
and
monitoring
program
based
on
sampling
and
monitoring
in
Puget
Sound
,
work
with
the
communications
and
outreach
team
to
develop
concepts
for
management
plan
publication
and
dissemination
,
and
assist
in
developing
early
action
alternatives
for
BBMP
implementation
in
2002
.
The
final
version
of
the
BBMP
is
due
for
completion
in
June
2001
with
basic
implementation
scheduled
to
begin
later
this
year
.
A
key
challenge
for
successful
implementation
is
coordination
among
all
the
stakeholders
and
parties
responsible
for
Balikpapan
Bay
.
Options
for
coordination
are
currently
being
considered
and
will
be
announced
with
the
final
draft
of
the
BBMP
.
Maurice
Knight
Project
Leader
Proyek
Pesisir
crmp
@
cbn
.
net
.
id
Note
:
Ian
Dutton
,
former
Chief
of
Party
for
the
Coastal
Resources
Management
Project
has
taken
the
position
of
Indonesia
Country
Director
for
The
Nature
Conservancy
.
Please
note
that
from
2
April
,
Ian
Dutton
'
s
email
address
(
at
the
TNC
office
in
Jakarta
)
will
be
dutton
@
cbn
.
net
.
id
Emails
intended
for
Ian
should
be
sent
direct
to
that
address
.
Emails
for
the
CRMP
staff
will
be
directed
on
by
Tammy
Carolina
.
Top
Story
No
.
3
:
Testimony
of
Andrew
S
.
Natsios
,
USAID
Administrator
-
designate
Thank
you
,
Mr
.
Chairman
and
members
of
the
Committee
,
for
the
opportunity
to
present
testimony
on
my
nomination
by
the
President
to
be
Administrator
of
the
U
.
S
.
Agency
for
International
Development
.
I
would
first
like
to
introduce
my
wife
Elizabeth
,
and
our
14
year
old
son
Philip
.
Our
other
two
children
,
Emily
and
Alex
,
are
attending
college
.
Let
me
begin
with
a
story
.
On
one
of
my
first
trips
to
Africa
as
USAID
’
s
Director
of
the
Office
of
Foreign
Disaster
Assistance
I
visited
the
town
of
Mugalama
in
Mozambique
during
the
civil
war
in
1989
.
It
was
surrounded
by
one
of
the
warring
factions
and
thus
cut
off
from
food
supply
in
a
region
where
the
agricultural
system
had
been
virtually
destroyed
.
Nothing
looked
terribly
unusual
,
but
as
we
went
from
hut
to
hut
we
realized
the
village
was
dying
,
most
of
the
families
were
too
weakened
from
hunger
to
even
move
out
of
their
huts
.
World
Vision
,
which
was
working
in
the
area
,
began
an
airlift
that
day
with
USAID
funding
because
I
had
the
authority
to
authorize
emergency
expenditures
on
the
spot
.
I
visited
the
same
area
after
the
peace
agreement
had
been
signed
where
World
Vision
,
once
again
with
USAID
funding
,
had
begun
large
-
scale
agricultural
reconstruction
programs
with
improved
seed
varieties
,
better
grain
storage
,
and
new
roads
to
export
surpluses
.
The
whole
region
had
been
transformed
from
complete
desolation
into
an
Eden
-
like
area
of
rich
agricultural
bounty
.
I
have
seen
some
of
the
most
terrible
events
of
the
past
decades
and
some
great
triumphs
as
well
.
Mozambique
after
terrible
suffering
was
one
of
the
triumphs
.
I
thought
I
would
make
a
few
comments
about
my
own
philosophic
prejudices
,
my
view
of
the
world
,
and
of
the
foreign
assistance
programs
of
the
United
States
government
.
Four
principles
frame
my
world
view
:
I
believe
that
we
live
in
a
fallen
world
inhabited
by
imperfect
people
who
stubbornly
resist
other
people
’
s
dreams
of
paradise
.
That
is
why
violent
revolution
nearly
always
ends
up
disappointing
or
horrifying
.
I
believe
that
a
universal
moral
order
exists
and
that
while
our
foreign
policy
should
be
focused
on
protecting
and
furthering
our
broad
national
interests
,
it
can
not
stray
too
far
from
the
constraints
moral
principle
places
on
our
actions
as
a
nation
.
I
believe
that
incremental
reforms
to
remedy
terrible
injustice
,
carefully
implemented
,
over
the
longer
term
can
make
gradual
improvements
in
the
world
.
There
are
few
quick
fixes
.
I
believe
that
the
family
,
the
local
community
,
religious
institutions
,
and
the
private
sector
form
the
foundation
of
a
stable
and
prosperous
society
.
As
a
great
power
,
I
believe
America
must
have
a
foreign
assistance
program
to
accomplish
its
foreign
policy
objectives
and
to
express
the
deep
humanitarian
instincts
of
the
American
people
.
Properly
managed
it
is
a
powerful
instrument
for
the
President
to
influence
the
course
of
events
around
the
world
.
Too
often
we
see
military
force
and
diplomacy
as
the
only
instruments
at
his
command
,
when
in
fact
foreign
assistance
is
sometimes
the
most
appropriate
and
potentially
the
more
likely
to
succeed
,
when
diplomacy
is
not
enough
or
military
force
imprudent
.
A
peaceful
,
stable
,
and
civilized
world
order
is
very
much
in
the
interest
of
the
United
States
as
the
sole
remaining
superpower
with
the
world
’
s
largest
economy
.
A
well
-
administered
foreign
assistance
program
can
assist
the
President
and
the
Secretary
of
State
in
advancing
that
interest
.
Should
I
be
confirmed
as
Administrator
,
I
want
to
assure
the
committee
that
I
will
be
clear
about
whom
I
work
for
and
who
my
boss
is
:
I
report
to
and
serve
under
the
direction
of
the
Secretary
of
State
.
The
two
most
distinctive
trends
in
the
world
since
the
fall
of
the
Berlin
Wall
have
been
globalization
and
conflict
.
The
rise
of
the
internet
,
of
a
more
open
international
trading
and
financial
system
,
the
spread
of
democratic
capitalism
as
the
preferred
model
of
political
and
economic
development
,
contrast
remarkably
with
the
increase
in
the
number
of
failed
or
failing
states
and
the
increasing
number
of
civil
wars
,
many
of
enormous
brutality
.
The
U
.
S
.
Agency
for
International
Development
(
USAID
)
,
along
with
the
rest
of
our
foreign
policy
apparatus
,
has
adjusted
too
slowly
over
the
last
decade
to
these
two
challenges
.
Nearly
two
-
thirds
of
the
countries
with
USAID
field
missions
have
been
ravaged
by
civil
conflict
over
the
past
five
years
,
in
some
cases
destroying
years
of
economic
and
political
progress
.
I
have
witnessed
the
horror
of
these
conflicts
,
the
widespread
starvation
of
civilians
,
terrible
atrocities
,
the
collapse
of
governments
and
national
economies
.
First
with
USAID
and
then
with
World
Vision
,
I
worked
to
rescue
the
victims
from
these
catastrophes
.
Should
I
be
confirmed
,
USAID
will
begin
a
deliberate
effort
to
focus
its
limited
program
funds
on
conflict
prevention
and
resolution
,
in
conjunction
with
already
existing
efforts
at
the
State
and
Defense
Departments
.
We
had
warning
signs
of
the
Rwandan
genocide
well
before
it
occurred
;
because
we
did
not
act
on
them
nearly
a
million
people
are
dead
and
central
Africa
has
been
plunged
into
a
civil
war
which
has
killed
nearly
two
million
additional
people
.
According
to
the
Carnegie
Commission
for
Preventing
Deadly
Conflict
,
total
NATO
peacekeeping
and
humanitarian
aid
efforts
in
Bosnia
cost
$
53
billion
.
Surely
it
is
better
to
prevent
disasters
,
such
as
Rwanda
and
Bosnia
,
before
they
occur
,
than
to
clean
up
the
mess
after
it
is
too
late
.
The
globalization
of
the
world
economy
has
meant
that
governments
,
while
still
essential
,
are
not
the
only
institutions
through
which
public
services
are
provided
.
The
role
of
religious
institutions
,
non
-
governmental
organizations
,
private
foundations
,
universities
,
and
the
private
market
economy
in
providing
services
and
accomplishing
public
objectives
has
dramatically
increased
.
USAID
will
undertake
a
much
more
systematic
effort
to
leverage
its
funds
and
technical
expertise
with
those
of
these
private
institutions
to
serve
poor
people
in
the
developing
world
and
build
stronger
self
-
sustaining
local
institutions
.
These
partnerships
will
profoundly
change
the
model
through
which
USAID
does
its
business
with
a
much
greater
role
for
private
institutions
in
development
in
the
future
.
Without
economic
growth
no
development
is
ultimately
sustainable
.
I
would
like
to
focus
more
of
USAID
’
s
resources
on
economic
development
to
reduce
poverty
and
on
agricultural
development
to
reduce
hunger
and
malnutrition
.
The
American
free
market
approach
to
both
agricultural
and
economic
development
provide
important
lessons
which
USAID
should
do
more
to
share
with
the
developing
world
.
For
much
of
the
third
world
,
economic
growth
and
poverty
reduction
are
synonymous
with
agriculture
since
75
percent
of
the
world
’
s
poor
live
in
rural
areas
.
All
countries
that
have
graduated
from
the
third
to
the
first
world
,
have
begun
with
their
agricultural
sectors
.
The
last
fifteen
years
have
not
been
good
to
agriculture
programs
in
USAID
:
agricultural
development
funding
has
declined
from
$
1
.
2
billion
in
1985
to
$
300
million
this
year
.
In
1985
,
USAID
had
258
agricultural
scientists
and
agricultural
economists
,
when
I
left
the
first
Bush
Administration
that
had
declined
to
183
,
now
there
are
only
48
left
.
I
believe
this
situation
must
be
reversed
.
USAID
has
and
will
continue
to
maintain
preeminent
international
leadership
in
health
.
Its
programs
in
women
’
s
reproductive
health
,
child
survival
,
HIV
/
AIDS
,
infectious
diseases
,
and
nutrition
are
among
the
best
in
the
world
.
The
HIV
/
AIDS
epidemic
is
now
reaching
such
catastrophic
levels
it
is
decimating
entire
societies
,
creating
negative
population
growth
rates
:
we
are
beginning
to
see
famine
-
like
conditions
developing
in
some
particularly
hard
hit
countries
.
Secretary
Powell
has
pledged
a
10
percent
increase
in
USAID
’
s
HIV
/
AIDS
funding
for
FY
2002
,
a
pledge
we
will
keep
with
a
heavy
emphasis
on
prevention
--
the
best
use
of
limited
resources
.
USAID
must
do
business
differently
.
The
Agency
cannot
make
sweeping
changes
to
its
business
model
without
completely
overhauling
the
central
management
systems
through
which
USAID
does
its
work
.
The
procurement
system
,
finance
and
budgeting
systems
,
personnel
system
,
and
information
management
systems
are
in
advanced
states
of
paralysis
or
disrepair
.
The
books
of
USAID
have
been
unauditable
for
four
years
.
In
a
recent
study
of
federal
agencies
,
USAID
finished
second
to
last
in
a
survey
of
whether
the
personnel
system
rewards
managers
for
accomplishing
the
objectives
of
the
agency
.
Another
survey
reports
that
the
procurement
system
is
so
dysfunctional
USAID
proportionately
loses
more
legal
challenges
by
contractors
than
any
other
federal
agency
.
USAID
spent
$
100
million
on
a
management
information
system
that
had
to
be
scrapped
.
While
some
progress
has
been
made
in
fixing
these
systems
,
it
has
been
too
slow
,
and
neither
innovative
nor
sweeping
enough
to
get
the
job
done
.
USAID
’
s
career
officers
are
demoralized
and
frustrated
by
these
systems
,
which
make
it
nearly
impossible
for
them
to
get
their
work
done
.
They
want
to
help
me
overhaul
the
systems
.
Should
I
be
confirmed
,
I
intend
to
spend
my
first
year
personally
supervising
the
reconstruction
of
these
four
critical
management
systems
.
My
management
style
is
consultative
,
open
,
and
direct
.
In
addition
to
these
management
reforms
I
hope
the
Congress
will
consider
earmarks
reform
,
to
reduce
the
number
and
intrusiveness
of
earmarks
,
the
inflexibility
of
which
makes
it
very
difficult
for
USAID
to
get
its
work
done
,
show
any
creativity
,
or
customize
USAID
programs
in
the
field
to
the
local
situation
.
In
exchange
for
earmarks
reform
,
USAID
would
agree
to
create
a
new
model
for
doing
business
,
and
deliver
better
results
and
improved
management
.
During
World
War
II
,
the
German
army
stripped
Greece
of
its
meager
food
supply
to
provision
Rommel
’
s
army
in
North
Africa
.
The
famine
which
followed
killed
500
,
000
Greeks
,
nearly
10
percent
of
the
population
of
the
country
.
One
of
the
victims
was
my
great
uncle
.
The
story
of
his
suffering
and
death
has
been
told
and
retold
in
my
family
for
four
generations
.
It
took
twenty
years
before
Greece
could
begin
to
produce
large
agricultural
surpluses
,
after
receiving
support
from
the
U
.
S
.
government
agricultural
development
programs
run
by
USAID
’
s
predecessor
agency
,
and
after
graduating
a
generation
of
Greek
farmers
from
the
American
Farm
School
,
a
school
still
supported
by
USAID
through
the
American
Schools
and
Hospitals
Abroad
program
.
In
1963
,
my
parents
took
me
to
visit
my
grandparents
’
villages
which
were
desperately
poor
.
Thirty
years
later
I
returned
with
my
wife
and
children
to
see
the
same
villages
,
now
prosperous
and
charming
,
which
were
exporting
their
agricultural
surpluses
to
the
European
Union
.
Free
trade
,
agricultural
and
rural
investment
had
created
a
miracle
in
three
decades
.
Greece
will
not
see
a
famine
again
because
it
has
entered
the
ranks
of
first
world
countries
.
Foreign
assistance
does
work
,
but
it
takes
years
of
investment
and
hard
work
.
I
look
forward
to
working
with
the
Committee
to
create
a
new
USAID
.
Things
are
going
to
change
.
Top
Story
No
.
4
:
Timber
Consultant
Says
Bad
Guys
Are
Winning
the
War
By
Bruce
Emorid
JAKARTA
(
JP
)
:
It
’
s
not
all
black
and
white
when
Jim
Jarvie
turns
his
expert
eye
on
the
rape
of
the
country
’
s
forests
.
Sure
,
there
are
the
bad
guys
,
a
gang
of
thieves
which
includes
corrupt
concession
aires
,
government
officials
and
,
reportedly
,
members
of
the
security
apparatus
on
the
take
.
And
yet
Jarvie
says
there
are
also
those
who
are
trying
their
best
to
do
the
right
thing
-
because
they
know
their
foreign
markets
require
that
they
comply
with
sustainable
logging
standards
-
and
being
frustrated
in
the
attempt
.
Jarvie
,
with
bachelor
’
s
and
master
’
s
degrees
in
ecology
taxonomy
and
evolution
,
first
came
to
the
country
from
his
native
Scotland
in
the
1980s
,
serving
as
a
VSO
British
vol
unteer
working
on
spice
-
pro
ducing
trees
.
After
receiving
his
doctorate
in
biology
in
the
U
.
S
.
,
he
ran
a
project
on
plant
inventory
in
Bukit
Baka
Bukit
Raya
National
Park
in
Kalimantan
.
He
said
he
also
became
involved
in
a
USAID
project
promoting
sustainable
forestry
in
a
nearby
concession
.
“
I
became
aware
there
of
the
partnerships
needed
to
really
promote
conservation
,
between
academics
,
NGOs
and
the
industry
.
”
After
a
period
in
Irian
Jaya
working
with
the
local
government
to
put
a
conservation
agenda
into
spatial
planning
,
Jarvie
focused
on
how
forest
conservation
,
forestry
and
decentralization
must
work
together
for
the
long
-
term
future
of
the
forests
.
Today
he
is
a
consultant
on
timber
certification
for
sustainable
forest
programs
.
In
an
interview
in
Jakarta
and
by
e
-
mail
,
Jarvie
discussed
the
perilous
situation
of
the
country
’
s
forests
.
Question
:
What
are
you
trying
to
do
in
reconciling
conservation
needs
with
the
needs
of
communities
and
concessionaires
?
Answer
:
To
start
with
,
not
reinventing
the
wheel
,
I
work
with
the
certification
process
because
it
is
the
only
third
-
party
,
audited
system
that
functions
in
Indonesia
.
It
’
s
the
timber
trade
version
of
the
ISO
standards
.
It
’
s
market
based
and
transparent
.
Certification
of
a
concession
is
a
trade
tool
that
lets
an
end
consumer
be
confident
that
the
product
they
are
buying
comes
from
an
area
of
land
in
which
sustainable
forest
man
agement
is
being
practiced
.
The
certification
definition
of
sustainable
forest
manage
ment
stands
upon
principles
and
criteria
that
fully
inte
grate
social
,
ecological
and
production
issues
.
None
stand
individually
;
together
they
form
an
integrated
system
.
This
tool
works
all
over
the
globe
,
so
I
try
and
reconcile
conservation
needs
with
communities
and
concessionaires
via
the
best
available
tool
already
proven
.
I
recognize
that
most
national
parks
have
been
allo
cated
in
areas
where
conces
sionaires
find
,
or
at
least
found
,
it
difficult
to
operate
.
The
lowland
forests
of
Indonesia
are
the
largest
tracts
of
land
of
their
type
threat
ened
on
our
planet
.
They
are
being
burned
,
converted
and
otherwise
lost
.
The
only
remaining
tracts
,
principally
in
East
Kalimantan
and
West
Papua
(
Irian
Jaya
)
,
which
have
a
management
system
that
should
be
interested
in
their
longevity
,
are
the
concessions
.
So
it
’
s
easy
.
If
you
are
going
to
save
lowland
forests
,
work
with
concessions
to
ensure
their
survival
.
What
are
the
benefits
of
certification
?
Through
certification
,
there
is
now
an
emerging
middle
ground
that
permits
the
conservation
,
social
and
production
forestry
sectors
to
work
together
constructively
and
pragmatically
.
Certification
is
based
on
long
-
term
sustainability
of
forests
.
This
serves
the
forestry
sector
through
providing
acceptable
profit
and
long
-
term
access
to
certified
timber
markets
.
From
the
conservation
perspective
,
sustainable
forest
management
will
promote
long
-
term
biodiversity
conservation
and
go
a
long
way
toward
improving
the
current
forestry
practices
that
continue
to
cause
alarm
.
What
are
the
problems
with
the
situation
at
the
moment
?
First
and
foremost
a
lack
of
strong
and
law
and
order
,
exacerbated
further
by
the
chaos
of
regional
autonomy
.
There
are
concessionaires
who
want
to
do
better
,
not
because
of
newfound
vision
but
because
they
have
some
markets
demanding
better
practices
and
a
need
to
generate
a
more
responsible
corporate
front
.
This
appears
to
be
largely
because
their
concessions
have
been
allocated
in
the
provinces
by
the
central
government
,
at
a
time
when
local
central
government
’
s
control
is
questionable
.
The
problems
are
based
in
history
.
Soeharto
’
s
New
Order
Government
allocated
forest
concessions
mainly
to
powerful
conglomerates
and
politi
co
-
business
families
.
Now
responsibility
for
manage
ment
forests
other
than
con
servation
areas
(
national
parks
and
reserves
)
is
devolved
to
the
district
level
,
with
criteria
and
standards
not
enforced
by
central
gov
ernment
-
it
is
too
weak
.
Most
districts
have
no
capacity
for
detailed
spatial
and
develop
ment
planning
for
sustainable
development
,
nor
mechanisms
to
coordinate
forest
and
watershed
management
with
neighboring
districts
.
What
about
the
security
authorities
?
The
security
of
logging
concessions
is
supposedly
a
joint
responsibility
of
the
concessions
and
district
forest
department
(
ministry
)
,
yet
nei
ther
makes
any
attempt
to
stop
illegal
logging
.
Some
govern
ment
officials
and
concession
staff
are
reportedly
known
to
act
in
collusion
with
illegal
loggers
by
turning
a
blind
eye
or
providing
permits
for
tim
ber
cutting
,
transport
and
cus
toms
-
sanctioned
import
of
heavy
equipment
from
outside
of
Indonesia
There
are
those
who
want
to
stop
illegal
logging
practices
.
The
most
proactive
sometimes
face
serious
intimidation
and
even
arson
and
murder
.
What
can
be
done
to
resolve
the
situation
?
Lots
of
initiatives
have
been
suggested
or
tried
with
varying
degrees
of
pragmatism
in
design
,
and
commitment
to
implementation
.
An
export
ban
on
Indonesian
timber
is
often
dis
cussed
,
but
this
will
gain
little
national
or
local
support
and
is
probably
unenforceable
.
It
would
kill
the
few
Indonesia
and
international
initiatives
that
have
~
the
potential
to
foster
sustainable
forest
management
.
In
the
short
term
,
enforcement
of
national
law
is
critical
.
A
recent
report
by
the
Director
of
Nature
Conservation
concluded
that
local
police
capacity
was
insufficient
to
address
the
scale
and
power
of
illegal
logging
networks
and
that
military
action
may
be
necessary
to
protect
national
parks
.
Emergency
action
must
be
taken
to
enforce
closure
of
ille
gal
sawmills
and
stop
illegal
logging
operations
.
Where
concessionaires
have
lost
con
trol
over
their
own
concession
areas
,
all
operations
should
be
suspended
,
especially
the
building
of
new
logging
roads
that
open
up
new
areas
of
the
forest
frontier
to
exploitation
.
Can
the
media
play
a
part
?
A
concerted
media
cam
paign
to
promote
public
debate
and
mobilize
civil
soci
ety
must
be
an
integral
part
of
any
action
to
control
illegal
logging
.
Public
,
political
and
donor
attitudes
must
change
to
favor
the
prosecuting
those
involved
in
illegal
logging
,
including
top
officials
;
state
-
enforced
protection
of
ecosys
tems
that
are
critically
impor
tant
for
conservation
of
national
and
global
biodiver
sity
;
independent
third
-
party
monitoring
of
forestry
prac
tices
and
public
exposure
of
wrongdoing
;
increasing
awareness
of
the
watershed
and
environmental
values
of
forests
;
and
capturing
the
long
-
term
benefits
that
can
accrue
if
forests
are
managed
under
an
“
ethical
consumerism
”
umbrella
.
For
the
long
term
,
the
most
promising
approach
for
sus
tainable
forest
management
is
to
foster
initiatives
that
encour
age
joint
management
between
concessionaires
,
communities
and
district
government
.
As
I
said
,
via
certification
there
is
already
a
growing
minority
of
logging
concessions
going
for
international
and
local
timber
“
green
”
certification
mecha
nisms
as
an
alternative
forest
governance
mechanism
that
can
secure
local
buy
-
in
and
bet
ter
practice
.
A
change
from
large
-
scale
,
company
-
based
ex
ploitation
to
lower
-
impact
joint
ventures
will
require
a
com
plete
rethinking
of
forest
prof
itability
and
beneficiaries
.
The
illegal
logging
in
Indonesia
has
global
relevance
but
no
simple
solution
.
The
scientific
community
,
the
con
servation
movement
,
industry
and
the
Indonesian
and
donor
governments
must
move
from
apparent
complacency
to
vigorous
action
at
local
levels
.
What
are
the
most
frustrating
challenges
you
face
?
The
lack
of
action
against
illegal
logging
is
seriously
frustrating
.
Those
against
ille
gal
logging
are
divided
and
spend
more
time
in
workshops
debating
each
other
,
wasting
time
and
money
,
than
accom
plishing
anything
real
Illegal
loggers
don
’
t
have
workshops
and
they
don
’
t
debate
.
They
just
get
on
with
it
.
That
’
s
why
they
’
re
winning
,
and
winning
handsomely
.
Top
Story
No
.
5
:
The
End
for
Indonesia
'
s
Lowland
Forests
?
Source
:
Science
Vol
.
292
(
5518
)
,
May
04
,
2001
By
Paul
Jepson
,
James
K
.
Jarvie
,
Kathy
MacKinnon
and
Kathryn
A
.
Monk
Twenty
years
ago
,
Indonesia
used
the
best
principles
of
conservation
biology
to
plan
a
national
protected
area
system
based
on
representativeness
,
irreplaceability
,
complementarity
,
and
connectivity
.
Large
areas
of
all
habitats
were
proposed
as
conservation
areas
within
each
biogeographic
region
.
Subsequently
,
all
of
the
country
'
s
forests
(
more
than
70
%
of
the
total
land
area
)
were
allocated
for
production
,
watershed
protection
,
or
conservation
,
and
Indonesia
endorsed
the
principles
of
sustainable
forest
management
.
Unfortunately
,
these
scientific
principles
were
never
fully
reconciled
with
national
policy
and
practice
,
even
though
Indonesia
was
one
of
the
first
signatories
to
the
Convention
on
Biological
Diversity
.
Today
,
Indonesia
is
a
society
in
transition
,
torn
apart
by
economic
and
political
crises
,
and
the
gap
between
scientific
best
practice
and
the
reality
of
current
forest
mismanagement
could
hardly
be
wider
.
If
the
current
state
of
resource
anarchy
continues
,
the
lowland
forests
of
the
Sunda
Shelf
,
the
richest
forests
on
Earth
,
will
be
totally
destroyed
by
2005
on
Sumatra
and
2010
on
Kalimantan
.
Where
did
things
go
wrong
?
Suharto
'
s
New
Order
Government
(
1966
-
1998
)
allocated
use
rights
(
forest
concessions
)
over
timber
-
rich
rainforest
to
powerful
conglomerates
and
politico
-
business
families
.
After
Suharto
'
s
fall
from
power
,
the
interim
government
of
President
Habibie
(
1998
-
99
)
passed
two
pieces
of
legislation
on
regional
autonomy
that
were
vague
about
the
extent
of
regional
autonomy
for
resource
planning
and
management
.
The
responsibility
for
the
management
of
all
forests
other
than
conservation
areas
(
national
parks
and
reserves
)
was
devolved
to
the
district
level
within
provinces
,
although
criteria
and
standards
were
still
to
be
set
by
the
central
government
.
This
neglected
the
fact
that
most
districts
have
no
capacity
for
detailed
spatial
and
development
planning
for
sustainable
development
,
nor
mechanisms
to
coordinate
forest
and
watershed
management
with
neighboring
districts
.
In
December
2000
,
we
visited
protected
areas
and
forest
concessions
in
Sumatra
and
Kalimantan
.
We
found
a
rapidly
deteriorating
situation
compared
to
just
6
months
previously
.
The
one
-
million
-
hectare
Kerinci
-
Seblat
National
Park
in
Sumatra
is
surrounded
by
logging
concessions
that
cover
biodiversity
-
rich
lowland
habitats
excised
from
proposed
park
boundaries
after
1982
.
A
major
project
,
financed
by
a
World
Bank
loan
and
a
grant
from
the
Global
Environment
Facility
(
GEF
)
,
aimed
to
establish
integrated
conservation
management
regimes
for
the
greater
Kerinci
ecosystem
.
This
is
crucially
important
for
the
continued
survival
of
Asian
megafauna
such
as
the
Sumatran
rhinoceros
,
the
Sumatran
tiger
and
the
Asian
elephant
.
In
the
concessions
we
visited
,
illegal
logging
gangs
were
operating
freely
along
logging
roads
.
Large
areas
of
forest
had
been
newly
cleared
and
burned
to
create
new
agricultural
plots
.
Numerous
piles
of
sawn
timber
indicated
extensive
portable
saw
mill
operations
within
the
forest
.
Within
concessions
,
basic
security
measures
were
lacking
,
and
road
barriers
were
unmanned
.
A
skid
trail
used
by
the
illegal
gangs
to
drag
out
rough
-
sawn
timber
even
crossed
one
concessionaire
'
s
yard
.
Entrepreneurs
(
known
as
"
cukong
"
)
prefinance
these
gangs
;
loans
are
repaid
with
timber
delivered
to
sawmill
and
warehouse
gates
.
Concessionaires
claimed
that
logging
gangs
would
gang
up
to
burn
camps
and
logging
trucks
if
a
company
attempted
to
interfere
with
their
illegal
activities
.
The
security
of
logging
concessions
is
supposedly
a
joint
responsibility
of
the
concession
company
and
the
district
forest
department
,
yet
neither
make
any
attempt
to
stop
illegal
logging
.
Roads
constructed
by
the
forest
concessionaires
to
provide
access
to
new
and
undisturbed
forests
are
appropriated
by
illegal
logging
networks
.
Key
officials
(
"
oknum
"
)
in
local
government
act
in
collusion
with
illegal
loggers
by
turning
a
blind
eye
and
/
or
providing
permits
for
timber
transport
.
Some
government
officials
want
to
stop
illegal
logging
practices
;
they
face
serious
intimidation
and
even
arson
and
murder
.
In
Gunung
Leuser
National
Park
,
leaders
of
logging
gangs
(
"
tauke
"
)
have
negotiated
agreements
with
leaders
of
communities
for
title
over
forest
lands
that
overlap
official
park
boundaries
.
Several
of
these
gangs
are
backed
by
army
and
rebel
groups
working
in
collusion
with
foreign
-
backed
interests
.
Malinau
communities
of
East
Kalimantan
have
signed
away
rights
for
up
to
15
,
000
ha
of
land
,
some
of
which
is
already
licensed
by
the
central
government
to
timber
concession
companies
.
The
cukong
protect
themselves
with
quasi
-
legal
documents
that
make
villages
liable
for
payments
of
up
to
US
$
230
,
000
should
they
renege
on
the
deal
.
Communities
have
two
reasons
to
surrender
their
quasi
-
legal
rights
.
First
,
immediate
cash
benefits
far
exceed
anything
acquired
during
past
political
eras
.
Second
,
they
fear
retribution
from
illegal
logging
networks
.
Participation
in
illegal
logging
is
more
lucrative
in
the
short
term
than
any
benefits
offered
by
concessionaires
,
conservation
initiatives
,
or
sustainable
forestry
projects
supported
by
donor
agencies
.
Although
contradicting
state
norms
,
illegal
logging
is
becoming
semi
-
legal
and
rapidly
established
as
the
de
facto
institutional
arrangement
governing
Indonesia
'
s
forests
.
The
state
is
unable
,
or
unwilling
,
to
address
this
illegal
activity
.
In
August
2000
,
after
international
publicity
about
illegal
logging
in
Tanjung
Puting
National
Park
,
the
Minister
of
Forestry
wrote
to
the
relevant
provincial
authorities
asking
for
action
against
the
main
offender
,
a
well
-
known
member
of
Indonesia
'
s
People
'
s
Assembly
.
The
request
was
ignored
.
In
three
case
-
study
areas
,
Kerinci
-
Seblat
and
Gunung
Leuser
national
parks
(
Sumatra
)
and
Malinau
district
(
Kalimantan
)
,
illegal
operations
appear
to
lead
to
one
or
two
known
principal
backers
,
residing
in
regional
centers
.
District
bureaucracies
are
generally
unaware
and
uncaring
of
biodiversity
issues
and
have
limited
capacity
to
govern
.
Local
governing
elites
rarely
consider
the
environmental
costs
of
rampant
forest
exploitation
or
believe
that
environmental
damage
can
be
rectified
with
technical
solutions
,
financed
by
increased
district
prosperity
or
grants
from
the
central
government
and
international
donors
.
In
essence
,
they
are
replicating
the
resource
management
model
of
the
Suharto
regime
at
the
local
level
.
Indonesia
'
s
government
and
the
international
community
face
some
hard
choices
if
they
wish
to
stem
this
biological
catastrophe
.
To
wait
until
the
political
climate
settles
would
be
disastrous
for
biodiversity
and
forest
management
.
Given
current
trends
,
we
estimate
that
Kerinci
'
s
lowland
forests
,
some
of
the
richest
habitats
on
Earth
,
will
be
destroyed
within
3
years
.
Illegal
logging
will
vastly
increase
the
risk
and
impacts
of
fire
during
the
next
El
Niño
event
.
A
combination
of
forest
degradation
and
land
clearance
were
the
root
causes
of
the
1998
-
99
fire
disaster
that
blanketed
nearly
20
million
people
across
Southeast
Asia
in
smoke
for
months
,
with
disastrous
costs
to
local
health
and
economies
.
Allowing
the
indiscriminate
logging
to
continue
will
result
in
long
-
term
damage
to
watershed
forests
.
In
October
2000
,
districts
around
Kerinci
National
Park
suffered
major
flooding
that
led
to
deaths
,
destroyed
roads
and
rice
crops
,
and
caused
local
food
shortages
.
An
export
ban
on
Indonesian
timber
will
gain
little
national
or
local
support
and
is
probably
unenforceable
.
Foreign
pressure
for
such
a
ban
carries
the
risk
of
a
nationalist
backlash
that
would
exacerbate
the
situation
further
.
It
would
kill
the
few
Indonesian
and
international
initiatives
that
have
the
potential
to
foster
sustainable
forest
management
.
In
the
short
term
,
enforcement
of
national
law
is
critical
.
A
recent
report
by
the
Indonesian
Directorate
of
Nature
Conservation
concluded
that
local
police
capacity
was
insufficient
to
address
the
scale
and
power
of
illegal
logging
networks
and
that
military
action
may
be
necessary
to
protect
national
parks
.
Emergency
action
must
be
taken
to
enforce
closure
of
illegal
sawmills
and
stop
illegal
logging
operations
.
Where
concessionaires
have
lost
control
over
their
own
concession
areas
,
all
operations
should
be
suspended
,
especially
the
building
of
new
logging
roads
that
open
up
new
areas
of
the
forest
frontier
to
exploitation
.
Priority
actions
should
target
the
ecosystems
of
Leuser
and
Kerinci
(
Sumatra
)
and
Tanjung
Puting
and
Gunung
Palung
(
Kalimantan
)
,
where
vast
losses
of
irreplaceable
and
globally
important
biodiversity
are
imminent
.
Such
action
would
send
a
clear
message
to
districts
that
decentralized
government
also
means
responsible
government
.
A
concerted
media
campaign
to
promote
public
debate
and
mobilize
civil
society
must
be
an
integral
part
of
any
action
to
control
illegal
logging
.
Public
,
political
,
and
donor
attitudes
must
change
to
favor
the
following
:
prosecuting
all
those
involved
in
illegal
logging
,
including
top
officials
;
state
-
enforced
protection
of
ecosystems
that
are
critically
important
for
conservation
of
national
and
global
biodiversity
;
independent
third
-
party
monitoring
of
forestry
practice
and
public
exposure
of
wrongdoing
;
increasing
awareness
of
the
watershed
and
environmental
values
of
forests
;
and
capturing
the
long
-
term
benefits
that
can
accrue
if
forests
are
managed
under
an
"
ethical
consumerism
"
umbrella
.
For
the
long
term
,
the
most
promising
approach
for
sustainable
forest
management
is
to
foster
initiatives
that
encourage
joint
management
between
concessionaires
,
communities
,
and
district
government
.
Already
,
a
growing
minority
of
logging
concessions
are
embracing
international
and
local
timber
"
green
"
certification
mechanisms
as
an
alternative
forest
governance
mechanism
that
can
secure
local
buy
-
in
and
better
practice
.
A
change
from
large
-
scale
,
company
-